ArticlePDF Available

Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh

Authors:
  • Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock
  • Bangladesh Fisheries Research Institute (BFRI) Riverine Sub-Station Khepupara Patuakhali

Abstract and Figures

A research on the assemblages of benthic macro faunal community in the coastal areas of Bangladesh was conducted during February-March, 2015 following the standard methods to assess the status of environmental pollution. The abundance (r=0.846) and species richness (r=0.864) of the macrobenthic communities were significantly influenced by the water salinity of the sampling sites (p ≤ 0.05). Both the study areas namely the Bakkhali River Estuary and the Meghna River Estuary showing the highest (3909 ± 540 ind./m2) and lowest (2236 ± 689 ind./m2) density of benthic macrofaunal abundance respectively might be considered as moderately polluted areas according to the results obtained from Shannon-Wiener index of species diversity (2.69 ± 0.13 and 2.00 ± 0.11 respectively) and Margalef’s species richness (2.21 ± 0.43 and 1.36 ± 0.11 respectively). Therefore, it is plausible that the macrobenthic community explained in the present study might be a key future outline to assess the status of coastal water pollution of those concerned areas of Bangladesh.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Research Article Open Access
Sarker et al., Fish Aquac J 2016, 7:1
http://dx.doi.org/10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Research Artilce Open Access
Fisheries and Aquaculture Journal
F
i
s
h
e
r
i
e
s
a
n
d
A
q
u
a
c
u
l
t
u
r
e
J
o
u
r
n
a
l
ISSN: 2150-3508
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
Keywords: Macrobenthos; Bakkhali river estuary; Meghna river
estuary; Shannon-wiener index; Margalef’s species richness
Introduction
Benthos is the organism that inhabit in bottom of an aquatic body.
Benthic communities are usually dominated by dierent species of
polychaete, oligochaete worms, gastropods, bivalvia and various minor
insect larvae. Benthic organisms such as macro, meio and micro fauna
and ora play an important role in food chains in an aquatic ecosystem
[1]. Macrobenthic organisms may be inuenced positively or negatively
by physico-chemical parameters of the environment depending on
their sources [2]. According to environmental conditions benthic
communities vary considerably [3]. e amount of nutrients released
from the sediment by benthic communities may vary [4]. Various
physical and chemical conditions of the water body such as depth,
current of the water, organic contents of the sediments, contaminations
of bed sediments environment, toxicity of sediments inuence the
abundance and distribution of macrobenthos [5]. Macrobenthos are
the most commonly used organisms for bio-monitoring in lotic habitat
worldwide [6]. It is evident that macrobenthos play an important role
in improving and preserving water quality through mineralization and
recycling of organic matters [7,8]. e physical and chemical status
of the riverine ecosystem becomes recognizable through the elasticity
of the community structure of the benthic organisms [9,10]. at’s
why benthic macro-invertebrates make ideal subject for biological
assessment of water quality [11].
Bangladesh is blessed with an extensive coastline of about 710 Km
[12]. e southeastern and southwestern coast of this country is mostly
covered by a complex estuarine ecosystem with strong interactions of
biotic and abiotic factors. e main estuarine systems of the country
are Brahmaputra-Megna (Gangetic delta), Karnaphuly, Matamuhuri,
Bakkhali and Naf rivers, which are comprised of mangroves, salt
marshes, sea grass, seaweeds, sheries, coastal birds, animals, coral
reefs, deltas, salt beds, minerals and sand dunes. e estuarine
environment, which serves as feeding, breeding and nursery grounds
for a variety of animals, varies according to the volume of discharge of
the river and tidal range. ese diverse living resources in the estuarine
environment play an important role which is economically signicant
in many ways. Although coastal and estuarine resources contribute a
vital role in terms of both the ecosystem and the economy, study of the
estuarine coastal environment in Bangladesh is still lacking [13].
Khan [14] conducted an investigation on the abundance and
distribution of macrobenthic organisms in the Mouri River, Khulna
to determine the level of river pollution. ey identied twenty (20)
dierent species in their study area where polychaeta dominated all
over the river. Abu Hena [15] conducted a primary research work on
the composition of macrobenthos in the Bakkhali Channel System,
Cox’s Bazar to investigate the relationship between soil parameters and
the macrobenthos composition in their study area. But there is almost
no information on the long term study of benthos particularly in the
coastal waters of Bangladesh. erefore the present study was designed
to explore diversity of benthos in the South-Western coastal waters of
Bangladesh with the following objectives.
Objectives
• To know the diversity of benthic macro fauna in the Meghna
River Estuary (at Chairman Ghat, Noakhali) and the Bakkhali
River Estuary (Cox’s Bazar).
• To compare the benthic macro faunal abundance in between
two selected estuaries.
• To assess the environmental conditions of the Meghna River
Estuary and the Bakkhali River Estuary.
*Corresponding author: Jahangir Sarker Md, Department of Fisheries and Marine
Science, Noakhali Science and Technology University, Noakhali, Bangladesh, Tel:
+880-321-71487; Fax: +880-321-62788; E-mail: swaponj@yahoo.com
Received November 25, 2015; Accepted February 10, 2016; Published February
20, 2016
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay
MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to Assess
Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-
3508.1000157
Copyright: © 2016 Sarker J Md, et al. This is an open-access article distributed
under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the
original author and source are credited.
Abstract
A research on the assemblages of benthic macro faunal community in the coastal areas of Bangladesh was
conducted during February-March, 2015 following the standard methods to assess the status of environmental
pollution. The abundance (r=0.846) and species richness (r=0.864) of the macrobenthic communities were
signicantly inuenced by the water salinity of the sampling sites (p 0.05). Both the study areas namely the
Bakkhali River Estuary and the Meghna River Estuary showing the highest (3909 ± 540 ind./m2) and lowest (2236
± 689 ind./m2) density of benthic macrofaunal abundance respectively might be considered as moderately polluted
areas according to the results obtained from Shannon-Wiener index of species diversity (2.69 ± 0.13 and 2.00 ± 0.11
respectively) and Margalef’s species richness (2.21 ± 0.43 and 1.36 ± 0.11 respectively). Therefore, it is plausible
that the macrobenthic community explained in the present study might be a key future outline to assess the status of
coastal water pollution of those concerned areas of Bangladesh.
Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to Assess Coastal
Water Pollution in Bangladesh
Jahangir Sarker Md1*, Shamsul Alam Patwary Md1, Borhan Uddin AMM1, Monjurul Hasan Md1, Mehedi Hasan Tanmay1, Indrani Kanungo1
and Mohammed Rashed Parvej2
1Department of Fisheries and Marine Science, Noakhali Science and Technology University, Noakhali, Bangladesh
2Bangladesh Fisheries Research Institute, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 2 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
MaterialsandMethods
Sediment samples were collected from the Meghna River Estuary
(at Chairmanghat, Noakhali) and the Bakkhali River Estuary (Cox’s
Bazar) during February-March, 2015 (Figure 1). 6 sampling stations
(3 from each estuary with triplicate fashion) were selected to carry out
the present study. Among the two study sites the Bakkhali river estuary,
Cox’s Bazar, is situated in the southern region of Bangladesh. e
approximate geographical location of this estuary is between 20085ʹ40ʺ
to 21046ʹ92ʺ N latitude and 91096ʹ60ʺ to 92034ʹ37ʺE longitude
(Figure 1). e estuary is directly inuenced by semi-diurnal tides and
climatology impacted by monsoon winds where it’s bottom consists
mostly of muddy and sandy particles [16]. 3 sampling stations from
the Bakhkhali River Estuary namely S-IB, S-2B, S-3B and another 3
stations from the Meghna River Estuary namely S-4M, S-5M and S-6M
were selected. Besides on the coast of Bangladesh the Meghna River
Estuary is a coastal plain estuary. e bathymetry, tides and outow
from the Meghna River are the important driving forces of that estuary
[17]. e approximate geographical location of this estuary is between
(22035ʹ14.7ʺN and 91001ʹ31.8ʺE to 22035ʹ24.6ʺN and 91001ʹ47.4ʺE)
(Figure 1).
For macrobenthic fauna, samples were collected using a small boat
during February to March, 2015. Sediment samples were collected
using an Ekman dredge having a mouth opening of 0.02 m2. Collected
sediment samples were sieved through 500 µm mesh screen to retain
macrobenthos. e sieved organisms were preserved immediately with
10% formalin solution in the plastic container with other residues.
Preserved samples were then brought back to laboratory for further
analysis. In the laboratory, small amount of “Rose Bengal” was added
to increase visibility of organisms. Identication of macrobanthic fauna
were done using simple microscope up to possible taxonomic level [18-
20] and their counting were made as total individual per m2 (ind./m2).
During sampling, in situ water quality parameters were measured at
each sampling site. e water salinity (ppt), temperature (°C), pH, and
DO (Dissolved Oxygen, mg/L) alkalinity (ppm) were measured using
refractometer (NewS-100, TANAKA, Japan), thermometer (centigrade
scale), pH meter (HANNA Instruments), DO meter (HANNA
Instruments) and Hach hardness and alkalinity kit respectively.
e total number of macro invertebrates was counted in a sample
and then number of macro-invertebrates per square meter occurrence
was computed using the following formula Welch [21],
*10000
.
=O
Nas
Where
N=Number of macro-invertebrates 1 sq. m. of profoundal bottom
O=No. of macro-invertebrate (actually counted) per sampled area,
a=Transverse area of Ekman dredge in sq. cm, and
s=Number of sample taken at one sampling site.
Speciesdiversityindex(H)
Species richness index (d); and evenness index were calculated
according to following equations
e data harvested from monthly samples were blended to provide
the value of Shannon-Wiener Index (Species diversity, H) according
to [22],
1
=−=
s
i
H PiLnPi
Where
S=Total number of species in a sample,
Pi=ni/N=Proportion of individuals of the total sample belonging
to the ith species.
N=Total number of individual of all the species,
ni=Number of individuals belonging to the ith species.
eMargalef’sindex
Species Richness (D) is simple ratio between total species (S) and
Figure 1: Map showing the location of two study sites namely the Meghna River Estuary, Noakhali and Bakkhali River Estuary, Cox’s Bazar of Bangladesh.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 3 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
total numbers of individual (N) [23]. It can be used to compare one
community with another. e index is
1
ln
=S
DN
Where
D=Margalef’s index
S=Number of species in sample
ln=log normal
N=Total number of individuals in sample
Simpsonindex(D)
e Simpson Index value also ranges between 0 and 1, and the
greater the value, the greater the sample diversity [24]
Simpson Index
1
1
2
=
=
s
i
D
Pi
In the Simpson index, P is the proportion (n/N) of individuals
of one particular species found (n) divided by the total number of
individuals found (N), Σ is still the sum of the calculations, and s is the
number of species.
Species Evenness: According to Cox [25,26] the species evenness is
max
=H
EH
Where
e value of E is between 0.
Hmax=ln(S) and S=S=Total number of species in a sample
H=Shannon Diversity value
Equitability
Shannon diversity divided by the logarithm of number of taxa [27]
was measured by using following formula:
=
Hs
JLogs
Where
J=Equability index
Hs=Shannon and Weiner Index
S=Number of species in a population
edominanceindex(D)
e dominance index [27] was measured to determine whether or
not particular sheries species dominate in a particular aquatic system
and can be useful index of resource monopolization by a superior
competitor, particularly in communities that have been invaded by
exotic species. is index was determined by using following formula:
1
2
=

=

i
ni
Dn
Where
ni=number of individuals of species i
n=total number of individuals
Menhinick’srichnessindex
e ratio of the number of taxa to the square root of sample size [28].
/=
Menhinick
I SN
Where
S=Number of species in sample
N=Total number of individuals in sample
Brillouinindex
It is measured by using following formula [29]
ln( !) ln( !)
=
i
Brillouin
Nn
I
N
Where
N! is N factorial, i.e., N × (N-1) × (N-2) × (N-3) × ... × 3 × 2 × 1
Fisher’salpha
A diversity index, dened implicitly by the following formula [27].
Where
S=number of taxa,
n=number of individuals and
a=Fisher’s alpha.
Berger-Parkerdominance
According to Harper the Berger-Parker dominance is simply the
number of individuals in the dominant taxon relative to n [27].
Paleontological Statistics (PAST) version 3.15, a soware package
for paleontological data analysis written by Ryan [30] was used to run
the analysis. PAST has grown into a comprehensive statistical package
that is used not only by paleontologists, but in many elds of life
science, earth science, and even engineering and economics.
ResultsandDiscussion
e abundance of macrobenthos was studied during February
to March, 2015 in the Bakkhali river estuary situated in Cox’s Bazar
district and the Meghna river estuary situated at Chairman Ghat
in Noakhali district. Among the observed water quality parameters
(Table 1) temperature (°C) is the important one because it has a
major inuence on biological activity and growth and the higher the
water quality the greater the biological activity (Washington State
Department of Ecology, 1991). e mean temperature (°C) observed
in the Bakkhali River estuary and Meghna River estuary were 28.33 ±
1.53 and 27.33 ± 1.53 respectively. Due to runo of huge freshwater
from other upper rivers of Bangladesh through the Meghna River to
the Bay of Bengal, the average salinity dierence of this estuary is lower
than the Bakkhali River estuary (Figure 2). e average salinity of the
Meghna river estuary was 5.67 ± 0.58 ppt which was lower than the
average salinity of the Bakkhali River estuary (22.00 ± 2.65 ppt) during
the study period (Table 1). ere was no signicant dierence in pH
values observed between two study sites. e average pH measured
in the study sites were 6.98 ± 0.45 in the Bakkhali River estuary and
7.87 ± 0.81 in the Meghna River estuary (Table 1 and Figure 3). e
values of dissolved oxygen observed in the present study inuenced
the abundance of the macrobenthic community both in the Meghna
River and the Bakkhali River estuary (Figure 4). is result is supported
by Islam [31], who reported that Species richness of macrobenthic
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 4 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
community was positively (p < 0.005) inuenced by dissolved oxygen
and percentage of silt while it was negatively (p < 0.005) inuenced
by percentage of sand and particle density. e abundance of benthic
community was signicantly (p < 0.05) inuenced by water salinity
(Table 1). Hossain and Marshall [32] also identied that species
richness increased onwards, though abundance (density) showed no
distinct directional trend. Diversity indices were generally positively
correlated with salinity and pH (p < 0.05) and negatively with clay
and organic matter. Hossain and Marshall [32] suggested that species
distribution and community structuring is more strongly inuenced by
sediment particle characteristics than by the chemical properties of the
water (pH and salinity).
5 major groups of macrobenthos (Polychaeta, Oligochaeta,
Arthropods, Gastropods and Bivalvia) identied in Bakhlali river
estuary (3909 ± 540) was higher than the Meghna river estuary (2236
± 689) where the existence of bivalvia and gastropoda were found
absent in the Meghna river estuary during the study period (Table
2). Polychaete and bivalvia showed the highest (49.42 %) and lowest
(5.54 %) density respectively (Table 2) among 28 families (Table 3)
identied from 5 major microbenthic groups. e average benthic
Figure 2: Relationship between the salinity (ppt) and abundance of macro benthic communities observed in the study sites. Bars indicate Standard Error.
Figure 3: Relationship between the changes of pH and abundance of macro benthic communities in the study sites. Bars indicate Standard Error.
Sites Stations Temperature (0C) Salinity (ppt) Dissolved Oxygen
(ppm) pH Alkalinity (ppm)
Bakkhali River
Estuary
S-1B 27 19 6.8 7.5 135
S-2B 28 24 13.7 6.75 120
S-3B 30 23 7.1 6.7 114
Mean ± Sd 28.33 ± 1.53 22 ± 2.65 9.20 ± 3.9 6.98 ± 0.45 123 ± 10.82
Meghna River
Estuary
S-4M 26 6 12.57 7.15 174
S-5M 27 5 12.89 8.75 168
S-6M 29 6 9.15 7.72 180
Mean ± Sd 27.33 ± 1.53 5.67 ± 0.58 11.54 ± 2.07 7.87 ± 0.81 174 ± 6.00
Table 1: In situ water quality parameters measured from the Bakkhali River Estuary and the Meghna River Estuary.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 5 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
organisms found in the sampling stations of the Bakkhali River
Estuary and the Meghna River Estuary were (3909 ± 540 Ind./m2
and 2236 ± 689 Ind./m2 respectively) was similar to the work done
by Ibrahim who identied that the benthic communities were more
dominant during pre-monsoon season (25,836.8 ind./m2) as compared
to post-monsoon season (21,573.1 ind./m2 ) in the coral areas of
Karah Island, Terengganu, Malaysia. Besides khan identied that
the population density varied from 96 to 9410 ind./m2 in the Mouri
River of Bangladesh. Amongst 28, the 10 most abundant microbenthic
families recorded from the two study sites were Lumbrinereidae-
12.30%, Cerithidae-10.12%, Nerediidae-8.43%, Goniadidae-7.47%,
Naididae-7.47, Capitellidae-6.26%, Neptydae-5.07%, Ocypodidae- 4.83,
Isaeidae-4.82% and Sternaspidae-2.89% (Table 3). Lumbrinereidae was
found dominant both in the Meghna River Estuary and the Bakkhali
River Estuary where Cerithidae was dominant in the Bakhkhali river
estuary (Table 3). e present ndings were quite similar to the ndings
of Hossain [33] who investigated the polychaetes faunal biodiversity
of the Meghna River estuarine bed. Similar results from other study
[33] on faunal composition, seasonal abundance of polychaete (ind./
m2), species richness and species biodiversity (Swandwip, Hatiya,
Bhola, Barisal and Chandpur) of Bangladesh revealed that Polychaetes
was the most dominant among the macrobenthic groups constituted
56.72% of the total macrobenthos. However, results from the present
study on microbenthic species composition was a little bit higher than
that of the results postulated from Abu Hena on Bakhlali river estuary
(Polychaeta, 9.966-30.31%; Oligochaeta, 3.68-30.31%; Crustacea, 0.02-
58.40%; Bivalvia, 1.40-82.09% and Gastropoda, 0.08-4.25% and similar
to the results of Asadujjaman [14,15,18,34].
Among the recorded 28 macrobenthic families from the study sites,
the maximum number of families was found in S-1B and S-2B of the
Bakkhali River Estuary where 21 families were common in both stations
(Table 3). Abundance of polychaetes were found to be the highest
(9110 ind./m2) among all macro-benthic communities (Table 2).
Maximum value (2089 ind./m2) macrobenthos was found at sampling
station S-2B of the Bakkhali River Estuary and minimum (711 ind./
m2) at station S-4M of the Meghna River Estuary (Table 2). A total 15
families were identied under taxonomic group of Polychaeta (Table
3). Olygochaetes were common at all the stations and occupied fourth
position as regards to the abundance of total macro-benthos (Table 2).
e maximum value (311 ind./m2) was recorded at station S-5M of the
Meghna River Estuary whereas the minimum (177 ind./m2) value was
recorded at station S-2B of the Bakkhali River Estuary (Table 2). A total
2 families were identied under the group of Oligochaeta (Table 3).
Arthropods constituted 12.77% of total macro-benthos (Table
2) and ranked 3rd. e maximum value (533 ind./m2) was found at
station S-5M of the Meghna River Estuary and minimum (266 Ind./
m2) at station S-1B of the Bakkhali River Estuary (Table 2). A total of
4 families were identied under the taxonomic group of Arthropoda
(Table 3).
Gastropods constituted 14.70% of total macro-benthos (Table 2)
however absent in the Meghna river estuary (Table 2). Gastropods had
its highest density (1066 ind./m2) at station S-1B and lowest (711 Ind./
m2) at station S-3B of the Bakkhali River Estuary (Table 2). A total of 3
families were recorded during the study period under this group (Table
3).
Figure 4: Relationship between the changes of DO (ppm) and abundance of macro benthic communities in the study sites. Bars indicate Standard Error.
Benthos Groups Bakkhali River Estuary Meghna River Estuary Mean ± SD Total Percentage (%)
S-1B S-2B S-3B S-4M S-5M S-6M
Polychaete 1555 2089 1733 711 1733 1289 1518.33 ± 432.73 9110 49.42
Oligochaete 221 266 177 267 311 222 244 ± 42.83 1464 7.94
Arthropods 266 445 311 311 533 489 392.50 ± 100.91 2355 12.77
Bivalvia 311 400 311 0 0 0 170.33 ± 172.90 1022 5.54
Gastropoda 1066 933 711 0 0 0 451.67 ± 463.38 2710 14.70
Unidentied 400 355 177 266 355 221 295.67 ± 80.07 1774 9.62
Total 3819 4488 3420 1555 2932 2221 3072.50 ± 1070.42 18435 100
Mean ± SD 3909 ± 540 2236 ± 689
Table 2: Abundance of Benthic groups (individuals/m2) found in the study sites.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 6 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
Maximum value (400 ind./m2) of bivalvia was found at station
S-2B and minimum (311 Ind./m2) at S-1B and S-3B (Ind./m2). Bivalvia
ranked 7th and contributed 1.15% of total Macro-benthos (Table
2). Total 3 families of benthos were identied under this taxonomic
group (Table 3). e percentages of Polycheate were higher than the
other benthic groups at all the stations (Table 3). e stations (S-4M,
S-5M, S-6M) of the Meghna river estuary showed higher percentages of
Olygochaete than the stations of Bakkhali river estuary.
Some water quality parameters were strongly correlated with the
abundance of the benthic macrofaunal communities. e abundance
of the benthic macrofaunal communities were signicantly positively
correlated with salinity (r=.846; p ≤ 0.05) and negatively correlated
with alkalinity (r=-.842, p ≤ 0.05). On the other hand, the abundance
of the benthic macrofaunal communities were signicantly positively
correlated with hardness (r=0.857, p ≤ 0.05) and TDS (r=0.887; p
≤ 0.05). e abundance of benthic communities were negatively
signicant with DO (r=-.106, p ≤ 0.05) (Table 4).
Macrobenthic species composition in Bakkhali river estuary showed
the maximum numbers of Polycheate (46%) followed by gastropods-
23%, atrhropods-9%, bivalvia-8% and oligochaete-6% where the
Meghna river estuary (Figure 5) showed the maximum number of
Polychaete (56%) followed by arthropods-20%, oligochaete-12%
(Figure 5). e density of macrobenthos found in 6 stations of the
two study sites were tabulated in Table 5 with percentage and ranked
according to the abundance of the macrobenthos in each station.
Polycheate ranked number 1 in all stations while other benthic groups
were uctuated within the stations (Table 5).
A biodiversity index seeks to characterize the diversity of a
sample or community by a single number. e concept of the ‘‘species
diversity’’ involves two components: the number of species or richness
and the distribution of individuals among species. However, Shannon–
Wiener diversity index considers the richness and proportion of each
species while Evenness and Dominance indices represent the relative
number of individuals in the sample and the fraction of common
species respectively. Quality of an aquatic ecosystem is dependent on
the physico-chemical qualities of waters and it is reected on biological
diversity. Dierent diversity indices were recorded in Table 6. About
28 families were identied from sampling stations during the study
period. Among the 28 families, the highest number of families were
identied from Station S-2B (22 families) followed by the S-1B (21
families), S-3B (15 families), S-6M (11 families), S-5M (10 families) and
S-4M (09 families) (Table 6). e Dominance-D value of the sampling
stations was found 0.06878. e highest Dominance-D value was
found in station S-6M (0.2155) followed by the S-4M (0.1546), S-5M
(0.1392), S-3B (0.0913), S-2B (0.07605) and S-1B (0.07552) (Table
5). e Simpson_D value of the sampling stations was identied as
0.9312. e highest and lowest values (Table 6) of Simpson_D were
Family Bakkhali River Estuary Meghna River Estuary Total Mean Standard
Deviation Percentage (%)
S-1B S-2B S-3B S-4M S-5M S-6M
Capitellidae 356 267 311 44 133 44 1155 192.50 137.09 6.26
Goniadidae 222 400 400 0 311 44 1377 229.50 174.31 7.47
Lumbrinereidae 89 0 178 *356 *756 *889 2268 378.00 366.30 12.30
Nereidae 311 400 177 222 311 133 1554 259.00 99.26 8.43
Onupidae 44 0 0 0 0 0 44 7.33 17.96 0.24
Spionidae 89 0 0 0 0 0 89 14.83 36.33 0.48
Sternaspidae 311 89 133 0 0 0 533 88.83 122.46 2.89
Syllidae 44 178 0 0 0 0 222 37.00 71.28 1.20
Magelonidae 44 89 267 0 0 89 489 81.50 99.21 2.65
Neptydae 44 313 267 44 178 89 935 155.83 115.79 5.07
Paraonidae 0 0 0 0 44 0 44 7.33 17.96 0.24
Maldanidae 0 44 0 0 0 0 44 7.33 17.96 0.24
Sabellidae 0 89 0 44 0 0 133 22.17 37.17 0.72
Glyceridae 0 44 0 0 0 0 44 7.33 17.96 0.24
Cossuridae 0 133 0 0 0 0 133 22.17 54.30 0.72
Orbiniidae 0 44 0 0 0 0 44 7.33 17.96 0.24
Naididae 178 222 177 267 311 222 1377 229.50 52.10 7.47
Tubicidae 44 44 0 0 0 0 88 14.67 22.72 0.48
Mysidae 44 44 44 0 0 44 176 29.33 22.72 0.95
Isaeidae 222 400 267 0 0 0 889 148.17 172.54 4.82
Ampeliscidae 0 0 0 133 177 89 399 66.50 77.98 2.16
Ocypodidae 0 0 0 178 356 356 890 148.33 175.01 4.83
Veneridae 133 222 89 0 0 0 444 74.00 91.69 2.41
Trapezidae 89 44 0 0 0 0 133 22.17 37.17 0.72
Tellinidae 89 133 222 0 0 0 444 74.00 91.69 2.41
Trachidae 222 222 0 0 0 0 444 74.00 114.64 2.41
Cerithidae *533 *711 *622 0 0 0 1866 311.00 345.30 10.12
Littorinidae 311 0 89 0 0 0 400 66.67 124.88 2.17
Unidentied 400 356 177 267 356 222 1778 296.33 87.74 9.64
Total 3819 4488 3420 1555 2933 2221 18436 3072.67 1070.42 100.00
*Indicates the highest number of the stations.
Table 3: Abundance of benthos families (individuals/m2) observed in the present study.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 7 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
identied in the stations S-1B (0.9245) and S-6M (0.7845) respectively.
Another important diversity index is Shannon_H diversity index. e
value of Shannon_H diversity index was recorded 2.89 while the value
of Equitability J was found highest in the station of S-3B (0.94) and
the lowest (Table 6) was in the station of S-6M (0.80). On the other
hand another diversity index Fisher Alpha showed highest value in the
station of S-2B (3.01) and the lowest was in the station of S-4M (1.27)
(Table 6). Aer analyzing the diversity indices of the sampling stations
of Bakkhali River Estuary and Meghna River Estuary, the signicant
dierences were found between the two study sites which are shown
in Figure 6. Dierent diversity indices showed signicant dierences
between the two study sites. e diversity values of Shannon H (Bakkhali
River Estuary-2.85, Meghna River Estuary-2.11), Evenness (Bakkhali
River Estuary-0.67, Meghna River Estuary-0.63), Simpson Index
(Bakkhali River Estuary-0.93, Meghna River Estuary-0.84), Mechinick
(Bakkhali River Estuary-0.24, Meghna River Estuary-0.16), Margalef
(Bakkhali River Estuary-2.67, Meghna River Estuary-1.36) and Fisher
alpha (Bakkhali River Estuary-3.16, Meghna River Estuary-1.55) were
found higher in the Bakkhali River Estuary and lower in the Meghna
River Estuary (Figure 6). Only the Dominance-D value and Berger-
Parker value of the Meghna River Estuary were found higher than the
Bakkhali River Estuary (Figure 6).
Shannon Weiner diversity Index is a commonly used diversity
index that takes into account both abundance and evenness of species
present in the community. In the present study aer analyzing the whole
samples (18) from six sampling stations of two sampling sites, overall
H value was found 2.89 (Table 6). e highest Shannon diversity index
(2.781) was found at S-2B in the study period and lowest was found at
S-6M (1.909) (Table 6). In biological communities, Shannon-Wiener
diversity index varies from 0 to 5. According to this index, values less
than 1 characterize heavily polluted condition, and values in the range
of 1 to 2 are the characteristics of moderate polluted condition while the
value above 3 signies stable environmental conditions [35,36]. Higher
value of Shannon_H indicated that the sampling stations have high
number of individuals. Signicant dierence was found in the mean
Shannon diversity index among the stations of the study sites (Table 6).
is nding is similar to the ndings of Bhandarkar, who investigated
on the potential of benthic macro-invertebrates community
assemblages in predicting the water quality status. Bhandarkar [37]
identied that (Shannon-Weiner index value ranges from 1.2 to 2.9 in
three ecosystems), all the selected sampling sites fall under moderate
pollution. e Shannon equitability index values showed a greater
equitability in the apportionment of individuals among the species in
all the sites.
According to Margalef [38], the higher diversity values reect
the suitability of habitat for the organism and have been reported to
be correlated with longer food chain and complex food web of the
ecosystems and also more stable community. Margalef index has no
limit value and it shows a variation depending upon the number of
species. In the present study the values of Margalef diversity index
were between 1.089 and 2.497 at station S-4M and S-2B respectively.
Menhinick index, like Margalef’s index, attempts to estimate species
richness but at the same time it is independent on the sample size. In
the present investigation, it ranged from 0.185 to 0.34 (Table 6). e low
diversity associated with station S-5M, as described by the Shannon,
Margalef and Menhinick indices, may be attributed to lesser number
of species and environmental degradation due to anthropogenic
pressures, besides other biotic factors [39]. e mean Margalef’s value
of the Bakkhali River Estuary (2.21) is higher than the mean value of
the Meghna River Estuary (1.17). Table 5 showed how the values dier
among the stations of the study sites. Again, Hossain [33] identied
that the Shannon species diversity index of polychaetes varied from
Figure 5: Percentage of macro benthic groups in the Bakkhali River Estuary (A) and the Meghna River Estuary (B).
Temperature Salinity DO pH Alkalinity Abundance
Temperature 0.445 -0.491 -0.357 -0.443 0.289
Salinity -0.318 -0.720 -0.980** 0.846**
DO 0.190 0.298 -0.106
pH 0.645* -0.287
Alkalinity . -0.842**
Abundance
**=highly correlated; *=moderately correlated (p ≤ 0.05)
Table 4: Relationship between water quality parameters and abundance of macrobenthic communities.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 8 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
0-1.36. It was the highest at Swandwip during post monsoon and lowest
at Bhola during monsoon in Bangladesh. Abu Hena [15] also identied
that the Shannon diversity index ranged from 0.65-1.04 among the
sampling stations at the Bakkhali River Estuary, Cox’s Bazar.
Species evenness refers to how close in numbers of each species in
an environment are. Mathematically it is dened as a diversity index,
a measure of biodiversity which quanties how equal the community
numerically. e higher value shows lower variation in number
of species. Usually it has been also dened as the ratio of observed
diversity to maximum diversity, the latter being said to occur when
the species in a collection are equally abundant [40]. Evenness index
value for collected 18 samples was 0.62, where the highest (0.85) and
the lowest (0.61) values of Evenness recorded from S-3B and S-6M,
respectively (Table 6). No signicant dierence was found in mean
value of evenness value among the stations and as well as within the
two study sites (Table 6).
In the present study diversity of benthic organisms were in the
sequence of Polychaete (49.42%) > Gastropods (14.70%) > Arthropods
(12.77%) > Oligochaete (7.94%) > Bivalvia (5.54%). On the other hand
there was an inverse relationship between these two indices in the three
sampling stations of the Bakkhali River Estuary. is ndings is similar
to the investigation of Bu-Olayan and omas who observed that
the diversity of benthic organisms were in the sequence of Annelida
> Mollusca > Crustacea > others group in Kuwait Bay of the Arabian
Study Sites Stations Benthos Group Individuals/m2Percentage (%) Rank of Abundance
Bakkhli River Estuary
S-1B
Polychaete 1556 41.21 1
Oligochaete 222 5.88 6
Arthropods 266 7.04 6
Bivalvia 265 7.02 6
Gastropoda 1067 28.26 2
Unidentied 400 10.59 5
Total 3776 100
S-2B
Polychaete 2089 46.55 1
Oligochaete 266 5.93 6
Arthropods 445 9.92 6
Bivalvia 400 8.91 6
Gastropoda 933 20.79 3
Unidentied 355 7.91 6
Total 4488 100
S-3B
Polychaete 1733 50.67 1
Oligochaete 177 5.18 6
Arthropods 311 9.09 6
Bivalvia 311 9.09 6
Gastropoda 711 20.79 3
Unidentied 177 5.18 7
Total 3420 100
Meghna River Estuary
S-4M
Polychaete 711 45.72 1
Oligochaete 267 17.17 4
Arthropods 311 20.00 4
Bivalvia 0 0.00 0
Gastropoda 0 0.00 0
Unidentied 266 17.11 4
Total 1555 100
S-5M
Polychaete 1733 59.11 1
Oligochaete 311 10.61 5
Arthropods 533 18.18 4
Bivalvia 0 0.00 0
Gastropoda 0 0.00 0
Unidentied 355 12.11 5
Total 2932 100
S-6M
Polychaete 1289 58.04 1
Oligochaete 222 10.00 6
Arthropods 489 22.02 3
Bivalvia 0 0.00 0
Gastropoda 0 0.00 0
Unidentied 221 9.95 6
Total 2221 100
* 1-5% = rank 7; 06-10% = rank 6; 11-15% = rank 5; 16-20% = rank 4; 21-25% = rank 3; 26-40% = rank 2; >41%=rank 1.
Table 5: Density of macrobenthos found in the Bakkhali River Estuary and the Meghna River Estuaryo.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 9 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
Gulf. Evenness index (–) was found to be increased with increasing
Bu-Olayan H and omas [41] identied that low diversity indices
correspond to the increase in trace metal level in benthic species
collected from four sites, wherein high abundance of certain benthic
species and high trace metal levels due to manmade perturbations were
observed altering the diversity indices and those indices would validate
benthic organisms as an indicator to trace metal pollution in Kuwait
marine ecosystem, however primary or secondary data regarding trace
metal concentrations is absent in the present study area [41].
Conclusion
e coastline along the South-Eastern part of Bangladesh has
high sheries resources and the sheries production of the estuarine
areas of that coast is higher than other coastal areas of the country.
Environmental pollution is believed to be the major constraints of
sheries production of an area. Although similar research is untouched
to assess the environmental pollution of a water body, macrobenthic
structure of those water bodies is used as indicator. erefore, due
to the lack of detailed study on the macrobenthic structure of those
areas, present study was designed to assess the pollution status of
the Bakkhali River estuary and the Meghna River estuary. A total 28
families under 05 major groups/taxa of macrobenthic communities
were identied and the dominant group both in number of families
(16 families) and individuals (49.42%) was the Polychaeta followed by
Gastropoda (14.70%), Arthropods (12.77%), Oligochaete (7.94%) and
the lowest was Bivalvia (5.54%). e abundance (r=.846) and species
richness (r=.864) of the macrobenthic communities were signicantly
inuenced by the water salinity of the sampling sites (p ≤ 0.05). Both the
study areas namely the Bakkhali River Estuary and the Meghna River
Estuary showed the highest (3909 ± 540 ind./m2) and lowest (2236 ± 689
ind./m2) density of microbenthic communities respectively. ese two
study sites might be considered as moderately polluted areas according
to the results obtained from Shannon-Wiener index of species diversity
(2.69 ± 0.13 and 2.00 ± 0.11 respectively) and Margalef’s species
richness (2.21 ± 0.43 and 1.36 ± 0.11 respectively). erefore, it can be
concluded that the macrobenthic community explained in the present
study might be a key future outline to assess the status of coastal water
pollution of those concerned areas of Bangladesh.
Acknowledgment
The authors realized thanks to the laboratory staffs of the Department of
Fisheries and Marine Science, Noakhali Science and Technology University
(NSTU) for their help in sample collections.
Figure 6: Diversity Indices of the two study sites.
Stations S-1B S-2B S-3B Mean ± SD S-4M S-5M S-6M Mean ± SD All Stations
Taxa_S 21 *22 15 19.33±3.79 9 10 11 10 ± 1.0 28
Individuals 3819 *4488 3420 3909 ± 540 1555 2933 2221 2236 ± 689 18436
Dominance D 0.08 0.08 0.09 0.08 ±0.01 0.15 0.14 *0.22 0.17± 0.04 0.07
Simpson D *0.93 0.92 0.91 0.92 ± 0.01 0.85 0.86 0.78 0.83 ± 0.04 0.93
Shannon_H 2.76 *2.78 2.54 2.69 ±0.13 1.98 2.12 1.91 2.00 ± 0.11 2.89
Evenness 0.75 0.73 *0.85 0.78 ± 0.06 0.81 0.83 0.61 0.75 ± 0.12 0.62
Brillouin 2.74 *2.77 2.53 2.68 ± 0.13 1.97 2.11 1.89 1.99 ± 0.11 2.88
Menhinick *0.34 0.33 0.26 0.31 ± 0.04 0.23 0.18 0.23 0.22 ± 0.03 0.21
Margalef 2.43 *2.50 1.72 2.21 ± 0.43 1.09 1.13 1.30 1.17 ± 0.11 2.85
Equitability_J 0.91 0.90 *0.94 0.91 ± 0.02 0.90 0.92 0.80 0.87 ± 0.07 0.86
Fisher_alpha 2.93 *3.01 2.02 2.65 ± 0.55 1.27 1.29 1.51 1.36 ± 0.13 3.37
Berger-Parker 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.16 ± 0.02 0.23 0.26 *0.40 0.30 ± 0.09 0.12
*Indicates the highest value among the stations.
Table 6: Diversity Indices Observed in the Present Study.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to
Assess Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-3508.1000157
Page 10 of 10
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • 1000157
Fish Aquac J
ISSN: 2150-3508 FAJ, an open access journal
References
1. Sinelgrove PVR (1998) Biodiversity Conservation 7: 1123-1132.
2. Aura CM, Raburu PO, Herrmann J (2011) Macro invertibrate’s community
structure in Rivers Kipkaren and Sosiani, River Nzoia Basin, Kenya. J Eco Nat
Environment 3: 39-46.
3. McLusky DS (1989) The estuarine ecosystem. Chapman and Hall, London,
pp: 133.
4. Newrkla P, Gunatilaka A (1982) Benthic community metabolism of three
Austrian pre-alpine lakes of different tropic conditions and its oxygen
dependency. Hydrobiologia 92: 531-536.
5. Pearson TH (1970) The benthic ecology of Loch Linnhe and Loch Eil, a Sea-
Loch system on the west coast of Scotland. The physical environment and
distribution of the macrobenthic fauna. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 5: 1-34.
6. Bonada N, Prat N, Resh VH, Statzner B (2006) Development in aquatic insect
Bio-monitoring: a comparative analysis of recent approaches. Annual Review
of Entomology 51: 495-523.
7. Bilgrami KS, Munshi D (1985) Ecology of river Ganges: Impact on human
activities and conservation of aquatic biodata (Patna to Farakka). Allied Press,
Bhagalpur.
8. Venkateswarlu V (1986) Ecological studies on the rivers of Andhra Pradesh
with special reference to water quality and Pollution. Proc Indian Sci Acad 96:
495-508.
9. Wilhm RL, Dorris TC (1968) The biological parameters for water quality criteria.
Bio Science 18: 477-492.
10. Cairns JR, Dickson KL (1971) A simple method for the biological assessment
of the effects of waste discharges on aquatic bottom dwelling organisms. J Wat
Pollut Control 43: 755-772.
11. Hynes HBN (1970) The ecology of stream insects. Annual Review of
Entomology 15: 25-42.
12. Pramanik MAH (1988) Methodologies and techniques of studying coastal
systems: Case Studies II, Space and Remote Sensing Organization (SPARSO),
Bangladesh pp: 122-138.
13. Abu Hena MK, Ashraful MAK (2009) Coastal and estuarine resources of
Bangladesh: Management and conservation issues. Maejo International
Journal of Science and Technology 2: 313-42.
14. Khan AN, Kamal D, Mahmud MM, Rahman MA, Hossain MA (2007) Diversity,
Distribution and Abundance of Benthos in Mouri River, Khulna, Bangladesh. Int
J Sustain Crop Prod 2: 19-23.
15. Abu Hena MK, Kohinoor SMS, Siddique MAM, Ismail J, Idris MH, et al. (2012)
Composition of Macrobenthos in the Bakkhali Channel System, Cox’s Bazar
with Notes on the Soil Parameter. Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences 15:
641-646.
16. Belaluzzaman AM (1995) Ecology of the Intertidal Macrobenthic Fauna in
Cox’s Bazar Coastal Area, MSc Thesis, Institute of Marine Sciences, University
of Chittagong, Bangladesh pp: 199.
17. Jakobsen F, Azam MH, Kabir M, Mahboob-Ul (2002) Residual Flow in the
Meghna River Estuary on the Coastline of Bangladesh, Estuarine, Coastal and
Shelf Science 4: 587-597.
18. Ibrahim S, Hussin WMRW, Kassiml Z, Joni ZM, Zakaria MZ, et al. (2005)
Seasonal Abundance of Benthic Communities in Coral Areas of Karah Island,
Terengganu, Malaysia, Turkish Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 6:
129-136.
19. Alam MS (1993) Ecology of the Intertidal Macrobenthos of Halishahar coast,
Chittagong, Bangladesh, Ph. D. Thesis, Department of zoology, University of
Chittagong, Bangladesh pp: 243.
20. Al-Yamani, Faiza Y, Skryabin, Valeriy, Boltachova, et al. (2012) Illustrated Atlas
on the Zoo benthos of Kuwait, Kuwait Institute for Scientic Research.
21. Welch PS (1948) Limnology. Mc graw Hill book Company, New York.
22. Wilhm JL, Dorris TC (1966) Species diversity of benthic marco-invertebrates
in a stream receiving domestic and oil renery efuents. Am. Midl. Nat 76:
427-449.
23. Margalef R (1968) Perspectives in Ecological Theory. University of Chicago
Press, Chicago, IL p: 111.
24. Simpson EH (1949) Measurement of diversity. Nature pp: 688.
25. Cox WG (1996) Laboratory Manual of General Ecology. Ed Wm C Brown
Publsishers.
26. Stiling PD (1996) Ecology theories aladapplications. Ed Prentice Hall, New
Jersey.
27. Harper DAT (1999) Numerical Palaeobiology. John Wiley & Sons.
28. Magurran AE (2004) Measuring biological diversity. Blackwell.
29. Maurer BA, McGill BJ (2011) Measurement of species diversity. Biological
diversity: frontiers in measurement and assessment. Oxford University Press,
Oxford, New York pp: 55-64.
30. Ryan PD, Harper DAT, Whalley JS (1995) PALSTAT, Statistics for
palaeontologists. Chapman & Hall, Kluwer Academic Publishers.
31. Islam M, Shaqul, Sikdar M, Nurul Azim, Al-Imran M, et al. (2013) Intertidal
Macrobenthic Fauna of the Karnafuli Estuary: Relations with Environmental
Variables, World Applied Sciences Journal 21: 1366-1373.
32. Hossain M, Belal, Marshall, David J (2014) Benthic infaunal community
structuring in an acidied tropical estuarine system, Aquatic Biosystems.
33. Hossain MB (2009) Macrozoobenthos of the meghna river estuarine bed with
special reference to polychaete faunal biodiversity, International journal of
sustainable agricultural technology, Science publication, Ghurpukur Research
institute (GPRI), Bangladesh 3: 11-16.
34. Asadujjaman M, Hossain M, Belal, Shamsuddin M, Amin A, et al. (2012) The
effect of industrial waste of Memphis and Shelby country on primary planktonic
producers, Bioscience 20: 905-912.
35. Mason CF (1988) Biology of Fresh Water Pollution. Longman scientic and
technical.
36. Stub R, Appling JW, Hatstetter AM, Hass IJ (1970) The effect of industrial waste
of Memphis and Shelby country on primary planktonic producers, Bioscience
20: 905-912.
37. Bhandarkar SV, Bhandarkar WR (2013) A study on species diversity of
benthic macro invertebrates in freshwater lotic ecosystems in Gadchiroli district
Maharashtra, International journal of Life Sciences 1: 22-31.
38. Margalef R (1956) Information Y diversidad especi caenlas communidades de
organisms. Invest Pesg 3: 99-106.
39. Ravera O (2001) A comparison between diversity, similarity and biotic indices
applied to the macro invertebrate community of a small stream: The Ravella
River (Como Province, Northern Italy). Aquatic Ecol 35: 97-107.
40. Margalef DR (1958) Information theory in ecology. Gen Syst 3: 36-71.
41. Bu-Olayan AH, Thomas BV (2005) Validating species diversity of benthic
organisms to trace metal pollution in Kuwait Bay, off the Arabian Gulf, Applied
Ecology and Environmental Research 3: 93-100.
Citation: Sarker J Md, Patwary SA Md, Uddin AMMB, Hasan M Md, Tanmay
MH, et al. (2016) Macrobenthic Community Structure - An Approach to Assess
Coastal Water Pollution in Bangladesh. Fish Aquac J 7: 157. doi:10.4172/2150-
3508.1000157
OMICSInternational:PublicationBenefits&Features
Unique features:
• Increasedglobalvisibilityofarticlesthroughworldwidedistributionandindexing
• Showcasingrecentresearchoutputinatimelyandupdatedmanner
• Specialissuesonthecurrenttrendsofscienticresearch
Special features:
• 700OpenAccessJournals
• 50,000Editorialteam
• Rapidreviewprocess
• Qualityandquickeditorial,reviewandpublicationprocessing
• IndexingatPubMed(partial),Scopus,EBSCO,IndexCopernicus,GoogleScholaretc.
• SharingOption:SocialNetworkingEnabled
• Authors,ReviewersandEditorsrewardedwithonlineScienticCredits
• Betterdiscountforyoursubsequentarticles
Submityourmanuscriptat:http://www.omicsonline.org/submission
... The Meghna is the biggest freshwater-dominated estuary in Bangladesh due to heavy rainfall and freshwater discharges from upstream, as well as enriched living resources such as aquatic macrophytes (i.e., tropical moist forest, mangroves, salt marshes, sea grass, seaweeds), fisheries, coastal birds, animals, coral reefs and non-living resources such as deltas, salt beds, minerals and sand dunes [45,46]. The bedforms of the Meghna estuary are among the most intensively surveyed areas of benthic invertebrates and their relationship with highly variable hydrological factors (hydrodynamic conditions and physico-chemical properties of water columns) in Bangladesh. ...
... Nevertheless, as periods observation of hydrological factors over time are effortful and costly in many situations, their contribution may be underrated in benthic ecological investigations [47]. Several studies on macrobenthos have been carried out in the Meghna estuary [45,[48][49][50][51]. However, these studies were based on preliminary observations and only discussed the occurrence and composition of macrobenthos in the Meghna River estuary. ...
... Benthic studies in estuaries have demonstrated that the distribution of macrobenthos shows a clear affinity with abiotic variables [30,34,71,[81][82][83][84][85][86], and this is consistent with the current study. In our study area, Spearman's rank correlations indicated that abundance had significantly positive correlations with soil pH, salinity and alkalinity, which was true in most other research findings [32,45]. Alkalinity was significantly negatively correlated with abundance and DO but significantly positively correlated with hardness in the Bakkhali and Meghna estuary [45]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Assessment of benthic diversity and estuarine ecological quality is becoming increasingly important. Estuaries are not only highly productive and variable environments, but they are also areas of high anthropogenic perturbations. In this study, benthic macrofauna were sorted, identified and analyzed from a freshwater-dominated tropical estuary along the Bay of Bengal to assess their community structure, distribution and functional guilds, and to uncover the environmental drivers influencing their distributional patterns. Results revealed that the studied physio-chemical variables (DO, pH, alkalinity and temperature) were significantly varied (p < 0.05) among the sites. Capitella sp. was dominant (18%) of the forty morphospecies recorded, indicating organic richness of the area. The ANOVA results revealed that macrobenthic density differed significantly (p < 0.01) between the study locations, and diversity indices (Shannon diversity index, H') also differed significantly (F4,12 = 5.89; p = 0.02). The benthic density decreased from the head to the mouth, which could be related to salinity fluctuations and large freshwater discharges. Upstream sites were completely segregated from downstream and mid-estuarine sites, according to cluster analysis (CA). The SIMPER results clarified the site grouping pattern, showing that Mysis-1 spp., Capitella spp. and Nephtys-1 were the most significant contributors. From the communities, five functional trophic groups were identified where deposit feeders were the most dominant (66.44%). Most of the macrobenthos had strong positive correlations with DO (r = 0.92) and water temperature (r = 0.86) and a negative correlation with soil pH (r = −0.28), per correlation and CCA analyses. Individually, soil pH (r = 0.88) and alkalinity (r = 0.898) showed strong positive correlation with Capitella sp. and Chironomus sp.2. The above results indicate that macrobenthos of this estuary do not follow the usual pattern of spatial distribution, and they are structured by DO, alkalinity and soil pH. In addition, dominance of some pollution indicator species (Capitella sp. and Chironomus sp.) and deposit feeders indicates a poor ecological condition of the estuary.
... The area is primarily covered with the saltmarsh species Porteresia sp. [23] and directly influenced by the incoming semi-diurnal tide (two tidal cycles per lunar day of 24 h 50 min) of Bay of Bengal. Therefore, the water level in the study area shows considerable variation from neap to spring tides. ...
... Due to high discharge from the rivers Ganges, Jamuna, and Meghna, suspended sediment concentrations are generally abundant and the particles are fine, cohesive, prone to flocculate, and organically rich. The salinity varies from 4-6 ppt and the water temperature from 26-29 • C along the Noakhali Coast [23]. During the rainy season, the area receives on about 2200 mm of rainfall on average. ...
... This dissimilarity was contrary to the finding of Beasley et al. [65], First and Hollibaugh [66], and Braga et al. [6]. Sarker et al. [23] demonstrated that alkalinity was significantly negatively correlated with abundance, which agrees with the present findings. Diversity index showed a positive significant correlation with salinity, not only in saltmarshes in the Schelde [49] but also in other estuaries [67], which is opposite to our findings. ...
Article
Full-text available
Saltmarsh is one of the most productive coastal habitats in the marine environment, and the macroinvertebrate community is crucial to its ecology and productivity. These productive ecosystems are currently under threat due to climate change and anthropogenic activities. However, macroinvertebrate communities and their functionality in saltmarsh from subtropical coastal areas have previously been largely ignored. In this study, we aimed to elucidate (i) the diversity and community assemblages, (ii) trophic structure, and (iii) changes of macroinvertebrate diversity under different seasons and climatic variables from a subtropical saltmarsh habitat. A total of 29 taxa in the eight (8) major groups were recorded in both seasons, with polychaetes being dominant (64%) in monsoon and crustaceans (50%) in post-monsoon. Among the trophic groups identified, surface deposit feeders and omnivores were dominant, accounting for 78.52% of the total groups. The highest value of diversity index (2.04) was observed at station S3 in monsoon and the lowest (1.408) at station S2 in post-monsoon. Strong seasonal variability was confirmed by two-way ANOVA and PERMANOVA, and SIMPER analysis identified that shrimp larvae (Macrobrachium sp.) were the taxa that contributed the most to grouping patterns between areas and seasons. In addition, non-metric multidimensional scaling (nMDS) revealed a great dissimilarity of macrobenthic faunal assemblages among the study stations and seasons. Spearman’s rank correlation analysis and canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) results revealed that the climatic factors water temperature, salinity, and alkalinity variation influenced the benthic community diversity.
... It is from ancient Greek which means "Depth of the sea bottom" (Tagliapietra & Sigovini, 2010). Polychaete, oligochaete worms, gastropods, bivalves, and insect larvae are the typical benthic invertebrates which subjugate in aquatic bodies (Sarker Md, 2016). The survival of macrobenthos is determined by the biological, chemical, and physical factors of the environment (Muhammad Darif et al., 2016). ...
... In addition, commercial fishing activities also lead to changes of habitat structure and affect the diversity, community composition, biomass, and productivity of associated biota. Moreover, the physical and chemical environment of the water body such as depth, current, organic contents of the sediments, and contaminations of bed sediments' condition and toxicity of sediments influence the species richness and distribution of macrobenthos (Sarker Md, 2016). Macrobenthos communities are the most commonly used in biomonitoring to analyze contaminant loads due to high sensitivity to organic pollutants either in coastal water or fresh water (Azrina et al., 2006). ...
... The term assemblages of macrobenthic organisms refers to a collection or gathering of marine invertebrates that live at the bottom of a water column and visible to the naked eyes under the comparable environmental conditions and biological surroundings (Sarker Md, 2016). It is usually dominated by different species of polychaete worms, bivalvia. ...
Article
Full-text available
Macrobenthos animals are an architect of a variety of roles including as a part of the food web of aquatic ecosystem and improve the structure of the sediment and can determine the quality of the water. Macrobenthos communities have shown their potential role in biomonitoring to analyze contaminant loads due to high sensitivity to organic pollutants along the coastal water area. Besides, it is also used to determine heavy metals and petroleum hydrocarbons in coastal water due to their long sustainability with chemicals are primarily related with industrial calamities and occupational activities. Based on above perspectives, this systematic review has shown interesting findings about the macrobenthic diversity including community composition in the coastal areas of Malaysia. The study has focused on the diversity and abundance of macrobenthos communities along some potential coastal areas of Malaysia which emphasis on the states of Johor, Pulau Pinang, Selangor, Pahang, Terengganu, and Sarawak. Several studies have evidently revealed that pollutants and human activities have contributed to loss of macrobenthos towards abundance (individuals/m²) and species richness. The highest abundance of macrobenthos was Coleoptera sp. (1650 ind./m² followed by Hemiptera sp. (860 ind./m²) were observed in Sarawak and Crustacea sp. (597 ind/m²) was found in Selangor, respectively. While Crustacea (10 ind/m²) was found as the lowest in the coastal water Pahang only. A major shortcoming among the studies was sampling time along with sampling method which was observed in this systematic review of different studies of macrobenthic assemblages in the coastal waters of Malaysia. However, the existing study reveals the baseline information on macrobenthic community which are still inadequate in Malaysia. Hence, a long-term monitoring for eco-biology and species diversity of macrobenthic assemblages are necessary for their sustainable development in this fascinating tropical coastal water of Malaysia.
... Recent extensive dredging in the Pasur River estuary to carry coal to the Rampal power station increases turbidity and sedimentation, which has an impact on the recruitment, survival, and abundance of macro-benthos and other inhabitants. The macro-benthic community structure of Bangladesh's rivers and estuaries has been studied by a number of researchers, including Sharif et al. [12], Ullah et al. [13], Matin et al. [14], Haque et al. [15], Sarker et al. [16] and Islam et al. [17]. The majority of the earlier research solely looked at the taxonomic variety of benthos in estuaries while ignoring the functional traits of this major group. ...
... In addition, the evenness index (F = 9.915, p = 0.005) increased with the increasing H', and a significantly higher value was observed in the period of post-monsoon (0.92) compared to pre-monsoon (0.75) and monsoon (0.50) season respectively. Sarkar et al. [16] observed the evenness value ranged from 0.61-0.85 at Meghna and Bakkhali River estuary, which supports the present findings. ...
Article
Full-text available
Macro-benthos is commonly considered an indicator for evaluating the health of an aquatic ecosystem. Earlier research from subtropical mangrove estuaries, however, has primarily relied on conventional taxonomic methods to determine the pattern of macro-benthos diversity. Therefore, this study aimed to describe the pattern of both taxonomic and functional groups of macro-benthos with respect to ecological variables in three separate seasons (pre-monsoon, monsoon, and post-monsoon) from a mangrove-dominated Pasur River estuary, Bangladesh. The findings revealed significant seasonal variations in the water and sediment parameters (p < 0.05). During the study period, 47 species belonging to 35 families of macro-benthos were identified. The pollution indicator species, Capitella capitata complex was found to be dominant. The highest density of macro-benthos was recorded in post-monsoon (545 ± 13.76 ind./m 2) followed by pre-monsoon (214 ± 5.57 ind./m 2) and monsoon (63 ± 2.27 ind./m 2). Diversity indices, Shannon, and evenness also displayed a similar seasonal trend. This pattern may be explained by the more stable bottom and higher food availability during post-monsoon, and on the other side, by erosion and higher turbidity during monsoon. Analysis of similarity (ANOSIM) detected a significant difference in community assemblage among the seasons (R = 0.7222, p = 0.0005), whereas similarity percentage analysis (SIMPER) identified Dendronereis aestuarina as the most contributory species for the overall average dissimilarity. Six functional feeding groups (FFGs) were identified where gathering collectors (GC) had the highest total density (221.83 ind./m 2) and relative abundance (26.97%). The community was shown to be shaped by the amount of sedimentary silt and dissolved oxygen in the water main, according to a canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) study, they were positively correlated with the abundance of Pristinella acuminata, Lumbrineris sp., Cossura coasta, C. capitata complex, Neritina violacea, Laccotrephes griseus, Hydrometra butleri, Gomphus sp. and Libellula sp. CCA analysis also revealed a significant positive influence of pH, NO 3-N, PO 4-P, and organic matter, whereas, sand particles of sediments were found to have a negative effect on FFGs. Overall, the study suggests that the estuary is moderately diverse with macro-benthos and their functional feeding groups and influenced by monsoon strongly. The present study on FFGs of macro-benthos in an estuarine river of Bangladesh will provide baseline information for further investigation of other estuaries.
... Since they mineralize, encourage, and mix the oxygen flux into the sediment, macrobenthos play a crucial role in aquatic ecosystems by recycling organic matter. Physical and chemical factors, such as contamination of the sediment ecosystem, the organic matter of the deposits, the depths, fast deposition, and sediment toxicity, influence the distribution and abundance of benthic communities, causing shifts of macrobenthic communities toward lower abundance (Sarker et al., 2016). ...
... In addition, benthic macrofauna protects the water and contributes to improving water quality by mineralizing and recycling organic material, as well as decomposing organic material. (Sarker et al., 2016). Benthic communities are used as indicators in environmental impact studies (Warwick, 1993) to determine the types and levels of pollutants and to assess the environmental quality of coastal systems (Ponti and Abbiati, 2004;Boutoumit et al., 2021;Hisli et al., 2022). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study is on the relationships between the abundances, of cnidarians and echinoderms found in Çardak Lagoon and environmental variables. The benthos samples were collected in three replicates in October 2018, February, April, and June 2019, using a metal framed quadrat system of 100 x 100 cm and 393 cm3 sediment core by a SCUBA diver. Sediment material was collected at 7 sampling points of Çardak Lagoon in Çanakkale Strait. A total of 259 individuals belonging to phylum, Cnidaria and Echinodermata were found in the study area. Cnidarian, Actinia sp. and echinoderm, Asterina gibbosa were the most dominant species. The highest positive correlation value was between Cnidaria species number and organic matter (OM%) content in the sediment. The highest negative correlation value was between Echinodermata species number and NO2+NO3 in lagoon system.
... It is also specific for the diverse types of wet habitats, especially the flooded fir forest, which covers an area of twentythree hectares. Less was known whether the wetland represents a significant habitat for the invertebrate fauna, which, besides its important role in the food chains, significantly contributes towards improving and preserving water quality through mineralisation and recycling of organic matters structures and oxygenates the bottom by reworking sediments, recycling nutrients, decomposing organic matter and linking primary production with higher trophic levels (Sarker et al. 2016). Hence, it is used as an indicator for the detection of types and levels of stress in environmental impact studies (Warwick 1993) and since the implementation of the WFD (WFD 2000) became a valuable tool in the assessment of the quality of the water and the health of the aquatic ecosystem (Rosenberg & Resh 1993). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study depicts the results from the extensive monitoring of the invertebrate fauna of Belchishta Wetland, which is the largest preserved wetland in North Macedonia with an area of 137 hectares, including flooded forests and wet habitats. A total of thirty taxa belonging to eight systematic groups were registered, three of them being endemic species. Among the three endemic species, two are on the national list of endangered species. The thirty registered taxa of the invertebrate fauna of Belchishta Wetland point to a pronounced biodiversity, the framework of which includes endemic species with a narrow area of distribution and low abundance. These are justified arguments for the immediate adoption of conservation and protection measures through integral management of the whole Belchishta Wetland.
... A few studies were conducted on macrobenthic community structure, abundance and distribution in the Karnaphuli river (Islam et al., 2013), Meghna river estuary at Chairmanghat, Noakhali and the Bakkhali river estuary at Cox's Bazar (Sarker et al., 2016), lower Meghna river estuary (Sharif et al., 2017), Naf river estuary (Noman et al., 2019) and Gomti river, Cumilla (Rahman et al., 2021). Rashed-Un-Nabi et al. (2011) assessed the fish and shellfish assemblage in the Bakkhali River in relation with water parameters. ...
Article
Full-text available
The study aimed to assess the macrobenthos abundance and distribution from the Bakkhali River, East Coast of Bangladesh. Macrobenthic and water samples were collected from the upper, middle and lower part of the river during post-monsoon. Several indices were used to find macrobenthos abundance and distribution and their correlation with water parameters were also assessed. Present study identified a total of 628 macrobenthos individuals representing 10 major taxa at three stations where 9 taxa were reported in both upper and middle parts whereas only 7 taxa were observed at lower stream of the river. The highest abundance of macrobenthos (301.04 indivs/m2) was recorded at the lower stream and the lowest abundance (166.3 indivs/m2) was found at the upper part of the river. Macrobenthos distribution showed that the number of Oligochaetes was higher (220 indivs) followed by Nemertinas (169 indivs) and Polychaetes (145 indivs). Study findings reveal that macrobenthos abundance and distribution were comparatively higher at the lower stream than the upper and middle part because of higher level of pollution and sendimentation rate that might influence the macrobenthos abundance and diversity in the upper and middle part. The study also found macrobenthos abundance was proportionally increased with increasing salinity and pH. However, macrobenthos abundance was decreased with increasing temperature. Simpson index (D) was the highest (0.32) at middle and lower part and the lowest (0.23) was in the upper part. Shannon-wiener index (H) was also higher (1.68) at the upper part. Both the indices showed higher diversity at the upper part because of having maximum taxa in the station. Based on the H value, this study reported that Bakkhali River was moderately polluted since H value was in the range of 1.44 to 1.68. These might be because of anthropogenic sources of pollution in the vicinity of the river. This study suggests to take proper management strategies to control aquatic pollution and conserve aquatic biodiversity. The Dhaka University Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences
Article
Full-text available
The Batanghari River, located in Sumatera, has experienced many anthropogenic pressures which caused sedimentation and changes in the river's water quality. Plankton and benthic communities are organisms that are very sensitive to changes in environmental quality. This study aimed to investigate and update the spatial variation of water quality, plankton, and macrozoobenthos diversity in the Batanghari River. The results show that nitrite, ammonia and total phosphorus concentrations are quite high in the waters with a low clarity level. The highest diversity index and abundance of phytoplankton were found in Batanghari Tabir. Bacillariophyceae dominated the phytoplankton found in the Batanghari River. Zooplankton found in this study came from Cladocera, Rotifera, and Protozoa. The highest diversity index and abundance were found in Batanghari Tebo. The most common type of macrozoobenthos came from the Oligochaeta group. In general, phytoplankton was categorized as of a moderate diversity. Even zooplankton's and macrozoobenthos's diversity was relatively low in diversity.
Article
Full-text available
KEYWORDS A study was conducted to evaluate the potential of benthic macro-invertebrates community assemblages in predicting the water quality status. Three sampling stations with various environmental quality gradients were selected at the Wainganga, Gadhavi and Khobragadhi River in Gadchiroli district in order to determine differences or changes in the benthos community associated with variability in water quality. The diversity indices like Shannon-Wiener index, Evenness or Shannon equitability index and Margalef's index were calculated. According to Shannon-Wiener index of species diversity, all the selected sampling sites fall under moderate pollution. The Shannon equitability index values showed a greater equitability in the apportionment of individuals among the species in all the sites while Margalef's index of species richness reveals that the site-I had more healthy body and have higher species diversity among all sampling sites. The species diversity of site-II is greater than site-III. The site-III had poorer in species diversity and nutrient material.
Article
Full-text available
The coastal area of Bangladesh includes a number of bays into which different types of rivers empty, creating an estuarine ecosystem adjacent to the shore. The main estuarine systems are Brahmaputra-Megna (Gangetic delta), Karnaphuly, Matamuhuri, Bakkhali and Naf rivers, which are comprised of mangroves, salt marshes, seagrass, seaweeds, fisheries, coastal birds, animals, coral reefs, deltas, salt beds, minerals and sand dunes. The estuarine environment, which serves as feeding, breeding and nursery grounds for a variety of animals, varies according to the volume of discharge of the river and tidal range. It is highly productive in terms of nutrient input from different sources that promotes other living resources in the estuaries. Drought conditions exist during the winter months, i.e. November to February, and effective rainfall is confined to the monsoon period, i.e. May to June. Changes in salinity and turbidity depend on annual rainfall. The colour of most estuarine waters is tea brown or brown due to heavy outflows during the monsoon. The tidal mixing and riverine discharge governs the distribution of the hydrological parameters. The pH of these waters is reported to be slightly alkaline (>7.66) and dissolved oxygen (<6.0 mg/l) shows an inverse relationship to temperature. Studies of plankton have indicated two periods of maximum abundance, i.e. February- March and August-September. The abundance of fish and shrimp larvae varies in number and composition with season. Many marine and freshwater species are available in various types of coastal brackish water, which depend on monsoonal activities and local environmental conditions.
Article
Full-text available
Background Recent studies suggest that increasing ocean acidification (OA) should have strong direct and indirect influences on marine invertebrates. While most theory and application for OA is based on relatively physically-stable oceanic ecological systems, less is known about the effects of acidification on nearshore and estuarine systems. Here, we investigated the structuring of a benthic infaunal community in a tropical estuarine system, along a steep salinity and pH gradient, arising largely from acid-sulphate groundwater inflows (Sungai Brunei Estuary, Borneo, July 2011- June 2012). Results Preliminary data indicate that sediment pore-water salinity (range: 8.07 - 29.6 psu) declined towards the mainland in correspondence with the above-sediment estuarine water salinity (range: 3.58 – 31.2 psu), whereas the pore-water pH (range: 6.47- 7.72) was generally lower and less variable than the estuarine water pH (range: 5.78- 8.3), along the estuary. Of the thirty six species (taxa) recorded, the polychaetes Neanthes sp., Onuphis conchylega, Nereididae sp. and the amphipod Corophiidae sp., were numerically dominant. Calcified microcrustaceans (e.g., Cyclopoida sp. and Corophiidae sp.) were abundant at all stations and there was no clear distinction in distribution pattern along the estuarine between calcified and non-calcified groups. Species richness increased seawards, though abundance (density) showed no distinct directional trend. Diversity indices were generally positively correlated (Spearman’s rank correlation) with salinity and pH (p <0.05) and negatively with clay and organic matter, except for evenness values (p >0.05). Three faunistic assemblages were distinguished: (1) nereid-cyclopoid-sabellid, (2) corophiid-capitellid and (3) onuphid- nereid-capitellid. These respectively associated with lower salinity/pH and a muddy bottom, low salinity/pH and a sandy bottom, and high salinity/pH and a sandy bottom. However, CCA suggested that species distribution and community structuring is more strongly influenced by sediment particle characteristics than by the chemical properties of the water (pH and salinity). Conclusions Infaunal estuarine communities, which are typically adapted to survive relatively acidic conditions, may be less exposed, less sensitive, and less vulnerable than epibenthic or pelagic communities to further acidification of above-sediment waters. These data question the extent to which all marine infaunal communities, including oceanic communities, are likely to be affected by future global CO2-driven acidification.
Article
A study was made of physicochemical conditions and benthic macroinvertebrate community structure in a stream receiving domestic and oil refinery effluents. Measures derived from information theory, diversity per individual and redundancy, were found to be more precise measures of stream conditions as reflected by benthic macroinvertebrate populations than traditional methods.