ArticlePDF Available

EVALUATION AND ANALYSIS OF OCCUPATIONAL NOISE EXPOSURE IN AN AMASSED SAWMILL SITE

Authors:

Abstract

Modus operandi of wood processing machinery is characterized by high levels of noise which can affect the workers. This study evaluated and analyzed occupational noise exposure of sawmill operators in a sawmill session of a timber market in Ogidi, Anambra state of Nigeria on a recommended noise safety standard criterion by the Nigerian Environmental Standards and Regulation Enforcement Agency (NESREA). The range of the A-weighted equivalent sound pressure level (LAeq) obtained during the sawmill job operations was 85.8-99.7 dBA with a mean value of 95.6 dBA on idling of the machines and 99.3-112.3 dBA with a mean value of 107.1 dBA during the sawing operation. Analysis of the LAeq obtained on a typical noise levels scale showed 100% moderately quiet before and after the job operations and 100% very loud and uncomfortably loud on idling of the machines and sawing operations respectively during the job operation. The independent-samples t-test analyses between the observed noise level at the sawmills during the job operation and the recommended maximum permissible noise level exposure showed statistically significant difference at p< 0.05. The hazardous occupational noise level besetting the sawmill workers established in this study requires safety redress approach for safe work environment.
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
EVALUATION AND ANALYSIS OF OCCUPATIONAL NOISE EXPOSURE
IN AN AMASSED SAWMILL SITE
Adinife P. Azodo1*, Udeme V. Akpan 2, Tochukwu C. Mezue 3, Alexander I. Tyom 4
1, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Federal University of Agriculture, Abeokuta
2 Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria
3Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Federal Polytechnic Oko
4Department of Pure and Applied Physics, Federal University Wukari
Abstract
Modus operandi of wood processing machinery is characterized by high levels of noise which
can affect the workers. This study evaluated and analyzed occupational noise exposure of
sawmill operators in a sawmill session of a timber market in Ogidi, Anambra state of Nigeria
on a recommended noise safety standard criterion by the Nigerian Environmental Standards
and Regulation Enforcement Agency (NESREA). The range of the A-weighted equivalent
sound pressure level (LAeq) obtained during the sawmill job operations was 85.899.7 dBA
with a mean value of 95.6 dBA on idling of the machines and 99.3 112.3 dBA with a mean
value of 107.1 dBA during the sawing operation. Analysis of the LAeq obtained on a typical
noise levels scale showed 100% moderately quiet before and after the job operations and 100%
very loud and uncomfortably loud on idling of the machines and sawing operations respectively
during the job operation. The independent-samples t-test analyses between the observed noise
level at the sawmills during the job operation and the recommended maximum permissible
noise level exposure showed statistically significant difference at p< 0.05. The hazardous
occupational noise level besetting the sawmill workers established in this study requires safety
redress approach for safe work environment.
Keywords: wood, occupational noise, sawmill, exposure, safety
1. INTRODUCTION
Wood as an engineering material has found
its usefulness in its raw state and processed
form in many energy generation utilities
and construction industries. According to
Aruofor (2001), Nigeria is the largest
producer of wood in Africa with an annual
harvest of more than 100 million cubic
meters. This may be attributed to the heavy
dependency of most of the structural and
construction activities in the nation on the
wood resources (Aruofor, 2001). Wood by
nature is adaptable for multiple numbers of
domestic and industrial uses and
applications (Fuwape, 2001). The
maximization of wood potential and the
availability to the end user in commercial
quantity is only possible through
mechanical processes (Babalola et al.,
2018). Mechanical processing through the
use of machines makes wood available in
specific dimensions, sizes, and shapes
(Ohagwua and Ugwuishiwu, 2011). When
felled wood has been processed into beams
and planks, they are called lumber or
timber. The process of reducing wood logs
into desired specifications, grades and
marketable dimensions using sawmill
machinery useful to human societies is
termed sawmilling (Aina, 2006; Babalola et
al., 2018), This, of course, is the major
Journal of NIMechE Vol. 9 No. 2 pp 37-45
Printed in Nigeria
ISSN 2141-2987
Copyright@2019, The Nigerian Institution of Mechanical
Engineers (A Division of the Nigerian Society of Engineers)
37
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
economic activity of most sawmills
(Babalola et al., 2018).
Every workplace hasone or more prevailing
potential hazard associated with the
involved work process (Azodo and
Adejuyigbe, 2013; Azodoet al., 2018). In
sawmill industries, four types of sawmills
are basically used for the purpose of wood
log conversion to timbers. These include
band, dimensional swivel, rolling table, and
locally manufactured sawmills
(Kambuguet al., 2005 cited in Ssemanda,
2017). The characteristic and modus
operandi of wood processing machinery
coupled with the universal adoption of a
diesel engine for powering most machines
generate high levels of noise which can
influence the workers and the surroundings
(Agyeman-Prempeh, 2014; Owoyemi et
al., 2016). Sawmill machine elements,
cutter heads and circular saws operation
produce noise from structure vibration and
noise radiation of the workpiece or cutting
tool, mechanical resonance frequencies of
the machine frame, cutting tool rotation and
the workplace turbulence, fan dust and chip
removal air carrying systems (Owoyemi et
al., 2016). The hazardous nature of
occupational noise generated by wood
machinery is expressed in terms of the
exposure level and duration (Owoyemi et
al., 2016). Noise intensity and duration of
occupational noise exposure in the sawmill
environment are the volume of lumber and
the work characteristic done by the
machinery on a daily and weekly basis
(Koehncke, 1999; Owoyemi et al., 2016)
characteristically presented factors
affecting wood machinery noise emissions
under four categories as the timber features,
tooling, machine setting and system design.
The distinguishing peculiarity of sawmill
workers noise exposure from other
occupation with high noise potentials is that
most of them are entrepreneurs; as such
regulate their working hours themselves
and are scarcely aware of related
occupational health and safety standards
which predispose them to higher risks of
noise hazards (Odibo et al., 2018).Safety is
a vital and intricate factor to be considered
in the day to day work activities (Ismail et
al., 2010). Occupational health and safety
are interrelated and complementary as it
plays a vital role in the life of workers
(Buksh et al., 2018). Considering that
workers spend significant hours of the day
in their work environment noise
(Otoghileet al., 2018) it is imperative to
objectively and systematically keep under
surveillance the noise levels at the work
environment through reliable noise level
assessment at the workplace (Mika and
Józwik, 2016). Previous research works on
sawmill industries found in literature
considered assessment of noise exposure
intensity level (Ugbebor and Yorkor, 2015;
Adhikari and Sahu, 2016), control strategy
of sawmill noise (Vaishali et al., 2011),
safety approach observed by the sawmill
workers (Mburu and Kiiyukia, 2017;
Thepaksorn et al., 2018), effects of sawmill
noise on workers health (Chang and
Chang, 2009; Aremu et al., 2015; Aremu et
al., 2019), effects of safety intervention
practices (Odibo et al., 2018), and
prevalence of cumulative trauma disorders
risk (Adeyemi and Udo, 2016). There is no
known research found in the literature that
considered amassed sawmills in a location
operating almost at the same time.
Therefore, this study evaluated and
analyzed of occupational noise exposure of
sawmill operators in a sawmill sector of a
timber market in Ogidi, the Anambra state
of Nigeria on recommended standard
criteria.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was carried out in the sawmill
section of timber market Ogidi, Anambra
state, Nigeria. The timber market is located
on longitude 6.16° and latitude 6.86°. The
regulated daily kick off time of the business
activities in the timber market is from 7:30
am 5:30 pm Mondays - Saturdays. A total
of 31 sawmill survey sites were used for
this study. For each of the 31 sawmills,
ADINIFE P. AZODO1*, UDEME V. AKPAN 2, TOCHUKWU C. MEZUE 3, ALEXANDER I. TYOM 4
Evaluation and analysis of Occupational Noise Exposure in an Amassed Sawmill site
38
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
there were two to three operators/workers,
however, only one of the workers’ noise
exposure was assessed. Benetech Sound
Level Meter (SLM) type GM1352 was used
for the measurement of sound levels at-ear
of the operator. The sound level meter was
an internal calibrated sound level with an
accuracy of ±1.5 dB and 31.5 Hz 8 KHz
frequency response. The resolution setting
was 0.1 dB with a measuring range of 30
130 dB. The sound level of each of the
considered sawmill environment was
recorded before the commencement of each
day’s work activity (after 7:30 am) and
after the day’s work (before 5:30 pm).
Since the workers were moving during the
wood sawing operation, a purposefully
designed strap bag which served as the
SLM holder was used at the shoulder of the
workers. The maximum reading of the
SLM for the noise exposure level was
recorded at the idling time of the machines
and during the sawing operations. The SLM
noise exposure assessment was carried out
during the working hours. Each of the 31
sawmill survey sites used for this study
assessed sawmills was surveyed 20 times.
The varying noise levels obtained at each of
the assessed sawmills using the sound level
meter were computed to A-weighted
equivalent sound pressure level (LAeq) for a
single constant noise level value
representation of the total sound energy
being produced over the period of the
assessment.
This was done using the expression:
(
(
1
)
Where
LAeq = A-weighted equivalent sound
pressure level
LAi = A-weighted sound pressure level in
dB
N = total number of measurements
The computed A-weighted equivalent
sound pressure level (LAeq) at each of the
assessed sawmills were analyzed on typical
noise levels scale by Aaberg (2007) to
ascertain the noise intensity of the sawmill
work environments. The categories of the
noise intensity on the typical noise levels
scale is as follows; LAeq ≤ 30 dBA for very
quiet, 30 <LAeq 50 dBA for quiet, 50
<LAeq 75 dBA for moderately loud, 75
<LAeq 100 dBA for very loud and LAeq>
100 dBA for uncomfortably loud noise
levels (Aaberg, 2007; Azodo et al., 2018).
The independent samples t-test analyses
was used to establish if there is a significant
statistical difference between a) the
observed noise level at the sawmills during
the sawing operation and maximum
permissible noise level exposure; b) the
observed noise level at the sawmills at
idling periods of the machines and
maximum permissible noise level
exposure.
The analysis of the obtained data from the
survey was carried out using Statistical
Package for Social Science (SPSS 16.0)
software and Microsoft Excel spreadsheet.
The maximum noise exposure obtained
during the survey were evaluated and
presented in the maximum, minimum,
mean and standard deviation formats.
3. RESULT AND DISCUSSIONS
The descriptive statistical analysis of A-
weighted equivalent sound pressure level of
the 31 sawmills in the selected locations in
the study area are presented on Table 1.
 



39
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
Table 1. Descriptive statistics of A-weighted equivalent sound pressure level of the sawmills
in the selected locations in the study area
Sawmill
s
Off work hours
Job operation
Morning session
Evening session
Sawing operation
Min
Ma
x
Mea
n
Min
Ma
x
Mea
n
Min
Max
Mea
n
Min
Max
Mea
n
1
55.
1
62.
0
59.0
52.
4
74.
3
67.6
89.
3
102.
3
96.6
101.
4
107.
2
105.3
2
54.
3
61.
1
57.9
55.
0
72.
9
66.9
85.
0
99.9
96.1
93.0
108.
4
106.3
3
50.
2
59.
3
56.8
54.
0
73.
8
66.7
81.
0
100.
2
95.7
104.
6
110.
0
106.7
4
54.
2
60.
4
57.5
58.
8
76.
2
67.3
83.
0
98.9
95.5
103.
9
120.
0
109.7
5
54.
8
60.
1
58.0
57.
1
72.
0
64.2
86.
0
98.9
94.4
104.
8
119.
0
108.9
6
52.
1
60.
8
58.0
57.
5
74.
4
68.8
82.
0
99.8
95.4
105.
1
109.
0
106.8
7
54.
3
60.
9
57.7
54.
9
72.
7
66.1
81.
0
99.5
96.1
87.0
109.
8
106.9
8
54.
3
60.
0
57.0
52.
2
73.
9
66.0
90.
0
99.0
95.9
99.0
108.
7
106.6
9
53.
0
59.
7
57.1
54.
1
78.
5
68.2
66.
0
99.3
95.5
94.0
109.
1
107.0
10
52.
9
61.
2
57.3
50.
2
73.
0
66.2
91.
0
98.5
96.2
102.
3
108.
9
106.2
11
53.
8
61.
1
57.9
53.
2
70.
6
64.7
89.
0
99.3
95.5
103.
2
133.
0
120.2
12
51.
2
61.
1
57.5
52.
5
71.
6
66.5
86.
1
99.0
95.5
102.
1
122.
0
110.7
13
54.
0
61.
3
57.5
51.
4
73.
0
67.2
81.
0
100.
3
95.8
101.
0
108.
1
106.1
14
54.
4
61.
6
58.0
46.
9
71.
9
65.6
92.
1
99.8
96.3
102.
2
116.
0
106.8
15
47.
0
60.
0
57.4
44.
5
74.
3
66.9
84.
0
98.9
95.5
92.0
110.
0
106.2
16
51.
1
58.
8
56.8
57.
6
74.
5
66.0
82.
0
99.9
95.2
90.0
107.
7
105.0
17
53.
0
59.
9
57.6
56.
8
75.
0
67.1
86.
0
101.
0
95.3
94.0
108.
4
105.1
18
53.
7
69.
9
60.0
56.
2
72.
7
66.0
81.
0
99.8
94.7
101.
7
111.
0
106.1
19
52.
3
61.
7
57.3
58.
9
73.
3
66.0
86.
0
99.5
95.4
101.
2
115.
0
106.8
20
52.
3
61.
5
57.4
56.
4
71.
4
66.2
84.
0
100.
2
95.4
102.
2
111.
0
106.2
21
52.
8
63.
1
58.5
56.
4
71.
2
64.9
80.
0
97.9
94.6
101.
0
112.
0
106.0
22
54.
3
62.
8
58.8
55.
5
73.
7
67.0
91.
8
99.3
95.8
101.
0
107.
5
105.1
ADINIFE P. AZODO1*, UDEME V. AKPAN 2, TOCHUKWU C. MEZUE 3, ALEXANDER I. TYOM 4
Evaluation and analysis of Occupational Noise Exposure in an Amassed Sawmill site
40
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
23
53.
1
60.
7
57.8
53.
8
71.
1
66.1
83.
0
99.5
95.6
91.0
111.
8
106.3
24
53.
0
60.
4
57.6
55.
1
72.
6
64.3
86.
0
102.
0
96.0
94.0
107.
3
105.3
25
54.
7
60.
0
57.6
50.
6
72.
8
67.5
89.
0
99.0
95.2
103.
9
121.
0
110.1
26
53.
5
62.
2
58.3
51.
6
71.
9
67.2
87.
0
98.2
94.2
102.
6
120.
0
109.8
27
53.
9
61.
3
57.5
51.
2
72.
4
66.9
86.
0
99.8
94.8
101.
8
107.
7
105.8
28
55.
3
60.
4
57.8
52.
6
73.
9
65.8
90.
7
100.
1
95.8
102.
7
122.
0
110.5
29
52.
8
67.
8
58.6
54.
4
73.
0
67.6
87.
0
101.
7
96.3
102.
0
104.
9
103.5
30
53.
6
61.
8
58.2
51.
7
73.
8
66.6
80.
0
101.
7
96.1
101.
1
108.
0
103.3
31
53.
6
61.
3
58.0
54.
1
70.
6
65.3
83.
0
99.8
95.9
91.0
105.
9
103.6
The range of the A-weighted equivalent
sound pressure level in the market showed
that 85.899.7 dBA with mean value of
95.6 dBA on idling of the machines, while
it was 99.3 112.3 dBA with mean value of
107.1 dBA during sawing operation (Table
2). This study buttressed Vaishali et al.
(2011) and Owoyemi et al. (2016)
statement that noise emission of an idling
wood machinery during job operation can
be as high as 95dBA. The noise level
obtained in this study is similar to the
varying noise level operation range of from
80 to 120 dBA by Vaishali et al, (2011) and
Owoyemi et al. (2016).Also the noise
exposure range is similar to the outcome of
Adhikari and Sahu (2016) study which was
92.1 - 116.3 dBA. The mean value of 107.1
dBA obtained in this study is similar but a
little higher with Odibo et al.(2018) study
who obtained 101.08, 102.36 and 105.54
dBA from three different sawmill locations.
The variation in the A-weighted equivalent
sound pressure level obtained in this study
compared to previous studies may be
attributed to the amassed siting of the
sawmills. The LAeq obtained in this study is
higher than the recommended continuous
exposure limit of 85 dBA by NESREA. The
noise exposure level observed in this study
has noise induced occupational injury
potentials on the sawmill workers (Zhao et
al., 1991; Lang et al., 1992;Kryter,
1994).Assessment of the A-weighted
equivalent sound pressure level obtained
from the typical noise levels scale (Aaberg,
2007) to ascertain the noise intensity of the
sawmill work environments showed 100%
moderately quiet during off work hours for
the morning and evening sessions. During
the job operation, on idling of machine the
typical A-weighted equivalent sound
pressure level obtained in the sawmills
were 100% very loud and 100%
uncomfortably loud during the sawing
operations.
41
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
Table 2. Summary of the A-weighted equivalent sound pressure level of the sawmills in the
study area
Activities
Variables
N
Minimum
Maximum
Mean
Working hours
Machine Idling
31
85.8
99.7
95.6
Sawing operation
31
99.3
112.3
107.1
Off work hours
Morning session
31
53.2
61.4
57.8
Evening session
31
53.8
73.1
66.4
Independent-samples t-test analysis between the machine idling noise level and the maximum
permissible noise level
The independent-samples t-test which compared to the statistical significant difference between the
means of the idling machine noise level and the maximum permissible noise level found that the
machine idling noise level during the job operation was of statistical significance. Higher mean values
(mean = 95.56 ± .58, SEM = .58) compared to the maximum permissible noise level (mean = 85.0000
± .0000, SEM = .0000), with t (31) = 102.148, p = .000 (Table 3)considered at the value of "Sig. (2-
tailed)" which was less than 0.05.
Table 3. Independent-samples t-test for noise level between the machine idling noise level and the
maximum permissible noise level
Noise level
characteristics
Group Statistics
Independent Samples Test
N
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Std. Error
Mean
Mean
difference
T
Df
P-value
(Sig. (2-
tailed))
Idling noise level
31
95.5581
.57548
.10336
Maximum
permissible noise
level
31
85.0000
.00000
.00000
10.55806
102.148
60
.000
Independent-samples t-test analysis
between the sawmill machinery sawing
operation noise level and the maximum
permissible noise level,
The result of independent-samples t-test
which was used to test differences in the
means for the two independent groups, the
sawmill machinery sawing operation noise
level and the maximum permissible noise
level if they are significantly different from
each other, found that the sawmill
machinery sawing operation noise level
was of statistical significance with higher
mean values (mean = 107.0613 ± 3.11049,
SEM = .55866) compared to the maximum
permissible noise level (85.0000 ± .0000,
SEM = .0000), with t(31) = 39.490, p = .00
(Table 4). The groups’ means are
significantly different because of the value
of "Sig. (2-tailed)" is less than 0.05. The
findings revealed that the occupational
noise exposure of the sawmill workers at
timber market Ogidi is beyond the
maximum permissible noise exposure level
which unhealthy.
ADINIFE P. AZODO1*, UDEME V. AKPAN 2, TOCHUKWU C. MEZUE 3, ALEXANDER I. TYOM 4
Evaluation and analysis of Occupational Noise Exposure in an Amassed Sawmill site
42
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
Table 4. Independent-samples t-test for noise level between the sawmill machinery sawing
operation noise level and the maximum permissible noise level
Noise level
characteristics
Group Statistics
Independent Samples Test
N
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
Mean
Mean
difference
T
Df
P-value (Sig.
(2-tailed))
Sawing
operation noise
level
31
107.0613
3.11049
.55866
Maximum
permissible
noise level
31
85.0000
.00000
.00000
22.06129
39.490
60
.000
4. CONCLUSIONS
Occupational noise exposure level beyond
the maximum permissible noise level for
health and safety workers poses a big
challenge to the workforce or human
resources of any nation as occupational
health and safety are interrelated and
complementary as such plays an intricate
and vital role in the workers’ life.
Identification of noise exposure level
during jobs operations in an amassed
sawmills and analyzed on the guidelines
and standards for environmental pollution
control in Nigeria recommended for noise
exposure safety by NESREA carried out in
this study showed that workers at the
assessed sawmills were exposed to noise
level beyond the recommended noise
exposure limit 85 dBA during the job
process involved in the sawmills. The
hazardous occupational noise level
besetting the sawmill workers established
in this study requires the machine vibration
reduction through the use of machine
damper between the machine and the
foundation and workers’ personal
protective device
REFERENCES
Aaberg, D. (2007). Generator set noise
solutions: Controlling unwanted
noise from on-site power systems.
Cummins Power Generation
Incorporated.
Adeyemi, H. O. and Udoh, E. I. (2016).
Assessment of cumulative trauma
disorders among workers in
southwest Nigeria sawmilling
industry. Mindanao Journal of
Science and Technology, 14, 1-17.
Adhikari, A. and Sahu, S. (2016).
Prevalence of noise induced hearing
loss (NHIL) among sawmill workers
in west Bengal, India. International
Journal of Current Research and
Academic Review, 4(9), 12-20
Aina, O. M. (2006). Wood waste utilization
for energy generation. In Proceedings
of the International Conference on
Renewable Energy for Developing
Countries. Available
athttp://www.udc.edu/docs/cere/Aina
.pdf
Agyeman-Prempeh, N. O. W. O. (2014).
Noise Abatement in Machine Shops
Through the Use of Recycled
Coconut Fibre and Polyvinyl
Chloride Sheets as Noise Absorbing
ADINIFE P. AZODO1*, UDEME V. AKPAN 2, TOCHUKWU C. MEZUE 3, ALEXANDER I. TYOM 4
Evaluation and analysis of Occupational Noise Exposure in an Amassed Sawmill site
43
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
Materials (Doctoral dissertation,
University of Ghana).
Aremu, A. S., Aremu, A. O. and Olukanni,
D. O. (2015). Assessment Of Noise
Pollution From Sawmill Activities In
Ilorin, Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of
Technology, 34(1), 72-79.
Aremu, S. K., Adegbiji, W. A., Ibrahim, A.
O. and Dosunmu, A. O. (2019).
Evaluation of the Impact of Tinnitus
on Health-Related Quality of Life
amid Sawmill Workforces.
International Journal of Clinical
Medicine, 10,1 - 8.
Aruofor, R. O. (2001): Review and
Improvement of Data Related to
Wood Products
in Nigeria. Report Prepared for FAO
Rome,
Azodo A. P. and Adejuyigbe S. B. (2013).
Nigeria engineering students’
compliance with workshop safety
measures. International journal of
Innovation and Applied Studies. 3(2),
425-432. Avaliable at
http://www.issr-journals.
org/xplore/ijias/IJIAS/13-091-01.pdf
Azodo A. P., Idama O., Mezue T. C. and
Owoeye, F. T. (2018). Evaluation and
analysis of environmental noise from
petrol fuelled portable power
generators used in commercial areas.
Journal of Experimental
Research6(2) 8 13. Available at
http://www.er-
journal.com/papers/Azodo%20A_M
arch_2018_8-13.pdf
Babalola, A. A., Adeyemi, H. O., Lawal, N.
S., Adetifa, B. O. and Adama, K. O.
(2018). Characterization of small
scale lumber saw mills in a rural area
in Nigeria. Journal of Experimental
Research, 6(3), 12 - 21.
Buksh, N., Nargis, Y., Yun, C., He, D. and
Ghufran, M. (2018). Occupational
noise exposure and its impact on
worker’s health and activities.
International Journal of Public Health
and Clinical Sciences, 5(2), 180-195.
Chang, S. J. and Chang, C. K. (2009).
Prevalence and risk factors of noise-
induced hearing loss among liquefied
petroleum gas (LPG) cylinder
infusion workers in Taiwan.
Industrial health, 47(6), 603-610.
Fuwape, J. A. (2001). The impacts of forest
industries and wood utilization on the
environment. Journal of Tropical
Forest Resources, 17(2), 78-90.
Federal Environmental Protection Agency
(FEPA). (1991). Guidelines and
standards for environmental pollution
control in Nigeria. Federal Ministry
of Environment, Nigeria
Ismail, F., Harun, H., Ismail, R., Majid M.
Z. A. (2010). A Framework of Safety
Culture for the Malaysian
construction companies: a
methodological development.
Pertanika Journal of Social Science
and Humanities, 18(1), 4554.
Koehncke, N. K. (1999). An Investigation
of Noise Level in Alberta Sawmills.
(Masteral dissertation, University of
Alberta, Canada).
Kryter, K. (1994). The handbook of hearing
and the effects of noise: physiology,
psychology, and public health.
Boston: Academic Press.
Lang, T., Fouriaud, C. and Jacquinet-
Salord, M. C. (1992). Length of
occupational noise exposure and
blood pressure. International archives
ADINIFE P. AZODO1*, UDEME V. AKPAN 2, TOCHUKWU C. MEZUE 3, ALEXANDER I. TYOM 4
Evaluation and analysis of Occupational Noise Exposure in an Amassed Sawmill site
44
n
JOURNAL OF THE NIGERIAN INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS/VOL.9 NO.2 SEPTEMBER 2019
of occupational and environmental
health, 63(6), 369-372.
Mburu, R. O. M. A. C., &Kiiyukia, C.
(2017). Assessment of occupational
safety and health status of sawmilling
industries in Nakuru County, Kenya.
International Journal of Health
Sciences, 5(4), 75-102.
Mika, D. and Józwik, J. (2016). Normative
measurements of noise at CNC
machines work stations. Advances in
Science and Technology Research
Journal, 10(30), 138143.
Odibo, A. A., Nwaogazie, I. L., Achalu, E.
I. and Ugbebor, J. N. (2018). Effects
of safety intervention practices
among selected sawmill workers in
sawmills in Delta State, Nigeria.
International Journal of Health,
Safety and Environments (IJHSE),
4(2), 218-235
Ohagwua, C. J. and Ugwuishiwu, B. O.
(2011). Status of wood processing
and storage in Nigeria, Nigerian
Journal of Technology. 30(2), 94-
104.
Otoghile, B., Onakoya, P. A. and Otoghile,
C. C. (2018). Auditory effects of
noise and its prevalence among
sawmill workers. International
Journal of Medicine and Medical
Sciences, 10(2), 27-30.
Owoyemi, M. J, Falemara, B. C. and
Owoyemi, A. J. (2016). Noise
pollution and control in wood
mechanical processing wood
industries. Biomedical Statistics and
Informatics. 2(2), 54-60.
Ssemanda, J. 2017). Efficiency and
profitability in the sawmilling of
softwood plantation thinnings in
Uganda. (Bachelor degree
dissertation Makerere University)
Thepaksorn, P., Koizumi, A., Harada, K.,
Siriwong, W. and Neitzel, R. L.
(2018). Occupational noise exposure
and hearing defects among sawmill
workers in the south of Thailand.
International Journal of Occupational
Safety and Ergonomics, 1-9.
Ugbebor, J. N. and Yorkor, B. (2015).
Assessment and evaluation of noise
pollution levels in selected Sawmill
Factories in Port Harcourt, Nigeria.
International Journal on Emerging
Technologies, 6(2), 1 8.
Vaishali, P. C., Deepak, S. D. and
Chandrakant, R. P. (2011).
Assessment and Control of Sawmill
Noise. In International Conference on
Chemical, Biological and
Environment Sciences
(ICCEBS'2011) Bangkok, 299-303.
Zhao, Y. M., Zhang, S. Z., Selvin, S. and
Spear, R. C. (1991). A dose response
relation for noise induced
hypertension. Occupational and
Environmental Medicine, 48(3), 179-
184.
ADINIFE P. AZODO1*, UDEME V. AKPAN 2, TOCHUKWU C. MEZUE 3, ALEXANDER I. TYOM 4
Evaluation and analysis of Occupational Noise Exposure in an Amassed Sawmill site
45
... The noise and vibration measurements were simultaneously carried out at the unloaded and loaded (the grains grinding operations) stages. The noise level was measured at an average height of about 1.5 meters corresponding to the average ear level of a seated adult[29],[45]. The vibration was determined on the working seat of the machine operator from the grinding machine. The whole-bodyvibration was measured as it is the vibration transmitted to the entire body via the sit through the mechanical vibrations of the grinding machine affecting the floor and the operators' sits. ...
... Occupational noise exposure level beyond the maximum permissible noise level for health and safety workers poses a big challenge to the workforce or human resources of any nation as occupational health and safety are interrelated and complementary and, as such, plays an intricate and vital role in the workers' life. This observation was similar to the results obtained by other researchers that assessed the intensity of unloaded machines on the noise level in the work environment[29],[48]-[49]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Grinding machines is one of the outcomes of the agricultural sector work process mechanization aimed at reducing tedium and drudgery on the workers and improving overall productivity and production. However, the machinery drive component and mechanical energy are associated with noise and vibration, thereby inducing safety and health concerns for the operators. This study assessed and compared the vibro-acoustic characteristics caused by three different types of grinding machines; electric motor (3HP220V2800HD), diesel (R175A) and petrol (GX160) power drive engines used in grinding shops located in Wadata, Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State in association with the risk factors to the work environment. The instrumentation design for the grinding machine operations vibro-acoustic characterization was a sound level meter (S844+), a vibrometer (VM-6360), a digital stopwatch (PC-396) and retractable measuring tape (B300-AG). The noise measurements were made at an average seating height of 1.5 m in the operator’s work position and the vibrations on the seat surface of the operator. The data obtained were analysed for noise and vibration occupational risk exposure following the ISO 9612 for acoustics guidelines and ISO 2372 for mechanical vibration and shock. The average mean values for the noise level and vibrations were statistically highest when the diesel power drive engine, followed by the petrol engine, while the electric motor had the least vibro-acoustic effect. In addition, the analysis of the variance test showed that the result obtained for the vibration and noise levels for the three categories of power source drive had p-values less than 0.05, indicating that they are significantly different from zero at a confidence level of 95%. The findings of this study mandated that all operators of the machinery under investigation wear personal protective equipment (PPE).
... Oil palm mill has come to stay considering that palm oil is an important product in world trade [13] and is playing an important role in Nigerian economy [14]. Previous scientific studies on noise level measurements and evaluations found in the works of literature in different occupational dispensations included evaluation and analysis of the intensity of noise from various generators in the commercial areas [15], distraction effect of excessive noise pollution from mining machines during mining operations [8], assessment of noise emission from vibrator-block factories and the impact on human health [16], and occupational noise exposure in an amassed sawmill site was evaluated and analyzed by Azodo et al. [17]. However, no publicly available published literature was found that assessed the occupational exposure of workers in the palm oil mill. ...
Article
Mechanization of work processes in agro-based industries through the employment of improved tools and/or equipment powered by either fuel or diesel engines reduce tedium and drudgery on the workers as well as improve the overall productivity and production. However, it also leads to health threat to the workers through environmental noise pollution. This study assessed the occupational noise exposure of workers in three different palm oil mills. The noise level was measured using a noise metering device (model 1352) and noise descriptors (L10, L50, L90, Lav, LAeq, Tspl, DOSE (%) and TWA). The occupational health effects of noise exposure were deduced using a semi-structured questionnaire. The noise exposure was assessed during the palm nut digestion, and nut and pulp separation job operations as the noise emanates from the diesel powered engine, palm nut digester and nut and pulp separator. The average noise levels obtained from the palm oil mills during palm nut digestion, 99.36 (SD = 4.16) dBA and pulp separation, 98.18 (SD = 3.07) dBA, exceeded the recommended 85 dBA for an 8-hour exposure period permissible noise exposure limit standard by the NIOSH. The self-reported effect of the noise exposure level on the workers was interference with communication - 100%, tinnitus - 70%, ringing sensation - 76.75%, and noise stress - 73.30% of the workers. This research will inform the operators of the need for appropriate personal protective equipment usage and equip Government regulatory agencies to make appropriate regulations in order to protect oil mill workers.
Article
Full-text available
Activities of small scale lumber mills in the rural areas in Nigeria play a vital role in the local economy as a key rural employment generator. Unlike major saw mills in cities which have received lots of attention from researchers, policy makers and the general public, very little information is available on the activities of small scale lumber mills in the rural areas. An assessment of 7 small scale lumber mills was carried out by this study in Ibogun-a cluster of rural settlements in Ifo Local government area of Ogun State Nigeria. Preliminary investigations revealed that 42% of operators used only table saws for their operations while 52% utilized table saws, planning and smoothening machines respectively. The major power source in each of the sites visited was from air cooled diesel engines with 10-15 horse power capacity. Three major lumber sizes were identified as raw materials. The average total Energy expended daily was 318.04 MJ, average daily operational cost was N3436.43 ($9.4). Daily power utilization in the conversion process was estimated while the efficiencies of each site in size reduction process ranged from 85-87% respectively
Article
Full-text available
This study was aimed at evaluating the effects of safety education as safety-intervention programme on Sawmill workers in Delta State. Selected study area was 21 sawmills located within 3 local government areas (Sapele, Warri-south and Udu) in Delta State. Purposive sampling was adopted for selection of the 3 sawmills locations, while systematic and simple random sampling was used to select 21 sawmill sites and respondents (210) respectively. A structured questionnaire was used for data collection. Collected data were subjected to normality test, Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test, Knowledge Attitude, Practice and Skill (KAPS) analyses and regression analysis. The output from the pre-intervention revealed fair knowledge, attitude, practice and skills of respondents when compared to the post-intervention output that revealed1.51, 1.82 and 1.89 out of 2 for Sapele, Warri and Udu, respectively for awareness of occupational hazards; 2.52, 2.88 and 2.94 out of 3 for Sapele, Warri and Udu, respectively on knowledge of physicals; 2.49, 2.96 and 2.98 out of 3 for Sapele, Warri and Udu, respectively for chemical hazards; and 2.41, 2.91 and 2.96 out of 3 for Sapele, Warri and Udu on mechanical hazards. Furthermore, comparing the resultant grand means of the pre and post intervention assessments, it revealed high improvement (2.41, 3.18 and 3.35 out of 4 for Sapele, Warri and Udu) on the attitude of the workers towards occupational hazards. Looking at their safety practices a notable increase was recorded (2.44, 3.12 and 3.31 out of 4 for Sapele, Warri and Udu). Also recorded was an increase in skills as related to occupational safety (2.60, 3.37 and 3.40 out of 4 for Sapele, Warri and Udu. The regression analyses produced a goodness of fits for Sapele, Warri and Udu sawmills of 0.2016 (20.16%), 0.6041 (60.41%), 0.6813 (68.13%), it also, revealed that the intervention had positive contributions on the attitude of the respondents of both Experimental groups, (ie Warri and Udu classes) safety practice unlike the control (Sapele class) where there no intervention.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study was to investigate occupational noise exposure and hearing defects among sawmill workers in the South of Thailand. Seven hundred sawmill workers participated, of which 335 (47.9%) were male. The mean age of the sawmill workers was 33.5 years old (SD = 10.2), and more than 60% were <35 years old. 75.1% of the workers had less than 5 years of work experience. Only about one in four workers (25%) had been trained on use of personal protective equipment (PPE), and half of participants never or rarely wore PPEs while working. The prevalence rate of noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) was 22.8% (N =42). Male workers had significantly higher risk than female workers (OR=2.21). Workers who aged more than 25 years old had significantly higher risks for NIHL (OR=3.51-12.42) than workers less than 25 years old. Sawing workers had higher risk than the office workers for NIHL (OR=3.07).
Article
Full-text available
High level of noise is a disturbance to the human environment. Noise in industries is also an occupational hazard because of its attendant effects on workers’ health. Noise presents health and social problems in industrial operations, and the source is related to the machineries used in the industries. One of the unique features of the noise associated with wood machinery is the level of exposure and duration. Equipment used in a factory can be extremely loud. They can produce noise at decibels high enough to cause environmental health and safety concerns. The mechanically driven transport and handling equipment, cutting, milling, shaping and dust extractor installations in the wood industry generate noise. The sources of noise pollution have increased due to non-compliance with basic safety practices. The increased use of locally fabricated machine in the industry has increased the level of noise and vibration. The effects of industrial noise pollution as discussed include: increase in blood pressure; increased stress; fatigue; vertigo; headaches; sleep disturbance; annoyance; speech problems; dysgraphia, which means reading/learning impairment; aggression; anxiety and withdrawal. As presented in this paper, noise control techniques include; sound insulation, sound absorption, vibration damping and Vibration isolation.
Article
Full-text available
Minimisation of noise at a workstation is among fundamental tasks for maintaining safety at work, both in terms of health (the auditory system in particular) as well as work comfort. Thus, it is very important to systematically monitor noise levels by carrying out reliable measurements at a workstation. The method of performing noise measurements at workstations of specific machines is normalised so the results of such measurements for different machines is comparable. This paper presents noise measurements for DMC 635 numerically controlled milling machine, performed in accordance with PN ISO 230-5:2002 norm. The results showed that the level of noise at the operator’s workstation significantly exceeds the norm at certain machining parameters. The results of tests are concluded as detailed recommendation for the CNC machine tool operator to use hearing protection when at work.
Article
Full-text available
This study examined noise pollution from sawmilling in Ilorin metropolis, Nigeria. Noise measurements were made using HD600 digital data logging sound level meter in conjunction with structured questionnaire which was designed to elicit noise related information. The results of the study showed that the background noise within the sawmills was 58.1-64.86 dB(A) while machine equivalent noise was 81.1-112.3 dB(A). Approximately 73% of all the noise measurements are above the recommended limit of 85 dB(A) and these high noise intensities can initiate or perpetuate some work related health challenges. Also a noise contour map which shows the spatial impact of sawmill noise on the metropolis was developed. Within the sawmills, most of the workers are unprotected, disturbed and complain of noise-related ailments such as tinnitus (96.6%), headache (86.6%) and hearing impairment (71.9%). Therefore noise prevention and control strategies are suggested in addition to frequent audiometric tests, training, education, and enforcement of noise regulations.http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/njt.v34i1.9
Article
This research presents the methodological development of a framework for promoting safety culture for the Malaysian construction companies. There is no framework that has that been established in this context. The development will enable professionals to quantify and analyze safety culture in a consistent manner. A mixed methodology of qualitative and quantitative was adopted, in which sample for the study was limited to selected building contractors (Grade 7) in the Klang Valley. The preliminary survey identified leadership, organisational commitment, management commitment, safety training, and resource allocation as practices which embed safety culture into organisational culture. Hence, the development of the main survey includes the identification of these behavioural factors and their further expansion to include the aspects of psychological and situational factors' characteristics. Semi-structured interviews were also conducted to provide new insights on the importance of communications which are founded on mutual trust, shared perceptions between the Senior Management, Safety Officer, and Site Supervisor within the organisations. The safety related representatives from the industry players are validated based on the appropriateness, the ease of use, and the coverage of the framework.