Hochschule Merseburg
Question
Asked 24th Feb, 2015
Does the braking distance of a car depend on weight of the car?
d = v2/2ug,
d = minimum stopping distance,
v = velocity when brakes were applied
u = coeff. of friction between wheels and road
g = gravitational constant,
The above equation shows that braking distance is independent of mass of vehicle. I know that depending on the value of slip, the value of 'u' will change, but lets assume that 'u' is constant. So does it mean that two different vehicles, one a normal car and other a sports car would have a same braking distance for a given same 'v'. I am confused because this does not seem to be the case. What am I missing?
Most recent answer
no
All Answers (8)
Otto-von-Guericke-Universität Magdeburg
Hi,
you could try to use D'Alemberts principle or the Energy balance to solve this dynamical problem.
If you use the energy balance then you compare to states. In the first state the car has only kinetic energy E1 = 1/2*m*v^2. Since the car breaks until standstill it has no kinetic energy in the second state. Due to the friction, however, the system is not conservative. The kinetic energy of the first state is consumed by the work of the friction force E2 = umgd. The energy balance now gives you
E1 = E2
And you get d = v2/2ug.
Best regards,
Malaysian Agricultural Research and Development Institute (MARDI)
The weight does play a role. u = F_friction/F_normal. F_normal is the force that presses the road and tyres together, i.e. the weight of the car, F_normal = mg.
If we are comparing two cars, in your case a sedan car and a sports car, assuming that the mass is different for both cars (m_sports > m_sedan), say:
g = 10N/kg
m_sports = 2kg, F_sports = 2kg * g = 20N
m_sedan = 1kg, F_sedan = 1kg * g = 10N
say u = 1 for both cars,
then the only way u can be constant is by F_friction of both cars to change accordingly,
u_sedan = F_friction/F_sedan = 10N/10N = 1
u_sports = F_friction/F_sports = 20N/20N = 1
i.e. if the sports car has bigger mass, then the tyres need to be bigger as well. So if we say that u is constant, we are actually saying we are compensating for the mass of the cars with frictional force.
In reality though, for the same v, two cars (sports and sedan) do not have the same u, that is why you will see one go off a cliff.
Otto-von-Guericke-Universität Magdeburg
For the sake of Argument we assume that u is equal in both cases and since the frictional force only depends on the normal force and u the mass does not Play a role theoretically.
Even in reality that should be the case if u is constant and acceleration is the same for both cars.
Best,
1 Recommendation
Universiti Teknologi MARA
Theoretically it is but practically it is not. This is because of the varying operating variables such as normal loads (unladen and laden state) and load transfer effects during braking. As such, we can refer to EEC Directive 75/524 as guide for brake efficiency and adhesion utilisation analyses in order to incorporate suitable brake bias or proportioning valves to ensure good efficiency or adhesion utilisation trough out the possible vehicle operating variables.
Politecnico di Torino
You are right: theoretically, braking distance does not depend on mass. But in practice, yes. The explanation is that tire effective friction coefficient cannot be assumed constant: it slightly decreases with increasing normal force. So braking distances are longer when more mass is added. As a limit example, consider that on trucks, the tire coefficient usually is smaller than 0.65 even on dry roads>
Related Publications
Improvement of vehicle dynamics in limit cornering have been studied. Simulations and tests have verified that vehicle stability and course trace performance in limit cornering have been improved by active brake control of each wheel. The controler manages vehicle yaw moment utilizing difference braking force between left and right wheels, and vehi...
This paper deals with the behavioral analysis of skid steer vehicles (SSVs). The basic turning characteristics of SSVs were clarified using a transfer function of a two-degrees of freedom vehicle model. In addition, the relationship between changes in the turning radius and vehicle speed at different acceleration/deceleration values, as well as the...
This article has been published in the journal, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering [© IMechE]. The definitive version is available at: http://journals.pepublishing.com/content/119783 Two actuation mechanisms are considered for the comparison of performance capabilities in improving the...