Fig 2 - uploaded by Sergio Cellone
Content may be subject to copyright.
Top : 1 × 1 contour plot ( g band) of N50. The faintest and brightest contours displayed are 25 and 20 mag arcsec − 1 , respectively, with 0.25 mag arcsec − 1 separation between concentric contour levels. North is up and East to the left. Bottom left : greyscale plot after subtraction of a Sérsic model. Orientation and scale are the same as in the upper panel. Bottom right : enlarged view (15 × 15 ) of the central region with identification for the knots (see Table 1) 

Top : 1 × 1 contour plot ( g band) of N50. The faintest and brightest contours displayed are 25 and 20 mag arcsec − 1 , respectively, with 0.25 mag arcsec − 1 separation between concentric contour levels. North is up and East to the left. Bottom left : greyscale plot after subtraction of a Sérsic model. Orientation and scale are the same as in the upper panel. Bottom right : enlarged view (15 × 15 ) of the central region with identification for the knots (see Table 1) 

Source publication
Article
Full-text available
Conflicting evidence has been recently raised in order to use surface brightness profiles of dwarf galaxies as a distance indicator. In this paper we discuss in some detail the main error sources in profile fitting procedures for galaxies with more than one physical component, showing their impact on the resulting shape parameters. The apparent tig...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... conditions and other internal bias sources (e.g. ongoing star formation) act in facts in the sense of disturbing galaxy morphology making any fitting procedure somewhat dependent on galaxy apparent size and on environment conditions as well. In spite of any standard criterion to single out the bulge component, it is clear however that by simply ne- glecting the problem one would more likely tend to predict too “spiked” galaxy profiles preferring lower values of N (Andredakis et al. 1995). We will turn back on this point and its impact on the L − N relationship in Sect. 4. The galaxy N50 was originally classified as dEpec, N/BCDring by Ferguson & Sandage (1990). Because of poor spatial resolution, C99 failed to detect any BCD feature in this object eventually appearing as a normal dE, based also on its ( B − V ) 0 = 0 . 76 (cf. Caldwell & Bothun 1987). In any case, this would make N50 an interesting object because it is, along with N42, one of the two brightest dEs with convex profile (i.e., N > 1) in the C99 sample. To better assess its evolutionary properties, we collected new observations of N50 with the EFOSC2 cam- era at the ESO 3.6 m telescope in La Silla, Chile, on the nights of April 16 and 17, 1999, as a part of a study of the low surface brightness galaxy population of the NGC 5044 Group. A detailed description of the observations and image processing will be given in a forthcoming paper (Buzzoni et al. 2001). Direct images of this galaxy were obtained under sub-arcsec seeing conditions in the g , r , i , and z bands of the Gunn system (Schneider et al. 1983). Data reduction has been accom- plished using the IRAF 2 package achieving a ± 0 . 001 mag internal error, while external magnitude uncertainty from standard zero points amounted to ± 0 . 03 mag. Surface brightness profiles have been obtained in the four bands down S ∼ 28 mag arcsec − 2 . Direct imaging has been complemented also with long- slit spectroscopy between 4300 and 6300 A at 6 A FWHM wavelength resolution. Supplementary spectroscopic observations have been also carried out in the range 3500– 5400 A at 8 A FWHM resolution with a Boller & Chivens spectrograph at the 2.15 m telescope of the CASLEO ob- servatory in San Juan, Argentina on April 9, 1997. Figure 2 ( top panel ) shows a 1 × 1 g band contour plot of N50 (the stellar PSF FWHM is 0 . 96). The central r ≤ 3 . 5 (400 h − 0 1 pc) region shows several knots surround- ing a central cusp. These features are better seen after subtraction of a Sérsic model ( bottom left panel ), and even a probable dust lane can be appreciated west of the nucleus. An enlarged map that identifies the central knots is also reported in the figure ( bottom right ). Table 1 reports a full summary of the galaxy photometry, including aperture magnitudes and detailed measurements of the single knots. For the latter features, we tried different clean-up procedures to subtract the smooth galaxy contribution; however, a plain subtraction of the lo- cal “background” measured around each source eventually revealed the best choice. The internal photometric error amounted in this case to ± 0 . 004 mag in each band. The g surface brightness profile of N50 is shown in Fig. 3. Error bars including photon noise and sky level uncertainty have been taken into account in the plot. The bottom panel shows the g i colour profile (after slightly degrading the i frame to the g PSF to consistently sample surface luminosity). Note in the figure the blue colour bump about 3 from the centre due to the knotty ring. A smooth colour gradient is also evident along galaxy radius with the outermost regions sensibly bluer than the centre. This colour gradient affects the value of the parameter N , which increases monotonically from N = 1 . 39 in g to N = 1 . 63 in z , sampling the range 8 ≤ r ≤ 28 . The location of N50 in a g − r vs. g − i colour diagram is shown in Fig. 4. In the main panel of the figure we compared galaxy integrated colours with the locus of Main Sequence stars (based on the Vilnius spectral atlas of Straizys & Sviderskiene 1972), as well as with the theoretical colours for 15 Gyr template galaxies of different morphological type according to the three-zone synthesis models of Buzzoni (1998, 2000). As expected, N50 colours are slightly bluer than high-mass ellipticals, and intermediate between E and Sa Hubble types. A more detailed match of the population synthesis pre- dictions with the N50 colour profile and with the nuclear knotty features is attempted in the insert panel of Fig. 4. Buzzoni’s (1989) simple stellar population (SSP) models, computed for a Salpeter IMF, red horizontal branch morphology, and different metallicity ([Fe/H] = − 0 . 25 , 0 . 0, and +0 . 30) are reported, tracking evolution from 5 to 15 Gyrs. N50 aperture photometry at 2 . 5, 10 , and 30 is displayed together with individual photometry of the visible knots according to the identification number in Table 1 (see also the reference map in Fig. 2). A substantial agreement seems to exist between theoretical models and observations within the zero-point uncertainty in the magnitude scale. An old (10–15 Gyr) stellar population with slightly sub-solar metallicity ([Fe/H] ∼ − 0 . 2) appears to be the main component in N50 but a mild [Fe/H] radial gradient might also exist inducing the blueing colour drift along galaxy radius. Quite interestingly, nuclear knots reveal a much larger (and statistically significant) spread in colour. Knot #1 (the nucleus?) appears indeed even redder than the galaxy core, as do those lying close to the apparent dust lane (#8) visible one arcsec west of the nucleus (cf. Fig. 2). Dust reddening might be “patchy” on the N50 central region, with the west area (corresponding to knots # 1, 6, 7, near the dust lane # 8) slightly more obscured [∆ E ( B − V ) ∼ 0 . 05] than the east side (i.e., about knots # 3 and 4). Data in Fig. 4 are not corrected for our own Galaxy reddening (which however should not exceed E ( B − V ) ∼ 0 . 03 according to Burstein & Heiles 1982). In addition, one should also consider a little blue shift of all the galaxy data by ∆( g − r ) 0 . 012 and ∆( g − i ) 0 . 015 to take into account for k-correction. Even correcting for these effects, it seems likely however that the whole stellar population in N50 should consist of stars older than 5 Gyr, and only a much enhanced (super-solar) metallicity should be in- voked to predict a younger age. The spread in age among the galaxy stellar population is even more evident from the analysis of the integrated spectrum, shown in Fig. 5. Galaxy spectral energy distribution has been obtained by matching the CASLEO data in the range 3500 ≤ λ ≤ 4400 A with ESO observations (4400 ≤ λ ≤ 6300 A), adding then the monochromatic fluxes from the integrated g , r , i , and z magnitudes. Gunn photometry also set the absolute flux calibration reproducing galaxy energy distribution within the central 15 aperture. Two SSP models from the Buzzoni (1989) data set, with [Fe/H] = − 0 . 25 and age 5 and 15 Gyrs, are superposed on the plot. The older model fits well along the opti- cal and red wavelength while it lacks UV luminosity below 4500 A. On the contrary, the 5 Gyr stellar population pro- vides a good fit to the ultraviolet but it would predict too blue Gunn colours. Accounting for SSP luminosity evolution, in a simple interpretative scheme assuming a mix of these two main stellar components, this allows us to estimate that the old (15 Gyr) population comprises about 3/4 of the total mass of the galaxy. The redshift of N50, as derived from our spectra, amounts to cz = 2391 ± 97 km s − 1 (that is z = 0 . 0080 ± 0 . 0003). This yields a distance to the galaxy of 23 . 9 h − 0 1 Mpc and a distance modulus ( m − M ) = 31 . 9 − 5 log( h 0 ). From the model fit of Fig. 5, a bolo- metric correction to g of ( Bol − g ) = − 1 . 01 can be obtained, leading for N50 to M bol = − 17 . 7 + 5 log( h 0 ). This is L = 9 . 3 10 8 h − 2 L or M = − 16 . 1 + 5 log( h ). Estimating a theoretical M/L bol 5 1 from the relevant SSP models of Buzzoni (1989) (once accounting for the whole stellar mass by integrating the Salpeter IMF) then one obtains M tot ∼ 4 . 5( ± 1 . 0) 10 9 h − 0 2 M as a fair estimate of the total (stellar) mass of N50. In its overall morphology, N50 is very reminiscent of the dwarf ( M B = − 16 . 71 mag) galaxy Markarian 996, which Thuan et al. (1996) report to have smooth elliptical isophotes, with several bright knots and dust patches in its central ( ∼ 400 pc) region. However, contrary to what we observe in N50, Mrk 996 clearly shows signs of active ongoing star formation in its centre, thus fitting with a nE BCD (nuclear-elliptical blue-compact-dwarf) classifi- cation. The age we derive for the blue knots in N50 (see Fig. 6) suggests that it may have looked very similar to Mrk 996 a few Gyrs ago. Although now observed in its more quiescent evolutionary stage, the H β and 3727 A [OII] emission lines, prominent in our spectrum of the galaxy, still witness the presence of a wealth residual gas. In this sense, N50 probably represents an ideal link in the dE–BCD connec- tion (Thuan 1985; Evans et al. 1990; Meurer et al. 1992). Quite importantly, it is also worth noting from Fig. 6 that even any massive intervening starburst activity older than 2 Gyr, superposed to the galaxy “quiescent” old stellar component, would still maintain integrated colours redder than ( B − V ) = 0 . 7. According to the YC00 colour selection criterium, active dwarf ellipticals would therefore be recognized as “standard” galaxies in the L − N relationship. Despite such a negligible effect on the integrated colours, starburst episodes could however much more strongly affect galaxy surface brightness profiles. In the case of N50, for example, the presence of the bright knotty ring around the centre certainly modulates the Sérsic shape parameter leading to a higher fitting value for N . Each of the three ...
Context 2
... actually has a convex profile”, meaning the three “outliers” N42, N49, and N50. One of the questioned objects in the C99 sample is galaxy N42, for which C99 indicates N = 1 . 43 to be compared with N = 0 . 60 in the YC00 fit. At least two evident weak points emerge, in our opinion, from the YC00 analysis. Contrary to the C99 fitting procedure, that only relied on the S/N > 1 portion of galaxy surface brightness profile (i.e. with I ( r ) > σ SKY ), the new fit extends much farther from galaxy centre. In the outermost regions, photon noise and statistical uncertainty in the sky subtraction begin to dominate causing the output profile to artificially level off at large radii. By itself, this effect works in inducing nominally “concave” (i.e., N < 1) surface brightness profiles throughout in the YC00 fit (see Andredakis et al. 1995 for similar conclusions dealing with bulge deconvolution in spiral galaxies). In addition, even at first glance (cf. Fig. 1) the N42 surface brightness profile reveals at least two distinct components: an inner bulge and a main body extending out to ∼ 50 . This galaxy would therefore need a multi- component scheme (e.g.: Papaderos et al. 1996) to prop- erly decompose its profile. Cellone’s (1999) model for the N42 main component provided an integrated magnitude V T = 15 . 3 mag. After subtraction, this leaves the inner bulge component, with V bulge = 16 . 4, and extending out to r 17 , as evident from Fig. 1. Although this decom- position scheme might probably be not unique, it shows however that the main morphological component of the galaxy, providing about 3/4 of the total V luminosity, is in fact suitably fitted by the original “convex” profile. Our choice is also supported by a χ 2 test on the fitting residuals confirming that a simple Sérsic fit can be ruled out at a 95% confidence level. As a comparison, Fig. 1 ( lower panel ) also shows the profile of the bright dwarf N29. In this case, no change in slope is evident, and a single Sérsic law (with N = 0 . 54) fits nicely this profile all along its useful range, as confirmed again by the χ 2 statistics. The case of N51 (the second galaxy disputed by YC00) is similar to that of N42, although not so extreme, while for the third object, the previously uncatalogued galaxy N95A, C99 reported an exceedingly low surface brightness ( S 0 ∼ 24 mag arcsec − 2 ) that definitely prevented any reliable fit. For this reason this galaxy was not included in any subsequent analysis. While statistical tests support in our case both the choice of a two-component fit for N42, and a simple Sérsic law for N29, more generally any suitable correction for the bulge contribution in dwarf galaxies may be a non- univocal task. Seeing conditions and other internal bias sources (e.g. ongoing star formation) act in facts in the sense of disturbing galaxy morphology making any fitting procedure somewhat dependent on galaxy apparent size and on environment conditions as well. In spite of any standard criterion to single out the bulge component, it is clear however that by simply ne- glecting the problem one would more likely tend to predict too “spiked” galaxy profiles preferring lower values of N (Andredakis et al. 1995). We will turn back on this point and its impact on the L − N relationship in Sect. 4. The galaxy N50 was originally classified as dEpec, N/BCDring by Ferguson & Sandage (1990). Because of poor spatial resolution, C99 failed to detect any BCD feature in this object eventually appearing as a normal dE, based also on its ( B − V ) 0 = 0 . 76 (cf. Caldwell & Bothun 1987). In any case, this would make N50 an interesting object because it is, along with N42, one of the two brightest dEs with convex profile (i.e., N > 1) in the C99 sample. To better assess its evolutionary properties, we collected new observations of N50 with the EFOSC2 cam- era at the ESO 3.6 m telescope in La Silla, Chile, on the nights of April 16 and 17, 1999, as a part of a study of the low surface brightness galaxy population of the NGC 5044 Group. A detailed description of the observations and image processing will be given in a forthcoming paper (Buzzoni et al. 2001). Direct images of this galaxy were obtained under sub-arcsec seeing conditions in the g , r , i , and z bands of the Gunn system (Schneider et al. 1983). Data reduction has been accom- plished using the IRAF 2 package achieving a ± 0 . 001 mag internal error, while external magnitude uncertainty from standard zero points amounted to ± 0 . 03 mag. Surface brightness profiles have been obtained in the four bands down S ∼ 28 mag arcsec − 2 . Direct imaging has been complemented also with long- slit spectroscopy between 4300 and 6300 A at 6 A FWHM wavelength resolution. Supplementary spectroscopic observations have been also carried out in the range 3500– 5400 A at 8 A FWHM resolution with a Boller & Chivens spectrograph at the 2.15 m telescope of the CASLEO ob- servatory in San Juan, Argentina on April 9, 1997. Figure 2 ( top panel ) shows a 1 × 1 g band contour plot of N50 (the stellar PSF FWHM is 0 . 96). The central r ≤ 3 . 5 (400 h − 0 1 pc) region shows several knots surround- ing a central cusp. These features are better seen after subtraction of a Sérsic model ( bottom left panel ), and even a probable dust lane can be appreciated west of the nucleus. An enlarged map that identifies the central knots is also reported in the figure ( bottom right ). Table 1 reports a full summary of the galaxy photometry, including aperture magnitudes and detailed measurements of the single knots. For the latter features, we tried different clean-up procedures to subtract the smooth galaxy contribution; however, a plain subtraction of the lo- cal “background” measured around each source eventually revealed the best choice. The internal photometric error amounted in this case to ± 0 . 004 mag in each band. The g surface brightness profile of N50 is shown in Fig. 3. Error bars including photon noise and sky level uncertainty have been taken into account in the plot. The bottom panel shows the g i colour profile (after slightly degrading the i frame to the g PSF to consistently sample surface luminosity). Note in the figure the blue colour bump about 3 from the centre due to the knotty ring. A smooth colour gradient is also evident along galaxy radius with the outermost regions sensibly bluer than the centre. This colour gradient affects the value of the parameter N , which increases monotonically from N = 1 . 39 in g to N = 1 . 63 in z , sampling the range 8 ≤ r ≤ 28 . The location of N50 in a g − r vs. g − i colour diagram is shown in Fig. 4. In the main panel of the figure we compared galaxy integrated colours with the locus of Main Sequence stars (based on the Vilnius spectral atlas of Straizys & Sviderskiene 1972), as well as with the theoretical colours for 15 Gyr template galaxies of different morphological type according to the three-zone synthesis models of Buzzoni (1998, 2000). As expected, N50 colours are slightly bluer than high-mass ellipticals, and intermediate between E and Sa Hubble types. A more detailed match of the population synthesis pre- dictions with the N50 colour profile and with the nuclear knotty features is attempted in the insert panel of Fig. 4. Buzzoni’s (1989) simple stellar population (SSP) models, computed for a Salpeter IMF, red horizontal branch morphology, and different metallicity ([Fe/H] = − 0 . 25 , 0 . 0, and +0 . 30) are reported, tracking evolution from 5 to 15 Gyrs. N50 aperture photometry at 2 . 5, 10 , and 30 is displayed together with individual photometry of the visible knots according to the identification number in Table 1 (see also the reference map in Fig. 2). A substantial agreement seems to exist between theoretical models and observations within the zero-point uncertainty in the magnitude scale. An old (10–15 Gyr) stellar population with slightly sub-solar metallicity ([Fe/H] ∼ − 0 . 2) appears to be the main component in N50 but a mild [Fe/H] radial gradient might also exist inducing the blueing colour drift along galaxy radius. Quite interestingly, nuclear knots reveal a much larger (and statistically significant) spread in colour. Knot #1 (the nucleus?) appears indeed even redder than the galaxy core, as do those lying close to the apparent dust lane (#8) visible one arcsec west of the nucleus (cf. Fig. 2). Dust reddening might be “patchy” on the N50 central region, with the west area (corresponding to knots # 1, 6, 7, near the dust lane # 8) slightly more obscured [∆ E ( B − V ) ∼ 0 . 05] than the east side (i.e., about knots # 3 and 4). Data in Fig. 4 are not corrected for our own Galaxy reddening (which however should not exceed E ( B − V ) ∼ 0 . 03 according to Burstein & Heiles 1982). In addition, one should also consider a little blue shift of all the galaxy data by ∆( g − r ) 0 . 012 and ∆( g − i ) 0 . 015 to take into account for k-correction. Even correcting for these effects, it seems likely however that the whole stellar population in N50 should consist of stars older than 5 Gyr, and only a much enhanced (super-solar) metallicity should be in- voked to predict a younger age. The spread in age among the galaxy stellar population is even more evident from the analysis of the integrated spectrum, shown in Fig. 5. Galaxy spectral energy distribution has been obtained by matching the CASLEO data in the range 3500 ≤ λ ≤ 4400 A with ESO observations (4400 ≤ λ ≤ 6300 A), adding then the monochromatic fluxes from the integrated g , r , i , and z magnitudes. Gunn photometry also set the absolute flux calibration reproducing galaxy energy distribution within the central 15 aperture. Two SSP models from the Buzzoni (1989) data set, with [Fe/H] = − 0 . 25 and age 5 and 15 Gyrs, are superposed on the plot. The older model fits well along the opti- cal and red wavelength while it lacks UV luminosity below 4500 A. On the contrary, the 5 Gyr stellar population pro- vides a ...
Context 3
... (1990). Because of poor spatial resolution, C99 failed to detect any BCD feature in this object eventually appearing as a normal dE, based also on its ( B − V ) 0 = 0 . 76 (cf. Caldwell & Bothun 1987). In any case, this would make N50 an interesting object because it is, along with N42, one of the two brightest dEs with convex profile (i.e., N > 1) in the C99 sample. To better assess its evolutionary properties, we collected new observations of N50 with the EFOSC2 cam- era at the ESO 3.6 m telescope in La Silla, Chile, on the nights of April 16 and 17, 1999, as a part of a study of the low surface brightness galaxy population of the NGC 5044 Group. A detailed description of the observations and image processing will be given in a forthcoming paper (Buzzoni et al. 2001). Direct images of this galaxy were obtained under sub-arcsec seeing conditions in the g , r , i , and z bands of the Gunn system (Schneider et al. 1983). Data reduction has been accom- plished using the IRAF 2 package achieving a ± 0 . 001 mag internal error, while external magnitude uncertainty from standard zero points amounted to ± 0 . 03 mag. Surface brightness profiles have been obtained in the four bands down S ∼ 28 mag arcsec − 2 . Direct imaging has been complemented also with long- slit spectroscopy between 4300 and 6300 A at 6 A FWHM wavelength resolution. Supplementary spectroscopic observations have been also carried out in the range 3500– 5400 A at 8 A FWHM resolution with a Boller & Chivens spectrograph at the 2.15 m telescope of the CASLEO ob- servatory in San Juan, Argentina on April 9, 1997. Figure 2 ( top panel ) shows a 1 × 1 g band contour plot of N50 (the stellar PSF FWHM is 0 . 96). The central r ≤ 3 . 5 (400 h − 0 1 pc) region shows several knots surround- ing a central cusp. These features are better seen after subtraction of a Sérsic model ( bottom left panel ), and even a probable dust lane can be appreciated west of the nucleus. An enlarged map that identifies the central knots is also reported in the figure ( bottom right ). Table 1 reports a full summary of the galaxy photometry, including aperture magnitudes and detailed measurements of the single knots. For the latter features, we tried different clean-up procedures to subtract the smooth galaxy contribution; however, a plain subtraction of the lo- cal “background” measured around each source eventually revealed the best choice. The internal photometric error amounted in this case to ± 0 . 004 mag in each band. The g surface brightness profile of N50 is shown in Fig. 3. Error bars including photon noise and sky level uncertainty have been taken into account in the plot. The bottom panel shows the g i colour profile (after slightly degrading the i frame to the g PSF to consistently sample surface luminosity). Note in the figure the blue colour bump about 3 from the centre due to the knotty ring. A smooth colour gradient is also evident along galaxy radius with the outermost regions sensibly bluer than the centre. This colour gradient affects the value of the parameter N , which increases monotonically from N = 1 . 39 in g to N = 1 . 63 in z , sampling the range 8 ≤ r ≤ 28 . The location of N50 in a g − r vs. g − i colour diagram is shown in Fig. 4. In the main panel of the figure we compared galaxy integrated colours with the locus of Main Sequence stars (based on the Vilnius spectral atlas of Straizys & Sviderskiene 1972), as well as with the theoretical colours for 15 Gyr template galaxies of different morphological type according to the three-zone synthesis models of Buzzoni (1998, 2000). As expected, N50 colours are slightly bluer than high-mass ellipticals, and intermediate between E and Sa Hubble types. A more detailed match of the population synthesis pre- dictions with the N50 colour profile and with the nuclear knotty features is attempted in the insert panel of Fig. 4. Buzzoni’s (1989) simple stellar population (SSP) models, computed for a Salpeter IMF, red horizontal branch morphology, and different metallicity ([Fe/H] = − 0 . 25 , 0 . 0, and +0 . 30) are reported, tracking evolution from 5 to 15 Gyrs. N50 aperture photometry at 2 . 5, 10 , and 30 is displayed together with individual photometry of the visible knots according to the identification number in Table 1 (see also the reference map in Fig. 2). A substantial agreement seems to exist between theoretical models and observations within the zero-point uncertainty in the magnitude scale. An old (10–15 Gyr) stellar population with slightly sub-solar metallicity ([Fe/H] ∼ − 0 . 2) appears to be the main component in N50 but a mild [Fe/H] radial gradient might also exist inducing the blueing colour drift along galaxy radius. Quite interestingly, nuclear knots reveal a much larger (and statistically significant) spread in colour. Knot #1 (the nucleus?) appears indeed even redder than the galaxy core, as do those lying close to the apparent dust lane (#8) visible one arcsec west of the nucleus (cf. Fig. 2). Dust reddening might be “patchy” on the N50 central region, with the west area (corresponding to knots # 1, 6, 7, near the dust lane # 8) slightly more obscured [∆ E ( B − V ) ∼ 0 . 05] than the east side (i.e., about knots # 3 and 4). Data in Fig. 4 are not corrected for our own Galaxy reddening (which however should not exceed E ( B − V ) ∼ 0 . 03 according to Burstein & Heiles 1982). In addition, one should also consider a little blue shift of all the galaxy data by ∆( g − r ) 0 . 012 and ∆( g − i ) 0 . 015 to take into account for k-correction. Even correcting for these effects, it seems likely however that the whole stellar population in N50 should consist of stars older than 5 Gyr, and only a much enhanced (super-solar) metallicity should be in- voked to predict a younger age. The spread in age among the galaxy stellar population is even more evident from the analysis of the integrated spectrum, shown in Fig. 5. Galaxy spectral energy distribution has been obtained by matching the CASLEO data in the range 3500 ≤ λ ≤ 4400 A with ESO observations (4400 ≤ λ ≤ 6300 A), adding then the monochromatic fluxes from the integrated g , r , i , and z magnitudes. Gunn photometry also set the absolute flux calibration reproducing galaxy energy distribution within the central 15 aperture. Two SSP models from the Buzzoni (1989) data set, with [Fe/H] = − 0 . 25 and age 5 and 15 Gyrs, are superposed on the plot. The older model fits well along the opti- cal and red wavelength while it lacks UV luminosity below 4500 A. On the contrary, the 5 Gyr stellar population pro- vides a good fit to the ultraviolet but it would predict too blue Gunn colours. Accounting for SSP luminosity evolution, in a simple interpretative scheme assuming a mix of these two main stellar components, this allows us to estimate that the old (15 Gyr) population comprises about 3/4 of the total mass of the galaxy. The redshift of N50, as derived from our spectra, amounts to cz = 2391 ± 97 km s − 1 (that is z = 0 . 0080 ± 0 . 0003). This yields a distance to the galaxy of 23 . 9 h − 0 1 Mpc and a distance modulus ( m − M ) = 31 . 9 − 5 log( h 0 ). From the model fit of Fig. 5, a bolo- metric correction to g of ( Bol − g ) = − 1 . 01 can be obtained, leading for N50 to M bol = − 17 . 7 + 5 log( h 0 ). This is L = 9 . 3 10 8 h − 2 L or M = − 16 . 1 + 5 log( h ). Estimating a theoretical M/L bol 5 1 from the relevant SSP models of Buzzoni (1989) (once accounting for the whole stellar mass by integrating the Salpeter IMF) then one obtains M tot ∼ 4 . 5( ± 1 . 0) 10 9 h − 0 2 M as a fair estimate of the total (stellar) mass of N50. In its overall morphology, N50 is very reminiscent of the dwarf ( M B = − 16 . 71 mag) galaxy Markarian 996, which Thuan et al. (1996) report to have smooth elliptical isophotes, with several bright knots and dust patches in its central ( ∼ 400 pc) region. However, contrary to what we observe in N50, Mrk 996 clearly shows signs of active ongoing star formation in its centre, thus fitting with a nE BCD (nuclear-elliptical blue-compact-dwarf) classifi- cation. The age we derive for the blue knots in N50 (see Fig. 6) suggests that it may have looked very similar to Mrk 996 a few Gyrs ago. Although now observed in its more quiescent evolutionary stage, the H β and 3727 A [OII] emission lines, prominent in our spectrum of the galaxy, still witness the presence of a wealth residual gas. In this sense, N50 probably represents an ideal link in the dE–BCD connec- tion (Thuan 1985; Evans et al. 1990; Meurer et al. 1992). Quite importantly, it is also worth noting from Fig. 6 that even any massive intervening starburst activity older than 2 Gyr, superposed to the galaxy “quiescent” old stellar component, would still maintain integrated colours redder than ( B − V ) = 0 . 7. According to the YC00 colour selection criterium, active dwarf ellipticals would therefore be recognized as “standard” galaxies in the L − N relationship. Despite such a negligible effect on the integrated colours, starburst episodes could however much more strongly affect galaxy surface brightness profiles. In the case of N50, for example, the presence of the bright knotty ring around the centre certainly modulates the Sérsic shape parameter leading to a higher fitting value for N . Each of the three “outliers” that depart from the L N relation in the NGC 5044 sample studied by C99 (namely N42, N49, and N50), displays a different kind of pecu- liarity. As shown in Sect. 2, N42 has a normal colour ( B − V = 0 . 75), but its morphology reveals the presence of a central bulge that should be accounted for in a multi- component fitting model. On the other hand, N49 is a very blue ( B − V = 0 . 49) irregular galaxy (C99), and cannot therefore be included in our analysis of the dwarf elliptical population. N50 takes only apparently the look of a standard dE object. In the previous section we showed that in spite of its quite normal B − V , this galaxy shows the ...

Similar publications

Article
Full-text available
The project started during 1996 and it have been initiated by prof. W. Seggewiss from Hoer List observatory, Bonn University. The project is conformable to the observa-tional possibilities of the Rozhen NAO and tke Belogradchik AO. From the program list with ca. 70 objects for further investigation 30 open cluster from three different groups were s...

Citations

... In this work we want to further follow up a longrange study on the low-mass LSB galaxy population of the NGC 5044 group. In particular, after assessing group morphology and membership in previous contributions (Cellone & Buzzoni 2001, we would like to tackle here the problem of galaxy evolutionary properties, according to a multiwavelength observational approach that includes integrated and surface-brightness multicolour photometry, further complemented in most cases with a spectroscopic input. Our analysis will rely on original stellar population synthesis models, to which refer galaxy data in order to lead to a convenient and physically self-consistent picture of the galaxy evolutionary status for the NGC 5044 group. ...
... While many bright dE/dS0 do show composite structure (i.e. "bulge"+"disk", see Cellone 1999;Cellone & Buzzoni 2001), we did not attempt here to make any profile decomposition; Sérsic shape parameter n thus traces the global morphology of each galaxy. All the calculations made use of the g-band or the V -band observations for the Eso and Casleo subsamples, respectively. ...
... In a few cases, however, the excursion toward even bluer colours, more appropriate to intermediate-type spirals, makes evident some star-formation activity among the dEs of lowest mass. Direct evidence in this sense has been collected for N50 (Cellone & Buzzoni 2001) displaying several blue knotty regions around its core. This may also be the case for N55, N93C, and N138, among the faintest dwarf ellipticals easily recognized also in Fig. 6 as "embedded" in the dSph region of the c-m diagram. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this third paper of a series we present Johnson–Gunn B, g, V, r, i, z multicolour photometry for 79 objects, including a significant fraction of the faintest galaxies around NGC 5044, assessing group membership on the basis of apparent morphology (through accurate Sérsic-profile fitting) and low-resolution (R= 500–1000) optical spectroscopy to estimate the redshift for 21 objects. Early- and late-type systems are found to be clearly separate in Sérsic parameter space, with the well-known luminosity versus shape relation being mostly traced by different morphological types spanning different ranges in the shape parameter n. A significantly blue colour is confirmed for Magellanic irregulars (Sm/Ims), while a drift toward bluer integrated colours is also an issue for dwarf ellipticals (dEs). Both features point to moderate but pervasive star-formation activity even among nominally ‘quiescent’ stellar systems. Together, dEs and Ims provide the bulk of the galaxy luminosity function, around M(g) ≃−18.0 ± 1.5, while the S0 and dwarf spheroidal (dSph) components dominate the bright and faint-end tails of the distribution respectively. This special mix places the NGC 5044 Group just ‘midway’ between the high-density cosmic aggregation scale typical of galaxy clusters and the low-density environment of looser galaxy clumps like our Local Group. The bright mass of the 136 member galaxies with available photometry and morphological classification, as inferred from appropriate M/L model fitting, amounts to a total of 2.3 × 1012 M⊙. This is one seventh of the total dynamical mass of the group, according to its X-ray emission. The current star-formation rate within the group turns to be about 23 M⊙ yr−1, a figure that may however be slightly increased as a result of the evident activity among dwarf ellipticals, as shown by enhanced Hβ emission in their spectra. Lick narrow-band indices have been computed for 17 galaxies, probing all the relevant atomic and molecular features in the 4300–5800 Å wavelength range. Dwarf ellipticals are found to share a subsolar metallicity (−1.0 ≲ [Fe/H] ≲− 0.5), with a clear decoupling between iron and α elements, as already established for high-mass systems. Both dEs and dS0s are consistent with a high age, about one Hubble time, although a possible bias towards higher values of age may be induced by the gas emission affecting the Hβ strength.
... Following Cellone & Buzzoni (2001), to get possible analytical profiles for the two components we first fitted a Sérsic law to the outer region of the galaxy in the range r = 6.0 − 11.8 arcsec (dashed line in FS90 110 panel of Fig. 3). Then, we subtracted the intensities of this model from the observed ones in the whole profile range. ...
... We are aware that this decomposition scheme might be not unique as it depends on the radial ranges selected to perform the fits, as well as on sky subtraction effects (see, for instance, Cellone & Buzzoni 2001, for a discussion about the art of profile fitting). However, the validity of our approach is supported by the small and stable residuals shown in Fig. 3. ...
Article
We present a photometric analysis of four galaxies classified as compact elliptical (cE) galaxies in the FS90 Antlia Group catalogue. Only 6 members of this rare type of galaxies are known until now. Using data in various photometric systems, we measured brightness and colour profiles, as well as structural parameters. By comparing them with those of other galaxies in the Antlia cluster, as well as with confirmed cE galaxies from the literature, we found that two of the FS90 cE candidates, albeit being spectroscopically confirmed Antlia members, are not cE galaxies. However, one of these objects presents strong ellipticity and position angle variations that resemble those already reported for M32, leading us to speculate about this kind of objects being progenitors of cE galaxies. The other two FS90 cE candidates, for which radial velocities are not available, match some features typical of cE galaxies like being close in projection to a larger galaxy, displaying flat colour profiles, and having a high degree of compactness. Only one of the remaining cE candidates shows a high central surface brightness, two components in its brightness profile, distinct changes in ellipticity and position angle where the outer component begins to dominate, and seems to follow the same trend as other confirmed cE galaxies in a luminosity versus mean effective surface brightness diagram. Moreover, it shows a distorted inner structure with similar characteristics to those found by simulations of interacting galaxies, and an extremely faint structure that seems to link this object with one of the Antlia dominant galaxies, has been detected in MOSAIC-CTIO, FORS1-VLT, and ACS-HST images. The cE nature of this galaxy as well as the possible interaction with its bright companion, still have to be confirmed through spectroscopy. Comment: 15 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS
... We here take a typical host and a typical dwarf galaxy and estimate their angular radii as a function of redshift. The host is a giant elliptical, 0230-027 (Dunlop et al. 2003) and the dwarf galaxy is N29, a member of the NGC 5044 group (Cellone & Buzzoni 2001). For the detection limit we use the Holmberg radius, i.e. the radius at which the surface magnitude is 26.5 mag arcsec −2 . ...
Article
Full-text available
Dwarf-galaxy sized dark matter halos may be detectable when a bright background source is gravitationally lensed on scales of milliarcseconds. Such effects can be caused by dark galaxies as well as luminous ones. Here we discuss conditions for detecting a luminous lensing object through direct imaging, via measurements of the point spread function (PSF) to subtract the quasar from the image, revealing the quasar host galaxy and any luminous lens. The technique applies to both types of millilensing effect, i.e. magnification and image splitting. We show that luminous dwarf-galaxy lenses should be detectable with this method up to redshifts z~0.2.
... However, this relation describes old, single population objects. A significant fraction of dE galaxies is known to harbour young or intermediate-age stellar populations (e.g., Cellone & Forte 1996), as well as hidden discs, bars, spiral structure (e.g., Drinkwater et al. 2001; Barazza et al. 2002;De Rijcke et al. 2003), or even ongoing star formation at their centres (e.g., Vigroux et al. 1984;Cellone & Buzzoni 2001;Lisker et al. 2006). van Zee et al. (2004) found in their sample of 16 Virgo dwarfs that all galaxies are dominated by populations in the age range 5-7 Gyrs. ...
Article
Full-text available
We present the first colour–magnitude relation (CMR) of early-type galaxies in the central region of the Antlia cluster, obtained from CCD wide-field photometry in the Washington photometric system. Integrated (C−T1) colours, T1 magnitudes, and effective radii have been measured for 93 galaxies (i.e. the largest galaxies sample in the Washington system till now) from the FS90 Antlia Group catalogue. Membership of 37 objects can be confirmed through new radial velocities and data collected from the literature. The resulting colour–magnitude diagram shows that early-type FS90 galaxies that are spectroscopically confirmed Antlia members or that were considered as definite members by FS90, follow a well-defined CMR that spans 9 mag in brightness with no apparent change of slope. This relation is very tight for the whole magnitude range but S0 galaxies show a larger dispersion, apparently due to a separation of ellipticals and S0s. Antlia displays a slope of −13.6 in a T1 versus (C−T1) diagram, in agreement with results for clusters like Fornax, Virgo, Coma and Perseus, which are dynamically different to Antlia. This fact might indicate that the build-up of the CMR in cluster of galaxies is more related to galaxies internal processes than to the influence of the environment. Interpreting the CMR as a luminosity–metallicity relation of old stellar systems, the metallicities of the Antlia galaxies define a global relation down to MV≈−13. We also find, for early-type dwarfs, no clear relation between luminosity and effective radius, indicating a nearly constant mean effective radius of ∼1 kpc. This value is also found in several samples of dwarf galaxies in Virgo and Coma.
... A subsample of 13 galaxies was also observed spectroscopically at ESO. First results, involving nearly 50% of these data, have been already presented [5,6,7]. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Detailed surface photometry for 79 (mostly dwarf) galaxies in the NGC 5044 Group area is analysed, revealing the existence of different morphologies among objects originally classified as early-type dwarfs. Particularly, a significant fraction of bright dwarf "ellipticals" show a distinct bulge+disc structure; we thus re-classify these objects as dwarf lenticulars (dS0). Our finding points at a possible scenario where these systems are the remnants of "harassed" disc galaxies. This is emphasized by the discovery of a few objects with hints for very low-surface brightness spiral-like structure. The colours. structure, and spatial distribution of the different galaxy types suggest that our classification may indeed be separating objects with different origins and/or evolutionary paths.
... Surface BV photometry for a small sample of dwarf and intermediate luminosity (mostly) elliptical galaxies in the NGC 5044 Group (of which 6 objects in common with the present work) has been presented in Cellone (1999, hereafter C99), while Khosroshahi et al. (2004) completed these results with a morphological study of a brighter sample of member galaxies, based on BRI photometry. Cellone & Buzzoni (2001) discussed the properties of a few particular dwarfs, including a possible link between dEs and blue compact dwarfs (BCD). A systematic H I radio survey of this field has recently been carried out by McKay et al. (2004) providing new hints for the low-surface brightness galaxy population of this loose group. ...
... A systematic H I radio survey of this field has recently been carried out by McKay et al. (2004) providing new hints for the low-surface brightness galaxy population of this loose group. In this paper we further extend the Cellone & Buzzoni (2001) analysis and present multicolour surface photometry for 33 dwarf and intermediate-luminosity galaxies (plus six likely unclassified new members) in the field of the NGC 5044 Group, along with mid-resolution spectroscopy for a subsample of 13 objects. ...
... In turn, N156 shows an additional very interesting feature: a warped disc taking the form of a pair of LSB outer spiral arms or tidal tails. 7 Again, N42 lies off the main µe − gT relation due to its poor Sérsic fit (see also Cellone & Buzzoni 2001). We shall be back in more detail to these three notable galaxies (i.e. ...
Article
We present multicolour imaging for a sample of 33 dwarf and intermediate-luminosity galaxies in the field of the NGC 5044 Group, complemented with mid-resolution spectroscopy for a subsample of 13 objects. With these data, a revised membership and morphological classification is made for the galaxies in the sample. We were able to confirm all but one of the ‘definite members’ included in the spectroscopic subsample, galaxies which were originally classified based on morphological criteria. An important fraction of background galaxies, however, is probably present among ‘likely’ and ‘possible’ members. The presence of a nucleus could be detected in just five out of the nine galaxies originally classified as dE,N, confirming the intrinsic difficulty of photographic-plate morphological classification for this kind of object. Our deep surface photometry provided clear evidence for disc structure in at least three galaxies previously catalogued as dE or dS0. Their transition-type properties are also evident from the colour–magnitude diagram, where they lie near the late-type galaxy locus, suggesting an evolutionary connection between a parent disc-galaxy population and at least some present-day dEs. Six new dSph candidates were also found, most of them at small projected distances from NGC 5044, the central galaxy of the group. The NGC 5044 Group appears clearly defined in redshift space, with a mean heliocentric radial velocity of 〈vr〉= 2461 ± 84 km s−1 (z= 0.0082), and a moderate dispersion of σ= 431 km s−1. Our kinematical data show no luminosity segregation for early-type galaxies: both dwarf and bright E/S0 systems show very similar velocity distributions (σ∼ 290 km s−1). This is in contrast to late-type galaxies, which seem to display a broader distribution (σ∼ 680 km s−1).
... However, these two quantities are rendered impractical for a systematic study of the LSB component by their strong non-linear coupling (see discussion in e.g. Young & Currie 1994, Cellone & Buzzoni 2001, and dependence on the fitting procedure (see above). Furthermore, observational uncertainties connected with, e.g., the sky subtraction (see e.g. ...
Article
Full-text available
(shortened) We analyze deep Near Infrared (NIR) broad band images for a sample of Blue Compact Dwarf Galaxies (BCDs), allowing for the quantitative study of their extended stellar low-surface brightness (LSB) host galaxies. NIR surface brightness profiles (SBPs) of the LSB hosts agree at large galactocentric radii with those from optical studies. At small to intermediate radii, however, the NIR data reveal for more than half of our sample a significant flattening of the exponential SBP of the LSB host. Such SBPs ("type V" SBPs, Binggeli & Cameron 1991) have rarely been detected in LSB hosts of BCDs at optical wavelengths, where the relative flux contribution of the starburst is stronger than in the NIR and can hide such central intensity depressions of the LSB host. The structural properties, frequency and physical origin of type V LSB SBPs in BCDs and other dwarf galaxies have not yet been systematically studied. Nevertheless, their occurrence in a significant fraction of BCDs would impose important new constraints to the radial distribution of their stellar mass, and to the photometric fading of BCDs after the termination of star-forming activity. Both a modified exponential (Papaderos et al. 1996a) and the Sersic law give satisfactory empirical descriptions for type V SBPs. However, we argue that the practical applicability of Sersic fits to LSB SBPs of BCDs is limited by, e.g., the extreme sensitivity of the solutions to small SBP uncertainties. Most stellar LSB host galaxies in the sample show optical-NIR colors indicative of evolved stellar populations with subsolar metallicity. Unsharp-masked NIR images and optical-NIR maps reveal numerous morphological details, and cases of non-uniform dust absorption on spatial scales up to ~1 kpc. Comment: 29 pages, 17 figures; accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics; 1 typo in Table 2 corrected; higher resolution images are available at http://www.uni-sw.gwdg.de/~knoeske/PUB_LIST/noeske_BCDs_NIR.ps.gz
Article
The distribution of galaxy properties in groups and clusters holds important information on galaxy evolution and growth of structure in the Universe. While clusters have received appreciable attention in this regard, the role of groups as fundamental to formation of the present-day galaxy population has remained relatively unaddressed. Here, we present stellar ages, metallicities and α-element abundances derived using Lick indices for 67 spectroscopically confirmed members of the NGC 5044 galaxy group with the aim of shedding light on galaxy evolution in the context of the group environment. We find that galaxies in the NGC 5044 group show evidence for a strong relationship between stellar mass and metallicity, consistent with their counterparts in both higher and lower mass groups and clusters. Galaxies show no clear trend of age or α-element abundance with mass, but these data form a tight sequence when fitted simultaneously in age, metallicity and stellar mass. In the context of the group environment, our data support the tidal disruption of low-mass galaxies at small group-centric radii, as evident from an apparent lack of galaxies below ∼109 M⊙ within ∼100 kpc of the brightest group galaxy. Using a joint analysis of absorption- and emission-line metallicities, we are able to show that the star-forming galaxy population in the NGC 5044 group appears to require gas removal to explain the ∼1.5 dex offset between absorption- and emission-line metallicities observed in some cases. A comparison with other stellar population properties suggests that this gas removal is dominated by galaxy interactions with the hot intragroup medium.
Article
(Abridge) We present a new analysis of the early-type galaxy population in the central region of the Antlia cluster, focusing on the faint systems like dwarf ellipticals (dE) and dwarf spheroidals (dSph). We confirm 22 early-type galaxies as Antlia members, using GEMINI-GMOS and MAGELLAN-MIKE spectra. Among them, 2 belong to the rare type of compact ellipticals (cE), and 5 are new faint dwarfs that had never been catalogued before. In addition, we present 16 newly identified low surface brightness galaxy candidates, almost half of them displaying morphologies consistent with being Antlia's counterparts of Local Group dSphs, that extend the faint luminosity limit of our study down to MB = -10.1 (BT = 22.6) mag. We built an improved CMR in the Washington photometric system, i.e. integrated T1 magnitudes versus (C - T1) colours, which extends \sim 4 mag faintwards the limit of spectroscopically confirmed Antlia members. When only confirmed early-type members are considered, this relation extends over 10 mag in luminosity with no apparent change in slope or increase in colour dispersion towards its faint end. The intrinsic colour scatter of the relation is compared with those reported for other clusters of galaxies; we argue that it is likely that the large scatter of the CMR, usually reported at faint magnitudes, is mostly due to photometric errors along with an improper membership/morphological classification. The distinct behaviour of the luminosity versus mean effective surface brightness relation at the bright and faint ends is analyzed, while it is confirmed that dE galaxies on the same relation present a very similar effective radius, regardless of their colour. The projected spatial distribution of the member sample confirms the existence of two groups in Antlia, each one dominated by a giant elliptical galaxy and with one cE located close to each giant.