Question
Asked 11th Jan, 2016

What is the maximum compression ratio achieved so far for a compression ignition engine?

Diesel or compression ignition engines have better specific fuel  consumption than S.I. engines because they enjoy higher compression ratios. What is the highest achieved by manufacturers so far and what sets up a limit to that maximum?

Most recent answer

Mohamed F. Al-Dawody
University of Al-Qadisiyah
Generally the range of compression ratio starts from (12-24):1

Popular answers (1)

Typically, about 25:1 for production type 4 stroke engines using diesel fuel. Materials, and thus costs, are probably the main limitation. Emissions are another factor, NOx goes up with compression ratio.
4 Recommendations

All Answers (19)

Typically, about 25:1 for production type 4 stroke engines using diesel fuel. Materials, and thus costs, are probably the main limitation. Emissions are another factor, NOx goes up with compression ratio.
4 Recommendations
Andras Kovacs
qs biodiesel
 up to hundreds of bar
1 Recommendation
Mario Hirz
Graz University of Technology
It depends on the degree of supercharging. Naturally aspirated diesel engines in automotive, truck or commercial vehicle applications have compression ratios of up to 25:1 as mentioned by Robert. Turbo- or Supercharged diesel engines have lower compression ratios, e.g. 14:1 to 20:1 depending on the intake air pressure. Supercharging grades of 1.5-3 and even more are reached in common in diesel engine applications. 
Kind regards,
Mario
4 Recommendations
Francesco Pizzonia
Università della Calabria
All compression ignition engine products today are supercharged diesel engines. For this reason they have 14:1 to 18:1 compression ratios, with the maximum intake manifold pressure equal to 2,5 - 2,8.
Francesco  
Kamal Nasreldin Abdalla
University of Khartoum
Dear Andras
Compression ratio is defined as the ratio when total cylinder volume when piston is at its bottom dead center divided by the clearance volume( volume of cylinder when piston is at its top dead center and so it has no units i.e. dimensionless.
1 Recommendation
  1. 16-20 is the compression ratio for diesel engine 
Normally, It ranges from 14-24
T.Karthikeya Sharma
National Institute of Technology, Andhra Pradesh
as per my knowledge 25 is the maximum compression ratio achieved by some of the diesel engines....
Kamal Nasreldin Abdalla
University of Khartoum
Please specify the manufacturer of the engine that has a compression ratio of 25 ?
1 Recommendation
Mario Hirz
Graz University of Technology
This range is from literature, I think from retired commercial naturally aspirated diesel engines. Examples of modern commercial diesel engines with high compression ratio:
Kind regards,
Mario
Kamal Nasreldin Abdalla
University of Khartoum
Dr Sharma  do you have a manufacturer in mind who manufactured an engine with a compression ratio of 25? Please give some details
Mario Hirz
Graz University of Technology
- Here is an additional link, which might be of interest for you:
- Exemplary diesel engines with high compression ratio up to 24:
kind regards,
Mario
3 Recommendations
Kamal Nasreldin Abdalla
University of Khartoum
Thank you Mario
They only have 2 kW engines with compression ratio of 23 which is a very small engine.
Mario Hirz
Graz University of Technology
Yes, these high compression ratios mainly occur in small diesel engines today. Most of them are for mobile industrial applications, e.g. generators or water pumps. Development targets are a certain power output, even if the engine displacement is small, and (relatively) low fuel consumption - and this with low cost technologies. 
Kind regards,
Mario
1 Recommendation
What is the normal compression ration for single cylinder diesel (Trem III A Emission ). whats is the port timing diagram for the same in real time application.
Avinash Kumar Namdeo
Lingaya's University
what will be the consequences in increasing CR apart from higher nox emissions
what are the limitations in increasing CR
Kamal Nasreldin Abdalla
University of Khartoum
Temperatures in the combustion chamber will rise to higher limits that may not be tolerated by the materials surrounding the combustion chamber. Expansion or even melting and then jamming of piston may occur resulting in complete mechanical failure.
1 Recommendation
Ashish Thakur
Mekelle University
Dear Kamal Nasreldin Abdalla,
I think its maximum 25:1.
For a temperature concern I am agree with you in a totality. (However, in most real-life internal combustion engines, the ratio of specific heats changes with temperature and that significant deviations from adiabatic behavior will occur).
Compression ratios are often between 14:1 and 23:1 for direct injection diesel engines, and between 18:1 and 23:1 for indirect injection diesel engines. Since diesel engines operate on the principle of compression ignition, a fuel which resists auto-ignition will cause late ignition, which can lead to engine knock. Anything over 10:1 is a high compression ratio. Anything over 12:1 is "highly compressed".
PSi limitations
Today, the average high-performance street or strip turbocharged four-cylinder race engine sports a compression ratio of 9.5:1, with some even running compression ratios as high as 11.5:1 or more on alcohol. Modern automobile technology allows our racing generation to get the best of both worlds. Boost levels above 12 psi should generally be avoided even with racing fuel on a 9.5:1 motor. Compression ratios of 10:1 and higher require lower boost levels, higher octane fuel, inter cooling, or some combination of the above. Compression ratios in the 7 or 8:1 range can usually handle 12-20 psi on pump gasoline.
Air is compressed much more highly during the succeeding compression stroke than would be the case with a spark-ignition engine, with compression ratios of up to 25:1 typical. When the piston is at the highest point within the cylinder, that's called Top Dead Center, and that's where cylinder volume is smallest. The comparison of these two volumes is where your ratio comes from. Increase the compression ratio: Higher compression ratios produce more power, up to a point. The more you compress the air/fuel mixture, however, the more likely it is to spontaneously burst into flame (before the spark plug ignites it). Higher-octane gasolines prevent this sort of early combustion.
Automotive engineers constantly trying improve fuel efficiency and fuel economy by designing new efficient engines with high compression ratios. The higher the ratio, the more compressed the air in the cylinder is. ... It's the same thing with compression ratios. By keeping the explosion in a smaller space, more of its power can be harnessed. Increase in compression ratio induces greater turning effect on the cylinder crank. That means that the engine is. Getting more push on the piston, and hence more torque is generated. The torque gain due to compression ratio.
A high compression ratio is desirable because it allows an engine to extract more mechanical energy from a given mass of air–fuel mixture due to its higher thermal efficiency. This occurs because internal combustion engines are heat engines, and higher compression ratios permit the same combustion temperature to be reached with less fuel, while giving a longer expansion cycle, creating more mechanical power output and lowering the exhaust temperature. Since diesel engines operate on the principle of compression ignition, a fuel which resists autoignition will cause late ignition, which can lead to engine knock. Diesel engines have a higher peak combustion temperature than petrol engines, but the greater expansion means they reject less heat in their cooler exhaust. However, in most real-life internal combustion engines, the ratio of specific heats changes with temperature and that significant deviations from adiabatic behavior will occur.
Compression pressures that are too high can result in difficult starting and detonation or “pinging” which in turn can cause engine damage. If the static compression pressure is too high or too low, the engine will not run as well as it should, and in some cases the resulting problems can be serious. Temperature rising must be considered as it is also a serious matter in this concern.
Hope it help you out.
Ashish
Mohamed F. Al-Dawody
University of Al-Qadisiyah
Generally the range of compression ratio starts from (12-24):1

Similar questions and discussions

Related Publications

Chapter
Es sind große Namen, mit denen wir täglich umgehen: Daimler und Benz, Otto und Diesel. Was steckt dahinter? Man glaubt es zu wissen, doch vieles war ganz anders. Die Frühgeschichte des Automobils erweist sich zum großen Teil als Geschichte der Entstehung und Verbesserung der Motoren. An erster Stelle ging es um die Nutzung des Energiegehaltes flüss...
Article
Ein hochgradig modular gestalteter Ansatz zur objektorientierten Modellierung innermotorischer Vorgänge von Verbrennungsmotoren wird vorgestellt. Dieser kann als reine Stand-Alone-Prozessrechnung genutzt werden, ebenso kann er den Hochdruckteil in 1-D-Strömungssimulationstools ersetzen oder in ähnliche Programme integriert werden. Den Anforderungen...
Article
La precisione e la rapidità di calcolo delle prestazioni di dispositivi per la dissipazione del calore, associati ad ambienti caratterizzati da forti sollecitazioni termiche, presentano caratteristiche di particolare interesse soprattutto se applicate a geometrie peculiari quali i condotti di scarico dei motori a combustione interna. Scopo dell’att...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.