Figure 3 - uploaded by Nabo Muravu
Content may be subject to copyright.
Types of Change Source: Balogun & Hope Hailey (2004) The figure identifies four types of strategic change plotted against the nature of change and the end state. 2.1.3.10 The 'Cultural Web' Culture is 'how things are done around here' (Drennan, 1992). Johnson (1990), Johnson and Scholes (1999), Johnson et al (2005) and Knight & Marshall (2008, p.270), devised the cultural behavior model as a technique for managing change. They tried to explain why firms often fail to adjust to environmental change as quickly as required. The model is concerned with the manifestations of culture in organisations and identifies six interrelated elements, namely: Symbols / titles: Symbolic aspects of the organization, Power structures: Core assumptions and important beliefs Organisational structures: Formal or informal systems Control systems: Measurements and reward systems Rituals / routines: Interactive behaviour and rituals Myths / stories: Embed organizational history into the present Johnson (1990) concluded that firms developed a way of comprehending their organisation -a paradigm or shared mindset -out of which they could not think if it were particularly strong. Together with Lewin's forcefield analysis, the 'cultural web' is a useful means of identifying obstructions to and potential accelerators for change. 2.1.4 Styles for Managing Change Styles of change management describe how the change process is actually managed. They are not new at all but to some extent reworking and expansion of the 'design choices' in the Balogun and Hope Hailey's change model. They sit on a continuum ranging from "coercion" in which change is forced on people, through 'collaboration' and 'participation' in which employees are involved on what and how to change, to 'education' and 'delegation' in which change is mostly delegated. 2.1.5 Resistance to Change Even with the best planned change process, some reaction to change is inevitable. Negative reactions are bound to be experienced in overt behaviour or passive resistance. There are four basic reactions to change and these can be countered in various ways. Disengagement: Refers to psychological withdrawal from change which is countered by involving the affected individual to freely identify and address their concerns. Disidentification: The individual's identity feels threatened by the change and they must be involved to establish change ownership and commitment. Disenchantment: Is usually expressed as negativity, anger or coalition building. The anger must be managed, acknowledged as normal and not held against them. Disorientation: The employee become lost and confused and change must be explained to minimise the ambiguity that they experience. Managers must be able to diagnose these reactions especially because each brings with it significant and different concerns such that there is no 'one best way' to address them. The traditional view of managing resistance to change is to treat it as something to be overcome but the contemporary view holds resistance simply as some form of feedback which can be used very productively to manage the change process. The key strategies for managing resistance to change are communication, participation, empathy and support.

Types of Change Source: Balogun & Hope Hailey (2004) The figure identifies four types of strategic change plotted against the nature of change and the end state. 2.1.3.10 The 'Cultural Web' Culture is 'how things are done around here' (Drennan, 1992). Johnson (1990), Johnson and Scholes (1999), Johnson et al (2005) and Knight & Marshall (2008, p.270), devised the cultural behavior model as a technique for managing change. They tried to explain why firms often fail to adjust to environmental change as quickly as required. The model is concerned with the manifestations of culture in organisations and identifies six interrelated elements, namely: Symbols / titles: Symbolic aspects of the organization, Power structures: Core assumptions and important beliefs Organisational structures: Formal or informal systems Control systems: Measurements and reward systems Rituals / routines: Interactive behaviour and rituals Myths / stories: Embed organizational history into the present Johnson (1990) concluded that firms developed a way of comprehending their organisation -a paradigm or shared mindset -out of which they could not think if it were particularly strong. Together with Lewin's forcefield analysis, the 'cultural web' is a useful means of identifying obstructions to and potential accelerators for change. 2.1.4 Styles for Managing Change Styles of change management describe how the change process is actually managed. They are not new at all but to some extent reworking and expansion of the 'design choices' in the Balogun and Hope Hailey's change model. They sit on a continuum ranging from "coercion" in which change is forced on people, through 'collaboration' and 'participation' in which employees are involved on what and how to change, to 'education' and 'delegation' in which change is mostly delegated. 2.1.5 Resistance to Change Even with the best planned change process, some reaction to change is inevitable. Negative reactions are bound to be experienced in overt behaviour or passive resistance. There are four basic reactions to change and these can be countered in various ways. Disengagement: Refers to psychological withdrawal from change which is countered by involving the affected individual to freely identify and address their concerns. Disidentification: The individual's identity feels threatened by the change and they must be involved to establish change ownership and commitment. Disenchantment: Is usually expressed as negativity, anger or coalition building. The anger must be managed, acknowledged as normal and not held against them. Disorientation: The employee become lost and confused and change must be explained to minimise the ambiguity that they experience. Managers must be able to diagnose these reactions especially because each brings with it significant and different concerns such that there is no 'one best way' to address them. The traditional view of managing resistance to change is to treat it as something to be overcome but the contemporary view holds resistance simply as some form of feedback which can be used very productively to manage the change process. The key strategies for managing resistance to change are communication, participation, empathy and support.

Source publication
Article
Full-text available
Non-profit organisations (NPOs) play a critical role in society’s political and socio-economic development as more cost-effective, flexible and less bureaucratic surrogates for governments. This paper focuses on the management of strategic change in this rarely researched sector. The study critically reviewed the management of strategic change in a...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... and Hope Hailey (2005) and Johnson and Scholes (2005) identified the following four types of strategic change (see Figure 3). Adaptation: Refers to incremental change which doesn't require shift in the present paradigm. ...
Context 2
... rewards addressed the short-term need for market competitiveness while culture change provides us with capabilities for future success. (Director 3, COMESA). COMESA ensures fair and competitive remuneration for its staff by conducting salary surveys every two years and adjusting its remuneration regime accordingly. ...

Similar publications

Article
Full-text available
This research analyzes how gender equality influences the participation of European senior citizens in a range of volunteering activities (Social Awareness, Professional and Political, Education, and Religion). The main contribution is the simultaneous consideration of different levels of data aggregation: individual, national and welfare system. T...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The influx of non-profit organizations over the last decades is not deniable. Unfortunately, management accounting practices have not been introduced with the same frequency as in for-profit organizations. Therefore, this study is conducted to uncover that management accounting is still visible and being practiced in non-profit organizations. In pa...
Article
Full-text available
The world of travel and tourism have perhaps changed forever as a result of COVID-19; considered the worst global pandemic to affect the world, post World War II. The spread of the Coronavirus diseases was considerably attributed to the travel and tourism industry, and with the attempt to curb the spread of the virus, the industry experienced calam...
Thesis
Full-text available
Establishing a family is a major step in everyone’s life. Changing expectations to culturally and socially defined beliefs in the gender roles of modern Japanese families have led to a significant realignment of fathers’ responsibilities within the home and childcare. Gender equality in Japan lags behind many of the OECD countries of the developed...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Alternative healthcare, community development, social justice, and education are all areas where non-governmental organisations (NGOs) are increasingly being recognised or promoted, but these efforts are hampered by government inefficiency and resource constraints. However, the statement of non-profit organisations is more complicated t...

Citations

... The early SPMM practices, albeit being based on financial measures, were devised by practitioners and not academic researchers and were complimented by cost accounting concepts later appearing in influential academic literature. The actual managerial accounting records revealed that accounting simply kept pace with the informational needs of large single- (Muravu, 2020) *This relates mainly to "grey" or unpublished literature that is undated. Common "grey" literature refers to literary materials and research produced by institutions other than traditional commercial or academic publishers and distributors (GreyNet, 1999; Wikipedia, 2019). ...
... TSOs are a crucial contributing sector to the globalised economy and assist central government in pursuing social objectives. They execute social programmes resulting in positive social change hence they have become a prominent feature in many countries (Salamon & Anheier, 1997;Brickley & Van Horn, 2000;Muravu, 2011Muravu, , 2020. NPOs more than tripled in the last 3 decades of the 20 th century (Ebrahim 2003) and rapid growth was attributed to donors" confidence that NPOs are more cost effective than governments in delivering key social services, had better reach to society"s underprivileged and poor, and play a key democratisation role globally. ...
... This includes, improving TSO work given the complex numerous problems they face in program and service delivery in dynamic environment, to ascertain their organisational effectiveness in achieving mutually identified socio-development goals, facilitate crossorganisation performance comparisons to satisfy increased funders and regulators requirements. Anheier (2000) and Muravu (2011Muravu ( , 2020 claim that NPO models range from approximating a government agency; resembling a business firm to being slightly more than a mere informal network. Admittedly, TSOs" performance has been handled through various conceptual frameworks and utilised in different managerial processes. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose - There has been a substantial amount of literature on strategic performance measurement and management (SPMM) especially following the so called "performance measurement revolution" of the 1980s and 1990s. However, the bulk of it pertains the private sector. This paper explores the genesis and trajectory of SPMM and dispenses with some common equivocations on the subject thereby contributing to scarce public and third sector SPMM literature Design/Method/Approach - The study utilised a systematic literature review to conduct a thematic analysis on the precedents and antecedents of SPMM in the private, public and third sectors. Findings - SPMM is centuries old and has existed since ancient civilisations or human trade. Earliest mention of private sector SPMM was around 220 AD. Public sector SPMM dates to around 1900 through the work of the New York Bureau of Municipal Research, while third sector SPMM is traceable to post-WWII,accelerating in the 1960s and 1970s. SPPM therefore developed in a phased and parallel manner between the public and private sectors since around 1900 and for all three sectors since the 1960s. During the 1990s, there was wholesale implementation of modern multi-dimensional SPMM systems, first in the private sector then concurrently in the public and third sectors. Since then, SPMM evolved with emphasis on embracing new managerial innovations and customising then to purpose-fit based on diverse sectoral, institutional and country contexts driven by fast-paced change in the environment. Research Limitations - Research was too broad, the literature too diverse hence the systematic review was cumbersome and time-consuming considering attendant constraints and could impact replicability. Practical Implications - The paper makes a direct contribution to strategic performance measurement and management theory and practice which is invaluable since SPMM is a highly practitioner dependent field. Originality/value - The systematic review was a marathon study which interrogated the development and trajectory of the field of SPMM in the private, public and third sectors. The study constitutes the single most comprehensive application of systematic literature review to the SPMM field, which concurrently explores the rarely covered yet crucial aspects of public and third sector SPMM, thereby providing unique insights and contributions to literature.
... The early SPMM practices, albeit being based on financial measures, were devised by practitioners and not academic researchers and were complimented by cost accounting concepts later appearing in influential academic literature. The actual managerial accounting records revealed that accounting simply kept pace with the informational needs of large single- (Muravu, 2020) *This relates mainly to "grey" or unpublished literature that is undated. Common "grey" literature refers to literary materials and research produced by institutions other than traditional commercial or academic publishers and distributors (GreyNet, 1999; Wikipedia, 2019). ...
... TSOs are a crucial contributing sector to the globalised economy and assist central government in pursuing social objectives. They execute social programmes resulting in positive social change hence they have become a prominent feature in many countries (Salamon & Anheier, 1997;Brickley & Van Horn, 2000;Muravu, 2011Muravu, , 2020. NPOs more than tripled in the last 3 decades of the 20 th century (Ebrahim 2003) and rapid growth was attributed to donors" confidence that NPOs are more cost effective than governments in delivering key social services, had better reach to society"s underprivileged and poor, and play a key democratisation role globally. ...
... This includes, improving TSO work given the complex numerous problems they face in program and service delivery in dynamic environment, to ascertain their organisational effectiveness in achieving mutually identified socio-development goals, facilitate crossorganisation performance comparisons to satisfy increased funders and regulators requirements. Anheier (2000) and Muravu (2011Muravu ( , 2020 claim that NPO models range from approximating a government agency; resembling a business firm to being slightly more than a mere informal network. Admittedly, TSOs" performance has been handled through various conceptual frameworks and utilised in different managerial processes. ...
Article
الأزمة هي حدث غير متوقع ومفاجئ، يتم فيه تسليط الضوء على الفجوة الاستراتيجية بسبب عدم وجود التكيف مع التغييرات التي تحدث في بيئة المنظمة، تؤدي الأزمة إلى تغيير تنظيمي سريع وظروف اقتصادية متقلبة ومشاكل للعاملين والتغيرات التكنولوجية غير المتوقعة والآثار السياسية، لذا هدف البحث إلى تحديد واقع القيادة الاستراتيجية الممثلة (الشخصية الاستراتيجية، والتفكير الاستراتيجي، التغيير الاستراتيجي، والقرارات الاستراتيجية) وفاعلية إدارة الأزمات الممثلة (اتخاذ قرار الاستجابة، الاتصالات وتدفق المعلومات، حشد وتعبئة الموارد) في وزارة الصحة العراقية من خلال تحليل إجابات عينة من رؤساء الأقسام والشعب في الوزارة بلغت (56) موظف، حيث وجد البحث أن هناك تأثيرا إحصائيا للقيادة الاستراتيجية بجميع أبعادها بفاعلية إدارة الأزمات، وتبين أن التفكير الاستراتيجي لدى القيادات الادارية في الوزارة لم يكن بالمستوى المقبول في التأثير بمراحل إدارة الأزمة وتعزيز فرصة تحسين سرعة قرار الاستجابة. مع وجود توجه لتوظيف التغير الحاصل في الموارد لإحداث المزيد من التغيرات في مجال بناء قدرات لإدارة الأزمة. وأوصى البحث بضرورة زيادة قدرة الوزارة على التعلم من الأزمات السابقة عبر تحليل أدائها السابق وأسباب إخفاقاتها السابقة وتقييم كفاية وفاعلية خطط وبرامج إدارة الأزمات السابقة بقصد تحسينها وكما يمكن مقارنة خططها وممارساتها في إدارة الأزمة مع دول أو مؤسسات أخرى ودمج الدروس المستفادة في خطط إدارة الأزمة فضلا عن توثيق وخزن المعرفة المتحصلة من تجربة التعامل مع الأزمات السابقة.