ArticlePDF Available

Epithelioma of Malherbe: New ultrasound patterns

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Calcifying epithelioma of Malherbe, or Pilomatricoma, is considered an uncommon cutaneous neoplasia, normally occurring in children as a solitary, firm, asymptomatic, hard, subcutaneous, slowly growing nodule on the face, neck, or proximal upper extremity. In literature, two Pilomatricoma ultrasound patterns are described: the totally calcified nodule and the hypoechoic nodule with internal calcific foci. High frequency ultrasound has not yet been applied for routine diagnosis of Pilomatricoma. The aim of the study was to retrospectively identify specific ultrasound features. We retrieved 124 histologically Pilomatricoma cases: 28 patients with 32 lesions were preoperatively evaluated with ultrasound. 22/32 have shown a solid formation, hypoechoic, with a sharp outline. Of these 22, 10 lesions were completely calcifying and 12 partially calcified. In 3/32 lesions with uncertain diagnosis, ultrasounds showed a complex/mixed pattern with pseudo-fluid areas and microspots. 7/32 lesions with US different diagnosis included 3 complex lesions, 2 cystic lesions and 2 solid nodular lesions. In addition to well-known ultrasound patterns (completely calcified and partially calcified) we identified three new, not yet described, patterns that constitute the 31% of the cases: complex, pseudocystic and pseudotumoral.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Open Access
RESEARCH
BioMed Central
© 2010 Solivetti et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in
any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Research
Epithelioma of Malherbe: new ultrasound patterns
Francesco M Solivetti*
1
, Fulvia Elia
1
, Alessandra Drusco
1
, Chiara Panetta
2
, Ada Amantea
2
and Aldo Di Carlo
3
Abstract
Backround: Calcifying epithelioma of Malherbe, or Pilomatricoma, is considered an uncommon cutaneous neoplasia,
normally occurring in children as a solitary, firm, asymptomatic, hard, subcutaneous, slowly growing nodule on the
face, neck, or proximal upper extremity. In literature, two Pilomatricoma ultrasound patterns are described: the totally
calcified nodule and the hypoechoic nodule with internal calcific foci. High frequency ultrasound has not yet been
applied for routine diagnosis of Pilomatricoma. The aim of the study was to retrospectively identify specific ultrasound
features.
Methods: We retrieved 124 histologically Pilomatricoma cases: 28 patients with 32 lesions were preoperatively
evaluated with ultrasound.
Results: 22/32 have shown a solid formation, hypoechoic, with a sharp outline. Of these 22, 10 lesions were completely
calcifying and 12 partially calcified. In 3/32 lesions with uncertain diagnosis, ultrasounds showed a complex/mixed
pattern with pseudo-fluid areas and microspots. 7/32 lesions with US different diagnosis included 3 complex lesions, 2
cystic lesions and 2 solid nodular lesions.
Conclusion: In addition to well-known ultrasound patterns (completely calcified and partially calcified) we identified
three new, not yet described, patterns that constitute the 31% of the cases: complex, pseudocistyc and
pseudotumoral.
Background
Calcifying Epithelioma of Malherbe - or Trichomatri-
coma, Pilomatricoma, Pilomatrixoma (PM) - is an
uncommon tumour [1], with an incidence of 1/800-1000
cutaneous tumours and about 20 new reports per year
[2,3], affecting predominantly women. It is more com-
mon at a young age, especially in the first two decades of
life, with an onset below 10 years in 40% of cases [4,5].
Although multiple localizations have been described in
literature [6,7], PM occurs as a solitary lesion on the face
(47% of cases), neck [8] and upper trunk and can be asso-
ciated to other diseases, e.g. Steinert's Myotonic Dystro-
phy and Gardner Syndrome [4,7,9,10].
Recent studies have shown that recurrent activating
mutations in the ss-catenina gene (CTNNB1), induce PM
tumourigenesis through activation of the WNT signalling
pathway [11,12]. Despite the benign biological behaviour
of the majority of cases, the treatment is still surgical.
However, in recent years, aggressive cases with local post-
surgery recurrences or metastasis have been described
[2,3,13,14], accounting for variable percentage rates in lit-
erature, with 6 cases out of 228 in the Forbis series [6].
According to some authors [13], local recurrences are
related to tumour aggressiveness, while for others, these
cases are only associated with an incomplete surgical
excision [15].
The tumour presents as a slow growing subcutaneous
mass, sometimes dark on the surface, with well-defined
borders and, often, with lobulated contours at ultrasound.
The size of the tumour is usually small, less than one cm,
but, in the Darwish series, 3 out 26 had more than 2 cm
lesions and 11 out of 26 had 11 - 20 mm lesions [16].
Histologically, the lesion appears as a well defined nod-
ule, often calcified and inflamed, sometimes reproducing
a granulomatous reaction. It originates from the matrix
cells of the hair follicle, having a basaloide appearance,
composed of anucleated eosinophilic cells (shadow or
ghost cells) which are typical of trichilemmal keratiniza-
tion [17].
* Correspondence: solivetti@tiscalinet.it
1 Struttura di Radiologia e Diagnostica per Immagini, Istituto Dermosifilopatico
di Santa Maria e San Gallicano-IFO-Roma, Italy
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Page 2 of 7
The clinical diagnosis is often difficult: in a recent
series, most of the cases were clinically confused with
sebaceous cysts [16] and, in the Pirouzmanesh series,
only 100 out 346 (28,9%) cases were correctly diagnosed
as PM [18].
In a survey where "soft rays" were employed, data did
not discriminate among the different pathologies [19].
Although the finding of a nodular calcified lesion in chil-
dren, should address the clinical diagnosis to PM [20],
classic X-ray, ultrasound and CT scan do not allow a dif-
ferential diagnosis with dermatofibroma, epidermoid
cyst, lipoma, sebaceous calcified cyst, fibrocalcified
lymphadenitis, foreign body granuloma, chronic abscess
or organized hematoma [18,21].
Moreover, FNAB has shown a significant number of
false positives and negatives [22] and MRI is considered
inconclusive [23]: in the Lim series [20], out of 5 cases
considered, only 60% were diagnosed correctly.
Therefore, it is necessary to identify a diagnostic imag-
ing technology to assure a correct diagnostic hypothesis.
High-frequency ultrasound [24] is a very simple, reli-
able imaging technique, yet poorly reported in literature
and in numerically limited series [19]. Hughes et al. [25]
presented a cohort of 28 clinically suspected PM cases,
diagnosed employing a relatively low frequency probe (7
MHz). 20 patients underwent surgery and were evaluated
histologically: 16 were confirmed as PM, 2 were epider-
moid cysts and, in 2, it was not possible to asses any diag-
nosis. Similar data have been reported by Ulrich et al.
[26], Lim el al. [20], Hwang el al. [27] and Whittle el al.
[28]; Buchwald et al. [29] diagnosed one case of PM using
ultrasound microscopy. In the Whittle series [28], typical
PM sonographic features were characterized by a
hypoechoic small superficial nodule (between epidermis
and dermis), with not always well-defined margins, with
some calcified areas (98% of this series) of variable
appearance, formed of central or peripheral single or
grouped foci of variable shapes [24]. The lesion was
sometimes surrounded by a hypoechoic halo and some-
times perilesional Doppler flow signals were present.
So far, two different PM sonographic patterns have
been described in literature: the totally calcified nodule
and the hypoechoic nodule with internal calcified foci.
Conducting a retrospective study of our cases, the
paper aims to identify high-frequency ultrasound pat-
terns of PM that should improve clinical diagnosis.
Methods
Images of 124 patients with a histological diagnosis of PM
were retrieved from the 1996-2008 archive of the Der-
matopathology Unit of our Institute. Pre-operatory ultra-
sound images of 28/124 patients were available. In order
to avoid the comparison of two inhomogeneous groups,
we only analyzed data of these 28 patients (with 32
lesions and 5 different locations on one patient), whose
clinical records were complete.
Fourteen females and 14 males, aged between 12 and 58
years, were considered in the study. Three different
Esaote ultrasound units (Genoa, Italy) were sequentially
used during the period 1996-2008: respectively, AU4
apparatus with 20-MHz Anular Array, single crystal
probe, an AU5 apparatus, with the same probe, and,
lastly, a My Lab 70, with linear probe having a maximum
rated frequency of 18 MHz, completed of colour, power
and pulsed Doppler.
Only in two cases, with unclear ultrasonographic fea-
tures, was the study also performed with contrast
medium (Sono Vue © Bracco, Milano, Italy), employing a
multi-frequency linear probe (7-12 MHz); in all cases,
retrospectively, the images were jointly discussed by
Radiologists of our group.
Finally, data were analyzed using a statistical package
IBM SPSS, limited by an obvious lack in the numbers of
the cohort and the control group. Statistical analysis of
data was performed by means of Mc Neman's test for
binomial data to assess differences in sensitivity and spec-
ificity.
Results
We reviewed 32 high-frequency ultrasound images of 28
patients (one patient had 5 lesions). Three different ultra-
sound units have been used sequentially during the
period 1996-2008. The first two types of equipment, AU4
and AU5, which had the same probe, did not show any
relevant image quality difference. Although using a
slightly lower frequency with respect to the previous ones
(18 MHz versus 20 MHz), the third apparatus, a My
Lab70, showed a better image quality when the lesion size
was compatible to the piezoelectric crystal resolution
power.
The size of the 32 lesions ranged from 3 to 22 mm. In
particular, 2 cases exceeded 20 mm, 6 were between 10
and 20 mm and the remaining 24 were smaller than 10
mm.
Table 1: Locations of pilomatricomas
Localization No. of lesions
Head 20
Upper extremity 8
Neck 2
Wrist 1
Trunk 1
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Page 3 of 7
In 20 cases, the lesions were localized on the head, 2 on
the neck, 8 on the forearm, in 1 case on the wrists and
one on the back (Table 1 - Location of pilomatricoma).
We compared each clinical ultrasonographic diagnosis
to the respective definitive histopathological response of
the lesions. 22/32 cases (69%) were correctly diagnosed as
PM, 7/32 cases (22%) were misdiagnosed and in 3/32
cases (9%), it was not possible to assess any diagnostic
hypothesis with ultrasound.
In 4 cases, vascular signals were visible with colour and
power Doppler; this feature was usually peripheral and
only rarely intra-lesional, and was observed in lesions
larger than 10 mm. The apparatus setting was that gener-
ally used for superficial lesions at low flow speed. Tumour
locations were always superficial, between the dermis and
subcutaneous tissue. Our ultrasound images, obtained
with high-frequency probes, in all correctly diagnosed
cases, showed solid, hypoechoic, and sharp rimmed
lesions: 10 were fully calcified (Fig. 1) and 12 partially cal-
cified (Fig. 2); 5 of the latter had only calcified
microspots. In 4 cases, a perilesional peripheral
hypoechoic halo was also observed.
In 3 uncertain diagnosed cases, a complex ultrasound
lesion (mixed pattern) was found, with mixed fluid and
solid areas, scattered microcalcifications, and some sig-
nals to the colour Doppler (Fig. 3). The 7 misdiagnosed
cases included 3 mixed pattern lesion, 2 cystic-like (Fig.
4) and 2 solid, vascularised nodules with irregular con-
tours (Fig. 5) (Table. 2-US findings of pilomatricomas).
Figure 6 shows a detail of the histological pattern of these
tumor.
Finally, 2 lesions, with pseudo-neoplastic features, were
also studied with a second generation contrast medium
(SonoVue, Bracco, Milan, Italy), injected via a bolus in the
antecubital vein, and showed moderate enhancement of
the lesion and the presence of rather irregular internal
vessels. The most experienced radiologist (30 years of
general ultrasound and 11 of dermatological ultrasound),
Figure 1 Pattern type 1: nodulation fully calcified, no longer evaluable.
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Page 4 of 7
assessed a correct diagnosis in 11/15 cases (74%), misdi-
agnosed in 2/15 cases (13%) and provided a non conclu-
sive response in the remaining 2/15 cases (13%). There
were no significant differences (p = ns) among experi-
enced and less experienced radiologists in diagnosing
PM.
Due to the small size of the lesions and to the need for
immediate surgical treatment, none of our patients were
studied by CT scan or MRI.
Only 1 case of multiple PM (5 lesions in the same
patient) was found, and the genetic examination excluded
the coexistence of myotonic dystrophy.
Discussion
PM is an uncommon cutaneous tumour affecting young
adults, especially women. It originates from the matrix
cells of the hair follicle.
Figure 2 Pattern type 2: partially calcified nodulation, mostly sol-
id, hypoechogenic, with well defined borders, and coarse calcifi-
cations.
Figure 3 Pattern type 3: complex nodulation, with undetectable contours, with fluid and macrocalcified areas. The lesion presents well de-
fined borders. B) Histologic section at low power. The proliferation is surrounded by connectival stroma, and is edged by a basaloid epithelia with
tricholemmal and shadow cells, associated to a moderate inflammatory reaction (E-E1, 25x).
Figure 4 Pattern type 4: A)Pseuso-cystic, Lesion borders and sizes
are not well evaluable. Fluid nodule with feature similar to a thick-
ened wall cyst, extending up to the derma.
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Page 5 of 7
Despite their benign behaviour, very malignant forms
have been reported in literature. So far, most of the stud-
ies have revealed the difficulties encountered in diagnos-
ing PM clinically. Imaging techniques such as X-ray, CT
scan, MRI, and FNAB have failed to differentiate PM
from other pathologies. Ultrasounds have only been of
significant use in detecting bigger lesions, and most of the
authors evaluated images obtained from low-frequency
ultrasound (7.5-10 MHz). Since the probe resolution
power is a direct proportional function of the frequency
used, a very high frequency must be employed to charac-
terize small lesions such as PM. In particular, the follow-
ing data, provided from the Esaote Research Centre of
Genoa, concerning the real experimental resolution
power of their manufactured ultrasonographic probes:
7.5 MHz linear probe: axial resolution 0.2, lateral resolu-
tion 0.25; 10 MHz linear probe: axial resolution 0.154, lat-
eral 0.187; 13 MHz linear probe: axial resolution 0.188,
lateral resolution 0.144; 18 MHz linear probe: axial reso-
lution 0.085, lateral resolution 0.104; 20 MHz annular
array: axial resolution 0.077, lateral resolution 0.094.
In our study, we have reviewed 32 series of images
obtained from high-frequency ultrasound units and have
found 5 sonographic patterns to differentiate PM from
other subcutaneous tumours. In particular, Type 1 and 2
of our classification correspond to the two typical
hypoechoic solid nodules, fully calcified and partially cal-
cified respectively, already described in literature. These
lesions normally present a hypoechoic peripheral rim in a
significant number of cases, and rarely, vascular signals
with colour Doppler.
In our series, 22 lesions exhibited the solid and calcified
patterns of type 1 (10 cases) and 2 (12 cases), and diagno-
sis was confirmed at histopathology.
Eight cases (25%) of our series showed internal fluid
areas with a thick-wall: 6 complex lesions (type 3) and 2
pseudo-cystic (type 4). Type 4 fluid areas were larger than
type 3 and showed a good transmission of the ultrasound
wave, without enhancement of the posterior wall. Histo-
logically, the pseudo-cystic lesions showed huge groups
of ghost cells, without stroma, clearly correlated to the
sonographic features.
Lim et al. [20] described 2 cases out of 17 with little
endotumoural liquid-like areas, which the author, and,
more recently, Choo et al. [30], considered to be related
to degenerative phenomena. We are the first to report the
occurrence of real ultrasonographic cystic areas in PM.
As pointed out by some dermatopathologists [31], the
tumour originates from a cystic formation of the follicle
matrix, with more or less thick walls, depending on the
neoplasia evolvement, and with consequential formation
of an internal mass of shadow cells, with low vascularisa-
tion and almost absent stroma. Generally, calcifications
and signs of inflammation appear belatedly.
The homogeneity of pseudo-cystic fluid areas, the lack
of internal interfaces and of fibrous support structures,
the absence of internal signs with colour Doppler, but
without enhancement of the posterior wall, might
address the operator to an erroneous diagnosis. The
resemblance of sonographic features to so-called seba-
ceous cysts (epidermal or trichilemmal cysts), might
result from the very high frequency probes that we first
used in this particular type of dermopathology. Two
cases, with a tumour-like pattern (type 5), were indistin-
guishable from an aggressive neoplasia of the superficial
structures; in both patients, the lesions were significantly
old and, histologically, displayed chronic flogistic phe-
nomena and fibrosis.
Conclusion
Based on the above, some remarks can be drawn:
Figure 5 Pattern type 5: Pseudo-neoplastic, solid nodulation, hy-
poechogenic, not homogeneous, with irregular anterior contours,
with signal with Colour and Power-Doppler.
Figure 6 Shadow cell and thricholemmal keratinization details,
interspersed inflammatory cells (E-E 20×).
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Page 6 of 7
1 -Using very high frequency probes, we have identified
five different ultrasound patterns of PM. Pattern type 3, 4
and 5 have never been described before, not even in the
recent paper of Choo et al. [30].
This finding constitutes a new important contribution
that deserves to be promptly shared with other specialists
working in the field:
• type 1, 31.5% of cases; nodule fully calcified, semi-
superficial with minimal solid hypoechoic peripheral
ring, with an average size of 11 mm (Fig. 1);
• type 2, 37.5% of cases; nodule partially calcified, with
internal calcareous formations, of variable size (average
diameter of 10 mm), with a solid hypoechoic peripheral
component, avascular (Fig. 2);
• type 3, complex formation; 19% of cases (Fig. 3);
type 4, 6% of cases; pseudocystic formation, without
enhancement of the posterior wall, with semi thick walls
(Fig. 4)
• type 5, 6% of cases; pseudo-neoplastic nodules; the
inflammatory phenomena seemed to justify the pattern
(Fig. 5).
2-As described in literature, the diagnostic accuracy of
an experienced operator is very high for "classic" forms,
but it is lower for the three new patterns.
3-There were no differences in the evaluation of the
features of the images among less experienced and expert
radiologists. This evidence could be explained by the rel-
atively high incidence of lesions with non-classical pat-
terns encountered in our series.
4-We used higher resolution apparatus, that certainly
permitted good performances in the diagnosis of the
"classic" forms, but showed better results in discriminat-
ing the peculiar characteristics of pattern 3, 4 and 5.
However, more cases would be needed to evaluate the
real incidence of those new patterns.
5-Although our results showed only 69% of correct
diagnosis compared to 96% (50/52) of Whittle et al. [28]
and 82% of Lim et al. [20] (17/18), we reached 100% when
considering only the "classic" forms (pattern 1 and 2),
which are really easily diagnosable with ultrasounds.
6-In agreement with Choo et al. [30], and for the few
cases we studied, the colour-power Doppler and the sec-
ond generation contrast media did not seem to give sig-
nificant diagnostic advantages. In conclusion, we believe,
that the knowledge of these three new patterns, not pre-
viously described, could help in the clinical diagnosis of
pilomatricoma, and, consequently, in the diagnostic and
therapeutic management of this type of neoplasia.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
FE and AD carried out the research, participated in the sequence alignment
and drafted the manuscript text. CP and AA assessed the pathological diagno-
sis. ADC contributed with his professional experience to the revision of the
manuscript. FMS conceived the study, participated in its design, carried out the
research and coordinated the study. All authors read and approved the final
manuscript.
Author Details
1Struttura di Radiologia e Diagnostica per Immagini, Istituto Dermosifilopatico
di Santa Maria e San Gallicano-IFO-Roma, Italy, 2Struttura di Dermopatologia,
Istituto Dermosifilopatico di Santa Maria e San Gallicano-IFO-Roma, Italy and
3Direttore Scientifico, Istituto Dermosifilopatico di Santa Maria e San Gallicano -
IFO-Roma, Italy
References
1. Malherbe A, Chenantais J: Note sur l'epithèlioma calcifiè des glandes
sèbacée. Prog Me d 8(826):1880.
2. Harbon S, Choisnard S, Carbillet JP, Agache P, Laurent R: Ricbourg B.
Epithélioma calcifié de Malherbe. Revue dequatrevingts cas. Ann Chir
Plast Esthét 1990, 35(4):277-82.
3. Niedermeyer HP, Peris K, Hofler H: Pilomatrix carcinoma with multiple
visceral metastases. Cancer 1996, 77(7):1311.
4. Berberian BJ, Colonna TM, Battaglia M, Sulica VI: Multiple pilomatricomas
in association withmyotonic dystrophy. J Am Acad Dermatol 1997,
37:268.
5. Nield DV, Saad MN, Ali MH: Aggressive Pilomatrixoma in a child: a case
report. Br J Plast Surg 1986, 39:139.
6. Forbis R, Helwig EB: Pilomatrixoma. Arch Dermatol 1961, 83:606.
7. Sherrod QJ, Chiu MW, Gutierrez M: Multiple pilomatricomas: cutaneous
marker for myotonic dystrophy. Dermatol Online J 2008, 14(7):22.
8. Taaffe A, Wyatt EH, Bury HP: Pilomatricoma (Malherbe). A clinical and
hystopatologic survey of 78 cases. Int J Dermatol 1988, 27:477.
9. Pujol RM, Casanova JM, Egido R, Pujol J, de Moragas JM: Multiple familial
pilomatricomas: a cutaneous marker for Gardner Sindrome? Pediatr
Dermatol 1995, 12(4):331.
10. Harper PS: Calcifying epithelioma of Malherbe. Association with
myotonic muscular dystrophy. Arch Dermatol 1972, 106:41.
11. Kazakov DV, Sima R, Vanecek T, Kutzner H, Palmedo G, Kacerovska D,
Grossmann P, Michal M: Mutation in exon 3 of the CTNNB1 gene (beta-
catenin gene) in cutaneous adnexal tumours. Am J Dermatopathol
2009, 31(3):248-55.
Received: 11 February 2010 Accepted: 6 May 2010
Published: 6 May 2010
This article is available from: http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42© 2010 Solivetti et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.Journal of Experiment al & Clini cal Cance r Research 2010, 29:42
Table 2: US findings of pilomatricomas
Type US features No. of lesions
Type 1 Fully calcified 10
Type 2 Partially calcified 12
Type 3 Complex lesion 6
Type 4 Pseudocystic lesion 2
Type 5 Pseudotumoural 2
Solivetti et al. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
http://www.jeccr.com/content/29/1/42
Page 7 of 7
12. Millar SE: Molecular mechanisms regulating hair follicle development.
J Invest Dermatol 2002, 118(2):216-25.
13. Detlefs RL: Pathology quiz case 2. Arch Dermatol 1984, 120:782.
14. Mir R, Cortes E, Papantoniou PA, Heller K, Muehlhausen V, Kahn LB:
Metastatic trichomatricial carcinoma. Arch Pathol Lab Med 1986,
110(7):660.
15. Vico P, Rahier I, Ghanem G, Nagypal P, Deraemaecker R: Pilomatrix
carcinoma. Eur J Surg Oncol 1997, 23(4):370.
16. Darwish AH, Al-Jalahema EK, Dhiman AK, Al-Khalifa KA:
Clinocopathological study of pilomatricoma. Saudi Med J 2001,
22(3):268.
17. Hashimoto T, Inamoto N, Nakamura K, Harada R: Involucrin expression in
the skin appendage tumours. Br J Dermatol 1987, 117(3):325.
18. Pirouzmanesh A, Reinish JF, Gonzalez-Gomez I, Smith EM, Meara JG:
Pilomatrixoma: a review of 346 cases. Plast Reconstr Surg 2003,
112(7):1784.
19. Rossi E, Carbone M, Iurassich S, Amodio F, Gatta G, Vallone G: Epitelioma
calcifico di Malherbe: correlazione tra segni clinici, reperti istologici e
immagini ecografiche in 4 casi. Radiol Med 1998, 96(4):410.
20. Lim HW, Im SA, Lim GY, Park HJ, Lee H, Sung MS, Kang BJ, Kim JY:
Pilomatricomas in children: imaging characteristics with pathologic
correlation. Pediatr Radiol 2007, 37(6):548.
21. Martino G, Braccioni A, Cariati S, Calvitti M, Veneroso S, Tombesi T, Vergine
M: Il pilomatricoma o epitelioma calcifico di Malherbe. Descrizione di
un caso e revisione della letteratura. G Chir 2000, 21(3):104.
22. Layfield LJ, Glasgow BJ: Aspiration biopsy cytology of primary
cutaneous tumours. Acta Cytol 1993, 37(5):679.
23. Hoffman V, Roeren T, Moller P, et al.: MR imaging of a pilomatrixoma.
Pediatr Radiol 1998, 28:272.
24. Cammarota T: Ecografia in Dermatologia. Poletto Editore, Milano 1998.
25. Hughes J, Lam A, Rogers M: Use of ultrasonography in the diagnosis of
childhood pilomatrixoma. Pediatr Dermatol 1999, 16:341.
26. Ulrich J, Wesarg I: High-frequency ultrasound in the diagnosis of
pilomatrixoma. Pediatr Dermatol 2001, 18(2):163.
27. Hwang JY, Lee SW, Lee SM: The common ultrsonographic features of
pilomatricoma. JUltrasound Med 2005, 24(10):1397.
28. Whittle C, Martinez W, Baldassare G, Smoje G, Bolte K, Busel D, González S:
Pilomatrixoma: ultrasound diagnosis. Rev Med Chil 2003, 131(7):735.
29. Buchwald HJ, Spraul CW, Kampmeier J, Lang GK: Ultrasound
biomicroscopy in eyelid lesions - a clinical study in 30 patients. Klin
Monatsbl Augenheilkd 2002, 219:95.
30. Choo HJ, Lee SJ, Lee YH, Lee JH, Oh M, Kim MH, Lee EJ, Song JW, Kim SJ,
Kim DW: Pilomatricomas: the diagnostic value of ultrasound. Skel
Radiol 2010, 39:243-250.
31. Ackerman AB, De Viragh PA, Chongchitnant N: Neoplasm with follicular
differentiation. Lea &Febiger, Philadelphia 1993, cap 21:477.
doi: 10.1186/1756-9966-29-42
Cite this article as: Solivetti et al., Epithelioma of Malherbe: new ultrasound
patterns Journal of Experimental & Clinical Cancer Research 2010, 29:42
... Among skin focal lesions, pilomatricoma, also known as calcifying epithelioma of Malherbe or trichomatricoma, is a benign tumor derived from the matrix cells of the hair follicles. [3][4][5] It is predominantly found in females during childhood and youth, but can also occur in adults. [3][4][5] Pilomatricoma is typically identified through inspection and palpation when a patient presents with a soft-tissue swelling. ...
... [3][4][5] It is predominantly found in females during childhood and youth, but can also occur in adults. [3][4][5] Pilomatricoma is typically identified through inspection and palpation when a patient presents with a soft-tissue swelling. Further evaluation is often conducted using high-frequency (7 to 15 MHz) ultrasound (HFUS) associated with color Doppler flow imaging (CDFI). ...
... Further evaluation is often conducted using high-frequency (7 to 15 MHz) ultrasound (HFUS) associated with color Doppler flow imaging (CDFI). 1,4 On color Doppler ultrasound, pilomatricoma exhibits diverse echogenic patterns. [4][5][6][7] While pilomatricomas with typical features evaluated using HFUS and CDFI demonstrate excellent diagnostic performance, misdiagnosis frequently occurs for pilomatricomas with atypical sonographic features. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Pilomatricoma has various manifestations on color Doppler ultrasound, and a differential diagnosis is challenging. The objective of this study was to investigate which characteristics of skin lesions on color Doppler ultrasound are effective in distinguishing pilomatricoma from epidermoid cyst and dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans. Materials and methods Records of patients with pilomatricomas (n = 63), epidermoid cysts (n = 76), and dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans (n = 19) who underwent color Doppler ultrasound evaluation and surgical excision were reviewed. The anatomical distribution and color Doppler ultrasound characteristics of these lesions were analyzed. The 63 pilomatricomas were categorized into five types based on their color Doppler ultrasound characteristics, and the roles of these five types in the differential diagnosis of the aforementioned diseases were studied. Results Pilomatricomas, epidermoid cysts, and dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans exhibited some similar characteristics. Dominantly markedly hyperechoic or hyperechoic appearance, posterior acoustic shadowing, and the presence of vascularity were the major characteristics of pilomatricomas. The pilomatricomas could be categorized into five types, with type II having a diagnostic performance of sensitivity of 65.08%, specificity of 98.95%, area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) of 0.743, positive predictive value of 97.62%, and negative predictive value of 81.03% for the diagnosis of the aforementioned skin diseases. Conclusion A combination of dominantly markedly hyperechoic or hyperechoic appearance, posterior acoustic shadowing, and the presence of vascularity exhibits higher diagnostic performance for the differential diagnosis of pilomatricomas, epidermoid cysts, and dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans.
... Son tumores benignos derivados de la matriz del pelo. Se denominan además pilomatricomas o epiteliomas calcificados de Malherbe (14). ...
... Although ultrasound is more accurate than CT and MRI in diagnosing subcutaneous masses, PMX is still challenging to definitively diagnose using ultrasound [5]. Solivetti et al. [25] described five US patterns to differentiate PMX from other subcutaneous tumors. ...
Article
Full-text available
Pilomatrixoma (PMX), also known as calcifying epithelioma of Malherbe, is a rare benign neoplasm that arises from the hair matrix cells, commonly in the head, neck, and upper trunk regions, infrequently affecting upper and lower extremities. It has to two peaks of presentation: under 20 years of age or between 50 and 65 years of age, slightly more common in females. The neoplasm exhibits diverse clinical manifestations and is frequently subject to misdiagnosis with alternative dermatological diseases. We present an atypical case of PMX affecting the upper extremity of a 62-year-old female patient. Surgical removal of the affected tissue under local anesthesia was performed, and subsequent histopathological analysis confirmed the presence of PMX. Based on the literature search we performed, we found out that this pathology is underreported in Jordan, with only one study published describing this tumor in the maxillofacial region. Physicians should be aware of this condition and its different presentations to include it in the differential diagnosis of suspected cases to provide the appropriate management and follow-up.
... Yi et al demonstrated that calcification inside lesions may be caused by calcium salt deposition or internal connective tissue hyperplasia, accompanied by calcification in the late stages of infection [17]. Second, US features of these lesions with calcification are all hypoechoic nodules associated with acoustic shadow and blood flows inside nodules, which can be misdiagnosed as calcified epithelioma [18,19]. In group A, 3 (2.3%) ...
Article
Aims: Ultrasound (US) findings of epidermoid cyst (EC) are complex and diverse. Cases of misdiagnoses are high when EC is accompanied by inflammation. The aim of this study was to analyze the features of US diagnosis of EC with inflammation and explore the characteristic images which can improve the accuracy of ultrasound diagnosis. Material and methods: A total of 241 cases were included and retrospectively analyzed. Complete clinical data of all cases were available. Lesions were examined by US before operation and the diagnosis was confirmed by histopathological examination. Based on pathological results ECs with/without acute and chronic inflammation and/or granuloma, all cases were divided into two groups: inflammation and non-inflammation group. The difference of clinical data and US features between groups was analyzed by univariate and multivariate logistic regression. Results: Analysis of skin color, length/thickness, shape, boundary, CDFI and US diagnosis accuracy showed statistical differences between the two groups (p<0.05). Multivariate logistic regression model showed that indistinct boundaries and color Doppler signal were more frequent than those in ECs without inflammation (OR=4.72, 5.89, p<0.05). Conclusion: Indistinct boundaries and color Doppler signal are important features for US diagnosis of EC with inflammation, which can help in improving the accuracy of diagnosis.
Article
Full-text available
Pilomatricomas (PM) are benign neoplasms that arise from hair follicle matrix cells. They are one of the most frequently excised pediatric skin masses. A typical clinical presentation is a slow growing, painless, firm, superficial mass in the head and neck of a child. We present a rare presentation of PM. A preschool aged girl presented with an enlarging scalp mass following a history of minor blunt trauma to the area. Two months prior, the child sustained a ground level fall and subsequently developed a painless “bump” at the site of injury on the scalp. The ``bump” was initially the size of a “mosquito bite” and enlarged to the size of a “ping pong ball”. Given the rapid progression and history of trauma, there was a broad differential diagnosis. An extensive workup including sonography, computed tomography, MRI, and biopsy were performed. The final pathologic diagnosis was confirmed as pilomatricoma. An atypical presentation of PM in a child can mimic a wide variety of pathology. Our case demonstrates unusual features of rapid enlargement and preceding trauma. With the widespread use of sonography for evaluation of superficial lesions, the radiologist may be the first to suspect the diagnosis of PM. Knowledge of the typical imaging findings in PM can be valuable, especially in more unusual cases.
Article
A 6‐year‐old, neutered, crossbreed, female dog was presented for a well‐defined subcutaneous mass on the head evolving for a year. An ultrasound exam revealed a well‐circumscribed, oval, heterogeneous and hyperechoic soft tissue mass, with hyperechoic internal foci, a hypoechoic peripheral rim, a cystic fluid component and a high vascularisation in colour Doppler. An isolated hair was also detected and removed from the fluid component. The mass was sampled and histological examination suggested a benign pilomatricoma. The owner declined further investigation and complete resection of the mass. This is the first report of ultrasonographic features of a pilomatricoma in a dog.
Article
Aim: To explore and compare the ultrasonic (US) features of pilomatricoma (PM) and epidermoid cyst (EC) in the differential diagnosis and improve the accuracy of US diagnosis of PM. Materials and methods: Three hundred and nine patients who underwent US examination before surgery with a histopathological diagnosis of PM or EC after surgery were analysed retrospectively. The patients were categorised into the training and validation sets according to the inspection times. Univariate analysis was undertaken on the US and clinical features of PM and statistically significant variables (p<0.05) were included in the multivariate logistic regression model to establish a diagnostic model. Results: The results demonstrated that the multivariate logistic regression model for PM was statistically significant (p<0.001). The risk factors included posterior echo attenuation and hypoechoic halos (odds ratio [OR] = 9.277, 10.254) and the protective factors included age, diameter thickness, and posterior echo enhancement (OR=0.936, 0.302, 0.156). The performance of the diagnostic model was tested using the training set (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve [AUC] = 0.974, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.955-0.994) and the validation set (AUC = 0.967, 95% CI = 0.926-1.000), which demonstrated good discriminant ability. Conclusions: The diagnostic accuracy for PM was higher than that for EC when the nodule is characterised by posterior echo attenuation, hypoechoic halos, smaller thickness, and younger age. The US diagnostic model developed may be used to guide the diagnosis of PM.
Chapter
This chapter reviews the ultrasonographic features of the most common benign nonvascular dermatologic tumors and pseudotumors. It comprises a broad range of pathologies, including cystic and solid lesions.The material is highlighted by clinical-ultrasonographic and histologic correlations with state-of-the-art images.KeywordsBenign dermatologic tumor ultrasoundDermatologic ultrasoundEpidermal cyst ultrasoundTrichilemmal cyst ultrasoundPilonidal cyst ultrasoundPilomatrixoma ultrasoundDermatofibroma ultrasoundPseudolymphoma ultrasound
Chapter
The particularities of performing high-frequency ultrasonography in children are explained. Sonographic features of a selection of disorders exclusive, more prevalent or characteristic of childhood are discussed, including benign and malignant neoplasms, hamartomas, inflammatory disorders, vascular lesions, developmental anomalies, foreign bodies, and hematomas. A clinico-histopathologic-sonographic correlation is offered for each disorder.KeywordsPilomatricomapilomatrixomaNeurofibromaHemangiomaVascular malformationPediatric
Article
Background: Pilomatrixoma is a benign tumor of the skin, preferentially found in children. The final diagnosis is made by biopsy. High resolution ultrasound (US) is a non invasive method for its diagnosis. Aim: To describe the US findings in children with pilomatrixoma. Material and methods: Fifty five patients with 62 clinically suspected pilomatrixomas were studied by US. All examinations were done with an ATL HDI 5000, linear 5-12 MHz transducer. Pathological study confirmed the diagnosis pilomatrixoma in 52 cases. Results: Fifty of 52 pilomatrixomas were diagnosed by US, with a sensitivity of 96%. The mean age of patients was 7.5 years. Forty seven lesions (90%) were located in the head, neck or upper extremities and their mean size was 8.5 mm. Thirty two lesions were hypodermal, 14 were dermohypodermal and 6 were dermal. In 44 lesions the contour was regular and non delineated, 44 lesions were oval, 41 lesions had an acoustic shadow, 36 were echogenic or hyperechogenic, 31 had a peripheral halo (60%), 55 had calcifications (98%), nine had perilesional vessels, 2 had intratumoral vessels and 7 had inflammatory changes. US excluded the diagnosis of pilomatrixoma in 10 lesions formulating a correct differential diagnosis in eight, with a specificity of 80%. Conclusions: Pilomatrixomas had two US types of presentation. The first is a well defined nodule with peripheral halo partially calcified or with microcalcifications. The second is a completely calcified nodule without peripheral halo and with a strong acoustic shadow. US is a useful, sensitive and specific diagnostic method for pilomatrixoma (Rev Méd Chile 2003; 131: 735-40)
Article
During a genetic study of myotonic dystrophy, seven individuals were found with histologically proven benign calcifying epitheliomas of Malherbe. In one family, mother and son were affected with both conditions; in another, two siblings were affected. Four patients had multiple tumors. No tumors were found in relatives without muscle disease. It is likely that the occurrence of calcifying epithelioma represents a further pleiotropic effect of the myotonic dystrophy gene; since this tumor is frequently mistaken clinically for a simple sebaceous cyst, its occurrence in myotonic dystrophy may be more common than is apparent.
Article
A 39-year-old man who was congenitally blind in his left eye presented with a 2-month history of progressive headaches, proptosis of the right eye, visual loss, anosmia, and double vision on superior gaze. Nasal endoscopy revealed submucosal swelling that had caused lateral displacement of the uncinate process. A gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance image (Figure 1) showed a large mass lesion arising from the floor of the anterior fossa, with extension into the right frontal lobe, paranasal sinuses, nasal cavity, and right orbit. The patient was taken to the operating room for nasal endoscopy with biopsy. After the uncinate process was removed, a large, whitish mass was observed completely replacing the ethmoid cells. Biopsy specimens were obtained. After a diagnosis was established, the patient underwent a craniofacial approach to the lesion via bifrontal craniotomy with orbital and nasal osteotomy for resection of the intracranial, paranasal sinus, and orbital tumor followed by anterior cranial fossa floor reconstruction with dural repair and pericranial flap.
Article
Previous studies suggested that mutant beta-catenin gene cells in cutaneous adnexal tumors with matrical differentiation contribute to their tumorigenesis. Except for pilomatricoma and pilomatrical carcinoma, only a handful of other cutaneous adnexal tumor types have been studied. DNA was extracted from 86 lesions including 17 proliferating tricholemmal and trichilemmal tumors, 15 trichoblastomas, 7 trichoadenomas, 4 pilomatricomas, 1 pilomatrical carcinoma, 4 basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) with shadow cells, 2 trichofolliculomas, 3 BCCs with sebaceous differentiation, 9 sebaceous adenomas, 6 sebaceomas, 14 sebaceous carcinomas (both ocular and extraocular forms), 2 gigantic horns, and 2 apocrine mixed tumors with shadow cells and subjected to polymerase chain reaction with newly designed primers encompassing glycogen synthase kinase-3beta phosphorylation sites of the CTNNB1 gene. Also, 3 craniopharyngiomas were studied. Sequenced polymerase chain reaction products for possible beta-catenin gene mutations showed a total of 8 alterations. These included 5 different point mutations, 3 of them identified in 2 different tumors: S23N (cribriform trichoblastoma), D32Y (pilomatricoma and craniopharyngioma), G34R (pilomatrical carcinoma and craniopharyngioma), S37F (2 BCCs with shadow cell differentiation), and G34V (craniopharyngioma). This study broadens the list of cutaneous adnexal tumors harboring CTNNB1 mutations and extends the listing of the mutations occurring in these neoplasms.
Article
The purpose of this study was to analyze statistically significant diagnostic factors for pilomatricoma on the basis of ultrasonographic features. Sonographic images were retrospectively reviewed from 44 pilomatricomas, and from 43 control subjects with other subcutaneous tumors. Two radiologists determined the tumoral shape, margin, echotexture, echogenicity, posterior shadowing, posterior enhancement, hypoechoic rim, internal calcification, and vascularity. The reliable diagnostic factors for pilomatricoma were hypoechogenicity (P < 0.001), heterogenicity (P < 0.05), internal calcification (P < 0.001), hypoechoic rim (P < 0.001), and posterior shadowing (P < 0.001). Scattered dots were the most common patterns of internal calcification. A combination of hypoechogenicity, heterogenicity, internal calcification of scattered-dot pattern, and a hypoechoic rim was a statistically significant difference between the two groups (P < 0.001; odds ratio, 21). The features of heterogeneous echotexture, internal echogenic foci in scattered-dot pattern, and a hypoechoic rim or posterior shadowing itself could be discriminative ultrasonographic criteria for differentiating pilomatricomas from other subcutaneous tumors.
Article
The authors present a series of 5 cases of cutaneous sebaceous neoplasms having "benign" architectural features (symmetry, sharp circumscription, smooth borders, pseudoencapsulation) but which simultaneously displayed atypical cytology including abnormal mitoses, high mitotic rates, and moderate-to-striking pleomorphism including bizarre cells. The patients included 4 females and 1 male, ranging in age at diagnosis from 49 to 72 years. All presented with a small solitary nodule (6-9 mm) on the forehead (2), chest wall (1), occiput (1), and shoulder (1). The lesions were surgically excised. There were no recurrences on follow-up ranging from 16 to 148 months (average 77 months). In none of the patients was there a history of internal malignancy before or after diagnosis of the cutaneous neoplasms. Of 3 tumors assessed immunohistochemically for the expression of DNA mismatch repair gene proteins, only one showed loss of MLH1 expression. This was the only tumor to contain numerous tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. Our report emphasizes the existence of rare sebaceous tumors that, despite a deceptively bland architectural appearance, discordantly exhibit a range of atypical cytological features more characteristic of either low-grade or even high-grade carcinomas. Whether such tumors should be classified as sebaceomas with atypia or sebaceous carcinomas is unclear at present. Further studies are needed to confirm their seemingly benign course as identified in this report, as are further investigations to clarify their association with Muir-Torre syndrome.
Article
We report an interesting case of multiple pilomatricomas (MPs) in a patient with myotonic dystrophy. Pilomatricoma (calcifying epithelioma of Malherbe) is a benign tumor of hair matrix derivation. It usually occurs as a solitary, firm, asymptomatic nodule on the face, neck, or proximal upper extremity. Most pilomatricomas have activating mutations in the ss-catenin gene (encoded by CTNNB1), leading to involvement of the WNT signaling pathway. The resulting gene product activates transcription leading to tumorigenesis [1]. Since the onset of MPs may precede the signs of myotonic dystrophy, they can serve as potential early cutaneous markers for this systemic disease.