ThesisPDF Available

On a learning system for industrial automation: Model-based control and diagnostics for decision support

Authors:
  • ABB Research Sweden

Abstract

Access to energy is fundamental to economic and technological advancement. Hence, the more the world develops, the greater the demand for energy becomes. Evidently, the production and consumption of energy alone account for more than 80% of global anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. There is broad scientific consensus that efficiency improvements in energy production and consumption must come first on the path to reducing global GHG emissions. As the largest producer and consumer of energy, the industrial sector faces tremendous challenges due to stringent environmental regulations, intense price-based global competition, rising operating costs and rapidly changing economic conditions. Therefore, increasing energy and resource efficiency while improving throughput and asset reliability is a matter of utmost importance. Satisfying such demanding objectives requires an optimal operation, control and monitoring of plant assets and processes. This is one of the main driving forces behind developing digital solutions, methods, and frameworks that can be integrated with old and new industrial automation platforms. The main focus of this dissertation is to investigate frameworks, process models, soft sensors, control optimization, and diagnostic techniques to improve the operation, control, and monitoring of industrial plants and processes. In this thesis, a generic architecture for control optimization, diagnostics, and decision support system, referred to here as a learning system, is proposed. The research is centred around an investigation of different components of the proposed learning system. Two very different case studies, one representing large-scale assets and another representing a fleet of small-scale assets, are considered to demonstrate the genericness of the proposed system architecture. In this thesis, a very energy-intensive chemical pulping process represents the case study of large-scale assets, and a micro gas turbine (MGT) fleet for distributed heat and power generation represent the case study of a fleet of small-scale assets. One of the main challenges in this research arises from the marked differences between the case studies in terms of size, functions, quantity, and structure of the existing automation systems. Typically, only a few pulp digesters are found in a Kraft pulping mill, but there may be hundreds of units in a MGT fleet. The main argument behind the selection of these two case studies is that, if the proposed learning system architecture can be adapted for these significantly different cases, then it can be adapted for many other industrial applications as well. Within the scope of this thesis, mathematical modelling, model adaptation, model predictive control, and diagnostics methods are studied for continuous pulp digesters, whereas mathematical modelling, model adaptation, and diagnostics techniques are explored for the MGT fleet. Due to the naturally varying wood quality, significant residence time, insufficient measurements, and complexity of pulping reactions, modelling and controlling a continuous pulp digester is a challenging task. Moreover, process abnormalities due to non-ideal flow in the digester often occur that considerably affect the pulp quality. Within this dissertation, variation of wood-chip quality is identified as one of the main process disturbances. Thereafter, a feedforward model predictive control (MPC) approach is explored by feedforwarding the lignin content of the wood chips to the controller. The result shows that the disturbance rejection and tracking performance of the feedforward MPC are superior to other alternatives, like Proportional–integral–derivative (PID), MPC, and current industrial control. When it comes to diagnostics, a literature gap is identified in the area of modelling digester faults. Hence, the well-known Purdue model, a widely used dynamic model of the digester, is extended to simulate process faults like screen-clogging, hangups, and channelling. The findings suggest that both hangups and channelling considerably affect the pulp quality at the blowline. The impact of channelling is prominent on reaction temperature compared to hangups, while hangups change the residence time of the wood chips significantly. Subsequently, a hybrid diagnostics scheme for pulp digester, combining a physical model and a Bayesian network (BN), is demonstrated. Overall, the results show that fault type and severity can be estimated with acceptable accuracy even in presence of noise. Enabling remote fleet diagnostics is expected to foster the commercialization of distributed micro-combined heat and power (micro-CHP) generators, i.e., MGTs. Even though the modelling and diagnostics of large-scale gas turbines are well researched, studies targeting MGT are limited. In this thesis, a physical model of a commercial MGT system is developed. Subsequently, a hybrid scheme by combining a physics-based gas path analysis with a data-driven approach is used to enable MGT diagnostics. The proposed scheme was tested by simulating case studies corresponding to single and multiple faults. Furthermore, sensitivity studies are performed for different measurement uncertainties (i.e., sensor noise and bias) to evaluate the robustness of the scheme against measurement uncertainties. The findings show that the proposed diagnostics approach performs satisfactorily even under measurement uncertainties. To sum up, the increased availability of data and higher computing power is fostering the development of accurate process models and algorithms necessary for optimal operation, control, and monitoring of industrial processes. With the emergence of new measurement techniques, it is possible to leverage productivity and quality with tighter control of key process parameters. Additionally, studying the underlying mechanism of process degradation and developing diagnostics methods by incorporating these can lead to significant economic benefits. Having said that, to tap the full potential of these digital solutions, an integrated framework like that presented in this thesis, i.e., a learning system is essential. <*Note: If you want a hard copy of the thesis, please reach out>
A preview of the PDF is not available
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
p>This project is about the design of PID controllers and the improvement of outputs in multivariable processes. The optimisation of PID controller for the Shell oil process is presented in this paper, using Genetic Algorithms (GAs). Genetic Algorithms (GAs) are used to automatically tune PID controllers according to given specifications. They use an objective function, which is specially formulated and measures the performance of controller in terms of time-domain bounds on the responses of closed-loop process. A specific objective function is suggested that allows the designer for a single-input, single-output (SISO) process to explicitly specify the process performance specifications associated with the given problem in terms of time-domain bounds, then experimentally evaluate the closed-loop responses. This is investigated using a simple two-term parametric PID controller tuning problem. The results are then analysed and compared with those obtained using a number of popular conventional controller tuning methods. The intention is to demonstrate that the proposed objective function is inherently capable of accurately quantifying complex performance specifications in the time domain. This is something that cannot normally be employed in conventional controller design or tuning methods. Finally, the recommended objective function will be used to examine the control problems of Multi-Input-Multi-Output (MIMO) processes, and the results will be presented in order to determine the efficiency of the suggested control system.</p
Article
Full-text available
The operation of continuous pulp digesters play a pivotal role in the profitability of a pulp mill. Particularly, process faults due to the non-ideal flow behaviour in the digester have direct impact on the pulp quality, production rate and chemical utilization of the plant. The study begins with an introduction on process faults in continuous reactors by explicitly focusing on continuous pulp digesters. Operational data from a commercial pulp digester is analysed to examine process abnormalities. Subsequently, the extended Purdue model is modified to simulate non-ideal flows related continuous digester faults. The affect of different process faults on important process variables are analysed with the help of simulation studies. In the second part of the paper, a hybrid fault diagnostics approach based on first-principle digester model and Bayesian network is proposed and validated. Additionally, the methodology of developing the diagnostics approach are also described.
Chapter
Full-text available
Due to the intense price-based global competition, rising operating cost, rapidly changing economic conditions and stringent environmental regulations, modern process and energy industries are confronting unprecedented challenges to maintain profitability. Therefore, improving the product quality and process efficiency while reducing the production cost and plant downtime are matters of utmost importance. These objectives are somewhat counteracting, and to satisfy them, optimal operation and control of the plant components are essential. Use of optimization not only improves the control and monitoring of assets but also offers better coordination among different assets. Thus, it can lead to extensive savings in the energy and resource consumption, and consequently offer a reduction in operational costs, by offering better control, diagnostics and decision support. This is one of the main driving forces behind developing new methods, tools and frameworks. In this chapter, a generic learning system architecture is presented that can be retrofitted to existing automation platforms of different industrial plants. The architecture offers flexibility and modularity, so that relevant functionalities can be selected for a specific plant on an as-needed basis. Various functionalities such as soft-sensors, outputs prediction, model adaptation, control optimization, anomaly detection, diagnostics and decision supports are discussed in detail.
Article
Full-text available
Over the past twenty years, numerous research outcomes have been published, related to the design and implementation of soft sensors. In modern industrial processes, various types of soft sensors are used, which play essential roles in process monitoring, control and optimization. Emerging new theories, advanced techniques and the information infrastructure have enabled the elevation of the performance of soft sensing. However, novel opportunities are accompanied by novel challenges. This work is motivated by these observations and aims to present a comprehensive review of the developments since the start of the millennium. While a few books and review articles are published on the related topics, more focus on the most up-to-the-date advancement is put in this work, from the perspective of systems and control.
Article
Full-text available
Being at the heart of modern pulp mills, continuous pulp digesters have attracted much attention from the research community. In this article, a comprehensive review in the area of modeling, control and diagnostics of continuous pulp digesters is conducted. The evolution of research focus within these areas is followed and discussed. Particular effort has been devoted to identifying the state-of-the-art and the research gap in a summarized way. Finally, the current and future research directions in the areas have been analyzed and discussed. To date, digester modeling following the Purdue approach, Kappa number control using model predictive controllers and health index-based diagnostic approaches by utilizing different statistical methods have dominated the field. While the rising research interest within the field is evident, we anticipate further developments in advanced sensors and integration of these sensors for improving model prediction and controller performance; and the exploration of different AI-based approaches will be at the core of future research.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The concepts of Hybrid and Cognitive Digital Twin are introduced as elements of the next level of process control and automation in the process and manufacturing industry. We propose an architecture for the implementation of Hybrid and Cognitive Twins as part of the COGNITWIN software toolbox. The toolbox is designed to cover cognitive capabilities for optimal operations and maintenance of process equipment and assets, thereby minimizing production overheads and increasing efficiencies for the process industry. Furthermore, we identify a set of relevant use cases in the process industry and discuss the possible applicability and use of the toolbox.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The concept of a Cognitive Digital Twin (abbreviated CT or CDT) is presented in this paper as an extension of Digital Twins (DTs) with cognitive capabilities in the context of the process industry. With cognitive capabilities, we foresee possibilities for the next level of automation in process control systems. This article proposes an architecture associated with a CT control system, exemplified in a process industry use case. The CT is therefore seen as a more comprehensive approach in comparison to a traditional DT.
Article
Incipient faults almost occur gradually at a low rate in systems and usually are unnoticeable during their early stages. If diagnostic tools or proper monitoring systems ignore them, they could not be detectable until their effects become severe and cause catastrophic damages to systems. This paper presents a survey on model-based (incipient) fault diagnosis approaches to show the significance of the incipient faults diagnosis in nonlinear closed-loop systems and, by taking a glance through data-based incipient fault diagnosis advancements, a picture of their present state of the art is also briefly discussed for completeness. Moreover, a classification of the most used state estimation filters is also provided. Consequently, recent works on incipient fault diagnosis approaches are reviewed, and an incipient fault diagnosis case study is investigated for a discrete-time nonlinear open-loop system affected by stochastic noise and disturbances. Specifically, a numerical example of a closed-loop three-tank system is considered, and simulations are accomplished, to demonstrate the inability of open-loop incipient fault diagnosis approaches in detecting incipient faults in the proposed closed-loop system.
Article
In kraft pulp digester, lignin in wood chips is removed through delignification by hydroxide and sodium sulfide solution. Since both macroscopic and microscopic properties of wood pulp significantly affect the attributes of paper products, several multiscale modeling frameworks have been developed. However, these models did not consider fiber-to-fiber (F2F) heterogeneity; it is an important challenge these days as the fibers are provided from multiple sources to meet the increasing demand. Therefore, we developed a multiscale modeling framework to describe the evolution of heterogeneous fibers in a digester by running multiple kinetic Monte Carlo simulations in parallel. Specifically, the F2F heterogeneity is incorporated by introducing variation in heat capacity and dissolution rate for each fiber. Based on the developed multiscale model, we also designed an offset-free model predictive control system to regulate the cell wall thickness distribution of fibers as well as Kappa number in a pulping process.