ArticlePDF Available

A new representative of the "orthopteroid" family Cnemidolestidae from the lower Permian of Germany

Authors:
  • General Direction for Cultural Heritage of Rhineland-Palatinate - State Archaeology

Abstract and Figures

Palatinarkema prokopi gen. et sp. nov., the third German representative of the late Carboniferous–early Permian archaeorthopteran clade Cnemidolestidae is described and figured. It is compared to the other known genera. We discuss putative aspects of the paleoecology of these stick-insect-like “orthopteroids”, based on their body and leg structures, plus the presence of a high disparity of color patterns in their forewings, suggesting an important diversity of biology and habitats for these insects. Their elongate bodies and legs show some similarities with the extant but distantly related stick insects. Cnemidolestids possibly expressed cryptic behaviours among the vegetation, using disruptive colors but also ovale eye-like spots, as in the extant insects.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Acta Palaeontol. Pol. 66 (X): xxx–xxx, 2021 https://doi.org/10.4202/app.00879.2021
A new representative of the “orthopteroid” family
Cnemidolestidae from the lower Permian of Germany
ANDRE NEL and MARKUS J. POSCHMANN
Nel, A. and Poschmann, M.J. 2021. A new representative of the “orthopteroid” family Cnemidolestidae from the lower
Permian of Germany. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 66 (X): xxx–xxx.
Palatinarkema prokopi gen. et sp. nov., the third German representative of the late Carboniferous–early Permian ar-
chaeorthopteran clade Cnemidolestidae is described and figured. It is compared to the other known genera. We discuss
putative aspects of the paleoecology of these stick-insect-like “orthopteroids”, based on their body and leg structures,
plus the presence of a high disparity of color patterns in their forewings, suggesting an important diversity of biology
and habitats for these insects. Their elongate bodies and legs show some similarities with the extant but distantly related
stick insects. Cnemidolestids possibly expressed cryptic behaviours among the vegetation, using disruptive colors but
also ovale eye-like spots, as in the extant insects.
Key words: Insecta, Polyneoptera, Archaeorthoptera, cryptic behavior, insect predation, Palaeozoic, Germany.
André Nel [anel@mnhn.fr, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4241-7651], Institut de Systématique, Evolution, Biodiversité
(ISYEB), Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, CNRS, Sorbonne Université, EPHE, Université des Antilles, CP 50, 57
rue Cuvier, 75005 Paris, France.
Markus J. Poschmann [markus.poschmann@gdke.rlp.de, https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9710-1673], Generaldirektion
Kulturelles Erbe RLP, Direktion Landesarchäologie/Erdgeschichte, Niederberger Höhe 1, D-56077 Koblenz, Germany.
Received 11 February 2021, accepted 12 April 2021, available online 8 September 2021.
Copyright © 2021 A. Nel and M.J. Poschmann. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (for details please see http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unre-
stricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Introduction
The superorder Archaeorthoptera is one of the major poly-
neopteran insect groups with remarkable morphological
and species diversity in ecosystems recorded since the late
Carboniferous. Among their most “basal” subclades, the or-
der Cnemidolestodea Handlirsch, 1937, even in the restricted
sense of Béthoux (2005), is one of the most diverse with
22 genera in the family Cnemidolestidae Handlirsch, 1906,
from the upper Carboniferous and lower Permian of Europe,
North America, Brazil, China, and possibly Madagascar
(Aristov 2014; Gu et al. 2014). The clade Cnemidolestidae is
supported by strong synapomorphies in their forewing ve-
nation, but it also shows an important diversity of venation
and coloration patterns.
Here we describe one further new genus and species from
the early Permian. It is the third representative of this family
from Germany (Dvořák et al. 2021) and the first record from
the Carboniferous–Permian of the Saar-Nahe Basin.
Institutional abbreviations.—PE, Naturhistorisches Museum
Mainz/Landessammlung für Naturkunde Rhein land-Pfalz,
Ger many.
Other abbreviations.—C, costa; CuA, cubitus anterior;
CuP, cubitus posterior; CuPa, most anterior branch of CuP;
CuPb, posterior branch of CuP; MA, median vein anterior;
MP, median vein posterior; ma-mp, specialized crossvein
between MA and MP+CuA+CuPa; R, radius; RA/P, radius
anterior/posterior; ScP, subcostal posterior.
Nomenclatural acts.—This published work and the nomen-
clatural acts it contains, have been registered in urn:lsid:
zoobank.org:pub:96EB973D-87B2-4086-A26F-C35E93
FD12B0
Material and methods
The fossil was observed using a Leica MZ 7.5 stereomicro-
scope both dry and immersed in isopropanol. Photographs
were taken with specimen immersed in isopropanol using a
Canon EOS 600D SLR camera equipped with a Canon EFS
60 mm macro lens. Original photographs were processed us-
ing the image-editing software Adobe Photoshop. Drawings
were made from enlarged photographs using Inkscape. The
wing venation nomenclature generally follows Kukalová-
Peck (1991) and Béthoux and Nel (2002).
2 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 66 (X), 2021
Systematic palaeontology
Superorder Archaeorthoptera Béthoux and Nel, 2002
Order Cnemidolestodea Handlirsch, 1937
Family Cnemidolestidae Handlirsch, 1906
Genus Palatinarkema nov.
ZooBank LSID: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:66B028D6-D771-47A1-95
DC-873DDDBDD7E3
Etymology: From Latin palatium, origin of Palatinate, the type region,
and the genus name Narkema.
Type species: Palatinarkema prokopi sp. nov., by monotypy; see below.
Diagnosis.—Forewing characters only. Posterior branch
of MP+CuA+CuPa anteriorly pectinate, with small bifur-
cations on only two branches; stem of anterior branch of
MP+CuA+CuPa very short; veinlet ma-mp very strong
and not aligned with anterior branch of MP+CuA+CuPa;
angle between anterior branch and posterior branch of
MP+CuA+CuPa very acute; no well-defined vein in area
between MA, MP+CuA+CuPa, ma-mp crossvein present;
branches of anterior branch of MP+CuA+CuPa and of RP
simple.
Palatinarkema prokopi sp. nov.
Fig. 1.
ZooBank LSID: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:D32AD59D-F659-4837-83
C8-0896E4CCFC45
Etymology: Named after our friend Jakub Prokop, specialist in fossil
insects.
Holotype: PE 2020/5004-LS a, b, part and counterpart of a complete
wing with parts of the basal region hidden by remains of an undeter-
mined insect wing and/or a mineral stain.
Type locality: East of the village of Niedermoschel, Saar-Nahe Basin,
Germany.
Type horizon: Niedermoschel black shale, Jeckenbach Subformation,
Meisenheim Formation, Lower Rotliegend, lower Permian (sensu
Schindler 1997), probably Asselian–?Sakmarian (Schneider and Wer-
neburg 2012; Schneider et al. 2020).
Material.—Holotype only.
Diagnosis.—As for the genus; two parallel darkened bands
in distal half of forewing plus some spots in mid part.
Description.—Based on forewing venation: estimated total
wing length about 17.1 mm, maximum width at midwing
4.4 mm; wing membrane probably originally hyaline with
oblique colored bands; concave ScP slightly curved, run-
ning parallel with costal margin, merging with RA at distal
two-thirds of wing; costal and subcostal areas nearly as
broad where preserved; stem of R diverging from M+CuA
near base of wing; division of RA and RP proximal of mid-
wing, 2.3 mm basal to connection of ScP with RA; strongly
convex ScP+RA simple ending on costal margin basal of
wing apex; numerous oblique crossveins present between
RA and costal wing margin; concave RP mostly posteriorly
pectinate ending with six simple branches terminating at the
wing tip; neutral (neither really convex not concave) vein
MA diverging from M+CuA and running parallel to stem of
R/RP; MA deeply forked into two simple branches, anterior
one MA1 shortly connected to RP and posterior one MA2
nearly straight; CuPa not visible at base, hidden by debris;
stem of MP+CuA+CuPa elongate, 1.7 mm long, bifurcating
into two branches, the posterior branch subdivided into four
branches; and an anterior branch with a short stem and bifur-
cating into two elongate branches, defining a long but rather
narrow area between it, MA and crossvein ma-mp, without
well-defined and strong vein inside it; angle between ante-
rior and posterior branches of MP+CuA+CuPa very acute,
ca. 18°; both branches of anterior branch of MP+CuA+CuP
simple; crossvein ma-mp between MA and anterior branch
of MP+CuA+CuPa very strong, apparently convex, and not
aligned with anterior branch of MP+CuA+CuPa; area be-
tween branches of RP, concave CuP basally dividing into
CuPa and CuPb, CuPb running parallel to MP+CuA+CuPa
towards posterior wing margin; anal area incomplete with
partly preserved first and second anal veins running parallel
to CuP and CuPb.
Stratigraphic and geographic range.—Type locality and
horizon only.
Discussion
Palatinarkema gen. nov. can be attributed to the Archae-
orthoptera as it shares the main diagnostic character of this
superorder, namely the basal fusion of CuA with M and sub-
sequent connection with the anterior branch of CuP as CuPa
(Béthoux and Nel 2002). Furthermore, it displays characters
typical of the order Cnemidolestodea (sensu Béthoux 2005),
such as ScP merging with RA, CuPa merging with MP+CuA,
MP+CuA+CuPa emitting an anterior branch weakly conver-
gent to MA, with a specialized crossvein ma-mp between it
and MA, thus defining a large median area between it and
MA (Béthoux 2005; Gu et al. 2014: figs. 1, 2). The archae-
orthopteran family Tococladidae and “lobeattids” show some
similarities in the forewing venation with Palatinarkema gen.
nov. in the subcostal, radial and cubital veins, with a funda-
mental difference concerning the vein MP separated from
CuA+CuP, resulting in the absence of a median area in the
former (Béthoux et al. 2003, 2012; Chen et al. 2020).
Aristov (2014), using a different diagnosis and wing vena-
tion nomenclature for the Cnemidolestodea, proposed a key
to families. On the basis of the character “MP weak, ending
on CuA or MA, or absent”, Palatinarkema gen. nov. falls
in the family Cnemidolestidae sensu Aristov 2014, which
includes also families Ischnoneuridae Handlirsch, 1906,
Aetophlebidae Handlirsch, 1906, Narkemidae Handlirsch,
1911, and Narkeminidae Pinto and Ornellas, 1991). Indeed,
in Palatinarkema gen. nov., MP is clearly basally fused to
CuA. Béthoux (2005) and Gu et al. (2014: fig. 2 A1, C1)
supposed that the vein MP can be reduced to a weak veinlet
between MA and CuA+CuP.
NEL AND POSCHMANN—NEW PERMIAN INSECT FROM GERMANY 3
The family Cnemidolestidae comprises the following
genera (Aristov 2014; Gu et al. 2014; Dvořák et al. 2021):
Aeto phlebia Scudder, 1885; Amphiboliacridites Lan giaux
and Parriat, 1974; Anarkemina A r i stov, 2014; Argen tino-
nar ke mina Martins-Neto, Gallego, and Brauck mann, 2007;
Bouleites Lameere, 1917; Carbonokata Aristov, 2013; Cne-
mi dolestes Handlirsch, 1906; Evenkiophlebia Ari stov,
2013; Irajanar kemina Martins-Neto, Gallego, and Brauck-
mann, 2007; Ischnoneura Brongniart, 1893; Long zhua Gu,
Béthoux, and Ren, 2011; Narkema Handlirsch, 1911; Nar-
ke mina Martynov, 1930; Narkeminopsis Whalley, 1979;
Nar ke minuta Aristov, 2013; Narkemulla Arist ov, 2013;
Para nar kemina Pinto and Ornellas, 1980; Piesbergopterum
Dvořák, Pecharová, Leipner, Nel, and Prokop, 2021; Proto-
Fig. 1. Forewing of the cnemidolestid archaeorthopteran Palatinarkema prokopi gen. et sp. nov. (holotype, PE 2020/5004-LS) from Niedermoschel,
Saar-Nahe Basin, Germany; Niedermoschel black shale, Lower Rotliegend, lower Permian. Photographs: part (A1), counterpart (A2), interpretive drawing
(A3); small lines along wing represent the limits of the different fields. Abbreviations: CuA, cubitus anterior; CuPa, most anterior branch of cubitus pos-
terior; CuPb, posterior branch of cubitus posterior; MA, median vein anterior; MP, median vein posterior; ma-mp, specialized crossvein between MA and
MP+CuA+CuPa; R, radius; RA/P, radius anterior/posterior; ScP, subcostal posterior. Scale bars 5 mm.
4 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 66 (X), 2021
diam phipnoa Brongniart, 1885; Tshunoptera Aristov, 2013;
Velizphlebia Martins-Neto, Gallego, and Brauck mann,
2007; and Xixia Gu, Béthoux, and Ren, 2014.
Palatinarkema gen. nov. shares with Narkema and Long-
zhua a narrow area between MA and MP+CuA+CuPa,
but differs from it in the quite longer anterior branch of
MP+CuA+CuPa with a simple anterior subdivision, and a
pectinate (with only a branch having a short fork) posterior
branch of MP+CuA+CuPa (Béthoux 2005: fig. 3; Gu et
al. 2011). Xixia has also a narrow area between MA and
MP+CuA+CuPa but the crossvein ma-mp is weaker than
in Palatinarkema gen. nov. and has a posterior branch of
MP+Cu A+CuPa simple or with two branches (Gu et al. 2014).
Ischnoneura, Cnemidolestes, Aetophlebia, Carbonokata,
and Anarkemina differ from Palatinarkema gen. nov. in
the crossvein ma-mp aligned with the anterior branch of
MP+CuA+CuPa and the presence of a well-defined sig-
moidal vein in the area between MA and MP+CuA+CuPa
(Béthoux and Nel 2005: figs. 18, 19; Aristov 2013: fig. 1g;
2014; Gu et al. 2014). Narkemulla has also a well-defined
Fig. 2. Habitus of the cnemidolestid archaeorthopteran Protodiamphipnoa gaudryi (Brongniart, 1885) (MNHN.F.R51393) from Commentry, France;
Gzhelian, Carboniferous. Photographs: part (A1) and counterpart (A2). Scale bars 10 mm.
NEL AND POSCHMANN—NEW PERMIAN INSECT FROM GERMANY 5
sigmoidal vein in the area between MA and MP+CuA+CuPa
(holotype specimen PIN 3115/119), but PIN 5384/16 has a
very different area between MA and MP+CuA+CuPa from
that of the holotype of this genus, much narrower and with-
out any vein (Aristov 2013: fig. 1c–e).
Argentinonarkemina, Protodiamphipnoa, Bouleites, and
Irajanarkemina share with Palatinarkema gen. nov. a nar-
row area between MA and MP+CuA+CuPa, but this area
is also very long compared to its width and with a very
short crossvein ma-mp and a very long anterior branch of
MP+CuA+CuPa (Béthoux and Nel 2005; Martins-Neto et al.
2007: figs. 2, 7). Paranarkemina differs from Pala tinarkema
gen. nov. in the absence of the crossvein ma-mp (Martins-
Neto et al. 2007: fig. 6). Narkeminuta has also a very weak
crossvein ma-mp (Aristov 2013: fig. 1i).
Palatinarkema gen. nov. differs from Narkemina, Pies-
bergopterum, Amphiboliacridites, Evenkiophlebia, Tshu no-
ptera, and Veliz p hleb i a in the clearly narrower area between
MA and MP+CuA+CuPa, the more acute angle between
the anterior and the posterior branches of MP+CuA+CuPa,
and the specialized crossvein ma-mp not aligned with the
anterior branch of MP+CuA+CuPa (Martynov 1930: fig. 6;
Langiaux and Parriat 1974; Martins-Neto et al. 2007: figs.
3–5; Aristov 2012, 2013: fig. 1a, f, h; Dvořák et al. 2021).
Their patterns of coloration are also different.
Narkeminopsis has a narrow area between MA and
MP+CuA+CuPa and a pectinate posterior branch of MP+
CuA+CuPa, but a more open angle than Palatinarkema gen.
nov., and a longer stem of anterior branch of MP+CuA+CuPa
(Béthoux and Nel 2005: fig. 20; Aristov 2013: fig. 1b). The
second species Narkeminopsis inversa Aristov, 2013, differs
from the type species Narkeminopsis eddi Whalley, 1979,
and Palatinarkema prokopi gen. et sp. nov. in the presence
of several branches of MP+CuA+CuPa and RP with forks.
Conclusions
The present discovery of Palatinarkema prokopi gen. et
sp. nov. increases our knowledge on the diversity of the
Cnemidolestidae. Unfortunately, the body structures of
the Cnemidolestidae remain poorly known, thus few mor-
pho-functional inferences can be drawn from their bi-
ology, and potentially shed light on the causes for their
extinction. Some late Carboniferous representatives (e.g.,
Protodiamphipnoa tertrini Brongniart, 1893, Cnemidolestes
woodwardi [Brongniart, 1893]) have elongate bodies and
very strong and long legs (but apparently not jumping hind
legs), somewhat reminiscent of those of some extant stick
insects (e.g., Eurycantha calcarata Lucas, 1869; Béthoux
and Nel 2005; Béthoux 2005), possibly suggesting similar
cryptic behavior among leaves and plants. The shape of their
hind wings remains poorly know, especially the relative size
of their anal fan (see Aristov 2012: figs. 2, 3). Thus we can-
not accurately establish their flight ability, but their massive
bodies and large legs suggest a rather poor flight ability. The
hypothesis of a cryptic lifestyle could be supported by the
spectacular diversity of color patterns of their forewings.
These are hyaline in some cases (in Narkemina kata A ristov,
2013), while some have a series of more or less parallel
bands of colors (in Narkeminopsis eddi or Cnemidolestes
woodwardi). Others have a large ovale eye-like spot situated
in the middle of the wing, as in Protodiamphipnoa gaudryi
(Brongniart, 1885) (Fig. 2), or a series of numerous spots
distributed in the distal part of the wing (Piesbergopterum
punctatum Dvořák, Pecharová, Leipner, Nel, and Prokop,
2021), or even a pattern of dark patches distributed over
the entire forewing as in Xixia huban Gu, Béthoux, and
Ren, 2014 (Béthoux and Nel 2005; Aristov 2013; Gu et al.
2014; Dvořák et al. 2021). Palatinarkema gen. nov. has a
pattern of colored parallel bands, probably with a disrup-
tive function during flight or at rest, which has been ob-
served rather frequently among Palaeozoic insects, e.g. also
in Palaeodictyoptera (Jarzembowski 2005; Li et al. 2013).
Stevens et al. (2006) noticed that this strategy is efficient
for insects to escape flying predators such as birds. Large
ovale eye-like spots are clearly less frequent during the
same period, but become more common during the Jurassic
and Cretaceous with the kalligrammatid lacewings, and
later with the Lepidoptera Saturniidae and Nymphalidae
Satyrinae. The eyespots can have multiple functions, such
as intimidation of a predator, deflection of the attack to a
non-vital zone of the body, and in sexual selection (Stevens
2005, Collins 2013; Crees et al. 2021). It is nearly impos-
sible to determine the exact function of the eyespots of
Protodiamphipnoa gaudryi, but their large size and con-
centric ellips of different colors would suggest a function of
intimidation as in some Recent Lepidoptera (Blest 1957), or
sexual selection. In the case of Piesbergopterum punctatum,
the small spots could have had a function of deflection of
attacks as they are small and mainly distributed in the non-
vital distal part of the forewing. In conclusion, such a dis-
parity in the wing patterns strongly suggests an outstanding
diversity with regards to the biology of the Cnemidolestidae.
The “giant” griffenflies (Odonatoptera Meganeuridae)
were the major flyi ng predators dur ing the late Carboni ferous
and until the middle Permian (Nel et al. 2018), before the
emergence of gliding or flying vertebrates. However, they
were probably not able to capture insects hidden among
the vegetation. The development of various strategies of
cryptic behavior among the late Carboniferous and early
Permian Cnemidolestidae suggests that the predation pres-
sure of the small terrestrial vertebrates greatly increased
at that time. The balance between the costs/benefit was
favorable for the development of cryptic coloration in some
of their potential prey.
Acknowledgements
MJP thanks Olivier Béthoux (Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle,
Paris, France) for offering generous help with software. We also thank
Andrew Ross (Museum of Scotland, Edinburgh, UK) and an anonymous
referee for their very useful remarks on the first version of the paper.
6 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 66 (X), 2021
References
Aristov, D.S. 2012. Members of genus Narkemina Martynov (Insecta; Eoblat-
tida: Cnemidolestidae) from the Carboniferous of Siberia [in Russian].
In: A.Û. Rozanov, A.V. Lopatin, and P.Û. Parhaev (eds.), Sovremennaâ
paleontologiâ: klassičeskie i novejšie metody, 37–48. Paleontologičeskij
Institut im. A.A.Borisâka Rossijskoj Akademii Nauk, Moskva.
Aristov, D.S. 2013. New and little-known Eoblattida (Insecta) from the
Paleozoic of Russia. Paleontological Journal 47: 272–282.
Aristov, DS. 2014. Classification of the order Cnemidolestida (Insecta: perli-
dea) with descriptions of new taxa. Far Eastern Entomologist 277: 1–46.
Béthoux, O. 2005. Cnemidolestodea (Insecta): an ancient order reinstated.
Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 3: 403–408.
Béthoux, O. and Nel, A. 2002. Venation pattern and revision of Orthoptera
sensu nov. and sister groups. Phylogeny of Palaeozoic and Mesozoic
Orthoptera sensu nov. Zootaxa 96: 1–88.
Béthoux, O. and Nel, A. 2005. Some Palaeozoic “Protorthoptera” are “ance-
stral” orthopteroids: major wing braces as clues to a new split among
the “Protorthoptera”. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 2: 285–309.
Béthoux, O., Gu, J.-J., Yue, Y.-L., and Ren, D. 2012. Miamia maimai n. sp.,
a new Pennsylvanian stem-orthopteran insect, and a case study on the
application of cladotypic nomenclature. Fossil Record 15: 103–113.
Béthoux, O., Nel, A., Galtier, J., Lapeyrie, J., and Gand, G. 2003. A new
species of Tococladidae Carpenter, 1966 from the Permian of France
(Insecta: Archaeorthoptera). Geobios 36: 275–283.
Blest, A.D. 1957. The function of eyespot patterns in the Lepidoptera. Be-
haviour 11: 209–258.
Brongniart, C. 1885. Les insectes fossiles des terrains primaires. Coup
d’oeil rapide sur la faune entomologique des terrains paléozoïques.
Bulletin de la Société des Amis des Sciences naturelles de Rouen 1885:
50–68.
Brongniart, C. 1893. Recherches pour servir à l’histoire des insectes
fossiles des temps primaires précédées d’une étude sur la nervation
des ailes des insectes. Bulletin de la Société d’Industrie Minérale de
Saint-Etienne (3) 7: 1–491.
Chen, L., Ren, D., and Béthoux, O. 2020. A new, rare and small “lobeattid”
species (Insecta: Archaeorthoptera) found at Xiaheyan (Pennsylva-
nian; Ningxia, China). Fossil Record 23: 71–74.
Collins, M.M. 2013. Interpretation of wing pattern elements in relation to
bird predation on adult Hyalophora (Saturniidae). Journal of the Lepido-
pterists’ Society 67: 49–55.
Crees, L.D., DeVries, P., and Penz, C.M. 2021. Do hind wing eyespots
of Caligo butterflies function in both mating behavior and antipreda-
tor defense? (Lepidoptera, Nymphalidae). Annals of the Entomolog-
ical Society of America [published online, https://doi-org.eres.qnl.
qa/10.1093/aesa/saaa050]
Dvořák, T., Pecharová, M., Leipner, A., Nel, A., and Prokop, J. 2021. New
archaeorthopteran insects from the Pennsylvanian of Piesberg reveal
unexpected mosaic of morphological traits and colouration pattern of
the tegmina. Historical Biology [published online, https://doi.org/10.1
080/08912963.2020.1867127]
Gu, J.-J., Béthoux, O., and Ren, D. 2011. Longzhua loculata n. gen. n. sp.,
one of the most completely documented Pennsylvanian Archaeorthop-
tera (Insecta; Ningxia, China). Journal of Paleontology 85: 303–314.
Gu, J.-J., Béthoux, O., and Ren, D. 2014. A new cnemidolestodean stem-
orthopteran insect from the late Carboniferous of China. Acta Palae-
ontologica Polonica 59: 689–696.
Handlirsch, A. 1906. Die fossilen Insekten und die Phylogenie der rezen-
ten Formen. Ein Handbuch für Paläontologen und Zoologen. i–vi +
1–640 pp. Engelman, V.W., Leipzig.
Handlirsch, A. 1911. New Paleozoic insects from the vicinity of Mazon
Creek, Illinois. American Journal of Science 31: 297–326, 353–377.
Handlirsch, A. 1937. Neue Untersuchungen über die fossilen Insekten mit
Ergänzungen und Nachträgen sowie Ausblicken auf phylogenetische,
palaeogeographische und allgemein biologische Probleme. Teil 1.
Anna len des Naturhistorischen Museums in Wien 48: 1–140.
Jarzembowski, E.A. 2005. Colour and behaviour in late Carboniferous ter-
restrial arthropods. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Geowis-
senschaften 156: 381–386.
Kukalová-Peck, J. 1991. Fossil history and the evolution of hexapod struc-
tures. In: CSIRO (eds.). The Insects of Australia. A Textbook for Stu-
dents and Research Workers, 141–179. Melbourne University Press,
Melbourne.
Langiaux, J. and Parriat, H. 1974. Faune entomologique du bassin de Blanzy-
Montceau. La Physiophile 81: 62–74.
Lameere, A. 1917. Révision sommaire des insectes fossiles du Stéphanien
de Commentry. Bulletin du Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle de
Paris 23: 141–200.
Li, Y., Ren D., Pecharová, M., and Prokop, J. 2013. A new palaeodictyopter-
id (Insecta: Palaeodictyoptera: Spilapteridae) from the upper Carboni-
ferous of China supports a close relationship between insect faunas of
Quilianshian (northern China) and Laurussia. Alcheringa 37: 487–495.
Lucas, H. 1869. Orthoptères de l’ile San-Georges, Archipel Salomon. Bul-
letin de la Société Entomologique de France 9: 25–26.
Martins-Neto, R.G., Gallego, O.F., Brauckmann, C., and Cruz, J.L. 2007.
A review of the South American Palaeozoic entomofauna. Part I: the
Ischnoneuroidea and Cacurgoidea, with description of new taxa. Afri-
can Invertebrates 48: 87–101.
Martynov, A.V. 1930. On the Paleozoic insects of the Kuznetsk Basin [in
Rus sian]. Izvetiâ Glavnogo Geologorazvedočnogo Upravleniâ 49: 73–
100.
Nel, A., Prokop, J., Pecharová, M., Engel, M.S., and Garrouste, R. 2018.
Palaeozoic giant dragonflies were hawker predators. Scientific Reports
8: 12141.
Pinto, I.D. and Ornellas, L. 1980. Upper Carboniferous insects from Ar-
gentina. 2. Familia Narkemocacurgidae (Parapleocoptera). Boletin de
la Academia Nacional de Ciencias de Cordoba Argentina 53: 287–291.
Pinto, I.D. and Ornellas, L. 1991. Substitute names for the extinct insecta
families Narkemocacurgidae Pinto et Ornellas, 1978 and Cacurgo-
narkemidae Pinto, 1990. Pesquisas, (Zoologia) 18: 93.
Schindler, T. 1997. Neue lithostratigraphische Leithorizonte im unteren
Rot liegend des Saar-Nahe-Beckens (U. Perm, SW Deutschland).
1. Leit hori zonte der lithostratigraphischen Einheit Lauterecken-bis
Odern heim- Schichten L-O 5 (Boy & Fichter). Mainzer geowissen-
schaftliche Mitteilungen 26: 37–44.
Schneider, J.W. and Werneburg, R. 2012. Biostratigraphie des Rotliegend
mit Insekten und Amphibien. In: Deutsche Stratigraphische Kommis-
sion (eds.), Stratigraphie von Deutschland X. Rotliegend. Teil I: Inner-
variscische Becken. Schriftenreihe der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Geo-
wissenschaften 61: 110–142.
Schneider, J.W., Lucas, S.G., Scholze, F., Voigt, S., Marchetti, L., Klein,
H., Opluštil, S., Werneburg, R., Golubev, V.K., Barrick, J.E., Nemyrov-
ska, T., Ronchi, A., Day, M.O., Silantiev, V.V., Rößler, R., Saber, H.,
Linnemann, U., Zharinova, V., and Shen, S.-Z. 2020. Late Paleozoic–
early Mesozoic continental biostratigraphy—links to the Standard Glob-
al Chronostratigraphic Scale. Palaeoworld 29: 186–238.
Scudder, S.H. 1885. Palaeodictyoptera: or the affinities and classification
of Paleozoic Hexapoda. Memoirs of the Boston Society of Natural His-
tory 3: 319–351.
Stevens, M. 2005. The role of eyespots as anti-predator mechanisms, princi-
pally demonstrated in the Lepidoptera. Biological Review 80: 573–588.
Stevens, M., Cuthill, I.C., Parraga, C.A., and Troscianko, T. 2006. The
effectiveness of disruptive coloration as a concealment strategy. In:
J.-M. Alonso, S. Macknik, L. Martinez, P. Tse, and S. Martinez-Conde
(eds.), Progress in Brain Research, 49–64. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Whalley, P.E.S. 1979. New species of Protorthoptera and Protodonata (In-
secta) from the upper Carboniferous of Britain, with a comment on the
origin of wings. Bulletin of the British Museum of Natural History,
Geology 32: 85–90.
... has some characters very similar to those of the order Cnemidolestodea (sensu Béthoux 2005, to include the Cnemidolestidae only), such as a specialised elongate triangular area between RP/MA and a long vein emerging from M + CuA, distally closed by the fusion of these veins; plus the vein MP emitting several parallel posterior branches. Notice that Aristov (2014) proposed a different definition of the Cnemidolestodea to include much more families in this order, but there is no clear synapomorphy supporting this order sensu Aristov (see Dvořák et al. 2021;Nel and Poschmann 2021). ...
... nov., there is a very strong oblique vein emerging from RP and ending into MP, which can only correspond to MA basally fused with R and re-emerging distally from RP, a character also present in few other Archaeorthoptera (e.g., Cacurgidae, see below). In the Cnemidolestidae, the vein MA is basally separating from MP + CuA and closely parallel to R/RP (Langiaux and Parriat 1974;Whalley 1979;Pinto and Pinto de Ornellas 1980;Béthoux 2005;Béthoux and Nel 2005;Martins-Neto et al. 2007;Gu et al. 2011Gu et al. , 2014Aristov 2013Aristov , 2014Dvořák et al. 2021;Nel and Poschmann 2021). The narrow area between MA and R/RP of the Cnemidolestidae is no longer present in Roqueia gen. ...
Article
The new archaeorthopteran family Roqueiidae is defined for the new genus and species Roqueia alpine, described from the Pennsylvanian (Kasimovian) of La Mure region (Isère, Alps, France). This new taxon is characterised by the set of characters: basal fusion of MA with R, its distal re-emergence from RP and ending into vein MP. The Roqueiidae are tentatively assigned to the order Cnemidolestodea together with the family Cnemidolestidae. ARTICLE HISTORY
... Intimidating eyespots on insect wings are nearly as ancient as the winged insects themselves. The oldest record of such anti-predator device is a pair of large transverse oval light rings (with a dark centre) on the dark forewings of a large protorthopteran Protodiamphipnoa gaudryi (Brongniart, 1885) (= P. tertrini Brongniart, 1894) from the latest Carboniferous of France [Nel, Poschmann, 2021]. Large concentric eyespots were widespread and diverse in Mesozoic lacewings of the family Kalligrammatidae (Jurassic-mid-Cretaceous), convergently similar to Cenozoic butterflies [Labandeira et al., 2016]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Large cicadas Papiliontina dracomima gen. et sp.n., P. spectans sp.n. and P. machaon sp.n. are described from the Middle to Late Triassic of Madygen, Kyrgyzstan. These are the oldest finds of the Mesozoic family Palaeontinidae. Two of the three species have a pair of large, concentric eyespots on their forewings, providing the earliest evidence for this anti-predator mechanism in Hemiptera. Fletcheriana magna Riek, 1976 from the Late Triassic of South Africa is singled out into Karoontina gen.n.: Karoontina magna (Riek, 1976), comb.n.
... Also, its CuA+CuPa has only posterior branches, while the new fossil has anterior ones. The archaeorthopteran Protophasma Brongniart, 1879, Anegertus Handlirsch, 1911, Nectoptilus Béthoux, 2005, Eoblatta Handlirsch, 1906, Ctenoptilus Lameere, 1917, Protodiamphi pneura Brongniart, 1885, Ischnoptera Béthoux & Nel, 2005, and more generally all the Cnemidolestidae, have also a pattern of the veins M and CuA+CuP very similar to that of the new fossil with a complex first anterior branch of CuA+CuP parallel to M(A?), but no rudiment of CuPaβ (Béthoux 2003(Béthoux , 2005: figs 5 -6; Béthoux & Nel 2005;Nel & Poschmann 2021a). Lastly, many of these mentioned taxa have their bases of RP close to base of M+CuA, and a stem RP very long and closely parallel to RA, unlike the new fossil. ...
Article
Here we present a state of the art of the Upper Carboniferous insects from the Iberian Peninsula, including new fossils of Panorthoptera (Archaeorthoptera), and of the orders Paoliida, Megasecoptera, and Palaeodictyoptera. These fossils are from Gzhelian deposits of different coalfields in León Province (Castilla y León, NW Spain). Among the insect orders, we have described the archaeorthopteran Hispanopteron romerali gen. et sp. nov., the Paoliida Simplexpaolia prokopi gen. et sp. nov., the megasecopterans Mischoptera bergidensis sp. nov. and Corydaloides leonensis sp. nov., in addition to an unnamed prothoracic winglet of palaeodictyopteran. The taxon Hispanopteron romerali is the sixth archaeorthopteran described or cited from the Iberian Peninsula, and increases the impressive diversity of the superorder. Simplexpaolia prokopi represents a new genus and species of latest Carboniferous Paoliidae and the first representative of this family in Spain. Corydaloides leonensis sp. nov. and Mischoptera bergidensis sp. nov. represent the second and third records of the order Megasecoptera in Spain, respectively, as well as the first specimens of the Corydaloididae and Mischopteridae families in the Iberian Peninsula. The deposition of these insect remains together with different fossils of plants, and the previously published evidence of diverse plant-insect interactions, suggest that the Gzhelian entomofauna found in the vegetation of these Carboniferous forests had already occupied numerous ecological niches under a tropical climate. In addition, we have carried out the review of all insect remains, and evidence of plant-insect interactions found so far from the Carboniferous of the Iberian Peninsula, observing a higher diversity than expected. © 2022 E. Schweizerbart’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Stuttgart, Germany.
... Disruptive color or eyespot patterns may have provided an evolutionary advantage to prey, allowing them to scare their predator and/or win time to flee or hide from them and thus are selected in some clades (Crees et al., 2021). Interestingly, evidence of such adaptations is well documented in the Palaeozoic archaeorthopteran order Cnemidolestodea, showing a spectacular diversity of patterns of coloration on wings, including oval eye-like spots very similar to those of the extant Lepidoptera Saturniidae (Jarzembowski, 2005;Nel & Poschmann, 2021). Nevertheless, during Carboniferous and Triassic, color patterns are recorded in lineages thought to be the prey of larger arthropods or of vertebrates (e.g., Dictyoptera, Archaeorthoptera, Palaeodictyopterida) and absent in insect predator lineages. ...
Article
Full-text available
Wing coloration is a very ancient feature among insects. Even the wings of the oldest known Pterygota showed transverse colored bands involved in a putative disruptive function. However, no evidence of wing coloration in the representatives of the superorder Odonatoptera is recorded before the latest Triassic. These were the only insect flying- predators until the pterosaurs began their diversification. Here we argue that the situation dramatically changed in the Early Jurassic, with the simultaneous appearance of Odonata with patterns of coloration in phylogenetically distant clades. It is especially the case in the Heterophlebiidae, a small family closely related to the Anisoptera, in which we could record no less than five different patterns of coloration in the same rather small area of North-Western Europe. At the same time and in the same area, small potentially insectivorous pterosaurs greatly diversified. The increase of the predation pressure on the Odonata is the most probable cause of the appearance of patterns of colored spots and bands on the dragonfly wings at that time. In the period between the Middle Jurassic to Early Cretaceous, the number of Odonata with spots and bands of color on wings dramatically increased, we assume in relation to the predation pressure due to an increasing diversification of insectivorous pterosaurs, but also small feathered dinosaurs and birds.
... Despite the inherent patchiness and deficiency of fossils, they are indispensable historical portholes revealing origins, diversification, and evolution of mimicry. Dating mimicry back to the Paleozoic encounters disputation [81][82][83], but such behavior must have originated before the Mesozoic, based on fossils depicting complicated mimesis and camouflage behavior. In the Jurassic Daohugou Lagerstätte (Inner Mongolia, China), a diverse insect assemblage of plant mimicry has been described [84][85][86][87]. ...
Article
The Mesozoic is a key era for the rise of the modern insect fauna. Among the most important evolutionary events in Mesozoic insects are the radiation of holometabolous insects, the origin of eusocial and parasitoid insects, diversification of pollinating insects, and development of advanced mimicry and camouflage. These events are closely associated with the diversification of insect ecological behaviors and colonization of new ecospaces. At the same time, insects had evolved more complex and closer ecological associations with various plants and animals. Mesozoic insects played a key and underappreciated ecological role in reconstructing and maintaining terrestrial ecosystems. A greater understanding of the history of insects may help to mitigate future changes in insect diversity and abundance.
Article
New grylloblattidan insect specimens from the early Permian (Asselian to early Sakmarian) Meisenheim Formation of the Saar-Nahe Basin in southwest Germany are described. The most abundant specimens are assigned to Pictoborella germanica (Prokop et al. in Geodiversitas 34: 271–281, 2012) and to Oborella brauckmanni Prokop et al., 2012. Morphological variation in these taxa is documented and discussed. Two new species, Oborella moschelensis sp. nov., and Artinska glanensis sp. nov., represented by one and three specimens, respectively, are proposed. A possible forewing of undetermined Liomopteridae is also recorded. With respect to grylloblattidans, the insects of the Meisenheim Formation reveal a decidedly Permian character.
Article
We describe an archaeorthopteran forewing from the Early Permian (Asselian or early Sakmarian) Humberg lake system (uppermost Meisenheim Formation) of Grügelborn/Saarland. It is attributed to a new genus and species, Saarelcana stapsi gen. et sp. nov., and it represents the oldest record of the Elcanoidea (= ‘Permelcanidae’ + Elcanidae). This is the seventh taxon of Archaeorthoptera from the Meisenheim Formation and underpins the extraordinarily high diversity of the group in the Pennsylvanian and Permian.
Article
Full-text available
Full body impressions and resting traces of Hexapoda can be of extreme importance because they bring crucial information on behavior and locomotion of the trace makers, and help to better define trophic relationships with other organisms (predators or preys). However, these ichnofossils are much rarer than trackways, especially for winged insects. Here we describe a new full-body impression of a winged insect from the Middle Permian of Gonfaron (Var, France) whose preservation is exceptional. The elongate body with short prothorax and legs and long wings overlapping the body might suggests a plant mimicry as for some extant stick insects. These innovations are probably in relation with an increasing predation pressure by terrestrial vertebrates, whose trackways are abundant in the same layers. This discovery would possibly support the recent age estimates for the appearance of phasmatodean-like stick insects, nearly 30 million years older than the previous putative records. The new exquisite specimen is fossilized on a slab with weak ripple-marks, suggesting the action of microbial mats favoring the preservation of its delicate structures. Further prospections in sites with this type of preservation could enrich our understanding of early evolutionary history of insects.
Article
Full-text available
New archaeorthopterans Contracladus impar gen. nov. et sp. nov. (uncertain assignement), Paraspiculum brauckmannii gen. nov. et sp. nov. (Caloneurodea) and Piesbergopterum punctatum gen. nov. et sp. nov. (Cnemidolestodea) are described from the Moscovian of Piesberg quarry near Osnabrück (Lower Saxony, Germany). All new taxa display unique patterns of their forewing venations. The mosaic of characters found in C. impar with a particular lack of a free vein CuA demonstrates the limits of the current systematics for Archaeorthoptera. The evidence for a supposedly disruptive pattern of colouration is demonstrated on the forewing membrane of P. punctatum, which shows numerous spots in the distal part of the wing. Those are inside the cells delimited by the crossveins. The exceptionally preserved fossils found in Piesberg document fine structural details and complete our knowledge on the early history of this diverse group of polyneopteran insects.
Article
Full-text available
In general, butterfly ventral hind wing eyespots are considered to play a role in predator–prey interactions. These eyespots are prominent wing pattern elements in Brassolini butterflies, and they vary in size, position, and number across taxa. Female Caligo Hübner, 1819 (Lepidoptera, Nymphalidae) appear to use the large eyespots of lekking males as a mate-locating cue, but female Opsiphanes Doubleday, 1849 (Lepidoptera, Nymphalidae) do not because males patrol to find mates. These behaviors led us to predict that male Caligo should have larger eyespots than females, but eyespot size would not differ between sexes in Opsiphanes. Our analyses supported these predictions. As displacement of the eyespots to the center of the wing might make them more conspicuous, we asked if eyespot position and size covaried across the Brassolini phylogeny. While we found a positive association between position and size, the relationship of these two variables contained significant phylogenetic signal. Two Brassolini species show strong sexual dimorphism where females converge on the color pattern of sympatric species of Caligo. Their ventral hind wing eyespots are much larger than those of close relatives, approximating those of Caligo, and further reinforcing the importance of ventral hind wing eyespots as a visual signal in this group of butterflies. Importantly, our results suggest that, in addition to antipredation defense, ventral hind wing eyespots can function in mating activities, and consequently they might be evolving under both natural and sexual selection in Caligo butterflies.
Article
Full-text available
A new species of stem Orthoptera, namely Phtanomiamia gui gen. et sp. nov., is described from the Pennsylvanian Xiaheyan locality in China. Despite the intensive collecting efforts undertaken at this locality, a single forewing was recovered. It shares with the “lobeattid” Miamia spp. two peculiar traits, namely a broad ScP–R/RA area and a very early branching of CuA + CuPa. On the other hand, it displays a free portion of CuA (between its divergence from M + CuA and its fusion with CuPa), a trait allowing exclusion of the new species from Miamia, to which it is most likely very closely related.
Article
Full-text available
The largest insects to have ever lived were the giant meganeurids of the Late Palaeozoic, ancient stem relatives of our modern dragonflies. With wingspans up to 71 cm, these iconic insects have been the subject of varied documentaries on Palaeozoic life, depicting them as patrolling for prey through coal swamp forests amid giant lycopsids, and cordaites. Such reconstructions are speculative as few definitive details of giant dragonfly biology are known. Most specimens of giant dragonflies are known from wings or isolated elements, but Meganeurites gracilipes preserves critical body structures, most notably those of the head. Here we show that it is unlikely it thrived in densely forested environments where its elongate wings would have become easily damaged. Instead, the species lived in more open habitats and possessed greatly enlarged compound eyes. These were dorsally hypertrophied, a specialization for long-distance vision above the animal in flight, a trait convergent with modern hawker dragonflies. Sturdy mandibles with acute teeth, strong spines on tibiae and tarsi, and a pronounced thoracic skewness are identical to those specializations used by dragonflies in capturing prey while in flight. The Palaeozoic Odonatoptera thus exhibited considerable morphological specializations associated with behaviours attributable to ‘hawkers’ or ‘perchers’ among extant Odonata
Article
Full-text available
A new stem-orthopteran insect assignable to the – traditional – genus and the – cladotypic-defined – taxon Miamia Dana, 1864 is described based on abundant material collected from the Xiaheyan locality (Ningxia, China; Early Pennsylvanian). Intra-specific wing venation variability in Miamia maimai n. sp. is appreciated based on wing pairs of single individuals, and on a complete series of conditions. Rare variants are reported. Details of head and leg morphology are documented: the new species possesses a five-segmented tarsus provided with paired claws and arolium, and labial palps with at least four segments, probably five. The nomenclatural section is conducted under the cladotypic nomenclatural procedure, but in a way largely consistent with the traditional usage. This experiment demonstrates that a combination composed of a "genus level-taxon" name previously associated with a definition and type material (e.g. Miamia), a specific epithet (e.g. maimai), and authorship information (e.g. Béthoux et al. 2012), with further mention to "Miamia maimai" or "M. maimai", provides a suitable reference to the species under all nomenclatural procedures, including the traditional one. doi:10.1002/mmng.201200008
Article
Full-text available
A new Late Carboniferous cnemidolestodean insect Xixia huban gen. et sp. nov., is described from the Xiaheyan locality (Zhongwei City, Ningxia, China; Tupo Formation). Its combination of character states and observed variants on the wing venations are indicative of homologies shared with more derived members of the order. In particular it is ascertained that MP runs fused with CuA and CuA + CuPa, but is not usually visible as a distinct vein. The new genus exhibits previously unknown coloration pattern composed of dark patches distributed over the whole forewing (as opposed to regular stripes or rows of spots, previously documented in the group). The comparatively abundant sample makes it one of the best documented cnemidolestodeans to date.