ArticlePDF Available

Optimal Spectrum-hole detection scheme for Cooperative CRN using dynamic weighted VIKOR

IGI Global
International Journal of Enterprise Information Systems
Authors:

Abstract

In the future, the wireless network environment may suffer due to the unavailability of new spectrum bands. Cognitive radio research considers the current spectrum underutilization and provides a better model for the next-generation wireless environment. Since the implementation of the cognitive radio and its policies is a bigger challenge under static spectrum allocation, i.e., current wireless networks policy, many issues are in front of us to accomplish a better cognitive radio wireless environment. One of the major challenges is a secure transmission and efficient free channel selection. In this research, the authors considered an efficient free-channel selection scheme as objective and derived an integrated approach for free-channel selection with techniques, Dynamic weighted-VIKOR.
DOI: 10.4018/IJEIS.2020010106

Volume 16 • Issue 1 • January-March 2020
Copyright © 2020, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
108



Jayakumar Loganathan, Vel Tech Rangarajan Dr.Sagunthala R&D Institute of Science and Technology, Chennai, India
S. Janakiraman, Pondicherry University, Pondicherry, India
Ankur Dumka, Graphic Era Deemed to be University, Chennai, India

In the future, the wireless network environment may suffer due to the unavailability of new spectrum
bands. Cognitive radio research considers the current spectrum underutilization and provides a better
model for the next-generation wireless environment. Since the implementation of the cognitive radio
and its policies is a bigger challenge under static spectrum allocation, i.e., current wireless networks
policy, many issues are in front of us to accomplish a better cognitive radio wireless environment.
One of the major challenges is a secure transmission and efficient free channel selection. In this
research, the authors considered an efficient free-channel selection scheme as objective and derived
an integrated approach for free-channel selection with techniques, Dynamic weighted-VIKOR.

Cooperative CRN, Multi-Criteria Decision Making, Spectrum Decision, VIKOR

Cognitive radio (CR) is a form of wireless communication which consists of a transceiver that is
capable of detecting which communication channels are in use and which are not in use and move
into unoccupied channels while avoiding occupied ones. Cognitive radio is the most hopeful way for
increasing the efficiency of the spectrum by providing opportunistic access to frequency bands to a
group of unlicensed users. Increasing demand for internet usage and wireless application, the demand
for radio spectrum will be very high in the coming years. Internet traffic has estimated as 100 GB for
a day in the year of 1992, the same amount of traffic created per hour in 1997. In 2002, per second
network traffic has calculated as 100GB and in 2014, the same traffic achieved in 400th of a second.
From this study, if the usage of internet forecast for coming years, then 20-25% of the increase will
be achieved every year. On the other hand, utilization of spectrum in some of the licensed bands are
considerably very less, nearly 30% of the allocated spectrum only utilized on those bands, which
is contradictory with the increasing demand of spectrum for various applications (Akyildiz et al.,
2006). So, balancing the future requirement of spectrum for wireless applications, effectively licensed
spectrum should be utilized for various applications. The cognitive radio network is one of the feasible

Volume 16 • Issue 1 • January-March 2020
109
solutions for handling this exponential growth of network traffic in a future radio communication
system by exploring underutilized spectrum opportunities (Kolodzy, 2002; Yucek & Arslan, 2009).
A number of researches had been conducted in various levels of CRN so far such as spectrum
sensing, spectrum decision, network management, resource management, routing, etc., Spectrum
sensing models propose a technique to find opportunities by using Listen Before Talk (LBT) method.
Numerous sensing model has already been found, the energy detector is one which considered by
most of them. Spectrum decision used to decide better channel with fewer chances of interference for
transmission, here also various decision-making schemes from various areas such as game theory,
Markovian, statistical prediction models are been considered (Kumar et al., 2017; Zhu et al., 2014;
Taherpour et al., 2017; Ali & Homouda, 2017).
In this paper, we propose a novel spectrum decision making the process for cooperative CRN by
using Multiple Criteria Decision making (MCDM) scheme. So far MCDM techniques are successfully
used in operation management, decision problems and resource management. Each technique has its
own merit and challenges with it. SAW (Kaliszewski & Podkopaev, 2016), TOPSIS (Kumar et al.,
2017; Jayakumar et al., 2016; Tian et al., 2010), VIKOR (Liao t al., 2015; Wei & Lin, 2008; Gul et
al., 2016), ELECTRE (Yu et al., 2018), PROMETHE (Shaher et al., 2017) are some familiar classical
MCDM models. MOORA, ARAS and SWARA are a recent and simple model for making a decision
from multiple numbers of alternatives. This paper makes the following list of contribution towards
the channel decision model for cooperative CRN:
1. Finalizing the network model for implementing spectrum decision model for cooperative CRN;
2. Proposed spectrum decision-making model using an enhanced version of MCDM;
3. Validated the proposed model with other classical MCDM techniques.

Among many key tasks of CRN, spectrum decision is the most important task which directly related to
the overall performance of CRN (see Figure 1). After completion of spectrum sensing, list of available
Figure 1. Spectrum sensing and decision model for CRN
22 more pages are available in the full version of this
document, which may be purchased using the "Add to Cart"
button on the product's webpage:
www.igi-global.com/article/optimal-spectrum-hole-detection-
scheme-for-cooperative-crn-using-dynamic-weighted-
vikor/243706?camid=4v1
This title is available in InfoSci-Journals, InfoSci-Journal
Disciplines Business, Administration, and Management.
Recommend this product to your librarian:
www.igi-global.com/e-resources/library-
recommendation/?id=2
Related Content
RFID Implementation in Australian Hospitals: Implications for ICT Sector and
Health Informatics
Chandana Unnithan (2014). International Journal of Enterprise Information Systems
(pp. 40-61).
www.igi-global.com/article/rfid-implementation-in-australian-
hospitals/112077?camid=4v1a
The Probabilistic Profitable Tour Problem
Mengying Zhang, John Wang and Hongwei Liu (2017). International Journal of
Enterprise Information Systems (pp. 51-64).
www.igi-global.com/article/the-probabilistic-profitable-tour-
problem/185548?camid=4v1a
Understanding Information Technology Implementation Failure: An
Interpretive Case Study of Information Technology Adoption in a Loosely
Coupled Organization
Marie-Claude Boudreau and Jonny Holmström (2011). Enterprise Information
Systems: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools and Applications (pp. 1496-1512).
www.igi-global.com/chapter/understanding-information-technology-
implementation-failure/48626?camid=4v1a
Business Process Management as a Critical Success Factor in EIS
Implementation
Vladimír Modrák (2010). Enterprise Information Systems for Business Integration in
SMEs: Technological, Organizational, and Social Dimensions (pp. 24-36).
www.igi-global.com/chapter/business-process-management-critical-
success/38191?camid=4v1a
... A modeling framework was designed for an emergency operating procedure, which can reduce cognitive errors in the process of accident resolution through MADM methods and simulations [97]. Moreover, some cognitively inspired MADM models have been applied to evaluation and selection processes, such as efficient free channel selection under wireless environment [107], network selection strategy [105], and automated cognitive workload assessment [106]. Also, cognitive networks were hot application fields for cognitively inspired MADM methods [61,[101][102][103]. Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the last decades, the art and science of multi-attribute decision-making (MADM) have witnessed significant developments and have found applications in many active areas. A lot of research has demonstrated the ability of cognitive techniques in dealing with complex and uncertain decision information. The purpose of representing human cognition in the decision-making process encourages the integration of cognitive psychology and multi-attribute decision-making theory. Due to the emergence of research on cognitively inspired MADM methods, we make a comprehensive overview of published papers in this field and their applications. This paper has been grouped into five parts: we first conduct some statistical analyses of academic papers from two angles: the development trends and the distribution of related publications. To illustrate the basic process of cognitively inspired MADM methods, we present some underlying ideas and the systematic structure of this kind of method. Then, we make a review of cognitively inspired MADM methods from different perspectives. Applications of these methods are further reviewed. Finally, some challenges and future trends are summarized. This paper highlights the benefits of the synergistic approach that is developed based on cognitive techniques and MADM methods and identifies the frontiers in this field.
... To carry out a comparative evaluation, two MCDM are implemented: TOPSIS and VIKOR. This selection was made because of the excellent results that these techniques have presented in decision-making processes for CRN (Divya & Nandakumar, 2019;Giral et al., 2021aGiral et al., , 2021bLoganathan et al., 2020;Rathee et al., 2021;Rodríguez-Colina et al., 2020;Sofuoğlu, 2021;Sumith et al., 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
Cognitive radio networks (CRN) allow for an increase in spectral efficiency and performance of today's wireless networks. Currently, multiple proposals exist in the area of spectral decision-making and mobility; however, very few evaluate the impact of collaboration between secondary users and the performance of spectrum access by many secondary users. Unlike existing works, this article provides a comprehensive quantitative analysis of the performance of CRN taking into account access to the spectrum simultaneously by multiple users and decision making based on collaboration through the exchange of information between nearby secondary users. This proposal is developed through the implementation of four modules: Input Module, Multi-user Module, Collaborative module and Decision-making module, where the results are evaluated comparatively through the handoff rate generated with two multicriteria techniques: Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) and Multi-Criteria Optimization and Compromise Solution (VIKOR). The evaluation is carried out taking into account three levels of collaboration, three multi-user access scenarios, and two multi-criteria techniques for a total of 18 simulation scenarios. The results obtained show the importance of implementing collaboration strategies, as for multi-user access, the number of handoffs increases as the number of serial users increases. TOPSIS presented the best results in 76 % of the analyzed cases where VIKOR generated a smaller number of handoffs; TOPSIS maintained good performance with differences not exceeding 90 handoffs.
Article
Dynamic spectrum allocation is the crucial aspect in Cognitive Radio Networks (CRN) to improve spectral efficiency where the selection of the target frequency channel plays a relevant role in the communication performance of the secondary user. Therefore, the current research work aims to analyze and comparatively evaluate three multi-criteria techniques in spectrum decision within an experimental environment. In order to achieve the above, it is incorporated actual information from licensed users through realistic spectral occupancy data measured in the GSM bands, the performance of the proposed methodology is validated through three multi-criteria decision-making techniques: Multiplicative Exponential Weighting (MEW), Simple Additive Weighting (SAW), and Multi-Criteria Optimization and Compromise Solution (VIKOR). The results obtained show the outstanding performance of the multicriteria algorithms in decision making and their application in cognitive radio networks, highlighting the high performance of the SAW algorithm in contrast to MEW and VIKOR. The contribution of this work is the use of actual spectral occupancy information captured through a spectral measurement campaign in Bogota, the use of three evaluation metrics in terms of handoff rate, bandwidth, and throughput, as well as a detailed analysis of the results obtained.
Article
Full-text available
Geneticalgorithms(GAs)areapopulation-basedmeta- heuristicglobaloptimizationtechniquefor dealingwithcomplexproblemswithaverylargesearchspace.Thepopulationinitializationisacrucial askinGAsbecauseitplaysavitalroleintheconvergencespeed,problemsearchspaceexploration, andalsothequalityofthefinaloptimalsolution.Thoughtheimportanceofdecidingproblem-specific populationinitializationinGAiswidelyrecognized,itishardlyaddressedintheliterature.Inthis article,differentpopulationseedingtechniquesforpermutation-codedgeneticalgorithmssuchas random,nearestneighbor(NN),genebank(GB),sortedpopulation(SP),andselectiveinitialization (SI),alongwiththreenewlyproposedordered-distance-vector-basedinitializationtechniqueshave beenextensivelystudied.Theabilityofeachpopulationseedingtechniquehasbeenexaminedin termsofasetofperformancecriteria,suchascomputationtime,convergencerate,errorrate,average convergence,convergencediversity,nearest-neighborratio,averagedistinctsolutionsanddistribution ofindividuals.Oneofthefamouscombinatorialhardproblemsofthetravelingsalesmanproblem (TSP)isbeingchosenasthetestbedandtheexperimentsareperformedonlarge-sizedbenchmark TSPinstancesobtainedfromstandardTSPLIB.Thescopeoftheexperimentsinthisarticleislimited totheinitializationphaseoftheGAandthisrestrictedscopehelpstoassesstheperformanceofthe populationseedingtechniquesintheirintendedphasealone.Theexperimentationanalysesarecarried outusingstatisticaltoolstoclaimtheuniqueperformancecharacteristicofeachpopulationseeding techniquesandbestperformingtechniquesareidentifiedbasedontheassessmentcriteriadefined andthenatureoftheapplication.
Article
Full-text available
Increasing demand of bandwidth for new generation mobile user leads the development of 4G and 5G so on. Each of the new architecture finds the better way to use available licensed spectrum and subscribes as much as users. Spectrum reuse and multiple access schemes increased the bandwidth considerable amount for mobile users. But forthcoming generation expectation is increasing rapidly, because of multimedia files sharing, live streaming, fully connected social networking applications. Here, we proposed a novel architecture for next generation cellular network with cognitive radio support. Analyzed the feasibility of proposed architecture and provided a concrete framework for achieving it. Proven that, overall usage of spectrum is increased considerably through that QOS improved well in the architecture.
Article
Full-text available
It is envisaged that in future Cognitive Radio (CR) networks deployment, the multiple radio access networks may coexist. The networks may have different characteristics in terms of multiple attributes. CR will have choices to select the optimal network out of the available networks. The optimal network selection is a challenging task which can be done by spectrum handoff with Multiple Attributes Decision Making (MADM). The spectrum handoff decision with MADM provides wider and optimum choice with quality of service. This motivates to develop the spectrum handoff scheme with MADM methods such as simple additive weighting, technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution, grey relational analysis and cost function based method, which is the objective of this paper. The CR preferences are based on voice, video and data services, called triple play services. The numerical results show that all MADM methods are effective for selecting the optimal network for spectrum handoff with reduced complexity in spectrum handoff decision. The paper shows that the proposed spectrum handoff scheme can be effectively implemented to select optimal network according to triple play services in CR networks.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Abstract - Optimal channel sensing and allocation schemes enable Cognitive Radios (CR) to identify and opportunistically transmit on under-utilized radio frequencies. Intelligent way of channel sensing strategies reflected directly to the major performance factors like end-to-end delay, interference, packet loss ratio and energy consumption. Since most of the CR devices are low power handheld devices, we need simpler and efficient channel sensing strategies. In this paper, improved history based channel sensing problems for multiple cognitive users (CU) networks are effectively modeled through channel deciding factor (CDF) from each available channel. The proposed sensing scheme improves both the misdetection ratio and energy consumption of participating radio devices. Each device in cooperative cognitive radio network decides its next channel by sharing the deciding factors with others; this will extend the sensing space of CR network.
Article
Full-text available
In Cognitive Radio Networks (CRN), one of the well known cooperative spectrum sensing scheme can overcome damaging effects of shadowing and fading. Even though cooperative way of channel sensing and sharing gives better performance, it takes increased amount of energy from all participating nodes in the network. In this paper, we designed an efficient cluster using multilevel-hierarchical and Euclidean-square distance for CRN. Reserved power of each node in the cluster also considered one the deciding factor for node selection, which greatly reduces the unnecessary allocation of resource to nodes which are not capable to sense for others. The proposed clustering model provides an optimal scheme to create cluster with reduced number of message exchange which improves the efficiency in sensing time, fault ratio and energy.
Article
Full-text available
The rapid development of wireless applications leads the scarcity of spectrum space and the current static allocation of spectrum has to be replaced by Opportunistic Spectrum Access (OSA). Various constraints and challenges are to be faced when implementing OSA model in our ongoing wireless networks. Cooperation between Networks nodes present in the OSA environment achieves efficient way of transmission by sharing the channel availability information with others in cognitive radio networks. In this paper, analyzed the various network models, channel selection solutions and challenges for implementing them into real time have been discussed. A Novel Hybrid method for channel selection in cooperative cognitive radio is also been given for the future direction of research in this field.
Article
Spectrum Sensing is playing vital role in Cognitive Radio Networks (CRN). Using cooperative network structure most of the researches had been carried out Channel sensing and proven the better performance than other. In this Energy efficient Sensing, Task assignment and free channel allocation for requested CR’s are mostly varies based on location of CR from Cluster head. Since heterogeneous CR users are participating in the cooperation, their willingness, Battery power, Sensing Accuracy are to be considered for CR’s weight calculation. Otherwise overall sensing results trustworthiness and performance of sensing task may be degraded. Using Multi Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) scheme we have calculated each node weight and given that as input to Multi-level hierarchical clustering technique. Based on the traffic of each blocks, sensing task will be allocated to a cluster. In MCDM, we derived the weight by using combination of MAHP (Modified Analytical Hierarchical Processing) for giving weight for attributes of each CR and VIKOR. Because of considering multiple factors of each CR node, unnecessarily complex sensing task will not be allocated to CR node with lower capability. Similarly, sensing task for channels with predetermined traffic will not be allocated to node with higher capability. Final result shows that increased average lifetime of each participating nodes in the simulation.
Article
In most cases, ELECTRE methods just apply to traditional multicriteria decision making (MCDM) problems with independent criteria. However, there exist more or less interdependences among criteria in actual situations. A special case is MCDM with prioritizations among criteria, called prioritized MCDM. In recent years, how to deal with MCDM problems in the environment of prioritized criteria becomes hot topic increasingly. Lots of existing methods, including PROMETHEE, are modified for the prioritized MCDM, but the advantages of ELECTRE have not been exploited to the prioritized MCDM. In my opinion, design specific ELECTRE methods for prioritized MCDM problems will benefit the developments of both ELECTRE and prioritized MCDM. In this paper, we firstly reformulate the expressions of concordance and discordance indices for use in the MCDM problems with dependent criteria, especially prioritized criteria, based on the concepts of fuzzy measures and digraphs respectively. After replacing the fuzzy measure by a prioritized measure, we successfully validate the concordance of an assertion under prioritized criteria. Furthermore, we design an approach to validate the discordance of the assertion based on a digraph constructed by the criteria and their prioritizations. Finally, we design three procedures to construct outranking relations in the prioritized MCDM environment according to the ideas of ELECTRE-I, ELECTRE-Iv, and ELECTRE-IS respectively. It is meaningful of this paper to provide a new idea to solve the prioritized MCDM problems and widen the application scope of ELECTRE methods by means of the reformulations of concordance and discordance.
Article
In this paper, a collaborative energy-harvesting Cog-nitive Radio (CR) network is considered such that the transmitter of the secondary user (SU) is allowed to harvest signal energy of the Primary User (PU) when presence of PU is detected. The harvested energy is converted to electrical power in order to supply the sensing and transmission energy of SUs. The time frame (time slot) is divided into two phases allocated to sensing (divided into two durations: spectrum sensing and results reporting) and transmission, respectively. The time spanned by the results reporting duration depends on the number of collab-orative sensing users, while the time spent on spectrum sensing duration controls the number of sensing samples. A constrained convex optimization problem of the overall probability of error is formulated incorporating constraints on time and energy resources along with PU interference protection presented as a threshold on probability of collision. We use a soft decision rule scheme while considering two energy harvesting scenarios namely, energy-surplus and energy deficit. In each scenario, the convexity of the optimization problem is established analytically and the global optimal solution is obtained. Simulation results are provided to demonstrate the impact of the different parameters on the overall system performance as well as to verify the deduced analytical results.
Article
In recent years, the employment of multiple criteria decision analysis (MCDA) techniques in solving complex real-world problems has increased exponentially. The willingness to build advanced decision models, with higher capabilities to support decision making in a wide range of applications, promotes the integration of MCDA techniques with efficient systems such as intelligence and expert systems, geographic information systems, etc. Amongst the most applied MCDA techniques are Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS). The development of a comprehensive perspective on research activities associated with the applications of these methods provides insights into the contributions of countries, institutes, authors and journals towards the advancements of these methods. Furthermore, it helps in identifying the status and trends of research. This in turn will help researchers in shaping up and improving future research activities and investments. To meet these aims, a bibliometric analysis based on data harvested from Scopus database was carried out to identify a set of bibliometric performance indicators (i.e. quantitative indicators such as productivity, and qualitative indicators such as citations and Hirsch index (h-index)). Additionally, bibliometric visualization maps were employed to identify the hot spots of research. The total research output was 10,188 documents for AHP and 2412 documents for TOPSIS. China took a leading position in AHP research (3513 documents; 34.5%). It was also the leading country in TOPSIS research (846 documents; 35.1%). The most collaborated country in AHP research was the United States, while in case of TOPSIS it was China. The United States had gained the highest h-index (78) in AHP research, while in TOPSIS it was Taiwan with h-index of 46. Expert Systems with Applications journal was the most productive journal in AHP (204; 2.0%) and TOPSIS research (125; 5.2%), simultaneously. University of Tehran, Iran and Islamic Azad University, Iran were the most productive institutions in AHP (173; 1.7%) and TOPSIS (115; 4.8%) research, simultaneously. The major hot topics that utilized AHP and will continue to be active include different applications of geographic information systems, risk modeling and supply chain management. While for TOPSIS, they are supply chain management and sustainability research. Overall, this analysis has shown increasing recognition of powerful of MCDA techniques to support strategic decisions. The efficacy of these methods in the previous context promotes their progress and advancements.