ArticlePDF Available

Student nurses’ knowledge of palliative care: evaluating an education module

Authors:

Abstract

There is evidence that education in palliative care in the UK is somewhat patchy and that this important area of health care should be given a greater emphasis in the nursing curriculum. This article describes an evaluation of a palliative care module taken by a group of third year student nurses. The effect of the module was evaluated using the palliative care quiz for nursing (PCQN), administered at the beginning and at the end of the module. The results demonstrate that the students significantly increased their understanding of aspects of pain and symptom control. In particular, they became knowledgeable about adjuvant therapies and opioid use. In contrast to previous studies, the students rejected the 'fear of addiction' associated with opioid use. Deficits in knowledge included side-effects of codeine, use of sedation and the use of placebos. The results support the need to develop a compulsory module in palliative care that is formally assessed and includes a palliative care placement. This would enable comprehensive and systematic coverage of palliative care in the undergraduate nursing curriculum.
T
he increasingly complex nature of
palliative care and its application in
different settings makes the educa-
tion of health professionals a priority.
The palliative care approach has been
described by the Department of Health
(DoH) (1996) as care that should be prac-
tised by all health professionals regardless
of setting. Therefore all health practition-
ers working with those with cancer and
other life-threatening conditions, e.g.
neurological conditions, cardiac and res-
piratory failure, should be able to provide
care with a palliative approach, as out-
lined in Box 1. The European Oncology
Nursing Society (EONS) supports the
dissemination of the principles of pallia-
tive nursing as a priority for nurses at all
stages of their professional development
(EONS, 1994). In recognition of this,
Kingston University, in the UK, has
developed a module in palliative care for
undergraduate student nurses. This article
describes the evaluation of the module,
which took place between January 2000
and May 2000.
Background
There is evidence that education in pallia-
tive care is inconsistent and that there is a
need for greater emphasis on palliative
care in the education of health profession-
als (Field, 1984; Benoliel, 1988; Oliver,
1989; Jeffrey, 1994; Chippendale, 2001).
Student nurses and newly registered
nurses have been identified as feeling inad-
equately prepared for aspects of palliative
care such as talking to patients about
death and dying (Birch, 1983; Hockley,
1989; Corner and Wilson-Barnett, 1992).
In 1994, under the auspices of EONS and
funded by the European Commission’s
‘Europe against Cancer’ programme and
Cancer Relief Macmillan Fund (a UK
charity), a working party was established
to identify a core curriculum appropriate
for preregistration nursing courses in all
European Union member states.
The core curriculum consists of five
themes; a central theme covering the prin-
ciples of palliative care serves to integrate
the remaining four themes, which are con-
cerned with symptom control, facing
death, ethical and legal issues and commu-
nication (Figure 1). This framework repre-
sents the key concepts related to the
knowledge, skills and attitudes required in
palliative care. The working party recom-
mended that a minimum of 12 hours be
devoted to deal specifically with palliative
nursing. The report does not give guid-
ance in relation to the stage in the course
that these 12 hours are included or over
what period of time they should be
included. The working party worked with
the assumption that many of the issues
inherent within the themes, such as com-
munication skills, loss and grief, and
anatomy and physiology will already have
been addressed in the curriculum.
Until 1998, teaching in palliative care
within the undergraduate nursing pro-
gramme at Kingston University followed
Education
Anne Arber is Senior
Lecturer and Pathway
Leader in Cancer and
Palliative Care, Kingston
University and St George’s
Hospital Medical School,
London, UK
Student nurses’ knowledge
of palliative care:
evaluating an education module
Anne Arber
Abstract
T
here is evidence that education in palliative care in the UK is
somewhat patchy and that this important area of health care
should be given a greater emphasis in the nursing curriculum.
This article describes an evaluation of a palliative care module
taken by a group of third year student nurses. The effect of the
module was evaluated using the palliative care quiz for nursing
(PCQN), administered at the beginning and at the end of the mod-
ule. The results demonstrate that the students significantly
increased their understanding of aspects of pain and symptom
control. In particular, they became knowledgeable about adjuvant
therapies and opioid use. In contrast to previous studies, the stu-
dents rejected the ‘fear of addiction’ associated with opioid use.
Deficits in knowledge included side-effects of codeine, use of
sedation and the use of placebos. The results support the need
to develop a compulsory module in palliative care that is formally
assessed and includes a palliative care placement. This would
enable comprehensive and systematic coverage of palliative care
in the undergraduate nursing curriculum.
International Journal of Palliative Nursing, 2001, Vol 7, No 12 597
International Journal of Palliative Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 131.227.130.074 on December 28, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
an integrated approach whereby different
aspects of palliative care were introduced
throughout the course. This is a common
approach used in the UK and the usual
mode of delivery for death education in
the USA and Canada, as identified by
Degner and Gow (1988). They found that
students were not always offered place-
ments that gave them clinical experience
of caring for and working with people
with terminal illnesses and the bereaved.
The main drawback to this approach,
they argued, is the variability in the
amount and type of education received
by student nurses.
Since 1998 student nurses at Kingston
University have been offered an optional
module in palliative care. Approximately
one-third of students opt to take the
module; those that do not will have a
minimal knowledge of palliative care. A
modular approach to palliative nursing
has been recommended as providing a
more systematic coverage of the palliative
approach (EONS, 1994). The aim of the
palliative care approach (DoH, 1996) is to
integrate both physical and psychosocial
wellbeing by focusing on quality of life,
sensitive communication and respect for
choice and autonomy (Box 1).
Since 1999 the palliative module has
also included a 1-week hospice place-
ment. This placement enables students to
be in a supportive environment and to
observe skilled role models delivering
hospice care in a multidisciplinary team.
The students receive approximately
50 hours of teaching in addition to the
1-week hospice placement over a period
of 5 months. This is far in excess of
the 12 hours recommended by EONS.
Most importantly, the students are also
required to produce a written assignment
in relation to palliative care.
At Kingston University palliative care
education has been prioritized as an
important aspect of the undergraduate
nursing programme. Good relationships
and close collaboration with the local
hospital, hospice and community pallia-
tive colleagues ensure the success of
this module. Students report excellent
mentorship and support during their
hospice placement and this has challenged
many of their preconceptions about
hospice care.
A number of authors have pointed out
the need for rigorous evaluation of the
effectiveness of teaching and learning in
all aspects of palliative care (Copp, 1994;
Yates et al, 1997). With this in mind the
module was evaluated using Ross et al’s
(1996) palliative care quiz for nursing
(PCQN). Ross et al suggested that this
tool could provide data about the level of
knowledge possessed by participants and
highlight any misconceptions they may
have relating to palliative care.
The aim of the evaluation
The evaluation had two main objectives:
To measure third year student nurses’
knowledge of palliative care at the
beginning and end of a module in pallia-
tive care using the PCQN
To identify significant change in student
nurses’ knowledge of palliative care at
the end of the module.
Method
The PCQN is a 20-item test of knowledge;
answers are given as ‘true’, ‘false’ or ‘don’t
know’ (Table 1). It has been validated by a
Student nurses’ knowledge of palliative care: evaluating an education module
598 International Journal of Palliative Nursing, 2001, Vol 7, No 12
Box 1. The palliative care approach
The palliative care approach is a vital and integral part of all clinical
practice, whatever the illness or its stage, informed by a knowledge and
practice of palliative care principles and supported by specialist palliative
care. The key principles underpinning palliative care, which should be
practised by all health professionals in primary care, hospital and other
settings, comprise:
Focus on quality of life including good symptom control
Whole-person approach taking into account the person’s previous life
experiences and current situation
Care that encompasses both the person with life-threatening disease
and those that matter to that person
Respect for patient autonomy and choice
Emphasis on open and sensitive communication, which extends to
patients, informal carers and professional colleagues
(DoH, 1996)
Figure 1. Framework for the inclusion of palliative nursing in basic
nursing courses.
Managing nursing
problems relating
to symptoms
Ethical and legal
issues
Facing
death
Communication
Integrating
theme
The principles
of palliative
care
International Journal of Palliative Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 131.227.130.074 on December 28, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
600 International Journal of Palliative Nursing, 2001, Vol 7, No 12
The questions on the PCQN are
grouped into three conceptual categories:
The philosophy and principles of pal-
liative care (questions 1, 9, 12, 17)
The management of pain and other
symptoms (questions 2–4, 6–8, 10,
13–16, 18, 20)
Psychosocial and spiritual care of indi-
viduals and families (questions 5, 11, 19).
wide process of consultation with experts
in the field of palliative care, piloting and
in-depth testing of the items. It focuses on
the basic type of information necessary
for entry to practice. In this sense it is
considered suitable for undergraduate
nursing students. The tool is easily admin-
istered and can be quickly completed by
the participants.
Student nurses’ knowledge of palliative care: evaluating an education module
Answer known before/after module
Correct No/ No/ Yes/ Yes/
Question answer No Yes No Yes P-value
1. Palliative care is only appropriate in situations where 2 11 2 17 P=0.022
there is evidence of irreversible deterioration False (6.3%) (34.4%) (6.3%) (53.1%)
2. The analgesic effect of other opioids is measured 14 9 3 5 P=0.146
against that of morphine. True (45.2%) (29.0%) (9.7%) (16.1%)
3. The extent of the disease determines the methods 5 3 25 P=0.146
of pain management. False (15.2%) (9.1%) (75.6%)
4. Adjuvant therapies are important in managing pain 3 9 21 P=0.004
True (9.1%) (27.3%) (63.6%)
5. It is crucial for family members to remain at the 14127P=0.375
bedside until death occurs. False (3.0%) (12.1%) (3.0%) (81.8%)
6. During the last days of life, drowsiness associated with 22 7 3 1 P=0.344
electrolyte imbalance may decrease the need for sedation True (66.7%) (21.2%) (9.1%) (3.0%)
7. Drug addiction is a major problem when morphine is 3 11 18 P=0.001
used on a long-term basis. False (9.4%) (34.4%) (56.3%)
8. Individuals who are taking opioids should also take 33
regular medication to prevent constipation True (100%)
9. Professional carers in palliative care must remain 31227P=1.000
emotionally detached. False (9.1%) (3.0%) (6.1%) (81.8%)
10. During the terminal stages of an illness, drugs that can
cause respiratory depression are appropriate for severe 15 11 2 2 P=0.022
dyspnoea True (50.0%) (36.7%) (6.7%) (6.7%)
11. Men generally resolve their grief more quickly 1 2 30 P=0.500
than women. False (3.0%) (6.1%) (90.9%)
12. The philosophy of palliative care is compatible with 24 3 5 P=0.727
that of aggressive treatment. True (75.0%) (9.4%) (15.6%)
13. The use of placebos is appropriate in the treatment 21 6 2 4 P=0.289
of some types of pain. False (63.6%) (18.2%) (6.1%) (12.1%)
14. In high doses, codeine causes more nausea and 20 3 7 2 P=0.344
vomiting than morphine. True (62.5%) (9.4%) (21.9%) (6.3%)
15. Suffering and physical pain are synonymous. 12 6 4 11 P=0.754
False (36.4%) (18.2%) (12.1%) (33.3%)
16. Pethidine is not an effective analgesic for the 7 19 3 4 P=0.001
control of chronic pain. True (21.2%) (57.6%) (9.1%) (12.1%)
17. The cumulative effect of repeated losses inevitably leads 73617P=0.508
to burnout for those who work in palliative care False (21.2%) (9.1%) (18.2%) (51.5%)
18. Manifestations of chronic pain are different from 58217P=0.109
those of acute pain. True (15.6%) (25.0%) (6.3%) (53.1%)
19. The loss of a distant or difficult relationship is easier to 42323P=1.000
resolve than the loss of one that is close or intimate False (12.5%) (6.3%) (9.4%) (71.9%)
20. The pain threshold is lowered by fatigue or anxiety 89610P=0.607
True (24.2%) (27.3%) (18.2%) (30.3%)
Table 1. Questions and results of the palliative care quiz for nursing (n=33)
International Journal of Palliative Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 131.227.130.074 on December 28, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
For the purpose of our study, one item
on the PCQN was changed: the drug
name demerol was changed to its British
equivalent of pethidine (question 16).
The PCQN was administered to all stu-
dents present on the first day of the mod-
ule (n = 45) in January 2000. Verbal
consent was sought and all the students
agreed to complete the quiz. Confiden-
tiality was maintained by use of student
identification numbers, rather than names.
The same questionnaire was adminis-
tered on the penultimate day of the mod-
ule in May 2000. Twelve students were
absent on this day, leaving a total sample
size of 33. If a student omitted to answer
any question on either questionnaire, this
question was eliminated from their data
and not included in the analysis.
Analysis
The change in knowledge before and after
the palliative care module was statistically
tested using McNemar’s test for change
(Ott and Mendenhall, 1994). This enables
the change in students’ level of knowledge
from the beginning to the end of the mod-
ule to be tested statistically. It tests the null
hypothesis that there was no difference in
knowledge overall, in particular that the
number of individuals who learned the
correct answer through the module (i.e.
answered the question incorrectly before,
yet correctly after the module) was equal
to the number of individuals whose
knowledge deteriorated (i.e. answered the
question correctly before, yet incorrectly
after the module). The critical significance
level was set to 0.05.
Findings
The total number of correct responses to
the PCQN before and after the module is
shown in Table 1. The overall percentages
are shown in brackets. The correct
response for each question is identified.
There is a significant increase of two
questions answered correctly following the
module (median 2.00). The lower quartile
was 0.25 and the upper quartile 4.0
(Wilcoxon signed ranks test; P = 0.001 (Ott
and Mendenhall, 1994)). Therefore, there is
a statistically significant increase in stu-
dents’ knowledge of palliative care by the
end of the module.
Philosophy of palliative care
There is a significant change in the stu-
dents’ level of knowledge on question one
related to the principles of palliative care
(Table 1). The appropriateness of pallia-
tive care was correctly identified by 11
(34.4%) students following the module as
not exclusively limited to situations where
there is irreversible deterioration (question
1). This demonstrates a tendency for
change (P = 0.022).
The students had difficulty identifying
the philosophy of palliative care as com-
patible with that of aggressive treatment
(question 12). Ross et al (1996) also iden-
tified a misconception that palliative care
is not compatible with the provision of
aggressive treatment. In the UK defini-
tions of palliative care usually refer to
active total care rather than aggressive
treatment (World Health Organization
(WHO), 1990). It is possible that the
terminology used in this question was
confusing and that this may account for
the students’ answers.
A number of students changed their
view about whether burnout was a risk for
those working in palliative care (question
17); six students who believed that
repeated losses did not inevitably lead to
burnout in palliative care at the start of the
module changed their view by the end of
the module and identified that repeated
losses did lead to burnout. This is an
important area for further research.
Psychosocial and spiritual care
Knowledge of psychosocial care includ-
ing the role of the family (question 5),
responses to loss and grief (question 19)
and gender and grief (question 11) was
good. Over 70% of students could
answer these questions correctly at the
start of the module. Proctor et al (2000)
found that their sample of 247 trained
nurses also had reasonable knowledge of
psychosocial aspects of care. The authors
suggest that this may be because practi-
tioners draw on practical and personal
knowledge and that this reflects acquisi-
tion of knowledge by experience rather
than by formal learning. This explanation
does not necessarily apply to the student
nurse group who will have had limited
practice experience. However, it may
reflect the attention given to teaching and
learning about psychosocial aspects of
care in the undergraduate nursing pro-
grammes. This is a good basis on which
to develop palliative education.
Pain and symptom control
There is a statistically significant change
in students’ level of knowledge on four
Student nurses’ knowledge of palliative care: evaluating an education module
International Journal of Palliative Nursing, 2001, Vol 7, No 12 601
‘The students had
difficulty
identifying the
philosophy of
palliative care as
compatible with
that of aggressive
treatment
(question 12).’
International Journal of Palliative Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 131.227.130.074 on December 28, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
questions related to pain and symptom
control. There is a significant improve-
ment in knowledge of adjuvant therapies
(question 4) with nine students (27.3%)
knowing the correct answer following the
module (P = 0.004). There is also a signifi-
cant improvement in knowledge related to
drug addiction not being a major problem
when morphine is used on a long-term
basis (question 7). Eleven students
(34.4%), who hadn’t known the correct
answer before the module took place
knew the correct answer following the
module (P = 0.001). Many studies have
found that nurses and doctors overesti-
mate the incidence of psychological
dependence related to the use of opioids.
The fear of patients becoming addicted to
these drugs acts as a barrier to pain con-
trol (Marks and Sachar, 1973; Watt-
Watson, 1985; McCaffery et al, 1990;
Hollen et al, 2000).
There is also a significant improvement
in the students’ ability to identify that
pethidine is not an effective analgesic for
chronic pain (question 16). An extra 19
students (57.6%) knew the correct
answer following the module (P = 0.001).
Hollen et al (2000) discussed how nurses
who reported more than 16 hours of pain
education were significantly more edu-
cated about opioids and Hauck (1986)
also found that education decreased con-
cerns about addiction. Hospice nurses
have been found to perform well when
managing the patient’s concern about
addiction (Sloan et al, 1999). The specific
focus of the module on the palliative care
approach, including pain and symptom
control, combined with a placement in a
hospice where students can observe
competent role models, may enable stu-
dents to discard the fear of addiction
found in other studies and improve their
knowledge of the use of opioids.
There is a tendency for improvement in
knowledge related to the appropriateness
of drugs that cause respiratory depression
for treating dyspnoea (question 10). There
was an increase of 11 students (36.7%)
who know that drugs that cause respira-
tory depression are appropriate for severe
dyspnoea (P = 0.022). Hauck (1986) also
found that education decreases concerns
about respiratory distress.
Students were already knowledgeable
about aspects of pain and symptom con-
trol when they started the module. All stu-
dents knew that when taking opioids,
regular medication is necessary to prevent
constipation (question 8). Over 75% of
students identified that the extent of the
disease determines the methods of pain
management (question 3).
Deficits in knowledge of symptom con-
trol following the module concern the
side-effects of codeine (question 14), the
need for sedation (question 6) and the use
of placebos (question 13). Of the stu-
dents, 63.6% were unable to identify, at
the beginning and end of the module, that
the use of placebos is inappropriate in
the treatment of pain. Hollen et al (2000)
found that 20% of hospice nurses and
more than 30% of the hospital nurses
believed that administration of a placebo
is a useful test for determining the
reality of pain. Pain experts acknowledge,
however, that a placebo response is to be
expected and is linked to the patient’s
expectations of a beneficial effect (Wall,
1999); therefore a placebo response is not
a useful test for determining the reality
of pain. As such, it is a concern that
63.6% of students in this study have
wrongly identified appropriate treatment
of pain and 30% of hospital nurses and
a smaller proportion of hospice nurses
have inaccurate understanding of the
placebo response.
At the end of the module the results of
the quiz were discussed with the students.
This enabled clarification of some of the
misconceptions related to placebos, seda-
tion and side-effects of specific drugs. In
the future I believe it is necessary to spend
more time facilitating learning related to
these specific needs.
Limitations
This evaluation has a small sample size so
there is difficulty generalizing these find-
ings to other groups of students. Also it is
difficult to extrapolate from the findings
to the students’ actual practice. A longitu-
dinal study would need to be undertaken
in order to identify the impact of this
module and clinical placement in practice.
Ideally, a comparative study would enable
comparison between those that attend the
module and those receiving the integrated
curriculum with or without the hospice
placement. There is also the need to
develop the PCQN further as some of the
questions may be ambiguous in the
British context.
Recommendations
The PCQN is a useful evaluative tool that
could be developed in palliative nursing in
Student nurses’ knowledge of palliative care: evaluating an education module
602 International Journal of Palliative Nursing, 2001, Vol 7, No 12
‘Pain experts
acknowledge…
that a placebo
response is to
be expected and
is linked to
the patient’s
expectations of a
beneficial effect…
therefore a
placebo response
is not a useful test
for determining
the reality of
pain.’
International Journal of Palliative Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 131.227.130.074 on December 28, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
the UK. It provides educators and practi-
tioners with useful information on nurses’
level of knowledge before training and
practice and is a useful adjunct to other
forms of evaluation. By identifying deficits
in knowledge such as the side-effects of
analgesic drugs and the use of sedation and
placebos, these may be addressed more
specifically in the programme.
The modular approach to palliative care
education combined with a clinical place-
ment appears successful in challenging
some of the misconceptions about pallia-
tive care and opioid use. Most impor-
tantly students are assessed on their
understanding and practice of palliative
care. However, further research needs to
be undertaken into student nurses’ experi-
ence of emotional work and stress when
working with those with life-limiting and
life-threatening disease.
Conclusion
The students who completed the pallia-
tive module did increase their knowledge
regarding palliative care with respect to
aspects of symptom control and opioid
use. An earlier focus group evaluation by
the first students to take the module, as
well as informal feedback from other stu-
dents, indicates that the module provides
the nurses with an increased feeling of
confidence when working with those
with advanced disease and those who are
dying (Arber and Gallaher, 1999).
Although more investigation is needed,
there does seem to be a strong argument
for a required module in palliative care
that is assessed separately, rather than the
integrated course so popular in many
programmes. This would enable more
systematic coverage of the palliative care
approach as an established component of
undergraduate nursing courses. This is
essential to bringing the palliative care
approach into all areas of health care
involving those with chronic and life-
threatening illness.
Arber A, Gallaher A (1999) Innovations and
Possibilities in Cancer and Palliative Care
Education for Student Nurses: The way forward?
Unpublished presentation made to the Education
Round Table, Trent Palliative Care Centre, The
Glebe Hotel, Warwickshire, UK, October
Benoliel JQ (1988) Health care delivery: not con-
ducive to teaching palliative care. J Palliat Care
4(1): 41–2
Birch JA (1983) Anxiety and conflict in nurse educa-
tion. In: Davis B, ed. Research into Nurse
Education. Croom Helm, London
Copp G (1994) Palliative care nursing education: a
review of research findings. J Adv Nurs 19: 552–7
Corner J, Wilson-Barnett J (1992) The newly regis-
tered nurse and the cancer patient: an educational
evaluation. Int J Nurs Stud 29(2): 177–90
Chippendale S (2001) The importance of funding
palliative care education: a look to the future. Int J
Palliat Nurs 7(6): 298–300
Degner LF, Gow CM (1988) Preparing nurses for
care of the dying: a longitudinal study. Cancer
Nursing 11(3): 160–9
DoH (1996) A Policy Framework for Commissioning
Cancer Services: Palliative Care Services. HMSO,
London
EONS (1994) Report and Recommendations of a
Workshop to Study the Feasibility of Educational
Programmes in Palliative Care for Nurses in
Europe. EONS, Dublin
Field D (1984) Formal instruction in United
Kingdom medical schools about death and dying.
Med Educ 18: 429–34
Hauck SL (1986) Pain: problem for the person with
cancer. Cancer Nursing 9: 66–76
Hockley J (1989) Caring for the dying in acute hos-
pitals. Nurs Times 85(7): 47–50
Hollen CJ, Hollen CW, Stolte K (2000) Hospice and
hospital oncology unit nurses: a comparative sur-
vey of knowledge and attitudes about cancer pain.
Oncol Nurs Forum 27(10):1593–99
Jeffrey D (1994) Education in palliative care: a quali-
tative evaluation of the present state and the needs
of general practitioners and community nurses.
Eur J Cancer Care 3: 67–74
Marks R, Sachar E (1973) Undertreatment of medical
inpatients with narcotic analgesics. Ann Int Med 8:
173–81
McCaffery M, Ferrell B, O’Neil-Page E, Lester M,
Ferrell B (1990) Nurses’ knowledge of opioid
analgesic drugs and psychological dependence.
Cancer Nursing 13: 21–7
Oliver D (1989) Training in and knowledge of termi-
nal care in medical students and junior doctors.
Palliat Med 32(4): 293–7
Ott RL, Mendenhall W (1994) Understanding
Statistics. 6th edn. Duxbury Press, Pacific Grove
Proctor M, Grealish L, Coates M, Sears P (2000)
Nurses’ knowledge of palliative care in the
Australian Capital Territory. Int J Palliat Nurs
6(9): 421–8
Ross MM, McDonald B, McGuiness J (1996) The
palliative care quiz for nursing (PCQN): the
development of an instrument to measure nurses’
knowledge of palliative care. J Adv Nurs 23:
126–37
Sloan PA, Vanderveer BL, Snapp JS, Johnson M,
Sloan DA (1999) Cancer pain assessment and man-
agement recommendations by hospice nurses. J
Pain Symptom Manage 18(2): 103–10
Wall P (1999) Pain: The Science of Suffering.
Phoenix, London
Watt-Watson J (1985) Nurses’ knowledge of pain
issues: a survey. J Pain Symptom Manage 2(4):
207–11
WHO (1990) Cancer Pain Relief and Palliative Care.
Technical Report Series 804. WHO, Geneva
Yates P, Clinton M, Hart G (1997) Design of a pro-
fessional development programme for palliative
care nurses (part 2). Int J Palliat Nurs 3(2): 70–5
Student nurses’ knowledge of palliative care: evaluating an education module
International Journal of Palliative Nursing, 2001, Vol 7, No 12 603
KEY WORDS
Palliative care approach
Education
Pain and symptom control
Evaluation
Psychosocial care
Curriculum development
‘… there does
seem to be a
strong argument
for a required
module in
palliative care
that is assessed
separately,
rather than the
integrated course
so popular
in many
programmes.’
International Journal of Palliative Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 131.227.130.074 on December 28, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
... There was also a lack of understanding with regards to the use of morphine in pain management, in palliative care. Many other studies have similarly found misconceptions about morphine, both among nursing students and qualified nurses [11][12][17][18][19]. These often results in poor pain management for patients [20][21], and therefore needs to be appropriately addressed in palliative care educational programs. ...
... This study, like some comparative studies in the literature found improvements in students' knowledge relating to pain management [17][18][19]. Studies with qualified nurses, have also reported improvements in nurses' knowledge of pain management [23][24]. ...
... Nevertheless, it seems the wording of this item was a problem. Like Arber [19], the authors of this study think that the term 'aggressive treatment' might have been unclear to the students and might need to be revised as 'compatible with disease specific treatments like cancer therapy and antiretroviral drugs' [25] or compatible with 'active total care' as is commonly used in the UK [19]. In addition, students still struggled with their knowledge of psychosocial and spiritual care. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract: In resource-poor settings some preregistration nursing curricula, do not include any palliative care content, and practising nurses, both newly graduated and student nurses have limited knowledge about palliative care. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of a palliative care course on Cameroonian preregistration nursing students’ palliative care knowledge. The study employed a longitudinal quasi-experimental pretest/posttest design. A 30 hours classroom based palliative care course, underpinned by the experiential learning theory was delivered to second and third year nursing students in a University in Cameroon. An evaluation of the i mpact of the course on students’ palliative care knowledge was conducted via a pretest/posttest survey. Data was analysed using both descriptive and inferential statistics. The study revealed very poor palliative care knowledge among preregistration nursing students, with a mean pretest score of 5.72/20 (Standard deviation of 2.54; Confidence Interval: 5.11-6.34). After the palliative care course there was a statistically significantly improvement in students’ overall palliative care knowledge, with a posttest score of 11.36 (SD= 2.03, CI 10.85-11.87). Demographic factors like students’ level in the nursing course and age were seen to be associated with students’ pre-cours e scores (P=0.002 and 0.027 respectively), but no demographic factor was implicated in the posttest score. There is therefore a need for curriculum revision to include palliative care content in the preregistration nurse training curricula of the pilot University. Keywords: Palliative Care Education, Pre-Registration Nursing Education, Resource-Poor Settings
... Knowledge does seem to improve as students' progress in their academic studies, but it still remains inadequate (Kwekkeboom et al., 2006;Al Qadire, 2014). One explanation may be that undergraduate nursing curricula provide limited and/or inconsistent content about palliative and end-of-life care (Arber, 2001;Kwekkeboom et al., 2006;Brajtman et al., 2007). Where theoretical and practical training on palliative care has been fully integrated in undergraduate nursing programmes, not only has it improved students' knowledge, but also led to more liberal attitudes towards death, dying and end-of-life care (Mastroianni et al., 2015;Chover-Sierra et al., 2017). ...
... meperidine or pethidine) can be explained as lack of familiarity with a brand name that is not widely used in Greece. In previous studies, "Demerol" was replaced with the term "pethidine" (Arber, 2001; Al Qadire, 2014) we are incorporating this modification in the Greek PCQN. In addition, that only 30% of our sample saw palliative care as compatible to aggressive treatment can be attributed to the negative connotation of the term "aggressive". ...
... 2014). Arber (2001) replaced this term with "active" to more correctly convey the core message that palliative care incorporates elements similar to that of active treatment (Arber, 2001). Our findings also point to some key student misconceptions that need addressed at the undergraduate level. ...
Article
Background: Ensuring adequate knowledge about palliative care and positive attitudes towards death and dying are crucial educational aspects when preparing undergraduate nursing students to respond effectively to the complexities of care for people affected by a progressive, life-limiting illness. In undergraduate nursing education in Greece, the level of students’ attained knowledge and developed attitudes towards palliative and end-of-life care remain unknown. Purpose: To investigate undergraduate nursing students’ knowledge about palliative care and attitudes towards death and end-of-life care, and explore demographic and academic factors as potential moderators of student knowledge and attitudes. Methods: We conducted a descriptive, cross-sectional, questionnaire-based survey. We recruited 2nd, 3rd and 4th year undergraduate nursing students from the country's two University Faculties. Participants completed a demographic form, the Palliative Care Quiz for Nursing (PCQN), and the Frommelt Attitudes Towards Care of the Dying (FATCOD) questionnaire. Results: The final sample was 529 students (response rate = 87.6%). Mean total PCQN scores revealed low levels of knowledge. Knowledge about pain/symptom management and psychosocial/spiritual care was insufficient. Mean total FATCOD scores indicated positive, liberal and supportive attitudes towards end-of-life care, with 60% of respondents keen to care for a dying person and their family. We noted less positive attitudes mainly in relation to student comfort with the care of a dying person and his/her imminent death. Academic parameters (year of study) and student demographic characteristics (older age) were the most significant moderators of both knowledge and attitudes. Greater knowledge about palliative care was a relatively weak, yet significant, predictor of more liberal attitudes towards care of the dying. Conclusion: Our findings suggest that structured courses in palliative care can be a core part of undergraduate nursing education. Specific attention could be given to such areas patient-health professional communication, misconceptions and biases towards death and dying, and comfort in caring for the dying in order to prepare student nurses to psychologically deal with the sensitive and challenging process of death and dying.
... The 20-item scale of PCQN is divided into three conceptual categories (Ross et al., 1996;Arber, 2001)-these categories are: a) philosophy and principles of palliative care, reflecting nurses' attitudes of towards PC (questions 1, 9, 12 & 17), b) psychosocial and spiritual care, reflecting nurses' knowledge on PC (questions 5, 11 & 19), and c) pain and symptom management, reflecting nurses' skills regarding PC (questions 2-4, 6-8, 10, 13-16, 18 & 20). These categories are significant because they divide the quiz questions into palliative care knowledge areas and help summarize participants' knowledge strengths and/or weaknesses (Ross et al., 1996). ...
... The possible reason for this might be that only a few nurses have been trained on PC. This is also evident in other studies including those by Rolandson et al. (2008), Proctor et al. (2000), Arber (2001), Raudonis et al. (2002), Knapp (2009), Brazil et al. (2012), and Carroll et al. (2005. For example, Rolandson et al. (2008) found that the mean score for Registered Nurses was 11.7 (SD = 3.1) and for Assistants in Nursing 5.8 (SD = 3.3). ...
Article
p> Introduction: Nurses can have a prominent role in end-of-life care. They should however have the appropriate knowledge and practice about Palliative Care (PC) in order to provide high quality of care at the end of life of for chronically sick patients. Methods: A cross sectional quantitative study and analysis was carried through a validated questionnaire tool based on the Palliative Care Quiz for Nursing (PCQN). The study included 150 nurses working in a major public hospital in Greece. Results: T he majority of nurses in Greece had poor knowledge about PC reaching a 8.9 PCQN overall score out of 20. The findings from this study confirmed the association of gender, age, work experience and level of education on nurses’ knowledge about PC. Conclusions: There is a lack of proper training and there are very few healthcare units specializing in PC provision in Greece. Special programs for PC are required in order to enhance nurses’ knowledge and attitude towards good PC practices. </p
... It is important that nurse educators have credibility in relation to what they are teaching; this in turn allows students to feel that they are being given the best information available to deal with this already difficult area of end of life care. Some studies have focused on assessing nursing students' end of life knowledge, skills and/or attitudes Arber, [2]; Mallory, [25].. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study looked at the lived experiences of clinical nurse educators who work with undergraduate nursing students in a hospital setting. It employed a phenomenological approach to focus on nurses’ personal experiences of death and dying. In particular this paper examined how nurses perceive the way the experiences influences the way that they instruct their students Informal interviews with four nurses were audio taped and transcribed. Rich descriptions of emotions which emerged are discussed in detail. Data were analysed using the Colaizzi method of analysis and common themes were identified. They included remaining professional, Humanizing stories and teaching different levels of undergraduates. These themes were evaluated in terms of their value of meaning for students and the possible implication for clinical care. The literature examined relevant to the study has previously identified the importance of nurses knowing the meaning of end of life care; caring and empathy; student nurses’ perception and the need for student belongingness. The study has added to the field by identifying the importance of nurses sharing personal experiences to enhance student learning in this already difficult area of nursing.
... All nurses, regardless which departments they are working at, are expected to understand the palliative care approach from their basic training these days. They are recommended to be exposed to education about palliative care during their initial training in school to understand what palliative care is [29]. However, there is a lack of initial preparation of Chinese nursing students as palliative care education and placement in hospice are still missing from our nursing schools. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Most nurses in China have not been trained to take care of end-of-life patients appropriately due to lack of educational resources and insufficient training. A palliative care program was launched by the Jiangsu Nursing Association (JNA training program) and to identify gaps in palliative care training. The main aim of this study was to evaluate the training effects of the JNA training program on nurses’ knowledge and attitudes to palliative care. Methods A cross-sectional study was conducted with 10 048 registered nurses in all regions of Jiangsu. All participants completed an online questionnaire using the Chinese version of The Palliative Care Quiz for Nursing (PCQN-C) and the Frommelt Attitude Toward Care of the Dying scale (FATCOD-B-C). A propensity score matched analysis was performed between the nurses who had attended the JNA training program and whose who hadn’t. Results The average score of PCQN-C among all nurses was 8.79, while the mean score of the FATCOD-B-C was 103.62. Those participants who attended the JNA training program had significantly better scores than those who did not. Propensity score matching analysis showed that the palliative care training program failed to improve nurses’ knowledge in psychosocial and spiritual care or their attitudes towards the necessity of family support although there was positive impact on other aspects of palliative care. Conclusions Knowledge of palliative care among Chinese nurses remains low. Training programs may improve general knowledge and attitudes to palliative care. However, important aspects of knowledge such as communication skills, family support, and psychosocial aspects of care, are missing. These gaps should be filled in future palliative care training programs targeting nurses with oriental culture background.
... All nurses, regardless which departments they are working at, are expected to understand the palliative care approach from their basic training these days. They are recommended to be exposed to education about palliative care during their initial training in school to understand what palliative care is (29). However, there is a lack of initial preparation of Chinese nursing students as palliative care education and placement in hospice are still missing from our nursing schools. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Background: Most nurses in China have not been trained to take care of end-of-life patients appropriately due to lack of educational resources and insufficient training. A palliative care program was launched by the Jiangsu Nursing Association (JNA training program) and to identify gaps in palliative care training. The main aims of this study were to evaluate the training effects of the JNA training program on nurses’ knowledge and attitudes to palliative care. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted with 10 048 registered nurses in all regions of Jiangsu. All participants completed an online questionnaire using the Chinese version of The Palliative Care Quiz for Nursing (PCQN-C) and the Frommelt Attitude Toward Care of the Dying scale (FATCOD-B-C). A propensity score matched analysis was performed between the nurses who had attended the JNA training program and whose who hadn’t. Results: The average score of PCQN-C among all nurses was 8.79, while the mean score of the FATCOD-B-C was 103.62. Those participants who attended the JNA training program had significantly better scores than those who did not. Propensity score matching analysis showed that the palliative care training program failed to improve nurses’ knowledge in psychosocial and spiritual care or their attitudes towards the necessity of family support although there was positive impact on other aspects of palliative care. Conclusions: Knowledge of palliative care among Chinese nurses remains low. Training programs may improve general knowledge and attitudes to palliative care. However, important aspects of knowledge such as communication skills, family support, and psychosocial aspects of care, are missing. These gaps should be filled in future palliative care training programs targeting nurses with oriental culture background.
... This is supported by findings from the case vignettes questions in the present study wherein participants indicated they would give less medication to a patient who smiles when reporting a pain score of 8/10 than a patient reporting the same pain score while grimacing. The inadequate level of both knowledge and positive attitudes about pain among nursing students is also supported by findings from studies using questionnaires other than the KASRP (Arber, 2001;Briggs, Carr, & Whittaker, 2011;Latchman, 2014;Ortiz et al., 2015;Watt-Watson et al., 2004). Studies that include case vignettes, semistructured interviews, and unpublished tools also report inadequate levels of both pain knowledge and positive attitudes (Briggs, 2010;Chiu, Trinca, Lim, & Tuazon, 2002;Hadjistavropoulos et al., 2015;Igier, Mullet, & Sorum, 2006;Lasch et al., 2002;Mackintosh-Franklin, 2014;Shaw & Lee, 2010;Watt-Watson, 1987). ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Poorly managed pain is a problem that affects individuals, entire health care systems, and societies worldwide. Nurses are involved in pain management, yet little is known about the knowledge and attitudes of nursing students. Aims: The aim of this study was to examine preregistration nursing students' knowledge and attitudes about the assessment and management of pain. Design: This was a cross-sectional, descriptive survey. Settings: Four education sites from two post-secondary institutions in Ontario, Canada. Participants/subjects: A convenience sample of 336 final year Bachelor of Science in Nursing and practical nursing students. Methods: Participants were recruited in the classroom setting to complete the Knowledge and Attitudes Survey Regarding Pain. A score of eighty percent is considered a pass. Results: Ninety percent of students who were in class on the day of the survey agreed to participate (n = 336/373). Fifteen (4.5%) participants passed the Knowledge and Attitudes Survey Regarding Pain, and the mean score was 66.7% (standard deviation 9.1). English as primary language, institution attended, and prior experience caring for someone with pain were independently associated with higher scores (p < .05). Students were found to have major gaps in knowledge and attitudes related to understanding the risk of respiratory depression after opioid therapy, calculating medication dosages, administrating medication, and understanding pharmacology. Conclusions: The majority of nursing students in this sample did not have adequate knowledge and positive attitudes about pain assessment and management.
... A recent systematic review [21] examined outcome measures in UPCE evaluation studies, with eleven studies conducted between 1990 and 2011 meeting the inclusion criteria (palliative care education evaluation, undergraduate medical students). Indicators for the effectiveness of UPCE programs were medical knowledge [23][24][25][26], attitudes related to palliative care [24,26,27] perception of confidence in issues related to palliative care [28,29], frequency of experiences in providing palliative care [26] and attitudes and emotional reactions towards death and dying [24,27,[30][31][32][33]. The authors conclude, that "no universally applicable validated questionnaire to assess the effectiveness of undergraduate palliative care education could be identified" and that "the increased focus by educational institutions on instilling palliative care skills in healthcare students necessitates the development of comprehensive and validated tools to evaluate the effectiveness of education initiatives" [21]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: The evaluation of the effectiveness of undergraduate palliative care education (UPCE) programs is an essential foundation to providing high-quality UPCE programs. Therefore, the implementation of valid evaluation tools is indispensable. Until today, there has been no general consensus regarding concrete outcome parameters and their accurate measurement. The Program in Palliative Care Education and Practice Questionnaire (German Revised Version; PCEP-GR) is a promising assessment tool for UPCE. The aim of the current study was to evaluate the psychometric properties of PCEP-GR and to demonstrate its feasibility for the evaluation of UPCE programs. Methods: The practical feasibility of the PCEP-GR and its acceptance in medical students were investigated in a pilot study with 24 undergraduate medical students at Heinrich Heine University Dusseldorf, Germany. Subsequently, the PCEP-GR was surveyed in a representative sample (N = 680) of medical students in order to investigate its psychometric properties. Factorial validity was investigated by means of principal component analysis (PCA). Reliability was examined by means of split-half-reliability analysis and analysis of internal consistency. After taking into consideration the PCA and distribution analysis results, an evaluation instruction for the PCEP-GR was developed. Results: The PCEP-GR proved to be feasible and well-accepted in medical students. PCA revealed a four-factorial solution indicating four PCEP-GR subscales: preparation to provide palliative care, attitudes towards palliative care, self-estimation of competence in communication with dying patients and their relatives and self-estimation of knowledge and skills in palliative care. The PCEP-GR showed good split-half-reliability and acceptable to good internal consistency of subscales. Attitudes towards palliative care slightly missed the criterion of acceptable internal consistency. The evaluation instruction suggests a global PCEP-GR index and four subscales. Conclusions: The PCEP-GR has proven to be a feasible, economic, valid and reliable tool for the assessment of UPCE that comprises self-efficacy expectation and relevant attitudes towards palliative care.
Chapter
Palliative Care entstand aus dem klinischen Bedürfnis, unheilbare und sterbende PatientInnen besser zu versorgen, und hat in den letzten 30 Jahren im Rahmen der modernen Palliativ- und Hospizbewegung weltweit eine enorme Entwicklung erfahren. Mit der akademischen Integration der Palliativmedizin als anerkanntes Fachgebiet und dem parallelen Aufkommen der evidenzbasierten Medizin steigen die Anforderungen an die Qualität der Forschungsmethodik in diesem Bereich. Das vorliegende Kapitel gibt einen Überblick über Assessmentmethoden in der Klinik und Lehre im Bereich Palliative Care. Es werden 3 Studien vorgestellt, die einen evidenzbasierten Assessmentansatz an einem universitären Zentrum für Palliativmedizin beschreiben. Die vorliegenden Studien bestätigen auch die Notwendigkeit einer verstärkten Integration wissenschaftlicher Evaluationsmethoden in die klinische Routine und Ausbildung im Bereich Palliative Care.
Article
Background To determine existing knowledge and attitude gaps about pain assessment and management in junior and senior nursing students at the University of Connecticut (UConn), School of Nursing, Storrs, CT. Methods Student nurses were recruited through in person presentation of the study in the classroom setting on three separate occasions over a 20-day period. An email with information included during the presentation as well as the link to the online survey were sent through the School of Nursing listserv. A flyer was attached in the initial email and shown to participants during the initial recruitment meeting. As an incentive, sixty students received gift cards at the study’s conclusion funded by a National Institute of Health CoEPE (Center of Excellence in Pain Education) grant awarded to the UConn School of Nursing. Results The majority of nursing students had the most difficulty with questions relating to pharmacology in pediatric pain management including proper dosages, drug ceilings, and proper medication uses. Surprisingly, juniors performed better than 4th and 5th year seniors when caring for hematology/oncology patients. However the differences were not statistically significant. Conclusions Overall, difficulty in questions related to pharmacology may be related to the timing in which the initial pharmacology course is taken, during the sophomore year, at UConn School of Nursing as well as the difficulty of the subject. One strength we found was a lack of bias in managing pediatric pain which we believe may be a result of baccalaureate education degree that includes additional courses related to the art of nursing in addition to the science.
Article
Yates et al (1996) provided a review of the literature on educational approaches to improving psychosocial care of terminally ill patients and their families and suggested that there was an urgent need for innovation in this area. A programme of professional development currently being offered to 181 palliative care nurses in Queensland, Australia, was also described. This paper presents research in progress evaluating this programme which involves use of a quasi-experimental pre-post test design. It also includes process and outcome measures to assess effectiveness in improving the participant's ability to provide psychosocial care to patients and families.
Article
Structured interviews of 37 medical inpatients being treated with narcotic analgesics for pain showed that 32% of the patients were continuing to experience severe distress, despite the analgesic regimen, and another 41% were in moderate distress. Chart review suggested significant undertreatment with narcotics: meperidine in doses of 50 mg every 3 to 4 hours or less (if needed) was prescribed for 63% of the 37 patients; a dose of more than 75 mg was prescribed for only 1 patient. The average amount actually received per day by the patients was 90 mg. A questionnaire survey of 102 house staff physicians in two New York teaching hospitals showed considerable misinformation about meperidine. Many physicians underestimated the effective dose range, overestimated the duration of action, and exaggerated the dangers of addiction for medical inpatients receiving meperidine in a therapeutic dosage range. Physicians who exaggerated the dangers of addiction were more likely to prescribe lower doses of drugs, even for patients with terminal malignancy. The authors suggest that such misconceptions probably lead to undertreatment with narcotic analgesics, causing much needless suffering in medical inpatients.
Article
A survey of medical students and junior doctors shows a lack of training and knowledge in the care of dying patients and symptom control. The need for an increased emphasis on this training is identified.
Article
Pain is often the most prevalent symptom among cancer patients referred to hospice or palliative care programs. This study was designed to use performance-based testing to evaluate the skills of hospice nurses in assessing the severe pain of a cancer patient and the pain management recommendations they would present to the patient's primary care physician. Twenty-seven hospice nurses (ranging in experience from 1 month to 10 years) were presented with the same standardized patient with cancer pain. In Part A (7 minutes), one of the investigators checked for predetermined behaviors as the nurses performed the clinical pain assessment. In Part B (7 minutes), the nurses answered questions regarding their recommendations for pain management for the patient seen in Part A. In the admission pain assessment, hospice nurses did well in assessing pain intensity (85%), pain location (70%), and pain-relieving factors (59%). However, only 48% of the nurses adequately assessed the pain onset, and only 44% adequately assessed other symptoms the patient might be experiencing. In Part B, 96% of the nurses recommended opioids, 96% recommended the oral route of administration, and 82% recommended regular dosing of the opioids. Fifty-six percent of nurses included a breakthrough medication in their analgesic recommendations. All of the hospice nurses treated the patient's fear of addiction in an appropriate manner, and 93% of the nurses recommended increasing the patient's opioid dosage to treat the persisting pain problem. There were no significant differences among nurses with regard to length of time as a hospice nurse or hospice certification on any of the items in either Part A or Part B. Most practicing hospice nurses were judged to be competent in the assessment and management of the severe pain of the standardized cancer patient, although some deficits were noted. Regular oral opioids were the analgesics of choice. Co-analgesics were rarely recommended.
Article
A questionnaire survey was carried out of all general practitioners, community hospital nurses and community nurses working in Worcester Health District in the west of England, to assess the present state and future needs of their education in palliative care. The overall response rate of the survey was 72%. The respondents were an experienced group of doctors and nurses. They felt that their undergraduate or basic training did not prepare them to care for dying patients in the community. Educational needs were identified: control of symptoms other than pain and bereavement care were priorities for doctors. Community hospital nurses rated pain control education as a major need. Alternative medicine and caring for dying children were additional areas for further education for the general practitioner and community nurses. Ninety per cent of general practitioners, 84% of community hospital nurses and 95% of community nurses felt that multi-disciplinary teaching sessions would be helpful. Analysis of their responses revealed that these would be most likely to succeed it they were arranged in the middle of the day during lunch or in the evenings. The doctors felt that they lacked protected learning time. Nurses also felt this, but in addition, identified lack of finance as a limiting factor in their post-basic education. There was evidence that existing educational resources in the district are under-utilized.
Article
This paper reports a study which aimed to develop an understanding of newly registered nurses' attitudes, knowledge, confidence and educational needs in relation to cancer care. An educational intervention designed to meet these nurses' needs was then developed and evaluated with 127 newly registered nurses from two general hospitals. Nurses attended two different educational interventions; one group of nurses completing a 3 day experiential workshop; and a second group attended a more formal seminar programme. A third group of nurses who were unable to obtain study leave were followed up as a control group. A triangulation strategy was used to collect data from different sources, and included a baseline study, and a study of nurses before, after and 3 months following the educational interventions. Data from the study revealed the perceived need and desire for more education on cancer care, and the strong association of cancer with death amongst newly registered nurses. Significant benefits to those nurses attending the workshop were demonstrated. These differences were however less obvious at 3 months follow-up.
Article
Inadequate knowledge of opioid analgesic drugs and the incidence of psychological dependence are major barriers to nursing management of patients in pain. This study analyzed data obtained from 27 workshops on pain across 14 states (2,459 nurses) to determine current nursing knowledge of pharmacological management of pain. Results indicate that nurses lack knowledge in classification of opioids ranging from 23 to 98% correct response across seven analgesic drugs. Less than 25% of nurses correctly identified the frequency of psychological dependence. Further analysis revealed significant differences in basic versus advanced learners and geographical differences in knowledge. Implications are made for nursing education and practice.
Article
In 1983, a small descriptive study looking at the distressing symptoms of 26 terminally ill patients (dying from malignant as well as non-malignant disease) was carried out at two different hospitals before the setting up of a hospital support team. Fifty-two nurses involved in the care of these patients were also interviewed, using a taped, semi-structured interview. Nurses generally found caring for the terminally ill rewarding, but first-year nurse learners found coping with their emotions difficult. The senior nurses would have liked more teaching on pain control and care of relatives. Support of nursing staff was seen to be better in wards where the nursing process was being practised.