1: Excel data sheet including geographic coordinates 

1: Excel data sheet including geographic coordinates 

Source publication
Article
Full-text available
This report provides a methodology for the evaluation of cultural losses due to flooding. First, the theo-retical background for the development of this methodology is described. Based on the available knowl-edge, it is proposed to evaluate the cultural losses using two factors: the physical damages of the cultural assets due to flooding and the cu...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... chapter attempts to evaluate the cultural losses by considering both physical damages of the cultural assets and the cultural values. Unlike in the previous chapter, the cultural assets are represented by point data in the GIS map and the types of the cultural assts are specially considered. Since all the data required for the assessment of cultural value as proposed in the methodology described in Chapter 1 are difficult to collect, a simple approach is used in this analysis for the assessment of the level of cultural value of each asset. The same data set collected previously (as in Chapter 2.1.1) and the Excel data sheet (in Figure 2.2) is used in this analysis. However, the digitization of data is different from the previous analysis. Here, the assets are marked as points instead of area polygons. Geocoding is the process of finding associated geographic coordinates (i.e. latitude and longitude) from other geographic data, such as street addresses, or zip codes (postal codes). In this study, the coordinates were found using the addresses of cultural assets. A freely available webtool (or Geocoder) called “GPS Visualizer” was adopted to transform the addresses to coordinates ( It allows the entry of addresses in a list. Here, a sample list can be downloaded in order to have an appropriate style. On the basis of a gazetteer service, addresses are converted to geographic coordinates and the geographical coordinates are displayed in Latitude-Longitude format. These data must be copied into an original address list. The output from the geocoder can be linked with the Excel spreadsheet. The final data set therefore contains the information on latitude, longitude, address, the type of building, the categorization and the dating of each building (Figure ...
Context 2
... 1.1: Changes in Exceedence Probability-Damage Curve as a Result of Adopting Replication Costs (modified from Rodakowski, 1978). ...................................................... 5 Figure 1.2: Proposed methodology for the assessment of cultural losses (Dassanayake and Oumeraci, 2011). .............................................................................................................. 7 Figure 1.3: Depth-damage curves for residential buildings (USACE, 2003, 2006, and Middelmann-Fernandes, 2010) ......................................................................................... 9 Figure 1.4: Expected flood damage due to surging floods (Nadal, 2007) .............................. 10 Figure 1.5: Building collapse curve – Class C buildings - masonry or concrete walls (USACE, 1985) ............................................................................................................................... 11 Figure 1.6: Building damage assessment criteria by (a) Clausen (1989) and (b) Pistrika and Jonkman (2010) .............................................................................................................. 12 Figure 1.7: Level of physical damage in cultural assets related to flood depth and velocity (damage criteria are adopted from USACE, 1985; Clausan, 1989; Queensland Government, 2002; Pistrika and Jonkman , 2010 and Figure 1.3) .................................. 13 Figure 2.1: The Excel Table including the information on the cultural assets in Hamburg- Wilhelmsburg area. ......................................................................................................... 20 Figure 2.2: a) Identification of cultural assets, (e.g. Holy Cross Church and the cemetery in Hamburg-Wilhelmsburg), b) digitisation of cultural assets as area polygons and c) all cultural assets in Hamburg-Wilhelmsburg after digitisation. ........................................... 21 Figure 2.3: Estimated flood depths for flooding scenario HH_XR2010A ................................ 22 Figure 2.4: Estimated flow velocities for flooding scenario HH_XR2010A ............................. 23 Figure 2.5: Cultural loss assessment model in ArcGIS Modelbuilder. ................................... 24 Figure 2.6: Calculation of damage level based on flood depth, velocity and depth-velocity product. ........................................................................................................................... 25 Figure 2.7: Conversion of vector data to raster data .............................................................. 25 Figure 2.8: The level of cultural losses in Hamburg-Wilhelmsburg area (based on physical damages to cultural assets). ........................................................................................... 26 Figure 2.9: The percentage of affected grid cells for each loss level. .................................... 26 Figure 3.1: Excel data sheet including geographic coordinates ............................................. 28 Figure 3.2: Digitized cultural assets in Hamburg-Wilhelmsburg as point data. ...................... 29 Figure 3.3: Attribute table which includes geographic coordinates. ....................................... 30 Figure 3.4: GIS model for the assessment of cultural losses based on physical damages and cultural values. ................................................................................................................ 32 Figure 3.5: Allocation of cultural value based on the class of cultural assets. ....................... 32   ...

Similar publications

Article
Full-text available
Flooding continues to be a common environmental hazard in both developed and developing countries. Crops, settlement and infrastructure are usually impaired wherever flooding occur. The severity of damage as a result of floods has been documented to have a relationship with the flood magnitude, flood frequency and settlement of population on flood...
Article
Full-text available
La zone présaharienne de la Tunisie est caractérisée par des conditions climatiques très contraignantes à la survie des végétaux (pluviométrie très faible et très irrégulière, températures élevées, évapotranspiration très intense…). Cependant certaines zones bio-géomorphologiques gardent encore des conditions plus ou moins favorables à l'existence...
Technical Report
Full-text available
The purpose of this technical paper is to describe and discuss the methodology used to create flow path maps for the purpose of predicting the trajectory of liquid pollutants in the terrestrial environment. The first section of this paper will discuss the impacts of hydrocarbons on the terrestrial environment and the need for accident mitigation me...
Preprint
Full-text available
ArcGIS is a widely used software for Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and cartography generation, and although it features a highly sophisticated package of software and tools, not all of them are necessary for the editing and structuring process of the Geographic Insititute Agustín Codazzi (IGAC) Division of Geography and Cartography; and in t...
Article
Full-text available
Rapid increase in settlement areas with rapidly increasing population after the industrial revolution led to the formation of unplanned and irregular urbanization. By including climate data into city plans, comfortable spaces have been created to make people comfortable. Bioclimatic comfort is defined as the conditions in which a person adapts to t...

Citations

... As underlined by UNESCO (2010), our heritage is increasingly affected by natural phenomena, even those not considered in the global register of catastrophic risks. Recent studies have furthermore highlighted the relationship between natural hazards and the little remaining or permanently lost cultural heritage (Dassanayake et al., 2012;Murthy, 2013;Nicu, 2019). Hydrological and hydraulic risks such as floods, debris flows, humidity and erosion are widely recognized for their catastrophic potential, and several studies have attempted to assess the hydraulic risks in historical cities, including the impact of climate change (Lanza, 2003;European Parliament, 2007;Arrighi et al., 2013;Camuffo et al., 2014;Arrighi et al., 2018). ...
... As underlined by UNESCO (2010), our heritage is increasingly affected by natural phenomena, even those not considered in the global register of catastrophic risks. Recent studies have furthermore highlighted the relationship between natural hazards and the little remaining or permanently lost cultural heritage (Dassanayake et al., 2012;Murthy, 2013;Nicu, 2019). Hydrological and hydraulic risks such as floods, debris flows, humidity and erosion are widely recognized for their catastrophic potential, and several studies have attempted to assess the hydraulic risks in historical cities, including the impact of climate change (Lanza, 2003;European Parliament, 2007;Arrighi et al., 2013;Camuffo et al., 2014;Arrighi et al., 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents a methodological approach for analysing and evaluating hydraulic risks in complex archaeological areas, and thereby substantially improve general preservation and conservation efforts involving cultural heritage.The hypogeum of Calaforno (province of Ragusa, Sicily) represents a unique sample of rock-cut architecture in terms of size and architectural features, and an ideal candidate for the case study due to its high historical, archaeological and cultural significance, as well as its intrinsic fragility and criticality associated with hydrogeological and seismic factors.The interdisciplinary research approach involved archaeological and engineering contributions towards the development of numerical models for the assessment of hydraulic risks threatening archaeological heritage. The morphological characteristics of the site rendered the use of a Laser Scanner necessary for three-dimensional survey.The prehistoric structures currently undergoing excavation outside the main entrance of the monument have raised concerns regarding the impact of the Manna stream, which flows a few meters from the main entrance to the hypogeum, which has seen periodic flooding in some of its rooms. Simulations of these flooding events were performed in order to attain better understanding of the hydraulic phenomena influencing the site, especially regarding the dynamics associated with surface runoff.The interdisciplinary approach to this research, combining in-depth archaeological expertise with digital 3D surveying and modelling technologies, has proven fundamental to the effective monitoring of this morphologically complex site, and should perhaps be considered integral to any preventive assessment and risk management initiative involving cultural heritage.
... environmental goods and services that have no market prices) using the Contingent Valuation Method from the literature (Iz-VRS, 2014, Markantonis et al., 2013). Damages to cultural heritage cover tangible damages based on average damages recorded in the AJDA application and intangible damages based on the magnitude of tangible damages and an additional factor for intangible damage (Dassanayake et al., 2012), for which Vu of the individual elements of cultural assets were proposed already in 2011 (Adamič et al., 2011). Tangible damage to structures, equipment and other fixtures of residential buildings is based on depth-damage curves (FEMA, 2014). ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Floods are the most frequent natural disasters and cannot be prevented. However, we can mitigate their consequences by implementing flood protection measures, which have to be economically sound. Therefore, when planning such measures, we have to know how to reduce the damage caused by floods and increase the actual benefits of the implemented measures. In the presented project, we upgraded the existing unified method for Slovenia. This method covers flood damage in different sectors (people and health, cultural heritage, natural environment, residential, agricultural and business sectors). For each of the sectors, a simple equation is used to calculate the damage cost, taking into account the strength, duration and dimension of the expected flood event with different return periods as well as exposure, vulnerability and values of the exposed elements in the targeted area. To estimate these values, both data from the census and market values were used. Using the proposed methodology, an application was developed based on the geographic information system. According to their type, the input data are based on three main forms: point, (poly)line, and (multi)polygon. Separate databases were established for each type of data. The developed application was tested in three flood areas in Slovenia. According to the results, it was adjusted for use by various groups of users.
... con- sisting of more than one site, so-called serial nominations 31 , we manually check each WHS and add further point data entries for serial sites based on maps and descriptions provided on the UNESCO website 2 . To reflect each WHS location as accurately as possible, we follow the methodology used in Chang et al. 100 and Dassanayake et al. 101 . Therefore, we correct the location of misplaced WHS by using Google Earth™ satellite imagery. ...
Article
Full-text available
UNESCO World Heritage sites (WHS) located in coastal areas are increasingly at risk from coastal hazards due to sea-level rise. In this study, we assess Mediterranean cultural WHS at risk from coastal flooding and erosion under four sea-level rise scenarios until 2100. Based on the analysis of spatially explicit WHS data, we develop an index-based approach that allows for ranking WHS at risk from both coastal hazards. Here we show that of 49 cultural WHS located in low-lying coastal areas of the Mediterranean, 37 are at risk from a 100-year flood and 42 from coastal erosion, already today. Until 2100, flood risk may increase by 50% and erosion risk by 13% across the region, with considerably higher increases at individual WHS. Our results provide a first-order assessment of where adaptation is most urgently needed and can support policymakers in steering local-scale research to devise suitable adaptation strategies for each WHS.
... Additional predictors of resilience measuring the expected time and resources needed to restore the functionality/quality of the asset [38] could potentially also be established. However, when dealing with cultural heritage assets, the multidimensional nature of the value of the asset and the complexity of its evaluation [45][46][47][48] are a major conceptual obstacle. Therefore, in such cases, predicting the time and resources that might be required to restore functionality and quality is much more difficult. ...
Article
Full-text available
A simplified risk assessment framework specifically developed for built immovable cultural heritage assets is proposed. The framework addresses the several components involved in a risk analysis and can be used as a screening procedure for the preliminary assessment of a large number of assets with limited resources. It can also be used to identify cultural heritage assets that require a more refined and resource demanding risk evaluation. The proposed risk analysis framework falls into the category of qualitative methods and is based on a series of structured questionnaires that address the main components of a risk analysis: The likelihood of the hazard, the consequences of the hazard, the vulnerability of the asset to the hazard, the loss of value of the asset and the capacity to recover from the event. In order to illustrate its application, a case study is presented in which the risk analysis is performed for a church in Italy that was damaged, in 2009, by the L'Aquila earthquake.
... Additional predictors of resilience measuring the expected time and resources needed to restore the functionality/quality of the asset [38] could potentially also be established. However, when dealing with cultural heritage assets, the multidimensional nature of the value of the asset and the complexity of its evaluation [45][46][47][48] are a major conceptual obstacle. Therefore, in such cases, predicting the time and resources that might be required to restore functionality and quality is much more difficult. ...
Article
A simplified risk assessment framework specifically developed for built immovable cultural heritage assets is proposed. The framework addresses all the components in a risk analysis and can be used as a screening procedure for the preliminary assessment of a large number of assets with limited resources. Furthermore, the framework can also be used to identify cultural heritage assets that require a more refined and resource demanding risk evaluation. The proposed risk analysis framework falls into the category of qualitative methods and is based on an existing approach developed for the vulnerability assessment of critical infrastructures. The qualitative risk analysis of the proposed methodology is based on a set of structured assessment flowcharts that address the main components of a risk analysis: the likelihood of the hazard, the vulnerability of the asset to the hazard, the consequences of the hazard, the loss of value of the asset and the capacity to recover from the event. To illustrate the applicability of the proposed methodology, an application example is also presented for the case of seismic risk.
Article
Endüstri Devrimiyle birlikte fosil yakıt tüketiminin yaygınlaşması ve ardından yaşanan modernleşme ile küreselleşme akımları kentleşme oranını hızlandırmıştır. Gittikçe artan üretim ve tüketim miktarı, yenilenemez enerji kaynaklarının kullanımını arttırarak atmosferde sera gazlarının birikmesine neden olmuştur. Bu durum dünyanın gittikçe ısınmasına yol açmış ve iklimsel değişimlerin meydana gelmesine ortam hazırlamıştır. Dolayısıyla yer küre, iklim değişikliği tehdidi ile karşı karşıya kalmıştır. Bu bağlamda İklim değişikliği, 21. yüzyılın en önemli küresel problemlerinden biri olup tüm ekosistemi etkileyen bir krizdir. Söz konusu etkiler günümüzde gittikçe daha fazla hissedilmektedir. Özellikle küresel ısınma devam ettikçe dünya genelinde olağan dışı atmosferik olayların, yangınların ve sellerin sayısı ile şiddetinde artışlar gözlemlenmektedir. Bu nedenle doğal afetlerin bıraktığı hasarlar somut bir biçimde kendini göstermeye başlamıştır. Ayrıca pek çok zorluğa ve olumsuz şartlara direnerek günümüze kadar ulaşabilmiş tarihi yapılar, antik kentler, tarihi çevreler, kültürel peyzajlar evrensel değere sahip olup tüm insanlığın ortak mirasıdır. Nitekim birer belge niteliğindeki bu mirasların korunarak geleceğe aktarılmaları önem arz etmektedir. Ancak iklim değişikliğinden etkilenenler arasında kültürel miras da yer almakta olup, günümüzde ve gelecekte tehlike altındadır. Bu çalışmanın amacı iklim değişikliğinin kültürel miras üzerindeki etkilerini irdelemektir. Çalışmada kapsamlı bir literatür taraması yapılarak lisansüstü tezlerden, makalelerden, kitaplardan yararlanılmış ve kavramsal çerçeve oluşturulmuştur. Yapılan taramalar ışığında iklim değişikliğinin kültürel mirasa etkileri açıklanmıştır. Elde edilen veriler araştırma kapsamında sunulmuştur.
Article
Full-text available
EXTENDED ABSTRACT The Problem: According to the climate change projections will be an increase in the torrential rains and related floods. In parallel with this, the risk of flood damage to the architectural heritage will increase in the future. Floods cause serious damage to the architectural heritage. Since flood risk analyses are generally made basin-based, studies on flood risks of cities are still inadequate. Therefore, flood risks arising from the architectural heritage's own characteristics and its current situations are not known. Not knowing which architectural heritage poses the flood risk and its potential losses increases the damage. Objective: In preventive preservation, the measures taken before the risks occur are effective in reducing the damage, even if they do not eliminate the risks completely. It is necessary to know the flood risk in order to make the architectural heritage be prepared against floods that are predicted to increase with the effect of climate change. In this study, it is aimed to develop a model for analysing the flood risk of architectural heritage. With the Architectural Heritage Flood Risk Analysis Model (MİSRAM) developed in line with this purpose, the vulnerability of any architectural heritage can be calculated with the parameter scores developed over the building's own characteristics and current state. Method: The development and implementation of the model was carried out in 4 stages. In the first stage; flood damage in the architectural heritage has been investigated; on-site detection, observation and investigations were made to determine the factors that increase the damage. Flood-induced forces and effects from the data obtained; the types of damage caused by these forces and effects in the architectural heritage, the areas where the damage occurred in the building and the possible damage risks were determined. In the second stage, the factors affecting the damage level were defined and transformed into flood risk parameters. In the third stage, the flood risk parameters and the coefficient of flood risk area were made into a calculation table in Excel program. The analyse form was created by adding the building identification section to the created calculation sheet. In the fourth stage, the risk analysis forms were filled in on-site. Findings: As a result of the researches made in the scope of the study's problem the findings below have been reached: • Climate change causes an increase in sudden and heavy rains and accordingly flash floods, and these effects will continue to increase in the future. • Architectural heritage located in the region with the same flood risk coefficient may have different flood risk levels depending on different parameters. Therefore, the flood risk of the architectural heritage cannot be calculated only through the flood risk of the region where it is located, a heritage specific risk analysis model should be developed and in this model, the heritage’s own characteristics and current situation should be taken into account. • Factors that increase flood damage in architectural heritage should be identified and included in the calculation in risk analysis. • There has been an increase in the number of floods in the province of Edirne after 2000s. Conclusion: The developed model proposal MISRAM was applied to the buildings of Bayezid II Complex, and the flood risk levels of the buildings were determined. Determining the flood risk level in the flood management planning of the architectural heritage is the first step and constitutes an important data for decision-makers. In further studies, it is recommended to develop protection measures and interventions that will not adversely affect the heritage values for the architectural heritage whose flood risk level is determined, and studies to analyse the flood risk of the cultural heritage other than the architectural heritage. Unique Value: The flood risk of the architectural heritage can be analysed and appropriate flood prevention and response decisions can be made via applying MISRAM. It can be integrated into disaster management plans of local governments, and it may constitute the first step in reducing the architectural heritage damages and preventing the losses in the flood disasters. MISRAM is a method that can be used both as a resource for creating architectural heritage flood risk maps and for decision-makers to make appropriate measures and intervention decisions. Keywords: Climate Change, Architectural Heritage Flood Risk Analysis, Flood Hazard on Architectural Heritage, Edirne Bayezid II Complex
Article
Archaeological sites are extremely vulnerable to the impacts of weather-related events, which may lead to irreparable damages to cultural heritage. Here an assessment of the debris-flow hazard for the UNESCO site of Roman Villa del Casale (Italy) is carried out, through a combination of historical analyses, field surveys, geomorphological and hydrological investigations and two-dimensional hydraulic numerical modelling, all performed at river catchment scale. Historical analyses reveal that the site has been hit by several landslides in the far and recent past. This is presently confirmed by the high level of exposure to the impact of rain-triggered debris-flow events, due to the position of the Villa at a closure section of the related river basin and to the hydro-geomorphological characteristics of the basin itself. By applying the proposed approach, a scenario analysis is carried out. Results allow one to highlight the dynamics of the impact of debris flows, thanks to space and time-dependent maps about deposition areas, water depth and speed values, and to identify the most vulnerable archaeological elements within the study site. The numerical simulations are also used to test the efficiency of the existing hydraulic defense systems and to support the implementation of an early warning system for the site protection. Here we also synthetize the design of the architecture of the wireless monitoring network, the sensor technology adopted to develop an effective real time environmental monitoring system and management platform, to construct a Wireless Sensor Network (WSN) - early warning and reporting system, which can be applied as a prevention measure.