University of Pavia
Question
Asked 9th May, 2014
Can powder diffraction data distinguish between normal and inverse spinel structures?
I'm trying to determine whether a PDF card indicates a normal versus inverse spinel structure. Is this possible to determine using only angle and intensity in a powder pattern? This is for a Ni-Co-O spinel. Both ions are expected in both the octahedral and tetrahedral sites. My understanding is that the structure factors for Ni and Co are similar enough that it makes normal methods difficult.
Most recent answer
As also suggested in the other answers, with powder diffraction is not possible distinguish the inversioni of spinels with elements so similar for what concern the scattering factors. I think it is very difficult!!
All Answers (6)
Technische Universität Braunschweig
I guess it is not easily possible. I do know it very well for magnetite (inverse) and maghemite (normal) that it is almost impossible to resolve the two phases by doing simple XRD. I would suggest using techniques such as XAS, XPS, SANS or Mössbauer Spec.
1 Recommendation
University of Oviedo
Using neutron diffraction one can distinguish much better Co ( 2.49 fm) from Ni (10.3 fm) and O (5.80 fm) because they have different scattering lengths (in paranthesis).
Washington State University
These are good suggestions. However, my samples are thin films and have far too small volumes for neutron diffraction or Mossbauer and probably SANS. I have done XPS on them. These materials can be high or low spin Co2+, Co3+, Ni2+, Ni3+, Ni4+ some in both octahedral and tetrahedral sites. XPS interpretation is quite difficult. I think XAS will only give me valence information, which could be complementary to the XPS..
Any other ideas?
Semnan University
You should Know that some of materials have same XRD patterns because of the nearly same electron populations and crystal structure. So, when you take XRD pattern and find that the pattern is the same of the other, I suggest you use ICP for elemental analysis to find the exact amounts of the elements and use XPS analysis to find the cation environment. You can use EPR to find that I there is an unpaired electron or not.
University of Guelph
If you are looking for inversion symmetry or the lack of it, then powder diffraction will not distinguish between the two. You will have to use a single crystal for x-rays.
Similar questions and discussions
Related Publications
We demonstrate that powder diffraction data can be collected from sub-micron crystals of a mbrane protein with nearly two orders of magnitude more atoms than the molecules commonly used for powder diffraction. The crystals of photosystem-1 protein were size-selected using a 500 nm pore- size filter and delivered to a soft x-ray beam with a photon e...
BENEFRI is a convention involving the Universities of Bern, Neuchâtel and Fribourg. It was established in 1993 and the branch convention in chemistry was signed in 1994. The objective is to promote co-operation between the Institutes of Chemistry of the three universities. In
this way it is hoped to economize on equipment and to establish joint tea...
This report lists eighteen quality powder x-ray diffraction patterns produced at Mound for various explosives of recent and current interest. In each case the best possible experimental pattern, obtained from the substance in question via automated diffractometric step-scans, was compared with the corresponding pattern, calculated from the lattice...