ArticlePDF Available

Concepts, Challenges, Barriers, and Opportunities Related to Evidence-Based Practice in Rehabilitation Counseling

Authors:

Abstract

Evidence-based practice espouses that all healthcare professionals should provide their clients with the most effective clinical services based on sound research evidence. This philosophy of practice has since permeated to an array of health care and human service disciplines, and the rehabilitation counseling profession is no exception. Although the evidence-based practice movement is not without its controversy and critics, this movement also presents a window of opportunity for the rehabilitation counseling profession to promote and support a systematic agenda for theory-driven rehabilitation counseling research. The use of scientific evidence derived from theory-driven research to inform rehabilitation counseling practices could contribute to higher employment rates and better quality of employment outcomes for people with disabilities. In this article, we provided an overview of the key concepts related to evidence-based practice, critical issues and challenges that surround the evidence-based practice movement, and the implications and opportunities of this movement for the rehabilitation counseling profession.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... The client may act with compliance based on the desire for approval from someone, rather than a true personal desire to return to work. As a result, the client's underlying actions represent unwillingness to cooperate (Chan et al., 2010). The idea of internal regulation can be positively influenced by Rehabilitation Counsellors through their use of mutually agreed goals and strategies presented in the rehabilitation plan. ...
... In examining changes in employment for people with disability or injury, it is important for policy makers and service providers to be responsive to an increasingly complex array of economic and labour force trends. The current expectation for healthcare and rehabilitation professionals to use empirically supported interventions in their practices will continue to strongly shape the future of rehabilitation counselling research and services (Chan et al., 2010). Additional research could explore the effectiveness of different rehabilitation counselling strategies by collecting data from ...
Article
Full-text available
Motivation has been recognised as an essential component in managing medical issues, adjusting to physical disability, cognitive impairment, returning to work, and improving psychosocial functioning. Rehabilitation aims to reduce the impact of impairments on activities of daily living and social role functioning, promoting both independence and social inclusion. This research explores the role of client motivation in workplace rehabilitation and demonstrates the implications for rehabilitation counselling practice. The research focuses on understanding the concept of motivation, reasons for its presence or absence, and why motivation is important to the workplace rehabilitation process. This study also explores significant influencing factors that may be utilised to increase motivation and promote more successful return to work outcomes, as well as considering the implications for rehabilitation practice and research.
... The ACES recommended best practices for clinical supervision are directly relevant to state VR settings, though there may be unique barriers to introducing new practices into complex state VR agency environments. Chan et al. (2010) described a variety of challenges to evidence informed practice implementation including the quality of available evidence, time constraints, the complexity and organizational contexts such as bureaucratic policies, lack of leadership buy-in, training impediments, and change-averse cultures. The authors emphasized that the diversity of VR service systems makes it difficult to reliably apply research to unique, individual contexts. ...
... Comprehensive meta-analyses research has demonstrated that effective leadership has a positive influence on many aspects of the organization from commitment, to culture, to performance (Karadag, 2015). Yet, there are challenges to implementing evidence supported practices in rehabilitation counseling agencies, including the complexity and scope of rehabilitation services, insufficient time in busy agencies, bureaucratic policies, and change-averse organizational cultures (Chan et al., 2010). The application of these recommendations must be considered within the unique contexts of individual state VR agencies, while also anticipating some resistance due to entrenched beliefs and inflexible structures. ...
... The ACES recommended best practices for clinical supervision are directly relevant to state VR settings, though there may be unique barriers to introducing new practices into complex state VR agency environments. Chan et al. (2010) described a variety of challenges to evidence informed practice implementation including the quality of available evidence, time constraints, the complexity and organizational contexts such as bureaucratic policies, lack of leadership buy-in, training impediments, and change-averse cultures. The authors emphasized that the diversity of VR service systems makes it difficult to reliably apply research to unique, individual contexts. ...
... Comprehensive meta-analyses research has demonstrated that effective leadership has a positive influence on many aspects of the organization from commitment, to culture, to performance (Karadag, 2015). Yet, there are challenges to implementing evidence supported practices in rehabilitation counseling agencies, including the complexity and scope of rehabilitation services, insufficient time in busy agencies, bureaucratic policies, and change-averse organizational cultures (Chan et al., 2010). The application of these recommendations must be considered within the unique contexts of individual state VR agencies, while also anticipating some resistance due to entrenched beliefs and inflexible structures. ...
Article
Full-text available
(Special issue of the Journal of Rehabilitation Administration focusing on clinical supervision) With the reduction of training resources and changes in hiring practices due to legislation impacting the professional development of Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) counselors, the responsibility for counselor training and professional development is increasingly left to the front-line supervisor. The professional development of counselors is considered a life-long process. Formal professional development processes begin when the counselor finishes an academic training program and enters professional practice. A lack of professional development opportunities in practice settings can result in a lack of ongoing counselor skill development and may trigger incongruence between Vocational Self-Concept and professional identity. Incongruity between Vocational Self-Concept and professional identity can lead to workplace dissatisfaction, burnout, and turnover. Conversely, purposeful and planned professional development opportunities help practitioners to continually enhance their skills and negotiate role incongruity and satisfy the professional development needs of the counselor. Counselors that have continual skill development and a balanced personal and professional identity are better suited to serve the needs of the agency and corresponding clientele. This article will discuss the role of the supervisor in the professional development of the counselor and discuss strategies for providing instruction and support in that process.
... Despite the growing body of research investigating positive psychology, its application to individuals with ASD is still scarce (e.g., Samson & Antonelli, 2013), and more research in this area is warranted. Because the breadth of rehabilitative services tends to be broad, researchers will encounter difficulties conducting studies using experimental designs due to practical and ethical concerns (Chan et al., 2010). Therefore, experience sampling methods (e.g., exploring people's actions, feelings, and thoughts during daily lives; Larson & Csikszentmihalyi, 2014), diary methods (e.g., using diaries to examine daily life events and mood; Jose et al., 2012), or ecological momentary assessments (e.g., collect repeated momentary assessments of participants' behaviors and experiences in their natural environment; Stone & Shiffman, 1994) can be alternatives to examine positive psychology constructs in rehabilitation studies to complement the breadth of the field. ...
Article
Full-text available
Positive psychology is a subdomain that addresses the importance of human strengths and personal assets in individuals’ well-being. The principles of positive psychology align with the philosophy of rehabilitation counseling by emphasizing individuals’ strengths to promote psychosocial adjustment to disability. Considering the intersection between positive psychology and rehabilitation counseling, applying the positive psychology framework to rehabilitation counseling will be a promising foundation for improvement in services and outcomes. As the number of individuals on the autism spectrum increases, more innovative services are needed to keep abreast of their needs. This article discusses how positive psychology can be applied to the population of individuals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and explores possible practices that can be replicated by practitioners to provide quality services for this emerging disability population. Implications for education and research are also discussed.
... Barriers to adaptive learning to implement the EBP process are well established, including factors such as time restrictions, limited access to research, poor confidence in skills to identify and critically appraise research, difficulties in interpreting guidelines, and inadequate support from colleagues and managers (Bucknall & Rycroft-Malone, 2010;Mittman, 2012). Barriers to learning new evidence-based interventions typically include insufficient training quantity and quality, limited training budgets, lack of supervision, monitoring, and consultation (Aarons, Wells, Zagursky, Fettes, & Palinkas, 2009;Chan et al., 2010;Powers, Bowen, & Bowen, 2010;Swain, Whitley, McHugo, & Drake, 2010). ...
... Well-documented barriers to the provision of evidence-based care in community mental health include lack of provider training, such as limited access to graduate training in evidence-based treatments, and limited professional supervision (Aarons et al., 2009;Chambless, 1999;Chan et al., 2010;Karekla et al., 2004). If community mental health has typically lacked adequate professional supervision in EBPs (Aarons et al., 2009), the chance to pursue consultant training within the PE Initiative appears to be a unique professional opportunity for providers. ...
Article
Previous studies have identified that ongoing consultation and organizational support are key factors in sustaining evidence‐based implementation initiatives in community mental health. Clinician‐level factors likely influence implementation but are not well delineated. This study assessed clinician‐reported professional development incentives for participating in consultation in prolonged exposure (PE) therapy to guide future evidence‐based practice (EBP) initiatives. Providers in the PE initiative (N = 22) completed a survey asking about their motivations to participate, the impact of consultation on the implementation of PE and their professional development goals, and the impact of organizational‐level support on their goals and on organizational‐level clinician turnover. Of the respondents, 10 had decided to pursue additional training to become PE consultants at their agencies. Providers (response rate = 22/35) reported joining the PE Initiative to learn an evidence‐based practice in general (not PE specifically) and increase their skill in treating posttraumatic stress disorder. Providers largely found ongoing consultation helpful and reported that consultation provided the feedback and support necessary to achieve their professional goals. Providers who decided to pursue PE consultant training reported that expanding upon supervision and clinical skills were strong motivators. Providers largely attributed clinician turnover within the PE Initiative to organizational‐level factors. Ongoing consultation facilitated providers’ professional development goals. The survey identified several areas for further exploration, including how consultation can reduce clinician turnover, and how taking on additional responsibility within implementation initiatives can facilitate provider engagement in the EBP.
Article
This article seeks to promote discussion about and renew interest in rebuilding the relationship between rehabilitation counseling and the disability advocacy community. Rooted in legislation, rehabilitation counseling was historically grounded in disability rights along with the disability advocacy community. Over the years, however, the nature of this relationship has drifted, with each one concentrating in their own respective domains. In turn, this has created a divide that, in the end, may prove less productive in achieving the mutual goal of full community inclusion of individuals with disabilities. To ignite this discussion, perspective was sought from two leaders of disability advocacy organizations about ways in which rehabilitation counseling and the disability community can reignite and fortify a collaboration in the future.
Article
Full-text available
Evaluation is central to the clinical supervision role as it serves as the basis for all counselor monitoring and feedback. Supervisors are required to continuously assess counselor competence and dispositions to fulfill their ethical gatekeeping responsibility and professional obligation to facilitate counselor development. Counselor evaluation practices are well-established within master's level rehabilitation counseling training programs, yet, practices in the field are less systematic and undefined. The purpose of this article is to describe promising practices from counselor supervision literature to offer state vocational rehabilitation (VR) administrators and supervisors varied options to consider in enhancing their current clinical supervision processes. The authors advocate for more intentional counselor evaluation practice and using evaluation as a professional development tool rather than a punitive process or procedural formality.
Article
Purpose The past few decades have witnessed significant growth in the disability sector and the rehabilitation counseling profession has responded by broadening its scope of practice to serve a range of people who experience illness, injury, and social disadvantage. Despite the sector's growth and the profession's flexible response to it, the rehabilitation counseling profession in Australia continues to face challenges in relation to its professional identity. The purpose of this article is to identify these challenges and present solutions by reviewing literature and professionalization responses in Australia and the United States. Method In this article, we examine ways of transcending the professional identity challenges faced by the Australian rehabilitation counseling community. This is achieved firstly by defining the characteristics of professions and their application to rehabilitation counseling and second, by suggesting possible actions to advance the profession. Results The necessary responses identified include the need for stronger professional governance, further development of the evidence base, and strict professional membership regulations. These goals will require the input of professional bodies and members, universities, rehabilitation regulators, employers, people with disabilities, and their families. Conclusions Rehabilitation counseling is a valued allied health and human service profession in the Australian work injury and disability sectors. By drawing on the experience of the profession in the United States, the authors have identified issues and solutions to facilitate the sustainability and advancement of rehabilitation counseling in Australia.
Article
Full-text available
The evidence-based practice (EBP) movement in medicine has permeated and affected a wide array of health care, social service, and education disciplines including vocational rehabilitation (VR). It is therefore important to review previous VR research in order to determine which topics meet the evidence-based criteria and which topics require additional research. This article introduces the criteria associated with EBP and reviews the literature pertaining to VR in light of these criteria. Specifically, we review rehabilitation outcome literature concerning the efficaciousness of (a) the state-federal VR program, (b) private sector rehabilitation, and (c) community-based rehabilitation. It should be noted that like many human service programs, research in VR has not traditionally employed a randomized clinical trial approach, which is the gold standard for EBP in medicine. However, there are many other types of research that can give information as to the empirical evidence to support the efficacy, clinical utility, and cost effectiveness of VR in returning people with chronic illnesses or disabilities to competitive employment.
Article
Like its three predecessors, the fourth edition of this book present current, informed reviews of research on treatments that work for a wide range of mental disorders. The 28 chapters cover pharmacological, psychosocial, and combined treatments for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), conduct disorder, disruptive behavior disorders, schizophrenic spectrum disorders, bipolar disorder in adults and children, major depressive disorder in adults and children, panic disorders, phobias, social and generalized anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), eating disorders, sleep disorders, sexual dysfunctions, substance use disorders, gambling disorder, impulse control disorders, neurocognitive disorders, and personality disorders. Authors of most of the chapters were substantially involved in the development of the treatments reviewed in their chapters.
Book
Much about this third edition of A Guide to Treatments That Work remains as it was in the first and second editions. Like its predecessors, this edition offers detailed evaluative reviews of current research on empirically supported treatments, written in most instances by clinical psychologists and psychiatrists who are major contributors to that literature. Similarly, the standards by which the authors were asked to evaluate the methodological rigor of the research on treatments have also remained the same. As before, they provide information on the quality of the research on treatment efficacy and effectiveness that is reviewed.
Book
Basic Concepts in Prevention. Prevention of Behavioral and Social Problems. Prevention of Learning Problems. Drug Prevention. Programs to Improve Physical Health. Injury Prevention. Child Maltreatment. Is Prevention Cost-Effective/ Importance of Policy. Current Status and Future Directions. Appendix A: Characteristics of Effective Skill Training Programs. Appendix B: Helpful Resources on Prevention. Indexes.
Article
The Ticket to Work and Work Incentives Improvement Act of 1999 (TWWIIA) provides supports and incentives designed to increase the return-to-work rates of Social Security beneficiaries and recipients. The legislation introduces supports such as the ticket to work and benefits planning and assistance and work incentives such as expedited reinstatement of benefits and extension of Medicare and Medicaid coverage. Whether these TWWIIAA initiatives are successful or not can be measured by the impact they have on the benefit and return-to-work rates of beneficiaries and recipients.
Article
The purpose of this study is to examine the roles and functions of benefits counseling specialists. One-hundred and forty-eight benefits counseling specialists rated the Benefits Specialists Practice Inventory - Revised using a 5-point importance rating scale. Data were analyzed using multi-trait analysis. The multi-trait analysis tentatively supported the three-factor structure of the Benefits Specialists Practice Inventory - Revised, indicating that benefits screening (M = 4.43, SD = 0.47), benefits advisement (M = 4.49, SD = 0.56), and benefits management (M = 4.07, SD = 0.88) are most central to the job performance of benefits counseling specialists. In addition, benefits counseling specialists in the current study rated themselves as relatively well prepared to perform these benefits counseling job functions, with benefits advisement rated the highest (M = 4.23, SD = 0.76), followed by benefits screening (M = 4.15, SD = 0.70), and then by benefits management (M = 3.75, SD = 0.96). However, multi-trait analysis also suggested that there might be more than three essential job functions for benefits counseling specialists and more comprehensive research in the future is warranted.
Article
The United States, the third most populous country globally, accounts for about 4.5% of the world's population. The U.S. population-currently estimated at 308.7 million persons-has more than doubled since its 1950 level of 152.3 million. More than just being double in size, the population has become qualitatively different from what it was in 1950. As noted by the Population Reference Bureau,-The U.S. is getting bigger, older, and more diverse." The objective of this report is to highlight some of the demographic changes that have already occurred since 1950 and to illustrate how these and future trends will reshape the nation in the decades to come (through 2050). The United States Is Getting Bigger. U.S. population growth is due to the trends over time in the interplay of increased births, decreased deaths, and increased net immigration. The United States Is Getting Older. Aside from the total size, one of the most important demographic characteristics of a population for public policy is its age and sex structure. This report illustrates how the United States has been in the midst of a profound demographic change: the rapid aging of its population, as reflected by an increasing proportion of persons aged 65 and older, and an increasing median age in the population. The United States Is Becoming More Racially and Ethnically Diverse, reflecting the major influence that immigration has had on both the size and the age structure of the U.S. population. This section considers the changing profile of the five major racial groups in the United States. In addition, trends in the changing ethnic composition of the Hispanic or Latino Origin population are discussed. Although this report will not specifically discuss policy options to address the changing demographic profile, it is important to recognize that the inexorable demographic momentum will have important implications for the economic and social forces that will shape future societal well-being. There is ample reason to believe that the United States will be able to cope with the current and projected demographic changes if policymakers accelerate efforts to address and adapt to the changing population profile as it relates to a number of essential domains, such as work, retirement, and pensions; private wealth and income security; the federal budget and intergenerational equity; health, healthcare, and health spending; and the health and well-being of the aging population. These topics, among others, are discussed briefly in the final section of this report. The United States, the third-largest population globally, accounts for about 4.5% of the world's population. The U.S. population-estimated in the 2010 Census at 308.7 million persons1-has more than doubled from its 1950 level of 152.3 million.2 More than just being double in size, the U.S. population has become qualitatively different from what it was in 1950. As noted by the Population Reference Bureau,-The U.S. is getting bigger, older, and more diverse."3 The objective of this report is to highlight some of the demographic changes that have already occurred since 1950 and to illustrate how these and future trends will reshape the nation in the decades to come.4 While this report will not discuss policy options, it is important to recognize that the inexorable demographic momentum will produce an increasingly older population in the United States. There is ample reason to believe that the United States will be able to cope with the current and projected changes if policymakers address and adapt to the changing demographic profile as it relates to a number of essential domains such as work, retirement, and pensions, private wealth and income security, transfer systems, and the health and well-being of the aging population.5 These topics are discussed briefly in the final section of this report.