Following in the footsteps of Murchison : The discovery of the Silurian and the Brecon Anticlinal HOGG Field Meeting

Abstract

Sir Roderick Impey Murchison was one of the most important figures in 19th century geology and exploration. He was Director-General of the Geological Survey, President of the Royal Geographical Society and publicly known as the ‘King of Siluria’. In July 1831, on his first field season as a solo geologist, Murchison explored the Wye Valley. Retrospectively, over his diary entry for one of the locations we shall visit, he wrote “This was the first true Silurian”.
The meeting and excursions explore Murchison’s field visits to the region in the early 1830s to gain a perspective on Murchison the man, his methods and geological thinking, how he modified the standard geological map of the time and how his visits to this area contributed to the publication of The Silurian System. A mix of recent and original notes, maps diagrams, sketches will be used to illustrate and follow in the footsteps of Murchison.

Full text

!"##"$%&'(%&()*+(,"")-)+.-(",(/012*%-"&!
(3*+(4%-2"5+16(",()*+(7%#01%8&(8&4()*+(91+2"&(:&)%2#%&8#!
!
!"#$%&'()!*+,%-!./&(0'1#23!4567!!89:%$!;<=!!
(!
:(,%+#4(+;201-%"&(,"1()*+(<%-)"16(",(=+"#"'6(=1"0.(
>?)*@AB)*(C0#6(AB>D(
(
E+84+1(F(G0&28&(<8$#+6(
!
>(

<!

6!
H&)1"402)%"&!
(!
"#$%&'()!*+,%-!./&(0'1#2!>91!9!1?&#2:3!'+,#1'2:!92$!'2@A/%2?'9A!@':/&%!'2!?0%!$%B%A#,+%2?!
#@!:%#A#:-!'2!?0%!2'2%?%%2?0!(%2?/&-C!./&(0'1#2!D%(9+%!9!>09?!'2!?#$9-E1!?%&+1!>#/A$!D%!
?%&+%$!9!F(%A%DCE!G!!,/DA'(A-!>%AA!)2#>2!@#&!0'1!1('%2?'@'(!F$'1(#B%&'%1E!92$!9$B#(9(-!#@!?0%!
#&$%&!92$!/?'A'?-!?#!D%!@#/2$!'2!?0%!%9&?0C!
*2$%%$!D-!?0%!?'+%!#@!0'1!A9?%&!-%9&1!45HI!J92'?-!K9'&!+9:9L'2%!81/D!?'?A%$!!FM!N%%)A-!O0#>!
#@!P#A'?'(9A3!O#('9A!92$!Q'?%&9&-!N9&%1E!=!@%9?/&%$!./&(0'1#2!91!9!1/DR%(?!'2!?0%'&!F.%2!#@!#/&!
S'+%E!1%&'%1!91!!TM!@9'?0@/A!@&'%2$!92$!%+'2%2?!O9B92?!92$!?0%!D%1?!,#11'DA%!#@!P&%1'$%2?1CU!!
./&(0'1#2!>91!892$!1?'AA!'1=!1-2#2-+#/1!>'?0!?0%!O'A/&'92!1-1?%+!!G!'?!>91!0'1!(&%9?'#2!'2!
456V!92$!?0%!O'A/&'92!D%(9+%!D#?0!9!?%&&'?#&-!#@!:%#A#:'(9A!?'+%!92$!92!'2(&%91'2:!%W,921%!
#@!A92$!?%&&'?#&-!?#!D%!(#2X/%&%$!92$!(A9'+%$!@#&!?0%C!O/(0!9!(9+,9':2'2:!9??'?/$%!A%$!?#!
0'1!@9+#/1!D'??%&!$'1,/?%!>'?0!0'1!#&':'29A!(#AA9D#&9?#&3!O%$:>'()!8O%(#&$!4V57=!C!!*?!19-1!
1#+%?0'2:!9D#/?!./&(0'1#2E13!(09&9(?%&!92$!9??'?/$%!?09?!0'1!@&'%2$1!D%:92!9$$&%11'2:!0'+!
'2!R%1?!91!FQ#&$!Y&9/>9()%E3!FZ#/2?!O'A/&'9E!92$!@'29AA-3!!'2!45;V3!!>91!,&#(A9'+%$!91!FS0%!['2:!
#@!O'A/&'9E!D-!?0%!\'10#,!#@!]W@#&$!8O%(#&$!4V5<=C!
N0'A1?!/2$#/D?%$A-!0%!>91!(#21'$%&%$!9!,&#A'@'(!@'%A$>#&)%&!92$!#D1%&B%&3!./&(0'1#2!>91!
2#?!9A>9-1!(#21'$%&%$!92!91?/?%!?0'2)%&!G!!91!1/(('2(?A-!#D1%&B%$!D-!Z09&A%1!^9&>'2_!TS0%!
$%:&%%!?#!>0'(0!0%!B9A/%$!&92)!>91!A/$'(&#/13!92$!0%!$'1,A9-%$!?0'1!@%%A'2:!92$!0'1!B92'?-!
>'?0!?0%!1'+,A'('?-!#@!9!(0'A$!`!S0%!1%&B'(%1!&%2$%&%$!?#!:%#A#:-!D-!./&(0'1#2!D-!0'1!
(A911'@'(9?'#2!#@!?0%!#A$%&!@#&+9?'#21!(922#?!D%!#B%&%1?'+9?%$a!D/?!0%!>91!B%&-!@9&!@&#+!
,#11%11'2:!9!,0'A#1#,0'(9A!+'2$CU!8^9&>'2!4Vb5_4I<@=C!
(!
72".+(8&4(8%I-(",()*%-(+;201-%"&!
S0'1!@'%A$!%W(/&1'#2!9??%+,?1!?#!$%+#21?&9?%!0#>!./&(0'1#2E1!@'%A$>#&)!?0%!N-%!J9AA%-!
92$!?0%!9&%9!D%?>%%2!\&%(#2!92$!\/'A?0!N%AA3!>0'(0!0%!?%&+%$!?0%!F\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29AC!>91!
9!1':2'@'(92?!@#&+9?'B%!%W,%&'%2(%!@#&!./&(0'1#2!92$!@#&!?0%!1/D1%X/%2?!&%,/?9?'#2!92$!
(9&%%&!0%!D/'A?!>0'(0!%2$%$!'2!0'1!F.92!#@!#/&!S'+%E!1?9?/1C!!
*?!9'+1!?#!%W,A#&%!1#+%!#@!?0%!?%&&9'2!?09?!>91!)%-!'2!./&(0'1#2E1!$%B%A#,+%2?!#@!>09?!
D%(9+%!0'1!$%@'2'2:!>#&)!FS0%!O'A/&'92!O-1?%+E3!>0'(0!0%!&%?&#1,%(?'B%A-!2#?%$!91!F?0%!@'&1?!
?&/%!O'A/&'92E!
c2@#&?/29?%A-3!0%&%!'1!2#?!?'+%!9B9'A9DA%!#2!?0'1!%W(/&1'#2!?#!(#B%&!9AA!#@!?0%!9A!?0%!:&#/2$!
'2!?0%!9&%9!>0%&%!./&(0'1#2!+9$%!1%+'29A!#D1%&B9?'#21!92$!@#&+%$!'$%913!!D/?!?0&#/:0!
@#AA#>'2:!0'1!@'%A$!2#?%1!92$!B'1'?'2:!)%-!A#(9?'#213!>%!9'+!?#!:9'2!9!,%&1,%(?'B%!#2!?0%!
./&(0'1#2!?0%!+923!0'1!+%?0#$1!92$!:%#A#:'(9A!?0'2)'2:3!0#>!0%!+#$'@'%$!?0%!1?92$9&$!
:%#A#:'(9A!+9,!#@!?0%!?'+%!92$!0#>!0'1!B'1'?1!?#!?0'1!9&%9!(#2?&'D/?%$!?#!?0%!,/DA'(9?'#2!#@!
FS0%!O'A/&'92!O-1?%+E!'2!456VC!!!
N'?0!?0%1%!'21':0?13!>%!+':0?!!D%!'2!9!D%??%&!,#1'?'#2!?#!9:&%%!#&!$'19:&%%!>'?0!^9&>'2E1!!
(#++%2?!#2!./&(0'1#2E1!X/9A'?'%1C!
!

;!
7+))%&'()*+(-2+&+!
!
*2!A9?%!d/2%!4564!./&(0'1#2!1%?!#/?!@&#+!Q#2$#23!9((#+,92'%$!D-!0'1!>'@%!Z09&A#??%3!#2!9!
1/++%&!:%#A#:'(9A!:&92$!?#/&!#@!e2:A92$!92$!N9A%1C!
!!
*2!?0%!?0&%%!-%9&1!,&%B'#/1!!845<53!45<V!f!456I=!./&(0'1#2!09$!?9)%2!:%#A#:'(9A!?#/&1!#2!
?0%!(#2?'2%2?!D/?!@#&!4564!./&(0'1#2g1!,A921!'2(A/$%$!9!:%2%&9A!1/&B%-!#@!\&'?'10!:%#A#:-C!!
S0%!(092:%!#@!A#(9?'#2!@#&!0'1!2#>!922/9A!%W(/&1'#2!'2?#!?0%!8(#2?'2%2?9A=!@'%A$!>913!'2!A9?%&!
9((#/2?13!,#&?&9-%$!91!9!$%A'D%&9?%!9(?!?#!$'1(#B%&!?0%!O'A/&'923!D/?!d9+%1!O%(#&$!84V57!92$!
2#!$9?%=!091!9&:/%$!?09?!./&(0'1#2E1!&%9A!'2?%2?!@#&!?0%!4564!?#/&!>91!?#!(0%()!?0%!9((/&9(-!
#@!Y&%%2#/:0E1!454V!+9,C!S0'1!+#&%!$#+%1?'(!(#2(%&2!1%%+1!?#!09B%!D%%2!2%(%11'?9?%$!D-!
0'1!+#?0%&G'2GA9>E1!,##&!0%9A?0!92$!Z09&A#??%E1!2%%$!?#!D%!8&%A9?'B%A-=!(A#1%!9?!092$!10#/A$!
0%&!+#?0%&!?9)%!?/&2!@#&!?0%!>#&1%C!
!!
\-!4564!Y&%%2#/:0E1!+9,!09$!D%%2!?0%!$%@'2'?'B%!1#/&(%!(09&?'2:!?0%!:%#A#:-!#@!e2:A92$!f!
N9A%1!@#&!#B%&!4I!-%9&13!91!09$!Z#2-D%9&%!92$!P0'AA',1E1!F]/?A'2%1E!'2!D%(#+'2:!?0%!1?92$9&$!
1-1?%+9?'(!$%1(&',?'#2!#@!?0%!1?&9?9C!h#>%B%&3!&%,#&?1!#2!A#(9A!:%#A#:-!9(&#11!?0%!A%2:?0!92$!
D&%9$?0!#@!?0%!'1A92$3!+92-!>&'??%2!/,!'2!?0%!S&9219(?'#21!#@!?0%!Y%#A#:'(9A!O#('%?-3!09$!
0':0A':0?%$!'29((/&9('%1!#2!?0%!+9,!92$!:'B%2!'2$'(9?'#2!#@!>0%&%!+#&%!$%?9'A!>91!2%%$%$C!
N'?0!Y&%%2#/:0g1!+9,!'2!092$!./&(0'1#2!?0#/:0?!0%!(#/A$!(#&&%(?!?0%!D#/2$9&'%1!#@!?0%!
+9,!8#2%!#@!?0%!+#1?!2#?#&'#/1A-!'29((/&9?%!A'2%1!D%'2:!?09?!D%?>%%2!?0%!]A$!"%$!
O92$1?#2%!92$!?0%!Y&9/>9()%!'2!N9A%1!92$!?0%!N%A10!\#&$%&1=!92$!(A%9&!/,!1#+%!#@!?0%!
/21#AB%$!1?&9?':&9,0'(9A!$'@@'(/A?'%1C!
!!
e2?&'%1!'2!./&(0'1#2g1!2#?%D##)1!@#&!?0%!,%&'#$!D%?>%%2!M,&'A!<<!92$!d/2%!4H3!4564!#@@%&!
1/D1?92?'9A!0'2?1!9D#/?!?0%!:&#/2$!0%!>91!,A922'2:!?#!&%(#22#'?&%!'2!?0%!N%A10!\#&$%&A92$C!
!!
iVisit%Bualt%&%follow%Syenite%&%Trap.%Presteign,%Kington%.%Amestree%curious%fossils%in%Slaty%
limestone%--%."!
"Ludlow%to%Craven%Arms%&%Church%Stretton%&%thence%by%Trap%&%Coal%to%Shrewsbury."%"fossils%
in%Slate%by%roadside%Grauwacke?"!
"From%Shrewsbury%see%Wellington%Trap%&%Wrekin."!
"Dudley%--%see%whether%the%limestone%be%unconformable%to%the%Coal%--%?!i!
!!
\%1'$%1!?&9,3!:&%->9()%3!92$!@#11'A13!./&(0'1#2!'2(A/$%$!?0%!FM+%1?&%%!A'+%1?#2%E!9+#2:!
0'1!#DR%(?'B%1C!!P0#2%?'(!+'1G1,%AA'2:1!D#?0!#@!M-+%1?&%-!92$!\/'A?0!1/::%1?!?09?!?0%!>#&$1!
>%&%!?9)%2!$#>2!@&#+!(#2B%&19?'#2C!!
S0%!FM+%1?&%%!A'+%1?#2%E!>91!+9&)%$!#2!Y&%%2#/:0E1!+9,!91!?0%!FS&921'?'#2!Q'+%1?#2%E!j!9!
A'2%9&!D92$!#@!A'+%1?#2%!1?&9?9!A-'2:!2#?!@9&!@&#+!?0%!D#/2$9&-!>'?0!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!
?09?!>91!)2#>2!'2!h%&%@#&$10'&%!92$!O0&#,10'&%!92$!>91!911/+%$!?#!@#AA#>!#/?!,9&9AA%A!?#!
?0%!>0#A%!A%2:?0!#@!?0'1!D#/2$9&-!9(&#11!N9A%1!?#!Z9&+9&?0%2!\9-C!
!

b!
!3*+(1"0)+(,"##"$+4(J6()*+(/012*%-"&-(401%&'()*+%1()"01(",(>?K>C!
!"%,&#$/(%$!@&#+!92!/2,/DA'10%$!+92/1(&',?!D-!dCMC!O%(#&$3!4V543!!
%2?'?A%$!T"#$%&'()!./&(0'1#2E1!:%#A#:'(9A!?#/&!#@!e2:A92$!92$!N9A%1!'2!4564UC!

7!
./&(0'1#2E1!&#/?%1!'2!?0%!N-%!J9AA%-!92$!\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29A!
8D91%$!#2!0'1!2#?%D##)!A#(9?'#21=!!

H!
3*+(L8I.8%'&(M"0)+!
]2!d/A-!;?0!4564!./&(0'1#2!92$!0'1!>'@%!Z09&A#??%!>%&%!'2!1#/?0!YA9+#&:9210'&%!9?!O/AA-!
82%9&!\9&&-=!B'1'?'2:!NC!^C!Z#2-D%9&%3!>0#!>91!"%(?#&!#@!?0%!,9&'10C!!N'AA'9+!\/()A92$!>91!
9A1#!B'1'?'2:!9?!?0%!19+%!?'+%C!!./&(0'1#2!(#21'$%&%$!Z#2-D%9&%E1!92$!P0'A',E1!F]/?A'2%1E!91!
0'1!F:%#A#:'(9A!D'DA%E!'2!?0%!%9&A-!,9&?!#@!0'1!:%#A#:'(9A!,/&1/'?13!1#!0'1!,/&,#1%!@#&!B'1'?'2:!
O/AA-!1%%+1!?#!09B%!D%%2!?#!:9'2!,#'2?%&1!?#!$'1?&'(?1!>0%&%!?0%&%!+':0?!D%!%&&#&1!#&!
'29((/&9('%1!#2!Y&%%2#/:0E1!+9,C!!
Z#2-D%9&%!9A1#!09$!&%A9?'B%1!92$!(#22%(?'#21!'2!?0%1%!$'1?&'(?1!8eB92!S0#+913!0'1!D&#?0%&G
'2GA9>!92$!P9?&#2!>91!@&#+!9!@9+'A-!>'?0!9!A9&:%!%1?9?%!R/1?!?#!?0%!>%1?!#@!\/'A?0!N9A%1=3!1#!
./&(0'1#2!9A1#!+9-!09B%!D%%2!1%%)'2:!'2?&#$/(?'#21!?#!?0%!:%2?&-!'2!?09?!,9&?!8./&(0'1#2!
>91!9(X/9'2?%$!>'?0!+92-!#@!?0%!!F\#&$%&!OX/'&%1E!!G!1%%!O'2(A9'&!f!K%22!4VVV!@#&!92!
9((#/2?!#@!0#>!./&(0'1#2!/1%$!92$!>91!%2(#/&9:%$!'2!0'1!,/&1/'?1!D-!?0%1%!(#22%(?'#21=C!!
./&(0'1#2!+9-!>%AA!09B%!0%9&$!#@!?0%!(/&'#/1!@#11'A1!'2!1A9?%-!A'+%1?#2%!92$!#@!?0%'&!
,#?%2?'9A!@#&!(A#1%&!'21,%(?'#2!@&#+!Z#2-D%9&%!#&!\/()A92$!81%%!9D#B%=C!
]?0%&!91,%(?1!#@!?0%!4564!?#/&!$%+#21?&9?%!./&(0'1#2g1!1,%('9A!'2?%&%1?!'2!?0%!?0%#&%?'(9A!
,&#:&9+!#@!Q-%AA3!9!(A#1%!,%&1#29A!92$!1('%2?'@'(!911#('9?%!9?!?0'1!?'+%!80%!09$!?#/&%$!?0%!
MA,1!>'?0!Q-%AA!'2!45<5=C!./&(0'1#2!>92?%$!?#!%W9+'2%!@'%A$!%B'$%2(%!?09?!+':0?!1/,,#&?!
Q-%AAE1!9&:/+%2?1!@#&!>09?!>91!?#!D%!A9?%&!$/DD%$!F/2'@#&+'?9&'92'1+E!92$!9A1#!%W,A#&%!
%B'$%2(%!@#&!9!2%>!?0%#&-!9D#/?!?0%!&%A9?'#210',!D%?>%%2!?0%!/,A'@?!#@!1?&9?9!92$!B#A(92'(!
&#()13!&%(%2?A-!#/?A'2%$!D-!eA'%!$%!\%9/+#2?C!
*?!1%%+%$!?#!D%!@#&!?0'1!&%91#2!?09?!./&(0'1#2!,A922%$!?#!B'1'?!N9A%1!92$!?0%!\#&$%&1!92$!
0%&%!?0%&%!1%%+%$!?#!D%!+92-!9&%91!>0%&%!!0%!(#/A$!'2B%1?':9?%!?0%!&%A9?'#2!D%?>%%2!?0%!
/,A'@?!#@!1?&9?9!92$!?0%!/2$%&A-'2:!,&#(%11%1!#@!':2%#/1!9(?'#2C!*2!?&9B%AA'2:!?#!\&%(#2!92$!
?0%!N-%!J9AA%-3!?0%23!!0%!@#&?/'?#/1A-!09,,%2%$!#2!#2%!#@!?0%!@%>!9&%91!'2!\&'?9'2!>0%&%!
1/(0!9!(#2@#&+9DA%!1%&'%1!D%?>%%2!?0%!]A$!"%$!k192$1?#2%!92$!?0%!Y&9/>9()%!(#/A$!
&%9$'A-!D%!1%%2Ci!
K&#+!O/AA-!./&(0'1#2!(9AA%$!'2!9?!O>921%9!8>'?0!9!D&'%@!%W(/&1'#2!?#!%W9+'2%!?0%!(#9A@'%A$!
&#()1!>'?0!^'A>-2!Q%>'1=!92$!?0%2(%!R#/&2%-%$!9(&#11!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!'2?#!?0%!
?%&&9'2!#@!?0%!Y&%->9()%!B'9!QA92$%'A#!92$!QA92$#B%&-3!!9A#2:!?0%!+9'A!(#9(0!&#9$!?#!9&&'B%!
9?!\&%(#2C!!h%!%2(#/2?%&%$!?0%!Y&%->9()%l]"O!D#/2$9&-!!?>'(%!#2!?0'1!R#/&2%-3!@'&1?!#2!
?0%!&#9$!?#!QA92$%'A#!92$!?0%2!!g6%miles%from%Llandovery%and%3%miles%from%Trecastle%the%blue%
Grauwacke%passes%%%into%%a%%slaty%%%thin%%%bedded%%%micaceous%%%reddish%sandstone,%at%the%
location%of%Capel%HorebgC!8./&(0'1#23!456A93!,C!54C=!!
S0%!./&(0'1#21!1,%2?!?0%!2':0?!#@!d/A-!4I?0!9?!?0%!Z91?A%!h#?%A3!\&%(#2C!!]2!?0%!+#&2'2:!#@!
d/A-!44?0!!./&(0'1#2!1)%?(0%$!?0%!B'%>!#@!?0%!\&%(#2!\%9(#21!@&#+!?0%!0#?%A!:&#/2$1!92$!
?0%23!'2!0'1!#>2!>#&$1_!
iTravelling%f%rom%Brecon%to%Builth%by%the%Herefordshire%road,%the%gorge%in%which%the%Wye%
flows%first%developed%what%I%had%not%till%then%seen.%Low-terrace%shaped%ridges%of%%grey%%rock%%
dipping%%slightly%%to%%the%south%east%appeared%on%the%opposite%bank%of%the%W%ye,%and%seemed%
to%rise%quite%%conformably%%from%%beneath%the%Old%Red%of%%Herefordshire.%%Boating%across%the%
river%at%Cavansham%%Ferry,%I%rushed%up%to%those%ridges,%and,%to%%my%%inexpressible%joy%%found%%
them%%replete%with%transition%%fossils,%afterwards%%identified%with%those%%at%%Ludlow.%Here%then%
was%the%key,%and%if%I%could%only%follow%this%out%on%the%strike%of%the%beds%to%the%north-east,%the%
case%would%be%good”%Source:%%Giekie%(1875)!
%!

5!
./&(0'1#2E1!,%2('A!1)%?(0!#@!!\&%(#2!
\%9(#21!@&#+!?0%!:&#/2$1!#@!S0%!Z91?A%!
h#?%A3!\&%(#23!d/A-!44?0!4564C!
!S0%!B'%>!&%+9'21!&%(#:21'9DA%!91!+/(0!
?0%!19+%C!!
!

]&$292(%!O/&B%-!.9,!!\&%(#23!]2%G'2(0!O0%%?!!b53!!456<!!
V!

4I!
Y&%%2#/:0E1!454V!Y%#A#:'(9A!.9,!#@!?0%!9&%9!D%?>%%2!\&%(#2!92$!\/'A?0!!N%AA1!O0#>'2:!
]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%3!!S&921'?'#2!Q'+%1?#2%!8DA/%=3!['AA91!8Y&%->9()%=!8D/@@=!92$!S&9,!8:&%%2=!

44!
G:N(>((((
(
E"28#%)6(>(31+1%2O+)(/%##(P3*+(,%1-)()10+(7%#01%8&Q(=M(7R(>>KB((D>DB(
S&%&'()%?!.'AA!1?92$1!'2!9!A9-GD-!#2!?0%!>%1?!1'$%!#@!M!;HI8S=!9D#/?!<Cb!+'A%1!2#&?0!#@!QA-1>%23!
92$!9D#/?!4C;!+'A%1!1#/?0!#@!e&>##$C!!
*++%$'9?%A-!?#!?0%!1#/?0%91?!#@!?0%!.'AA3!?0%!&#9$!$%1(%2$1!@&#+!92!/,,%&!&'B%&!?%&&9(%!8ca.%
<IG6I+C!9D#B%!&'B%&!A%B%A=!?#!9!A#>%&3!29&&#>%&!?%&&9(%!9D#/?!4I+C!9D#B%!&'B%&!A%B%AC!S0%!1#'A!#2!
?0%!/,,%&!?%&&9(%!'1!$9&)!&%$3!1'+'A9&!?#!?09?!?-,'(9AA-!@#/2$!(#B%&'2:!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%3!92$!
2#!$#/D?!./&(0'1#2!#D1%&B%$!?0'1C!\-!(#2?&91?3!?0%!1#'A!'2!?0%!D92)!>0'(0!$%1(%2$1!?#!?0%!A#>%&!
?%&&9(%!'1!D/@@!-%AA#>!>'?0!1+9AA!%W,#1/&%1!#@!:&%-!c,,%&!O'A/&'92!&#()C!*?!'1!0%&%!?09?!./&(0'1#2!
$%('$%$!0%!09$!iX/'?!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%CU!
Z#2@'&+9?'#2!#@!?0%!(092:%!'2!?0%!/2$%&A-'2:!:%#A#:-!+9-!>%AA!09B%!D%%2!&%9A'1%$!D-!0'1!
#D1%&B9?'#2!#@!:&%-!D%$1!@#&+'2:!9!1+9AA!>9?%&@9AA!'2!?0%!O:'?0>%2!\&##)3!>0'(0!9&%!%91'A-!1%%2!
@&#+!?0%!D&'$:%!9?!S&%&'()%?!.'AAC!
E"28#%)6(AS(T%+$."%&)(8)(L+,&=8,1"&((U,"1(L"+4(7%"&@V8&%W((=M(7R(>B?XK(D>ADD(
MD#/?!4II+!1#/?0!#@!S&%&'()%?!.'AA!9!1+9AA!&#9$!(A'+D1!>%1?>9&$!/,!?#!Z%@2!Y9@&#1!>0%&%!9!,9?0!
/,!?0%!0'AA!A%9$1!?#!Z#%$!O'#2Gm92'!8?&921AC!n!!>##$!#@!d#02!?0%!m922-=C!
./&(0'1#2!2#?%1!?0%1%!A#(9?'#21!#2!?0%!,&?%(%$'2:!,9:%!#@!!92$!9A?0#/:0!0%!$'$2E?!+9)%!92-!
$%?9'A%$!2#?%1!G!!'?!1%%+1!0%!91(%2$%$!?0%!0'AA!?#!:9'2!9!B'%>!#@!?0%!?#,#:&9,0-C!
Q##)'2:!%91?>9&$3!./&(0'1#2!i2#?'(%$!9!1%&'%1!#@!&'1'2:!&'$:%1!'2!?0%!0'AA1'$%!#2!?0%!#,,#1'?%!
8"9$2#&10'&%=!D92)!#@!?0%!N-%C!h9B'2:!?9)%2!9((#/2?!#@!?0%!$',!#@!?0%!D%$13!0%&%!9D#/?!4<o!?#!
?0%!%91?G1#/?0%91?3!./&(0'1#2!911/+%$!?09?!?0%!&'$:%1!&%,&%1%2?%$!?0%!1?&')%!#@!?0%!Y&%->9()%!
D%$1Ci!
h'1!'2?%&,&%?9?'#2!>91!?09?!#@!9!(#2@#&+9DA%!:%#A#:-!>0'(0!>91!,%&@%(?A-!&%@A%(?%$!'2!?0%!
?#,#:&9,0-C!h%!@/&?0%&!&%91#2%$!?09?!?0%1%!D%$1!>#/A$!%W?%2$!29?/&9AA-!?#!?0%!0':0%1?!,#'2?!#@!
?0%!0'AA1'$%3!>0'(0!(#/A$!D%!'$%2?'@'%$!#2!?0%!+9,!91!?0%!S/+,!#@!Y9&?0!?#!?0%!2#&?0!#@!?0%!&'$:%1!
92$!1#!0%!2#?%$!?0%!1?&')%!#@!?0%!D%$1!0%&%!91!@&#+!2#&?0!?#!1#/?0C!
h#>%B%&3!Y&%%2#/:0g1!+9,!8Y&%%2#/:03!454V3!K':C!<!89==!10#>1!?0%!1?&')%!#@!?0%!D%$1!'2!?0'1!
&%:'#2!91!D%'2:!2#&?0%91?G1#/?0>%1?C!*?!+9-!>%AA!09B%!D%%2!?0'1!92#+9A-!?09?!,&#+,?%$!
./&(0'1#2!?#!%W,A#&%!?0%!29?/&%!#@!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%GY&%->9()%!R/2(?'#2!9?!?0'1!1,#?3!
>0%&%91!0%!09$!2#?!,9'$!92-!1':2'@'(92?!9??%2?'#2!?#!'?!>0%2!%2(#/2?%&%$!,&%B'#/1A-C!!h%!
$%('$%$!?#!,/&1/%!?0%!(A911'(!@'%A$!1?&9?%:-!#@!?09?!?'+%3!?09?!#@!?&9B%&1'2:!9(&#11!1?&')%!'2!#&$%&!
?#!(#21?&/(?!9!0#&'L#2?9A!1%(?'#2!8O%(#&$3!4V573!,C<b=C!S#!$#!?0'1!0%!>#/A$!2%%$!?#!(&#11!?0%!
&'B%&C!!
*2!456<3!./&(0'1#2!&%B'1'?%$!?0'1!A#(9?'#2!+9)'2:!9!1)%?(0!0%&%!#@!?0%!B'%>!?#!S&%>%&2%!h'AA1!!
#B%&!?0%!N-%3!92$!(#+,A%?'2:!9!$%?9'A%$!1%(?'#2!!#@!?0%!&':0?!D92)!@&#+!c,,%&!QA92:#%$!$#>2!?#!
?0%!N-%!!!81%%!K'%A$!m#?%D##)!m#C!<3!456<3!Q^YOQ!56V!!.m!7<3!,,C!H5GHV=C!
!
(
!
!

4<!
3*+(Y,%1-)()10+(7%#01%8&Z((C0#6(>?K>(

46!
E"28#%)6(KS(((9"8)([""#(8&4(L858&-*8I(!+116((=M(7R(>>BK(D>\B(
((
./&(0'1#2!&%(#&$%$!?0%!29+%!#@!?0%!@%&&-!D-!>0'(0!0%!(&#11%$!?0%!N-%!9?!1%B%&9A!,#'2?1!'2!0'1!
2#?%13!D/?!>91!9?!@'&1?!/2$%('$%$!91!?#!0#>!?#!1,%AA!'?C!K'&1?A-!0%!&%(#&$1!'?!91!Z9B921092%3!D/?!
'2!?0%!2%W?!1%2?%2(%!?0'1!'1!(092:%$!?#!Z9B9210992!81%%!m#?%D##)!,CH!f!5=C!\-!?0%!?'+%!#@!?0%!
,/DA'(9?'#2!#@!Y%')'%g1!D'#:&9,0'(9A!9((#/2?!#@!./&(0'1#2!8Y%')'%!45Hb=3!?0%!29+%!#@!?0%!@%&&-!
09$!(092:%$!?#!?0%!+#&%!92:A'('L%$!@#&+!#@!gZ9B92109+!K%&&-g!S0%&%!'1!2#!&%(#&$%$!,A9(%!#2!
?0%!&'B%&!)2#>2!91!Z9B9210992!K%&&-3!92$!?0%&%!'1!2#!A#(9A!+%+#&-!#@!9!,A9(%!#@!?09?!29+%C!
S0'1!#@@%&1!1#+%!1/,,#&?'2:!%B'$%2(%!@#&!
!
O%(#&$!>0#!1/::%1?%$!?09?!Z9B92109+!K%&&-!>91!?0%!29+%!#@!9!D#9?!92$!2#?!9!,A9(%!8O%(#&$3!
/2,/DA'10%$!,9,%&=C!h#>%B%&!?0%!29+%!Z9B92109923!?&921A9?%1!@&#+!?0%!N%A10!91!g\#9?!#@!
d#02g!8Z9B92!8Z9@92=!n!D#9?3!O0992!8O'#2=!n!d#02=3!92$!%B'$%2(%!(92!D%!$%$/(%$!91!?#!>0%&%!
?0'1!D#9?!#,%&9?%$C!D/?!./&(0'1#2!>91!>&'?'2:!9!,0#2%?'(!B%&1'#2!#@!9!N%A10!29+%3!29+%A-!
Z9B92!O0992!#&!Z9@92!O'#23!+%92'2:!d#02g1!\#9?!
Z&#11!?0%!N-%!@&#+!S&%&'()%?!.'AA!D-!?0%!#2%GA92%!1/1,%21'#2!D&'$:%3!@#AA#>!?0%!A92%3!?/&2'2:!!
A%@?!#B%&!?0%!#A$!&9'A>9-!D&'$:%!92$!9@?%&!9D#/?!IC7b)+!,9&)!9?!9!:9?%!%2?&92(%!R/1?!,91?!?0%!!
Z&#11!?0%!1?'A%3!$#>2!9!@%>!-9&$1!?#!9!:9?%!9?!?0%!D#??#+3!92$!?/&2!D9()!$#>21?&%9+!9A#2:!?0%!
&'B%&!D92)C!S0%!,##A!#@!X/'%?!>9?%&!0%&%!'1!)2#>2!?#!92:A%&1!#2!?0%!&'B%&!91!\#9?!P##AC!]2!?0%!
D92)3!+#&%!#&!A%11!#,,#1'?%!9!(#??9:%!#2!?0%!#?0%&!1'$%3!9&%!?0%!&%+9'21!#@!9!1?#2%!A92$'2:!
,A9?@#&+!84444!;45b=C!
]B%&!?0%!&'B%&3!'2!?0%!D92)1'$%!:9&$%2!#@!?0%!(#??9:%!'1!9!D/&'%$!92(0#&!,#'2?!D#A?%$!'2?#!?0%!
&#()C!*++%$'9?%A-!/,1?&%9+!#@!\#9?!P##A!?0%!&'B%&!(&#11%1!#B%&!9!1%&'%1!#@!B%&-!,&#+'2%2?!
&#()-!A%$:%13!)2#>2!A#(9AA-!91!h'&#!"#()1C!*2!?0%!1/++%&!!+#2?01!!?0%1%!!A%$:%1!:%2%&9AA-!
,&#B'$%!%W(%AA%2?!92$!%W?%21'B%!%W,#1/&%!#@!?0%!c,,%&!O'A/&'92!C!
(
E"28#%)6(DS(((E#8&-)+.*8&(]08116S((=M((7R(>>^^(D>\_!(
M@?%&!(&#11'2:!?#!?0%!"9$2#&10'&%!D92)3!./&(0'1#2!+9$%!0'1!>9-!/,!?0%!B9AA%-!1'$%3!>0'(0!0%&%!
&'1%1!'2!9!1%&'%1!#@!+'2#&!1(9&,!92$!$',!1A#,%1C!!S0%1%!9&%!?0%!iA#>!?%&&9(%G109,%$!&'$:%1!#@!
:&%-!&#()!$',,'2:!1A':0?A-!?#!?0%!OCeC!#2!?0%!#,,#1'?%!pA%@?q!D92)Ci!S0%!A9&:%1?3!A#(9?%$!?#!?0%!
2#&?0>%1?!#@!QA921?%,092!h#/1%!>91!D%'2:!9(?'B%A-!X/9&&'%$!'2!?0%!%9&A-!45II13!92$!?0'1!
9@@#&$%$!./&(0'1#2!92!#,,#&?/2'?-!?#!%W9+'2%!?0%!Y&9/>9()%!92$!'?1!@#11'A13!+9&)'2:!?0%!
,A9(%!iDi!#2!0'1!(&#11G1%(?'#23!92$!2#?'2:!?0%&%!iX/9&&'%1!#@!DA/%!(9A(C!:&9/>9()%3!1A9?-!:&'?1!GG!
D/'A$'2:!1?#2%!;!?#!5!'2(0%1!?0'()!GG!@#11'A1C!^',!+9'2A-!e91?!4<!?#!4boC!
./&(0'1#2!!2#?%$!?09?!g?0%!10%AA1!9&%!@&%X/%2?A-!'2!@9+'A'%1g!8./&(0'1#23!4564D3!,C!4I3!A'2%1!6!
92$!;=!92$!?0%!&#()g!#((91'#29AA-!D%(#+%1!?&/%!:'2:%&D&%9$!&#()!#&29+%2?%$!>'?0!?0%!(91?1!#@!
?0%!9D#B%!10%AA1Cg!8./&(0'1#23!4564D3!,C4I!A'2%1!4<!92$!46=C!
OC!hC!O?&9>!84V6I=!$%1(&'D%$!?0'1!X/9&&-!91!D%A#2:'2:!c,,%&!Q/$A#>!\%$1!10#>'2:!9!DA/%!
(9A(9&%#/1!@A9::-!D%$1!1/((%%$%$!D-!9D#/?!V+!86I!@%%?=!#@!:&%%2!@A9::-!109A%1!>'?0!09&$!DA/%!!
:&'?!D92$1!(#2?9'2'2:!P&#?#(0#2%?%1!A/$A#B%21'1!8!O-2C3Z0#2%?%1!1?&'9?%AA9!=!!8^9A+C=3!O9A#,'29!
A/29?9!8O-2C3!^9A+92%AA9!A/29?9=!8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=3!Z9+9&#?#%(0'9!2/(/A9!8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=3!
]&D'(/A#'$%9!&/:9?9!8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=3!K/(01%AA9!9+-:$9A'29!8O-2C3!]&?0#2#?9!9+-:$9A'29=!
!

4;!
8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=3!]&?0#(%&91!1,C3!h#A#,%AA9!D/AA9?/+!8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=3!\%-&'(0'9!
)A#%$%2'!B9&C!?#&#1!d#2%13!O%&,/A'?%1!A#2:'11'+/1!3!^9-'9!29B'(/A9!8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=3!
Y#2'#,0#&9!(-+D9%@#&+'1!8dC!$%!ZC!O#>%&D-=C!S0%!&#()1!'2!?0%!X/9&&-!(#&&%A9?%!>'?0!
?0#1%!#@!?0%!c,,%&!N0'?(A'@@'92!K#&+9?'#2!8Q/$@#&$'92=!#@!?0%!1?92$9&$!O'A/&'92!
1?&9?':&9,0-!'2!?0%!Q/$A#>!9&%9!8Z0%+13!4VV63!,C6I;=C!
!
S0%!@'%A$!2#?%1!#@!4564!10#>!./&(0'1#2g1!A'+'?%$!)2#>A%$:%!#@!?0%!@#11'A1!?09?!0%!
@#/2$!'2!?0%!QA921?%,092!X/9&&'%1C!*2!0'1!9??%+,?1!?#!91(&'D%!?0%+!?9W#2#+'(9AA-!0%!
+9)%1!(#+,9&'1#21!>'?0!&%(%2?!@9/2913!%C:C!A1#(9&$'93!J%2/1C!!
h'1!'+,%&@%(?!)2#>A%$:%!'1!2#?!1/&,&'1'2:!:'B%2!?09?!?0'1!>91!?0%!D%:'22'2:!#@!0'1!
@#&9-1!'2?#!?0%!Y&%->9()%!92$!?09?!>0%2!0%!@'&1?!,/DA'10%$!A'1?1!#@!g(09&9(?%&'1?'(!
#&:92'(!&%+9'21g!'2!456;!+92-!#@!?0%!@#11'A1!@#/2$!0%&%!92$!'2!#?0%&!c,,%&!O'A/&'92!
&#()1!>%&%!2#?%$!91!2%>!1,%('%1!8./&(0'1#23!456;3!?9DA%!@9('2:!,9:%!46=C!h#>%B%&3!0'1!
109&,!#D1%&B9?'#2!#@!?0%!,&%1%2(%!#@!92$!@#&+!#@!?0%!@#11'A1!9?!QA921?%,092!>91!?#!,A9-!
92!'+,#&?92?!,9&?!'2!./&(0'1#2g1!/2$%&1?92$'2:!#@!?0%!:%#A#:-!#@!?0'1!9&%9C!
./&(0'1#2!(#2?'2/%$!/,!?0%!1'$%!#@!?0%!B9AA%-!i'2!?0%!%W,%(?9?'#2!#@!@'2$'2:!9!
(#2@#&+9DA%!,9119:%!@&#+!?0%!Y&9/>9()%!?#!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%C!h%!2#?%$!C!C!C!T!
?0%!1?&9?9!#@!?0%!6&$!&'$:%!8D=!`C!,911!/,>9&$1!8?0%!@#11'A1!:&9$/9AA-!$'19,,%9&'2:=!'2?#!
+'(9(%#/1!:&%%2'10!09&$!:&'?!192$1?#2%!>0'(0!,A/2:%1!?#!?0%!e91?!/2$%&!?0%!]A$!"%$!
O92$1?#2%CU!
]2!?0%!#?0%&!092$3!O?&9>!19'$!?09?!9?!?0'1!,A9(%!iS0%!9(?/9A!R/2(?'#2!#@!?0%!c,,%&!
Q/$A#>!92$!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!'1!2#?!%W,#1%$3!D/?!'2!?0%!@'%A$!9D#B%!?0%!X/9&&-!
:&%%2!+9&A1!@#&+!9!1+9AA!@%9?/&%i!8O?&9>3!4V6I=C(
E"28#%)6(^S((`1$""4(Y"!O]!IVHI!;6I6!U8&4(`1$""4(7)8)%"&W((
S0'1!'1!,&#D9DA-!?0%!A/2(0!1?#,C!!
*2!?0%!$',!#@!?0%!+9'2!&#9$!,911'2:!?0&#/:0!?0%!B'AA9:%!'1!9!D&'$:%!#B%&!ZA%??>&!\&##)C!
Q##)'2:!$#>2!@&#+!?0%!,9&9,%?!'2?#!?0%!D%$!#@!?0%!1?&%9+!D%A#>!?0%!D%$&#()!#@!?0%!
1?&%9+!'13!1#+%>09?!/2%W,%(?%$A-3!!:&%%2'10G!(#A#/&%$!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%C!!
S0'1!'1!,9&?!#@!?0%!1#/?0>%1?%&2!%W,&%11'#2!#@!?0%!:&%9?!Z0&/(0!O?&%??#2!Q'2%9+%2?!
8?0%!N&%)'2GO?&%??#2G"9$2#&!@9/A?GA'2%=!C!
./&(0'1#2!>91!,/LLA%$!D-!?0'1!&%9,,%9&92(%!#@!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%_!!
TAt%Erwood%the%Old%Red%mottled%&%green%marl%&%hard%green%grit%are%brought%in,%dipping%
to%the%South%at%about%15°."%And%he%added,%"Greenough’s%map%has%I%think%been%put%into%
error%by%this%outlier%of%Old%RedCU!
./&(0'1#2!,&#(%%$%$!?#!D9()!?#!?0%!"'B%&!N-%!8Y"!O]!I5V6!;6<I=3!!92$!0%&%!0%!
(#2@'&+%$!?0%!,&%1%2(%!#@!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!92$!?0%!F%&&#&E!#@!Y&%%2#/:0E1!+9,C!
!

4b!

47!

4H!

45!
a=1++&"0'*Z-(I8.(*8-(H()*%&O(J++&(.0)(%&(+11"1(J6()*%-("0)#%+1(",(R#4(M+4Q((

/012*%-"&b-(V")+J""O(V"S(A(>?K>!
!!
[8'+(X!
\&%(#2!+!d/A-!44?0!
P%2G-GB92!<I7<!@?!Y&%%2>##$g1!+9,!
"#9$!@&#+!\&%(#2!?#!S&%(91?A%!,&#,%&!D-!Q921,-?0'$!C!M$+'&9DA%!2%>!&#9$!D%?>%%2!?0%1%!
,A9(%1!
!!
[8'+(_!
M1(%2$'2:!?0%!N-%!@#&!9!@%>!+'A%1!9D#B%!h9-!>0%&%!?0%!&#9$!?/&21!#@@!'2!(#+'2:!@#&!\&%(#2!
,911!D-!QA92:#%$!Z91?A%!f!X/'?!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!G!91(%2$'2:!9!A'??A%!)2#AA!e91?!#@!
S&%&'()%?!.'AA!@'2$!Y&9/>9()%!1A9?%!>'?0!@#11'A1!#2!%'?0%&!1'$%!#@!?0%!&#9$!j!h'AA!(#21'1?'2:!#@!
'?!?09?!A%$!#2%!?#!@#AA#>!?0%!1?&/(?/&%!#@!?0%1%!D%$1!9(&#11!?0%!N-%!D-!9!@%&&-!9?!
Z9B921092%C!
S0%!0'AA!#2!?0%!&C!D92)!#@!?0%!N-%!9?!Z9B9210992!(9AA%$!Z%@2!Y9B9&#1!f!?0%!0':0%1?!9D#B%!
?0'1!f!?0%!.'AA!#@!S&%&'()%?!!'1!(9AA%$!!N%&2#1!rrrrrrrrr!
S0%!&'$:%1!>'?0!@#11'A1!>0'(0!91(%2$!?0%!N-%!@&#+!S&%&'()%?!.'AA!'2?#!!?0%!S&%>%&2%!h'AA1!?#!
?0%!m#&?0!(/A+'29?'2:!'2!S#>%&GY9&?0!#&!?0%!S/+,!#@!Y9&?0!'2!?0%!,9&'10!#@!QA92$%'A#C!
!!
[8'+(?!
Z&#11'2:!?0%!N-%!9?!Z9B921092%!K%&&-!91!D%A#>3!91(%2$%$!#B%&!1%B%&9A!&'$:%1!#@!Y&9/>9()%!
1A9?%!G!9AA!#@!>0'(0!>%&%!,9&9AA%A!?#!%9(0!#?0%&!92$!2%9&A-!CCCCC!@&#+!m!?#!O#/?0!9$R#'2'2:!?0%!
1A#,%!?#!S&%&'()%?!'2!?0%'&!0':0%1?!D%$13!f!?#!?0%!Y9&>!.9%2!X/9&&'%1!#2!?0%!A#>%1?C!
S0%!A#>%1?!&'$:%!$',1!+#&%!1?%%,A-!?092!?0%!/,,%&!&'$:%!9?!9D#/?!4b!?#!45o!1A':0?A-!?#!?0%!O!
#@!e91?!!G!'?!'1!9!+#&%!192$-!1?#2%!?0%2!?0%!/,,%&!G!@#11'A1!#((/&!'2!9AA!?0%1%!&'$:%1!Gs?0%!@#11'A1!
1%%+!?#!$%(&%91%!'2!X/92?'?-!'2!?0%!/,,%&!1?&9?9!f!?0%1%!1%%2!'2!?0%!c,,%&!"'$:%!+9&)%$!?#!
>0%&%!?0%-!9&%!X/9&&'%$!@&#+!9!%1(9&,+%2?!9D#/?!;I!?#!bI!@%%?!$%%,!G!f!>0%&%!?0%-!$',!<!
?#!4bo!!2%9&A-!e91?C!G!9AA!?0%!e1(9&,+%2?1!,&#?&/$'2:!?0&#g!?0%!?/&@!9&%!:&%-!>'?0!!A'(0%21!f!
?0%!>%9?0%&!'2?#!10%9&'2:!1A9?-!%$:%1!ss!>0%2!@&%10!X/9&&'%$!?0%-!:%2%&9AA-!,&%1%2?!9!
1A'()%21'$%!@&9(?/&%!@&#+!?#,!?#!e91?!'2!?0%!^'&%(?'#2!#@!!1?&')%!#@!?0%!D%$1!!B'L!@&#+!m!?#!bC!
!!
[8'+(\!
MD#B%!@#/2$!0#&'L#2?9A!f!?0'()!D%$$%$!f!$',,'2:!1A':0?A-!>%1?C!m%>!(/?!$':!9:9'2!O#/?0!!
Q%@?!f!&':0?!D92)!!'B-!f!A'(0%2!!
ZA'@@!1!2#>!0#&'L#2?9QCC!
N%1?!G!>%9?0%&'2:!:&9-!K#11'A1!?# !@%>!!
^'@@%&%2(%1!6!A%$:%1!
bII@!?!h%29AA?!(#9&1%!1A9?%!$',!&!D92)!OON!4I!
MD%&$'0'2'#!.'AA!
Z#2?#&?%$!OA9?%!
OA9?%!@&#+!P%2!CCCCCCC!*2!MD%&:#':#'!
!
4V!

!!
[8'+(>B!
MAA!?0%!D%$1!'2!?0%!X/9&&-!9&%!B%&-!0#+#:%2%#/1!f!9&%!9!@&9(?'#2!DA/%!(#9&1%!:&9/>9()%!1A9?%!
:&'?!>%9?0%&'2:!?#!CCC%$:%1!G!A9+'29%1!@&%X/%2?A-!#@!$%%,!@A9+%!DA/%!#W-$!#@!'&#2!>0'(0!
0-$&9?%1!&9,'$A-!#2!%W,#1/&%!G!?0%!10%AA1!9&%!@&%X/%2?A-!?0%!(91?!#@!O,'&'@'$1!f!'2!$&#,,'2:!#/?!
#@!?0%'&!2%1?1!'2!?0%!1?9?%!#@!0-$&9?%!#@!'&#2!G!
K/('$1!A9&:%!t!1+9AA!G!]&?0#(%&913!O,'&'@'$1!CCCCCCCC !CCCCCCCCCC!G!92$!%A#2:9?%$!D'B9AB%!&%1%+DA'2:!
P9AA92?1!G!G!#?0%&!c2)2#>2!D'B9AB%1!S%&%D&9?/A'%!G!1%&,/A'2%!D#$'%1!G![#(9&$'9u!J%2/1!92$!9!
1+9AA!,%&@%(?!S&#(0'9C!
!!
S0%!1/&@9(%!#@!?0%!D%$1!1#+%?'+%1!#@@%&!9!>#&A-!9,,%9&92(%!
S0%!>%9?0%&%$!X/9&&'%$!f!1/&@9(%!D'?1!,9&?'2:!u!!>'?0!?0%'&!#W-$!#@!'&#2!92$!(9A(9&%#/1!
,9&?'(A%1!D%(#+%!X/'?%!192$-!f!A':0?!92$!#((91'#29AA-!D%(#+%1!!?0%!:'2:%&!D&%9$!&#()!
9((%2?/9?%$!>'?0!(91?1!#@!?0%!9D#B%!10%AA1C!
G!S0%!0%9$!#@!?0%C!'2?%&'#&!1?#2%1!#@!X/9&&-!B9&-!@&#+!b!?#!5!'2(0%1!'2!
!!
[8'+(>>!
S0'()2%11!G!2#!>9-!D#9&$1!G!
!!
*2!?0%!1?&9?9!9D#B%!?0%!6&$!&'$:%!87=!91!1%%2!#2!?0%!A%@?!D92)!#@!?0%!N-%!,911!/,>9&$1!8?0%!
@#11'A1!:&9$/9AA-!$'19,,%9&'2:=!'2?#!+'(9(%9#/1!:&%%2'10!09&$!:&'?!192$1?#2%!>0'(0!,A/2:%1!?#!
?0%!e91?!/2$%&!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!@&#+!?0%!e91?%&2!1'$%!#@!?0%!2%>!0%>!0#/1%!#@!
S&%>%&2%!h'AA!?#!?0%!Z0/&(0!#@!S&%>%&2%!X/'?%!,9&9AA%A!?#!?0%!'2@%&'#&!&'$:%1!#@!10%AA-!
Y&9/>9()%!G!?0%!A#>%1?!D%$1!#@!?0%!]A$!"%$!9&%!#D1(/&%$!#2!?0%!109,%C!#@!?0%!0'AA!D/?!'2!
91(%2$'2:!'?!?0%!@'&1?!D%$1!B'1'DA%!9&%!&%$!f!:&%%2!+9&A1!?0'()A-!D%$$%$!?0%!&%$!D%'2:!&%$!
D%'2:!9('$C !!*2!91(%2$'2:!1A#,%!?0%1%!9&%!1/&+#/2?%$!D-!09&$!?0'2!D%$$%$!:&%%2'10!
1'A'(%#/1!:&'?1!>'?0!'&#2!#(0&%!%W?%&'#&1!f!@'29AA-!D-!&%$!f!:&%%2!?0'()!D%$$%$!1'A'(%#/1!
192$1?#2%!G!9!(#++#2!B9&'%?-!#@!?0%!]A$!"%$!9A1#!?0%!D%$1!#@!>0'(0!9&%!(#2@#&+9DA%!?#!?0%!
Y&9/>9()%!1A9?%C!
!!
[8'+(>A!
N0%&%!?0%1%!:&#/,1!9&%!,&#D9DA-!?&9B%&1%$!D-!1/(0!1?&%9+1!%9(0!#((91'#2!?0%!&9,'$1!f!
>9?%&@9AA1!9?!C?0%!:#&:%!(9AA%$!Z&9':!P>?!G-G$%%!>0'(0!*!$'$!2#?!B'1'?!j!S0%!
>9?%&!&/10%1!!?0&/g!9!29&&#>!:#&:%!G!5I!@%%?!$%,?0!#@!:#&:%!!f!A':0?!&%91#29DA-!B'1'DA%!9?!?0%!
?#,!!G!9A1#!9!>9?%&@9AAC!!!
S0%!D%$1!9?!?0%!@#&$!#@!Z9B92109+!9&%!(#+,9(?!DA/%!1A9?%!G!7!?#!5!'2(0%1!?0'()!>'?0#/?!@#11'A1!
G!$',!4<!?#!4bo!e!>'?0!9!A'??A%!O!#@!e!!
G!#2!&%(&#11'2:!?0%&!N-%!9?!Z9B92109+!91(%2$!?0%!N-%!?#!e&>##$!(&#11'2:!?0%!#A$%&!1?&9?9!
#@!Y&9/>9()%!G!1A9?%!'2!?0%!?0%!X/9&&'%1!9?!Y&>!.#%2!8Y&##+992v!@'2$!?0%!DA/%!1?#2-!1A9?%!
2%9&A-!#&!X/'?%!0#&'L#2?9AC!
S0'()%1?!D%$1!?0%!A#>%1?!G!1/(0!S%&%D&9?/A9%!92$!O,'&'@%&!1?'AA!?#!D%!1%%2!D/?!1(9&(%&!?092!'2!
?0%!S&%>%&2%!0'AA1!G!9A1#!9!,A92?!A')%!&%%$l1%9l1,%('+%2!!G!S0%!D%$1!'2!?0%!N-%!0#>%B%&!
9,,%9&!?#!,&%1%&B%!?0%'&!$'&%(?'#2!G!D%?>%%2!?0'1!,A9(%!f!e&>##$!2%9&!D-C!
!
<I!

[8'+(>K!
*!?0'2)!?09?!?0%&%!'1!9!,9&?'9A!$%2/$9?'#2!f!'2!?0%!N-%!9&%!+92-!D#/A$%&1!G!?0%!!!!!1?&9?9!%B'$%2?A-!
/2$%&:#!9!(#21'$%&9DA%!A#(9A!@A%W/&%!D-!>0'(0!9?!e&>##$!?0%!]A$!"%$!+#??A%$!&%$!f!:&%%2!+9&A!
f!09&$!:&%%2!:&'?!9&%!D&#/:0?!$',,'2:!?#!?0%!1#/?0!9?!9D#/?!4bo!1#!?09?!?0%!Y%#A#:'1?!'2!+9)'2:!
0'1!$%+9&(9?'#2!#@!.9,!'@!0%!09$!,911%$!#B%&!?0%!Y&9/>9()%!#@!?0%!A91?!4w!+'A%1!+':0?!+9,!?0%!
]A$!&%$!/,!?#!?0%!1?&%?(0!9?!e&>##$!8Y&%%2#/:0g1!+9,!091!*!?0'2)!D%%2!,/?!'2!%&&#&!D-!?0'1!
92?'(A'2%!#@!]A$!"%$=!
GGGGGGGGG!M1(%2$'2:!?0%!N-%!?#!?0%!c,,%&!K%&&-!9AA!$#/D?1!(%91%3!@#&!?0%!19+%!DA/%!:&%->9()%!
1A9?%1!#2!D#?0!D92)1!#@!1?&%9+!9&%!1%%2!9A1#!?#!,A/2:%!?#!?0%!1#/?0!/2$%&!,9?(0%1!#@!]A$!&%$3!1#!
?09?!>%!09B%!9!&%,A'(9!#@!?0%!(91%!#@!?0%!S&%>%&2%!h'AA1!9?!9!A#>%&!A%B%A!f!9?!9!A%11!92:A%!#@!
'2(A'29?'#2!B'L!5!?#!4Io!!'+'?9?'#2!#@!4b!?#!<I!o!G!S0%!@9/A?!*!09$!2#?!?'+%!?#!?&9(%!D/?!'?!+/1?!D%!
B%&-!(#21'$%&9DA%!G!D/?!?0%&%!(92!!
!!
[8'+(>D!
D%!2#!$#/D?!#@!'?1!%W'1?%2(%!1'2(%!*!@#/2$!?0%!19+%!@#11'A1!'2!?0%!Y&9/>9()%!1A9?%!9?!c,,%&!K#&$!
9D#B%!$%1(&'D%$C!
Z#2?'2/'2:!?#!91(%2$!?0%!N-%!?0%!&'B%&!&/21!#DA'X/%A-!#B%&!?0%!,&%B9'A'2:!$',!O#/?0!#@!f!O#/?0!
e91?%&A-!$',!#@!?0%!:&9/>9()%!1A9?%!1#!?09?!-#/!9&%!*!>'?0!9!@%>!
0#&'L#2?9A!,9?(0%1!f!1#+%!@A%W/&%1!9A>9-1!9&'1'2:!#@!A#>%&!1?&9?9C!G!9!2%>!(/?!#@!?0%!&#9$!?#!
9B#'$!9!A'??A%!0'AA!#@@%&1!9!B%&-!?0'()!D%$$%$!h9&$!&#()!#@!09B'2:!?0%!#/?>9&$!9,,%9&92(%!#@!6!?#!;!
@%%?!?0'()=!D/?!'2!?/&2!1,A'??'2:!?#!1A9?%1!:%2%&9AA-!?0&#g!1#+%?'+%1!2%9&A-!9!@##?!#@!(#+,%?%2?!
&#()!G!%B%2!'2!?0%1%!*!#D1%&B%$!
1,'&'@%&1!G!l!$',!O#/?0=!
"'B%&!?#!Z#A!X/%1?9!?0%!(A'@@1!#2!%'?0%&!1'$%!#@!?0%!N-%!,&%1%2?!9!0#&'L#2?9A!9,,%9&92(%!?0%!
%$:%1!>%9?0%&%$!1A9?-!#@!:&9-!f!(#B%&%$!>'?0!A'(0%21!G!'B-!f!D/10%1!G!ZA'@@1!#2!A%@?!D92)!<!?#!6II!
@?!0':0C!
!!
[8'+(>^!
Q')%!#A$!(91?A%1 !G!*2!?0%!,91?!(9AA%$!?0%!h%229AA?!?0'()!&##@'2:!1A9?%1!9&%!X/9&&'%$!?0%!19+%!$',!
,&%B9'A'2:!
!
<4!

<<!

<6!
E"28#%)6(XS((L#+))$1(c((L1%2O8481&((=M(7R(B?X^(DAD^(
(
!
]2!M/:/1?!63!./&(0'1#2!&%?/&2%$!?#!?0%!N-%!J9AA%-!>'?0!?0%!"%B%&%2$!SCSC!Q%>'1!#@!M-+%1?&-C!
S0%'&!9,,&#9(0!>91!@&#+!?0%!%91?!!G!#2!?0%!"9$2#&10'&%!\92)3!92$!?0%-!B'1'?%$!Z&9':!P>AA!^/!'2!
?0%!\9(0!h#>%-!:#&:%!8O]!4<4!;6b=!9D#/?!4Cb!)+!2#&?0%91?!#@!QA921?%,092!X/9&&'%13!&%?/&2'2:!
?#!h9-G#2!N-%C!!
Z&9':!P>AA!^/!'1!2#?!9!B%&-!9((%11'DA%!A#(9?'#23!'?!'1!'2!9!29&&#>!:#&:%!?09?!(92!D%!9,,&#9(0%$!
#2A-!D-!9!>9$'2:!/,!?0%!1?&%9+!#&!B'9!9!$%1(%2$'2:!9!1?%%,!B%&-!1?%%,!D92)C!h#>%B%&3!0%!
+9$%!92!9((/&9?%!1)%?(0!#@!?0%!1?&/(?/&%!?09?!(92!D%!@#/2$!?0%&%3!1#!0%!+/1?!09B%!@#/2$!9!
:##$!B'%>C!
S0%!@#AA#>'2:!$9-!./&(0'1#2!?&9B%AA%$!8>'?0#/?!Q%>'1=!#2!9A#2:!?0%!h9-!?#!\/'A?0!&#9$!#2!?0%!
\&%()2#()10'&%!D92)!#@!?0%!N-%3!92$!1?#,,%$!9?!Z#%$!O'#2G!m92'!?#!$&9>!9!@'%A$!1)%?(03!92$!
?0%2!(#+,A%?%$!9!?&9B%&1%!#2!?0%!&':0?!D92)!@&#+!S&%&'()%?!.'AA!?#!Z%@2!Y9@&#1C!!h'1!2#?%1!9A1#!
10#>!?09?!0%!09$!D%:/2!?#!1/D$'B'$%!?0%!&#()1!D91%$!#2!@#11'A1C!h%!,&#(%%$%$!?#!?0%!ZA%?>&!
\&##)!9?!e&>##$!'2!#&$%&!?#!/2$%&?9)%!9!+#&%!(#+,A%?%!1/&B%-C!
./&(0'1#2!%B'$%2?A-!>92?%$!?#!/2$%&1?92$!?0%!92#+9A-!#2!Y&%%2#/:0E1!+9,!0%!09$!
$'1(#B%&%$!?0%!,&%B'#/1!-%9&!j!92$!0'1!+#?'B%!9?!?0'1!1?9:%!+9-!2#?!09B%!D%%2!?&/A-!
1?&9?':&9,0'(9A!j!?0%!E#&$%&'2:!#@!?0%!&#()1E!!0%!A9?%&!%1,#/1%$!91!0'1!+'11'#2!G!!D/?!0'1!@#(/1!
>91!#2!@'2$'2:!%B'$%2(%!@#&!92$!/2$%&1?92$'2:!?0%!1?&/(?/&%3!2#?!A%91?!D%(9/1%!0'1!(/&'#1'?-!
>91!9&#/1%$!D-!>09?!0%!09$!1%%2!?0%!,&%B'#/1!$9-!9?!Z&9':!P>AA!^/C!!h'1!%W,A#&9?'#2!D%:92!D-!
91(%2$'2:!?0%!ZA%??>&!\&##)!!@&#+!e&>##$!?#!Z&'()9$9&23!>0%&%!'?!@A#>1!?0&#/:0!9!29&&#>!
:#&:%!>0'(0!'1!'2!9((%11'DA%!'2!,9&?13!1#!'?!'1!2#?!%2?'&%A-!(A%9&!0#>!0%!@#AA#>%$!?0%!ZA%??>&3!D/?!
?0%&%!9&%!9!1%&'%1!#@!@##?,9?01!?09?!(&'11(&#11!?0%!B9AA%-!92$!'?1!1A#,%1!92$!'?!'1!A')%A-!?09?!
./&(0'1#2!/1%$!?0%1%!?#!9'$!0'1!1/&B%-C!
*?!9A+#1?!1%%+1!91!?0#/:0!./&(0'1#2!&%B%A1!'2!'2!9((%11'DA%!A#(9?'#21!j!0%!(%&?9'2A-!$'$2E?!
,%&(%'B%!?0%+!91!9!D9&&'%&!?#!%W,A#&9?'#2!92$!+9)'2:!#D1%&B9?'#21C!!
!

<;!

<b!

<7!

<H!

<5!
L#+))$1(c(L1%2O8481&((>?KA(((@(/012*%-"&Y-(8))+I.)-()"($"1O("0)()*+(-)102)01+S(
>?KA(.S(?B!
*2!?0%!N-%!91!@9&!91!(92!D%!1%%2!?0%!A#>%1?!D%$1!9&%!&%$!92$!:&%%2!+9&A1?#2%1!>0'(0!
9@?%&>9&$1!9A?%&29?%!>'?0!:&%%2'10!09&$!+'(9(%#/1!@A9:1?#2%1!!f!&%$!1#+%!1,#??%$!>'?0!:&%%2!
?0%!>0#A%!09B'2:!+/(0!#@!?0%!1/,%&@'('9A!9,,%9&92(%!#@!]A$!"%$C!!!
S0%!>0#A%!$',,'2:!ON!<Io!S0'1!'1!1##2!$'1(#B%&%$!?#!D%!9!,9&?'9A!@A%W/&%!D-!91(%2$'2:!'2!?0%!D%$!
#@!?0%!ZA%??>&!'2!>0'(0!?0%1%!D%$1!1#+%!#@!?0%!@'2%1?!$%%,!,#&,0#&-!&%$!f!#?0%&1!D&'AA'92?!
:&%%2!'2!B%&-!1?&#2:!D92$1!f!#@!:&%9?!?0'()2%11!92$!9&%!1%%2!?#!D%!0':0A-!(#2?#&?%$!/2$%&!
Z&'()9$9&2!Z0/&(0!?#!?0%!Oe!92$!#2!?0%!#?0%&!?#!?0%!mN!/2$%&!S>+,9?0!h'AAC!j!>0'A1?!
91(%2$'2:!?0%!ZA%??>&!1?'AA!@/&?0%&!?#!?0%!uu!.'AA!?0%!19+%!&%$!1-1?%+!,911%1!@'&1?!/2$%&!:&%%2!
@A9:1!92$!@'29AA-!/2$%&!?0%!@#11'A'@%&#/1!:&#/,!#((/,-'2:!?0%!1'$%1!92$!1/++'?!#@!S>+,9?0!j!
0%2(%3!'C%C!#2!?0%!OC!1'$%!#@!?0'1!(928u=!?0%!$',!#@!?0%!A#>%1?!D%$1!'1!6Io!f!2%9&A-!$/%!m#&?0!8bo!e!
#@=!C!
S0%!S>+,9?0!&'$:%!'1!%11%2?'9AA-!Y&%->9()%!9AA!?0%!A92$1!#2!%'?0%&!1'$%!9&%!:&%-!(A9-13!f!?0%!
,%9)1!:&%-!A'(0%21C!
G!#2!?0%!e91?%&2!1A#,%!?#>9&$1!e&>##$!?0%!D%$1!9&%!?0&#>2!'2!?0%!mN!9?!6Io!#B%&A-'2:!?0%!@A9:!
1?#2%!9D#B%!$%1(&'D%$!D/?!?0%!>0%%A!9&#/2$!f!D-!!!$%1(%2$'2:!?0%!N-%!?0%!19+%!1-1?%+!91!
(#21?'?/?%1!?0%!>%1?%&2!@9(%!#@!S>+,9?0!'1!@#/2$!?#!09B%!&%(#B%&%$!'?1!?&/%!O!e91?%&2!$',!9?!4b!
?#!45oC!
!!
.S?>!
M?!@'&1?!1/,,#1%1!?0%!:&%9?!!uu!#@!&%$!A92$!%W?%2$'2:!@&#+!e&>##$!91!92!9,%W!?#!D-!Z&'()!?#!
.%&?0-&!Z-2#:!C!!
G!>91!?0%!]A$!"%$!O92$1?#2%!D&#/:0?!'2!D-!9!:&%9?!@9/A?!j!D/?!?0%!9D#B%!>#&)!8,911%1u=!?0'1!&%$!
1-1?%+!?#!/2$%&A9'2!?0%!/,,%&!@#11'A1!:&%->9()%C!
S0'1!&%$!1-1?%+!0%&%!#@!(#21'$%&9DA%!?0'()2%11!9@@#&$1!9!:##$!(0%()!$'1?&'(?!!f!'1!?&9(%9DA%!D-!
?0%!%-%!@#&!+92-!+'A%1!D%?>%%2!<!!:u!:u!
G!*?!'1!$%B%A#,!?0%!%X/'B9A%2?!#@!?0%!"%$!Y&9/>()%!#@!O9A#,!D%@#&%!$%1(&'D%$3!f!'1!?0%&%@#&%!A#>!
'2!?0%!1%&'%1!
G!*?!9,,%9&!?#!?&9B%&1%!?0%!N-%!#,,#1'?%!e&>##$!D/?!?0%!"%B$!.!N'AA'9+1!'2(/+D%2?!#@!?0%!
,9&'10!0%!?0'2)1!'1!0%&%!?##!(#/A$!2#?!(#2@'&+!!?0#E!!0%!)2%>!#@!%W?%2?!?#!?0%!2#&?0C!
Altered'in'frequent'views''''''(fault)'''see'map'–'!!
#2!?0%!1/++'?!#@!S>+G,9?0!0'AA!?0%!$'1'2?%:&9?'2:!1/&@9(%1!#@!?0%!(A%9B9:%!#@!?0%!D%$1!:'B%1!?0%!
9,,%9&92(%!#@!B%&?'(9A!D%$1!09B'2:!9!1?&')%!#@!ON!f!me!D/?!#2!:#'2:!$#>2!?#!?0%!D%$!#@!?0%!
N-%!>0%&%!1'+'A9&!9,,%9&92(%1!#((/&!9?!?0%!@%&&-!*!@#/2$!?09?!?0%-!>%&%!$%(%,?'B%!j!!
]D1%&B%$!?09?!?0%!D&%9)1!f!@A%W/&%1!>%&%!@/AA-!(#++#2!#((/&&%2(%1!#2!?0%!A%@?!D92)!#@!?0%!
N-%!/2$%&!Y9&?0!f!,9&?'(/A9&A-!9?!?0%!'B-G%2(&/1?%$!@9(%1!l!uuu!!>0'(0!#((/,'%1!?0%!,&#?&/$'2:!
)2#AA!2%9&!?0%!@9/A?!#@!?0%!\&9'(0GN-%!l\9(0#>%-!j!A'2%!#@!?0%!Z&9':!,>AAG$%%!(#2?#&?'#21C!
!!
.S(?A!
S0%!+#1?!'2?%&%1?'2:!,#'2?!*!#D1%&B%$!%W,A929?#&-!#@!?0%!:&%9?!@A%W/&%!9D#B%!$%1(&'D%$!9,,%9&1!
D-!1(&9+DA'2:!$#>2!?0%!ZA%??>&!@&#+!?0%!uuu!.'AA!!?#!e&>##$!!G!9!A'??A%!m!#@!Z0/&(0C!
!

<V!
E"28#%)6(_((R5+15%+$(",(()*+(91+2"&(:&)%2#%&8#(%&()*+(`1$""4(4%-)1%2)(U=M(7R(B_D(D>AW!
((((((((((((((((((((/012*%-"&Z-(+.%-"4+(d(7+.)+IJ+1(>?KX((3%1(982*(
S0'1!A#(9?'#2!,&#B'$%1!9!:##$!B'%>!?#!A##)!#B%&!?0%!A92$1(9,%!!1/++9&'1%!>09?!./&(0'1#2!09$!
$'1(#B%&%$!#2!0'1!%W(/&1'#21!'2!?#!?0%!!N-%!B9AA%-!#@!?0%1%!,9&?1C!!
S0%!@'29A!#((91'#2!#@!./&(0'1#2E1!@'%A$>#&)!'2!?0%!\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29A!+':0?!D%!1%%2!91!9!(#2?&91?!
?#!0'1!'2'?'9A!%2(#/2?%&!9?!e&>##$!@'B%!-%9&1!%9&A'%&!?09?!09$!,&#B%$!1#!@#&?/'?#/1!92$!
,&#$/(?'B%C!./&(0'1#2!&%(#&$1!?0%!#((91'#2!'2!0'1!2#?%D##)!91!FM2!%,'1#$%EC!!S0'1!'2('$%2?!
?0&#>1!1#+%!A':0?!#2!0'1!(09&9(?%&!92$!?0%!#2!&%9A'?-!#@!?0%!&%,/?9?'#2!0%!(/A?'B9?%$!91!9!+92!
#@!?0%!,&#$':'#/1!%2%&:-!'2!?0%!@'%A$C!!!
S0%!:&#/2$!(#B%&%$!D-!./&(0'1#2!#2!0'1!?#/&1!1/::%1?1!0%!$'$!09B%!92!%W(%,?'#29A!(9,9('?-!@#&!
09&$!@'%A$!>#&)C!Z09&A%1!Q-%AA!$%1(&'D%1!1#+%?0'2:!#@!?0%!29?/&%!#@!./&(0'1#2E1!@'%A$!F&#/?'2%E!!
'2!?0%'&!R#'2?!45<5!(#2?'2%2?9A!?#/&!
TWe%got%under%sail%by%six%some%mornings%&%at%5%o’c.lk%some%others%&%M.%certainly%keeps%it%up%
with%more%energy%than%anyone%I%ever%travelled%withU!8Q%??%&!Q-%AA!?#!0'1!@9?0%&3!<7!.9-!45<53!
X/#?%$!9@?%&!N'A1#2!84VH<=!,C4VHC=!
Q-%AA!(#+,A9'2%$!?09?!./&(0'1#2!09$!Ta%little%too%much%of%what%Mathews%used%to%redicule%in%his%
slang%as%‘the%keep%moving,%go-it-if-%it-kills-you’%system,%and%I%had%to%fight%sometimes%for%the%
sake%of%geology,%as%his%wife%had%for%her%strength,%to%make%him%proceed%with%somewhat%less%
precipitatio2U!8[C!Q-%AA!45543!J#AC!4_!4VH=C!!
S0%!(91/9A!#D1%&B%&!+':0?!9??&'D/?%!?#!0'1!+'A'?9&-!92$!0/2?'2:!D9():&#/2$!92$!Q-%AA!1%%+%$!
?#!09B%!9$+'&%$!0'1!(#+,92'#2E1!%2%&:-C!!h#>%B%&3!'?!1##2!'?!D%(9+%!9,,9&%2?!?09?!
./&(0'1#2!(#/A$!#2A-!1?92$!?0%!$9'A-!%@@#&?!D-!/1'2:!1?'+/A9?'2:!$&/:1_!
“Murchison%must%have%been%intended%for%a%strong%man,%if%the%sellers%of%drugs%had%not%enlisted%
him%into%their%service,%so%that%he%depends%on%them%for%his%existence%to%a%frightful%extent,%yet%
withal%he%can%get%through%what%would%knock%up%most%men%who%never%need%the%doctor.%He%has%
only%given%in%one%day%and%a%half%yet.%On%one%occasion%we%were%on%an%expedition%together,%and%
as%a%stronger%dose%was%necessary%than%he%had%with%him,%I%was%not%a%little%alarmed%at%finding%
there%was%no%pharmacy%in%the%place,%but%at%last%we%went%to%a%nunnery,%where%Mdlle.%La%Supe
´rieure%sold%all%medicines%without%profit%[.%.%.]%who%hoped%my%friend%would%think%better%of%it,%as%
the%quantity%would%kill%six%Frenchmen.%M.%was%cured,%and%off%the%next%morning,%as%usual.”!
O#/&(%!_!Q%??%&!G!!Q-%AA!?#!0'1!+#?0%&3!44!d/2%!45<53!'2!Q-%AA3![C!84554=!>3!,C!45VC!
S0%!%,'1#$%!'2!4567!+':0?!>%AA!09B%!(9/:0?!./&(0'1#2!9>9-!@&#+!0'1!1/,,#&?!#@!1?'+/A92?1C!*?!
1%%+1!?#!09B%!#((/&&%$!A9?%!'2!?0%!$9-!9@?%&!9!1%B%&%!1?#&+!>0%2!./&(0'1#2!>91!'21,%(?'2:!
?0%!:&#/2$!D%?>%%2!x1:>-$$!h>(0!92$!Z&'()9&$9&2C!
./&(0'1#2E1!2#?%1!92$!#D1%&B9?'#21!!'2!?0'1!%,'1#$%!10#>!/,!1#+%!#@!0'1!9??'?/$%1!92$!
,&%R/$'(%13!,9&?'(/A9&A-!?#>9&$1!?0#1%!E29?'B%1E!!>0#!$#!2#?!1,%9)!e2:A'10C!!M?!#?0%&!?'+%1!'2!0'1!
2#?%D##)1!0%!>&'?%1!(#++%2?!#2!?0%!1#('9A!(#2$'?'#21!0%!%2(#/2?%&%$3!#((91'#29AA-!:'B'2:!
>9-!?#!1-+,9?0-!!@#&!?0%!F$#>2?&#$$%2E!G!9!?&9'?!2#?!#@?%2!911#('9?%$!>'?0!./&(0'1#2!?0%!
(/A?'B9?%$!'+,%&'9A'1?y!!!
*2?%&%1?'2:A-3!9!!,&%B'#/1!F%,'1#$%E!!'2!456<!'2!\&%(#2!9A1#!'2$'(9?%$!9?!./&(0'1#2E1!
B/A2%&9D'A'?-3!&%(#&$'2:_!
“Alas,%3%days%viz%4nights%at%the%Castle%Brecon%–%1st%Big%Sunday%to%recoup,%journalize%and%recover%
–%overdid%my%work%–%brought%on%%??%Fever%–%went%to%Merthyr%on%20th%when%I%ought%to%have%
taken%physic%&%returned%worse.%%The%Surgeon%Watkins%a%rough%practitioner%but%the%chemist%old%
Vaughan%a%kind%and%intelligent%man.”%%8456<!.lm!76C!,C77=!
!
!

6I!

d/A-!4567!!!!!!.&!./&(0'1#2!
!!Z91?A%!*22!
!!\&%(#2 !!!!e,'1#$%!
!!
!^9B'$!.#&:92!#@!S'&GD9(0!
!
9!1%B%&%!?&'9A!'2!>%?!1?#&+!#@!&9'2!?9)%2!:'$$-!92$!9D#/?!?#!:#C!
!^9B'$!.#&:92E1!>'@%!89!"9$2#&10'&%!N#+92=!
eW(%AA%2?!:##$!>#+92!j!0%&!(09&9(?%&!'2!#,,#1'?'#2!?#!?0%!1/1,'('#2!#@!0%&!0/1D92$C!
!!
S0%!#2A-!@##$!?0%1%!,##&!,%#,A%!09$!>'?0!?%9!f!9!A'??A%!$&#,!#@!&/+!81%&B%$! !D-rrrrrrrr!'2!
92!#A$!(&/%?=!&%B'B%$!+%C!
]A$!>##$%2!D#>A!D&#/:0?!#/?!@#&!+%!!!!!1?92$!'2!(A#1%!?0%!@'&%!>0'A1?!(A#?0%1!>%&%!$&-'2:!f!w!
0#/&!?#!,&#$/(%!D#'A'2:!>9?%&!j!('&(/A9?'#2!&%1?#&%$!92$!&%?/&2!#@!1%21%1C!
]A$!A9$-!>&9,,'2:!+%!'2!0%&!0/1D92$E1!>9&+!(#9?!G!f!,/AA'2:!>9&+!>##A%2!1?#()'2:1!#B%&!+-!
092$1!*!@9(%$!?0%!>%9?0%&!?#!&'$%!0#+%!?#!\&%(#2!4I!+'A%!&'$%!#B%&!?0%!+##&A92$1!f!
+#/2?9'2C!
eB%2!#A$!^9B'$!+%A?%$!?0#/:0!0%!>91!1/1,'('#/1!#@!>09?!*!>#/A$!:'B%!0'+C!S0%!>'@%E1!
'2$':29?'#2!9?!0'1!(0/&A'102%11C!
h#>!10%!+9$%!T?0%!!rrrrrr!?9)!F0'1E!9/$!(A#9)!9D#/?!0'+UC!
m#>!?0%!+9&%!>91!D&#/:0?!92$!0%!+#/2?%$!809B'2:!9!D&#)%2!A%:=!#2!9!19()!>'?0!<!09'&!D92$1!
2#!1?'&&/,1!f!?0%2(%!>%!&%9(0%$!\&%(#2C!
!!
^9B'$!.#&:92!'1!,&#,&'%?#&!#@!6I!9(&%1!@&%%0#A$!j!1,%9)1!A'??A%!e2:A'10!f!S'&G\9(0!'1!0'1!#>23!9!
-#/2:%&!D&#?0%&!N'AA'9+!.#&:92!9!ZA%&:-+92!'2!\&9$@#&$!x#&)10'&%C!!h'1!Z%A?'(!,&'$%!8X/'?%!A')%!
#2%!#@!+-!h':0A92$!)'21+92=!09$!0'+!9?!@'&1?!?#!'2@#&+!+%!91!#@!?0'1!>0'A1?!/2$%&!?0%!1+#)%-!
#((A/1'#2!#@!?0%!@9&+!@'&%C!
h%!>91!?#!:'B%!+%!9!&%91#2!#@!0'1!(#2$'?'#2C!
N0'A1?!#2!?0%!&'$%!?#!\&%(#2!0%!A%?!#/?!?09?!?0%!"%B%&%2$!N'AA'9+13!?0%!b!-%9&1!0'1!-#/2:%&!
D&#?0%&l]A$!.#&:92!09B'2:!1,%2?!+/(0!#2!19'$!N'AA'9+E1!%$/(9?'#2!?#!(&%9?%!9!,9&1#2!#@!0'+!
09$!$#2%!0'1!D%1?!#/?!#@!D&#?0%&A-!A#B%!>'?0!Z0&'1?'92!(09&'?-!?#!&#D!#A$!^9B'$!#@!0'1!0%&'?9:%!j!
1%2$!0'+!9!Z092(%&-!A%??%&!f!,/?!0'+!?#!Q%:9A!#@@'(%1!(A9'+'2:!?0%!,&#,%&?-C!
h#>!9!\&%(#2!9??#&2%-!19B%$!^9B'$!92$!0#>!0%!091!%B%&!1'2(%!&%?/&2%$!?0%!19'$!"%B%&%2$!
A%??%&1!/2#,%2%$C!
!!
*!(922#?!A#B%!?0%!OC!N%A10!j!?0#/:0!^9B'$!.#&:92E1!>'@%E1!92!%W(%AA%2?!)'2$!>#+92!j!10%!>91!
#@!"9$2#&!f!0%2(%!e2:A'10C!^9B'1!>91!?0%!1/1,'('#/1!GGGGrrrrrrr!?0#/:0!>%!%2$%$!%W(%AA%2?!
@&'%2$1!f!#2!:9'2'2:!#@!?0%'&!]A$!!Z#9(0!9?!?0%!!DA9()1!#@!\&%(#2!0%!@%A?!9109+%$!#@!9,,%9&'2:!
?0%!rrrr!?'+%&!92$!D%::%$!+%!?#!:'B%!0'+!>09?!*!,A%91%$C!!M!h':0A92$%&!(#/A$!2%B%&!09B%!
+9$%!?0%!!!,&%A'+'29&'%1!91!?#!b!#&!4I!10'AA'2:1!@#&!0'1!?91)1C!S0'1!'1!?0%!'21?&/(?'B%!$'@@%&%2(%C!
h#>%B%&!?#!$#!#A$!^9B'$!R/1?'(%!0%!09$!09$!9!A#2:!D#/?!>'?0!0'1!D&#)%2!A%:!f!09$!D%%2!
,&%B%2?%$!@&#+!>#&)'2:!92$!09$!'2(/&&%$!9!^#(?#&E1!D'AA!#@!4I$C!
!
64!

6<!
S0%!:&9B%!0%9$1?#2%!#@!^9B'$!f!M22%!.#&:923!Z&'()9$9&2!Z0/&(0-9&$C!

66!
G85%4(/"1'8&((
^9B'$!.#&:92!>91!D#&2!'2!4HH;!92$!$'%$!#2!V?0!d/2%!45;4!89:%$!7H=!92$!>91!
D/&'%$!#2!4<?0!d/2%!45;4C!!M22%!.#&:92!>91!D#&2!'2!4HHb!92$!D/&'%$!#2!<7?0!
M,&'A!45;7!89:%$!H4=C!
!
N'AA'9+!.#&:92!>91!D#&2!'2!4HHV!92$!$'%$!'2!45b5!89:%$!#@!HV=C!
^9B'$!.#&:92E1!@9?0%&!>91!.#&:92!.#&:92!84H;bG45<V=!&%(#&$%$!91!@9&+%&!#@!
b<!9(&%1!9?!S'&!\9(0C!
M1!^9B'$!.#&:92!&%B%9A%$!?#!./&(0'1#2!0%!@9&+%$!6I!9(&%1!92$!+#2%-!>91!
1,%2?!#2!%$/(9?'2:!0'1!-#/2:%&!D&#?0%&!N'AA'9+!8,&#D9DA-!9?!Z0&'1?E1!Z#AA%:%!
\&%(#2=!'?!'1!,#11'DA%!?09?!.#&:92!1%2'#&!1#A$!<<!9(&%1!#@!A92$!?#!@/2$!0'1!
D&#?0%&E1!%$/(9?'#2C!!
N'AA'9+!.#&:92!>91!#&$9'2%$!,&'%1?!45Ib3!9!E4I!-%9&!+92E!9?!Z9+D&'$:%3!
9$+'??%$!?#!e++92/9A!Z#AA%:%!'2!4546!91!9!1'L9&3!&%+#B%$!?#!z/%%2E1!Z#AA%:%!'2!
45473!0%!+9?&'(/A9?%$!'2!45<<!92$!>91!9>9&$%$!9!\C^C!'2!45<6C!!
L"&&+2)%"&($%)*()*+(91"&)e!,8I%#6(
S0%!"%B%&%2$!N'AA'9+!.#&:92!'1!$%1(&'D%$!91!T9!,#&?A-3!A#X/9('#/1!N%A10+92a!
45I7j4<!911'1?92?!(/&9?%!MAA!O9'2?13!N%AA'2:?#23!O0&#,10'&%a!'2(/+D%2?!#@!
\'%&A%-3!x#&)1C3!@&#+!454<CU!8MA%W92$%&!f!O+'?03!<II73!]W@#&$!Z#+,92'#2!?#!?0%!
\&#2?{13!]cP=C!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
N'AA'9+!.#&:92!>91!J'(9&!#@!Z0&'1?!Z0/&(03!\&9$@#&$!@&#+!454H!92$!>91!2#?%$!
91!9!T1?&%2/#/1!>#&)%&!'2!?0%!(9/1%!#@!&%A':'#2!92$!?%+,%&92(%UC!h%!>913!D-!9AA!
&%,#&?13!#@!9!(0#A%&'(!92$!'&91('DA%!?%+,%&9+%2?3!92$!'?!>91!&%,#&?%$!#@!0'+!?09?!
#2!#2%!#((91'#2!0%!1%2?!0'1!(##)!?#!R9'A!@#&!+9)'2:!?0'2!19/(%y!8h9+DA%-!"#>%!
84V<6=!S0%!.9?%&29A!"%A9?'B%1!#@!?0%!\&#2?{1!!D-!Z9W?#2!P&%11=C!
*?!'1!19'$!?09?!^&!S0#+91!\#/A?D-!'2!Z09&A#??%g1!2#B%A3!O0'&A%-3!'1!+#$%AA%$!#2!?0'1!
@9+'A-!@&'%2$C!
N'AA'9+!.#&:92!$'%$!#2!6I!.9&(0!45b5!G!?0&%%!-%9&1!D%@#&%!P9?&'()!\&#2?%C!
!
*2!45IV!"%B$!P9?&'()!\&#2?{!D%(9+%!9!@%AA#>!(/&9?%!'2!O0&#,10'&%!92$!?0%!
?>#!1/D1%X/%2?A-!D%(9+%!A'@%GA#2:!@&'%2$1C!!
*2!454<!9!R#'2?!>%$$'2:!>'?0!P9?&'()!9?!O?C!]1>9A$g1!Z0/&(03!Y/'1%A%-3!%9(0!
(/&9?%!'2!?/&2!+9&&'%$!?0%!g#?0%&!?>#gC(\&#2?{!>91!+9&&'%$!?#!!.9&'9!
\&92>%AA!D-!.#&:92!92$!.#&:92!>91!+9&&'%$!?#!.9&'9E1!!(#/1'23!d92%!
K%22%A3!D-!!\&#2?{C!
S0%!?>#!D&'$%13!A')%>'1%3!9(?%$!91!%9(0!#?0%&g1!D&'$%1+9'$1C!d92%!K%22%A!
/A?'+9?%A-!D%(9+%!e+'A-g1!:#$+#?0%&!G!92$!>91!?0%!1#/&(%!#@!0%&!+'$$A%!
29+%!8M22%!>91!29+%$!9@?%&!0%&!+9?%&29A!:&92$+#?0%&!92$!#2%!#@!
P9?&'()!\&#2?%g1!1'1?%&1=C!!!N'AA'9+!.#&:92!>91!A9?%&!?#!,%&@#&+!?0%!
+'2'1?%&'9A!$/?'%1!#@!(0&'1?%2'2:!Z09&A#??%3!\&92>%AA3!e+'A-!92$!M22%3!92$!
1%B%&9A!-%9&1!A9?%&!1?'AA3!0%!g#@@'('9?%$g!9?!.9&'9g1!8.&1C!\&#2?{=!@/2%&9A_!0%!
9A1#!,%&@#&+%$!?0%!@/2%&9A!1%&B'(%!#@!P9?&'()g1!?0&%%!(0'A$&%23!.9&'93!
eA'L9D%?0!92$!\&92>%AAC!!
!

6;!
G86(A((((
(
E"28)%"&(?S((((((((L"1&(N(!8&((=M((7V(\?^>(K^K\(
E"28)%"&(\S(((((((L8-)+##(M*%$8&+-)((=M((7R(B>^?(KX>X(
E"28)%"&(>BS(((((:##)(!8$1((=M(7R(BKXB(K_>B(!
!
S0'1!,9&?!#@!?0%!%W(/&1'#2!%W,A#&%1!?0%!>%1?%&2!%W?%21'#2!#@!?0%!\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29A!D%?>%%2!
B9AA%-1!#@!?0%!h#2$$/3!x1('&!@9(0!92$!x1('&!!@9(0!92$!?0%!'2?%&B%2'2:!&'$:%1!92$!0'AA1C!
!
./&(0'1#2!@'&1?!%2(#/2?%&%$!?0'1!,9&?!#@!?0%!1?&/(?/&%!'2!456<C!]2!O/2$9-!b?0!M/:/1?!0%!09$!9!
(#2@%&%2(%!>'?0!\/$:%2!?0%!]&2$92(%!O/&B%-#&!?0%2!(&#11'2:!?0%!.-2-$$!e,,-2?!!1#/?0!!@&#+!
\/'A?0!N%AA1!?#!\&%(#2!!!T!>0'(0!*!@#/2$!?#!D%!9!$'&%(?!?&921B%&1%!1%(?'#2!!'2!?0%!91(%2$'2:!#&$%&CU!
9A#2:!>09?!'1!2#>!?0%!\!;b<I!&#9$C!!./&(0'1#2!(#B%&%$!+/(0!:&#/2$!3!1%%+'2:A-!:%??'2:!9A+#1?!
91!@9&!91!\&%(#2C!h%!+/1?!09B%!D&'%@A-!B'1'?%$!.%&?0-&!Z-2#:!92$!0%&%!'1!@'&1?!+%2?'#2!#@!Z#22G-G
K92C!h%!9A1#!+9)%1!2#?%!#@!!"BC!N9A?%&!^9B'%1!3!>0#!09$!1/&B%-%$!92$!>&'??%2!!TM!Y%2%&9A!B'%>!
#@!?0%!9:&'(/A?/&%!92$!$#+%1?'(!%(#2#+-!#@!1#/?0!N9A%1U!8454;=!>0'(0!>91!?0%!O#/?0!N9A%1!
%X/'B9A%2?!#@!K9&%E1!?#+%!#2!^%&D-10'&%C!!*?!'1!2#?!(A%9&!0#>!+/(0!./&(01'#2!)2%>!#@!#&!
(#21/A?%$!?0'1!B#A/+%3!D/?!'?!(#2?9'21!D91'(!:%#A#:'(9A!#D1%&B9?'#213!+9'2A-!'2!&%A9?'#2!?#!?0%!
$'1?&'D/?'#2!#@!1#'A1!92$!'?!(#2?9'21!92!'2?%&%1?'2:!+9,C!N0%?0%&!?0'13!#&!1#+%!#?0%&3!>91!?0%!
1#/&(%!#@!'2@#&+9?'#23!./&(0'1#2!&%?/&2%$!?#!?0'1!9&%9!!A9?%&!'2!?0%!+#2?0!@#AA#>'2:!92#?0%&!
1%(?'#2!92$!?&9B%&1%!9(&#11!.-2-$$!e,,-2?!!#2!0'1!>9-!?#!\&%(#23!>0%&%!0%!>91!A9'$!/,!@#&!6!
$9-13!?0&#/:0!#B%&!>#&)C!
!
S0'1!!9&%9!(#2?'2/%$!?#!'2?&':/%!./&(0'1#2!92$!0%!&%?/&2%$!?0%!@#AA#>'2:!-%9&!'2!4566!!>0%&%!0%!
+9$%!9!$%?9'A%$!$%1(&',?'#2!92$!1/&B%-!#@!FU!S0'1!1'2:/A9&!&#()-!,&#+#2?#&-!?0%!(/A+'29?'#2!!
1?&9?9!#@!?0%!P%2'21/A9&!#@!Q/$A#>!"C!>0'(0!1?&%?(0%$!@&#+!e&>##$!f!S&%&'()%?!#2!?0%!N-%!?#!
?0'1!1,#?`CCU!8./&(0'1#2!4566!,C7C=C!
!
h%&!&%?/&2%$!9:9'2!'2!4567!'2!O%,?%+D%&!@#AA#>'2:!?0%!\&'?'10!M11#('9?'#2!.%%?'2:!9?!\&'1?#A3!
09B'2:!+9$%!92!9,,#'2?+%2?!>'?0!d#02!P0'AA',1!!?#!+%%?!0'+!'2!\&%(#2!8,&%1/+9DA-!./&(0'1#2!
,9'$!P0'AA',1u=!!>0%&%!0%!(A%9&A-!>92?%$!?0%!-#/2:!19B92?E1!!B'%>!#2!?0%!1?&/(?/&%!#@!?0%!\&%(#2!
M2?'(A'29A!92$!'2!,9&?'(/A9&!#2!?0%!(A%9B9:%!!'2!?0%!&#()1!92$!92-!1':2'@'(92(%!?0'1!+':0?!0#A$C!
S0%!%B%2?1!#@!?0'1!%W(/&1'#2!!9&%!#/?A'2%$!D-!Y%')%!'2!0'1!./&(0'1#2!+%+#'&!#@!45HbC!
!
P&#$/(%$!0%&%!9&%!?0%!@'%A$!2#?%1!#@!D#?0!./&(0'1#2!92$!P0'AA',1!j!>0'(0!!9@@#&$1!9!(#+,9&'1#2!
#@!?0%'&!1?-A%!j!92$!:'B%!'2$'(9?'#21!91!?#!0#>!%9(0!9,,&#9(0%$!92$!&%(#&$%$!92!%W,#1/&%3!
,%&09,1!>'?0!'21':0?1!'2?#!?0%!%W?%2?!#@!?0%'&!F,0'A#1#,0'(9A!?0'2)'2:EC!!S0'1!'1!>#&)!'2!,&#:&%11!!
92$!9!+#&%!$%?9'A%$!929A-1'1!>'AA!D%!,&#$/(%$!9?!9!A9?%&!$9?%C!
!
!
(
(
(
(
(

/V(X^(UV+$(V")+J""O(VBXW((:0'0-)(>?KA(
!!
O/2$9-!M/:/1?!b?0!!!!pK&#+!Z>+Gm92?!Y>-2!1?&%9+!1%(?'#2q!?&9B%AA'2:!1C!
!!
PVC!
!!
.%&?0-&!Z-2#:!8$A%??>!Z-2#:=!81%%!Z&9$#()E1!h'1?#&-!#@!N9A%1!!!!!!!!!!!0#/1%!9?!!
!!!!!f!S0%#,0C!d#2%1!\&%(#2!
!!
Z#&2G-GK92!j!@#&+%&A-!(#B%&%$!>'?0!>##$C!
&%$!D92$!(A#1%!#2!m!1'$%!92$!O!1'$%!!
>'?0!;!j!bII!-9&$1!j!9,%W!1?%%,!$',!1#/?0!
!!
"B$C!N9A?%&!^9B'%1!!#@!
!!
.%&?0-&!Z-2#:1E!)%,?!#2!6&$!S0/&1$9-!](?!#A$!1?-A%!j!!
D#??A%1!#@!!Orrrrrrrru!!f!!\rrrrrrrr!
#A$!Z0/&(0!#@!.%&?0-&!Z-2#:!
!!
Z#&21?#2%!9AA!?0&#E!?0%!"%$!D%$!'2!D#>A$%&1!j!?/&2%$!/,!D-!?0%!,A#/:0!j!!
f!,9&?'(/A9&A-!'2!D%$!!#@!9?!P>A!Z9%2!#2!?0%!x1('&!j@9>&!j!<4l<!+8'A%1=!9D#B%!?0%!c,,%&!Z09,%A!
A'??A%!$',!'2!?0%!1?&9?9!9?!?09?!,#'2?C!
"%$!Y&'?1!f!9!
!
6b!

67!

P9:%1!6IG64!%W?&9(?%$!@&#+_!!N9A?%&!^9B'%1!8454;=!General%view%of%the%agriculture%and%domestic%
%economy%of%south%Wales;%containing%the%counties%of%Brecon,%Caermarthen,%Cardigan,%Glamorgan,%
Pembroke,%Radnor3!J#AC!4C!^&9>2!/,!@#&!?0%!Z#21'$%&9?'#2!#@!S0%!\#9&1!#@!M:&'(/A?/&%!92$!@#&!!
!*2?%&29A!*+,&#B%+%2?C!O0%&>##$3!m%%A-!fd#2%1_!P9?%&2#1?%&!"#>C!!!
!
!
6H!

65!
M/:/1?!!45?0!456<!
O%(?'#2!\&%(#2!?#!c,,%&!Z09,%A!
Q9'$!/,!'2!\&%(#2!!4V?0G<41?!M/:/1?!

6V!

;I!

;4!

/V(XX((>?KK((((.8'+(X(
!!
L"1&@N@!8&(91+2"&(
!!
!!
[8'+(X((
S0%!TQ/$A#>!"#()U!'1!9!09&$!@A9::-!:&9/>9()%!192$1?#2%!D92$!!!>'?0!1+9AA!1,92:A%1!#@!+'(9!
$'11%+'29?%$!!
8G!!9!@%>!(91?1!#@!10%AA1=!
!G!Q'(0%2!(#B%&'2:!'?!91!#2!?0%!D92)1!#@!?0%!N-%!j!!
!!
!!
S0'1!1'2:/A9&!&#()-!,&#+#2?#&-!?0%!(/A+'29?'#2!1?&9?9!#@!?0%!P%2'21/A9&!!!#@!Q/$A#>!"!>0'(0!
1?&%?(0%$!@&#+!e&>##$!f!S&%&'()%?!#2!?0%!N-%!?#!?0'1!1,#?C!h91!9!@A9?!?#,!#@!!>'$?0!2#?!
%W(%%$'2:!bI!,9(%1!j!92!92('%2?!(91?A%!K92!#&!J92!j!Z#&2!?0%!T0#/1%U!j!'?!*!1/&&#/2$%$!D-!9!
$#/DA%!$'?(0!f!091!9!>%AA!#2!'?1!1/++'?C!6I!-%9&1!9:#!'?!>91!(#B%&%$!>'?0!A9&:%!#9)1!?0#E!(A'+D!
?0%!(&9:1!+9)%1!9!,&#?&/1'#2!j!0%2(%!?0%!29+%C!
S0%!&#()!'1!@A9::-!Q/$A#>!>'?0!(#++#2!@#11'A1!!
@'&1?!1':0?!?0%!D%$1!1%%+!?#!$',!#@@!'2!#2%!$'&%(?'#2!B'LC!mmN!,911'2:!/2$%&!?0%!]A$!"%$!#@!
.%&?0-&!Z-2#:!D/?!/,#2!%W9+'29?'#2!'2!?0%!&'B/A%?!D%A#>!?0%!QC"C!'1!@#/2$!@9'&!D%(#+'2:!
B%&?'(9A!f!?0%2!?/&2'2:!#B%&!?#!?0%!e!f!N!#@!O#/?0!>'?0!:&%%2!D%$1!#@!?0%!]A$!"%$!$',,'2:!#@@!
'?C!
!!!!
[8'+((\(
P911'2:!@&#+!?0%!Z#&2!x!K92!?#!\&%(#2!j!?0%!@#AA#>'2:!D%$1!9&%!1%%2!'2!92!91(%2$'2:!#&$%&!!G!!!G!
?0%!$',!!$%(&%91'2:!@&#+!B%&?'(9A!?#!4bo!
!!
41?!h9&$!?0'()!D%$$%$!192$1?#2%1!>'?0!+9&A1!!&%$!f!:&%%2!j!?#,1!#@!%$:%1!#2A-!1%%2!8m%/9$$!!
.#2)A%-=!
<C!!!8M?!P#2?!-!K9%2=!!1?#2-!D%$$%$!(0#(#A9?%!"%$!O92$1?#2%!f!.9&A1!!
6C!!!8KA92)!#@!\9??A%G@9(0=!!G!h9&$!rrrrrrr!A':0?!:&%%2!+'(9(%#/1!192$1?C!!S0'22'2:!D%$$%$!>'?!
A9+'29%!#((/,'%$!D-!>0'?%!X/9&?L!(&-1?9A1!G!f!1#+%!B%'21!!
G!DA9()%&!1/D1?92(%!f!GGGGGGGrrrrrrr!91!9!09&$%&!+#&%!(#+,9(?!f!+#&%!!+'(9(%#/1!192$1?#2%!
D&%(('9?%$!#2!'?!!DA%2$%u!f!+'2/?%!(&-1?9A1!#@!!u!e'&%2!YA9L%u!
;C!!\9??A%!K9>&C!!"%$$'10!+9&A1!f!m#$/A%1!
bC!j!"%$!Y&%%2!f!&%:/A9&A-!B9&'%:9?%$!rrr!&%$!'1rrrrrr!#2!09&$%&!109A%C!
7C!O92$1?#2%!(0#(#A9?%!j!?0'()!D%$$%$!9?!A#>%1?!#@!?0%!N9?)'21!e1?9?%!
HC!O92$1?#2%!f!.9&A1!?0'2!%B%2!D%$$%$!
5C!Z#&21?#2%!j!4<!@%%?!%W,#1%$rrrrrrrrrr!!rrrrrrrr!G!4!+!mN!#@!\&%(#2!!
!
;<!

;6!

;;!
>?KX (afH3<([<HEEH[7(HV(7HEgMH:Q(8@&#+!Y%')'%!45Hb3!,,C<6;G<6b=!!
!
M?!?0%!%2$!#@!?0%!\&'1?#A!.%%?'2:!?0%!N##$>9&$'92!P&#@%11#&!8'C%C!O%$:>'()=!>%2?!$#>2!
'2?#!^%B#2!f!Z#&2>9AA!?#!1#!1#+%!@/&?0%&!>#&)!9+#2:!?0%!&#()1!?0%&%C!h%!>91!9?!?09?!?'+%!
'2?%2?!#2!:%??'2:!9!(A/%!?#!?0%!0'1?#&-!#@!?0%!R#'2?1!D-!>0'(0!&#()1!9&%!1#!9D/2$92?A-!
?&9B%&1%$C!!\/?!./&(0'1#2!09B'2:!+92/1(&',?1!92$!,&##@!10%%?1!#2!092$3!$'$!2#?!
9((#+,92-!0'23!?0/:0!#2(%!9:9'2!?0%!/2>%9&-'2:!%W,A#&%&!!#@!O'A/&'9!@#/2$!(9/1%!?#!:#!#B%&!
,9&?!#@!0'1!#A$!1%(?'#21!?#!B%&'@-!?0%+3!$&'B'2:!@&#+!?#>2!?#!?#>2!'29!D/?(0%&E1!(9&?!>0'(0!
0%!09$!0'&%$!@#&!?0'1!,/&,#1%C!h'1!@&'%2$!P0'AA',1!+%?!0'+!D-!9,,#'2?+%2?!9?!\&%(#23!?#!
%W9+'2%!>'?0!0'+!?0%!(/&'#/1!A'??A%!?&9(?!#@!Z#&2!-!J9%23!92$!?0%!P&#@%11#&!091!+9$%!0%!
@#AA#>'2:!+%+#&92$9!#@!?0%!R#/&2%-_!G!TN%A10!,#2'%1!>%&%!'2!&%X/%1'?'#2!92$!>%!&%9(0%$!
?0%!0'AA3!0#,'2:!?#!%1(9,%!?0%!R%9A#/1!(#+,92-!#@!9!N%A10!@9&+%&3!>0#!A##)%$!/,#2!?0%!
+%2!#@!?0%!09++%&!91!1#+%!)'2$!#@!+'2%&1!1%(&%?A-!,&#>A'2:!@#&!:#A$!#&!(#9AC!./&(0'1#2!
09$!,9'$!+92-!B'1'?13!92$!09$!?&'%$!?#!%W,A9'2!?#!?0%!'2X/'1'?'B%!9:&'(/A?/&9A'1?!>0-!?0%!
D9&&%2!:&%-!&#()1!,&#+'2%2?!9D#B%!?0%!F]A$!"%$!O%9E!09$!1#!+/(0!'2?%&%1?!'2!0'1!%-%1C!]2!
?0'1!#((91'#2!*!9A1#!09$!?#!%2(#/2?%&!?0%!F#A$!+92!#@!?0%!+#/2?9'2E!D%(9/1%!+-!(A'2#+%?%&!
>91!'2!:&%9?!/1%!'2!&%1,%(?!#@!$',3!(A%9B9:%!92!R#'2?1C!FMW%1!#@!%A%B9?'#2E3!F$'&%(?'#2!#@!@9/A?E3!
%W?%2?!#@!?0&#>E3!%2B%A#,%!#@!#A$!&%$E3!92$!#?0%&!1?&92:%!,0&91%1!+9$%!#/&!@&'%2$!B%&-!
92:&-3!1#!?09?!3!/2A')%!N%A10+%2!'2!:%2%&9A3!0%!#@@%&%$!/1!2#!)'2$!#@!>%A(#+%!#&!
&%@&%10+%2?3!D/?!9,,%9&%$!?#!&%R#'(%!'2!#/&!:#'2:!9>9-!91!9!&%A'%@!@&#+!1#+%!,#1'?'B%!%B'ACU!
K':/&%$!O%(?'#21!#@!?0%!!
\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29A!@&#+!S0%!
O'A/&'92!O-1?%+!8456V=!J#A/+%!<C!!

;b!
./&(0'1#2E1!K'%A$!m#?%13!\&%(#23!eW(/&1'#2!>'?0!P0'AA',1!!?#!!
Z#&2G-G@923!!O%,?%+D%&!4567C!

;7!

;H!

;5!

;V!
C"*&([*%##%.-Z(!%+#4(V")+-h(91+2"&h(
`;201-%"&($%)*(/012*%-"&()"(
(L"1&@6@,8&((7+.)+IJ+1(>?KXC!

bI!

b4!

b<!

b6!

b;!
3*+(R0)2"I+_!?0'1!'1!./&(0'1#2E1!(#&&%(?'#21!?#!Y&%%2#/:0E1!454V!
.9,!8@&#+!?0%!\YO!9&(0'B%=!

./&(0'1#2!456V!j!$%?9'A!#@!+9,!9((#+,92-'2:!!S0%!O'A/&'92!O-1?%+!10#>'2:!?0%!\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29A!
bb!

Y%#A#:'(9A!O/&B%-!]A$!O%&'%13!O0%%?!;<3!41?!%$'?'#2!845;b=3!!!\&%()2#()!!
10#>'2:!!\&%(#2!M2?'(A'29A!
b7!

bH!

\YO!4_bI[!10%%?1!\&%(#2!<46=3!h9-G#2GN-%!84VH=3!S9A:9&?0!8<4;=\/'A?0!N%AA1!84V7=!me"Z!
(#,-&':0?!
b5!

\YO!4_bI[!O0%%?!<46!\&%(#23!10#>'2:!?0%!9&%9!D%?>%%2!\&%(#2!92$!!?0%!
1#/?0!>%1?%&2!%W?%21'#2!#@!?0%!\&%(#2!92?'(A'29AC!!!me"Z!(#,-&':0?!
bV!

7I!
M+,+1+&2+-(8&4(!01)*+1(M+84%&'((
!
\MOOeSS3!.C!4VV6C!S0%!O'A/&'92!#@!?0%!m%>D&'$:%G\/'A?0G!.-2-$$!e,,-2?!9&%9C!*2!8N##$(#()3!mC!hC!
f!\911%??3!.C!YCa!%$1=!Y%#A#:'(9A!eW(/&1'#21!'2!P#>-1!Z%2?&9A!N9A%1C!c2'B%&1'?-!#@!N9A%1!P&%113!
m9?'#29A!./1%/+!#@!N9A%13!Z9&$'@@3!<54G6IIC!
!!
Zhe"mO3!QC!4VV6C!S0%!O'A/&'92!#@!?0%!N-%!B9AA%-!1#/?0!#@!\/'A?0C!*2!8N##$(#()3!mC!hC!f!\911%??3!.C!
YCa!%$1=!Y%#A#:'(9A!eW(/&1'#21!'2!P#>-1!Z%2?&9A!N9A%1C!c2'B%&1'?-!#@!N9A%1!P&%113!m9?'#29A!./1%/+!
#@!N9A%13!Z9&$'@@C!6I4G64IC!
!!
Ye*[*e3!MC!45HbC!Q'@%!#@!O'&!"#$%&'()!*C!./&(0'1#2!\9&?C3![CZC\C3!KC"COC3!1#+%?'+%!$'&%(?#&!#@!?0%!
Y%#A#:'(9A!O/&B%-!#@!?0%!c2'?%$!['2:$#+C!\91%$!#2!0'1!R#/&29A1!92$!A%??%&1!>'?0!2#?'(%1!#@!0'1!
1('%2?'@'(!(#2?%+,#&9&'%1!92$!9!1)%?(0!#@!?0%!&'1%!92$!:&#>?0!#@!,9A9%#L#'(!:%#A#:-!'2!\&'?9'2!8<!
B#A1=C!d#02!./&&9-3!Q#2$#2C!
!
Ye*[*e3!MC!45VHC!S0%!K#/2$%&1!#@!Y%#A#:-C!.9(+'AA923!Q#2$#2!C!
!!!
Y"eem]cYh3!YC!\C!454VC!Y%#A#:'(9A!.9,!#@!e2:A92$!92$!N9A%1C!Q#2:+923!Q#2$#2C!
!
hMNQex3!^C!4VVHC!FS0%!K'&1?!S&/%!O'A/&'92E!_!92!%B9A/9?'#2!#@!?0%!1'?%!#@!./&(0'1#2g1!
$'1(#B%&-!#@!?0%!O'A/&'92C!P&#(%%$'2:1!#@!?0%!Y%#A#:'1?1g!M11#('9?'#23!4I53!464G4;IC!
!!
QxeQQ3![C!.3!4554!Q'@%!Q%??%&1!92$!d#/&29A1!#@!O'&!Z09&A%1!Q-%AA3!\9&?!8<!B#A1=C!!Q#2$#2_!d#02!./&&9-C!
!
.c"Zh*O]m3!"C!*C!456A9C!K'%A$!m#?%D##)3!m#C!4C!./&(0'1#2!,9,%&1C!Q^YOQ!56V3!.lm!bH3!Y%#A#:'(9A!
O#('%?-!9&(0'B%1C!Q#2$#2C!
!
.c"Zh*O]m3!"C!*C!!456ADC!K'%A$!m#?%D##)C!m#C!<C!./&(0'1#2!,9,%&13!Q^YOQ!56V3!.lm!b53!Y%#A#:'(9A!
O#('%?-!9&(0'B%13!Q#2$#2C!
!
.c"Zh*O]m3!"C!*C!!456<C!K'%A$!m#?%D##)3!m#C<C!./&(0'1#2!,9,%&13!Q^YOQ!56V3!.lm!7<3!Y%#A#:'(9A!
O#('%?-!9&(0'B%13!Q#2$#2C!
!
.c"Zh*O]m3!"C!*C!!4567C!K'%A$!m#?%D##)3!m#C<C!8d/A-=!!./&(0'1#2!,9,%&13!Q^YOQ!56V3!.lm!HH3!
Y%#A#:'(9A!O#('%?-!9&(0'B%13!Q#2$#2C!
!
.c"Zh*O]m3!"C!*C!!456;C!]2!?0%!1?&/(?/&%!92$!(A911'@'(9?'#2!#@!?0%!S&921'?'#2!&#()1!#@!O0&#,10'&%3!
h%&%@#&$10'&%!92$!,9&?!#@!N9A%13!92$!#2!?0%!Q'2%1!#@!^'1?/&D92(%!>0'(0!09B%!9@@%(?%$!?09?!1%&'%1!#@!
^%,#1'?13!'2(A/$'2:!?0%!J9AA%-!#@!eA%B9?'#2!#@!N##A0#,%C!P&#(%%$'2:1!#@!?0%!Y%#A#:'(9A!O#('%?-3!<3!
46G45C!
.c"Zh*O]m3!"C!*C!!456VC!S0%!O'A/&'92!O-1?%+!@#/2$%$!#2!:%#A#:'(9A!&%1%9&(0%1!!'2!?0%!(#/2?'%1!#@!
O9l#,3!h%&%@#&$3!"9$2#&3!.#2?:#+%&-3!Z9+9&?0%23!\&%(#23!P%+D&#)%3!.#2+#/?03!YA#/(%1?%&3!
N#&(%1?%&3!92$!O?9@@#&$!>'?0!?0%!$%1(&',?'#21!#@!?0%!(#9A@'%A$1!92$!#B%&A-'2:!@#&+9?'#21C!d#02!
./&&9-3!Q#2$#2C!
!
Ph*QQ*PO3!dC!!!%4567C!Y%#A#:'(9A!2#?%1!92$!1)%?(0%1!#@!1?&9?93!%?(C3!\&'1?#A3!M/1?3!%?(C!8M/:CGO%,?C!
4567=a!g\&%(#23!MD%&-1?>-?03!O2#>$#2'93!f(!4567ga!g^',1!#@!D%$1C!f(C!2%9&!QA92D%&'1!4567gC!!P0'AA',1l
\#W%1!54GV<l66C!!]W@#&$!./1%/+!#@!m9?/&9A!h'1?#&-C!
!
!
!

74!
!
OeZ]"^3!dC!MC!4V57C!Z#2?&#B%&1-!'2!J'(?#&'92!Y%#A#:-3!!S0%!Z9+D&'92GO'A/&'92!^'1,/?%C!
P&'2(%?#2!c2'B%&1'?-!P&%113!]W@#&$C!
!
OeZ]"^3!dC!MC!c2,/DA'10%$!,9,%&C!M!"#+92(%!#@!?0%!K'%A$!_!"#$%&'()!./&(0'1#2E1!Y%#A#:'(9A!
^'1(#B%&-!#@!4564C!
!
OSMKK]"^3!"C!MC!4V5VC!O('%2?'1?!#@!e+,'&%!_!O'&!"#$%&'()!./&(0'1#2C!1('%2?'@'(!%W,A#&9?'#2!92$!
J'(?#&'92!'+,%&'9A'1+C!Z9+D&'$:%!c2'B%&1'?-!P&%113!Z9+D&'$:%!
!
OS"MN3!OC!hC!4V6IC!S0%!O'A/&#G^%B#2'92!\#/2$9&-!'2!O#/?0G!(%2?&9A!N9A%1C!d#/&29A!#@!?0%!
.92(0%1?%&!Y%#A#:'(9A!M11#('9?'#23!43!HVG4I<C!
!!
OS"MN3!OC!hC!4V6HC!S0%!0':0%&!Q/$A#B'92!&#()1!#@!?0%!\/'A?0!$'1?&'(?C!z/9&?%&A-!d#/&29A!#@!?0%!
Y%#A#:'(9A!O#('%?-C!Q#2$#23!V63!;I7G;b7C!
!!
|*SSeQ3![C!MC!B#2C!4VI*C!h'1?#&-!#@!Y%#A#:-!92$!P9A9%#2?#A#:-!?#!?0%!%2$!#@!?0%!m'2%?%%2?0!!
Z%2?/&-!8?&921A9?%$!D-!.9&'9!.C!]:'AB'%GY#&$#2=C!!N9A?%&GO(#??3!Q#2$#2!
/8.-(
3"."'18.*%28#(
]&$292(%!O/&B%-!4_<b3III3!eW,A#&%&!4553!!\/'A?0!N%AA1!l!QA92@9'&!j-+G./9AA?!
!
=+"#"'%28#(
\YO!4_bI3III!O0%%?!<46!\&%(#2!
\YO!4_bI3III!O0%%?!!4VH!h9-G#2GN-%!
\YO!4_bI3III!O0%%?!!4V7!\/'A?0!N%AA1!
\YO!4_bI3III!O0%%?!<4;!S9A:9&?0!
(
!
!
:2O&"$#+4'+I+&)-(
S0%!0%A,!92$!>'AA'2:2%11!#@!@9&+%&1!92$!A92$#>2%&1!?#!9((%11!A92$!'1!
:&9?%@/AA-!9()2#>A%$:%$3!,9&?'(/A9&A-_!
N%2$-!P#>%AAC!S-!QA>-23!e&>##$3!
.&!PC!f!!.&1!KC!d#2%13!S-G*19@3!e&>##$C!
.&!YC!f!^C!.#&:923!!K92!c(09@!3!P#2?G@9%2C!
m92?:>&%'$$-2!K9&+3!P#2?GK9%2C!
!
S092)1!9A1#!?#!]W@#&$!c2'B%&1'?-!./1%/+!#@!m9?/&9A!h'1?#&-!892$![9?%!
O92?&-3!M&(0'B'1?=!@#&!9((%11!92$!,%&+'11'#2!?#!/1%!#@!d#02!P0'AA',1!@'%A$!
2#?%D##)1!@#&!?0'1!1?/$-C!
!
!
!