ArticlePDF Available

Optimizing the Utility of Allium cepa L. var. aggregatum (sibuyas Tagalog) for the Allium Test by Elucidating its Mitotic Periodicity and Rhythmicity Under Varying Light Conditions

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The occurrence of pattern of mitotic activity has long been studied in different plants; in the onion Allium cepa, determination of its mitotic activity has led to its utilization in the Allium test for cytotoxicity and mutagenicity of test substances. In this study, the pattern of mitotic activity of A. cepa var. aggregatum and the effect of light exposure on mitotic activity were determined to test the utility of A. cepa L. var. aggregatum as an alternative to the common onion, A. cepa, for the Allium test. Bulblets of A. cepa var. aggregatum were allowed to root for three days in tap water under three different set-ups: constant light exposure set-up (Light), constant dark set-up (Dark) and 12 hours light-12 hours dark set-up (Light-Dark). The root tips from the bulblets were then excised and subjected to microscopic observation for the mitotic index (MI) every hour after the third day. The results showed no significant difference observed across the three set-ups. However, MI for the Dark and Light set-ups were periodic, showing peaks or maxima of MI falling between 11 AM and 12 PM, whereas that of Light-Dark set-up was rhythmic, having an hourly fluctuation, but also showed maximum between 11 AM and 12 PM. It is recommended that A. cepa var. aggregatum root tips be excised between 11 AM and 12 PM for the Allium test.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Optimizing the utility of allium cepa L. var. aggregatum (sibuyas Tagalog)
43Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Optimizing the Utility of Allium cepa L. var. aggregatum
(sibuyas Tagalog) for the Allium Test by Elucidating its Mitotic
Periodicity and Rhythmicity Under Varying Light Conditions
Ambrocio Melvin A. Matias* and Ian Kendrich C. Fontanilla
Institute of Biology, College of Science, University of the Philippines, Diliman, Quezon City
Telefax: (63-2) 920-5471
*Corresponding author: Email: kelvin4225@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
The occurrence of pattern of mitotic activity has long been studied in different plants; in the onion Allium
cepa, determination of its mitotic activity has led to its utilization in the Allium test for cytotoxicity and
mutagenicity of test substances. In this study, the pattern of mitotic activity of A. cepa var. aggregatum
and the effect of light exposure on mitotic activity were determined to test the utility of A. cepa L. var.
aggregatum as an alternative to the common onion, A. cepa, for the Allium test. Bulblets of A. cepa var.
aggregatum were allowed to root for three days in tap water under three different set-ups: constant light
exposure set-up (Light), constant dark set-up (Dark) and 12 hours light-12 hours dark set-up (Light-Dark).
The root tips from the bulblets were then excised and subjected to microscopic observation for the
mitotic index (MI) every hour after the third day. The results showed no significant difference observed
across the three set-ups. However, MI for the Dark and Light set-ups were periodic, showing peaks or
maxima of MI falling between 11 AM and 12 PM, whereas that of Light-Dark set-up was rhythmic, having
an hourly fluctuation, but also showed maximum between 11 AM and 12 PM. It is recommended that A.
cepa var. aggregatum root tips be excised between 11 AM and 12 PM for the Allium test.
Keywords: Allium cepa var. aggregatum, periodicity, rhythmicity, mitotic index, light, Allium test
Matias, AMA and Fontanilla, IKC
44
INTRODUCTION
The Allium test is widely used as an environmental
monitoring tool due to its ease of use and low cost as
well as high correlation of its results with animal models
(Evandri et al. 2000; Fijesko 1979; Quilang et al. 2008;
Rathore et al. 2006; Vidakoviæ et al. 1993; Yi & Meng
2003). The test took its origin from Levan (1938), who
studied the effects of colchicine on mitosis using Allium
cepa. Since then, A. cepa has been used as a test
organism for cytotoxicity and mutagenicity for
environmental monitoring, which involved exposing the
roots of Allium in a test substance, cutting the root and
observing the root cells under the microscope for mitotic
activity and chromosomal aberrations (Fijesko 1985).
In the Allium test, root tips should be cut during optimal
mitotic activity, which is measured in terms of the
mitotic index or MI (the ratio of observed dividing and
non-dividing cells). Jong (1997) suggested that cutting
should be done during midday (12:00-1:00 PM) based
on previous studies that determined the optimal mitotic
activity of A. cepa. However, studies determining
optimal mitotic activity show inconsistent results (Lewis
1901; Kellicot 1904; Solomon & Trent 1941). Lewis
(1901), using a 4-hour interval set up, showed mitotic
maxima at 12 PM and 12 AM, demonstrating
periodicity, which is characterized by the occurrence
of one or two peaks of high mitotic activity. However,
Winter (1929) argued that Lewis’ results were uniform
rather than showing periodicity as shown by the
comparison of the percentage of dividing cells at
different times. In a similar work by Kellicot (1904)
where the onions were planted in soil and a 2-hour
interval was employed, maxima were achieved at 11
AM and 1 PM. Later on, Solomon & Trent (1941)
observed mitotic activity under varying light conditions
at one-hour intervals. The results showed rhythmicity,
or the occurrence of hourly fluctuations in mitotic
activity, under normal light condition. However,
periodicity was evident in continuous light and
continuous dark set-ups.
Effect of light on mitosis is demonstrated in other
systems (Yeoman & Davidson 1971; Nemota &
Furuya 1985). In Chattonella antiqua (red tide
flagellate), light can induce cell division, but it can also
inhibit division by exposing cells that divide under
continuous light (Nemota & Furuya 1985). In callus
cultures, light tends to have inhibitory effect on cell
division (Yeoman & Davidson 1971; Fraser et al. 1967).
This decreased cell division, resulting to decreased
callus formation, might be due to reduction of some
substance by light (Yeoman & Davidson 1971). It is
currently suggested that cell division is affected by
circadian clock since cell cycle genes, i.e. cyclins and
cyclin-dependent-kinase (CDK), are under circadian
control (Moulager et al. 2007). Thus, alteration of
exposure to light might change patterns of mitotic
activity.
Recent works involving the Allium test include those
of Evandri et al. (2000), which showed that water in
polyethylene bottles could induce cytogenetic
aberration; and Quilang et al. (2008), which
demonstrated the effects of polychlorinated biphenyls
(PCB’s) on Allium root cells. Both studies made use
of the common onion variety of A. cepa, though other
studies also employed other varieties of A. cepa and
even other species. For instance, Yi & Meng (2003)
observed increased anaphase aberration and
micronuclei as well as the presence of pycnotic cells in
root tips of A. sativum (garlic). In another modified
Allium test, Vidakovic (1993) used A. cepa var.
aggregatum (A. ascalonicum in the literature) as test
organism for waste drilling fluid, which promoted
cytotoxicity, particularly inhibition of mitotic activity, in
the onion roots. Allium cepa var. aggregatum, also
known as the bunching onion or locally as “sibuyas
tagalog,” has since been synonymized with A.
ascalonicum (Rabinovitch & Currah 2002). Its utility
by Vidakovic (1993) could attest to its suitability,
perhaps even more so than the common onion variety
of A. cepa since A. cepa var. aggregatum were found
to grow faster and in greater numbers than those of
the common onions based on authors’ personal
observations.
Since different species and varieties are being
employed for the Allium test, there is a need to
ascertain the period of optimal mitotic activity for each
type of Allium other than the common onion variety in
order to optimize the time to cut the root tips. This study
therefore aimed to investigate the periodicity and
rhythmicity of mitotic activity in A. cepa var.
aggregatum root tips. Furthermore, since mitotic
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Optimizing the utility of allium cepa L. var. aggregatum (sibuyas Tagalog)
45
activity is hypothesized to be affected by light, this study
also investigated the effects of varying durations of
light exposure to the periodicity of mitotic activity in A.
cepa var. aggregatum, by measuring the mitotic index
(MI). Other factors that could affect periodicity of
mitotic activity such as hormone activity and
temperature were not considered in this study.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Allium cepa var. aggregatum were purchased from
the local market in San Jose, Nueva Ecija. Scaly leaves
were removed until the bulb leaves were exposed. For
each bulb, only one bulblet was used. Three set-ups
were prepared similar to Solomon & Trent (1941) with
modification of light source: 24 hour light exposure
(Light), 12-hour-light-exposure then 12-hour-dark
exposure (Light-Dark) and no light exposure (Dark).
For each set-up, 18 bulblets were prepared as in Quilang
et al. (2008) in which each was placed on top of a 100
mL glass bottle filled with tap water to expose the
bottom end of the bulblet to water. The Light set up
was exposed to continuous light, the Light-Dark set-up
was alternately exposed to light and placed in a dark
locker every 12 hours (i.e. 7 AM and 7 PM,
respectively), and the Dark set-up was placed in a dark
locker during the entire duration of the experiment. The
Light and Light-Dark set-ups were exposed to light by
placing them in front of fluorescent bulbs; light intensity
ranged from 70 to 171.5 Fcandle and was measured
using an ExTech EA31 Easy ViewTM light meter. Only
18 bulblets were prepared for each set up due to the
limited space on the laboratory bench that allowed
uniform exposure of the set-ups to the light apparatus.
The roots were allowed to grow for three days.
On the 4th day, roots were excised every hour for 24
hours starting at 7 PM until 6 PM the next day. For
every hour, 3 bulblets from each set-up were selected
for root excision. Around 3-5 roots were cut from each
bulblet using a pair of dissecting scissors. Since there
were only 18 bulblets for each set up, each bulblet was
sampled for roots for a total of four times to complete
the hourly sampling over a 24 hour period. All 18
bulblets for each set up were randomly arranged prior
to root excision. The roots were placed into 1.5-ml
microfuge tubes containing Farmer’s solution (1 part
acetic acid, 3 parts ethanol) for fixation, after which
they were stored at 40 C prior to use.
The root tips were prepared for examination through
the squash method following El-Shahaby et al. (2003)
with some modifications. Around 1-3 mm of the root
tip was cut and placed on a glass slide, then exposed to
1 N HCl for 1-2 minutes, after which the HCl was
blotted off using tissue paper. The root tip was then
macerated using the cover slip. Aceto-orcein was added
onto the macerated tissue; after 5-8 minutes, the slide
was passed through a flame to heat-fix the stain on the
tissue. A cover slip was placed on top of the tissue,
and the excess aceto-orcein was blotted off using tissue
paper. The slide was subsequently viewed under a 40x
objective. For each root tip sample, 1000 cells were
scored, taking note at which stage the cell was in:
interphase, prophase, metaphase, anaphase or
telophase. Scoring of cells for all the slides began in
the upper left side of the slide and proceeded through a
convention of moving the slides from left to right until
1000 cells were counted.
The mitotic index (MI) of each root tip sample for every
hour (or the number of mitotic cells over 1000) was
determined. For the determination of periodicity and
rhytmicity, the MI for each hour was plotted. One-
way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was performed
for every hour, comparing the MI of each set-up. For
each hour, there were 3 bulblets, and root tips were
excised from these bulblets. Each root tip cut from a
bublet for every hour was considered as a replicate,
yielding three replicates for each hour.
To determine whether there was difference in the MI
obtained from different treatments (Light set-up, Dark
set-up and Light-Dark set-up), One-way Analysis of
Variance (ANOVA) was employed using Excel 2007.
Prior to ANOVA, data was transformed using arc sin
(Zar 1999). Two trials were done for this experiment.
RESULTS
For Trial 1, the MI obtained from the Dark set-up across
different time intervals were very similar with those of
the Light-set-up, with the curves of the two set-ups
showing a similar pattern (Figure 1). In the Light set-
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Matias, AMA and Fontanilla, IKC
46
up, the maxima MI were observed at 1AM, 12 PM
and 8 PM, with the highest MI value obtained at 12
PM. In the Dark set-up, 11 AM had the highest MI
followed by 12 AM and 8 PM. In both set ups, three
maxima MI were observed: (1) 12 AM to 1 AM; (2) 11
AM to 12 PM; and (3) 8 PM; highest maxima was
obtained at 11 AM to 12 PM. In the Light-Dark set-
up, the maxima MI were at 12 AM, 6 AM and 12 PM;
two of these maxima were within the range of the
maxima MI in the other two set-ups. Unlike the other
two set-ups, however, the MI of Light-Dark set-up
appeared to be fluctuating at an hourly interval
characterized by an increase in one hour followed by a
decrease in the succeeding hour. Furthermore, the MI’s
of Light-Dark set-up were generally lower than in the
other set-ups.
In Trial 2, the Light set-up had maxima MI at 12 AM,
12 PM, and 10 PM with highest maxima at 12 PM;
Dark set-up at 12 AM, 12 PM and 11 PM with highest
at 12 AM; the Light-Dark at 12 AM, 12 PM and 7 PM,
with highest at 12 PM. The Light and Dark set-ups
followed a similar pattern in Trial 1 in terms of the
presence of maxima MI which were distinctly higher
than the other points. In comparison to these two, the
Light-Dark set-up had a fluctuating pattern from 12
AM to 12 PM, but continually decreased at 1 PM to 5
PM and increased at 7 PM then followed a fluctuating
pattern (Figure 2). Based on the plots, Trial 1 and Trial
2 had almost similar results in terms of the patterns.
However, unlike in Trial 1, the MI of Light-Dark set-
up in Trial 2 was relatively high making it similar with
the other two set-ups at 11 AM to 1 PM; hence the
three plots seemed to overlap at this time interval.
In comparing the MI for the three set-ups, a significant
difference based on ANOVA was obtained in Trial 1,
though this was only observed at two time periods, 1
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Figure 1. Plot of Mitotic Index for each hour of the day obtained from the first trial showing periodicity for Dark and Light
while rhythmicity for Light-Dark set-up. Error bar corresponds to standard error.
Optimizing the utility of allium cepa L. var. aggregatum (sibuyas Tagalog)
47
AM and 9 PM, (p= 0.063 and p= 0.036, respectively)
(Table 1). No significant difference was obtained from
Trial 2 based on ANOVA (Table 2).
DISCUSSION
In both trials, the maxima fell in the range of 11 AM to
12 PM and 11 PM to 1 AM, which is in agreement
with previous works on the common onion variety of
A. cepa by Kellicot (1904) and Lewis (1901). These
results agree with those of Solomon and Trent (1941);
however, the maxima for the continuous light differed
slightly, which was observed at 7 AM, 11 AM, 3 PM
and 10 PM. The results for the Dark set-up were similar
with those of Solomon & Trent (1941) except that the
frequency of mitosis in the Dark-set-up in this study
was lower than that obtained from the common onion.
The Light-Dark set-up appeared to have lower MI than
the other two set-ups, particularly in Trial 1. In Trial 2,
the Light-Dark set-up appeared to have a similar MI
value with the other two set-ups. This result, however,
differed with that of Solomon and Trent (1941) in which
the day-night set-up (Light-Dark) had the highest MI
of all the three set-ups. In all set-ups, the frequency of
mitosis was lower than that observed for the common
onion variety by Solomon & Trent (1941).
The intensity of light used in the experiment was 70-
171.5 Fcandle for both trials. This intensity is low
compared to the presumed intensity of light from the
sun (720 – 11000 Fcandle), which was used by Solomon
& Trent (1941) for their Light-Dark set-up. The
disparity in terms of the MI for this study and that of
Solomon & Trent (1941) could be attributed to the
different light intensities.
By definition of periodicity by Solomon & Trent (1941),
which is the occurrence of waves or peaks for the
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Figure 2. Plot of the Mitotic Index for each hour of the day obtained from the second trial showing periodicity for Dark
and Light while rhythmicity for Light-Dark set-up. Error bar corresponds to standard error.
Matias, AMA and Fontanilla, IKC
48
mitotic activity at different times of the day, the MI for
A. cepa var. aggregatum is periodic in both Dark and
Light set-ups. The maxima for both were distinct and
higher than the other points. On the other hand, the MI
of the Light-Dark set-up appeared to be rhythmic,
defined by the occurrence of hourly fluctuations in
mitosis.
In this study, we tested how light could cause these
variations in mitosis. Using ANOVA, it was found that
there was no significant difference between each
treatment for each hour in Trial 2 (Table 2).
Furthermore, the significant difference observed in Trial
1 did not justify the significance of light in defining the
pattern for the mitotic activity, particularly as the
difference occurred only in two time periods, at 1 AM
and at 9 PM (Table 1). The Dark-set up and Light-set
up had almost similar pattern (periodic pattern). This
suggested that alteration of condition (i.e. from light to
dark) affects mitotic activity, thus showing different
 Tr ia l1
 DarksetupLightsetupLig h tDarksetup
TimemeanMISDmeanMISDmeanMISD
12AM0.0270± 0.00100.0210± 0.00000.0247± 0.0042
1AM0 .01 97 ± 0.00800.0240± 0.00360.0117± 0.0006*
2AM0 .01 90 ± 0.00350.0140± 0.00460.0177± 0.0023
3AM0 .01 73 ± 0.00290.0167± 0.00400.0170± 0.0046
4AM0 .01 63 ± 0.00210.0143± 0.00810.0107± 0.0015
5AM0 .01 50 ± 0.00440.0130± 0.00300.0113± 0.0059
6AM0 .01 53 ± 0.00250.0127± 0.00420.0200± 0.0046
7AM0 .01 80 ± 0.00600.0120± 0.00560.0137± 0.0015
8AM0 .01 53 ± 0.01240.0167± 0.00740.0137± 0.0029
9AM0 .01 53 ± 0.00850.0137± 0.00650.0140± 0.0046
10AM0.0173± 0.00810.0173± 0.00670.0170± 0.0053
11AM 0.0333± 0.01600.0173± 0.00420.0150± 0.0046
12PM 0.0197 ± 0.00350.0310± 0.0130 0.0230± 0.0072
1PM0.0160± 0.00350.0217± 0.00840.0140± 0.0035
2PM0.0133± 0.00720.0157± 0.00400.0080± 0.0044
3PM0.0157± 0.00600.0120± 0.00870.0183± 0.0060
4PM0.0120± 0.00100.0167± 0.00550.0090± 0.0030
5PM0.0163± 0.00420.0107± 0.01070.0167± 0.0102
6PM0.0173± 0.01360.0160± 0.00610.0140± 0.0062
7PM0.0187± 0.00290.0183± 0.00590.0110± 0.0035
8PM0.0250± 0.00780.0257± 0.01340.0150± 0.0044
9PM0.0177± 0.00250.0230± 0.00350.0133± 0.0040*
10PM 0.0217 ± 0.00760.0157± 0.0031 0.0173± 0.0006
11PM 0.0167 ± 0.00640.0143± 0.0035 0.0160± 0.0035
* corresponds to set-up in which there is significant difference (á=0.05)
Table 1
The average Mitotic Index for each hour and set-up obtained from Trial 1 starting from 12 AM to 11 PM.
ANOVA was used to determine the difference between each set-up for each hour.
Values expressed as Mean±SD (Standard Deviation)
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Optimizing the utility of allium cepa L. var. aggregatum (sibuyas Tagalog)
49
patterns. Similarly, the effect of light could have been
due to the previous light/dark regime in which cells were
exposed; exposure to light after cell division could
therefore have prevented further divisions (Nemota &
Furuya 1985).
In addition to light, cell division is also regulated by cyclin
and cyclin-dependent-kinase (CDK) proteins, which
increases activity of CDK and release the transcription
factor for genes of DNA replications, respectively.
Moulager et al. (2007) suggested that cyclins and
CDK’s are under circadian control. These proteins, in
turn, are induced by phytohormones, particularly
cytokinin. Cytokinin is said to regulate cell cycle at both
the G1/S phase and G2/M phase progressions (Zhang
et al. 2004). Cytokinin concentrations also vary across
different times of exposure to light (Nova’kova et al.
2005). The role of cylins, CDK’s and cytokinins in the
rate of cell division should therefore not be ruled out.
 Tri al 2
 DarksetupLightsetupLightDarksetup
TimemeanMISDmeanMISDmeanMISD
12AM0 . 02 67 ± 0.00210.0203± 0.0081 0. 0 21 0± 0.0087
1AM0 .01 50 ± 0.00350.0137± 0.00 46 0.0 14 3± 0.0045
2AM0 .01 27 ± 0.00210.0137± 0.00 25 0.0 19 0± 0.0062
3AM0 .01 47 ± 0.00830.0127± 0.00 31 0.0 10 7± 0.0055
4AM0 .01 67 ± 0.00290.0157± 0.01 16 0.0 13 0± 0.0053
5AM0 .01 63 ± 0.00570.0050± 0.00 44 0.0 08 7± 0.0042
6AM0 .01 23 ± 0.00400.0137± 0.00 35 0.0 19 0± 0.0090
7AM0 .01 20 ± 0.00720.0113± 0.00 55 0.0 14 7± 0.0015
8AM0 .00 77 ± 0.00380.0140± 0.00 52 0.0 20 7± 0.0083
9AM0 .00 83 ± 0.00290.0117± 0.00 81 0.0 12 7± 0.0064
10AM0 . 01 47 ± 0.00500.0107± 0.0059 0. 0 21 0± 0.0010
11AM 0 . 01 07 ± 0.00550.0163± 0.0081 0. 0 11 0± 0.0069
12PM 0. 02 30 ± 0.00300.0243± 0.0074 0. 0 23 3± 0.0091
1PM0. 01 33± 0.00930.0133± 0. 00 25 0. 017 0± 0.0082
2PM0. 00 77± 0.00320.0100± 0. 00 46 0. 015 0± 0.0046
3PM0. 01 50± 0.00260.0080± 0. 00 66 0. 011 7± 0.0012
4PM0. 01 50± 0.00350.0070± 0. 00 26 0. 008 7± 0.0035
5PM0. 01 27± 0.00510.0133± 0. 01 03 0. 008 0± 0.0044
6PM0. 01 13± 0.00230.0087± 0. 00 15 0. 011 7± 0.0032
7PM0. 01 30± 0.00260.0180± 0. 00 26 0. 021 0± 0.0104
8PM0. 01 10± 0.00350.0170± 0. 00 26 0. 014 7± 0.0049
9PM0. 01 43± 0.00150.0170± 0. 00 46 0. 017 7± 0.0065
10PM 0. 01 27 ± 0.00150.0183± 0.0040 0. 0 17 7± 0.0015
11PM 0. 02 20 ± 0.00850.0090± 0.0060 0. 0 16 7± 0.0025
No significant difference in all groups (á=0.05)
Table 2
The average Mitotic Index for each hour and set-up obtained from Trial 2 starting from 12 AM to 11 PM.
ANOVA was used to determine the difference between each set-up for each hour.
Values expressed as Mean±SD (Standard Deviation)
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Matias, AMA and Fontanilla, IKC
50
CONCLUSION
Even though it was not shown that light affects the
pattern of mitotic activity, the periodicity and rhythmicity
of mitosis was still evident in the experiment. In this
study, the duration of exposure to light at 70-171.5
Fcandle illumination did not affect the mitotic activity
in the root tips of A. cepa var. aggregatum. However,
a pattern of mitotic activity was still seen, and these
were periodic for the Light and Dark set-ups and
rhythmic for the Light-Dark set-up. The mechanism
causing these patterns is still not clear but is being
suggested to be controlled by the cyclin and CDK
proteins as well as the plant hormone cytokinin.
These observations have practical applications for the
Allium test, particularly in the usage of A. cepa. var.
aggregatum, a close relative of A. cepa, as model
organism. Root excision is suggested to be done around
11 AM – 1PM where MI is highest; this time period
also falls within the range given by Jong (1997) for
root excision of A. cepa.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors wish to thank the Institute of Biology,
particularly the Genetics Research Laboratory, for the
use of equipment and chemicals, and Ms. Erika Alvero,
Dr. Janet Puzon and Dr. Lilian Ungson for their helpful
comments on the study.
REFERENCES
El-Shahaby, O.A., H.M. Abdel Migid, M.I. Soliman and I.A.
Mashaly. 2003. Genotoxicity screening of industrial
wastewater using the Allium cepa chromosome aberration
assay. Pakistan J. Biol. Sci. 6(1): 23-28.
Evandri M. G., P. Tucci, and P. Bolle. 2000. Toxicological
evaluation of commercial mineral water bottled in
polyethylene terephthalate: a cytogenetic approach with
Allium cepa. Food Addit. Contam. 17(12): 1037-1045.
Fijesko G. 1985. The Allium test as a standard in
environmental monitoring. Hereditas 91: 169-178.
Fijesko G.1979. Mercury and selenium in a modified Allium
test. Hereditas 91: 169-178.
Fraser R., U. Loening and M. Yeoman. 1967. Effect of light
on cell division in tissue culture. Nature 215:873.
Jong K. 1997. Laboratory manual of plant cytological
techniques. Edinburgh, Royal Botanic Garden: 97 pp.
Kellicott, W. E. 1904. The daily periodicity of cell division
and of elongation in the root of Allium. Bull. Torr. Bot. Club.
31: 529-550.
Levan A. 1938. The effect of colchicine on root mitoses in
Allium. Hereditas 24: 471-486.
Lewis, A. C. 1901. Contributions to the knowledge of the
physiology of karyokinesis. Bot. Gaz. 32:423-425.
Moulager M., A. Monnier, B. Jesson, R. Bouvet, J. Mosser,
C. Schwartz, L. Garnier, F. Corellou and F. Bouget. 2007. Light-
dependent regulation of cell division in Ostreococcus:
evidence for a major transcriptional input. Plant Physiol.
144:1360-1369.
Nemota Y. and M. Furuya. 1985. Inductive and inhibitory
effects of light on cell division in Chattonella antiqua. Plant
Cell Physiol 26(4):669-674.
Nova’kova, M., V. Motyka, P. Dobrevi, J. Malbecki, A.
Gaudinova’ and R. Vankova. 2005. Diurnal variation of
cytokinin, auxin and abscissic acid levels in tobacco leaves.
J. Exp. Bot. 56(421): 2877-2883.
Quilang J., M de Guzman, M. H. de Hitta-Catalan, R. Rubio,
S. Jacinto, E. Santiago, and E. Cao. 2008. Effects of
polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) on root meristem cells of
common onion (Allium cepa L.) Phil. J. Sci. 137(2): 141-151.
Rabinowitch H.D. and R. Kamensetsky. 2002. Shallot (Allium
cepa, Aggregatum Group). In Rabinowitch, H.D., and L.
Currah (eds). Allium crop sciences: recent advances. UK,
CABI Publishing: 515 pp.
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
Optimizing the utility of allium cepa L. var. aggregatum (sibuyas Tagalog)
51
Rathore H.S., S. Bi, A. Sharma, and M. Makwana. 2006.
Prevention of aluminium Chloride-Induced Mitodepression
with Myrobalan (fruit of Terminalia chebula, Retz,
Combretaceae) in Allium cepa model. Ethnobot. Leaflets
10: 272-279.
Solomon D. and J. Trent. 1941. Preliminary report on
periodicity and rhythmicity of mitotic phases of root tips
under varying light conditions. Trans. Kans. Acad. Sci. 44:
202-207.
Vidakoviæ •., D. Papeš and M. Tomiæ. 1993. Toxicity in
waste drilling fluids in modified Allium test. Water Air Soil
Poll. 69: 413- 423.
Winter J. 1929. Some observations on the rate of mitosis in
root tip meristems of Gladiolus. Trans. Am. Microsc. Soc.
48(3): 276 -291.
Yeoman M. and A. Davidson. 1971. Effect of light on cell
division in developing callus cultures. Ann Bot 35(5):1085-
1100.
Yi, H. and Z. Heng. 2003. Genotoxicity of hydrated sulfur
dioxide on root tips of Allium sativum and Vicia faba. Mut.
Res. 537: 109-114.
Zar J. 1999. Biostatistical Analysis 4th ed. New Jersey, Prentice
Hall: 663 pp.
Zhang K., L. Diederich, and P. John. 2004. The cytokinin
requirement for cell division in cultured Nicotiana
plumbaginifolia cells can be satisfied by yeas Cdc25 protein
tyrosine phosphate. Implications for mechanisims of
cytokinin response and plant development. Plant Physiol.
137:308-316.
Science Diliman (January-June 2011) 23:1, 43-51
... Six replicates were maintained for each set. The duration of each mitotic stage can now be calculated using the following equation [50]: ...
... Mitotic index (MI), duration, and transition of divisional phases are the important features of mitotic fidelity and cellular fitness [50]. Number of dividing cells and rate of cell divisions determine the rate of cell production by a meristem [21]. ...
Article
Full-text available
A Lathyrus sativus L. mutant isolated in ethylmethane sulfonate-treated M2 progeny of mother variety BioL-212 and designated as rlfL-1 was characterized by inwardly rolled-leaf and stem and bud fasciations. The mutant exhibited karyomorphological peculiarities in both mitosis and meiosis with origin of aneuploidy. The mitosis was vigorous with high frequency of divisional cells and their quick turnover presumably steered cell proliferations. Significant transcriptional upregulations of cysteine and glutathione synthesis and concomitant stimulations of glutathione-mediated antioxidant defense helped rlfL-1 mutant to maintain balanced reactive oxygen species (ROS) metabolisms, as deduced by ROS-imaging study. Glutathione synthesis was shut down in buthionine sulfoximine- (BSO-) treated mother plant and mutant, and leaf-rolling and stems/buds fasciations in the mutant were reversed, accompanied by normalization of mitotic cell division process. Antioxidant defense was downregulated under low glutathione-redox but cysteine-desulfurations and photorespiratory glycolate oxidase transcripts were markedly overexpressed, preventing cysteine overaccumulation but resulted in excess H2O2 in BSO-treated mutant. This led to oxidative damage in proliferating cells, manifested by severe necrosis in rolled-leaf and fasciated stems. Results indicated vital role of glutathione in maintaining abnormal proliferations in plant organs, and its deficiency triggered phenotypic reversal through metabolic diversions of cysteine and concomitant cellular and metabolic modulations.
... al. 2003). The cited reasons are the low cost, easy handling, and good correlation with mammalian test systems (Matias and Fontanilla 2011). For example, Rank and Nielsen (1994) showed in a comparative carcinogenicity study in rodents a correlation of 82% with the Allium cepa test. ...
... al. 1994). The result of Allium cepa test highly correlates with the result of cytotoxicity testing using animal models (Matias and Fontanilla 2011;Dalla Nora et. al. 2010). ...
Article
Full-text available
The use of nonprescription or over-the-counter drugs is generally considered safe for the general population. However, establishing safety profile of drugs during pregnancy is complicated by exclusion of pregnant women in pre-marketing clinical trials for medication due to ethical reasons. But there are plant bioassays like the Allium cepa test which can be utilized as an alternative to animal and human studies for an initial safety review assessment. Allium cepa test is an easy, inexpensive and sensitive test for detecting cytotoxicity and mutagenicity. This study utilized the said test to assess the cytotoxicity of selected over-the-counter drugs. Allium cepa test was done in triplicates for each 50 mg drug solutions of Chlorphenamine maleate, Guaifenesin, Ibuprofen, Mefenamic Acid, Magnesium Aluminum Hydroxide or MgAlOH, Omeprazole, and Loperamide and for the non-cytotoxic (distilled water) and cytotoxic (Hydroxyurea) controls. The Mitotic Index (MI) in percentage was determined as a measure of growth inhibition or cytotoxicity. Results showed that Chlorphenamine maleate, MgAlOH, and Omeprazole have similar effects as Hydroxyurea, the cytotoxic control. These over-the-counter drugs are potentially cytotoxic based on Allium cepa test. While Loperamide showed minimal toxicity with its MI value in between the values of Hydroxyurea and distilled water, its use can be considered potentially cytotoxic. These data suggest that the following over-the-counter medications have potential cytotoxicity to humans especially to pregnant women: Omeprazole, Chlorphenamine maleate, MgAlOH, and Loperamide. Guaifenesin, Ibuprofen, and Mefenamic acid showed MI values that were not significantly different from distilled water, which implies that these test substances are non-cytotoxic. This study provides an alternative cytotoxicity assessment of over-the-counter drugs, which may pose potential cytotoxicity in humans, especially to pregnant women who have easy access to OTC drugs and non-human and non-animal models for cytotoxicity assessment of OTC drugs without any ethical issues.
... The root tips were dissected after 96 h at 12 pm. An active mitotic activity period is at 12 am and 12 pm (Rank and Nielsen 1998;Matias and Fontanilla 2011). These root tips were fixed in absolute ethanol:glacial acetic acids (3:1 v/v) for 48 h in incubator. ...
Article
Full-text available
Allium cepa assay was carried out in this study to evaluate genotoxic effects of raw and treated water samples from Perak River in Perak state, Malaysia. Samples were collected from three surface water treatment plants along the river, namely WTPP, WTPS, and WTPK. Initially, triplicates of equal size Allium cepa (onions) bulbs, 25-30 mm in diameter and average weight of 20 g, were set up in distilled water for 24 h at 20 ± 2 °C and protected from direct sunlight, to let the roots to grow. After germination of roots (0.5-1.0 cm in length), bulbs were transferred to collected water samples each for a 96-h period of exposure. The root physical deformations were observed. Genotoxicity quantification was based on mitotic index and genotoxicity level. Statistical analysis using cross-correlation function for replicates from treated water showed that root length has inverse correlation with mitotic indices (r = - 0.969) and frequencies of cell aberrations (r = - 0.976) at lag 1. Mitotic indices and cell aberrations of replicates from raw water have shown positive correlation at lag 1 (r = 0.946). Genotoxicity levels obtained were 23.4 ± 1.98 (WTPP), 26.68 ± 0.34 (WTPS), and 30.4 ± 1.13 (WTPK) for treated water and 17.8 ± 0.18 (WTPP), 37.15 ± 0.17 (WTPS), and 47.2 ± 0.48 (WTPK) for raw water. The observed cell aberrations were adherence, chromosome delay, C-metaphase, chromosome loss, chromosome bridge, chromosome breaks, binucleated cell, mini cell, and lobulated nuclei. The morphogenetic deformations obtained were likely due to genotoxic substances presence in collected water samples. Thus, water treatment in Malaysia does not remove genotoxic compounds.
... The cell division cycle can be delineated into major phases G 1 , S, G 2 and M phase. Cell division manifests in a periodic manner during 24h period [26][27][28][29][30][31]. A double rhythm was found in roots of Allium cepa grown under room condition in moist sawdust 32 . ...
Article
Full-text available
Atenolol, an adrenergic beta blocker, commonly employed in the management of cardiovascular diseases, has been evaluated for its cytotoxicity using Allium cepa. L assay system. Four different treatments, 2 spurt treatments (T1 & T3) of 2h duration each varying at time points of cell division cycle (6AM to 8AM and 11AM to 1PM), T2 of 3h duration (8AM to 11AM), and T4 of 17h duration (approximately for one cell cycle), were given with 10µg/ml Atenolol to the root meristems of A.cepa and were observed for their recovery for 72h with 24h intervals. All the treatments induced wide range of aberrations including disturbed meta-anaphases, chromosome breaks, bridges, and stickiness. The 0h of T2, 48h of T1, 72h of T1 and T4 showed significant decrease in cell division. Differential response to the drug toxicity and significant decrease in cell division indicates the possibility of Atenolol affecting mechanisms that ensure DNA stability and the cell cycle progression. In view of the wide spread use of the drug in the management of cardiovascular diseases and chronic hypertension, more intensive studies employing mammalian and submammalian assay systems are needed.
Article
Full-text available
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) are chemical mixtures that are common environmental pollutants and considered potential carcinogens. In this study, the common onion, Allium cepa, was used to determine the cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of a mixture of PCBs at three concentrations, namely, 10 nM, 100 nM, and 1000 nM. Distilled deionized water and 0.2% dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) were used as negative controls. Cytotoxicity was observed at the three concentrations tested as shown by a significant reduction in average mitotic indices. Chromosomal aberrations were also observed, which is suggestive of the genotoxicity of these pollutants. The effects of PCBs on the early life stages of zebrafish, Danio rerio, were also investigated. The three levels of PCBs were tested including the embryo medium, 0.2% DMSO, and 2% ethanol that served as controls. Embryos at 6 – 8 hours postfertilization were exposed to the different treatments and were observed everyday for 5 days. Results showed a significant decrease in the mean number of melanocytes and average length at 5 days postfertilization, a delay in hatching of embryos, and a significant increase in average percent of fish with deformities for the 1000 nM PCB concentration. This study demonstrates that the Allium test is a simple and reliable method to assess cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of PCBs. Exposure of zebrafish embryos to high concentrations of PCBs also delays growth and hatching rates and causes teratogenic effects. These results may have implications on the health of humans and other organisms at risk to PCB exposures as these chemicals are known to bioaccumulate.
Chapter
This multiauthor book contains 19 sections discussing the evolution and taxonomy, genetic diversity, domestication, genetic transformation, breeding, agronomy, pre- and postharvest treatments, storage, diseases, pests, onion cultivation in the tropics (including country reports), sulfur compounds and flavour, and ornamental and medicinal uses of Allium spp., particularly garlic, onions, leeks and shallots. It will be of value to those interested in the biological aspects of alliums, including scientists and field experts.
Article
A modified Allium test is presented implying that from the start of the experiment series of onions are grown in the different liquids to be tested - without first letting the root tips sprout in pure water. For screening purposes, macroscopical observations after two days of treatment, documented with photographic evidence of the degree of growth retardation or stimulation, will often suffice. For specific purposes, these observations should be supplemented by microscopic analysis, as has been done in the present work. The two procedures of the Allium test were compared: The new version, with longer time of treatment, seemed to be a little more sensitive than the original method. The specific aim of this study was to investigate whether sodium selenite has any effect antagonistic to methylmercury chloride poisoning, as has been reported in certain animal materials. No such effect was observed in the present experiments.
Article
The toxicity of four waste water samples from reserve pit upon the root-tip cells of Allium ascalonicum L. was researched by applying modified Allium test. The samples were a mixture of substances and their chemical composition was only partly known. The first task was to find out the optimal duration for root-tips treatment. The treatment lasting 48 h has been accepted because it enables delivery of results only four days after the sample has been received. All undiluted four waste drilling fluid samples showed cytotoxicity as well as toxicity, which was proved by cytogenetic parameters such as high inhibition of mitotic activity or low mitotic index and high percentage of chromosomal and genomic aberrations. The toxicity was significantly reduced by increasing the degree of sample dilutions. The results of this investigation demonstrated that the modified Allium test could be easily used for detection of waste drilling fluids toxicity degree.