Content uploaded by Hoan Ngoc Doan
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Hoan Ngoc Doan on May 11, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
UNCORRECTED PROOF
#EKHD7BE<DL?HEDC;DJ7B>;C?97BD=?D;;H?D= NNN NNNN NNNNNN
EDJ;DJIB?IJI7L7?B78B;7J,9?;D9;?H;9J
#EKHD7BE<DL?HEDC;DJ7B>;C?97BD=?D;;H?D=
@EKHD7B>EC;F7=;MMM;BI;L?;H9EC
+;9O9B;: )- 7I 7 )&,KD9J?ED7B?P;: ;B;9JHEIFKD ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; <EH E?BM7J;H
I;F7H7J?ED
!E7D '=E9 E7D a7 )>K )>ED= /E a7 $E>;? !7O7I>? a8 $;D@? $?D7I>? a9a ⁎ 07J7HK ,7A7? a9 '7EJE -IKJIKC? a9
7Doctor’s Program of Materials Chemistry, Graduate School of Science and Technology, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Matsugasaki, Sakyo, Kyoto 606-8585, Japan
8Master's Program of Innovative Materials, Graduate School of Science and Technology, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Matsugasaki, Sakyo, Kyoto 606-8585, Japan
9Faculty of Materials Science and Engineering, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Matsugasaki, Sakyo, Kyoto 606-8585, Japan
+-"% "'(
:?JEH 2KD>E %;;
Keywords:
B;9JHEIF?DD?D=
)EBO;J>OB;D; J;H;F>J>7B7J;
)EBO:?C;J>OBI?BEN7D;
07IJ; H;9O9B?D=
(?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED
,-+-
"D H;9;DJ O;7HI BEM9EIJ 7D: ;<<;9J?L; J;9>DEBE=?;I <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED >7L; 8;;D >?=>BO :;I?H;: :K; JE 7D
?D9H;7I; E< E?BO M7IJ;M7J;H 7D: <H;GK;DJ E?B IF?BB 799?:;DJI ->?I IJK:O :;CEDIJH7J;I 7 9EIJ;<<;9J?L; 7D: IKI
J7?D78B; FH;F7H7J?ED E< ^;N?8B; ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I M?J> >?=> E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; KI?D= H;9O9B;:
FEBO;J>OB;D; J;H;F>J>7B7J; H)- ->; H)- ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; M7I FH;F7H;: L?7 ;B;9JHEIF?DD?D= ?D J>; <EBBEM
?D= IJ;F J>; H)- C;C8H7D; M7I :?F9E7J;: M?J> FEBO:?C;J>OBI?BEN7D; )&, JE ?CFHEL; J>; M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED
FH;IIKH; 7D: 7DJ?M7J;H<EKB?D= FHEF;HJO E< J>; H)- ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; ->; ;<<;9J E< )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED ED J>;
C;C8H7D; CEHF>EBE=O IKH<79; 9>;C?IJHO J>;HC7B 7D: C;9>7D?97B FHEF;HJ?;I IKH<79; M;JJ78?B?JO 7D: E?BM7J;H
I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; M7I ;L7BK7J;: ->; C;C8H7D;I 7H; IKF;HEB;EF>?B?9 M?J> 7D E?B 9EDJ79J 7D=B; E< X 7D:
;N>?8?J ;N9;BB;DJ 7DJ?M7J;H<EKB?D= FHEF;HJ?;I ->; )&,<KD9J?ED7B?P;: H)- C;C8H7D;I 97D ;<<;9J?L;BO I;F7
H7J; L7H?EKI E?BM7J;H C?NJKH;I :H?L;D 8O =H7L?JO M?J> 7 >?=> ^KN ∼ % Ca−>a 7D: 7 >?=> I;F7H7J?ED
;<]9?;D9O <EH KF JE J;D 9O9B;I 7D: J>KI >7I FEJ;DJ?7B ?D:KIJH?7B 7FFB?97J?ED
1. Introduction
(?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED >7I H;9;DJBO 7JJH79J;: CK9> 7JJ;DJ?ED :K; JE
7D ?D9H;7I; E< M7IJ; <HEC J>; E?B ?D:KIJHO 7D: J>; E99KHH;D9; E< E?B
IF?BBI M>?9> >7I 97KI;: 7:L;HI; ?CF79JI JE 8EJ> J>; ;9EIOIJ;C 7D: >K
C7D 8;?D=I 45 +;9;DJBO =H;7J ;<<EHJI >7L; 8;;D :;LEJ;: JE :;L;BEF
?D= ;<]9?;DJ E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED J;9>D?GK;I <EH E?BO M7IJ;M7J;H JH;7J
C;DJ ?D9BK:?D= :?IF;HI7DJI 45 7:IEHFJ?ED 4–5 8KHD?D= 45 IA?C
C;HI 45 7D: C;C8H7D; I;F7H7J?ED 45 CED= J>;I; J;9>D?GK;I ]
8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED <78H?97J;: 8O ;B;9JHEIF?D
D?D= 7H; ;C;H=?D= 7I =EE: 97D:?:7J;I :K; JE J>;?H >?=> ^;N?8?B?JO
7D: >?=> I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; 4–5 /7H?EKI FEBOC;HI IK9> 7I
FEBOL?DOB?:;D; ^KEH?:; 45 FEBO?C?:; 45 FEBOKH;J>7D; 45
FEBOε97FHEB79JED; 45 FEBOB79J?:; 45 7D: FEBOIKB<ED7C?:;FEBO
79HOBED?JH?B; 45 >7L; 8;;D M?:;BO KI;: <EH FH;F7H?D= ^;N?8B; ;B;9
JHEIFKD ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED !EM;L;H J>; 9EIJ
E< FHE:K9?D= J>;I; C;C8H7D;I ?I DEJ 7BM7OI ;9EDEC?97BBO L?78B; 8;
97KI; J>;I; L?H=?D FEBOC;HI >7L; 7 >?=> 7D: IJ78B; 9EIJ ->; C7J;H?
7BI KI;: ?D J>; FH;L?EKI IJK:?;I M;H; L?H=?D FEBOC;HI M>?9> 9EKB: B;7:
JE 7DEJ>;H ;DL?HEDC;DJ7B ?IIK; 45 0?J> 7D ?D9H;7I?D= B;L;B E< 7JJ;D
J?ED <E9KI;: ED FH;I;HL?D= J>; ;DL?HEDC;DJ J>; :;L;BEFC;DJ E< 9EIJ;<
<;9J?L; ;<]9?;DJ 7D: IKIJ7?D78B; C;J>E:I JE I;F7H7J; 7D: H;9O9B;
E?BM7J;H IJH;7CI ?I IJ?BB >?=>BO ?D :;C7D: )H;L?EKI IJK:?;I I>EM;: J>7J
KI?D= M7IJ; FEBOC;HI 87I; ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; <EH M7J;HE?B I;F7H7J?ED ?I
J>; FHEC?I?D= 7FFHE79> ,EM ;J 7B <78H?97J;: M7IJ; FEBOIJOH;D; ]8;HI
8O IEBKJ?ED 8BEM IF?DD?D= 7D: IK99;II<KBBO 7FFB?;: J>;C JEM7H:I E?BM7
J;H I;F7H7J?ED 45 "D 7::?J?ED ;B;9JHEIFKD C;C8H7D;I <78H?97J;: <HEC
M7IJ; 9?=7H;JJ; <EH 7FFB?97J?ED ED E?BM7J;H C?NJKH; 7D: ;CKBI?EDI I;F
7H7J?ED M;H; FHE:K9;: 8O %?K 7D: 9EMEHA;H 45
"D 7::?J?ED JE E?B IF?BB FEBBKJ?ED FB7IJ?9 8EJJB; M7IJ; ?I 7 I;H?EKI
9ED9;HD <EH J>; E9;7D &EIJ FB7IJ?9 8EJJB;I 7H; C7:; <HEC FEBO;J>OB
;D; J;H;F>J>7B7J; )- 7 IODJ>;J?9 FEBOC;H M?J> >?=> ;DL?HEDC;D
J7B H;I?IJ7D9; J>7J ?I IJ?BB 8;?D= KI;: <EH M7J;H 7D: IE<J :H?DAI ->;H;
<EH; J>; :?I97H:;: )- 8EJJB;I 7H; H;I?IJ7DJ JE :;9ECFEI?D= D7JKH7BBO
?D J>; E9;7D :K; JE J>;?H :KH78?B?JO 7D: 7I 7 H;IKBJ J>?I FHE8B;C 7BIE
B;7:I JE I;L;H; ;DL?HEDC;DJ7B FEBBKJ?ED 45 EH J>?I H;7IED M7IJ;
C7D7=;C;DJ 7D: H;9O9B?D= J;9>DEBE=O <EH )- 8EJJB;I ?I 7D ?CFEH
J7DJ H;I;7H9> ];B: <EH ;DL?HEDC;DJ7B 9EDI;HL7J?ED 45 ->; FHE]J
?DLEBL;: ?D H;9O9B;: )- H)- FHE:K9J?ED ?I H;B7J?L;BO BEM 8;97KI;
J>; H)- 8EJJB;I 7H; C7?DBO H;9O9B;: JE C7A; BEM9EIJ FHE:K9JI IK9>
7I I>;;JI IJ7J?ED;HO 7D: :;J;H=;DJ 8EJJB;I ->;H;<EH; J>;H; ?I 7 :;
⁎EHH;IFED:?D= 7KJ>EH
Email address: A?D7I>?A?J79@F $ $?D7I>?
>JJFI:E?EH=@@;9;
+;9;?L;: #7DK7HO+;9;?L;:?DH;L?I;:<EHC &7H9>99;FJ;: &7H9>
L7?B78B;EDB?D; NNN
Y
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
C7D: <EH 7 C;J>E: 8O M>?9> JE C7A; L7BK;7::;: H)- FHE:K9JI J>7J
E_I;J J>; 9EIJ E< H;9O9B?D= 7D: ;D9EKH7=; J>; 9EBB;9J?ED E< )- 8EJ
JB; M7IJ; FFBO?D= H)- ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I JE 7D E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED
FHE9;II 97D 8; 7D 7BJ;HD7J?L; JE KI?D= 7 L?H=?D FEBOC;H 7I ;B;9JHEIF?D
D?D= M7IJ; )- <EH 7 9EIJ H;:K9J?ED 97D 8; ;NF;9J;: JE 8; 7 FEM;H<KB
H;9O9B?D= C;J>E: <EH 7 IKIJ7?D78B; IE9?;JO KHJ>;HCEH; KI?D= H)- 7I
7 I;F7H7J?ED C;C8H7D; 9EKB: B;7: JE 7DEJ>;H ;DL?HEDC;DJ7B 8;D;]J 8;
97KI; ?J 97D H;:K9; J>; H;B;7I;: E< J>; FB7IJ?9 JE J>; ;DL?HEDC;DJ +;
9;DJBO 7 DKC8;H E< IJK:?;I >7L; ;N7C?D;: J>; FHE:K9J?ED E< ;B;9JHE
IFKD H)- D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH ]BJH7J?ED EF;H7J?EDI ,JH7?D ;J 7B
<78H?97J;: 7 JEK=> D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <HEC H)-&- IEBK
J?EDI <EH ICEA; ]BJH7J?ED 45 D 7DJ?C?9HE8?7B H)- D7DE]8HEKI C;C
8H7D; KI;: <EH M7J;H ]BJH7J?ED M7I 7BIE FHE:K9;: 8O 37D:;H ;J 7B 45
!EM;L;H J>; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; E< J>; ;B;9JHEIFKD H)-
>7I DEJ O;J 8;;D H;FEHJ;: ?D J>; B?J;H7JKH;
"D J>?I IJK:O M; ?DJHE:K9; 7 <79?B; 7D: IKIJ7?D78B; J;9>DEBE=O JE
FHE:K9; 7 IKF;HEB;EF>?B?9 7D: KD:;HE?B IKF;H>O:HEF>E8?9 C;C8H7D;
KI?D= H)- <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED ->; H)- C;C8H7D;I M;H; <78
H?97J;: <HEC H)-&- IEBKJ?EDI ->; KI;: IEBL;DJI 97D 8; 9EB
B;9J;: KI?D= 7 L7FEH 9ED:;DI7J?ED IOIJ;C 7D: 97D 8; H;9O9B;: ?D EH:;H
JE H;:K9; J>; H;B;7I; E< IEBL;DJI JE J>; ;DL?HEDC;DJ M>?9> C7A;I J>;
FHE:K9J CEH; 9EIJ ;<<;9J?L; 7D: ;DL?HEDC;DJ<H?;D:BO K; JE J>; 9>;C
?97B FHEF;HJ?;I E< )- J>; 7IIFKD H)- C;C8H7D; I>EMI 7 BEM M7J;H
?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; 7D: 7 B79A E< 7DJ?M7J;H <EKB?D= M>?9> 7H; L;HO ?C
FEHJ7DJ <EH 7 C;C8H7D; KI;: <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED ->; 7IIFKD H)-
]8HEKI C;C8H7D; M7I :?F9E7J;: M?J> FEBO:?C;J>OBI?BEN7D; )&,
M>?9> >7I 7 BEM IKH<79; ;D;H=O FHEF;HJO ;D>7D9?D= J>; 7DJ?M7J;H <EKB
?D= FHEF;HJ?;I 7D: EL;H9EC?D= J>; 78EL; M;7AD;II;I ->; M;JJ78?B?JO
7D: M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; E< J>; H)- ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; 97D 8; C7
D?FKB7J;: 8O 9EDJHEBB?D= J>; 7CEKDJ E< )&, ?D J>; :?FF?D= IEBKJ?ED
->; ;<<;9JI E< )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED ED CEHF>EBE=O 7D: IJHK9JKH; 9>;C
?97B 9ECFEI?J?ED E< J>; C;C8H7D; IKH<79; J>;HC7B FHEF;HJ?;I C;9>7D
?97B FHEF;HJ?;I 7D: E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; M;H; ?DL;IJ?=7J;:
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Materials
+;9O9B;: )- F;BB;JI <HEC FEIJ9EDIKC;H )- M7J;H 8EJJB;I
+– M;H; A?D:BO FHEL?:;: 8O H $7PKI>? 27C7:7 :L7D9;:
?8HE,9?;D9; $OEJE "DIJ?JKJ; E< -;9>DEBE=O $OEJE #7F7D -H?^KE
HE79;J?9 79?: - :?9>BEHEC;J>7D; & >;N7D; ;J>OB;D; J;JH7
9>BEH?:; 97H8ED J;JH79>BEH?:; 7D: 8HECE8;DP;D; M;H; FKH9>7I;: <HEC
07AE E (I7A7 #7F7D )&, FH;FEBOC;H 7D: 9HEIIB?DA;H ,OB=7H:
M;H; C7DK<79JKH;: 8O EM EHD?D= E ., BB E< J>; 9>;C?97BI
M;H; KI;: 7I H;9;?L;: M?J>EKJ <KHJ>;H FKH?]97J?ED
2.2. Electrospinning
D H)- IEBKJ?ED M?J> 7 9ED9;DJH7J?ED E< MJ M7I FH;F7H;:
8O :?IIEBL?D= H)- F;BB;JI ?D 7 IEBL;DJ C?NJKH; E< JH?^KEHE79;J?9 79?:
- 7D: :?9>BEHEC;J>7D; & MM ->; IEBKJ?ED M7I C?N;:
<EH C?D KI?D= 7 FB7D;J7HO 9;DJH?<K=7B C?N;H + ->?DAO E
-EAOE #7F7D 7J HFC 7D: J>;D :;=7II;: 7J HFC <EH I ->;
FH;F7H;: IEBKJ?EDI M;H; A;FJ ?D 7 9EDIJ7DJJ;CF;H7JKH; I>7A;H &&,
O;B7 E #7F7D 7J X JE E8J7?D >ECE=;D;EKI IEBKJ?EDI ->; H)-
D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I M;H; FH;F7H;: KI?D= 7 8K?B:KF ;B;9JHEIF?D
D?D= IOIJ;C E< EKH EMD :;I?=D KH?D= J>; ;B;9JHEIF?DD?D= FHE9;II J>;
<;;: H7J; E< J>; H)- IEBKJ?ED M7I A;FJ 7J C% >a−8O 7 IOH?D=;
FKCF $, $ ,9?;DJ?]9 "D9 &7II79>KI;JJI ., >?=> LEBJ
7=; E< A/ =;D;H7J;: <HEC 7 >?=> LEBJ7=; FEM;H IKFFBO !/.)
& E #7F7D M7I 7FFB?;: JE 7 D;;:B; M?J> 7D ?DD;H :?7C
;J;H E< CC ->; :?IJ7D9; 8;JM;;D J>; D;;:B; 7D: ]8;H 9EBB;9
JEH M7I ]N;: 7J 9C HEJ7J?D= :HKC 9EL;H;: 8O 7 IJ7?DB;IIIJ;;B
C;I> 'E M7I KI;: 7I 7 ]8;H 9EBB;9JEH M?J> 7 9EDIJ7DJ HEBB?D=
IF;;: E< HFC ->; H;B7J?L; >KC?:?JO 7D: J;CF;H7JKH; E< Z
7D: Z X H;IF;9J?L;BO M7I C7?DJ7?D;: 8O CED?JEH?D= M?J> 7 >O
=HEJ>;HCE=H7F> FB79;: ?DI?:; J>; ;B;9JHEIF?DD?D= 9>7C8;H ->; H;IKBJ
?D= ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I M;H; FB79;: ?D 7 L79KKC EL;D <EH > 7J X JE
H;CEL; 7DO H;J7?D;: IEBL;DJI
2.3. PDMS modi=cation
)EBO:?C;J>OBI?BEN7D; )&,<KD9J?ED7B?P;: H)- C;C8H7D;I
H)-)&, M;H; FH;F7H;: KI?D= 7 :?F9E7J?D= C;J>E: )&, FH;
FEBOC;H M7I 8B;D:;: M?J> 7 9HEIIB?DA;H 7J 7 9EDIJ7DJ M;?=>J H7J?E E<
->; 7IFH;F7H;: H)- C;C8H7D;I M;H; 9KJ ?DJE 7 HEKD: I>7F;
M?J> 7 :?7C;J;H E< CC 7D: M;H; ?CC;HI;: ?D 7 )&,>;N7D; IE
BKJ?ED M?J> L7HO?D= )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI 7D: MJ 7J X
<EH > <J;H J>; :?F9E7J?D= FHE9;II J>; 7H9>?L;: ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;
M7I :H?;: <EH > ?D 7 L79KKC EL;D 7J X ->; E8J7?D;: C;C8H7D;I
M;H; :;DEJ;: 7I H)-)&,6 H)-)&,6 H)-)&,6 7D:
H)-)&,6 H;IF;9J?L;BO
2.4. Membrane characterization
&EHF>EBE=O 7D: ;D;H=O :?IF;HI?L; 1H7O IF;9JHEC;JHO 1 <EH J>;
C;C8H7D;I M;H; IJK:?;: 8O 7 ];B:;C?II?ED I97DD?D= ;B;9JHED C?9HE
I9EF; ,& #(% #(% %J: #7F7D ;GK?FF;: M?J> 7D (N
<EH: ;D;H=O :?IF;HI?L; 1H7O IF;9JHEC;J;H ->; C;C8H7D;I M;H; IFKJ
J;H9E7J;: M?J> 7 DC J>?9A B7O;H E< F7BB7:?KC 7D: E8I;HL;: KI?D=
,& 7J 7D 799;B;H7J?D= LEBJ7=; E< A/ ?8;H :?7C;J;HI M;H; 7D7
BOP;: KI?D= ,& ?C7=;I 7D: ?C7=; FHE9;II?D= IE<JM7H; "C7=;# ->;
IKH<79; HEK=>D;II E< J>; C;C8H7D;I M7I :;J;HC?D;: KI?D= 7 DED9ED
J79J B7I;H FHE]BEC;JHO 7D7BOI?I C;J>E: CEKDJ;: ED 7 B7I;H I97D
D?D= C?9HEI9EF; /$ $;O;D9; E #7F7D "+ IF;9JH7 E< J>; C;C
8H7D;I M;H; H;9EH:;: KI?D= 7D -"+ IF;9JHEF>EJEC;J;H -"+
#7I9E E #7F7D M?J> 7 KD?L;HI7B 7JJ;DK7J;: JEJ7B H;^;9J7D9; 799;I
IEHO -+ )+( (' ;GK?FF;: M?J> 7 :?7CED: FH?IC #7I9E E #7F7D
->; 9>;C?97B 9ECFEI?J?EDI E< J>; C;C8H7D; IKH<79;I M;H; ?DL;IJ?
=7J;: KI?D= 7D 1H7O F>EJE;B;9JHED IF;9JHEC;J;H #(% #(% E
#7F7D EDJ79J 7D=B; 7D7BOI?I M7I 9ED:K9J;: KI?D= 7 )>E;D?N 9ED
J79J7D=B; IOIJ;C $HECJ;A E &7B7OI?7 7J X 7D: J>; E8J7?D;:
?C7=;I M;H; 7D7BOP;: M?J> 7D7BOI?I IE<JM7H; "C7=;# EH J>; 7D7BO
I?I J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I M;H; FB79;: ED 7 =B7II IK8IJH7J; M7
J;H M7I KI;: <EH J>; M7J;H 9EDJ79J 7D=B; 0 7D: >;N7D; M7I KI;:
<EH J>; E?B 9EDJ79J 7D=B; &;7IKH;C;DJI M;H; 97HH?;: EKJ ED J>; C;C
8H7D; IKH<79;I 7J HEEC J;CF;H7JKH; ?D 7D EF;D;: 9>7C8;H ->; LEB
KC; E< J>; I;II?B; :HEF M7I C7?DJ7?D;: 7J μ% ->; I7CFB; C;C8H7D;I
M;H; FB79;: ?D 7 >;N7D; 87J> :KH?D= 9EDJ79J 7D=B; C;7IKH;C;DJ JE
;L7BK7J; J>; KD:;HE?B >O:HEF>E8?9?JO ->; 7L;H7=; 9EDJ79J 7D=B; L7B
K;I M;H; E8J7?D;: 8O C;7IKH?D= 7J B;7IJ ]L; :?<<;H;DJ C;7IKH;C;DJ
FE?DJI 79HEII J>; I7CFB; IKH<79; ->; M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; L7BK; M7I
C;7IKH;: 8O 7 >EC;C7:; J;IJ?D= IOIJ;C E< EKH EMD :;I?=D 7I I>EMD
?D ?= , ->; J>;HC7B FHEF;HJ?;I E< J>; H;IKBJ?D= ]8;HI M;H; IJK:
?;: KI?D= :?<<;H;DJ?7B I97DD?D= 97BEH?C;JHO , ->;HCE=H7CI M;H;
E8J7?D;: KI?D= 7 - "DIJHKC;DJI * 97BEH?C;J;H - "DIJHKC;DJI
#7F7D "D9 -EAOE #7F7D M?J> 7 >;7J?D= H7J; E< X C?Da−?D 7 D?
JHE=;D 7JCEIF>;H; ->; J>;HCE=H7L?C;JH?9 7D7BOI?I - 9KHL;I 7D:
J>; ]HIJ :;H?L7J?L; E< J>; - 9KHL; :?<<;H;DJ?7B J>;HCE=H7L?C;JH?9
- 9KHL; M;H; E8J7?D;: 8O 7 - C79>?D; ?I9EL;HO - -
"DIJHKC;DJI M?J> 7 >;7J?D= H7J; E< X C?Da−?D 7 D?JHE=;D 7JCEI
F>;H; ->; C;9>7D?97B FHEF;HJ?;I E< J>; I7CFB;I M;H; 9>7H79J;H?P;:
KI?D= 7 KD?L;HI7B J;DI?B; J;IJ?D= C79>?D; -',"%(' +-–
E #7F7D 9HEII>;7: IF;;: CC C?Da− BE7: 9;BB ' ->; ]
8HEKI I7CFB;I M;H; 9KJ EKJ ?D J>; <EHC E< C?D?7JKH?P;: :E= 8ED;I>7F;:
IF;9?C;DI JOF; ?D , ",( KI?D= 7 9KJJ?D=
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
8B7:; ->;D J>; IF;9?C;DI M;H; CEKDJ;: EDJE 7 F7F;H <H7C; KI?D=
:EK8B;I?:;: J7F; ->; J>?9AD;II E< J>; J;IJ?D= IF;9?C;D M7I C;7IKH;:
KI?D= 7 C?9HEC;J;H I9H;M =7K=; &?JKJEOE − &?JKJEOE #7F7D
-;DI?B; J;IJI M;H; F;H<EHC;: ?D 7D 7JCEIF>;H; M?J> 7 J;CF;H7JKH; 7D:
H;B7J?L; >KC?:?JO E< Z X 7D: Z H;IF;9J?L;BO ->; J;IJI M;H;
F;H<EHC;: KI?D= 7J B;7IJ ]L; IF;9?C;DI <EH ;79> ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;
2.5. Oil-water separation experiment
->; I;F7H7J?ED ;NF;H?C;DJI M;H; F;H<EHC;: KI?D= 7 :;7:;D: ]BJH7
J?ED 7FF7H7JKI ->; E8J7?D;: CE:?];: H)-)&, C;C8H7D; M7I 9KJ
?D 7 HEKD: I>7F; M?J> 7 :?7C;J;H E< CC 7D: J>;D ]N;: 8;JM;;D J>;
]BJ;H >EB:;H $ , :L7DJ;9 E #7F7D M?J> 7 IJ7?DB;IIIJ;;B IKF
FEHJ;H ;<EH; 9ED:K9J?D= J>; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED J>; C;C8H7D;I M;H;
FH;M;JJ;: M?J> J>; 9EHH;IFED:?D= E?B ,;F7H7J?ED J;IJI M;H; 9ED:K9J;:
8O FEKH?D= C% E< J>; E?B M7J;H C?NJKH; LEBKC; H7J?E ?DJE J>;
KFF;H JK8; 7D: J>; E?B M7I 9EBB;9J;: ?D 7 8;7A;H 7J J>; 8EJJEC E< J>;
]BJ;H >EB:;H ->; ^KN J>HEK=> J>; C;C8H7D; M7I 97B9KB7J;: KI?D= J>;
<EBBEM?D= ;GK7J?ED
M>;H; F?I J>; ^KN V?I J>; LEBKC; E< J>; F;HC;7J; E?B J>HEK=> J>;
C;C8H7D; :KH?D= J?C; t 7D: A?I J>; ;<<;9J?L; 9EDJ79J 7H;7 E< J>; C;C
8H7D; 7D: J>; C?NJKH; ->; I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O M7I 97B9KB7J;: KI?D=
J>; <EBBEM?D= ;GK7J?ED
M>;H; η?I J>; I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O, M ?I J>; M;?=>J E< J>; E?B 9EBB;9J;:
?D J>; 8;7A;H 7<J;H I;F7H7J?ED 7D: Ma ?I J>; ?D?J?7B M;?=>J 8;<EH; J>;
I;F7H7J?ED ->H;; I7CFB;I E< ;79> ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; M;H; J;IJ;: -E :;
J;HC?D; J>; H;9O9B?D= 78?B?JO E< J>; <KD9J?ED7B?P;: H)- C;C8H7D; J>;
J;IJI M;H; H;F;7J;: J?C;I M?J>EKJ 7DO JH;7JC;DJ 8;JM;;D J>; 9O9B;I
->; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED J;IJ M7I I;J KF <EBBEM?D= 7 FK8B?I>;: H;FEHJ
45
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Morphology and surface chemical composition
)H;L?EKI IJK:?;I :;CEDIJH7J;: J>7J J>; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED 7D: IKH
<79; M;JJ78?B?JO E< J>; ;B;9JHEIFKD C;C8H7D;I M;H; IJHED=BO :;F;D:;DJ
ED J>; ]8;H :?7C;J;H FEHEI?JO FEH; I?P; IKH<79; 9>;C?IJHO 7D: IKH<79;
HEK=>D;II E< J>; C;C8H7D;I 45 ->;H;<EH; J>; CEHF>EBE=O 7D:
IJHK9JKH; E< J>; 7IIFKD 7D: )&,CE:?];: H)- C;C8H7D;I M;H; ?D
L;IJ?=7J;: ?= 7‒; I>EMI J>; CEHF>EBE=O 7D: IJHK9JKH; E< J>; 7IIFKD
7D: )&,CE:?];: H)- C;C8H7D;I ->; H)- ;B;9JHEIFKD ]8;HI >7L;
7 ICEEJ> IKH<79; 7D: 7 BEM :;=H;; E< ?DJ;H9EDD;9J;: D;JMEHA IJHK9
JKH; M?J> 7 ]8;H :?7C;J;H E< Z DC ?= , ->; <EHC7J?ED
E< J>; ?DJ;H9EDD;9J;: D;JMEHA IJHK9JKH; ?D J>; 7IIFKD H)- I7CFB;
9EKB: 8; 7II?=D;: JE J>; ?D9ECFB;J; ;L7FEH7J?ED E< J>; KI;: IEBL;DJI
45 0>;D J>; H)- C;C8H7D; M7I CE:?];: M?J> 7 )&, IEBK
J?ED E< MJ 7 IB?=>J 9>7D=; ?D J>; CEHF>EBE=O E< J>; C;C8H7D; M?J>
?D9H;7I;: ?DJ;H9EDD;9J;: 8ED:?D= IJHK9JKH; M7I E8I;HL;: 7I I>EMD ?D
?=I 8 7D: ?= , "D J>; 97I; E< 7 )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED E< MJ IEC;
7:>;I?L; 7H;7I ?D M>?9> J>; LE?:I 8;JM;;D H)- ]8;HI M;H; ]BB;: 8O
)&, 7FF;7H;: ED J>; C;C8H7D; IKH<79; 0?J> 7 <KHJ>;H ?D9H;7I; ?D
)&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED J>; 7:>;I?L; IJHK9JKH; 7CED= J>; ]8;HI ?D9H;7I;:
I?=D?<?97DJBO 0>;D J>; )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED M7I <KHJ>;H ?D9H;7I;: JE
MJ J>; 7:>;I?L; 7H;7I 8;97C; B7H=;H J>7D J>7J E< J>; H)-)&
,6 0>;D J>; )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED M7I ]D7BBO ?D9H;7I;: JE MJ J>;
FEHEKI IJHK9JKH; E< J>; C;C8H7D; M7I =H;7JBO :;9H;7I;: 7D: J>; LE?:I
8;JM;;D J>; ]8;HI M;H; 7BCEIJ ]BB;: M?J> )&,
->; HEK=>D;II E< J>; C;C8H7D; IKH<79; M7I <KHJ>;H ?DL;IJ?=7J;:
L?7 7 DED9EDJ79J B7I;H FHE]BEC;JHO 7D7BOI?I C;J>E: ?= < :;CED
IJH7J;I J>; 9EHH;IFED:?D= Ra7 L7BK;I E< J>; C;C8H7D;I ->; :;J7?B;: EF
J?97B FHE]BEC;JHO ?C7=;I M;H; :;CEDIJH7J;: ?D ?= , ->; 7IIFKD
H)- C;C8H7D; ;N>?8?J;: J>; >?=>;IJ Ra7 L7BK; E< [C ?D:?97J?D= 7
H;B7J?L;BO HEK=> IKH<79; I ;NF;9J;: J>; 9EHH;IFED:?D= Ra7 L7BK; :;
9H;7I;: JE [C M>;D J>; C;C8H7D; M7I CE:?];: M?J> MJ )&,
IEBKJ?ED M>?9> M7I C7?DBO :K; JE J>; ?DJ;H9EDD;9J?ED 8;JM;;D ]8;HI
<EHC;: 8O J>; )&, B7O;H ->; HEK=>D;II =H7:K7BBO :;9H;7I;: M?J>
7 <KHJ>;H ?D9H;7I; ?D J>; 9ED9;DJH7J?ED E< J>; )&, M>?9> H;IKBJ;:
<HEC J>; ?D9H;7I; ?D J>; 7CEKDJ E< 7:>;I?L; 7H;7 <EHC;: 8O )&,
->KI J>; H)-)&,6 7D: H)-)&,6 ;N>?8?J;: Ra7 L7BK;I E<
Fig. 1. ,& ?C7=;I E< 7 7IIFKD H)- 8 H)-)&,6 9 H)-)&,6 : H)-)&,6 7D: ; H)-)&,6 < ->; Ra7 L7BK;I E< J>; C;C8H7D;I ?DI;JI J>; 9EHH;IFED:?D=
EFJ?97B FHE]BEC;JHO ?C7=;I
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
7D: [C H;IF;9J?L;BO M>?9> 9EHH;IFED:;: JE J>; H;IKBJI <HEC J>;
,& 9>7H79J;H?P7J?EDI 0?J> 7 <KHJ>;H ?D9H;7I; ?D )&, 9ED9;DJH7
J?ED J>;H; M7I DE E8L?EKI :?<<;H;D9; ?D Ra7 <EH H)-)&,6 7D:
H)-)&,6
->; FH;I;D9; E< J>; )&, B7O;H ED J>; <KD9J?ED7B?P;: H)- C;C
8H7D; M7I ?DL;IJ?=7J;: 8O 7JJ;DK7J;: JEJ7B H;^;9J7D9; EKH?;H JH7DI<EHC
?D<H7H;: -+ -"+ C;7IKH;C;DJI ?= 7 I>EMI J>; -+ -"+ IF;9
JH7 E< J>; H)- C;C8H7D;I 8;<EH; 7D: 7<J;H CE:?]97J?ED M?J> :?<<;H;DJ
7CEKDJI E< )&, ->; :?<<;H;D9;I ?D J;HCI E< JH7DIC?JJ7D9; 7J
7D: 9Ca−E< J>; H)-)&, C;C
8H7D;I 7H; 7JJH?8KJ;: JE J>; <KD9J?ED7B =HEKFI E< )&, 4–5 ->;I;
87D:I 7H; 7II?=D;: JE ! 7IOCC;JH?9 IJH;J9>?D= 9Ca− !
IJH;J9>?D= 9Ca− ! 8;D:?D= 9Ca− ,?–(–,? 7IOCC;J
H?9 IJH;J9> ?D= 9Ca− M7==?D= L?8H7J?EDI E< –!a– 9Ca−
! HE9A?D= 9Ca− 7D: ,?– IJH;J9>?D= 9Ca− "J I>EKB: 8;
DEJ;: >;H; J>7J J>; -+ -"+ H;IKBJ E< J>; H)-)&,6 :E;I DEJ
I>EM 7 87D: 7J 9Ca−7IIE9?7J;: M?J> J>; FH;I;D9; E< J>; ,?–!
=HEKF ?D J>; 9HEIIB?DA;H M>?9> ?D:?97J;I J>7J J>; )&, FH;FEBOC;H 7D:
9HEIIB?DA?D= 7=;DJ 7H; 9ECFB;J;BO FEBOC;H?P;: 7I I>EMD ?D ?= 8
->; 9>;C?97B 9ECFEI?J?ED E< J>; )&, B7O;H ED J>; H)- ]8;HI
M7I <KHJ>;H ;L7BK7J;: 8O 1), ?= 7 I>EMI J>; 1), IF;9JH7 E< J>;
H)- C;C8H7D; 7<J;H CE:?]97J?ED M?J> :?<<;H;DJ 7CEKDJI E< )&,
?D M>?9> J>; I 7D: ( I I?=D7BI 7FF;7H 7J ;/ 7D:
;/ H;IF;9J?L;BO "D 7::?J?ED ,? I?=D7BI 7BIE 7FF;7H ?D J>; )&,<KD9
J?ED7B?P;: H)- C;C8H7D;I 7I I;;D 7J 8?D:?D= ;D;H=?;I E< ;/
7D: ;/ ->?I H;IKBJ ?D:?97J;I J>7J J>; IKH<79; E< J>; H)- ]8;HI
M7I CE:?];: 8O )&, ->; :;J7?B;: ;B;C;DJ7B 9ECFEI?J?ED E< J>; H)-
C;C8H7D; 8;<EH; 7D: 7<J;H )&, <KD9J?ED7B?P7J?ED M7I 97B9KB7J;: 7I
I>EMD ?D ?= 8 I 7 H;IKBJ J7A?D= J>; H)- ]8;HI J>7J M;H; CE:?];:
8O J>; ),& IEBKJ?ED M?J> MJ 7I 7D ;N7CFB; J>; H;B7J?L; F;H9;DJ7=;
E< ,? ED J>; C;C8H7D; ?D9H;7I;: I?=D?<?97DJBO <HEC D;7HBO –
!EM;L;H ;L;D ?< J>; JH;7JC;DJ 9ED9;DJH7J?ED E< )&, M7I ?D9H;7I;:
J>; F;H9;DJ7=; E< ,? M7I 7BCEIJ 9EDIJ7DJ 7I I>EMD ?D ?= 8 "D 7::?
J?ED J>; F;H9;DJ7=; E< ,? M7I 7BCEIJ J>; I7C; 7I J>; ;B;C;DJ7B H7J?E E<
7 8KBA )&, ,? 799EH:?D=BO 7BB E< J>; ,? F;H9;DJ7=;I <EH J>;
H)- ]8;HI <KD9J?ED7B?P;: M?J> )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI E< 7D: MJ
I>EM 7FFHEN?C7J;BO –
->; 9>7D=?D= ]8;H IKH<79; 9>;C?97B 9ECFEI?J?ED M7I <KHJ>;H ?DL;I
J?=7J;: 8O 7D 1), D7HHEM IF;9JHKC 7J I <EH J>; 7IIFKD 7D: CE:?];:
H)- C;C8H7D;I I I>EMD ?D ?= 7 8HE7: I IF;9JH7 9;DJ;H;: 7J
;/ 9EKB: 8; :;9ECFEI;: ?DJE ;/ ;/ 7D: ;/
7D: J>;I; F;7AI 9EHH;IFED:;: JE J>; –!– –( 7D: (–=( 8?D:
?D= ;D;H=?;I H;IF;9J?L;BO ->; H)- C;C8H7D; 9E7J;: M?J> J>; MJ
)&, IEBKJ?ED H)-)&,6 :;CEDIJH7J;: J>7J J>; F;7A ?DJ;DI?JO E<
–( 7D: (–=( 8?D:?D= ;D;H=?;I =H;7JBO :;9H;7I;: ?D 9ECF7H?IED M?J>
J>7J E< J>; 7IIFKD H)- C;C8H7D; 7I I>EMD ?D ?= 8 0?J> 7 <KHJ>;H
?D9H;7I; ?D )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED J>; I?=D7BI 9EHH;IFED:?D= JE J>; (
7D: ( =( 8?D:?D= ;D;H=?;I :?I7FF;7H ?D 7BB J>; 1), D7HHEM IF;9JH7
?D:?97J?D= J>7J J>; IKH<79;I E< J>; H)- C;C8H7D;I M;H; <KBBO 9EL;H;:
M?J> )&,
Fig. 2. 7 -+ -"+ IF;9JH7 E< J>; H)-)&, D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I E8J7?D;: M?J> L7H?EKI )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI 8 -+ "-"+ IF;9JH7 E< J>; H)-)&,6 )&,6KBA )&
,6)H;FEBOC;H 7D: )&,6HEIIB?DA;H
Fig. 3. 7 ,KHL;OI97D 1), IF;9JH7 E< H)-)&, D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I E8J7?D;: <HEC L7H?EKI )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI 7D: 8 :;J7?B;: ;B;C;DJ7B 9ECFEI?J?ED E< J>; H)- C;C8H7D;
8;<EH; 7D: 7<J;H )&, <KD9J?ED7B?P7J?ED
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
Fig. 4. I IF;9JH7 7D7BOI?I E< J>; 7IIFKD H)- 8KBA )&, 7D: H)-)&, ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I E8J7?D;: M?J> L7H?EKI )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI
->; :?IJH?8KJ?ED E< )&, ED J>; C;C8H7D; M7I ;L7BK7J;: 8O KI?D=
1 ,? C7FF?D= 7I I>EMD ?D ?= , I 7 H;IKBJ 7 >ECE=;D;EKIBO :?I
F;HI;: ,? 9EDJ;DJ ED J>; ]8;HI M7I E8I;HL;:
3.2. Thermal properties
->; ;<<;9J E< )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED ED J>; J>;HC7B FHEF;HJ?;I E< J>;
H)- C;C8H7D;I M7I ?DL;IJ?=7J;: 8O KI?D= , 7D: - 7D7BOI?I 7I
I>EMD ?D ?= "D J>; , J>;HCE=H7CI 7D ;D:EJ>;HC?9 F;7A 9EHH;
IFED:;: JE 7D ;DJ>7BFO H;B7N7J?ED J>7J 7FF;7H;: 7J 7FFHEN?C7J;BO X
<EH ;79> I7CFB; M>?9> M7I 7JJH?8KJ;: JE J>; FH;I;D9; E< 7 C;IECEHF>?9
F>7I; EH?;DJ;: 7CEHF>EKI F>7I; ?D J>; ]8;HI 45 ->; C;IECEH
F>?9 F>7I; MEKB: 8; <EHC;: M>;D J>; ]8;HI M;H; IJH;J9>;: :KH?D= J>;
;B;9JHEIF?DD?D= FHE9;II 7D:EH J>; >;7J?D= JH;7JC;DJ 7<J;H J>; :?F9E7J
?D= FHE9;II 7J X KHJ>;HCEH; J>; FH;I;D9; E< J>; )&, B7O;H ED
J>; H)- ]8;HI 9EKB: FH;L;DJ J>; >;7J?D= ;<<;9J ED J>; H)- 97KI?D= 7D
?D9H;7I; ?D J>; 9EB: 9HOIJ7BB?P7J?ED J;CF;H7JKH; Tc E< J>; H)-)&,
I7CFB;I
->; ;<<;9J E< )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED ED J>; J>;HC7B :;=H7:7J?ED E<
H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I M7I ;L7BK7J;: KI?D= - 7I :;I9H?8;: ?D
?=I 8 7D: , ->; H;IKBJI I>EM J>7J J>; FOHEBOI?I E< J>; 7IIFKD
H)- I7CFB; IJ7HJ;: 7J 7FFHEN?C7J;BO X ->; I7CFB; M7I 9EC
FB;J;BO :;=H7:;: 7J X M?J> 7 F;7A 7J X 7D: FHE:K9?D= H;I?:K;
M?J> 7D 7CEKDJ E< MJ &;7DM>?B; J>; H)-)&, I7CFB;I I>EM
7 >?=>;H J>;HC7B IJ78?B?JO M?J> JME CEH; F;7AI 7J X 7D: X ?D
J>; - 9KHL;I ?D:?97J?D= J>; FH;I;D9; E< )&, ED J>; I7CFB; M?J>
7 >?=>;H :;=H7:7J?ED J;CF;H7JKH; ->; - 7D: - 9KHL;I E< J>;
7IIFKD H)- 7D: H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I I>EM :?<<;H;DJ I>7F;I M?J>
:?<<;H;DJ )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI M>?9> ?D:?97J;I J>7J :?<<;H;DJ 7CEKDJI
E< )&, M;H; ?D9EHFEH7J;: ?DJE J>; H)- ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; 0>;D J>;
)&, 9EDJ;DJ ?D9H;7I;: J>; - 9KHL;I E< J>; H)-)&, I7CFB;I
I>EM 7 :;9H;7I; ?D M;?=>J BEII ?D J>; H7D=; E< X X M?J> 7
- F;7A 7J X 7D: ?DIJ;7: 7D ?D9H;7I; E< - F;7AI 7J X 7D:
X M;H; C;7IKH;: ->; H)-)&, I7CFB;I M;H; 9ECFB;J;BO :;
=H7:;: 7J 7FFHEN?C7J;BO X
3.3. Wettability
>?=>BO I;B;9J?L; M;JJ78?B?JO ?I 7 9HK9?7B <79JEH J>7J I?=D?<?97DJBO
7<<;9JI J>; I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; E< J>; C;C8H7D; 45
->;H;<EH; J>; M;JJ78?B?JO E< J>; 7IIFKD H)- 7D: H)-)&, C;C
8H7D;I M7I ;N7C?D;: ->; ;<<;9J E< )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED ED J>; 0
7D: M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; M7I IJK:?;: ?= 7 I>EMI J>7J J>; 7IIFKD
H)- C;C8H7D; :;CEDIJH7J;I 7 >?=> 0 E< X M>?9>
Fig. 5. 7 , J>;HCE=H7CI 7D: 8 - 9KHL;I E< J>; 7IIFKD H)- 7D: H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I E8J7?D;: M?J> L7H?EKI )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
Fig. 6. 7 0 7D: ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; E< J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D; 8 E?B 9EDJ79J 7D=B; 7D: KD:;HE?B 0 E< J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D; 9 :OD7C?9 C;7IKH;C;DJ E< M7J;H 7:>;
I?ED E< J>; 7IIFKD H)- 7D: H)-)&,6 I7CFB;I : CE8?B?JO E< J>; M7J;H :HEFB;J ED J>; -M;JJ;: H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D;
?I CK9> >?=>;H J>7D J>7J E< J>; FH?IJ?D; )- ]BC ->; ?D9H;7I; ?D J>;
0 E< J>; H)- C;C8H7D; M7I 7JJH?8KJ;: JE J>; ?D9H;7I; E< IKH<79;
HEK=>D;II M>?9> B;: JE J>; JH7FF?D= E< 7?H FE9A;JI KD:;H J>; M7J;H
:HEFB;J ->; >?=>;IJ 0 E< X M7I <EKD: M?J> J>; H)-)&,6
I7CFB; ->; ?D9H;7I;: 0 E< J>; CE:?];: I7CFB;I MEKB: 8; :K; JE
J>; FH;I;D9; E< )&, M?J> 7 BEM IKH<79; ;D;H=O !EM;L;H M>;D J>;
)&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED <KHJ>;H ?D9H;7I;: J>; 0 E< J>; H)-)&,6
7D: H)-)&,6 :;9H;7I;: JE X 7D: X H;IF;9J?L;BO I :?I
9KII;: 78EL; J>; :;9H;7I?D= 0 <EH J>; I7CFB;I M?J> J>; )&, 9ED
9;DJH7J?ED ?D9H;7I;: <HEC MJ JE 7D: MJ MEKB: 8; 97KI;: 8O J>;
:;9H;7I; E< IKH<79; HEK=>D;II ?D9H;7I?D= IEB?: 7H;7 <H79J?ED 97KI;: 8O
J>; <EHC7J?ED E< 7:>;I?L; 7H;7I ->; 7IIFKD H)- C;C8H7D; I>EM;: 7
BEM M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; E< A)7 !EM;L;H 7<J;H CE:?<O?D= M?J>
J>; MJ )&, IEBKJ?ED J>; M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; I?=D?<?97DJBO ?D
9H;7I;: JE A)7 ->; M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; E< J>; H)-)&,
H;79>;: J>; >?=>;IJ L7BK; E< A)7 M>;D J>; )&, 9EDJ;DJ <KHJ>;H
?D9H;7I;: JE MJ ->; M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; :;F;D:;: ED J>; IKH
<79; M;JJ78?B?JO 7D: FEH; I?P; E< J>; ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; 7D: 9EKB: 8; ;N
FH;II;: KI?D= J>; <EBBEM?D= ;GK7J?ED 45
M>;H; ΔPw?I J>; M7J;H ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; γw?I J>; IKH<79; J;DI?ED E<
M7J;H ?D 7?H r?I J>; 9KHL7JKH; H7:?KI E< C;D?I9KI θw?I J>; 9EDJ79J 7D
=B; E< J>; B?GK?: ED J>; IKH<79; E< ]8;HI R?I J>; ;GK?L7B;DJ FEH; H7:?KI
E< J>; C;C8H7D; .I?D= J>; 78EL; ;GK7J?ED J>; ?D9H;7I; ?D M7J;H ?DJHK
I?ED FH;IIKH; E< J>; H)-)&, M7I 7JJH?8KJ;: JE J>; ?D9H;7I; E< 0
7D: J>; :;9H;7I; E< FEH; I?P;
->; E8J7?D;: H)-)&, C;C8H7D; ;N>?8?J;: IKF;HEB;EF>?B?9?JO
M?J> 7D E?B 9EDJ79J 7D=B; E< X ?D 7?H 7D: KD:;HE?B IKF;H>O:HEF>E8?9?JO
.(0 X /?:;E , 7D: ?= 8 ->; H;IKBJI 7BBEM;: J>; E?B
JE IFH;7: EKJ 7D: F7II J>HEK=> J>; C;C8H7D; M>?B; A;;F?D= J>; M7J;H
78EL; J>; C;C8H7D; BJ>EK=> J>; 7IIFKD H)- C;C8H7D; M7I KD:;H
E?B IKF;H>O:HEF>E8?9 J>; 7IIFKD H)- 9EKB: DEJ FH;L;DJ J>; 7:>;I?ED
E< E?B ED J>; C;C8H7D; ?= 9 7D: /?:;E , I>EM J>7J M>;D 7 M7J;H
:HEFB;J 9EC;I ?DJE 9EDJ79J M?J> J>; 7IIFKD H)- C;C8H7D; IKH<79; ?J
?I F?DD;: EDJE J>; C;C8H7D; IKH<79; M>?9> ?D:?97J;I J>; FEEH 7DJ?M7
J;H <EKB?D= E< J>; KDCE:?];: H)- C;C8H7D; !EM;L;H ?D J>; 97I;
E< J>; H)- C;C8H7D; <KD9J?ED7B?P;: M?J> J>; )&, J>; C;C8H7D;
I>EM;: ;N9;BB;DJ 7DJ?M7J;H<EKB?D= F;H<EHC7D9; ?= 9 7D: /?:;E ,
I>EM 7 M7J;H :HEFB;J J>7J ?I <EH9;: JE 9EDJ79J J>; H)-)&,6 C;C
8H7D; IKH<79; KDJ?B 7D E8L?EKI :;<EHC7J?ED 7FF;7HI J>;D ?J ?I B?<J;: KF
7D: DE :;<EHC7J?ED 97D 8; <EKD: ?D J>; I>7F; E< J>; M7J;H :HEFB;J 9
9EH:?D=BO I?D9; J>; M7J;H :HEFB;J 9ECFB;J;BO :;J79>;: <HEC J>; C;C
8H7D; IKH<79; J>?I ?D:?97J;I 7 >?=> 7DJ?M7J;H<EKB?D= 78?B?JO
-E <KHJ>;H :;CEDIJH7J; J>; 7DJ?M7J;H<EKB?D= FHEF;HJO E< J>; C;C
8H7D; J>; CE8?B?JO E< 7 M7J;H :HEFB;J ED 7 JH?9>BEHE;J>;D; -M;J
J;: H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; M7I ;L7BK7J;: I I>EMD ?D ?= :
7D: /?:;E , 7 M7J;H :HEFB;J ?CC;:?7J;BO CEL;: :EMD J>; C;C
8H7D; ;L;D M>;D J>; 0 M7I X M>?9> C;7DJ J>7J J>; E?BM;J
J;: H)-)&, C;C8H7D; ;N>?8?J;: J>; <;7JKH;I E< HE8KIJ 7DJ?M7J;H
<EKB?D= 7D: I;B<9B;7D?D= ->; FH;I;D9; E< - ?D J>; C;C8H7D; B;: JE
J>; <EHC7J?ED E< 7 IOIJ;C 97BB;: 7 IB?FF;HO B?GK?:?D<KI;: FEHEKI IKH<79;
,%"), ?D M>?9> 7 BK8H?97J?D= B?GK?: B7O;H M7I ?DJHE:K9;: ?DJE 7 C?9HE
D7DEC;J;HI97B; FEHEKI IJHK9JKH; 0?J> J>; FH;I;D9; E< 7 BK8H?97J?D= B?G
K?: E?B J>; ,%"), 9EKB: H;F;B 7 B?GK?: M7J;H J>7J ?I ?CC?I9?8B; M?J>
J>; BK8H?97J?D= B?GK?: E?B ->; CEB;9KB7HBO ICEEJ> 7D: 9>;C?97BBO >E
CE=;D;EKI BK8H?97J?D= B?GK?: B7O;H FHEL?:;I ;NJH;C;BO BEM IB?:?D= 7D=B;
7D: 9EDJ79J 7D=B; >OIJ;H;I?I B;7:?D= JE J>; 9EDJ?DKEKI CEL;C;DJ E< J>;
M7J;H ED J>; IKH<79; 45
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
3.4. Mechanical properties
"D FH79J?97B I;F7H7J?ED 7FFB?97J?EDI J>; C;9>7D?97B FHEF;HJ?;I E<
J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I I>EKB: 8; IJHED= ;DEK=> JE M?J>IJ7D: J>;
M;?=>J E< J>; ]BJH7J?ED B?GK?: ->; ;<<;9J E< J>; )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED ED
J>; J;DI?B; IJH;D=J> E< J>; H)-)&, M7I ;L7BK7J;: 7D: J>; JOF?97B
IJH;IIIJH7?D 9KHL;I 7H; I>EMD ?D ?= 7 ->; C7N?CKC J;DI?B; IJH;II
7D: J>; ;BED=7J?ED 7J 8H;7A E8J7?D;: <HEC J>; 9KHL;I 7H; IKCC7H?P;:
?D ?= 8
->; H;IKBJI E< J>; J;DI?B; J;IJ I>EMD ?D ?= 7 I>EM J>7J J>; 8H;7A
?D= E< J>; C;C8H7D;I E99KHH;: ?D JME IJ;FI "D EJ>;H MEH:I 7 DEDB?D
;7H H;=?ED 7D: 7 IK8I;GK;DJ B?D;7H H;=?ED ?D J>; IJH;IIIJH7?D 9KHL; ?D:?
97J;: J>; ?DJ;H9EDD;9J;: IJHK9JKH; E< J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I M?J>
7 9E;N?IJ;D9; E< 9EDD;9J;:KD9EDD;9J;: F7HJI ?D J>; C;C8H7D;I ->;
8H;7A?D= E< J>;I; C;C8H7D;I 9EKB: 8; ;NFB7?D;: 8O 7 JMEIJ;F 8H;7A
?D= C;9>7D?IC 45 .D:;H 7D 7FFB?;: J;DI?B; IJH;II J>; KD9EDD;9J;:
F7HJI ?D J>; ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; 9EKB: ;7I?BO :;<EHC 7D: M;H; <EH9;: JE
8; 7B?=D;: 7BED= J>; IJH;II :?H;9J?ED H;IKBJ?D= ?D DEDB?D;7H ;B7IJ?9 8;
>7L?EH ?D J>; ]HIJ H;=?ED 0>;D <KHJ>;H IJH;II M7I 7FFB?;: <HEC J>7J H;
=?ED J>; IJH7?D 9KHL; JH7DI<EHC;: ?DJE 7 B?D;7H ;B7IJ?9?JO KDJ?B 8H;7A?D=
M?J> 7 >?=> B?D;7H?JO E< M>?9> 9EKB: 8; 7JJH?8KJ;: JE J>; ;BED=7
J?ED E< ?D:?L?:K7B ]8;HI (L;H7BB J>; ?D9H;7I; E< )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?ED
?D J>; :?F9E7J?D= IEBKJ?ED B;: JE >?=>;H C;9>7D?97B FHEF;HJ?;I E< J>;
H)-)&, C;C8H7D; ->; 7IIFKD H)- C;C8H7D; M>?9> >7: J>;
BEM;IJ ?DJ;H9EDD;9J;: 8ED:?D= :;=H;; :;CEDIJH7J;: J>; BEM;IJ J;DI?B;
IJH;D=J> E< Z &)7 7D: 7D ;BED=7J?ED 7J 8H;7A E< Z
KHJ>;HCEH; H)-)&,6 ;N>?8?J;: J>; >?=>;IJ C;9>7D?97B FHEF;H
J?;I M?J> 7 J;DI?B; IJH;D=J> E< Z &)7 7D: 7D ;BED=7J?ED 7J 8H;7A
E< Z
3.5. Separation performance of the PDMS-functionalized rPET membrane
D9EKH7=;: 8O J>; ;N9;BB;DJ IKF;HEB;EF>?B?9 7D: KD:;HE?B IKF;H>O
:HEF>E8?9 FHEF;HJ?;I E< J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I 7 I;H?;I E< E?BM7
J;H I;F7H7J?ED ;NF;H?C;DJI M;H; F;H<EHC;: 8O KI?D= J>; I;JKF 7I I>EMD
?D ?= 7 7D: /?:;E , D E?BM7J;H C?NJKH; M7I FEKH;: EDJE J>;
FH;M;JJ;: C;C8H7D;I M>?9> >7: 8;;D ]N;: 8;JM;;D JME F7HJI E< 7 ]B
J;H >EB:;H ->; H;IKBJ I>EM;: J>7J EDBO E?B 9EKB: F;HC;7J; J>HEK=> J>;
H)-)&, C;C8H7D; M?J> >?=> ^KN M>?B; J>; M7J;H M7I A;FJ 78EL;
J>; C;C8H7D; 7D: DE E8L?EKI M7J;H H;C7?D;: ?D J>; 9EBB;9J;: E?B ->;
I;B;9J?L; F;HC;7J?ED E< J>; D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D; <EH E?B 7D: M7J;H 97D
8; ;NFB7?D;: 8O J>; ;IJ?C7J?ED E< ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; ΔPc 87I;: J>;
2EKD=%7FB79; J>;EHO 7D: 7 I?CFB?];: ;GK7J?ED
M>;H; ΔPc?I J>; B?GK?: ?DJHKI?ED FH;IIKH; γL?I J>; IKH<79; J;DI?ED E<
E?B EH M7J;H ?D 7?H r?I J>; 9KHL7JKH; H7:?KI E< C;D?I9KI θ?I J>; 9EDJ79J
7D=B; E< J>; B?GK?: ED J>; IKH<79; E< ]8;HI R?I J>; ;GK?L7B;DJ FEH; H7
:?KI E< J>; C;C8H7D; 0>;D J>; E?B 9EDJ79JI J>; IKH<79; E< C;C8H7D; ?D
7?H γO?I J>; IKH<79; J;DI?ED E< E?B 7D: θO?I J>; 9EDJ79J 7D=B; E< E?B ED
J>; IKH<79; E< ]8;HI M>?9> ?I D;7HBO X EM?D= JE J>; IKF;H>O:HEF>?B?9
?JO E< J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D;I EDI;GK;DJBO J>; 9EHH;IFED:?D=
ΔPc?I M>?9> C;7DI J>7J J>; IKH<79; 97DDEJ IKFFEHJ 7 9ECFEI
?J; ?DJ;H<79; 7D: M?BB 7BBEM J>; E?B JE IFEDJ7D;EKIBO F;HC;7J; ?DJE J>;
C;C8H7D; M?J> J>; 97F?BB7HO :H?L?D= FH;IIKH; E< ΔPc !EM;L;H M>;D
J>; M7J;H 9EDJ79JI J>; IKH<79; E< C;C8H7D; J>; M7J;H 9EDJ79J 7D=B; ?I
X J>KI J>; 9EHH;IFED:?D= ΔPc?I ?D:?97J; J>7J 7D ;NJ;HD7B FH;I
IKH; CKIJ 8; 7FFB?;: JE <EH9; J>; M7J;H J>HEK=> J>; C;C8H7D;
"J M7I E8L?EKI J>7J J>; ^KN M7I :;9H;7I;: =H7:K7BBO M>?B; J>; I;F7
H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O IJ7O;: D;7HBO J>; I7C; M>;D J>; KI;: )&, 9ED9;DJH7
J?ED ?D9H;7I;: ->; M7J;H F;HC;7J?ED ^KN M7I 7I >?=> 7I Z %
Ca−>a−7D: M7I 79>?;L;: M?J> J>; H)-)&,6 I7CFB; M?J> 7 I;F
7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O E< !EM;L;H J>; ^KN E8J7?D;: <HEC J>;
H)-)&,6 I7CFB; I?=D?<?97DJBO :;9H;7I;: JE Z % Ca−>a−
->; :;9H;7I; ?D J>; ^KN 9EKB: 8; 7JJH?8KJ;: JE J>; H;:K9; E< FEH; I?P;
7D: J>; FEHEI?JO E< J>; C;C8H7D; -E 9ECF7H; M?J> EJ>;H 7:IEH8;DJI
IK9> 7I FH?IJ?D; <E7C 9ECC;H9?7B 7:IEH8;DJ 7D: M7IJ; FEBOIJOH;D;
;B;9JHEIFKD ]8;HI M), H;FEHJ;: ?D H;9;DJ MEHA 45 J>; I;F7H7J?ED
;<]9?;D9O E< J>; H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; M7I 7CED= J>; 8;IJ ->;
H)-)&,6 I>EM;: 7 I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O E< M>?B; J>; FH?I
J?D; <E7C 9ECC;H9?7B 7:IEH8;DJ 7D: M), I>EM;: 7D:
H;IF;9J?L;BO ->;H;<EH; J>; H)-)&,6 97D 8; 7 FHEC?I?D= 97D:?
:7J; <EH J>; E?B IF?BB7=; H;CEL7B 9ECF7H;: JE J>; 9ECC;H9?7B 7:IEH8;DJ
-78B; , I>EMI J>; 9ECF7H?IED E< J>; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9;
E< L7H?EKI ;B;9JHEIFKD ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I FH;F7H;: <HEC L?H=?D 7D: H;
9O9B; FEBOC;HI ?D H;FEHJ;: IJK:?;I 7D: J>?I MEHA ->; H)-)&,6
I>EMI >?=>;H E?B ^KN J>7D 7DO C;C8H7D; FH;F7H;: 8O ;B;9JHEIF?DD?D=
->; C7?D 7:L7DJ7=; E< J>; 9KHH;DJ IJK:O ?D 9ECF7H?IED JE J>; FH;L?EKI
H;FEHJI ?I J>; ;CFBEOC;DJ E< H)- <EH J>; <78H?97J?ED E< J>; C;C8H7D;
->; C7J;H?7BI KI;: ?D J>; FH;L?EKI IJK:?;I M;H; L?H=?D FEBOC;HI M>?9>
9EKB: B;7: JE 7DEJ>;H ;DL?HEDC;DJ7B ?IIK; 45 ->; KI7=; E< J>; H)-
H;:K9;I J>; FB7IJ?9I 9EDIKCFJ?ED J>7J 9EKB: 8H?D= 7D ?D:?H;9J 8;D;]J JE
J>; ;DL?HEDC;DJ ;I?:;I J>; H)- >7I 7 BEM;H FH?9; J>7D J>; L?H=?D
FB7IJ?9I J>?I KI7=; 9EKB: FHEL?:; 7 H;C7HA78B; 9EIJ H;:K9J?ED
->; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; E< J>; H)-)&,6 C;C
8H7D; M7I <KHJ>;H ?DL;IJ?=7J;: KI?D= J>H;; A?D:I E< E?B ;J>OB;D; J;JH7
9>BEH?:; a!aBa 97H8ED J;JH79>BEH?:; Ba 7D: 8HECE8;DP;D;
a!aH 7I I>EMD ?D ?= 9 ->; H;IKBJI H;L;7B;: J>7J J>;H; M7I
DEJ CK9> :?<<;H;D9; ?D J;HCI E< J>; I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; E< J>;
H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; M>;D J>; KI;: E?BI M;H; ;J>OB;D; J;JH79>BE
Fig. 7. 7 ,JH;IIIJH7?D 9KHL;I 7D: 8 J;DI?B; FHEF;HJ?;I E< J>; )&,<KD9J?ED7B?P;: H)- C;C8H7D;I <78H?97J;: M?J> :?<<;H;DJ )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
Fig. 8. 7 )>EJE=H7F> I>EM?D= J>; E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED ;NF;H?C;DJ 8 BKN 7D: I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O E< J>; H)-)&, ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I E8J7?D;: <HEC L7H?EKI )&, 9ED9;DJH7J?EDI
a!aBaM7J;H LL 9 BKN 7D: I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O E< :?<<;H;DJ A?D:I E< E?B KI?D= J>; H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; : >7D=;I ?D J>; M7J;H ^KN M?J> ?D9H;7I?D= I;F7H7J?ED 9O9B;I
E< J>; E?BM7J;H C?NJKH; KI?D= J>; H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; ; ;I?=D;: IOIJ;C <EH J>; 9EDJ?DKEKI I;F7H7J?ED E< 7 B?=>J E?BM7J;H C?NJKH;
H?:; 7D: 97H8ED J;JH79>BEH?:; ->; ^KN;I 9EKB: H;79> D;7HBO %
>a−Ca M>?B; J>; I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O 9EKB: 8; >?=> 7FFHEN?C7J;BO
!EM;L;H M>;D J>; 8HECE8;DP;D; M7I KI;: 7I 7 J;IJ?D= E?B
J>; ^KN I?=D?<?97DJBO :;9H;7I;: JE Z % >a−Ca ->; KI; E<
8HECE8;DP;D; 97KI;: J>; IM;BB?D= E< J>; )&, B7O;H ED J>; C;C8H7D;
7D: H;:K9;: J>; FEH; I?P; E< J>; C;C8H7D; B;7:?D= JE 7 :;9H;7I; ?D E?B
^KN
&;C8H7D; <EKB?D= ?I 7 9ECCED 7D: :?<]9KBJ ?IIK; :KH?D= E?BO M7
J;H JH;7JC;DJ ?D FH79J?97B 7FFB?97J?EDI D ?:;7B C;C8H7D; I>EKB: FEI
I;II 8EJ> =EE: 7DJ?<EKB?D= FHEF;HJ?;I 7D: H;9O9B78?B?JO !;H;?D J>; 7D
J?<EKB?D= F;H<EHC7D9; 7=7?DIJ M7J;H M7I J;IJ;: 8O :;J;9J?D= J>; E?B ^KN
9>7D=;I EL;H DKC;HEKI 9O9B;I KI?D= J>; H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; ->;
C;C8H7D; ;N>?8?J;: 7D EKJIJ7D:?D= F;H<EHC7D9; M?J> D;7HBO DE ^KN
:;9H;7I; 7D: A;FJ 7 >?=> I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O E< 7<J;H J;D 9O9B;I
:K; JE ?JI ;N9;BB;DJ M7J;HH;F;BB?D= 78?B?JO
;I?:;I 7DEJ>;H 7:L7DJ7=; E< J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D; 9EC
F7H;: JE EJ>;H 9ECC;H9?7B 7:IEH8;DJI ?I J>7J J>;O 97D 8; KI;: 7I I;F7
H7J?ED C;:?7 <EH J>; 9EDJ?DKEKI 9EBB;9J?ED E< B?=>J E?B <HEC 7D E?BM7J;H
C?NJKH; I I>EMD ?D ?= ; 7D: /?:;E , J>; H)-)&,6 C;C
8H7D; M7I ]N;: JE 7 C;C8H7D; >EB:;H 9EDD;9J;: JE 7 L79KKC FKCF
JE O?;B: 7 FH;IIKH;:H?L;D ^EM <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED 0?J> IKF;H
E;B;EF>?B?9 FHEF;HJ?;I J>; E?B 97D H7F?:BO F;HC;7J; J>HEK=> J>; C;C
8H7D; (D J>; EJ>;H >7D: J>; KD:;HE?B IKF;H>O:HEF>E8?9?JO FH;L;DJI
J>; M7J;H <HEC F;HC;7J?D= J>HEK=> J>; C;C8H7D; B;7:?D= JE J>; >?=>
E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED ;<]9?;D9O E< J>; IOIJ;C ;97KI; E< ?JI ;N9;BB;DJ
I;F7H7J?ED FHEF;HJ?;I J>; H)-)&,6 C;C8H7D; ?I 78B; JE I;F7H7J;
:?<<;H;DJ E?BM7J;H C?NJKH;I 7D: J>KI >7I FEJ;DJ?7B ?D:KIJH?7B 7FFB?97
J?EDI
4. Conclusion
BEM9EIJ 7D: ;DL?HEDC;DJ7BBO <H?;D:BO ]8HEKI C;C8H7D; <EH
E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED M7I IK99;II<KBBO <78H?97J;: ->; )&,<KD9J?ED
7B?P;: H)- C;C8H7D;I M?J> IKF;HEB;EF>?B?9 7D: KD:;HE?B IKF;H>O
:HEF>E8?9 FHEF;HJ?;I M;H; C7:; KI?D= ;B;9JHEIF?DD?D= 7D: :?F9E7J?D=
C;J>E:I ->; CEHF>EBE=O 9>;C?97B 9ECFEI?J?ED J>;HC7B 7D: C;9>7D
?97B FHEF;HJ?;I IKH<79; M;JJ78?B?JO 7D: E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9;
E< J>; H)- C;C8H7D; 97D 8; 9EDJHEBB;: 8O C7D?FKB7J?D= J>; )&,
9ED9;DJH7J?ED ?D J>; :?F9E7J?D= IEBKJ?ED ->; H)-)&, C;C8H7D;
I>EMI 7 >?=> E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED F;H<EHC7D9; M?J> ;N9;BB;DJ 7DJ?M7
J;H <EKB?D= 8;>7L?EH ;97KI; E< ?JI EKJIJ7D:?D= 7DJ?M7J;H <EKB?D= FHEF
;HJ?;I J>; H)-)&, C;C8H7D; ?I 78B; JE A;;F 7 >?=> I;F7H7J?ED F;H
<EHC7D9; 7<J;H J;D 9O9B;I J>KI FEII;II?D= =H;7J FEJ;DJ?7B <EH E?BM7J;H
I;F7H7J?ED FHE9;:KH;I
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
+;:?- 7KJ>EHI>?F 9EDJH?8KJ?ED IJ7J;C;DJ
Hoan Ngoc Doan: ED9;FJK7B?P7J?ED "DL;IJ?=7J?ED 0H?J?D= EH?=?D7B
:H7<J Phu Phong Vo: "DL;IJ?=7J?ED Kohei Hayashi: "DL;IJ?=7J?ED
Kenji Kinashi: ,KF;HL?I?ED 0H?J?D= H;L?;M ;:?J?D= Wataru Sakai:
0H?J?D= H;L?;M ;:?J?D= Naoto Tsutsumi: 0H?J?D= H;L?;M
;:?J?D=
Declaration of Competing Interest
->; 7KJ>EHI :;9B7H; J>7J J>;O >7L; DE ADEMD 9ECF;J?D= ]D7D9?7B
?DJ;H;IJI EH F;HIED7B H;B7J?EDI>?FI J>7J 9EKB: >7L; 7FF;7H;: JE ?D^K;D9;
J>; MEHA H;FEHJ;: ?D J>?I F7F;H
Acknowledgements
->?I IJK:O M7I F7HJ?7BBO IKFFEHJ;: 8O H7DJI?D?: <HEC #,),
EH;JEEH; )HE=H7C I?7<H?97 ,9?;D9; )B7J<EHCI #7F7D !'
?I I?D9;H;BO =H7J;<KB JE )HE<;IIEH ,EDE ,7I7A? $"- <EH 9EDJ79J 7D=B;
9>7H79J;H?P7J?ED 7D: )HE<;IIEH -7A;I>? ,>?EDE $"- <EH ,& 9>7H
79J;H?P7J?ED !' =H;7JBO 79ADEMB;:=;I J>; &?D?IJHO E< :K97J?ED
,FEHJI 7D: KBJKH; E< #7F7D &1- I9>EB7HI>?F FHEL?:;: 8O J>; #7F7D
;I; EL;HDC;DJ <EH >?I IJK:?;I 7J $OEJE "DIJ?JKJ; E< -;9>DEBE=O
Appendix A. Supplementary data
,KFFB;C;DJ7HO C7J;H?7B H;B7J;: JE J>?I 7HJ?9B; 97D 8; <EKD: ?D J>;
EDB?D; L;HI?ED 7J :E?>JJFI:E?EH=@@;9;
References
45 # ;O;H ! -H7DDKC - 7AA; )/ !E:IED -$ EBB?;H DL?HEDC;DJ7B ;<<;9JI
E< J>; ;;FM7J;H !EH?PED E?B IF?BB 7 H;L?;M &7H )EBBKJ KBB –
>JJFI:E?EH=@C7HFEB8KB
45 #;HD;BVL !EM JE :;<;D: 7=7?DIJ <KJKH; E?B IF?BBI '7JKH; –
>JJFI:E?EH=7
45 $K@7M?DIA? & $?:E ,EKB; % /7B;DJ?D; $ EOI;D $ %ED=D;9A;H &
+;:CED: 7J; E< :?IF;HI7DJI 7IIE9?7J;: M?J> J>; ;;FM7J;H !EH?PED E?B IF?BB DL
?HED ,9? -;9>DEB – >JJFI:E?EH=;IF
45 2 >;D %?K 0 %;? )EHJ;>7KBJ , *?D )EHEKI 8EHED D?JH?:; D7DEI>;;JI <EH
;<<;9J?L; M7J;H 9B;7D?D= '7J ECCKD >JJFI:E?EH=
D9ECCI
45 2 07D= # ; ! 27E !0 3>K ,! 2K !2 3>7E 2 3>K ! 0K
2 3>7D= % ,>? #EKB;>;7J;: =H7F>;D;MH7FF;: IFED=; ;D78B;I <7IJ 9B;7DKF
E< L?I9EKI 9HK:;E?B IF?BB '7J '7DEJ;9>DEB – >JJFI:E?EH=
DD7DE
45 # ; 07D= 1 2?D # 2K ?D= )EBO8;DPEN7P?D;<KD9J?ED7B?P;: C;B7C?D;
IFED=;I M?J> ;D>7D9;: I;B;9J?L; 97F?BB7H?JO <EH ;<]9?;DJ E?B IF?BB 9B;7DKF , FFB
&7J;H "DJ;H<79;I – >JJFI:E?EH=79I7C?
8
45 # H?JJ+7ICKII;D )# H7D:L?A &;7IKH?D= ?=D?J78?B?JO <EH ?D I?JK 8KHD?D= E< E?B
IF?BBI M;7J>;H;: KD:;H H9J?9 9ED:?J?EDI <HEC B78EH7JEHO IJK:?;I JE B7H=;I97B;
];B: ;NF;H?C;DJI &7H )EBBKJ KBB – >JJFI:E?EH=
@C7HFEB8KB
45 / HE@; $;BB;H "CFHEL;: C;9>7D?97B E?B IF?BB H;9EL;HO KI?D= 7D EFJ?C?P;:
=;EC;JHO <EH J>; IA?CC;H IKH<79; DL?HED ,9? -;9>DEB –
>JJFI:E?EH=;IC
45 +$ KFJ7 # KD:;H:7B; &0 D=B7D: !EPKC? (?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED J;9>
D?GK;I 7 H;L?;M E< H;9;DJ FHE=H;II;I 7D: <KJKH; :?H;9J?EDI # &7J;H >;C
&7J;H D;H=O ,KIJ7?D – >JJFI:E?EH=
9J7>
45 # 3>7D= 3>7D= # ,ED= % %?K 2 ,? # 2K ?D= B;9JHEIFKD ^;N?8B;
D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED # &7J;H >;C >JJFI
:E?EH=-
45 % !EK ' 07D= # 0K 3 K? % #?7D= 2 3>7E ?E?DIF?H;: IKF;HM;JJ78?B?JO
;B;9JHEIFKD &?9HE'7DE]8;HI 7D: J>;?H 7FFB?97J?EDI :L KD9J &7J;H
– >JJFI:E?EH=7:<C
45 0 &7 * 3>7D= !K7 + 1?ED= # 3>7E 0 +7E , !K7D= 1 3>7D >;D
!K7D= B;9JHEIFKD ]8;HI <EH E?B–M7J;H I;F7H7J?ED +, :L
– >JJFI:E?EH=+
45 2 07D= %7? 1 07D= 2 %?K ! !K 2 KE $ &7 ;? #! 1?D
;7:IED,JH?D= IJHK9JKH;: D7DE]8;HI <EH IC7HJ 7D: H;L;HI?8B; (?B07J;H I;F7H7
J?ED M?J> EKJIJ7D:?D= 7DJ?<EKB?D= FHEF;HJO , FFB &7J;H "DJ;H<79;I
– >JJFI:E?EH=79I7C?8
45 & 3>7D= 0 &7 , 0K -7D= # K? * 3>7D= >;D + 1?ED= !K7D=
B;9JHEIFKD <HE=IF7MD IJHK9JKH;: C;C8H7D; <EH =H7L?JO:H?L;D E?BM7J;H I;F7H7
J?ED # EBBE?: "DJ;H<79; ,9? – >JJFI:E?EH=@@9?I
45 0 &7 3 KE # 3>7E * 2K 07D= # !7D ! )7D # 27E * 3>7D= ,$
,7C7B , ; ,C;:J !K7D= )EBO?C?:;9;BBKBEI; 79;J7J; 9EH;I>;BB ;B;9JHE
IFKD ]8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED ,;F )KH?< -;9>DEB
– >JJFI:E?EH=@I;FFKH
45 0 7D= % %?K KE -KD78B; M;JJ78?B?JO E< ;B;9JHEIFKD )EBOKH;J>7D;,?B?97
9ECFEI?J; C;C8H7D;I <EH ;<<;9J?L; I;F7H7J?ED E< M7J;H?D(?B 7D: E?B?D07J;H
;CKBI?EDI >;C KH # – >JJFI:E?EH=
9>;C
45 + + ,) ,KD:7H7D # , J>?O7D7J>?B 78H?97J?ED E< IKF;H>O:HEF>E8?9
FEBO97FHEB79JED;8;;IM7N ;B;9JHEIFKD C;C8H7D;I <EH >?=>;<]9?;D9O E?BM7J;H
I;F7H7J?ED +, :L – >JJFI:E?EH=+#
45 2 #?D= % 3>7D= + !K7D= 7? ! 7? * 3>7D= * K .BJH7>?=>F;H<EH
C7D9; ;B;9JHEIFKD FEBOB79J?:; C;C8H7D;I M?J> ;N9;BB;DJ E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED
78?B?JO L?7 ?DJ;H<79?7B IJ;H;E9ECFB;N 9HOIJ7BB?P7J?ED # &7J;H >;C
– >JJFI:E?EH=-
45 3 3>K 0 07D= *? 2 %KE 2 %?K 2 1K K? 07D= 1 >;D 7B9?D78B;
FEBOC;H C;C8H7D; M?J> H;L?L78?B?JO <EH ;<]9?;DJ E?BOM7J;H H;C;:?7J?ED :L
&7J;H >JJFI:E?EH=7:C7
45 )$ ,EM + "I>?J7 ,?D=>7B ,KIJ7?D78B; 7FFHE79> JE H;9O9B; M7IJ; FEBOIJOH;D; JE
>?=>L7BK; IK8C?9HED ]8;HI KI?D= IEBKJ?ED 8BEM IF?DD?D= 7D: 7FFB?97J?ED JEM7H:I
E?BM7J;H I;F7H7J?ED # DL?HED >;C D= >JJFI:E?EH=@
@;9;
45 0 %?K & K? 2 ,>;D 3>K % %KE & %? # %? 07IJ; 9?=7H;JJ; ]BJ;H 7I D7DE]
8HEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH ED:;C7D: ?CC?I9?8B; E?BM7J;H C?NJKH;I 7D: ;CKBI?EDI
I;F7H7J?ED # EBBE?: "DJ;H<79; ,9? >JJFI:E?EH=@@9?I
45 , %7L?BB; & -7OBEH &?BB?ED EJJB;I 7 &?DKJ; 0EHB:’I )B7IJ?9 ?D=; “7I 7D=;H
EKI I B?C7J; >7D=;” K7H: ?D >JJFIMMMJ>;=K7H:?7D9EC;DL?HEDC;DJ
@KD7C?BB?ED7C?DKJ;MEHB:IFB
45 E>;D " +7O ->; =BE87B H?IAI E< ?D9H;7I?D= H;B?7D9; ED 8EJJB;: M7J;H '7J ,KI
J7?D – >JJFI:E?EH=I
45 & WHW &$ QK8KA HIB7D , 7HP7D?7D ` ?B?9? D 7FFHE79> JE J>; KI7=;
E< FEBO;J>OB;D; J;H;F>J>7B7J; )- M7IJ; 7I HE7:M7O F7L;C;DJ C7J;H?7B # !7P
7H: &7J;H – >JJFI:E?EH=@@>7PC7J
45 1 %?D # 2K ! %? #2$ %7C $ ,>?> "&% ,>7C $2 %;KD= +;9O9B?D= FEBO
;J>OB;D; J;H;F>J>7B7J; M7IJ;I 7I I>EHJ ]8;HI ?D ,JH7?D!7H:;D?D= ;C;DJ?J?EKI
ECFEI?J;I ,! # !7P7H: &7J;H – >JJFI:E?EH=
@@>7PC7J
45 "' ,JH7?D * 0K & )EKHH7>?C? &, !;:;DGL?IJ +- (BIIED +% D:;HIIED
B;9JHEIF?DD?D= E< H;9O9B;: )- JE =;D;H7J; JEK=> C;IECEHF>?9 ]8H; C;C8H7D;I
<EH ICEA; ]BJH7J?ED # &7J;H >;C – >JJFI:E?EH=
-!
45 ' 37D:;H & ?BB7D ,M;;JI;H +;9O9B;: )- D7DE]8;HI <EH M7J;H ]BJH7J?ED
7FFB?97J?EDI &7J;H?7BI 7I;B – >JJFI:E?EH=
C7
45 & 3>7D= 0 &7 # K? , 0K # !7D 2 3EK !K7D= !O:HEJ>;HC7B IODJ>;
I?P;: ./H;I?IJ7D9; 7D: JH7DIF7H;DJ 9E7J?D= 9ECFEI?J;: IKF;HEBE;F>?B?9 ;B;9JHE
IFKD C;C8H7D; <EH >?=> ;<]9?;D9O E?BO M7IJ;M7J;H JH;7JC;DJ # !7P7H: &7J;H
>JJFI:E?EH=@@>7PC7J
45 # ; # 3>7D= 07D= 3 %? # 2K ?D= ,KF;H>O:HEF>?B?9 7D: KD:;HM7J;H
IKF;HEB;EF>E8?9 D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D; M?J> >?;H7H9>?97B IJHK9JKH;: IA?D <EH ;<<;9
J?L; E?B?DM7J;H ;CKBI?ED I;F7H7J?ED # &7J;H >;C – >JJFI
:E?EH=9J77
45 # ; 3ED= * #?D # 2K ?D= ?EC?C;J?9 7D: IKF;HM;JJ78B; D7DE]8HEKI
IA?DI <EH >?=>BO ;<]9?;DJ I;F7H7J?ED E< E?B?D07J;H ;CKBI?EDI :L KD9J &7J;H
– >JJFI:E?EH=7:<C
45 3 3>K 0 07D= *? 2 %KE 2 %?K 2 1K K? 07D= 1 >;D 7B9?D78B;
FEBOC;H C;C8H7D; M?J> H;L?L78?B?JO <EH ;<]9?;DJ E?BOM7J;H H;C;:?7J?ED :L
&7J;H – >JJFI:E?EH=7:C7
45 2 %? 3 3>K # 2K ?D= 7H8ED D7DEJK8;I ;D>7D9;: ^KEH?D7J;: FEBOKH;J>7D;
C79HEFEHEKI C;C8H7D;I <EH M7J;HFHEE< 7D: 8H;7J>78B; 7FFB?97J?ED , FFB
&7J;H "DJ;H<79;I – >JJFI:E?EH=79I7C?
8
45 RPT7C $ ]C;DAE # ;DP;H <<;9J E< KBJH7L?EB;JEPED; JH;7JC;DJ ED J>;
IKH<79; 7D: 8KBA FHEF;HJ?;I E< FEBO:?C;J>OB I?BEN7D; 7D: FEBOL?DOBC;J>OB I?BEN
7D; D;JMEHAI )EBOC;H K?B:< – >JJFI:E?EH=
@FEBOC;H
45 # EDPSB;P+?L;H7 + "=B?E 7H?BB7HE K9; &+ -?DU ,JHK9JKH7B 7D: J>;H
CE7D7BOJ?97B 9>7H79J;H?P7J?ED E< FEHEKI )&, <E7C C7J;H?7BI ->; ;<<;9J E< ?C
FKH?J?;I :;H?L;: <HEC 7 IK=7H J;CFB7J?D= FHE9;II )EBOC;HI 7I;B –
>JJFI:E?EH=FEBOC
45 $ ]C;DAE 0 07BB79; # ;DP;H ,KH<79; CE:?]97J?ED E< ,OB=7H: FEBO:?
C;J>OB I?BEN7D; D;JMEHAI 8O KBJH7L?EB;J 7D: KBJH7L?EB;JEPED; JH;7JC;DJ # EB
BE?: "DJ;H<79; ,9? – >JJFI:E?EH=@9?I
45 )) /E !' E7D $ $?D7I>? 0 ,7A7? ' -IKJIKC? ) !KOD> ;DJH?<K=7BBO
IFKD H;9O9B;: )- FHE9;II?D= 7D: 9>7H79J;H?P7J?ED )EBOC;HI 7I;B
>JJFI:E?EH=FEBOC
45 $ $EJ7 $MED 0 >E? #& &78HO -KJ;@7 !O=HEH;IFEDI?L; C;C8H7D;I
<EH ;<<;9J?L; E?B–M7J;H I;F7H7J?ED '7J ECCKD >JJFI:E?EH=
D9ECCI
45 # ; # 3>7D= 07D= 3 %? # 2K ?D= ,KF;H>O:HEF>?B?9 7D: KD:;HM7J;H
IKF;HEB;EF>E8?9 D7DE]8HEKI C;C8H7D; M?J> >?;H7H9>?97B IJHK9JKH;: IA?D <EH ;<<;9
J?L; E?B?DM7J;H ;CKBI?ED I;F7H7J?ED # &7J;H >;C – >JJFI
:E?EH=9J77
45 >;D 0;D= &7>CEE: , >;D # 07D= ,;F7H7J?ED C;9>7D?IC 7D: 9ED
IJHK9J?ED E< IKH<79;I M?J> IF;9?7B M;JJ78?B?JO <EH (?B07J;H I;F7H7J?ED , FFB
&7J;H "DJ;H<79;I – >JJFI:E?EH=79I7C?
8
UNCORRECTED PROOF
H.N. Doan et al. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering xxx (xxxx) xxx-xxx
45 -, 0ED= ,! $7D= ,$2 -7D= # ,COJ>; !7JJED H?DJ>7B # ?P;D
8;H= ?E?DIF?H;: I;B<H;F7?H?D= IB?FF;HO IKH<79;I M?J> FH;IIKH;IJ78B; ECD?F>E8?9
?JO '7JKH; – >JJFI:E?EH=D7JKH;
45 & -;D@?C87O7I>? #2 )7HA # &KJE 2 $E87O7I>? + 2EI>?A7M7 2 &EDD7? ,
,>?H7JEH? "D I?JK <EHC7J?ED E< IB?FF;HOB?GK?:"D<KI;: D7DE]8HEKI IKH<79; <EH
7 JH7DIF7H;DJ 7DJ?<EKB?D= ;D:EI9EF; %;DI 79I 8?EC7J;H ,9? D= >JJFI
:E?EH=79I8?EC7J;H?7BI8 79I8?EC7J;H?7BI8
45 - "I\A && ;C?H -7?BEH;: ;B;9JHEIFKD ]8;HI <HEC M7IJ; FEBOIJOH;D; <EH >?=> E?B
7:IEHFJ?ED ,KIJ7?D &7J;H -;9>DEB ;>JJFI:E?EH=@
IKIC7J;