ArticlePDF Available

Reduced Periodontal Support for Lower Central Incisor – A 3D Finite Element Analysis of Compressive Stress in the Periodontium

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Background: The aim of this study was to assess the stress concentration in simulated periodontal alveolar bone containing healthy teeth with and without attachment loss. Methods: Six 3-D models of a lower central incisor were created simulating the teeth structure, cancellous and cortical bone and periodontal ligament. Each model presented a 1mm increasing distance between cement-enamel junction (CEJ) and alveolar bone crest (ABC) (1 to 6mm). A 100N, 45-degree load was applied to the buccal face of the lower central incisor. The effects of Minimum Principal Stress (MPS) on lamina dura (LD) and ABC were analyzed. Results: The results showed an increase of MPS in the surrounding bone (ABC and LD) due to periodontal attachment loss. The 6mm attachment loss model showed the highest (p<0.001) magnitude in MPS. Each millimeter increase in CEJ-ABC distance generated a 12% pattern of attachment loss and an increase at least of 65.7% for ABC and 33.6% for LD. Conclusion: Under simulated conditions, attachment loss increases stress concentration in the surrounding bone suggesting a partly
Content may be subject to copyright.
© International Academy of Periodontology
Journal of the International Academy of Periodontology 2021 23/1: 65–71
Correspondence to: João Paulo Mendes Tribst, Department of
Dental Materials and Prosthodontics, São Paulo State University
(Unesp), Institute of Science and Technology, Av. Eng. Francisco
José Longo, n° 777, Jardim São Dimas, 12245-000 São José dos
Campos, SP, Brazil. Email: joao.tribst@gmail.com
Introduction
The primary function of the human dentition is food
preparation and processing through a biomechanical
masticatory process. This process is involves transferring
masticatory forces to the periodontium and this is medi-
ated through the teeth (Versluis and Versluis-Tantbirojn,
2011). The periodontal apparatus (cementum, periodontal
ligament and alveolar bone) plays an important role in sta-
bilizing teeth. The forces produced during mastication are
distributed and absorbed by the alveolar process through
the alveolar bone. In health, the tooth-periodontium
complex, maintains tissue homeostasis when subjected
to physiological forces (Cattaneo et al., 2009).
Reduced Periodontal Support for Lower
Central Incisor – A 3D Finite Element
Analysis of Compressive Stress in the
Periodontium
Milena Cerqueira da Rocha,1 Daniel Maranha da Rocha,1
João Paulo Mendes Tribst,2 Alexandre Luiz Souto Borges2 and
Fabiano Alvim-Pereira1
Abstract
Background: The aim of this study was to assess the stress concentration in simulated
periodontal alveolar bone containing healthy teeth with and without attachment loss.
Methods: Six 3-D models of a lower central incisor were created simulating the teeth struc-
ture, cancellous and cortical bone and periodontal ligament. Each model presented a 1mm
increasing distance between cement-enamel junction (CEJ) and alveolar bone crest (ABC) (1
to 6mm). A 100N, 45-degree load was applied to the buccal face of the lower central incisor.
The effects of Minimum Principal Stress (MPS) on lamina dura (LD) and ABC were analyzed.
Results: The results showed an increase of MPS in the surrounding bone (ABC and LD)
due to periodontal attachment loss. The 6mm attachment loss model showed the highest
(p<0.001) magnitude in MPS. Each millimeter increase in CEJ-ABC distance generated a
12% pattern of attachment loss and an increase at least of 65.7% for ABC and 33.6% for LD.
Conclusion: Under simulated conditions, attachment loss increases stress concentration
in the surrounding bone suggesting a partly explanation regarding bone resorption risk
for teeth with periodontal attachment loss.
Keywords: Periodontium, nite element analysis, bone, incisor
1Departament of Dentistry, Universidade Federal de Sergipe,
SE, Brazil; 2Department of Dental Materials and Prosthodontics,
São Paulo State University (Unesp), Institute of Science and
Technology, Brazil.
Chronic periodontal disease is a major public
health condition that affects more than one third of
the population, 10-15% in its most severe form (Eke
et al., 2012). Chronic periodontitis is the primary cause
of tooth loss in people over age 35 (Deng et al., 2010).
Diminished periodontal support results from the sur-
rounding chronic inammation arising in respons to the
presence of a periodontal pathogenic biolm (Cattaneo
et al., 2009). Even after effective chronic periodontal
disease treatment, a subsequent optimal maintenance
phase, and the advances in bone regeneration therapies,
vertical bone regeneration around tooth is an unsolved
challenge for clinicians (Van Dyke et al., 2015).
Evidence in the literature indicates that previous at-
tachment loss is classied as a risk indicator for recurrent
disease (Takeuchi et al., 2010; Martin et al., 2010; Hirata et
al., 2019). This risk may be explained by the diminished
periodontal support removing the capability of teeth to
withstand physiological chewing forces (Takeuchi et al.,
2010; Martin et al., 2010).
66 Journal of the International Academy of Periodontology (2021) 23/1
Among the methods for stress analysis of complex
structures, nite element method (FEM) is a widely ap-
plied tool for bioengineering studies in dentistry (Dal
Piva et al., 2019; Tribst et al., 2020). Different mechanical
stimuli can impact the balance of bone homeostasis
(Mercuri et al., 2016). The relationship between bone and
mechanical stimuli has been evaluated by FEM analysis
and PET/CT scanning (in vivo) with good correlation
between these two methods (Suenaga et al., 2015).
Three-dimensional nite element analysis has been
used in periodontology to estimate the potential effects
of mechanical stimuli and stress on the periodontal
apparatus (Poiate et al., 2008; Ona and Wakabayashi,
2006; Kondo and Wakabayashi, 2009; Tajima et al., 2009;
Papadopoulou et al., 2013; Wakabayashi et al., 2008).
Therefore, the aim of this study was to use nite ele-
ment analysis to measure and map the stress distribution
of simulated normal and reduced periodontal support.
Materials and Methods
A computational-laboratorial study was conducted using
a three-dimensional human lower central incisor model,
constructed into the BioCAD protocol that consists of
creating virtual geometric models of biological struc-
tures based on anatomical references (Papadopoulou
et al., 2013). A three-dimensional scanned image of a
lower central incisor with 19 mm length (9 mm crown;
10 mm root) was used as the reference for modeling the
structures (Poiate et al., 2009). The complete model was
constituted of cancellous bone, 1.0 mm cortical bone,
0.2 mm periodontal ligament (Wakabayashi et al., 2010)
space and tooth (enamel, dentin and pulp) (Figure 1).
Computer-aided design (CAD) software Rhinoceros
4.0 (McNeel North America) was used to achieve the
3-D model. Six different geometries of periodontal at-
tachment were performed, in order to simulate different
levels of periodontal attachment loss. In each situation
different distances (1 mm; 2 mm; 3 mm; 4 mm; 5 mm
and 6 mm) between the enamel-cement junction (CEJ)
and alveolar bone crest (ABC) were simulated.
The geometric data were imported into Ansys soft-
ware (version 16.0; Ansys, Canonsburg, PA) for static
structural analysis. The mechanical properties of the
tissues mechanical considered were: elastic, homoge-
neous, linear and isotropic. Biomechanical proprieties
of the tissues was based on previously published data
(Table 1) for bone (Moroi et al., 1993), enamel, dentin
and periodontal ligament (Monteiro et al., 2018) and
pulp (Toparli et al., 1999).
Figure 1. Geometric modeling of structures
Material/tissue Young’s Moduli
(GPa) Poisson Ratio
Enamel 84,1 0,30
Dentin 14,7 0,31
Pulp 0,000003 0,45
Periodontal ligament 0,0118 0,45
Cortical bone
(Moroi, 1993) 14,7 0,30
Cancellous bone
(Moroi, 1993) 0,49 0,30
Table 1. Mechanical properties of materials/tissues
simulated
Mesh generation used tetrahedral elements. The
overall mean number of units was 197,908 elements
and 347,271 nodes. The elements had 0.2 mm mean size
and mesh surface convergence applied was 5%. It was
ensured that all contacts were considered fully bonded,
which means that the model was considered solid, with
no gaps between structures.
A simulated 100N and 45-degree angled load applied
at the buccal incisal edge of the lower central incisor.
Nodal restriction was applied at the cortical bone base in
all directions. The Consistency of the results was veried
by total displacement analysis and von Mises criteria.
The stress concentration was analyzed using the
Minimum Principal Stress (MPS) criteria, where positive
values were related to tensile stresses and negative values
to compressive stresses. Data processing performed
was arranged in stress color maps and numeric values.
Mechanical stress was analyzed in the cortical bone
and focused in two critical structures: alveolar bone crest
and lamina dura. Stress variations are presented as a scale
color map, where different colors mean different stress
da Rocha et al.: Periodontal support nite element analysis 67
concentrations. Qualitatively the proximity colors with
red in the scale, indicates higher stress concentration. For
quantitative analyses the numerical values of minimum
principal stress distributed in each structure (alveolar bone
crest and lamina dura) were assessed. The colorimetric
scales were adjustable for a visual comparison between
the groups.
Results
The qualitative analysis (Figure 2) shows a color map
illustrating the MPS distribution among the models.
In the analyses of alveolar bone crest, an increase of
compressive zones could be veried when the cement-
enamel junction (CEJ) to the alveolar crest (ABC) dis-
tances were increased. In the 1 mm model compressive
stress concentration peaks were observed on the lingual
bone crest. With an increase in the CEJ-ABC distance,
an increase in the minimum principal stress was located
mainly on lingual face and in the 5 to 6 mm models some
peaks were noted on the buccal face. For the lamina
dura color map, an increasing CEJ-ABC distance lead
to wider compressive stress concentration areas. In the
1 to 3 mm models, compressive areas were primarily
located to proximal regions (near to fulcrum area). For
4 mm, the location peaks of compressive stress started
to spread to buccal and lingual areas. It is noteworthy
that in all models, the 6 mm situation presented the
broadest areas of compressive stress.
Quantitative analyses were also performed and re-
vealed the same pattern of qualitative data, augmented
values of MPS showed an increased distance for CEJ-
ABC. For each millimeter increase in CEJ-ABC distance,
about 11% of the linear attachment was lost up to a 12%
total attachment area loss (Table 2).
Minimum principal stress distributions, as assessed
by scatter plots for 2D distribution, showed statistical
signicant differences (SSD) among groups for changes
in alveolar bone crest and lamina dura. The compres-
sive stress values were also compared in pairs (1 vs. 2,
2 vs. 3, 3 vs. 4, 4 vs. 5 e 5 vs. 6). Statistical signicant
differences were found for both the alveolar bone crest
and lamina dura (Figure 3). Moreover, it was noted that
with a decrease in periodontal support the intra model
variance of MPS display amplication (Figure 3).
Pearson’s correlation coefcient analyses between
attachment loss and peak of MPS were performed for
ABC and LD. Statistical signicant difference and high
Figure 2 - Color mapping of compression stress in the alveolar bone (a) ABC view, (b) LD occlusal view, (c) LD
proximal view
68 Journal of the International Academy of Periodontology (2021) 23/1
positive correlation (p=0.020; r=0.882) were found for
LD. SSD had a very high positive correlation (p=0.001;
r=0.975) for ABC.
The MPS peak increase in the no attachment loss
model, showed that the peak of compression stress
increased by 65.7% (ABC) and 33.6% (LD) with 11%
of attachment loss (2 mm model), and up to 252.6%
(ABC), 464.6% (LD) and 55.6% of attachment loss (6
mm model) (Figure 4).
Discussion
Horizontal attachment loss is a consequence of peri-
odontitis that remains even with the reestablishment of
periodontal health. Reduced periodontal support does
not seem to limit bite force (Kleinfelder and Ludwigt
2002). Subjects with attachment loss can exert up to
three times higher forces on the teeth. These func-
tions may related to affected sensory function of the
periodontal ligament (Johansson et al., 2006). Different
mechanical stimuli can modulate bone-remodeling
processes (Burger et al., 1999), and alter molecular path-
ways in bone metabolism (Rubin et al., 2006). Excessive
mechanical stress during hyper-occlusion may lead to
alveolar bone destruction during occlusal traumatism
(Tsutsumi et al., 2013). An important gap in knowledge
still remains unanswered whether the masticatory loads
in severe attachment loss can exceed bone adaptive load
bearing capability leading to periodontal tissue damage.
In the present study an overall increase in the mini-
mum principal stress (mainly compressive stress) was
Distance of
CEJ-ACB
Alveolar Crestal Bone Lamina Dura
Number of
nodes
% of linear
attachment lost
Minimum
Principal Stress
(MPa) Number of
nodes
% of
attachment
area lost
Minimum
Principal Stress
(MPa)
Peak Peak
1 mm 178 0,0% -14,76 6176 0,0% -21,64
2 mm 183 11,1% -24,46 5463 12,4% -28,91
3 mm 181 22,2% -25,37 4290 24,7% -33,07
4 mm 175 33,3% -33,86 3601 36,9% -45,99
5 mm 170 44,4% -48,96 3080 48,4% -60,51
6 mm 160 55,6% -52,04 2333 59,3% -122,18
CEJ - Cementum Enamel Junction
ABC - Alveolar Bone Crest
MPS - Minimum Principal Stress
Table 2. Descriptive statistics of compressive stress in ABC and LD in each simulated CEJ-ABC distance
Figure 3. Chart of distribution of Minimal Principal Stress values among groups
da Rocha et al.: Periodontal support nite element analysis 69
demonstrated in the target bone structures (alveolar bone
crest and lamina dura). This result shows that even with
the same force (that simulated bite forces), the tooth
surrounding bone structures were subjected to higher
compressive stress. Cyclic stress may generate cumulative
damage to the bone (Hambli et al., 2016). Therefore, if
a tooth has reduced periodontal support, the cyclic oc-
clusal forces can intensify bone damage. In periodontal
maintenance therapy, reinforcement of oral hygiene and
biolm removal is indicated (Armitage et al., 2016). Also
in this phase, occlusal adjustment has been reported to
improve periodontal health in terms of bacterial prole
and clinical appearance (Meynardi et al., 2016).
The distribution of stress values presented a non-
parametric distribution in the investigated bone struc-
tures, this is expected due to anatomic characteristics of
the designed structures, the vector force incidence, and
the axis of tooth rotation. Other studies have shown
a similar distribution conguration (Ona and Waka-
bayashi, 2006; Geramy et al., 2004).
Stress values exceeding the critical threshold of
between 50 and 60 MPa have been reported to cause
detrimental effects on human cortical bone (Sugiura et
al., 2000). In our study, peaks of MPS were reached in
the 5 and 6 mm model in lamina dura. These ndings
are not in agreement with a previous study that found
the height bone reduction potentially did not cause
mechanical damage (Ona and Wakabayashi, 2006). It is
noteworthy that literal interpretation of the stress values
is not a straightforward matter and characteristics such
as position of the teeth (Gerami et al., 2016), oclusal
dynamic and cyclic loading conditions should all be
taken into account (Benazzi et al., 2013). Caution also
is necessary since the effects of forces are dependent
on the accuracy of the elastic properties that are being
fed into the program and the accurate biomechanical
proprieties of tissues (McGuinness et al., 1991). Alveolar
bone was chosen for analysis because it is one of the
rst tissues affected by the inammatory response to
bacterial stimuli (Nakamura et al., 2010). Biochemical
mediators regulate inammation and bone resorption
and some in vitro studies have shown that these sites can
also be be modulated by mechanical stimuli (Hienz et
al., 2015). The lamina dura area was chosen for analysis
because it has an intimate anatomical relationship with
the root surface and during injury, adaptive remodeling
occurs during the repair phase aiming to better cope
with excessive loads (Gerami et al., 2016).
An increase in the intensity of the MPS peak was
clearly seen in the LD when 40% of the attachment
area was lost, this increase also showed a peak increase
in the ABC, but without any change in pattern. The
correlation coefficient between the MPS peak and
percentage of attachment loss reveled the high degree
dependence between these parameters. When the force
of occlusion was constant, and the attachment area of
the tooth became smaller, the compressive/area stress
tended to increase.
Even considering the inherent limitations of
finite element analysis, and the restrictions in the
created computational mathematical model, such as
simplification of structures mechanical properties
(Cook and Mongeau 2007), the specic dental element
designed and its anatomical morphology are reasonable
Figure 4. Chart of Minimal Principal Stress peak increase in relation to no attachment loss model
70 Journal of the International Academy of Periodontology (2021) 23/1
if their impact on the conclusions is carefully taken
into account. It has been shown, for example, that the
assumption properties for periodontal ligament could
interfere with the stress values, but this did not change
the biomechanical behavior of tooth-periodontal
structure (Wood et al., 2011). Moreover, force application
is a difcult task to mimic because of the nature of
masticatory function and natural loading scenario.
However, the patterns of compressive stress distribution
values found in the simulated models, clearly indicated
a trend towards increase stress concentration when
periodontal attachment was reduced.
The results of this study provide some knowledge to
understanding the relationahip between occlusal trauma
in teeth with reduced attachment apparatus and normal
periodontal ligament space. Clinically, this suggests that
in vivo, similar clinical situations, submitted to chewing
forces can generate stresses that exceed physiological
limits and cause periodontal bone damage. Questions
about the threshold capability should be explored. These
ndings may potentially assist in the development of
treatment strategies and prevention to avoid alveolar
bone injury during periodontal treatment maintenance
phase. Thus, teeth with attachment loss and normal peri-
odontal ligament space, should receive special attention
in relation to occlusal relations and masticatory loads.
Limitations of this study are that the present models
do not represent all the oral variations such as changes
in pH, temperature, sliding occlusal loading, pres-
ence of bacteria, different antagonistic materials, and
parafunctional habit. The simulated condition used for
this study were considered isotropic and homogeneous
with a simplied behavior.
Conclusion
The results of this study demonstrate that attachment
loss around teeth increases stress concentration in the
surrounding bone. Despite inherent limitations of the
model used the results dene a biomechanical chang-
ing in stress pattern, which help to partly explain bone
resorption risk for teeth with periodontal attachment
loss and normal ligament space.
Acknowledgment
CAPES/FAPITEC/SE supported this research.
References
Armitage GC, Xenoudi P. Post-treatment supportive
care for the natural dentition and dental implants.
Periodontology 2000 2016; 71:164-184.
Benazzi S, Nguyen HN, Schulz D, Grosse IR, Gruppioni
G, Hublin J, Kullmer O. The evolutionary paradox of
tooth wear: simply destruction or inevitable adapta-
tion? PlOS one 2013; 8:e62263.
Burger EH, Klein-Nulend J. Mechanotransduction in
bone—role of the lacuno-canalicular network. The
FASEB Journal 1999; 13:101-112.
Cattaneo PM, Dalstra M, Melsen B. Strains in periodon-
tal ligament and alveolar bone associated with orth-
odontic tooth movement analyzed by nite element.
Orthodontics & Craniofacial Research 2009; 12:120-128.
Cook DD, Mongeau L. Sensitivity of a continuum vocal
fold model to geometric parameters, constraints, and
boundary conditions. Journal of the Acoustic Society of
America 2007; 121:2247-2253.
Dal Piva AMO, Tribst JPM, Saavedra GSFA, Souza RO,
Melo RM, Borges ALS, Ozcan M. Short communica-
tion: Inuence of retainer conguration and loading
direction on the stress distribution of lithium disili-
cate resin-bonded xed dental prostheses: 3D nite
element analysis. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of
Biomedical Materials 2019; 100:103389.
Deng F, Zhang H, Zhang H, Shao H, He Q, Zhang
P. A comparison of clinical outcomes for implants
placed in fresh extraction sockets versus healed sites
in periodontally compromised patients: a 1-year
follow-up report. The International Journal of Oral &
Maxillofacial Implants 2010; 25:1036-1040.
Eke PI, Page RC, Wei L, Thornton-Evans G, Genco RJ.
Update of the case denitions for population-based
surveillance of periodontitis. Journal of Periodontology
2012; 83:1449-1454.
Gerami A, Dadgar S, Rakhshan V, Jannati P, Sobouti
F. Displacement and force distribution of splinted
and tilted mandibular anterior teeth under occlusal
loads: an in silico 3D nite element analysis. Progress
in Orthodontics 2016; 17:16.
Geramy A, Faghihi S. Secondary trauma from occlusion:
three-dimensional analysis using the nite element
method. Quintessence International 2004; 35:835-843.
Hambli R, Frikha S, Toumi H, Tavares JM. Finite ele-
ment prediction of fatigue damage growth in can-
cellous bone. Computer Methods in Biomechanics and
Biomedical Engineering 2016; 19:563-570.
Hienz SA, Paliwal S, Ivanovski S. Mechanisms of Bone
Resorption in Periodontitis. Journal of Immunology
Research 2015; 2015:615486.
Hirata T, Fuchida S, Yamamoto T, Kudo C, Minabe M.
Predictive factors for tooth loss during supportive
periodontal therapy in patients with severe periodon-
titis: a Japanese multicenter study. BMC Oral Health
2019; 15:19.
Johansson AS, Svensson KG, Trulsson M. Impaired masti-
catory behavior in subjects with reduced periodontal tis-
sue support. Journal of Periodontology 2006; 77:1491-1497.
Kleinfelder JW, Ludwigt K. Maximal bite force in pa-
tients with reduced periodontal tissue support with
and without splinting. Journal of Periodontology 2002;
73:1184-1187.
da Rocha et al.: Periodontal support nite element analysis 71
Kondo T, Wakabayashi N. Inuence of molar support
loss on stress and strain in premolar periodontium: a
patient-specic FEM study. Journal of Dentistry 2009;
37:541-548.
Martin JA, Page RC, Loeb CF, Levi PA, Jr. Tooth loss in
776 treated periodontal patients. Journal of Periodontol-
ogy 2010; 81:244-250.
McGuinness NJ, Wilson AN, Jones ML, Middleton J.
A stress analysis of the periodontal ligament under
various orthodontic loadings. The European Journal of
Orthodontics 1991; 13:231-242.
Mercuri EG, Daniel AL, Hecke MB, Carvalho L. Inu-
ence of different mechanical stimuli in a multi-scale
mechanobiological isotropic model for bone remod-
elling. Medical Engineering & Physics 2016; 38:904-910.
Mercuri EG, Daniel AL, Hecke MB, Carvalho L. Inu-
ence of different mechanical stimuli in a multi-scale
mechanobiological isotropic model for bone remod-
elling. Medical Engineering & Physics 2016; 38:904-910.
Meynardi F, Pasqualini ME, Rossi F, Dal Carlo L, Biancotti
P, Carinci F. Correlation between dysfunctional occlu-
sion and periodontal bacterial prole. Journal of Biologi-
cal Regulators and Homeostatic Agents 2016; 30:115-121.
Moroi HH, Okimoto K, Moroi R, Tereda Y. Numeric
approach to the biomechanical analysis of thermal
effects in coated implants. International Journal of
Prosthodontics 1993; 6:564-572.
Monteiro JB, Dal Piva AMDO, Tribst JPM, Borges ALS,
Tango RN. The effect of resection angle on stress
distribution after root-end surgery. Iranian Endodontic
Journal 2018; 13:180-188.
Nakamura A, Osonoi T, Terauchi Y. Relationship between
urinary sodium excretion and pioglitazone-induced
edema. Journal of Diabetes Investigation 2010; 1:208-211.
Ona M, Wakabayashi N. Inuence of alveolar support
on stress in periodontal structures. Journal of Dental
Research 2006; 85:1087-1091.
Papadopoulou K, Hasan I, Keilig L, Reimann S, Eliades
T, Jager A, Deschner J, Bourauel C. Biomechanical
time dependency of the periodontal ligament: a
combined experimental and numerical approach.
European Journal of Orthodontics 2013; 35:811-818.
Poiate IA, Vasconcellos AB, Andueza A, Pola IR, Poiate
E, Jr. Three dimensional nite element analyses of
oral structures by computerized tomography. Journal
of Bioscience and Bioengineering 2008; 106:606-609.
Poiate IA, de Vasconcellos AB, de Santana RB, Poiate E.
Three-dimensional stress distribution in the human
periodontal ligament in masticatory, parafunctional,
and trauma loads: nite element analysis. Journal of
Periodontology 2009; 80:1859-1867.
Rubin J, Rubin C, Jacobs CR. Molecular pathways mediat-
ing mechanical signaling in bone. Gene 2006; 367:1-16.
Suenaga H, Chen J, Yamaguchi K, Li W, Sasaki K, Swain
M, Li Q. Mechanobiological bone reaction quantied
by positron emission tomography. Journal of Dental
Research 2015; 94:738-744.
Sugiura T, Horiuchi K, Sugimura M, Tsutsumi S. Evalu-
ation of threshold stress for bone resorption around
screws based on in vivo strain measurement of mini-
plate. Journal of Musculoskeletal & Neuronal Interactions
2000; 1:165-170.
Tajima K, Chen KK, Takahashi N, Noda N, Nagamatsu
Y, Kakigawa H. Three-dimensional nite element
modeling from CT images of tooth and its validation.
Dental Materials Journal 2009; 28:219-226.
Takeuchi N, Ekuni D, Yamamoto T, Morita M. Relation-
ship between the prognosis of periodontitis and oc-
clusal force during the maintenance phase--a cohort
study. Journal of Periodontal Research 2010; 45:612-617.
Toparli M, Gökay N, Aksoy T. Analysis of a restored
maxillary second premolar tooth by using three-
dimensional nite element method. Journal of Oral
Rehabilitation 1999; 26:157-164.
Tribst JPM, Dal Piva AMO, Borges ALS, Bottino MA. In-
uence of Socket-shield technique on the biomechani-
cal response of dental implant: three-dimensional
nite element analysis. Computer Methods in Biomechanics
and Biomedical Engineering 2020; 23:224-231.
Tsutsumi T, Kajiya H, Goto KT, Takahashi Y, Okabe
K. Hyperocclusion up-regulates CCL3 expression
in CCL2- and CCR2-decient mice. Journal of Dental
Research 2013; 92:65-70.
Van Dyke TE, Hasturk H, Kantarci A, Freire MO,
Nguyen D, Dalli J, Serhan CN. Proresolving nano-
medicines activate bone regeneration in periodontitis.
Journal of Dental Research 2015; 94:148-56.
Versluis A, Versluis-Tantbirojn D. Filling cavities or
restoring teeth? The Journal of the Tennessee Dental
Association 2011; 91:36-42.
Wakabayashi N, Ona M, Suzuki T, Igarashi Y. Nonlinear
nite element analyses: advances and challenges in
dental applications. Journal of Dentistry 2008; 36:463-471.
Wakabayashi N, Kondo T, Yahagi R, Suzuki T. A patient-
based model study of xed splinting of premolars
with reduced periodontal support. International Journal
of Computerized Dentistry 2010; 13:317-330.
Wood SA, Strait DS, Dumont ER, Ross CF, Grosse IR.
The effects of modeling simplications on craniofa-
cial nite element models: the alveoli (tooth sockets)
and periodontal ligaments. Journal of Biomechanics
2011; 44:1831-1838.
... e loading was based on displacing the orthodontic wire during controlled buccal movement of 1.0 mm. [12,13] e required results were: e displacement tendency (total deformation) based on the fulcrum point of the tooth during orthodontic movement, [14] microdeformation in bone tissue, [15] minimum and maximum principal stress for the periodontal ligament, [16] minimum and maximum principal stress for the tooth root, [17] von Mises stress for orthodontic wire, [18] and maximum principal stress for the adhesive interface of the composite resin bracket. [19] In addition to the stress distribution maps, the maximum values of each analysis were plotted for quantitative comparison. ...
... Understanding the stress distribution in the periodontium helps to predict the pain and potential damage which may occur even under functional bite force. [16] us, there will be a stimulus for bone tissue degeneration in situations of greater magnitude of compression stresses. [16] Basically, the mechanical response of the periodontal ligament initiates a cascade of biological events and induces the release of oxytocin which acts on alveolar bone remodeling; in addition, f a e they can simultaneously make moved teeth susceptible to orthodontically induced inflammatory root resorption. ...
... [16] us, there will be a stimulus for bone tissue degeneration in situations of greater magnitude of compression stresses. [16] Basically, the mechanical response of the periodontal ligament initiates a cascade of biological events and induces the release of oxytocin which acts on alveolar bone remodeling; in addition, f a e they can simultaneously make moved teeth susceptible to orthodontically induced inflammatory root resorption. [22] Nevertheless, none of the models simulated in the present study appear to be capable of generating root resorption with reaction forces <0.1 N in the medullary region of the bone and strain levels below 43 KPa. ...
Article
Full-text available
ABSTRACT Objectives: e bracketless orthodontic treatment (BOT) is an alternative technique which indicates using an orthodontic appliance composed of wires and composite resin assisted by 3D technology. However, the biomechanical response of central incisor orthodontic movement has yet to be investigated. us, the aim of the present investigation was to calculate the stress magnitude in central incisor movement through 3D finite element analysis using different wire diameters (0.012”, 0.014”, and 0.016”) of nickel–titanium wire and two different resin composites (Opallis and Filtek). Materials and Methods: A 3D volume composed of enamel, dentin, cortical bone, cancellous bone, periodontal ligament, composite resin, and different orthodontic wire diameters was designed. After the modeling process, the models were exported to computer-aided engineering software divided into a finite number of elements, and a mechanical structural static analysis was conducted. Results: e stress results were plotted on colorimetric maps and in tables for comparison between the different models. e results showed that the central incisor orthodontic movement with BOT does not induce damage to the periodontal ligament, dental root, or bone tissue, regardless of the simulated orthodontic wire diameter and resin composite materials. e palatal composite resin and orthodontic wire also presented acceptable stress magnitude during orthodontic movement. Conclusion: us, the BOT technique promoted a suitable biomechanical response during central incisor movement regardless the resin composite. Keywords: Biomechanics, Orthodontics, Finite element analysis, Tooth movement techniques
... After the 3D design process, the models were exported to the computer-aided engineering (CAE) software (Ansys version 15.0; Ansys, Canonsburg, PA, USA) in step format for the preprocessing. The mechanical properties simulated in the present study are described in Table 1 [12][13][14][15][16]. All contacts among the geometries were considered. ...
Article
Full-text available
Different all-ceramic crown designs are available to perform indirect restoration; however, the mechanical response of each model should still be elucidated. The study aims to evaluate the stress distribution in three different zirconia crown designs using finite element analysis. Different three-dimensional molar crowns were simulated: conventional bilayer zirconia covered with porcelain, a monolithic full-contour zirconia crown, and the cutback modified zirconia crown with porcelain veneered buccal face. The models were imported to the computer-aided engineering (CAE) software. Tetrahedral elements were used to form the mesh and the mechanical properties were assumed as isotropic, linear and homogeneous materials. The contacts were considered ideal. For the static structural mechanical analysis, 100 N occlusal load was applied and the bone tissue was fixed. Maximum principal stress showed that the stress pattern was different for the three crown designs, and the traditional bilayer model showed higher stress magnitude comparing to the other models. However, grayscale stress maps showed homogeneous stress distribution for all models. The all-ceramic crown designs affect the stress distribution, and the cutback porcelain-veneered zirconia crown can be a viable alternative to adequate function and esthetic when the monolithic zirconia crown cannot be indicated.
Article
Full-text available
This study evaluated the stress distribution in five different class II cavities of premolar models restored with conventional or bulk-fill flowable composite by means of finite element analysis (FEA) under shrinkage and occlusal loading. An upper validated premolar model was imported in the software, and five class II cavities with different occlusal extensions and dimensions were prepared: horizontal cavity on the mesial surface (horizontal slot), mesio-occlusal cavity, mesial cavity (vertical slot), tunnel type cavity and direct access cavity. The models were restored with conventional or bulk-fill flowable resin composite. The tested materials were considered as homogeneous, linear, and isotropic. The Maximum Principal Stress criteria was chosen to evaluate the tensile stress results. The lowest shrinkage stress value was observed in the direct access cavity restored with bulk-fill flowable resin composite (36.12 MPa). The same cavity, restored with conventional composite showed a score of 36.14 MPa. The horizontal slot cavity with bulk-fill flowable showed a score of 46.71 MPa. The mesio-occlusal cavity with bulk-fill flowable had a score of 53.10 MPa, while with conventional composite this was 55.35 MPa. Higher shrinkage stress was found in the vertical slot cavity with conventional resin 56.14 MPa, followed by the same cavity with bulk-fill flowable 56.08 MPa. Results indicated that the use of bulk-fill flowable composite resin more significantly decreased the polymerization shrinkage stress magnitude. The larger the cavity and the volume of material necessary to restore the tooth, the greater the residual stress on enamel and dentin tissue.
Article
Full-text available
Background Supportive periodontal therapy (SPT) must take individual patient risk factors into account. We conducted a multicenter joint retrospective cohort study to investigate the value of modified periodontal risk assessment (MPRA) and therapy-resistant periodontitis (TRP) assessment as predictive factors for tooth loss due to periodontal disease in patients with severe periodontitis during SPT. Methods The subjects were 82 patients from 11 dental institutions who were diagnosed with severe periodontitis and continued SPT for at least 1 year (mean follow-up = 4.9 years) between 1981 and 2008. The outcome was tooth loss due to periodontal disease during SPT. The Cox proportional hazards model was used to analyze sex, age, diabetes status, smoking history, number of periodontal pockets measuring ≥6 mm, rate of bleeding on probing, bone loss/age ratio, number of teeth lost, MPRA, and TRP assessment as explanatory variables. Results Univariate analysis showed that loss of ≥8 teeth by the start of SPT [hazard ratio (HR) 2.86], MPRA score indicating moderate risk (HR 8.73) or high risk (HR 11.04), and TRP assessment as poor responsiveness to treatment (HR 2.79) were significantly associated with tooth loss (p < 0.05). In a model in which the explanatory variables of an association that was statistically significant were added simultaneously, the HR for poor responsiveness to treatment and ≥8 teeth lost was significant at 20.17 compared with patients whose TRP assessment indicated that they responded favorably to treatment and who had lost <8 teeth by the start of SPT. Conclusion MPRA and TRP assessment may be useful predictive factors for tooth loss due to periodontal disease during SPT in Japanese patients with severe periodontitis. Additionally, considering the number of teeth lost by the start of SPT in TRP assessment may improve its predictive accuracy.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction This study aimed to investigate the influence of the resection angle on the stress distribution of retrograde endodontic treated maxillary incisors under oblique-load application. Methods and Materials A maxillary central incisor which was endodontically treated and restored with a fiber glass post was obtained in a 3-dimensional numerical model and distributed into three groups according to type of resection: control; restored with fiber post without retrograde obturation, R45 and R90 with 45º and 90º resection from tooth axial axis, respectively and restored with Fuji II LC (GC America). The numerical models received a 45º occlusal load of 200 N/cm² on the middle of lingual surface. All materials and structures were considered linear elastic, homogeneous and isotropic. Numerical models were plotted and meshed with isoparametric elements, and the results were analyzed using maximum principal stress (MPS). Results MPS showed greater stress values in the bone tissue for control group than the other groups. Groups with apicectomy showed acceptable stress distribution on the fiber post, cement layer and root dentin, presenting more improved values than control group. Conclusion Apicectomy at 90º promotes more homogeneity on stress distribution on the fiber post, cement layer and root dentin, which suggests less probability of failure. However, due to its facility and stress distribution also being better than control group, apicectomy at 45° could be a good choice for clinicians.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study is to compare the evolution in bacterial profile at evident periodontitis sites following two types of treatment-oral hygiene procedures alone (Group 1) and oral hygiene plus occlusal adjustment through selective grinding (Group 2). The presence of periodontal disease was ascertained by clinical examination (redness, oedema, probe depth, bleeding-on-probing). Bacterial profiling was carried out via phase contrast microscopy on plaque samples taken from periodontitis sites in both patient groups. Bacterial populations were characterized in terms of coccus content before (T0) and at monthly intervals after treatment (T1-6) over a period of six months. Static and dynamic occlusion was evaluated only in Group 2 patients. Whereas the poor pre-treatment bacterial profile was re-established progressively over the evaluation period in Group 1 patients, coccus populations flourished in Group 2 patients, reaching healthy levels (>70%) two months after occlusal adjustment, and clinical examination confirmed an absence of periodontal inflammation in these patients. Occlusal adjustment can lead to a marked, stable improvement in periodontal health in terms of bacterial profile and clinical appearance, presumably by obviating tissue distress caused by occlusal dysfunction, thereby providing unfavourable conditions for bacterial growth. Bacterial profiling is an effective indicator of periodontal health.
Article
Full-text available
Background Fixed orthodontic retainers have numerous advantages, but it is not known whether they can exert pathological forces on supporting tissues around the splinted teeth. The purpose of this study was to investigate how the inclination of the lower anterior teeth can affect dental displacement and also change the direction of occlusal loads exerted to dental and its supporting tissues. Methods Four three-dimensional finite element models of the anterior part of the mandible were designed. All the models contained the incisors and canines, their periodontal ligament layers (PDLs), the supporting bone (both spongy and cortical), and a pentaflex splinting wire placed in the lingual side of the teeth. Teeth inclination was considered to be 80° (model 1), 90° (model 2), 100° (model 3), and 110° (model 4) to the horizontal plane. The lower incisors were loaded with a 187-N vertical force. Their displacement patterns and the stress in their PDLs were evaluated. Results In incisors with 80° of inclination, less than a 0.1-mm lingual displacement was seen on the incisal edge and a similar distance of displacement towards the labial was seen on their root apices. However, in models with 90°–110° of inclination, the incisal edge displaced labially between about 0.01 and 0.45 mm, while root apices displaced lingually instead. By increasing the angle of the teeth, the strain in the periodontal ligament increased from about 37 to 58 mJ. The von Mises stresses around the cervical and apical areas differed for each tooth and each model, without a similar pattern. Increasing the angle of the teeth resulted in much higher cervical stresses in the incisors, but not in the canines. In the lateral incisor, cervical stress increased until 100° of inclination but reduced to about half by increasing the angle to 110°. Apical stress increased rather consistently in the incisor and lateral incisors, by increasing the inclination. However, in the canines, apical stress reduced to about half, from the first to fourth models. Conclusions Increasing the labial inclination can mostly harm the central incisors, followed by the lateral incisors. This finding warns against long durations of splinting in patients with higher and/or patients with reduced labial bone thickness.
Article
Full-text available
Cyclic stresses applied to bones generate fatigue damage that affects the bone stiffness and its elastic modulus. This paper proposes a finite element model for the prediction of fatigue damage accumulation and failure in cancellous bone at continuum scale. The model is based on continuum damage mechanics and incorporates crack closure effects in compression. The propagation of the cracks is completely simulated throughout the damaged area. In this case, the stiffness of the broken element is reduced by 98% to ensure no stress-carrying capacities of completely damaged elements. Once a crack is initiated, the propagation direction is simulated by the propagation of the broken elements of the mesh. The proposed model suggests that damage evolves over a real physical time variable (cycles). In order to reduce the computation time, the integration of the damage growth rate is based on the cycle blocks approach. In this approach, the real number of cycles is reduced (divided) into equivalent blocks of cycles. Damage accumulation is computed over the cycle blocks and then extrapolated over the corresponding real cycles. The results show a clear difference between local tensile and compressive stresses on damage accumulation. Incorporating stiffness reduction also produces a redistribution of the peak stresses in the damaged region, which results in a delay in damage fracture.
Article
Full-text available
Alveolar bone loss is a hallmark of periodontitis progression and its prevention is a key clinical challenge in periodontal disease treatment. Bone destruction is mediated by the host immune and inflammatory response to the microbial challenge. However, the mechanisms by which the local immune response against periodontopathic bacteria disturbs the homeostatic balance of bone formation and resorption in favour of bone loss remain to be established. The osteoclast, the principal bone resorptive cell, differentiates from monocyte/macrophage precursors under the regulation of the critical cytokines macrophage colony-stimulating factor, RANK ligand, and osteoprotegerin. TNF-α, IL-1, and PGE2 also promote osteoclast activity, particularly in states of inflammatory osteolysis such as those found in periodontitis. The pathogenic processes of destructive inflammatory periodontal diseases are instigated by subgingival plaque microflora and factors such as lipopolysaccharides derived from specific pathogens. These are propagated by host inflammatory and immune cell influences, and the activation of T and B cells initiates the adaptive immune response via regulation of the Th1-Th2-Th17 regulatory axis. In summary, Th1-type T lymphocytes, B cell macrophages, and neutrophils promote bone loss through upregulated production of proinflammatory mediators and activation of the RANK-L expression pathways.
Article
Full-text available
While nuclear medicine has been proven clinically effective for examination of the change in bone turnover as a result of stress injury, quantitative correlation between tracer uptake and mechanical stimulation in the human jawbone remains unclear. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between bone metabolism observed by 18F-fluoride positron emission tomography (PET) images and mechanical stimuli obtained by finite element analysis (FEA) in the residual ridge induced by the insertion of a removable partial denture (RPD). An 18F-fluoride PET/CT (computerized tomography) scan was performed to assess the change of bone metabolism in the residual ridge under the denture before and after RPD treatment. Corresponding patient-specific 3D finite element (FE) models were created from CT images. Boundary conditions were prescribed by the modeling of condylar contacts, and muscular forces were derived from the occlusal forces measured in vivo to generate mechanobiological reactions. Different mechanobiological stimuli, e.g., equivalent von Mises stress (VMS), equivalent strain (EQV), and strain energy density (SED), determined from nonlinear FEA, were quantified and compared with the standardized uptake values (SUVs) of PET. Application of increased occlusal force after RPD insertion induced higher mechanical stimuli in the residual bone. Accordingly, SUV increased in the region of residual ridge with higher mechanical stimuli. Thus, with SUV, a clear correlation was observed with VMS and SED in the cancellous bone, especially after RPD insertion (R(2) > 0.8, P < 0.001). This study revealed a good correlation between bone metabolism and mechanical stimuli induced by RPD insertion. From this patient-specific study, it was shown that metabolic change detected by PET in the loaded bone, in a much shorter duration than conventional x-ray assessment, is associated with mechanical stimuli. The nondestructive nature of PET/CT scans and FEA could potentially provide a new method for clinical examination and monitoring of prosthetically driven bone remodeling. © International & American Associations for Dental Research 2015.
Article
This study evaluated the bone microstrain, displacement, and stress distribution according to the surgical technique (conventional or Socket-shield) and evaluation period (immediately after implant installation or after healing). Each condition was modeled for the finite element analysis, totaling four groups, with a morse-taper implant and a cemented prosthesis. The maximum displacement , von Mises stress, and bone microstrain yielded higher values during the immediate stage, without a difference between Socket-shield and conventional treatments. The use of the Socket-shield technique does not negatively impact the biomechanical behavior of an implant-supported prosthesis immediately after healing from the implant installation. ARTICLE HISTORY
Article
The present study elucidates the mechanical performance of different designs of resin-bondedfixed dentalprostheses made of lithium disilicate simulating masticatory loads of anterior or canine guidance. A three-dimensional model of maxilla was constructed containing central incisor and canine teeth, with edentulous spaceof the lateral incisor. Three designs of prosthesis were created: retained in central incisor (1-I), retained in canine(1-C) andfixed in both teeth (2-IC). The computational analysis was performed for load in canine and centralincisor separately (100N, 45°). The tensile and shear stresses were calculated for the resin-bondedfixed dentalprosthesis, bonding surface of each retainer and cement layer using 3Dfinite element analysis. The 20 higheststress values were analyzed using two-way ANOVA and post-hoc Tukey test, all withα= 5%. The computationalanalysis showed that 2-retainer resin-bondedfixed dental prosthesis presented the worst prognosis regardless ofthe mandibular movement. ANOVA showed that Mandibular movement*Retainer interaction influenced on thetensile and shear stresses values (p < 0.01). Higher stresses were observed in the connector region for all groups(13–82.2 MPa; 11–70.2 MPa). In order to reduce the stress concentration in the resin-bondedfixed dentalprosthesis and the retainer made of lithium disilicate, the occlusion may serve as the selection criteria of theunitary abutment for better sustainability.
Article
Long-term successful treatment of chronic periodontitis requires placement of patients on post-treatment recall programs known as either periodontal maintenance therapy or supportive periodontal therapy. Selection of the recall intervals must be based on the specific needs of individual patients. A single recall interval (e.g. 6 months) is not suitable for all patients. The main purpose of these programs is to prevent the recurrence of periodontitis. The components of every periodontal maintenance therapy program include: review of medical/dental histories; complete oral examination with an emphasis on the detection of gingival inflammation; establishing whether the maintenance program is working by monitoring clinical attachment levels; evaluation of oral hygiene; and full-mouth supragingival and subgingival debridement (i.e. biofilm removal). Long-term post-insertion care for dental implants also requires a similar patient-specific recall program of supportive implant therapy. The main purposes of a supportive implant therapy program are to maintain a healthy peri-implant mucosa and thereby prevent the development of peri-implantitis. In cases in which plaque-induced peri-implant mucositis has occurred, a well-designed supportive implant therapy program can help return the mucosa to a healthy state. At the current time there is no consensus on the optimal interventions for the treatment of peri-implant mucositis. However, all effective supportive implant therapy programs emphasize meticulous oral hygiene practices, careful peri-implant examination, thoughtful analysis of risk factors and periodic removal of microbial deposits from the implants.