Conference PaperPDF Available

A compact branch-line coupler using folded microstrip lines

Authors:

Abstract

This paper presents a compact 3 dB Quadrature branch-line coupler using folded microstrip line geometry. Commercially available IE3D software has been used to design and simulate the structure. The proposed structure is simple and takes lesser optimization time. It has been shown that the structure provides about 43.63% compactness compared to the conventional branch line coupler. The structure, therefore, can be incorporated in the microwave circuit design where medium level compactness and faster design are preferred.
A Compact Branch-Line Coupler using Folded
Microstrip Lines
Ashmi Chakraborty Das
Electronics Engineering
Indian School of Mines
Dhanbad, India
ashmi.chakraborty@gmail.com
Lakhindar Murmu
Electronics Engineering
Indian School of Mines
Dhanbad, India
lakhindar.kgec25@gmail.com
Santanu Dwari
Electronics Engineering
Indian School of Mines
Dhanbad, India
santanu_dwari@rediffmail.com
Abstract—This paper presents a compact 3 dB Quadrature
branch-line coupler using folded microstrip line geometry.
Commercially available IE3D software has been used to design
and simulate the structure. The proposed structure is simple and
takes lesser optimization time. It has been shown that the
structure provides about 43.63% compactness compared to the
conventional branch line coupler. The structure, therefore, can
be incorporated in the microwave circuit design where medium
level compactness and faster design are preferred.
Keywords—branch-line coupler, microstrip bend, scattering
parameters.
I. INTRODUCTION
A branch line coupler is a four port circuit consisting to two
quarter wave lines of characteristic impedance Z0 coupled
together by means of other two quarter wave branch lines of
characteristic impedance Z02 connected at the ends. Such
circuits are widely used in different microwave circuits since
its interception. A brief description and even odd mode
analysis of Quadrature branch line coupler has been given in
[1].
In 2005 Sun, Yen and van der Weide [2] presented a
compact branch-line coupler using discontinuous microstrip
lines. Keshavarz, Dannaeian, Movahhdi, and Hakimi [3]
presented a compact dual-band branch-line coupler based on
the inter-digital transmission line. The design of a compact
broadband branch-line hybrid was presented by Chun and
Hong [4]. In the next year Chun and Hong [5] designed and
tested compact wide-band branch-line hybrids. Later, in the
same year, Chang, Nam and Kim [6] presented the design of
various compact branch-line couplers using artificial
transmission lines. In 2007 Tang, Chen and Wu [7] proposed
ultra compact microstrip coupler using high impedance open
stubs. A new method for designing the microstrip branch line
couplers with predetermined compact size and bandwidth was
proposed by Tang and Chen [8] in the same year.
__________________________________________________
978-1-4799-2174-4/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE
During this year few more works on branch line coupler
was carried out, out of which design of compact high
performance slow-wave microstrip branch-line coupler by
Wang and Wang [9] and design of novel miniaturized fractal-
shaped branch-line couplers using phase-equalising method by
Chen and Wang [10] worth to be mentioned separately.
Tang, Guang and Tsai [11] in 2008 presented
miniaturization of microstrip branch-line coupler with dual
transmission lines. Next year a novel compact branch-line
coupler using non-uniform transmission line was presented by
Hosseini, Hosseini and Yazdini [12]. Two years later, in 2011,
Zou, Wu and Ma [13] presented miniaturized branch-line
coupler with wide upper stop band using novel synthesized
microstrip lines with series LC tanks. Later of this year Yeung
[14] presented a compact dual-band 90o coupler with coupled-
line sections and Tsai, Yang, Chen and Chen [15] presented a
miniaturized 3 db branch-line hybrid coupler with harmonics
suppression. Other works that were done in this year include
design of fractal shaped branch-line couplers by Singhania,
Kumar, Dash and pal [16] and design of compact coupled line
quadrature hybrid coupler with enhanced balance bandwidth by
Velidi, Shankar, Divyabramham and Sanyal [17]. A case study
of slow-wave resonant structures in branch-line coupler
miniaturization was presented by Kurgan, Bekasiewicz and
Kitlinski [18] in 2012. The proposed structure in the above
work provides 88% surface area reduction compared to a
conventional branch line coupler.
In this paper we have presented a compact 3dB Quadrature
branch-line coupler using folded microstrip line geometry and
IE3D electromagnetic simulator software.
II. DESIGN AND RESULT
To design the folded microstrip line branch-line coupler we
have started with a conventional branch-line coupler. The
operating frequency is chosen to be 3 GHz whereas Rogers RT/
Duroid 5880 substrate with dielectric constant 2.2, thickness
0.381mm and loss tangent 0.0009 has been chosen as substrate
material. For these parameters we get strip thickness 1.167mm
and length 18.245mm for the quarter wave 50 ohm
()
Z0
transmission line and strip thickness 1.906mm and length
17.972mm for the quarter wave 35.36 ohm
()
Z02
transmission line. Next we have introduced four right angle
bends in each arm as shown in Fig.1. The inner radius of the
bend has been taken as 0.1mm. Therefore the outer radius of
the bends for 50 ohm and 35.36 ohm line will be 1.267mm and
2.006mm respectively. The mean radius of these two lines will
be 0.634mm and 1mm respectively. Since one right angle bend
is equivalent to a path length of R2π mm where “R” is the
mean radius of the bend and there are four bends in a particular
arm, total R2π mm arm length is covered by the bends. For
50 ohm and 35.36 ohm lines these lengths are 3.984mm and
6.283mm respectively. The remaining arm lengths which are
14.261mm and 11.689 mm are divided in between the bends,
as shown in Fig. 2. The respective parameters of the folded
microstrip line branch-line coupler are tabulated in table 1.
Table 1: Geometrical dimensions of folded microstrip line
branch-line coupler
()
Z0 a1
b
1 c
1
5.1305m
m
1m
m
2m
m
()
Z02 a2
b
2 c
2
2.8445m
m
2m
m
2m
m
The proposed design shows that the structure occupies an
area 2
14.75 mm 14.625 mm 215.72 mm×= . The conventional
branch line coupler, in comparison, occupies an
area 2
20.16 mm 19.14 mm 385.86 mm×= . This is equivalent
to compactness ratio 0.4409 or 44.09% compactness. The
magnitude response of the scattering parameters and the phase
response at the coupled ports are shown in Fig. 3 and Fig. 4
respectively.
Fig. 1. Compression of coupler arm due to bending
Fig 2. Schematic diagram of compact, folded microstrip line branch line
coupler.
Fig. 3. Variation of the magnitude of scattering parameters of the proposed
branch line coupler with frequency.
Fig. 4. Variation of the phase of the coupled ports of the proposed branch line
coupler with frequency.
III. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
Fig. 3 reveals that the structure operates at 3.25 GHz with
about -3.123 dB powers at the coupled ports and -30.76 dB
power at the isolated port. The return loss at the input port is -
29.53 dB. The difference in powers between the coupled ports
is 0.001 dB which is negligible. Fig. 4 reveals that the phase of
S21 and S31 is 0
147.7 and 0
57.02 respectively. Thus the phase
difference between the coupled ports is 0
90.68 . For an ideal
Quadrature branch line coupler the power at the coupled ports
should be – 3 dB and phase difference should be 0
90 . Thus the
amount of error introduced in magnitude is 4.1% and the
amount of error introduced in phase is 0.76%. For most of the
applications this error is tolerable.
Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 further reveals that the operating
frequency has been shifted to 3.25 GHz from the starting
design frequency 3GHz. This shift in frequency is due to the
introduction of the bends in the coupler arms. During the
introduction the bends we assumed that a bend of mean length
R2π provides the same phase shift as that of a transmission
line of path length R2π but this is not true. This change in
phase effectively decreases the total electrical length of the line
and hence the circuit operates at higher frequencies. To operate
at the desired frequency 3GHz optimization will be required.
Since the operating frequency will be shifted at a lower
frequency an increase in coupler line length will be required
which, in turn, will decrease the compactness of the coupler.
For a conventional coupler operating at frequency 3.25 GHz
we get strip thickness 1.167mm and length 16.841 mm for the
quarter wave 50 ohm
()
Z0 transmission line and strip
thickness 1.906mm and length 16.589 mm for the quarter wave
35.36 ohm
()
Z02 transmission line. Therefore the
conventional 3.25 GHz branch-line coupler occupies an area
2
18.75 mm 17.76 mm 333.00 mm×= . Thus the proposed
structure provides compactness ratio 0.3522 or 35.22%
compactness in comparison with a conventional 3.25 GHZ
branch line coupler.
Most of the available compact branch line couplers,
available in the literatures, provide compactness typically in the
range 30% - 80%. However these circuit geometries are very
complicated in nature and hence take a lot of time to design for
any arbitrary frequency of operation. This time requirement
often overrides the cost reduction achieved due to their
compactness (as large computer time and man power is
involved in their design). In that respect the proposed circuit
provides a well balance between the compactness and time
required for designing at an arbitrary frequency. Therefore
such circuits are well applicable when medium level
compactness and faster design are of prime interest.
REFERENCES
[1] D. M. Pozar, Microwave Engineering, 3rd ed, John Wwiley & Sons:
New Delhi, 2008, pp. 333 - 336..
[2] K. Sun, S. Ho, C. Yen and D. Weide, “A Compact Branch-Line
coupler using discontinuous microstrip lines,” IEEE Microwave and
Wireless Components Letters, Vol. 15, No. 8, Pp. 519-520, August
2005.
[3] R. Keshavarz, M. Danaeian, M. Movahhedi, and A. Hakimi, “A
compact dual-band branch-line coupler based on the interdigital
transmission line,” IEEE Microwave and Wireless Compoents
Letters, Vol. 15, Issue 12, pp. 889 – 891 , 2005.
[4] Y. Chun and J. Hong, “Design of a compact broadband branch-line
hybrid,” IEEE MTT – s International Microwave Sysmposium
Digest, pp. 997-1000, 2005.
[5] Y. Chun, and J. Hong, “Compact wide-band branch-line hybrids,”
IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 54,
No. 2, pp. 704-709 February 2006.
[6] K. Chang , K. Nam, and J. Kim, “Design of various compact branch-
line couplers by using artificial transmission lines,” IEEE MTT – s
International Microwave Sysmposium Digest, pp. 1726-1729, June
2006.
[7] C. Tang, M. Chen and J. Wu, “Realization of Ultra-Compact Planar
Microstrip Branch-Line Couplers With High-Impedance Open
Stubs,” IEEE MTT – s International Microwave Sysmposium Digest,
pp. 995-998, 2007.
[8] C. Tang, and M. Chen, “Synthesizing Microstrip Branch-Line
Couplers with predetermined compact size and bandwidth,” IEEE
Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 55, No. 9,
pp. 1926-1934, September 2007.
[9] J. Wang, B. Wang, Y. Guo, “A compact Slow-Wave microstrip
branch-line coupler with high performance,” IEEE Microwave and
Wireless Components Letters, Vol. 17, No. 7, pp. 501-503, July 2007.
[10] W. Chen G. Wang, “Exact design of novel miniaturized fractal-
shaped branch-line couplers using phase-equalising method,” IET
Microwaves, Antennas & Propagation, pp. 773-780,2007.
[11] C.Tang, M. Chen, and C. Tsai, “Miniaturization of microstrip branch-
line coupler with dual transmission lines,” IEEE Microwave and
Wireless Components Letters, Vol. 18, No. 3, pp. 185-187, March
2008.
[12] F. Hosseini, M. Khalaj-Amir hosseini, M.Yazdani, “Novel compact
branch-line coupler using non-uniform transmission line”, Asia
Pacific Microwave Conference, pp. 1577 – 1580, 2009.
[13] J. Zou, C. Wu, and T. Ma, “Miniaturized branch-line coupler with
wide upper stopband using novel synthesized microstrip lines with
series LC tanks,” IEEE International Workshop on Electromagnetics,
Applications and Student Innovation, pp. 71-74, 2011.
[14] L.Yeung, “A compact dual-band 90o coupler with coupled-line
sections,” IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques,
Vol. 59, No. 9, pp. 2227-2232, September 2011.
[15] K.Tsai, H. Yang, J. Chen, and Y. Chen, “A miniaturized 3 dB
branch-line hybrid coupler with harmonics suppression,” IEEE
Microwave and Wireless Components Letters, vol. 21, No. 10, pp.
597-539, October 2011.
[16] A. singhania, R. kumar, A. Raut, S.K.Dash, S. Pal, “Design of fractal
shaped branch-line couplers,” Asia Pacific Microwave Conference,
pp. 1 – 3, 2011.
[17] V. Velidi, G. Shankar, K. Divyabramham, and S. Sanyal, “Compact
coupled line quadrature hybrid coupler with enhanced balance
bandwidth,” Applied Electromagnetics Conference, pp. 1 – 4, 2011.
[18] P. Kurgan, A. Bekasiewicz, M. Kitlinski, “Slow-wave resonant
structures in branch-line coupler miniaturization: a case study,”
International Conference on Microwaves, Radars and Wireless
Communication, pp. 695 – 698, May, 2012.
... While DB-BLC 1 covers a wide frequency range, it is bulky at (162.58 mm × 161.31 mm). To reduce size, we fractalize the structure with sharp-edged chamfered bends to minimize capacitive effects [18]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Symmetry is a key factor for Branch-Line Couplers (BLCs) in RF and microwave systems. This balanced approach evenly distributes power between two output ports, aiding impedance matching and reducing unwanted coupling and crosstalk, while increasing input-output isolation. Furthermore, the symmetrical design of BLCs ensures favorable return loss and phase balance , which are essential for phase-sensitive detectors and beamforming. This symmetry also guarantees consistent performance over a wide frequency range, making it suitable for broadband or multi-frequency applications. We present a compact BLC operating in two frequency bands, ideal for 5G sub-6 GHz applications. It uses T-shaped lines with folded lines and stubs in a Minkowski fractal shape, resulting in a size reduction of 90%. The design and simulation were performed using the CST Microwave Studio at 0.7 GHz and 3.5 GHz, achieving a new high frequency band ratio of 5. A prototype on Rogers RT5880 substrate (ε r = 2.2, h = 0.787 mm) was tested to validate the design's effectiveness, offering potential for modern wireless applications requiring versatile frequency band operation.
... The T-section dual-band BLC is then reduced to a total circuit area of (74.2 mm × 66.2 mm), as illustrated in Fig. 4 Likewise, adjustments were made to the BLC's series and shunt TL segments to achieve additional size reduction using the meandering technique outlined in [26]. This technique involved integrating four right-angle bends into each arm, where each bend covered an approximate path length of πR/2 mm as shown in Fig. 5. Consequently, the combined path length of all four bends in each arm equated to 2πR mm. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper introduces an innovative 4×4 dual-band Butler matrix (BM) characterized by compactness and an enhanced frequency ratio (K). The design employs meandered lines and an interdigital capacitor unit cell based composite right/left-handed transmission-line (CRLH-TL) metamaterial (MTM) structure. The BM integrates compact dual-band 3 dB branch-line couplers (BLC), a 0 dB crossover, and a dual-band 45° phase shifter on a single Rogers RT5880 substrate (with ε <sub xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> r </sub> = 2.2 and h = 0.787 mm). Simulations and measurements results demonstrates reflection and isolation coefficients exceeding -20 dB at all ports, with a obtained insertion loss of -6±3 dB over the 0.7 GHz and 3.5 GHz frequency bands. The achieved phase differences of ±45°, ±135°, ±135°, and ±45° indicate a maximum average phase tolerance of ±4.5°. Importantly, the BM’s overall dimensions are 140 mm × 192 mm, resulting in a 78% size reduction compared to traditional BM designs. The proposed configuration is designed and simulated using CST Microwave Studio, with the agreement between simulated and measured parameters highlighting design reliability and effectiveness. Additionally, a performance evaluation comparing the proposed BM with existing circuits reveals its suitability for sub-6 GHz 5G dual-band antenna array beamforming networks (BFN) due to its compact size and improved band ratio.
... Therefore, compact directional coupler designs should be considered [1] - [10]. In [1], miniaturization is achieved by adding idle stubs, in [2], the branching of π-form transmission lines made it possible to reduce the size of a power divider operating at two different frequencies, in [3], [5], [10], replacing quarter-wave sections with artificial lines from high-resistance lines and stubs made it possible to obtain a compact coupler, in [4], [6], [9] defects in the screen are used, in [7], low-pass filters are used to miniaturize the coupler, in [8] to miniaturize the separator, bends of lines into the internal space of the device are used. Of course, a phase shifter on a directional coupler is not the only circuit solution for the implementation of phase shifters on a microwave substrate, so let's consider the designs of compact phase shifters, the description of which is presented in the IEEE database. ...
Article
The paper proposes and investigates the topology of a phase shifter based on a directional coupler. The dimensions of such a device are reduced by using artificial transmission lines instead of quarter-wave sections. By connecting several pairs of phase-shifting cells instead of the usual one, it was possible to obtain a phase shifter design with two phase shifts (instead of one).
... Authors [38] proposed a folded microstrip TL section as a miniaturization technique for compact BLC design. The method is fast and achieved excellent performance with a 43.63% size reduction at a 3GHz frequency. ...
Article
Full-text available
Beamforming networks for multiple beam antennas are believed to be in the vanguard of technological developments in mmWave for 5G wireless applications. The basic idea of beamforming technique is the application of multiple antenna elements radiating the same signal at an identical phase and wavelength, into one strong signal pointed to a specific direction. For low cost and power consumption, radio frequency beamforming networks (RF-BFNs) such as Blass matrices, Butler matrices, and Nolen matrices will play a critical role in achieving the ever-increasing demands in wireless technology. Therefore, this study aims to present a comprehensive survey and developments of RF-BFNs with (particular focus in Butler matrices). From the fundamental perspectives of the beamforming techniques and progress over time, component evolution includes branch-line coupler (BLC), Phase shifter (PS), and Crossovers to complete system Butler matrix (BM) integration. Different design techniques to improve bandwidth, size reduction, multi-band, and other performance characteristics are discussed extensively. Furthermore, the paper also discusses different geometry of Butler matrices in open microstrip transmission lines, substrate integrated waveguide (SIW) and gap waveguide (GWG) technologies highlighting key developments and research challenges from single band to dual-band operations.We expect this paper to provide more profound insights into the designs processes and suggest suitable ways to facilitate further developments of RF-beamforming networks at mmWave and sub-mmWave frequency ranges.
Chapter
One of the essential components of many microwave circuits is the branch-line coupler (BLC). In this work, a BLC using apertures and shorting post is investigated to obtain a broad-band response characteristic. A delay line has also been introduced to maintain its phase response. The structure operates in a frequency range of 3.3–3.67 GHz with a 370 MHz bandwidth, which is suitable for upcoming n78 5G communications. In this dedicated frequency band, the BLC shows good matching with lower reflection and isolation, stable coupling, and phase difference. The simulation has been carried out using HFSS simulation software.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
A case study of novel slow-wave resonant structures dedicated to efficient microstrip branch-line coupler size reduction has been presented. A compact 3-dB branch-line coupler has been designed to mimic the performance of its conventional counterpart, simultaneously demonstrating a substantial 88% surface area reduction. The vital usefulness of the approach in the process of microstrip line abbreviation has been experimentally validated. The measured in-band results are in excellent agreement with theoretical characteristics, while the out-of-band performance depicts an efficient suppression of unwanted signals up to the 6th harmonic.
Conference Paper
This paper presents the design of a broadband branch-line coupler. The proposed coupler features compact size on a single circuit layer structure. For the high power capability, broadband property and cost effectiveness, we have designed, fabricated and tested a new three-branch hybrid with lumped-distributed-elements. It has the fractional bandwidth of 45% at the center frequency of 2 GHz. Also, it shows the size reduction more than 35 % compared with the conventional design method.
Conference Paper
A single stage quadrature hybrid coupler with enhanced flat balance over a wide bandwidth is presented in this article. The present coupler is realized by replacing the transmission line sections of the conventional two-branch coupler by their equivalent parallel coupled microstrip lines (PCML). The impedance controlled wide-bandpass response produced by the PCML is utilized to achieve flat balanced response over wider bandwidth that is comparable to that of a four-branch conventional coupler. A lossless transmission line model is used to derive the design equations along with design graphs. A prototype microstrip coupler having a wide ±1.0 dB amplitude balance of 71% is fabricated at 2.4 GHz to validate theoretical predictions.
Article
A new dual-band 90° coupler using coupled transmission lines is proposed in this paper. As the coupler consists of only three quarter-wave coupled-line sections, it occupies less circuit area as compared to other existing dual-band branch-line couplers. A desired dual-band operation can be achieved by proper design of the coupling level for those coupled-line sections. Moreover, the coupler's configuration contains a degree of freedom so that its design is “customizable,” allowing itself to be conveniently realized on a variety of circuit and substrate technologies. As a result, it is suitable for use in many practical applications.
Article
This letter presents a miniaturized 3 dB branch-line hybrid coupler with second harmonic suppression using high-impedance transmission lines and interdigitated shunt capacitors. By using the interdigitated capacitors shunt with the transmission lines, further minimization of the 3 dB branch-line hybridcouplercanbeachievedcomparedwithpreviouslyreported techniques. The design of the interdigitated shunt capacitors re- quires concurrent optimization of the capacitance to the ground and the edge-coupling interdigitated capacitance between the ports. For validation, a miniaturized 3 dB branch-line hybrid coupler at 836.5 MHz was designed and implemented. The pro- posed 3 dB branch-line hybrid coupler achieved a compact size of 27.75 mm 25.7 mm, or equivalently , where is the free-space wavelength. Moreover, the coupler can sup- press second harmonic components by 20 dB while maintaining similar measured performance compared to the conventional branch-line hybrid coupler.
Article
Based on a new synthesized microstrip line, a miniaturized branch- line coupler with wide upper stopband is developed at 1.85 GHz. The new synthesized line consists of a pair of series LC tanks with two additional meander line inductors. The LC tanks introduce a pair of transmission zeros, which can be independently controlled to provide wide upper stopband from 3.5 to 8 GHz. Benefitting from the slow-wave nature of the synthesized microstrip lines, the proposed coupler also shows a very compact size, which is 28% the size of its conventional counterpart. The design methodology and experimental results are discussed in detail in the paper.
Article
In this research article an undergraduate student project on Koch fractal curves based branch line couplers design is reported. The new fractal shaped branch-line couplers, operating at 3.0 GHz, using Koch fractal shapes of different iteration orders, have been successfully designed. The designed couplers, all operated at the designed frequency, achieved a maximum 81% size reduction without much change in the operating frequency and its bandwidth.
Article
A new method of compact branch-line coupler is presented in this paper. The method utilizes nonuniform transmission lines (NTLs) instead of uniform transmission lines (UTLs) in each arm of branch-line. The normalized width w(z) /h function of the NTLs which is expanded in a truncated Fourier series is used for optimization. A 2-GHz branch-line coupler is designed, fabricated and measured. The measurement results are in good agreement with the simulation results. This new structure exhibits 50% size reduction (in circuit area) as compared with the conventional branch-line coupler.
Conference Paper
The ultra-compact microstrip branch-line couplers are proposed in this paper. Using the provided criteria to shorten the lengths of four quarter-wavelength transmission lines, the sizes of branch-line couplers can be greatly miniaturized. In this study, the reduction rate of the proposed couplers' sizes are over 88.9% and 76.8% using approaches with the pi-model and the T-model, respectively. Moreover, the measured frequency and phase responses show good agreement with the electromagnetic simulated results.