Question
Asked 16th Mar, 2021

What does a negative potential energy (total energy) depict in a molecular dynamics simulation?

In any MD simulation done using LAMMPS, what does negative total energy at every step mean?
Further, what does 0 E_mol and negative E_pair depict? Can you please suggest a text or brief explanation regarding the output of a molecular dynamics simulation.

Most recent answer

Desh Deepak Yadav
Indian Institute of Technology (Banaras Hindu University) Varanasi
Negative total energy in every step means energy reaches its minimum value(local minima or global minimum) and system is stable.
P.S: Negative potential energy is a relative concept and depends on the frame of reference .

All Answers (6)

Negative means favorable.
1 Recommendation
Rituparna Hazra
BITS Pilani
Negative potential energy refers to attractive interaction.
E_mol is molecular energy involving bond, angle, dihedral and improper contribution.
E_pair is pairwise interaction energy and it includes vdw, coulombic contribution and long range k-space energy.
Subham Prasad
National Institute of Technology (NIT) Uttarakhand
Rituparna Hazra , does attractive interaction mean that the system is stable? or should the total energy be zero for a stable system?
Rituparna Hazra
BITS Pilani
yes, attractive interaction means that the system is stable, it may be a local minima or a global minima depending on the system's PE surface.
zero energy means no force has been applied or there has been no displacement which can not be the case for a MD simulation.
Kostadin Georgiev Gaminchev
Bulgarian Academy of Sciences
Rituparna Hazra , for a system negative means equilibrium/favourable.
Due to Emmy's Noether theorem No, there is a conservation laws and it cannot be zero.
Desh Deepak Yadav
Indian Institute of Technology (Banaras Hindu University) Varanasi
Negative total energy in every step means energy reaches its minimum value(local minima or global minimum) and system is stable.
P.S: Negative potential energy is a relative concept and depends on the frame of reference .

Similar questions and discussions

Why a high negative pressure is recorded during LAMMPS simulation?
Question
3 answers
  • Yuvam BhatejaYuvam Bhateja
Respected peers,
I am trying to simulate the lignin molecule with a mixture of ozone and water with reaxff potential (I used the reaxff potential available on the LAMMPS example.). I am getting some questionable values for pressure. While running for NVE simulation on the following system: lignin + 500 ozone + 3500 water for 1 ns and 0K starting temperature, the system recorded a very high negative pressure of negative tens of thousand. Later this value saturated to around -2000 as the simulation reaches the end of 1 ns (the temperature at the end of 1 ns is around 473 K). According to LAMMPS documentation, the pressure is supposed to be atm units (I used 'real' units). Considering the negative pressure, I incremented water molecules to 5000 but the pressure trend remained the same (I simulated this particular system for 10 ns). I am pretty new with LAMMPS and I will be grateful if someone will help me understand these results
Below is my input file and I am attaching my log file (for lignin + 500 ozone + 3500 water system).
units real
boundary p p p
atom_style charge
read_data data.lignin+ozone+water.charge
pair_style reaxff lmp_control
pair_coeff * * ffield.reax.cho C H O
group lig id 1:201
group ozn id 202:1701
group water id >= 1702
group lig+ozn id 1:1701
compute reax all pair reaxff
#compute pressure all pressure thermo_temp
variable eb equal c_reax[1]
variable ea equal c_reax[2]
variable elp equal c_reax[3]
variable emol equal c_reax[4]
variable ev equal c_reax[5]
variable epen equal c_reax[6]
variable ecoa equal c_reax[7]
variable ehb equal c_reax[8]
variable et equal c_reax[9]
variable eco equal c_reax[10]
variable ew equal c_reax[11]
variable ep equal c_reax[12]
variable efi equal c_reax[13]
variable eqeq equal c_reax[14]
thermo 1
neighbor 2.5 bin
neigh_modify every 10 delay 0 check yes
#velocity all create 300.0 4928459 mom yes rot yes dist gaussian
#fix 1 all nve temp 300.0 300.0 0.1
fix 1 all nve
fix 2 all qeq/reaxff 1 0.0 10.0 1.0e-6 reaxff
fix 4 all reaxff/bonds 20 bonds.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water_nve300_1ns
fix 5 lig reaxff/bonds 20 bonds.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water(lignin)_nve300_1ns
fix 6 ozn reaxff/bonds 20 bonds.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water(ozone)_nve300_1ns
fix 7 lig+ozn reaxff/bonds 20 bonds.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water(lignin+ozone)_nve300_1ns
#fix 8 all press/berendsen iso 0.0 0.0 1000.0
#fix 5 all bond/break 5 1 1.9
minimize 1.0e-6 1.0e-9 10000 100000
log log.lignin+ozone+water.nve300_1ns
variable nqeq equal f_2
thermo_style custom step temp epair etotal press &
v_eb v_ea v_elp v_emol v_ev v_epen v_ecoa &
v_ehb v_et v_eco v_ew v_ep v_efi v_eqeq v_nqeq
timestep 0.1
dump 1 all atom 20 dump.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water_nve300_1ns
dump 2 lig atom 20 dump.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water(lig)_nve300_1ns
dump 3 ozn atom 20 dump.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water(ozn)_nve300_1ns
dump 4 lig+ozn atom 20 dump.reaxff.lignin+ozone+water(lig+ozn)_nve300_1ns
restart 10000 restart.lignin+ozone+water_nve300_1ns
run 10000
Thank you in advance.

Related Publications

Technical Report
Full-text available
Studies and structural analysis revealed a gate-trapping mechanism for the uptake of O2 in truncated Haemoglobin. This gate involves the Ile15, Ile19, Leu102, and Ile115 residues. To further study the gate-trapping process, MD and MC simulations with O2 outside the protein but close to the gate are performed. O2 is constrained to remain around the...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.