ArticlePDF Available

In search a medical tourism marketing pattern in Iran: The case of cultural sensitivities

Authors:

Abstract

Health tourism has a significant financial benefit in the current industrial world. In addition, attention is being paid to the medical and cultural sensitivities in the development of the medical tourism industry, which increases the willingness of foreign patients to receive health care and treatment. The purpose of this study was to investigate the role and importance of the factor of paying attention to the medical and cultural sensitivities of international patients in the proposed pattern of medical tourism marketing. In the stage of exploratory factor analysis, the proposed pattern including 9 factors with 60 items after confirmatory factor analysis confirmed and the ‘attention to the cultural and medical sensitivities’ factor with 6 variables ranked 8 among other factors. Regarding the issue of medical and cultural sensitivities of foreign patients, it can be expected that patients will be more intimate and sympathetic during admission to medical centres and receive health care services, which will increase their sense of security and trust towards health workers. Healthcare activists and government officials are expected to give special attention to the cultural and medical sensitivities in developing short-term and long-term plans for the development of the health tourism industry.
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=yjhm20
International Journal of Healthcare Management
ISSN: 2047-9700 (Print) 2047-9719 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/yjhm20
In search a medical tourism marketing pattern in
Iran: The case of cultural sensitivities
Fatemeh Najafipour Moghadam, Irvan Masoudi Asl, Somayeh Hessam &
Mahmoud Mahmoudi Farahani
To cite this article: Fatemeh Najafipour Moghadam, Irvan Masoudi Asl, Somayeh Hessam
& Mahmoud Mahmoudi Farahani (2020): In search a medical tourism marketing pattern in
Iran: The case of cultural sensitivities, International Journal of Healthcare Management, DOI:
10.1080/20479700.2020.1732647
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/20479700.2020.1732647
Published online: 26 Feb 2020.
Submit your article to this journal
Article views: 25
View related articles
View Crossmark data
In search a medical tourism marketing pattern in Iran: The case of cultural
sensitivities
Fatemeh Najapour Moghadam
a
, Irvan Masoudi Asl
b
, Somayeh Hessam
c
and
Mahmoud Mahmoudi Farahani
d
a
South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran;
b
Department of healthcare Services Management, School of Health
Management and Information Sciences, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran;
c
Department of Health Care Management, South
Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran;
d
Department of Biostatistics, Research Center, Tehran University of Technology,
Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT
Health tourism has a signicant nancial benet in the current industrial world. In addition,
attention is being paid to the medical and cultural sensitivities in the development of the
medical tourism industry, which increases the willingness of foreign patients to receive
health care and treatment. The purpose of this study was to investigate the role and
importance of the factor of paying attention to the medical and cultural sensitivities of
international patients in the proposed pattern of medical tourism marketing. In the stage of
exploratory factor analysis, the proposed pattern including 9 factors with 60 items after
conrmatory factor analysis conrmed and the attention to the cultural and medical
sensitivitiesfactor with 6 variables ranked 8 among other factors. Regarding the issue of
medical and cultural sensitivities of foreign patients, it can be expected that patients will be
more intimate and sympathetic during admission to medical centres and receive health care
services, which will increase their sense of security and trust towards health workers.
Healthcare activists and government ocials are expected to give special attention to the
cultural and medical sensitivities in developing short-term and long-term plans for the
development of the health tourism industry.
ARTICLE HISTORY
Received 2 July 2019
Accepted 9 February 2020
KEYWORDS
Cultural sensitivity; health
tourism; medical tourism
marketing; marketing;
pattern; Iran
Introduction
Tourism produces positive eects on the economy,
society, culture, and environment including its con-
tribution to GDP, improvements to infrastructure,
the protection and renaissance of culture and
increases in environmental awareness [1]. Medical
Tourism has been favoured by health care providers
in other countries around the world trying to attract
and accommodate medical travellers. As a result,
there has been a growing concern for the creation
of professional standards to protect the quality and
safety of patient care and the types of business
opportunities that are available in this new industry
[2]. As far as supply factors are concerned, hospital
accreditation, geographical distance, and cultural
familiarity emerge as important determinants of des-
tination country selection in the literature by
patients; moreover, geographically and culturally
related issues are often analyzed in conjunction
with other factors that aect international medical
tourism. Although the nature of marketing of tour-
ism services is dierent from those of other services
such as banking or transportation, all the P10 items
of McCarthy (1975) including product, price,
location/distribution and promotion, individuals,
physical evidence and processes, participation, perso-
nalization, can be extended to the health tourism
industry [3].
In Iran, in order to solve the problems caused by
dependence on oil exports, it is necessary to invest in
the production and export of those products and ser-
vices that can generate foreign exchange earnings. In
some cases, the country has a set of dened products
and services that can be converted into the capital by
investment and can be used as a source of currency
income [4]. According to the2017 World Economic
Forum (WEF), with 5.2 million international tourists
entering Iran, about $ 3.5 million has been paid by
them [5]. Iranian tourism industry despite enormous
potentials has faced a number of challenges including
wide-ranging nuclear-related sanctions, the negative
public image in the Western countries and lack of eec-
tive management of resources [6]. Moreover, the devel-
opment of this industry itself will promote the quality
of the services of hospitals and treatment, and create
employment in the health sectors and archive the
world standards leading to earning incomes and
foreign exchange and economic, social, cultural and
political prosperity in the country [7]. However, the
lack of coverage of health insurance, the lack of trans-
parency of costs, and the lack of medical packages that
© 2020 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
CONTACT Irvan Masoudi Asl drirvanmasoodiasl@yahoo.com Department of healthcare Services Management, School of Health Management and
Information Sciences, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT
https://doi.org/10.1080/20479700.2020.1732647
are barriers to medical travel have been challenging
providing facilities such as hoteling facilities,
interpreter, transportation, tourist tours, and defects
of the hospitals surveyed [7].
Medical tourism represents a growing health care
market, and this group of travellers presents unique
challenges for public health and clinical medicine. In
addition to traditional travel health recommendations,
medical tourists have unique health needs and should
be advised accordingly. Some of these needs include
ensuring current medical conditions are stable enough
for travel and the need for appropriate follow-up care
after procedures [8]. Results contribute to the limited
empirical research on the consumer dynamics and
underpinnings of an industry experiencing rapid
growth in an environment of signicant change and
uncertainty. Findings may also assist medical tourism
marketers to serve those already inclined to travel
abroad for healthcare services better, and to create
more favourable predispositions among those not cur-
rently inclined to do so [9]. Of course, this type of tour-
ism is due to the sensitivity of the health of individuals
to the required standards, including the availability of
technical and scientic knowledge, as well as medical
and therapeutic infrastructure. The goals for this type
of travel should be meeting these standards as a prere-
quisite for their success in attracting tourists from their
perspective [10]. Culture is seen as a pathway to the
transformative social practices, where individuals
transform their previously xed behaviours in dierent
transnational contexts. In simple language cultural
diversity can be understood in many dierent ways.
It is often referred to like the mixture of dierent
human groups societies or cultures in a specic geogra-
phy or in the Globe (as a whole). The diversity could
also be understood by dierences in race ethnicity
nationality religion or language among various groups
within a community organization or nation. Individual
values beliefs customs traditions and backgrounds also
bring cultural diversity [11]. Considering the impor-
tance of marketing in the prosperity of health tourism
and limited research, it was attempted to identify the
medical and cultural factors along with other factors
to design a marketing pattern appropriate to the struc-
ture of existing rules and resources. The present study
was applied in a descriptive-correlational and cross-
sectional study aiming for the investigation of the
importance of medical and cultural sensitivities in the
proposed medical tourism-marketing pattern.
Methodology
The present study was applied using a descriptive-cor-
relational and cross-sectional study. The statistical
population consisted of all the people working in the
medical universities of the country in the eld of health
tourism: 630 active people in the eld of health tourism
were selected by simple random sampling. A
researcher-made questionnaire was used to collect the
research data. The questionnaire was developed based
on an interview with experts and tourism activists in
the eld of marketing and tourism with the Likert
scale in a completely opposite = 1, opposite = 2, neither
agree nor disagree = 3, agree = 4, totally agree = 5. To
assess the validity of the content of the questionnaire,
from the viewpoint of professors, experts, and for
determining the content validity, quantitatively, two
content validity coecients (CVR) were higher than
0.62 and Content Validity Index (CVI) was higher
than 0.79. Cronbachs alpha coecient (0.82) and test
re-test and correlation (0.92) were used to assess the
reliability of the questionnaire(N=40).
After conrmation of the validity and reliability, 630
questionnaires were completed. In order to verify the
validity of the proposed conceptual pattern, factor
analysis was used that was conducted in two explora-
tory factor analysis and conrmatory factor analysis
(second-order). After performing the exploratory fac-
tor analysis, 9 components and 60 items whose factor
load was above 0.3were extracted. After the corrections
were made in the original conceptual pattern, the vali-
dated factors were extracted from the conrmatory fac-
tor analysis of LISREL 8.8. Goodness-t indicators for
all components, the calculation of the suggested pattern
for health tourism marketing was conrmed.
Findings
The results of the sample suciency test
(Bartlett)
In this research, in order to examine the existence of
the conditions for factor analysis, assuming the society
is normal, and the sampling accuracy index (KMO)
and Bartletts test have been used. The results of this
test showed that due to the lower level of a signicance
level of Bartlett test, the correlation between the terms
is appropriate for 0.05, and with KMO index larger
than 0.6, the number of samples is sucient for factor
analysis (Table 1).
Results of exploratory factor analysis
At this stage, the responses of the samples were entered
into SPSS version 22. Items with a factor load above 0.3
were selected for the continuation of the analysis and
the factor loads below 0.3 were not considered. Accord-
ing to these results, 3 items of the analysis process were
eliminated. The results are presented in Table 2.
Table 1. KMO and Bartlett tests.
sampling adequacy index(KMO) df χ
2
Signicance level
0.712 1953 30457.296 0.001
2F. N. MOGHADAM ET AL.
As shown in Table 3, the contribution of the rst
factor with a special value of 15.76 and a 25.02% var-
iance is very signicant, and the contribution of the
other factors is quite distinct. All of the indicators of
the questionnaire consisted of 9 main factors and
explained %57.22 of the total variance.
As shown in Table 4, all factor loads are larger than
0.5 and are %95 reliable in the condence level, so all
items remain in the model and there is no reason to
remove them.
The results of Table 5 conrm the divergent validity
of all variables in the model. It is worth mentioning
that the divergent validity is calculated for variables
that are directly measured by the questions of the ques-
tionnaire and do not include the second to the top, and
all factor loads are larger than 0.5 and are %95 reliable
in the condence level, so all items remain in the model
and there is no reason to remove them [12].
According to Table 6, estimated values for pattern
tting indices show that research data with factor
structure and theoretical basis of the research is appro-
priate to t, which indicates that the questions are con-
sistent with the theoretical constructs; therefore, the
proposed pattern can be conrmed.
The study results indicated that nine factors (pro-
motion, procedures and methods, partnership, phys-
ical evidences, medical package, product, paying
attention to cultural and medical sensitivities, cost
and people) were found eective in the Iranian ver-
sion of medical tourism pattern on the development
of the medical tourism services oering(AVE: 0.64,
CR: 0.966and Cronbachs alpha: 0.941). Based on
the results, the factor of paying attention to the medi-
cal and cultural sensitivity with 6 components (Table
4) ranked 8 in the proposed pattern and, according
to Table 5, has indicators (AVE: 0.575, CR:
0.888and Cronbachs alpha: 0.854). Thus, our data,
based on the tness indicators, have conrmed the
role of paying attention to the cultural and medical
sensitivity factor along with other factors in the pro-
posed pattern, and the proposed structure is
conrmed [12].
Discussion
Our ndings show the role and importance of the
factor of paying attention to the medical and cultural
sensitivities along with other factors in the proposed
pattern. According to Pakjou research, policies and
interests, traditions, cultures, and customers are tar-
gets that should be up to standards before reaching
the intentions of tourists. With a wide range of reli-
gious, ideological, philosophical ethical backgrounds,
Iran can set new standards in services and medical
tourism [13]. Findings of the literature of Khan and
et al., a review suggests that Medical Touristsper-
ceived risks about destination and travel motivations
Table 2. The matrix of rotating agents after turning in the varimax.
Factor1
Factor
loading Factor2
Factor
loading Factor3
Factor
loading Factor4
Factor
loading Factor5
Factor
loading Factor6
Factor
loading Factor7
Factor
loading Factor8
Factor
loading Factor9
Factor
loading
Q42 0.719 Q38 0.785 Q47 0.806 Q28 0.373 Q54 0.854 Q22 0.686 Q62 0.811 Q2 0.736 Q20 0.728
Q27 0.706 Q37 0.733 Q49 0.795 Q29 0.419 Q55 0.687 Q21 0.646 Q63 0.797 Q4 0.735 Q23 0.487
Q41 0.686 Q39 0.686 Q48 0.608 Q16 0.749 Q56 0.677 Q18 0.53 Q60 0.491 Q1 0.718 Q24 0.440
Q43 0.525 Q36 0.603 Q46 0.576 Q19 0.674 Q52 0.68 Q57 0.529 Q58 0.542 Q5 0.424 Q17 0.495
Q44 0.498 Q34 0.504 Q50 0.538 Q53 0.42 Q14 0.517 Q61 0.41 Q6 0.678 Q25 0.602
Q45 0.449 Q40 0.473 Q51 0.484 Q11 0.405 Q59 0.508
Q30 0.733 Q10 0.625 Q15 0.428
Q26 0.463 Q12 0.724 Q8 0.493
Q35 0.737
Q31 0.541
Q32 0.651
Q33 0.700
Q13 0.423
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT 3
will have an impact on the image of medical tourism
destinations [14].
There are many advantages in health tourism in
Iran, among which the most important ones are pro-
viding low-cost health care, short waiting times and
the highest quality of services and care, as well as the
most experienced specialists and the most up-to-date
technologies, access to biotechnology, biological
drugs, stem cells, and restoration, spinal cord injury
[15]. For instance, promoting Halal or Islamic tourism
would help in attracting lucrative Muslim tourist mar-
ket and embracing the rapidly changing dynamics of
global tourism, of which Halal tourism is an integral
part [16]. Tourism social entrepreneurship (TSE) is
suggested as a market-based strategy to address social
problems while maximizing the benets and minimiz-
ing the negative consequences that tourism may pro-
vide to the host communities. To date, there is a
limited understanding of how TSE can be a catalyst
for sustainable community development [17].
Table 3. Specic values and explained variances by the factors extracted from the exploratory factor analysis.
Special values of extracted factors before rotation Special values of extracted factors after rotation
factor
special
amount
%Variance
explained
%Cumulative of variance
explained
special
amount
%Variance
explained
%Cumulativeof variance
explained
1 15.76 25.02 25.02 6.26 9.94 9.94
2 4.111 6.52 31.54 6.13 9.73 19.67
3 3.31 5.25 36.79 4.47 7.09 26.76
4 2.72 4.31 41.1 3.91 6.20 32.96
5 2.46 3.91 44.99 3.56 5.61 38.57
6 2.15 3.41 48.41 3.42 5.43 44.01
7 2.10 3.17 51.58 3.08 4.88 48.89
8 1.79 2.84 54.42 2.75 4.36 53.24
9 1.77 2.81 57.22 2.51 3.98 57.22
Table 4. Convergent validity (second-order factor loads and AVE index) and reliability (Cronbachs alpha and CR).
Main variable Component
Convergent Validity Reliability
Second -factor
analysis
Rank in
pattern R
2
t-
value AVE CR
Cronbachs
alpha
Marketing of medical tourism
services pattern
Promotion 0.98 1 0.96 20.65 0.64 0.966 0.941
Procedures 0.88 4 0.77 17.50
Partnership 0.48 9 0.23 9.82
Evidence 0.83 5 0.69 16.13
Medical Package 0.77 6 0.59 16.74
Product 0.91 2 0.83 17.83
Medical and Cultural
Sensitivity
0.55 8 0.3 9.65
Cost 0.75 7 0.56 14.75
People 0.91 3 0.83 22.79
Table 5. Standardized coecients and the signicant number of pay attention to the medical and cultural factor of medical tourism
services marketing pattern.
Hidden variable Apparent variable
Convergent Validity Reliability
λR2
t-
Value AVE CR Cronbachsalpha
Medical and
cultural
sensitivity
In the provision of health, there is pay attention in oering treatment and
healthcare services to international patients to their clinical histories
(medicinal allergies, past record of special diseases and so forth) and the
documents are kept in this regard.
0.5 0.25 - 0.575 0.888 0.854
Healthcare and treatment services are oered to international patients
based on necessity and minimum side eects.
0.63 0.40 11.06
In Iran, it is easy to prepare Halal food. 0.93 0.86 13.18
Disclosing the patients secrets and providing information about the
treatment to others (without the consent of the patient or his guardian)
is prohibited.
0.82 0.67 12.61
Cultural dierences are considered in verbal communication (using a
translator or assigning a uent English speaking sta) as well as non-
verbal communication.
0.77 0.59 12.27
There are enough facilities for performing religious practices for followers
of all divine religions in Iran.
0.62 0.38 11.03
Table 6. Indicators of tting the factors of medical tourism
services pattern in Iran.
Index name Basic model Modied model Allowed range
χ
2
5.568 2.758 3>
)GFI) 0.78 0.85 0.8=<
)AGFI) 0.73 0.81 0.8=<
)RMSEA) 0.165 0.068 0.10>
)CFI) 0.85 0.96 0.9=<
)NFI) 0.84 0.90 0.9=<
)NNFI) 0.84 0.92 0.9=<
)IFI) 0.85 0.96 0.9=<
4F. N. MOGHADAM ET AL.
According to Momeni et al., to obtain competitive
advantages, Iran needs to implement long-term plans
to strengthen infrastructures and cultural reforms.
Further participation of the private sector is required
to strengthen the infrastructures and plan for a more
ecient application of mass media and local and pro-
vincial press to enhance awareness and cultural reform.
Finally, systematic plans with broker phenomenon and
enforcing hospitals from the perspective of inter-
national accreditation should be included in the agenda
of medical tourism authorities [18].
Culture is seen as a pathway to the transformative
social practices, where individuals transform their
previously xed behaviours in dierent transna-
tional contexts. Women transmitted local knowledge
by customizing trips to meet their guestsvarious
needs and interests as well as engage in the cultural
transformation. Visits from the homeland leading to
tourism activities turned mobile women into hosts,
tourists, and tourist-agents conrming the signi-
cance of tourism for women as a vehicle for empow-
erment [19]. Business programmes are expected to
perform with cultural sensitivity in international
and intercultural professional environments [20]. It
is preferable for a female Muslim to be cared for
by females and a male Muslim by males. This is
most important during connement when strict
privacy is very essential. Only female health workers
should be present and exposure should be kept to a
minimum [11].
Today, the medical tourism industry has an esti-
mated growth rate of up to 25% year-over-year for
the next 10 years and it is estimated that 34% of
the worlds population will travel internationally for
healthcare [21]. In recent years, policymakers have
begun to embrace behavioural economics to make
interventions for human behaviour and decision
making [22]. The most frequently mentioned
demand factors are the relatively high cost of medical
care in the origin country and the quality of medical
care in comparison with that of the destination
country. As far as supply factors are concerned, hos-
pital accreditation, geographical distance, and cultural
familiarity emerge as important determinants of des-
tination country selection in the literature by
patients; moreover, geographically and culturally
related issues are often analyzed in conjunction
with other factors that aect international medical
tourism [3]. Dierent industries use various market-
ing strategies to attract clients and make more
prot. Also, the development of this industry itself
will promote the quality of the services of hospitals
and treatment creating the employment in the coun-
trys health sector achieving world standards, and
ultimately leading to earning income and foreign
exchange and economic, social, cultural and political
prosperity in the country [7].
Today there is great receptiveness towards Medical
Tourism. When patients are travelling overseas there
is an emergence of new consumers and they show a
completely dierent behaviour pattern. As a result of
developments in communication tools information
technology and increased social media exchanges,
they have been exposed to dierent cultures and devel-
oped new ideas and viewpoints [11].
Conclusion
According to our ndings and considering the impor-
tance of paying attention to the cultural and medical
sensitivity factorand its 6 components in the proposed
pattern of medical tourism marketing, including pay-
ing attention to the medical sensitivities and patient
clinical records,providing services with minimal
side eects and complications,preparing Halal
food,protecting the secrets of the patient,paying
attention to the cultural sensitivitiesin verbal and
non-verbal communication, providing facilities for
performing religious duties, it is expected that policy-
makers and planners pay special attention to the fac-
tors inuencing the development of tourism
marketing and promotion of this industry.
Globalization across all sectors has brought com-
plex cultural needs in an already culturally diverse
world. Understanding culture and behaviour was
important in healthcare to provide comprehensive
care with a delightful experience but it has certainly
become essential in Medical Tourism as patients
arrive with dierent cultural beliefs and from dier-
ent geographies. Understanding of Culture in Medi-
cal Tourism is a two-way process as the patient
needs to understand the destinations cultural beliefs
as much as providers need to know and understand
the patientscultural beliefs.
Given a large number of citizens of neighbouring
countries including Iraq, Afghanistan, Oman visit
Iran for pilgrimage, tourism and treatment each year,
it is important to pay attention to cultural and medical
sensitivities in the provision of health tourism services.
Paying attention to the medical and cultural sensi-
tivities associated with health care stawith foreign
patients leads to their trust in the medical staand
the consolidation of human and friendly relations. In
fact, it can be expected that with the special attention
of the providers of care services and medical care to
the cultural sensitivities of foreign patients, they will
feel empathy in receiving services, relax and have
more condence in their health, and in the eld of vis-
iting their country. They share their positive experi-
ences with relatives, friends, and others that this will
have a positive eect on attracting foreign patients. it
is suggested that Conducting communication courses
and paying attention to the cultural sensitivities of
foreign patients from neighbouring countries of Iran
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT 5
for receiving medical services will be very helpful in
facilitating the communication of medical stawith
foreign patients.
Contribution
Masoudi I, Hessam S, Mahmoudi Farahani M, and
Najapoor Moghadam F designed research; Masoudi
I, Hessam S, and Najapoor Moghadam F, conducted
research; Mahmoudi Farahani M, analyzed data; and
Najapoor Moghadam F, Masoudi I, Hessam S,
wrote the paper. Masoudi I, had primary responsibility
for nal content. All authors read and approved the
nal manuscript.
Disclosure statement
No potential conict of interest was reported by the
author(s).
Notes on contributors
Irvan Masoudiasl, Ph.D. in Health service management,
Department of healthcare Services Management, School of
Health Management and Information Sciences, Iran Univer-
sity of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Fatemeh Najapour Moghadam, Ph.D. Student in Health
Service Management, South Tehran
Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. Her work
and research interests include cultural sensitivity in medical
tourism.
Somayeh Hessam, Assistant Professor, Department of health
service administration, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad
University, Tehran, Iran. Her work and research interests
include the eectiveness of cultural sensitivity in medical
tourism.
Mahmoud Mahmoudi Farahani,Professor, Department of
Biostatistics, Research Center, Tehran University of Tech-
nology, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. His research
interests include the impact of biostatistical research on
healthcare management practices in medical tourism.
ORCID
Fatemeh Najapour Moghadam http://orcid.org/0000-
0001-8466-6456
References
[1] Wang L, Yotsumoto Y. Conict in tourism develop-
ment in rural China. Tourism Management.
2019;70:188200.
[2] Sandberg DS. Medical tourism: an emerging global
healthcare industry. Int J Healthc Manag. 2017;10
(4):281288.
[3] Medhekar A. Public-private partnerships for inclusive
development: role of private corporate sector in
provision of healthcare services. Procedia - Social and
Behavioral Sciences. 2014;157:3344.
[4] Hopkins L LR, Runnels V, Packer C. Medical tourism
today. Public Health Policy. 2010;31(2):185198.
[5] forum We. Global Competitiveness Index 2018.
[6] Khodadadi M. Challenges and opportunities for tour-
ism development in Iran: perspectives of Iranian tour-
ism suppliers. Tourism Management Perspectives.
2016;19:9092.
[7] Nasiri Pour AAS. Leila the power of Tehran hospitals
in the development of therapeutic tourism. Hospital
Prole. Medical Tourism. 2013;35(30):2534.
[8] Gaines J, Lee CV. 39 - Medical tourism. In: Keystone
JS, Kozarsky PE, Connor BA, Nothdurft HD,
Mendelson M, Leder K, editor. Travel medicine (4th
Ed.). London: Elsevier; 2019. p. 371375.
[9] Guy BS, Henson JLN, Dotson MJ. Characteristics of
consumers likely and unlikely to participate in medical
tourism. Int J Healthc Manag. 2015;8(2):6876.
[10] Kazemi M. Study of the eective factors for attracting
medical tourism in Iran. In: Technology UO, editor.
Tourism ManagementUniversity of Technology;
2010.p.1115.
[11] Renée-Marie Stephano J. https://
wwwmedicaltourismmagcom/print-edition.
[12] Kalantari K. Structural equation modeling in socioeco-
nomic research. Tehran: Culture Saba Publishing;
2009.
[13] Pakjou A, Izadi M, Sh MP, et al. The pattern of travel
medicine ethics in an international cooperation pro-
gram of military medicine. J Military Medicine.
2011;13(2):15.
[14] Khan MJ, Chelliah S, Haron MS. Medical tourism des-
tination image formation process: A conceptual model.
Int J Healthc Manag. 2016;9(2):134143.
[15] Hassanpour M. A comparative study on the status of
health tourism in Iran and the world in order to formu-
late product development strategies. The Secretariat of
the Special Commerce Commission of Iran Chamber
of Commerce. 2014;69:68.
[16] Yousaf S, Xiucheng F. Halal culinary and tourism mar-
keting strategies on government websites: A prelimi-
nary analysis. Tourism Management. 2018;68:423
443.
[17] Aquino RS, Lück M, Schänzel HA. A conceptual fra-
mework of tourism social entrepreneurship for sus-
tainable community development. J Hosp Tourism
Manage. 2018;37:2332.
[18] Khalil M. An analysis of the competitive situation
medical tourism industry. IranBali Medical Journal.
2017;2:307316.
[19] Janta H, Christou A. Hosting as social practice:
Gendered insights into contemporary tourism mobili-
ties. Ann Tour Res. 2019;74:167176.
[20] Frank EJ. Teaching international business as an
Opportunity to Develop cultural sensitivity. J Teach
Int Bus. 2017;28(3-4):197211.
[21] Radovic Z, Nola IA. Medical tourism globe-trotting:
Features, impacts, and risks. Int J Healthc Manag.
2019;18:17.
[22] Park S, Hahn S, Lee T, et al. Two factor model of con-
sumer satisfaction: international tourism research.
Tour Manage. 2018;67:8288.
6F. N. MOGHADAM ET AL.
... As regards organizers of medical tourism, the set of innovative marketing activities is something that governmental agencies and destination officers, destination management organizations, DMOs (at the domestic, regional and local level), facilitators, clinic and hospital managers, tourist and hotel industry specialists and airline specialists are expected to know (e.g. Ağazade and Ergün, 2023;Crooks and Jin, 2022;Dryglas and Lubowiecki-Vikuk, 2019;Moghadam et al., 2021;Rydback, 2022). The presence of multi-stakeholders in the medical tourism market (Kamassi et al., 2020) and the variety of their interests aimed at satisfying the customer calls for partnership and cooperation in order to develop effective strategies of management and marketing for the businesses and destinations (e.g. ...
... Hyder et al. (2019) observed that such attributes may also complicate the understanding of attributes of credibility and, at the same time, institutional support may render attributes of credibility of healthcare more acceptable. In fact, the level of involvement in the network of institutions related to medical tourism may help to build trust and improve patient safety (Choi et al., 2015;Moghadam et al., 2021). Sousa and Alves (2019) suggested that medical tourism could be analyzed from the perspective of relationship marketing. ...
Chapter
Medical tourism marketing is usually focused on the promotion of individual medical tourism services or destinations. Discussions about the effective marketing strategy require a review of all instruments in the marketruing mix. The purpose of this chapter is to present the literature and analyze the synergy of the marketing mix from the viewpoint of the clinic/hospital, facilitators, and medical tourism destination. The VUCA concept that demonstrates that rules on devising marketing activities can be redefined will be the point of reference, thus making it possible to identify courses to be taken and recommendations for managers.
... Understanding culture and behaviour is of importance in healthcare about the provision of comprehensive care with a delightful experience, but it has certainly become essential in medical tourism because patients arrive with different cultural beliefs and from different geographies. Understanding culture in medical tourism is a two-way process as the patient needs to understand the destination's cultural beliefs as much as providers need to know and understand the patients' cultural beliefs (11). Examining such data is important to understand the level of customer satisfaction and demand. ...
... Healthcare activists and government officials are expected to give Special attention and emphasis to cultural and medical challenges in developing short-term and long-term plans for improving the health tourism industry (11). The medical tourism industry would not be developed without wellknown healthcare centers which popular for their therapeutic outcome, efficiency, patientcenteredness, responsive to governance and staff orientation (23). ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Medical tourism provides Effective economic, political and social profits to the countries active in the field, which should be taken into account in a competitive market. This study aimed to evaluate the relationship between foreign patients' satisfaction and other aspects of health tourism in educational and medical centers of the Iran University of Medical Sciences (IUMS). Methods: This was a descriptive correlational study with a researcher-made questionnaire. The first part of the questionnaire contained the demographic characteristics of the participants, and the second part included 30 questions about the components that affect receiving medical services by foreign nations. The reliability coefficient of the questionnaire was determined by using Cronbach's alpha (0.980). Expert judgment was used to assess the validity of the questionnaire. Out of 70 hospitals affiliated with the University of Iran in 2019, 10 hospitals from 35 licensed centers in the field of international health were randomly selected, and 300 questionnaires were delivered to foreign patients who were willing to complete the questionnaire. The received information was from Random sampling recorded in SPSS25 software. Descriptive Statistics was used to determine the effective factors. Results: The largest numbers of foreign patients in this study were from Iraq (64 %) and Kuwait (24 %), respectively. In correlation review, there was a significant relationship between satisfaction of foreign patients and financial dimension (0.785), quality of treatment dimension (0.914), medical facilities dimension (0.799) and tourism facilities dimension (0.918) in hospitals. Conclusion: This study demonstrates that there is a significant relationship between satisfaction of foreign patients and other aspects of health tourism (such as financial dimension, treatment quality, treatment and tourism facilities) in hospitals, Which needs to be given special attention by health tourism managers for short-term and long-term planning for its development.
... Cultural Sensitivities Moghadam et al. (2021) underscored the significance of cultural sensitivity in medical tourism marketing, emphasizing its role in building patient trust and enhancing healthcare experiences, calling for attention to cultural sensitivity in developing the health tourism industry. ...
... Based on the macroeconomic policies of the resistant economy, Iran has decided to invest in medical tourism (Momeni et al., 2018) to increase foreign exchange earnings and reduce its dependence on petroleum exports (Jabbari et al., 2013;Taheri et al., 2021). Despite numerous tourist attractions, modern health centers, specialized medical staff, low waiting time, and low cost of treatment (Hadian et al., 2021;Moghadam et al., 2020;Izadi et al., 2012), Iran has not yet been able to find a suitable position in this market. ...
Article
Full-text available
Using Fuzzy Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) method, this study sought to develop a framework to identify and prioritize the factors influencing the selection of Iran by medical tourists. After a literature review, three main dimensions and 38 factors affecting tourism destination choices were identified. A Fuzzy SWARA questionnaire was used to ask experts how important each of the identified factors was to a medical tourist’s choice of destination. In addition, medical tourists employed linguistic variables to assess the performance of the aforementioned factors. The results of the study revealed that “recommendations by friends and acquaintances,” ‘medical tourist’s previous experiences, ‘“image/brand of the host country”, “having friends or relatives in the destination country,” and “international accreditation” were the top priorities for Iran’s medical tourism policymakers and managers.
... The main reason for this notoriety is the fear of the people of the region from the arrival of tourists and the need to change the attitude of the people in the mentioned region towards illness and care. Moghadam et al. (2021) presented a marketing template in health tourism that investigated the impact of medical and cultural indices on foreign patients. The Survey community was selected as a random sample from all employees of medical universities in Iran who were active in the field of health tourism. ...
Article
Nowadays, the most successful and prominent wellness tourism centers are those that, consider the aspects of sustainable development, while providing memorable services with the best quality and reasonable prices. A wellness tourism center is seeking to meet the purposeful journey of wellness tourists by improving their mental, physical, and spiritual happiness. This paper presents a three-objective mathematical model to formulate the supply chain of services provided by a wellness tourism center. The purpose of this model is to establish a balance between sustainability aspects in this supply chain. The first objective seeks to maximize profits from the supply chain and the second and third objectives are to maximize customer satisfaction concerning environmental and social impacts. The proposed model includes quantitative parameters of operating costs, capacity increase cost, service capacity, and service demand. Due to the multi-objective nature of the model, the improved multi-choice goal programming method is used. Real data are collected from the Ardabil-Sarein wellness tourism center in Iran and used as a case study to validate and analyze the model. In collecting the dataset for the parameters, the three aspects of big data (3V’s) are considered. Findings show that the model offers different types of discounts for various periods following the tourist demand. Additionally, the wellness tourism center can use the original cost to expand its range of services by offering different tours. Finally, the limitations and managerial suggestions are discussed.
... 1017). In an exploratory factorial analysis, Moghadam et al. (2021) found that: ...
Article
Full-text available
There are several studies showing international hospital accreditation does have some impact on clinical standards and even bed occupancy rates. However, little is known about the impact on attracting more international medical tourists to hospitals that have received this distinction. It was expected, prior to the study, that participating in international accreditation might increase operational expenses and greater amounts of international patients would also boost patient volumes and profitability. However, this research found that the investment in accreditation led to insignificant changes (pre-accreditation versus post-accreditation) in operating profit margins (OPM), net profit margins (NPM), and the debt-to-equity (D/E) ratio. This suggests that international hospital accreditation has little impact on the financial aspects of the hospital's operations. It appears to be more of a signaling strategy than a recipe for growth. However, there may be some other tangible benefits of international accreditation (e.g., better medical/clinical outcomes).
... Besides, cultural similarities may influence the choice of destination. Geography, culture, language and religion play roles whereby medical tourism destinations cater to specific populations of medical tourists who prefer to obtain medical procedures in a familiar culture and background (73). Language and cultural factors also attract diaspora to return to their home countries to receive medical treatment (74)(75)(76). ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: This study aims to explore the Indonesian tourists' demand for medical tourism services in Malaysia. The study also investigates the Indonesian medical tourists' profiles and their preference for Malaysia for medical treatment services. Methods: This study conducted interviews with 49 potential patients from Indonesia who received cardiac treatment at the National Heart Institute (IJN) in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Results: The findings indicate that the key motives of Indonesian tourists travelling to Malaysia for medical treatment are their disappointment with medical practices and inadequate expertise in Indonesia. Besides, they are motivated by peer recommendations, medical expertise, transparency, administration and hospitality in Malaysia. The study findings show that Indonesian medical tourists can be acknowledged as an elite group with stable and above-average income. Conclusion: Results from the study enable medical tourism marketers to better target and segments their potential medical tourists and develop a strategic medical tourism marketing roadmap. This study shows that the high demand for medical tourism is related to Malaysia's availability of niche medical services. Besides, this paper expands the understanding of medical tourists' decision-making and argues its implications for Malaysian health policy and healthcare delivery for the medical tourism industry sustainability.
... According to a large amount of literature review [1][2][3][4][5][6][7], MT is a novel form of tourism, and it has become one of the fastestgrowing international businesses in the tourism industry for developing countries. Medical tourism has been emerging as a particularly lucrative sector, potential tourist market, and global phenomenon in health care. ...
Article
Full-text available
Medical tourism (MT) is the activity of traveling domestically or abroad to receive medical services. The scope of medical treatments covers dentistry, surgery, antiaging procedures, preventive medicine, and even some health-related treatments (meditation, physiotherapy, psychotherapy, addiction treatment, psychiatry, etc.). Due to the global boom in MT, governments are actively promoting MT packages to capture this huge business opportunity. However, what are the key factors that make MT development successful or unsuccessful? How can the performance of current MT operators be evaluated? And, how can the performance of underperforming operators be improved? This paper addresses these questions by proposing a MT assessment framework that summarizes the potential key factors of MT. In addition, this study proposes a model that integrates the Bayesian Best-Worst Method (Bayesian BWM) and grey Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluations based on Aspiration Level (grey PROMETHEE-AL) to assess the performance of assessed MT operators. The Bayesian BWM not only aggregates the judgments of multiple experts but also generates a set of objective group criteria weights. Besides, the modified PROMETHEE incorporates the grey theory and aspiration level concept to increase the usefulness of the original PROMETHEE. The results of the analysis show that the two most critical criteria for MT are “the operators have cloud computing systems to analyze the travelers’ sensor data in real-time and accurately to provide customized medical services” and “multilingualism and communication skills of medical travel-related personnel.” Poor performers in the travel industry can be improved by prioritizing the criteria in order of importance. The management implications of this study can be used as a basis for performance evaluation by operators and government health care organizations.
Article
Full-text available
By giving voice to highly-skilled mobile professional women who have relocated to Switzerland from various European countries, representing different nationalities, duration of migration and family circumstances, we shed light on the experiences of hosting – an under-researched segment of Visiting Friends and Relatives (VFR) mobilities. Our findings reveal a threefold investigation to sociality, tourism and mobility, by drawing on empirical insights to three angles: that of, culture, intimacy and identity as pathways to transformative social practices among hosts and guests. Highly-skilled mobile professional women’s hosting practices reflect a laboratory of sociality whereupon relations of closeness and proximity are tested under new conditions of social and private life in the new destination country.
Article
Full-text available
The continuous search for responsible and sustainable practices in the tourism industry paves the way for alternative approaches to tourism development. Often, local communities are at the foreground of these innovative tourism entrepreneurship and development strategies. The emergence of social enterprises operating in tourism refocuses the agenda of engaging and developing disadvantaged and underdeveloped communities sustainably through the industry. Tourism social entrepreneurship (TSE) is suggested as a market-based strategy to address social problems whilst maximising the benefits and minimising the negative consequences that tourism may provide to host communities. To date, there is limited understanding of how TSE can be a catalyst for sustainable community development. The purpose of this paper is to address this gap in knowledge by conceptualising TSE as a more holistic strategy for sustainable community development. By critically analysing the literature, this paper situates TSE within and for community development. A conceptual framework that incorporates community development concepts, generic social entrepreneurship and TSE principles, and community capitals perspectives, is proposed. This conceptual paper contributes to the emerging literature on TSE and may assist the actors in the TSE system as they establish new community-centric social enterprises.
Article
Full-text available
Background: Medical tourism is a relatively new concept where patients travel to a foreign destination to obtain quality medical treatments which much better or comparable and also available at a significantly lower cost. Though, a number of literature available with regard to the tourism industry and the competitiveness of the destination for medical tourists are hardly focused specifically in Northwest Iran. Purpose: The aim of this study is to determine the competitive status of East Azerbaijan province medical tourism industry. Materials and Method: It was a qualitative study which conducted in-depth interviews with 15 key stakeholders of the tourism industry in East Azerbaijan Province (North-West of Iran). Purposive sampling technique was used and the data analyzed by using framework analysis based on Porter's diamond model. Results: In the factory conditions, there are 8 sub-themes such as political and ideological attitudes, similarities of language, culture, restrictions on communication skills, and tourist attractions. In the demand conditions, there is fame of the physicians and the waiting time for receiving medical treatment. In the strategy for structure and rivalry, 7 sub-themes are included such as lack of hospitals approved by JCI, affordability of medical and tourism service prices, inefficient advertising system, and the strengthening medical tourism infrastructure in neighboring countries. Others regarding with supporting industries are poor tourism infrastructure, inadequate support of private sector, poor transfer of medical tourists, and Visa facilitation services. Conclusion: Long-term planning and involvement of private sector in strengthening the tourism infrastructure should be put at agenda in terms of making province’s medical tourism policy.
Article
This paper explores the phenomenon of conflict in tourism development in rural China. Four cases were selected and analyzed as part of this exploration. The study identified eight major conflict issues: land expropriation, ticket revenue distribution, vending rights, tourism management rights, house demolition, house building, entry restrictions, and village elections. The conflict evolution process indicates that these issues are dynamic and connected rather than static and isolated. Local government was found to be the most important conflicting party for local people due to its authority and economic interests in tourism development. In addition, an often-ignored conflicting party, villagers' committees, was found to have limitations in maintaining local people's interests. The findings of this study shed light on this complicated and sensitive tourism conflict phenomenon in rural China. A couple of practical implications for local authorities and UNESCO are outlined at the end of the paper.
Article
We applied theories of behavioral economics and conducted a field research on 881 tourists from China visiting Seoul through guided tour programs. We randomly assigned participants to study conditions based on theories of expectation, reciprocity, and peak-end rule. At the end of the tour, participants evaluated various aspects related to tour satisfaction and general impression of the city. A confirmatory factor analysis supported that these variables can be explained by two correlated factors, identified as the Current Satisfaction Factor (CSF) and the Future Behavior Factor (FBF). The multiple indicator multiple causes (MIMIC) model showed that CSF was impacted by expectation and tour season, and FBF by expectation, tour season, and first visit. Our results suggest that providing additional information before each activity can improve tourism satisfaction and non-manipulated variables such as tour season and first visit can be incorporated to further enhance tourism satisfaction.
Article
Today, the medical tourism industry has a projected growth rate of up to 25% year-over-year for the next 10 years and it is estimated that 3–4% of the world’s population will travel internationally for healthcare. The purpose of this article is to give a brief insight into relevant topics of medical tourism that remain undefined, unsolved or unregulated. The expected impacts of medical tourism include possible ethical, legal, and medical risks arising as a result of differences in particular countries in the standards applied in medical tourism institutions/facilities. Different standards of medical care, differences in legal systems and regulations, and taken procedures could result in unethical situations mainly due to the absence of internationally prescribed laws and accreditations related to medical tourism.
Article
Business program graduates are expected to perform with cultural sensitivity in international and intercultural professional environments. In order to support student development of the necessary mindset, a variety of assignments and activities have been integrated into the undergraduate International Business (IB) course. This article describes several types of exercises that can be used by anyone teaching this course or one where cultural sensitivity is an important component. No quantitative data are presented, nor are any claims made to the efficacy of these assignments. But student comments point to increased cultural sensitivity and a better understanding of the issues of globalization.
Article
Medical tourism is a multi-billion dollar industry today and continues to grow. There is a current competition to see what countries will capitalize on this growing global industry. The phenomenon of the industry is the amount of resources countries around the world are putting into attracting the medical tourist by offering high quality, low cost, specialized care with concierge and hospitality benefits. Medical Tourism is an important part of a growing interest of health care providers in other countries around the world willing to attract and accommodate medical travelers. As a result there has been a growing concern for the creation of professional standards designed to protect the quality and safety of patient care and the types of business opportunities that are available in this new industry.