ArticlePDF Available

Theoretical economic geography and spatial econometrics: Dynamic perspectives

Authors:
Bernard Fingleton at University of Cambridge
Bernard Fingleton
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

Theoretical economic geography has received significant new impetus from so-called `new economic geography` theory, and this provides the basis of the spatial econometric model developed in this paper. The model, which is seen as part of an attempt to bridge the gap that presently exists between this new body of theory and reality, is fitted using 3SLS to data on manufacturing productivity growth data for 178 regions of the EU covering the periods 1975-81, 1981-89, 1989-95. The resulting estimates point to the continued existence over time of increasing returns, and thus provides support for one of the main tenets of new economic geography theory. The results also highlight urbanization, peripherality, the initial level of technology and across-region spillovers as determinants of regional productivity growth variations, operating via the rate of technical progress and labour efficiency variations. There is no evidence that these variables are diminishing in significance systematically over time, leading to the conclusion that spatial polarization in productivity will persist. The paper points to the need for further testing of fundamental assumptions of the underlying theory, and for developments in the theory to accommodate interdependence between model parameters and the socio-economic context within which the process is operating.
Content uploaded by Bernard Fingleton
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Bernard Fingleton on Sep 23, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Theoretical economic geography and spatial econometrics: dynamic perspectives
Bernard Fingleton
Journal of Economic Geography; Apr 1, 2001; 1, 2; ABI/INFORM Global
pg. 201
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... Fingleton and McCombie (1998) estimate this relationship using data for the NUTS 2 regions of the EU, and find that, controlling for spillover effects and innovation diffusion, there exists a significant positive relationship indicating the presence of internal and external increasing returns to scale. More recently, Fingleton (2001aFingleton ( , 2001b) has used the same relationship but in the context of urban economic theory (Abdel-Rahman, 1988;Rivera-Batiz, 1988;Quigley, 1998;Abdel-Rahman and Fujita, 1990;Fujita and Thisse, 1996), with competitive industry and monopolistically competitive services as in Dixit-Stiglitz (1977) theory. This suggests that the increasing returns derive from the increased variety of services as the scale of activity increases, and depends on the relevance of services to manufacturing production, and the elasticity of substitution of services. ...
... Rather than being estimated, which would be technically somewhat complex, values are allotted to χ, υ and γ according to assumptions regarding the relative importance of distance versus size. It turns out that a value of 2 for each of these parameters produces reasonable results (see Fingleton (2001a) for an analysis based on a range of different W assumptions, and Anselin (1988) for a discussion of the formation of alternative W specifications). The data used to fit the model are annual average manufacturing productivity and output growth for 178 NUTS regions of the EU over a period of 20 years provided by Cambridge Econometrics. ...
... 24 In interpreting this, it is important to appreciate that educational attainment measures are potentially inconsistent across countries because of different standards employed. 25 Fingleton (2001aFingleton ( , 2002a estimates models similar to that outlined above and shows that significant differences occur in parameter values through time and across space. ...
View
... There has been criticism from some scholars about the adequacy of the administrative level as a measure of territorial aspects of the economic system, and the necessity to use ad-hoc units of analysis (Boldrin and Canova 2001). As we can notice, on the one hand, this type of statistical unit, as functional urban areas (Chesire and Carbonaro 1995), can be more appropriate, and on the other hand, the dynamic specifications of these areas suggest that their dimension is not fixed during the time (Fingleton 2001). Therefore, even if the administrative level is not exactly representative of the features of the growth process, it guarantees a satisfactory level of analysis, capable of capturing the subnational disparities (Fischer and Stirböck 2006). ...
... The additional advantages related to the GMM estimator, among the dynamic panel data, are the flexibility, and the few assumptions regarding the process of data generating. The Arellano-Bond estimator implies that the model is taken in first difference and therefore, we are also able to remove the unobserved time-invariant regional characteristics 17 . Furthermore, the presence of lags of each endogenous variable represents a set of instruments that can be used to account for the endogeneity problem. ...
International Skilled-Migration and Regional Growth in Poland
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2017
The paper aims to investigate the relationship between international migration and economic growth across the regions ofPoland. In most studies, the potential determinants of migration have been investigated, while the impact of these flows of individuals on economic growth has received less attention. Using a panel data during the time period 1999-2005, the authors tested if different kinds of migration flows, distinguished by educational level, had an effect on economic growth. In order to control both the issue of endogeneity, due to the presence of some potentially endogenous variables among the explanatory variables, and the problem of omitted variables, the paper implements the difference-GMM of Arellano-Bond. The findings show that high-skilled in-migration flows has a strong positive impact on the growth dynamics of Polish regions. On the other hand, the outflow of skilled individuals reduces the regional skill-intensity and has a negative effect on income. The results also support the idea that skilled-migration can promote the provincial convergence.
View
... In the regional development literature, growth centres can produce spreading effects to neighbouring areas if the two regions complement each other (Ke and Feser, 2010). The theoretical framework of interregional spillovers in this study is built upon the dynamics of multiregional population systems, economic geography, and spatial econometrics (see Cordey-Hayes (1975) and Fingleton (2001)). ...
Spillover Effects of Social and Economic Interactions on COVID-19 Pandemic Vulnerability Across Indonesia's Regions
Research
  • Oct 2021
This research study focuses on measuring the possible spillover effects of socioeconomic interactions on COVID-19 pandemic vulnerability across Indonesia's regions by utilising a spatial simultaneous model. The COVID-19 pandemic vulnerability level here is used to indicate the extent to which a region is susceptible to the spreading COVID-19 pandemic, as determined by not only the region's COVID-19 related epidemiological factors but also by its relevant socio-demographic and economic aspects, housing, environmental health, and availability of health facilities. High COVID-19 pandemic vulnerability levels were mostly found in districts in Java Island and southern Sumatera, suggesting high population density and mobility in both regions. It was revealed that 31 districts have low COVID-19 risk levels (from epidemiological indicators-related measurements), but they have high COVID-19 vulnerability levels (from epidemiological and socioeconomic indicators-based measurements). Labour productivity was found to have a reciprocal relationship with COVID-19 vulnerability, proving that the COVID-19 pandemic has a significant impact on labour productivity and vice versa. On the other hand, regional independence affects COVID-19 vulnerability, but this does not apply the other way around. Moreover, this study has also proven that COVID-19 pandemic vulnerability levels have socioeconomic spillover effects on neighbouring areas in Indonesia. Link: https://www.eria.org/publications/spillover-effects-of-social-and-economic-interactions-on-covid-19-pandemic-vulnerability-across-indonesias-regions/
View
... However, the empirics in this paper to some extent ignore this spatial dimension. While there is an extensive literature on spatial econometrics (e.g., Fingleton, 2001), this is concentrated almost exclusively using cross-section data. Although they can be virtually distinct, cities, towns, villages and open countryside are all part of the same functional economic and social system (Gruber & Soci, 2010). ...
Club convergence of per capita disposable income in the US
Article
  • Jun 2021
This paper examines the long‐run trends in per‐capita income across the US states (1995‐2018). Contrary to the majority of the literature on income convergence, which uses pre‐tax income as the variable of reference, we focus on per‐capita disposable household income. This enables us to better identify any convergence pattern. We apply the Phillips and Sul (2007, 2009) convergence methodology to check the existence of club convergence across the US and within the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) regions. Our findings confirm the club convergence hypothesis and highlight the role of tax policy in reducing regional disparities.
View
... Spatial econometric models started to appear in the 1970s in an attempt to address data on a regional scale (Anselin 2001). This type of model was later applied to the growing number of problems related with, among other things, urban issues, the housing sector (Armstrong and Rodríguez 2006, Long et al. 2007, Ibeas et al. 2012) and economic geography (Fingleton 2001(Fingleton , 2003. In all these fields, the use of data with a clearly spatial component is an essential part of the modelling process, and it quickly underlines the importance of addressing it by specifically considering its peculiarities, as had occurred with time series data in other research fields. ...
View
... On empirical level, according to Verdoorn law, the per-capita income development, closely related to labor productivity, is positively correlated to the product produced. Fingleton and Lopez-Bazo (Fingleton, 2001;Fingleton & López-Bazo, 2006) argue that the Verdoorn model offers a more realistic description of the regional development process and it is more compatible to specific endogenous models (Pfaffermayr, 2007). In neo-Keynesian line of thought, Kaldor (Kaldor, 1970;Kaldor, Targetti, & Thirlwall, 1989) also argues that the per-capita regional product depends to the economies of scale growth and gradual specialization, while coupled with the Verdoorn principle a strong statistical correlation between the product produced and (endogenous) productivity growth is taking place. ...
From traditional regional analysis to dynamics of local development: Foundations and theoretical reorientations
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2019
The conventional and traditional regional analysis seems to gradually changing focus, content and hermeneutic optic. The regional analysis of past seems increasingly saturated, being incapable to interpret and propose policy solutions that originate primarily from the potential of local development, innovation and entrepreneurship. To this end, new, multidisciplinary approaches of local development seem to prevail progressively, leading the study of development to the analysis of dynamically evolving localities.
View
... Doran and Fingleton (2014) also use aggregate output and employment rather than the manufacturing sector alone, likewise McCombie et al. (2017). As shown by Thirlwall and McCombie (1994), Fingleton (2001aFingleton ( , 2001b, Dall'erba et al. (2009), Le Gallo and Pa´ez (2013) and Britto and McCombie (2015), among others, various other specifications exist, and most relevant from the perspective of the current paper is the static Verdoorn law written as a regression equation, hence, ...
US Metropolitan Area Resilience: Insights from dynamic spatial panel estimation
Article
  • Oct 2017
In this paper, we show that the economic crisis commencing in 2007 had different impacts across US Metropolitan Statistical Areas, and seek to understand why differences occurred. The hypothesis of interest is that differences in industrial structure are a cause of variations in response to the crisis. Our approach uses a state-of-the art dynamic spatial panel model to obtain counterfactual predictions of Metropolitan Statistical Area employment levels from 2008 to 2014. The counterfactual employment series are compared with actual employment paths in order to obtain Metropolitan Statistical Area-specific measures of crisis impact, which then are analysed with a view to testing the hypothesis that resilience to the crisis was dependent on Metropolitan Statistical Area industrial structure.
View
... There has been criticism from some scholars about the adequacy of the administrative level as a measure of territorial aspects of the economic system, and the necessity to use ad hoc units of analysis (Boldrin, Canova, Pischke, & Puga, 2001). As we notice, on the one hand, this type of statistical unit, as functional urban areas (Cheshire & Carbonaro, 1995;Magrini, 2004), can be more appropriate, and on the other hand, the dynamic specifications of these areas suggest that their dimension is not fixed during the time (Fingleton, 2001). Therefore, even if the administrative level is not exactly representative of the features of the growth process, it guarantees a satisfactory level of analysis, capable of capturing the sub-national disparities (Fischer & Stirböck, 2006). ...
Distributive trade and regional productivity growth
Article
  • Aug 2017
The paper aims to investigate the relationship between distributive trade (wholesale and retail trade) and productivity growth across Italian provinces. In most studies, the potential determinants of productivity in the distributive trade have been investigated, while the impact of these activities on economic growth of the whole system has received less attention. By using panel data during the time period 2000–2013, the paper tests if the increase in the share of employees in distributive trade over the given period has promoted the productivity growth. This study applies both a random-effects model and, among the dynamic panel data estimators, a generalized method of moments estimator (GMM). In order to control both the issue of endogeneity, due to the presence of some potentially endogenous variables among the explanatory variables, and the problem of instrument proliferation, the GMM estimator is implemented together with a statistical method, which reduces the number of instruments when the set of endogenous variables is wide. The findings show that the distributive trade has a strong positive impact on the productivity growth. Moreover, this link is reinforced when we control the potential endogeneity. The results also support the idea that distributive trade can promote provincial convergence.
View
Related Variety and Employment Growth in Italy: Testing Sectoral Heterogeneity through Pavitt’s Taxonomy
Article
  • Jul 2020
The present study aims to provide additional evidence for the role and importance of related variety in manufacturing in fostering employment growth among Italian provinces (nuts 3) over the period 2001-2011. The focus is on assessing the sectoral specificities by adopting Pavitt's taxonomy. Concerning potential complementarities between manufacturing industries, the results indicate that the positive influence of externalities on growth dynamics are not necessarily due to the variety among high-tech sectors. Specifically, we find that the effects on employment are influenced by related variety among specialised suppliers and scale intensive sectors, in which their success in the market is not primarily related to R&D.The findings are robust once we control for some important variables able to capture the productive structure and the innovation (trademarks) of Italian regions.
View
Crecimiento económico regional y metodologías espacio-temporales: una revisión.
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2011
Se presentan algunos argumentos teóricos tomados de la teoría del crecimiento endógeno, para explicar por qué el espacio (que es un reflejo de las relaciones interregionales) y por qué el tiempo (que es un reflejo de la historia o trayectoria temporal de cada región) deben ir complementarios dentro del esquema o modelo de análisis del crecimiento económico de las regiones. Se reseñan dos propuestas metodológicas: la primera consiste en un modelo de datos panel con efectos espaciales y temporales y la segunda una cadena de transición de Markov combinada con clasificaciones de índices de correlación espacial local. Finalmente se destaca por qué estas metodologías pueden ser empleadas con datos de los departamentos colombianos, para realizar un análisis espacial y temporal del crecimiento económico para Colombia.
View
The Poor Stay Poor: Non-Convergence Across Countries and Regions
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 1995
We study the issue of income convergence across countries and regions with a Bayesian model which allows us to use information in an efficient and flexible way. We argue that the very slow convergence rates to a common level of per-capita income found, for example, by Barro and Sala-i-Martin, is due to a 'fixed effect bias' that their cross-sectional analysis introduces in the results. Our approach permits the estimation of different convergence rates to different steady states for each cross-sectional unit. When this diversity is allowed, we find that convergence of each unit to (its own) steady-state income level is much faster than previously estimated, but that cross-sectional differences persist: inequalities will only be reduced by a small amount by the passage of time. The cross-country distribution of the steady state is largely explained by the cross-sectional distribution of initial conditions.
View
View
Alternative Approaches to Spatial Autocorrelation: An Improvement Over Current Practice
Article
  • Oct 1977
  • INT REGIONAL SCI REV
THE ASSUMPTION THAT THE CORRELATION BETWEEN THE TEMPORAL ERROR TERMS ∈ t AND ∈t-n DECLINES AS n INCREASES CAN BE JUSTIFIED BY APPEALING TO FIRST OR SECOND ORDER MAR-KOV PROCESSES OR TO SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, BUT A SIMILAR ASSUMPTION CANNOT BE JUSTIFIED FOR SPATIAL ERROR TERMS. THIS INTRODUCES AMBIGUITY IN THE SPECIFICATION OF THE WEIGHTING MATRIX W. IN THIS PAPER WE PROPOSE THE JOINT GENERALIZED LEAST SQUARES, EQUICORRELATED ERROR TERMS, RANDOM ERROR COMPONENT MODELS, AND RANDOM COEFFICIENT REGRESSION MODELS AS ALTERNATIVE SOLUTIONS. THESE APPROACHES ARE SUBJECT TO FEW OR NO PERSONAL BIASES, YET THEY ARE ABLE TO RESOLVE THE PROBLEM OF SPATIAL AUTOCORRELATION.
View
View
Dynamic Models of Spatial Autocorrelation
Article
  • Feb 1977
Dynamic models have been studied intensively during the last decade, particularly in the field of growth theory and diffusion analysis. Consequently, problems like temporal autocorrelation have received much attention. Recently the attention of econometricians has also concentrated on spatial autocorrelation, particularly in the field of spatial interaction models. The existence of spatial autocorrelation among spatially dispersed phenomena appears to lead to significant differences in the treatment of multiregional models. In this paper, attention will be focused on the formal aspects of dynamic spatial diffusion models. Some statistical measures for temporal - spatial autocorrelation will be constructed. In addition, a formal derivation of necessary extensions in estimation procedures for dynamic multiregional econometric models will be presented, particularly in the field of seemingly unrelated regressions and instrumental variables. The analysis will be illustrated by means of a dynamic explanatory model for the spatial dispersion of foreign workers in The Netherlands.
View
A Cost-Efficiency Principle of Spatial Interaction
Article
  • Feb 1978
  • REG SCI URBAN ECON
A new macro-statistical principle of spatial interaction behavior is proposed. This cost-efficiency principle asserts in essence that, other things being equal, interaction patterns involving higher total costs are less likely to be observed than those involving lower costs. The main result of the paper is to show that this principle completely characterizes the important class of exponential gravity models. This characterization resolves the ‘sign’ problem inherent in the maximum- entropy derivation of these models. Moreover, since this principle focuses directly on the cost- minimizing nature of spatial interaction choices, it appears to have more behavioral content than the simple maximum-entropy approach. A number of extensions and generalizations of the cost-efficiency principle are also outlined which suggest that the principle may have a much wider range of application.
View
An asymptotic foundation for logit models
Article
  • Feb 1998
  • REG SCI URBAN ECON
An agent makes a discrete choice between alternatives. The alternatives are grouped, so that systematic utility differences occur between groups. Within groups, utility levels are random, based on a distribution F. For large groups, the behavior of the agent is shown to be governed by the logit model or its limiting cases. The cases are related to a classification of distributions by decay speed of the upper tail. The connections with the types of extreme value theory and elements of spatial economics are discussed.
View