Figure 3 - uploaded by Gentaro Watanabe
Content may be subject to copyright.
Nuclear “pasta.” The darker regions show the liquid phase, in which protons and neutrons coexist (i.e., the nuclear matter region); the lighter ones the gas phase, which is almost free of protons. Sequence (a)-(e) shows that of nuclear shape changes with increasing density. This figure is taken from Ref. [45]. 

Nuclear “pasta.” The darker regions show the liquid phase, in which protons and neutrons coexist (i.e., the nuclear matter region); the lighter ones the gas phase, which is almost free of protons. Sequence (a)-(e) shows that of nuclear shape changes with increasing density. This figure is taken from Ref. [45]. 

Source publication
Article
Full-text available
More than twenty years ago, it was predicted that nuclei can adopt interesting shapes, such as rods or slabs, etc., in the cores of supernovae and the crusts of neutron stars. These non-spherical nuclei are referred to as nuclear "pasta". In recent years, we have been studying the dynamics of the pasta phases using a method called quantum molecular...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... 3 . An explicit calculation in Ref. [ 49] shows that values of the elastic constants are B ∼ w C+L , C ≃ w C+L and K 3 ≃ 0 . 05 w C+L l 2 . Using the Lindemann criterion and the above typical values for l and w C+L , one can estimate the melting temperature T m 10 MeV for supernova matter and T m 1 MeV for neutron star matter. In the above estimate, however, decrease of the surface tension due to the evaporation of nucleons and thermal broadening of the nuclear density profile is not taken into account. Thus the melting temperature for supernova matter would be smaller than the above value in the real situation. More elaborated calculations on the Landau-Peierls instability and of the melting temperature can be seen in Refs. [43, 64, 65]. In closing the present section, let us briefly mention several phases which are not shown in Fig. 3. In block copolymer melts, various phases with complicated structures, e.g., gyroid phase, perforated lamellar phase and double diamond phase, etc., have been observed. As will be seen in Section 4, our simulations suggest that phases with multiply connected structures also appear in the nuclear systems (see also Ref. [50]). This point should be examined in the future study 3 . Since the seminal works by Ravenhall et al. [53] and Hashimoto et al. [20], properties of the pasta phases in equilibrium states have been investigated using various nuclear models. They include studies on phase diagrams at zero temperature [34, 45, 47, 59, 64, 65, 70] and at finite temperatures [32]. These earlier works have confirmed that, for various nuclear models, the nuclear shape changes in the way of Eq. (14) as predicted by Refs. [20, 53]. In these earlier works, however, a liquid drop model or the Thomas-Fermi approximation is used with an assumption on the nuclear shape (except for Ref. [70]). Thus the phase diagram at subnuclear densities and the existence of the pasta phases should be examined without assuming the nuclear shape. It is also noted that at temperatures of several MeV, which are relevant to the collapsing cores, effects of thermal fluctuations on the nucleon distribution are significant. However, these thermal fluctuations cannot be described prop- erly by mean-field theories such as the Thomas-Fermi approximation used in the previous work [32]. In contrast to the equilibrium properties, dynamical or non-equilibrium aspects of the pasta phases had not been studied until recently except for some limited cases [24, 50]. Thus it had been unclear even whether or not the pasta phases can be formed dynamically within the time scale of the cooling of neutron stars nor whether or not the formation ...
Context 2
... phases and that of the nucleon is not large. Due to this small gap, we can study pasta phases using some microscopic approach: the quantum molecular dynamics (QMD) is one possibility. We have explained the theoretical framework of molecular dynamics calculations for nucleons including QMD and then given an overview of our previous work. Our QMD simulations have shown that the pasta phases can be formed dynamically by cooling down hot uniform nuclear matter in a finite time scale ∼ O (10 3 − 10 4 ) fm /c , which is much shorter than the cooling time of a neutron star. We have also shown that transitions between the pasta phases can occur by compression during the collapse of a star. Our latest result strongly suggests that the pasta phase with rod-like nuclei can be formed by compressing a bcc lattice of spherical nuclei; this result will be examined in detail. As we have shown, nuclear pasta is an interesting system for a wide spectrum of researchers not only to nuclear astrophysicists. Physics of the pasta phases draws on nuclear physics, condensed matter physics, and astrophysics. The pasta phases are important for understanding stellar collapse and neutron star formation, which are long-standing mystery in the Universe. The authors are grateful to Kazuhiro Oyamatsu for giving us permission to use Fig. 3. They also thank Chris Pethick for helpful comments. The research reported in this article grew out of collaborations with Kei Iida, Toshiki Maruyama, Katsuhiko Sato, Kenji Yasuoka and Toshikazu Ebisuzaki. Further research currently in progress is performed using the RIKEN Super Combined Cluster System with MDGRAPE-2. This work was supported in part by the Nishina Memorial Foundation, by a JSPS Postdoctoral Fellowship for Research Abroad, by a JSPS Research Fellowship for Young Scientists, by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology through Research Grant No. 14-7939, and by RIKEN through Research Grant No. J130026. The integral mean curvature and the Euler characteristic (see, e.g., Ref. [39] and references therein for details) are powerful tools for extracting the morphological characteristics of the structure of nuclear matter. Suppose there is a set of regions R , where the density is higher than a given threshold density ρ th . The integral mean curvature and the Euler characteristic for the surface of this region ∂R are defined as surface integrals of the mean curvature H = ( κ 1 + κ 2 ) / 2 and the Gaussian curvature G = κ 1 κ 2 , respectively; i.e., ∂R HdA and χ ≡ ∂R GdA/ 2 π , where κ 1 and κ 2 are the principal curvatures and dA is the area element of the surface of R . The Euler characteristic χ depends only on the topology of R and is expressed ...
Context 3
... nuclear matter, which favors a spherical nucleus, being greater than those due to the electrical repulsion between protons, which tends to make the nucleus deform. When the density of matter approaches that of atomic nuclei, i.e., the normal nuclear density ρ 0 , nuclei are closely packed and the effect of the electrostatic energy becomes comparable to that of the surface energy. Consequently, at subnuclear densities around ρ ρ 0 / 2 , the energetically favorable configuration is expected to have remarkable structures as shown in Fig. 3; the nuclear matter region (i.e., the liquid phase of mixture of protons and neutrons) is divided into periodically arranged parts of roughly spherical (a), rod-like (b) or slab-like (c) shape, embedded in the gas phase and in a roughly uniform electron gas. Besides, there can be phases in which nuclei are turned inside out, with cylindrical (d) or spherical (e) bubbles of the gas phase in the liquid phase. As mentioned in the previous section, these transformations are expected to occur in the deepest region of neutron star inner crusts and in the inner cores of collapsing stars just before the star rebounds. Since slabs and rods look like “lasagna” and “spaghetti”, the phases with non-spherical nuclei are often referred to as “pasta” phases and such non-spherical nuclei as nuclear “pasta.” Likewise, spherical nuclei and spherical bubbles are called “meatballs” and “Swiss cheese”, respectively. More than twenty years ago, Ravenhall et al. [53] and Hashimoto et al. [20] inde- pendently pointed out that nuclei with such exotic shapes 2 can be the most energetically stable due to the subtle competition between the nuclear surface and Coulomb energies as mentioned above. Let us here show this statement by a simple calculation using an incompressible liquid-drop model (see also Ref. [46]). We consider five phases depicted in Fig. 3, which consist of spherical nuclei, ...
Context 4
... nuclear matter, which favors a spherical nucleus, being greater than those due to the electrical repulsion between protons, which tends to make the nucleus deform. When the density of matter approaches that of atomic nuclei, i.e., the normal nuclear density ρ 0 , nuclei are closely packed and the effect of the electrostatic energy becomes comparable to that of the surface energy. Consequently, at subnuclear densities around ρ ρ 0 / 2 , the energetically favorable configuration is expected to have remarkable structures as shown in Fig. 3; the nuclear matter region (i.e., the liquid phase of mixture of protons and neutrons) is divided into periodically arranged parts of roughly spherical (a), rod-like (b) or slab-like (c) shape, embedded in the gas phase and in a roughly uniform electron gas. Besides, there can be phases in which nuclei are turned inside out, with cylindrical (d) or spherical (e) bubbles of the gas phase in the liquid phase. As mentioned in the previous section, these transformations are expected to occur in the deepest region of neutron star inner crusts and in the inner cores of collapsing stars just before the star rebounds. Since slabs and rods look like “lasagna” and “spaghetti”, the phases with non-spherical nuclei are often referred to as “pasta” phases and such non-spherical nuclei as nuclear “pasta.” Likewise, spherical nuclei and spherical bubbles are called “meatballs” and “Swiss cheese”, respectively. More than twenty years ago, Ravenhall et al. [53] and Hashimoto et al. [20] inde- pendently pointed out that nuclei with such exotic shapes 2 can be the most energetically stable due to the subtle competition between the nuclear surface and Coulomb energies as mentioned above. Let us here show this statement by a simple calculation using an incompressible liquid-drop model (see also Ref. [46]). We consider five phases depicted in Fig. 3, which consist of spherical nuclei, ...
Context 5
... the modified URCA process, a bystander neutron absorbs the momentum and relaxes kinematical constraints. Pasta nuclei suppress the bremsstrahlung rate [ 27, 51]. If we assume that neutrino bremsstrahlung is dominated by the lowest reciprocal lattice vectors for which form factors do not vanish, the number of these vectors for each dimensional lattice leads to the neutrino emission rate of spherical, cylindrical and planar nuclei in the ratio of 6:3:1. If the nucleons in the core undergo a transition to a superfluid and/or superconducting state, the modified URCA process is suppressed by a factor of ∼ e − ∆ /k B T , where ∆ is the superfluid energy gap. In this case bremsstrahlung is dominant and the neutrino emission is suppressed efficiently as a consequence of the presence of pasta phases. Nuclear systems can be regarded as complex fluids of nucleons. Complex fluids are the systems in which scales of the fluid and their constituents cannot be separated clearly; both scales are strongly connected with each other. Such characteristic can be seen in various soft condensed matter systems. For example, polymer systems are one of the typical complex fluids (description of polymer systems in the present section is mainly based on an instructive review [28]). Actually, similar spatial structures to nuclear pasta as shown in Fig. 3 can be seen in some polymer systems such as domain structures in solutions and melts of block copolymers. Thus it would be interesting to compare the hierarchical structure of nuclear systems with that of polymer systems. Polymers are made up of monomers connected by covalent bondings and their degrees of polymerization are quite large ( > 100 ). Consequently, in polymer systems, the scale of constituents is as large as that of macroscopic phenomena such as phase separation of the domain structures. Thus polymer systems behave as complex fluids. In nuclear systems, the nature of a complex fluid is caused by strong and short range nuclear force. In Fig. 6, we show the hierarchical structures of nuclear systems and of polymer systems. Nuclear pasta phases and domain structures of block copolymers can be classified in the semimacroscopic scale. Thus theoretical methods based on the mesoscopic or semimacroscopic scales are practical for studying these systems. In the study of polymer systems, the density functional theory and the Ginzburg-Landau theory correspond to ...

Citations

Article
The first results of a new three-dimensional, finite temperature Skyrme-Hartree-Fock+BCS study of the properties of inhomogeneous nuclear matter at densities and temperatures leading to the transition to uniform nuclear matter are presented. Calculations are carried out in a cubic box representing a unit cell of the locally periodic structure of the matter. A constraint is placed on the two independent components of the quadrupole moment of the neutron density to investigate the dependence of the total energy density of matter on the geometry of the nuclear structure in the unit cell. This approach allows self-consistent modeling of effects such as (i) neutron drip, resulting in a neutron gas external to the nuclear structure; (ii) shell effects of bound and unbound nucleons; (iii) the variety of exotic nuclear shapes that emerge, collectively termed nuclear pasta; and (iv) the dissolution of these structures into uniform nuclear matter as density and/or temperature increase. In Part I of this work the calculation of the properties of inhomogeneous nuclear matter in the core collapse of massive stars is reported. Emphasis is on exploring the effects of the numerical method on the results obtained; notably, the influence of the finite cell size on the nuclear shapes and energy-density obtained. Results for nuclear matter in β equilibrium in cold neutrons stars are the subject of Part II. The calculation of the band structure of unbound neutrons in neutron star matter, yielding thermal conductivity, specific heat, and entrainment parameters, is outlined in Part III. Calculations are performed at baryon number densities of nb=0.04-0.12 fm-3, a proton fraction of yp=0.3 and temperatures in the range 0–7.5 MeV. A wide variety of nuclear shapes are shown to emerge. It is suggested that thermodynamical properties change smoothly in the pasta regime up to the transition to uniform matter; at that transition, thermodynamic properties of the matter vary discontinuously, indicating a phase transition of first or second order. The calculations are carried out using the SkM* Skyrme parametrization; a comparison with calculations using Sly4 at nb=0.08 fm-3, T=0 MeV is made.
Article
Full-text available
In the present paper, we investigate the onset of the “pasta” phase with different parametrizations of the density dependent hadronic model and compare the results with one of the usual parametrizations of the nonlinear Walecka model. The influence of the scalar-isovector virtual δ meson is shown. At zero temperature, two different methods are used, one based on coexistent phases and the other on the Thomas-Fermi approximation. At finite temperature, only the coexistence phases method is used. npe matter with fixed proton fractions and in β equilibrium are studied. We compare our results with restrictions imposed on the values of the density and pressure at the inner edge of the crust, obtained from observations of the Vela pulsar and recent isospin diffusion data from heavy-ion reactions, and with predictions from spinodal calculations.
Article
In this paper, we calculate the diffusion coefficients that are related to the neutrino opacities considering the formation of nuclear pasta and homogeneous matter at low densities. Our results show that the mean-free paths are significantly altered by the presence of nuclear pasta in stellar matter when compared with the results obtained with homogeneous matter. These differences in neutrino opacities certainly influence the Kelvin-Helmholtz phase of protoneutron stars and consequently the results of supernova explosion simulations.
Article
Full-text available
The effects of the α particles in nuclear matter at low densities are investigated within three different parametrizations of relativistic models at finite temperature. Both homogeneous and inhomogeneous matter (pasta phase) are described for neutral nuclear matter with fixed proton fractions and stellar matter subject to β equilibrium and trapped neutrinos. In homogeneous matter, α particles are present only at densities below 0.02 fm-3 and their presence decreases with increase of the temperature and, for a fixed temperature, the α particle fraction decreases for smaller proton fractions. A repulsive interaction is important to mimic the dissolution of the clusters in homogeneous matter. The effect of the α particles on the pasta structure is very small except close to the critical temperatures and/or proton fractions, when it may still predict a pasta phase while no pasta phase would occur in the absence of light clusters. It is shown that for densities above 0.01 fm3 the α-particle fraction in the pasta phase is much larger than that in homogeneous matter.
Article
Full-text available
The nuclear pasta—a novel state of matter having nucleons arranged in a variety of complex shapes—is expected to be found in the crust of neutron stars and in core-collapse supernovae at subnuclear densities of about 1014 g/cm3. Owing to frustration, a phenomenon that emerges from the competition between short-range nuclear attraction and long-range Coulomb repulsion, the nuclear pasta displays a preponderance of unique low-energy excitations. These excitations could have a strong impact on many transport properties, such as neutrino propagation through stellar environments. The excitation spectrum of the nuclear pasta is computed via a molecular-dynamics simulation involving up to 100,000 nucleons. The dynamic response of the pasta displays a classical plasma oscillation in the 1- to 2-MeV region. In addition, substantial strength is found at low energies. Yet this low-energy strength is missing from a simple ion model containing a single-representative heavy nucleus. The low-energy strength observed in the dynamic response of the pasta is likely to be a density wave involving the internal degrees of freedom of the clusters.
Article
Full-text available
We review the current status of models of matter at subnuclear density as it appears in astrophysical contexts; namely, during core collapse of supernovae and in the inner crusts of neutron stars. We discuss the main observational probes of this regime, and present preliminary results of our own studies of the so-called nuclear pasta that appears in this density regime.
Article
Full-text available
The structure and composition of the inner crust of neutron stars, as well as global stellar properties such as radius and moment of inertia, have been shown to correlate with parameters characterizing the symmetry energy of nuclear matter such as its magnitude J and density dependence L at saturation density. It is thus mutually beneficial to nuclear physicists and astrophysicists to examine the combined effects of such correlations on potential neutron star observables in the light of recent experimental and theoretical constraints on J, L, and relationships between them. We review some basic correlations between these nuclear and astrophysical observables, and illustrate the impact of recent progress in constraining the J-L parameter space on the composition of the inner crust, crust-core transition density and pressure, and extent of the hypothesized pasta region. We use a simple compressible liquid drop model in conjunction with a simple model of nuclear matter which allows for independent, smooth, variation of the J and L. We extend the model into the core using the same nuclear matter model to explore the effects on global crust and core properties, and on potential observables such as crust oscillation frequencies and mechanically supported crust deformation. Throughout we illustrate the importance of the relationship between J and L implicit in a particular model of nuclear matter to the predictions of neutron star properties.
Article
Full-text available
In cores of supernovae and crusts of neutron stars, nuclei can adopt interesting shapes, such as rods or slabs, etc., which are referred to as nuclear "pasta." In recent years, we have studied the pasta phases focusing on their dynamical aspects with a quantum molecular dynamic (QMD) approach. In this article, we review these works. We also focus on the treatment of the Coulomb interaction.
Article
Full-text available
We examine how the properties of inhomogeneous nuclear matter at subnuclear densities depend on the density dependence of the symmetry energy. Using a macroscopic nuclear model we calculate the size and shape of nuclei in neutron star matter at zero temperature in a way dependent on the density dependence of the symmetry energy. We find that for smaller symmetry energy at subnuclear densities, corresponding to larger density symmetry coefficient L, the charge number of nuclei is smaller, and the critical density at which matter with nuclei or bubbles becomes uniform is lower. The decrease in the charge number is associated with the dependence of the surface tension on the nuclear density and the density of a sea of neutrons, while the decrease in the critical density can be generally understood in terms of proton clustering instability in uniform matter.
Article
Full-text available
The neutron radius of a heavy nucleus is a fundamental nuclear-structure observable that remains elusive. Progress in this arena has been limited by the exclusive use of hadronic probes that are hindered by large and controversial uncertainties in the reaction mechanism. The Parity Radius Experiment at the Jefferson Laboratory offers an attractive electro-weak alternative to the hadronic program and promises to measure the neutron radius of 208Pb accurately and model independently via parity-violating electron scattering. In this contribution we examine the far-reaching implications that such a determination will have in areas as diverse as nuclear structure, atomic parity violation, and astrophysics.