FIG 1 - uploaded by Robert Albers
Content may be subject to copyright.
TF screening ␩ TF ϭ ln( p TF / p FG ) derived from literature 

TF screening ␩ TF ϭ ln( p TF / p FG ) derived from literature 

Source publication
Article
Full-text available
Explicit functions are widely used to interpolate, extrapolate, and differentiate theoretical or experimental data on the equation of state (EOS) of a solid. We present two EOS functions which are theoretically motivated. The simplest realistic model for a simple metal, the stabilized jellium (SJ) or structureless pseudopotential model, is the para...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... mE 1( x ) xe E 1( x ) represents a ‘‘modified exponential integral’’ function with E 1( x ) ϭ ͐ ρ x ( e Ϫ z / z ) dz . SL ϭ ͓ ͚ L 2 c k ( c 0 ϩ k ) ͔ / c 0 is just a fitted parameter and DL ( x ) ϭ ͚ L 2 ( c k / c k 0 Ϫ 1 ) p k ( x , c 0 ) includes the simple polynomials p k ( x , c 0 ) in x and c 0 with, for instance, p 2 ϭ 2 Ϫ x and p 3 ϭ x ϩ c 0 (3 Ϫ 3 x ϩ x 2 ). One should notice, thereby, that E 1( x ) and mE 1( x ) are very well-behaved functions and very fast algorithms for E 1( x ) are incorporated in modern mathematical software. In any case, also very accurate rapid approximations for E 1( x ) have been published. 6 ͑ 2 ͒ p APL gives for any value of K 0 Ј ϭ 3 ϩ ( c 0 ϩ c 2 ) 3 2 and for any order L the correct Fermi gas limit at x → 0 as well as the correct limiting behavior p → 0 for x → ρ without any higher-order discontinuity. ͑ 3 ͒ When APBAF compared the second order form H 12 with their third-order form SJEOS ͑ with the two free parameters K 0 and K Ј 0 and the direct adjustment of d to E 0 ), they find rather better agreement for the form H 12 with their LCGTO calculations than with their SJEOS form. The ‘‘aug- mented’’ ͑ more reasonable ͒ form ASJEOS of APBAF uses the additional parameter f for some constraint at x → 0 as our forms H 1 L and APL, but one additional parameter h is also used. This means, that a fair comparison should use our fourth-order form AP4 with c 4 constraint to E 0 , leaving three free parameters K 0 , K Ј 0 , and c 3 for the fitting. Due to the superior fitting of the second-order form H 12 in comparison with SJEOS, there is no doubt that our fourth-order form AP4 will fit the data of ‘‘regular’’ solids ͑ without electronic anomalies ͒ at least as good as their fourth-order form ASJEOS. ͑ 4 ͒ One should also notice that Fig. 1 of APBAF is mis- leading, since it uses the divergent form SJEOS down to x ϭ 0.1 as reference for the nondivergent H 02 form. The augmented jellium model ASJEOS removes this divergence by partial adaptation of our approach ͑ Ref. 1 of APBAF ͒ , and would therefore show a similar divergence as H 02 in this diagram. ͑ 5 ͒ The form ASJEOS has built in a higher-order discontinuity at x → 1, whereas our forms H 1 L and APL have only continuous derivatives up to the highest order. Some resemblance of ASJEOS for x Ͻ 1 to the our form APL is also obvious. 7 ͑ 6 ͒ APBAF did not realize that our form H 1 L and simi- larly APL do not only incorporate the Fermi gas limit ͑ for x → 0), but also the Thomas-Fermi ͑ TF ͒ screening represented by the parameter c 0 in the term e Ϫ c 0 x . Thereby c 0 represents an adjusted TF screening, which deviates only slightly from the original TF screening as discussed by us previously 2 ͑ Ref. 1 of APBAF ͒ . 7 The core overlap under strong compression is taken into account in H 1 L and APL by incorporation of the ͑ effective ͒ TF limit ͑ not only the Fermi gas limit ͒ . Therefore, H 1 L and APL are not only interesting for ‘‘standard treatments of white dwarf stars,’’ but represent to a good approximation the quantum statistical local density approximation of the TF model, when one takes into account, that the TF model gives only the repulsive pressure p rep ( x ), but the total pressure p ϭ (1 Ϫ x ) p rep ( x ) can be interpreted in this case as resulting from an additional attractive pressure Ϫ x p rep ( x ) in the forms H 1 L and APL like in the ‘‘universal EOS’’ ͑ Ref. 7 ͒ based on an effective Rydberg potential. With this rather arbitrary but useful approximation for the attractive part of the total pressure the TF model accounts typically for about 50% of the repulsive pressure near x ϭ 1 or for about 80% of the total pressure already in the zeroth order approximation of APL. ͑ 8 ͒ The ASJEOS approach uses an exponentially screened polynomial expansion for the total energy in powers of x starting with the zeroth-order term x Ϫ 2 for the screened Fermi gas whereas the APL approach is more directly related to the ͑ repulsive ͒ TF pressure , as illustrated in Fig. 1, where the TF ͑ universal ͒ screening ␩ TF ϭ In( p TF / p FG ) is plotted with respect to the TF radius r TF ϭ Z 1/3 r WS . Z is thereby the atomic number of the atom with the Wigner-Seitz radius r WS and p FG stands for the pressure of the corresponding Fermi gas. The first order form AP1 results here just in a straight line, which is fitted here to the initial slope of ␩ TF at x ϭ 0. The second order form AP2 gives in this case already an almost perfect fit of the TF pressure. If one considers instead of the total energy from the ASJEOS approach at first only a screened expansion of the repulsive potential ͑ SPL ͒ ...
Context 2
... mE 1( x ) xe E 1( x ) represents a ‘‘modified exponential integral’’ function with E 1( x ) ϭ ͐ ρ x ( e Ϫ z / z ) dz . SL ϭ ͓ ͚ L 2 c k ( c 0 ϩ k ) ͔ / c 0 is just a fitted parameter and DL ( x ) ϭ ͚ L 2 ( c k / c k 0 Ϫ 1 ) p k ( x , c 0 ) includes the simple polynomials p k ( x , c 0 ) in x and c 0 with, for instance, p 2 ϭ 2 Ϫ x and p 3 ϭ x ϩ c 0 (3 Ϫ 3 x ϩ x 2 ). One should notice, thereby, that E 1( x ) and mE 1( x ) are very well-behaved functions and very fast algorithms for E 1( x ) are incorporated in modern mathematical software. In any case, also very accurate rapid approximations for E 1( x ) have been published. 6 ͑ 2 ͒ p APL gives for any value of K 0 Ј ϭ 3 ϩ ( c 0 ϩ c 2 ) 3 2 and for any order L the correct Fermi gas limit at x → 0 as well as the correct limiting behavior p → 0 for x → ρ without any higher-order discontinuity. ͑ 3 ͒ When APBAF compared the second order form H 12 with their third-order form SJEOS ͑ with the two free parameters K 0 and K Ј 0 and the direct adjustment of d to E 0 ), they find rather better agreement for the form H 12 with their LCGTO calculations than with their SJEOS form. The ‘‘aug- mented’’ ͑ more reasonable ͒ form ASJEOS of APBAF uses the additional parameter f for some constraint at x → 0 as our forms H 1 L and APL, but one additional parameter h is also used. This means, that a fair comparison should use our fourth-order form AP4 with c 4 constraint to E 0 , leaving three free parameters K 0 , K Ј 0 , and c 3 for the fitting. Due to the superior fitting of the second-order form H 12 in comparison with SJEOS, there is no doubt that our fourth-order form AP4 will fit the data of ‘‘regular’’ solids ͑ without electronic anomalies ͒ at least as good as their fourth-order form ASJEOS. ͑ 4 ͒ One should also notice that Fig. 1 of APBAF is mis- leading, since it uses the divergent form SJEOS down to x ϭ 0.1 as reference for the nondivergent H 02 form. The augmented jellium model ASJEOS removes this divergence by partial adaptation of our approach ͑ Ref. 1 of APBAF ͒ , and would therefore show a similar divergence as H 02 in this diagram. ͑ 5 ͒ The form ASJEOS has built in a higher-order discontinuity at x → 1, whereas our forms H 1 L and APL have only continuous derivatives up to the highest order. Some resemblance of ASJEOS for x Ͻ 1 to the our form APL is also obvious. 7 ͑ 6 ͒ APBAF did not realize that our form H 1 L and simi- larly APL do not only incorporate the Fermi gas limit ͑ for x → 0), but also the Thomas-Fermi ͑ TF ͒ screening represented by the parameter c 0 in the term e Ϫ c 0 x . Thereby c 0 represents an adjusted TF screening, which deviates only slightly from the original TF screening as discussed by us previously 2 ͑ Ref. 1 of APBAF ͒ . 7 The core overlap under strong compression is taken into account in H 1 L and APL by incorporation of the ͑ effective ͒ TF limit ͑ not only the Fermi gas limit ͒ . Therefore, H 1 L and APL are not only interesting for ‘‘standard treatments of white dwarf stars,’’ but represent to a good approximation the quantum statistical local density approximation of the TF model, when one takes into account, that the TF model gives only the repulsive pressure p rep ( x ), but the total pressure p ϭ (1 Ϫ x ) p rep ( x ) can be interpreted in this case as resulting from an additional attractive pressure Ϫ x p rep ( x ) in the forms H 1 L and APL like in the ‘‘universal EOS’’ ͑ Ref. 7 ͒ based on an effective Rydberg potential. With this rather arbitrary but useful approximation for the attractive part of the total pressure the TF model accounts typically for about 50% of the repulsive pressure near x ϭ 1 or for about 80% of the total pressure already in the zeroth order approximation of APL. ͑ 8 ͒ The ASJEOS approach uses an exponentially screened polynomial expansion for the total energy in powers of x starting with the zeroth-order term x Ϫ 2 for the screened Fermi gas whereas the APL approach is more directly related to the ͑ repulsive ͒ TF pressure , as illustrated in Fig. 1, where the TF ͑ universal ͒ screening ␩ TF ϭ In( p TF / p FG ) is plotted with respect to the TF radius r TF ϭ Z 1/3 r WS . Z is thereby the atomic number of the atom with the Wigner-Seitz radius r WS and p FG stands for the pressure of the corresponding Fermi gas. The first order form AP1 results here just in a straight line, which is fitted here to the initial slope of ␩ TF at x ϭ 0. The second order form AP2 gives in this case already an almost perfect fit of the TF pressure. If one considers instead of the total energy from the ASJEOS approach at first only a screened expansion of the repulsive potential ͑ SPL ͒ ...
Context 3
... the correct Fermi gas limit at x 0), the corresponding repulsive pressure p repSPL gives with a best fitting of d 0 to the TF data near x → 0 the first order form represented by SP1 in Fig. 1 with its unfavorable ͑ convex ͒ curvature. A second order form SP2 gives no essential improvement and even a third-order form SP3 does not fit as well as AP2 especially for r TF Ͼ 4 nm. The ASJEOS approach would correspond in this range just to a fourth-order form SP4. This comparison indicates, that the APL expansion is specially suited to fit the TF pressure . Due to its expansion around x ϭ 1 it can take into account also more flexibly higher order corrections for exchange, correlation and atomic shell structure. SPL on the other hand represents a series expansion in the energy around x ϭ 0. p repSPL therefore starts with the wrong curvature and appears to be less flexible with respect to EOS data near x ϭ 1. All these disadvantages of SPL are encountered also in the ASJEOS approach, which includes in addition only a higher-order discontinuity at x ϭ 1. ͑ 9 ͒ If one adds to the repulsive potential E repSPL one more term x L to include the attractive pressure components, one obtains a modified jellium model, which gives for the pressure with the constraint p MJL ( x ϭ 1) ϭ 0 the second-order ...

Similar publications

Article
Full-text available
Mechanical behaviour of fired bricks containing varied amount of fine sand (FS) and waste glass powder (GP) was investigated. FS and GP were added to bricks at varied amount of 0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40 wt. %. Firing was done at 1200 o C and samples produced were evaluated for compressive and flexural strengths while microstructural analy...

Citations

... A 12-point series of values was fitted to the stabilized jellium equation of state (SJEOS). 31 Static-crystal lattice constants and cohesive energies were calculated for 55 solids 12 and bulk moduli for 44 solids, 13 as were Kohn-Sham band gaps of 21 insulators and semiconductors. 14 All the values were compared with the experimental values. ...
Article
Full-text available
The revised, regularized Tao–Mo (rregTM) exchange-correlation density functional approximation (DFA) [A. Patra, S. Jana, and P. Samal, J. Chem. Phys. 153, 184112 (2020) and Jana et al., J. Chem. Phys. 155, 024103 (2021)] resolves the order-of-limits problem in the original TM formulation while preserving its valuable essential behaviors. Those include performance on standard thermochemistry and solid data sets that is competitive with that of the most widely explored meta-generalized-gradient-approximation DFAs (SCAN and r2SCAN) while also providing superior performance on elemental solid magnetization. Puzzlingly however, rregTM proved to be intractable for de-orbitalization via the approach of Mejía-Rodríguez and Trickey [Phys. Rev. A 96, 052512 (2017)]. We report investigation that leads to diagnosis of how the regularization in rregTM of the z indicator functions (z = the ratio of the von-Weizsäcker and Kohn–Sham kinetic energy densities) leads to non-physical behavior. We propose a simpler regularization that eliminates those oddities and that can be calibrated to reproduce the good error patterns of rregTM. We denote this version as simplified, regularized Tao–Mo, sregTM. We also show that it is unnecessary to use rregTM correlation with sregTM exchange: Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof correlation is sufficient. The subsequent paper shows how sregTM enables some progress on de-orbitalization.
... As the stress tensor is not implemented in QE for meta-GGA functionals with spin polarization, we manually optimized the unit cell for r 2 SCAN by computing the energy of NiO unit cells at 11 cubic lattice constants within ±10% of the experimental value, 4.171 Å. 8 The equilibrium geometry and bulk modulus were then extracted using the stabilized jellium equation of state (SJEOS). 32 The Young's modulus and Poisson ratio were then determined by straining the system by ±1% in the direction transverse to the plane of magnetization (i.e., the plane formed by the nearest neighboring Ni atoms with the same spin) in increments of 0.2%. For the GGA functionals, we relaxed the unit cell geometry along the unstrained lattice directions for each 0.2% increment of the strained lattice scitation.org/journal/apm ...
... Comparison of AFII NiO equilibrium lattice constants a 0 (Å) and equilibrium bulk moduli B 0 (GPa) obtained by fitting to the SJEOS.32 A variety of functionals are presented: the PBE and PBEsol GGAs, and the SCAN and r 2 SCAN meta-GGAs. ...
Article
Full-text available
Transition metal oxide materials are of great utility, with a diversity of topical applications ranging from catalysis to electronic devices. Because of their widespread importance in materials science, there is increasing interest in developing computational tools capable of reliable prediction of transition metal oxide phase behavior and properties. The workhorse of materials theory is density functional theory (DFT). Accordingly, we have investigated the impact of various correlation and exchange approximations on their ability to predict the properties of NiO using DFT. We have chosen NiO as a particularly challenging representative of transition metal oxides in general. In so doing, we have provided validation for the use of the r2SCAN density functional for predicting the materials properties of oxides. r2SCAN yields accurate structural properties of NiO and a local spin moment that notably persists under pressure, consistent with experiment. The outcome of our study is a pragmatic scheme for providing electronic structure data to enable the parameterization of interatomic potentials using state-of-the-art artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) methodologies. The latter is essential to allow large scale molecular dynamics simulations of bulk and surface materials phase behavior and properties with ab initio accuracy.
... In both FP and PW results, the total energy of the FM state at the equilibrium volume, obtained with a fit to the stabilized jellium equation of state [83], has been subtracted. As shown in Fig. 9, the FM order is the ground state for both Ni 2 Mn 1.5 In 0.5 and Ni 2 Mn 1.5 Sn 0.5 when using rSCAN and the predicted equilibrium volume obtained with both approaches matches very well. ...
Preprint
Heusler compounds have been intensively studied owing to the important technological advancements that they provide in the field of shape memory, thermomagnetic energy conversion and spintronics. Many of their intriguing properties are ultimately governed by their magnetic states and understanding and possibly tuning them is evidently of utmost importance. In this work we examine the \alloys alloys with Density Functional Theory simulations and $^{55}$Mn Nuclear Magnetic Resonance and combine these two methods to carefully describe their ground state magnetic order. In addition, we compare the results obtained with the conventional generalized gradient approximation with the ones of strongly constrained and appropriately normed (SCAN) semilocal functionals for exchange and correlation. Experimental results eventually allow to discriminate between two different scenarios identified by ab initio simulations.
... The bulk modulus was obtained with the jellium equation of state [60,61] and the vacancy energy E v was calculated in a (2 × 2 × 2) MgO rock salt unit cell with the following equation: ...
Article
Full-text available
One of the key challenges preventing the breakthrough of magnesium‐ion batteries (MIB) is the formation of a passivating boundary layer at the Mg anode. To describe the initial steps of Mg anode degradation by O2 impurities, a Mg/O ReaxFF (force field for reactive systems) parameter set was developed capable of accurately modeling the bulk, surface, adsorption, and diffusion properties of metallic Mg and the salt MgO. It is shown that O2 immediately dissociates upon first contact with the Mg anode (modeled as Mg(0001), Mg(10 1‾ $\bar 1$ 0)A, and Mg(10 1‾ $\bar 1$ 1)), heating the surface to several 1000 K. The high temperature assists the further oxidation and forms a rock salt interphase intersected by several grain boundaries. Among the Mg surface terminations, Mg(10 1‾ $\bar 1$ 0)A is the most reactive, forming an MgO layer with a thickness of up to 25 Å. The trained force field can be used to model the ongoing reactions in Mg–air batteries but also to study the oxidation of magnesium metal in general.
... where are parameters obtained from a polynomial fit; and the stabilized jellium EOS [135,136]: ...
Article
The realization of novel technological opportunities given by computational and autonomous materials design requires efficient and effective frameworks. For more than two decades, aflow++ (Automatic-Flow Framework for Materials Discovery) has provided an interconnected collection of algorithms and workflows to address this challenge. This article contains an overview of the software and some of its most heavily-used functionalities, including algorithmic details, standards, and examples. Key thrusts are highlighted: the calculation of structural, electronic, thermodynamic, and thermomechanical properties in addition to the modeling of complex materials, such as high-entropy ceramics and bulk metallic glasses. The aflow++ software prioritizes interoperability, minimizing the number of independent parameters and tolerances. It ensures consistency of results across property sets — facilitating machine learning studies. The software also features various validation schemes, offering real-time quality assurance for data generated in a high-throughput fashion. Altogether, these considerations contribute to the development of large and reliable materials databases that can ultimately deliver future materials systems.
... Ordered representative #4 of AuCu 3 was found to be dynamically unstable and was discarded entirely from the ensemble of structures. The calculated free energies were fitted using the Stabilized Jellium EOS [45,46]: ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Disordered materials are attracting considerable attention because of their enhanced properties compared to their ordered analogs, making them particularly suitable for high-temperature applications. The feasibility of incorporating these materials into new devices depends on a variety of thermophysical properties. Among them, thermal expansion is critical to device stability, especially in multi-component systems. Its calculation, however, is quite challenging for materials with substitutional disorder, hindering computational screenings. In this work, we introduce QH-POCC to leverage the local tile-expansion of disorder. This method provides an effective partial partition function to calculate thermomechanical properties of substitutionally disordered compounds in the quasi-harmonic approximation. Two systems, AuCu3 and CdMg3, the latter a candidate for long-period superstructures at low temperature, are used to validate the methodology by comparing the calculated values of the coefficient of thermal expansion and isobaric heat capacity with experiment, demonstrating that QH-POCC is a promising approach to study thermomechanical properties of disordered systems.
... The meaning of each parameter is the same as that in Ref. [34]. [58] approach, zero-point corrections to a at zero temperature, denoted as a 0 with subscript 0 representing T = 0 K, are estimated as ...
Article
Full-text available
We show that an accurate description of the interplay between the anharmonic ionic interaction and the zero-point fluctuation of ions in crystalline aluminum (Al) can be achieved using the path-integral molecular dynamics (PIMD) method in conjunction with improved empirical modified embedded-atom method (MEAM) potentials. Our results show that the zero-point fluctuation of ions is noticeable at a temperature between 200 K and 250 K, roughly half of the Al Debye temperature of 428 K, with a selective influence on mechanical properties. The effect provides appreciable corrections to the lattice constant a, bulk modulus B, and elastic constant C11 at low temperature, but without much influence on elastic constants C12 and C44. With a revised MEAM potential which takes into consideration the influence of zero-point fluctuations, the PIMD method has a much improved accuracy in a, B, and the C's up to 700 K, when compared with precision experimental measurements. The largest errors of a and B can even be reduced by about an order in percentage below 300 K.
... where f i are parameters obtained from a polynomial fit; and the stabilized jellium EOS [141,142]: ...
Preprint
Full-text available
The realization of novel technological opportunities given by computational and autonomous materials design requires efficient and effective frameworks. For more than two decades, aflow++ (Automatic-Flow Framework for Materials Discovery) has provided an interconnected collection of algorithms and workflows to address this challenge. This article contains an overview of the software and some of its most heavily-used functionalities, including algorithmic details, standards, and examples. Key thrusts are highlighted: the calculation of structural, electronic, thermodynamic, and thermomechanical properties in addition to the modeling of complex materials, such as high-entropy ceramics and bulk metallic glasses. The aflow++ software prioritizes interoperability, minimizing the number of independent parameters and tolerances. It ensures consistency of results across property sets - facilitating machine learning studies. The software also features various validation schemes, offering real-time quality assurance for data generated in a high-throughput fashion. Altogether, these considerations contribute to the development of large and reliable materials databases that can ultimately deliver future materials systems
... The Brillouin zone was sampled using a (10, 10, 10) and (10, 10, 1) Γ-centred Monkhorst-Pack mesh 54 for bulk and surface calculations, respectively. Lattice constants were determined by fitting to an equation of state 55 . ...
Article
Full-text available
Electrochemical valorization of surplus biomass-derived feedstocks, such as glycerol, into high-value chemicals offers a sustainable route for utilization of biomass resources and decarbonization of chemical manufacturing; however, glycerol is typically valorized solely via anodic oxidation, with lower-value products such as hydrogen gas generated at the cathode. Here, we establish the efficient cathodic valorization of glycerol to the desirable C3 oxidation products via the electro-Fenton process at a stable NiSe2 cathode, built upon the theoretical understanding and experimental demonstration of the high selectivity and stability of NiSe2 toward acidic H2O2 electrosynthesis. A proof-of-concept linear paired electrochemical process for concurrent valorization of glycerol into the same oxidation products at both NiSe2 cathode and Pt anode achieves high selectivity for value-added C3 products and high glycerol conversion with little external energy input needed, when the electro-Fenton generation of hydroxyl radicals is carefully controlled. This conceptual strategy of linear pairing is generalizable for enabling atom-efficient electro-refinery of diverse biomass-derived feedstocks. Seeking high efficiency in the valorization of biomass-derived feedstocks is a great challenge. Now, a linear paired electrochemical valorization of glycerol to mainly C3 oxidation products is achieved in both compartments by combining the electro-Fenton process at a NiSe2 cathode and the direct oxidation of glycerol at a Pt anode.
... Lastly, one could also, in principle, make use of a simple semiempirical model proposed in the literature to express ∆V /V 0 in terms of a few parameters [51]. This model relies on the Debye model for the expression for the zero-point energy and the Dugdale-MacDonald parametrization of the bulk Grüneisen constant in terms of the first derivative of the bulk modulus with respect to pressure, B 1 [52]. ...
Preprint
The zero-point lattice expansion (ZPLE) is a small variation of the lattice parameters induced by the presence of phonons in a material compared to the static lattice picture. It contributes significantly to the zero-point renormalization (ZPR) of the band gap energy, but its consequences have not been investigated as thoroughly as those stemming from electron-phonon interactions. In the usual first-principles approach, one evaluates the ZPLE by minimizing the $T=0$ K Helmholtz free energy. In this work, we show that the formalism based on the Gr\"uneisen parameters, which commonly neglects zero-point effects, can be efficiently used to compute ZPLE for both isotropic and anisotropic materials at much lower computational cost. We systematically test this formalism on 22 cubic and wurtzite materials and obtain excellent agreement with free energy minimization results for both the ZPLE and the resulting band gap ZPR. We use our results to validate an empirical expression estimating the ZPLE-induced ZPR and unveil its sensitivity to the temperature range involved in estimating the ZPLE from experimental data. Our findings finally reveal that the ZPLE contribution to the band gap ZPR can reach 20% to more than 80% of the electron-phonon interaction contribution for heavier or more ionic materials, including materials containing light atoms. Considering both contributions on an equal footing is thus essential should one attempt to compare theoretical ZPR results with experimental data.