ArticlePDF Available

Merits of the PMiT (Papillary Microtumor) Terminology in the Definition of a Subset of Incidental Papillary Microcarcinomas of the Thyroid

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

An exponential increase in the detection of papillary thyroid microcarcinomas (PTMCs) has been observed in recent times, possibly because of recent improvements in the management of thyroid lesions and extensive histological examination. However, no definitive treatment guideline has been developed for PTMC, resulting in patients undergoing overtreatment. In 2003, the term papillary microtumor of the thyroid (PMiT) was proposed for small (< or =1 cm) intrathyroidal tumors with excellent prognostic prospects along with strict definition criteria. Since then, the term PMiT has been adopted by clinicians and surgeons. In this article, the authors report a series of 50 consecutive cases of PMiT collected and treated at the University Hospital of Turin, Italy. From the authors' experience, this terminology, which demarks a subset of PTMC, should be widely adopted as it is biologically sound, well accepted by both clinicians and patients, decreases the danger of overtreatment, minimizes the psychological anxiety engendered by a diagnosis of carcinoma, and maintains the patient's eligibility for health insurance.
Content may be subject to copyright.
1
Merits of the PMiT (Papillary
Microtumor) Terminology in the
Definition of a Subset of Incidental
Papillary Microcarcinomas of the Thyroid
Sofia Asioli, MD, Chiara Odasso, MD, Luigia Macrì, MD,
Nicola Palestini, MD, and Gianni Bussolati, MD, FRCPath
The incidence of thyroid cancer, particularly the
papillary forms, has been increasing sharply for many
years in Western countries. Recently, Colonna et al2
published a study on changes in the incidence of
both papillary and follicular thyroid cancers and the
effect of tumor size from data taken from 6 cancer
registries in France (1983-2000). They found that
the increase in papillary carcinomas was high for
both sexes; in particular, the study showed that the
sharpest increase with a yearly progression of more
than 12% was observed for carcinomas smaller than
10 mm.2A change in the distribution of the size of
papillary carcinomas has also been described in the
United States, where the estimated proportion of
microcarcinomas within papillary thyroid carcinomas
(PTCs) was 27% in 1996.3In Switzerland, an
increase was observed in thyroid microcarcinomas,
mainly of the papillary type, which rose from 17%
during the 1970 to 1979 period to 24% during the
1990 to 1998 period.4In Italy, Trimboli et al5
recently evaluated the temporal trend in tumor size,
Introduction
According to the latest World Health Organization
(WHO) definition, published in 2004, papillary thy-
roid microcarcinoma (PTMC) is defined as a papillary
carcinoma, often not detectable in clinical examina-
tion, that is found incidentally (ie, after thyroidectomy
performed for other indications or during ultrasound
examination) and measures 1 cm in diameter.1
An exponential increase in the detection of papillary
thyroid microcarcinomas (PTMCs) has been observed
in recent times, possibly because of recent improve-
ments in the management of thyroid lesions and exten-
sive histological examination. However, no definitive
treatment guideline has been developed for PTMC,
resulting in patients undergoing overtreatment. In
2003, the term papillary microtumor of the thyroid
(PMiT) was proposed for small (1 cm) intrathyroidal
tumors with excellent prognostic prospects along with
strict definition criteria. Since then, the term PMiT
has been adopted by clinicians and surgeons. In this
article, the authors report a series of 50 consecutive
cases of PMiT collected and treated at the University
Hospital of Turin, Italy. From the authors’ experience,
this terminology, which demarks a subset of PTMC,
should be widely adopted as it is biologically sound,
well accepted by both clinicians and patients,
decreases the danger of overtreatment, minimizes the
psychological anxiety engendered by a diagnosis of car-
cinoma, and maintains the patient’s eligibility for
health insurance.
Keywords: PMiT; papillary; microcarcinoma; thyroid
From the Departments of Biomedical Sciences and Oncology
(SA, LM, GB) and Surgery (CO, NP), University of Turin,
Turin, Italy.
This study was supported by grants from AIRC (Associazione
Italiana per la Ricerca sul Cancro), MIUR, Piedmont Region,
Compagnia di San Paolo “Special Project Oncology” and the
Fondazione Internazionale di Ricerca in Medicina Sperimentale
(FIRMS), Turin, Italy.
Address correspondence to: Sofia Asioli, MD, Department of
Biomedical Sciences and Human Oncology, Molinette Hospital,
University of Turin, Via Santena 7, 10126 Turin, Italy; e-mail:
sofia.asioli@unito.it.
International Journal of
Surgical Pathology
Volume XX Number X
Month XXXX xx-xx
© 2008 Sage Publications
10.1177/1066896908321181
http://ijsp.sagepub.com
hosted at
http://online.sagepub.com
2International Journal of Surgical Pathology / Vol. XX, No. X, Month XXXX
age at diagnosis, and histology in a retrospective
analysis of 500 thyroid cancers diagnosed over 20
years at the Thyroid Clinic of the University of Rome
“La Sapienza.” They found that the size of the PTC
decreased from 28 ±1.2 to 14 ±0.8 mm in the last
decade. Moreover, a significant increase of PTMC
rate, from 7.3% to 36.4%, was also observed.5This
exponential increase in the detection of PTCMs
could possibly be explained by recent improvements
in the management of thyroid lesions as well as
extensive histological examination of thyroid lesions.
From a pathology point of view, PTMCs are
small (1 cm) papillary carcinomas that share archi-
tectural, cytological, immunohistochemical, and
clinical features with their larger counterparts. The
clinical behavior of PTCM is usually indolent.6
Sometimes PTMCs present as “occult” carci-
noma and may have a clinical behavior, presenting
with regional lymph node metastases or, more rarely,
distant metastases.7-11 In an earlier study,12 PTMCs
presenting as a “histological surprise” were free of dis-
ease during a follow-up of 3 to 23 years, with a mean
of 6.4 years, and there was no single instance of dis-
tant metastasis.
However, no definitive treatment guideline has
yet been developed to indicate how best to treat and
manage these small tumors. The confusion sur-
rounding the definition and the treatment of PTMC
has been made plainly evident in various scientific
articles on the subject.13-20 The guidelines for differ-
entiated thyroid carcinoma recently published by
the American Thyroid Association21 and the
European Thyroid Association22 agree that in cases
of PTMC therapy should be adapted to the method
of discovery and to favorable prognostic criteria (ie,
unifocal lesion, classical histological subtype, no
extension beyond the thyroid capsule, no lymph
node metastasis, and normal contralateral lobe).
The existence of a subset of incidental papillary
microcarcinomas of the thyroid, defined as unifocal
small (1 cm) lesion with no extension beyond the thy-
roid capsule and without lymph node metastasis with
benign clinical course, is indisputable, and this subset
of PTMC could be designated from clinical and
histopathological points of view as a “minimal risk
group” of thyroid lesions, keeping in mind that we are
dealing with patients who have a normal life expectancy
and to whom we have to guarantee a very good quality
of life.
A panel of 4 thyroid pathologists, involved in a
consensus meeting that took place in Porto, March
3-5, 2003, during the 12th Annual Cancer Meeting,
aimed at developing uniform diagnostic criteria for
PTMC carcinomas and proposing a new term for a
subset of PTCM. Indeed, the panel renamed such a
subset of PTMC as “papillary microtumor” (PMiT).
Diagnosis of PMiT has to be based on the following
criteria: (a) size (1 cm); (b) absence of metastases
at presentation; (c) adult patients only; (d) unifocal
or multifocal lesions (2 or more lesions are detected
to be 1 cm); (e) exclusion of features indicative of
invasion of the thyroid capsule, blood vessel perme-
ation, or tall cells features; (f) PMiT could occur
within a benign lesion; and (g) PMiT could be occa-
sionally detected preoperatively at ultrasound exam-
ination, computed tomography, or magnetic resonance
imaging23 (Table 1).
The term PMiT was chosen because it indicates
that the lesion is of a small size, is a neoplastic
process belonging to the papillary family neoplasm,
and is not necessarily malignant. We are not aware
of other endocrine pathology centers having adopted
this terminology. However, since 2003, we have
adopted the Porto proposal criteria for PMiT, in
agreement with clinicians and surgeons. We report
our experience on a series of 50 consecutive cases
designated as PMiT (during the period from March
2003 to August 2007) and treated at our hospital.
Materials and Methods
Clinical Data
Cases were obtained from the files of all thyroid
specimens (1407 cases) analyzed at the Department
of Biomedical Sciences and Human Oncology,
University of Turin, during the period from March
2003 to August 2007. The lesions were diagnosed
as benign thyroid diseases (ie, goiters, thyroid
Table 1. Diagnostic Criteria of Papillary Microtumor
According to the Porto Proposal
Age 19 years
Size 1 cm
Metastases at presentation No
Number of lesions One or more (<1 cm when take
together)
Capsule invasion No
Vascular invasion No
Tall cells features No
Benign lesions Yes
Radiological images Detectable (1 cm)
PMiT (Papillary Microtumor): A Subset of PTMC / Asioli et al 3
autoimmune diseases, cystic lesions, follicular ade-
nomas) in 1052 cases (74.8%) and as malignant
thyroid lesions (ie, primary thyroid carcinomas, pri-
mary thyroid lymphoma, metastatic lesions) in 355
cases (25.2%). Among these cases, 273 (273/355,
76.9%) were diagnosed as papillary thyroid neoplasm,
specifically, 154 (154/273, 56.4%) PTC (>1 cm), 10
(10/273, 3.7%) “occult” PTMC (1 cm), 59
(59/273, 21.6%) “incidental” PTMC (1 cm), and
50 (50/273, 18.3%) PMiT (Figure 1).
In this article, we report a series of 50 consecutive
cases designated as PMiT, according to predefined cri-
teria. All patients were white individuals who were
treated at the same surgical init (ie, the Department of
Surgery at the Molinette Hospital, University of Turin).
Thirty-nine of the 50 cases designated as PMiT
(78%) were females and 11 (22%) were males, with
ages ranging from 38 to 77 years (median age of 55.1
years) and from 30 to 79 years (median age of 58.3
years), respectively, at the time of presentation.
Patients presented with goiter (40/50 cases, 80%),
solitary nodule (9/50 cases, 18%), and chronic lym-
phatic thyroditis (1/50 cases, 2%) at clinical observa-
tion. The hormonal status of the patients at
presentation was hypothyroidism (1/50 patient, 2%),
hyperthyroidism (7/50 patients, 14%), or euthy-
rodism (40/50 patients, 80%); 2 patients showed pri-
mary hyperparathyroidism (2/50 patients, 4%).
All patients underwent surgery, with 47 patients
undergoing total thyroidectomy without lymphade-
nectomy (47/50 cases, 94%) and 3 patients being
subjected to lobectomy (3/50 cases, 6%). Complica-
tions associated with surgery were permanent
hypoparathyroidism in 1 patient also submitted to
subtotal parathyroidectomy for primary hyperparathy-
roidism (2%), transient hypoparathyroidism in 2 cases
(4%), and temporary hypomobility of 1 vocal cord in 1
patient (1/50, 2%). No further treatment, including
radioiodine treatment, was provided. Follow-up data
were available for all patients (see below).
Histology
Tissues were fixed in buffered formalin and routinely
embedded in paraffin, and slides were stained with
hematoxylin and eosin. Two pathologists (GB and SA)
reviewed all cases according to the WHO classifica-
tion and the Porto proposal criteria (see above).1,23
Results
Papillary Microtumor Cases
Fifty out of the 119 cases of small papillary thyroid
lesions met the Porto proposal criteria. In particular, all
patients were adults (>19 years) without metastases at
presentation, and we excluded, from this category,
those cases (69/119 cases of PTMC) wherein the
tumor had features indicative of a potential for an
aggressive behavior (ie, invasion of the thyroid capsule,
blood vessel permeation, or tall cells features). We
identified a single focus of papillary microtumor in
43/50 cases and 2 lesions, less than 1 cm in diameter
when taken together, in 7/50 cases that were contained
within the thyroid gland and were found accidentally at
thyroidectomy done for some reason other than PMiT.
The prevalence of PMiT diagnosis was 3.6%
(50/1407 cases) in all the thyroid specimens ana-
lyzed at the Department of Biomedical Sciences and
Human Oncology, University of Turin, during the
period from March 2003 to August 2007. Indeed,
we found the following annual prevalences of PMiT:
0.6% (1/162) during the period from March to
December 2003, 5.2% (16/305) during the period
from January to December 2004, 5.9% (22/370)
during the period from January to December 2005,
2.5% (8/326) during the period from January to
December 2006, and 1.2% (3/244) during the
period from January to August 2007 (Figure 2).
At histology, the sizes of the carcinomas in all our
cases of PMiT ranged from 1 to 9 mm (median size of
3.16 mm). Seven patients (7/50 cases, 14%) showed
2 lesions with the appearance of PMiT. In such
cases, a diagnosis of multicentric PMiT was made.
Small papillary thyroid lesions 1cm
119 cases
PMiT
See Porto Proposal criteria
50/119 cases (42%)
“Incidental” PTMC
WHO 2004
Papillary carcinoma is found
incidentally and measures 1
cm diameter
59/119 cases (49.6%)
“Occult” PTMC
Despite their small size,
clinically present with
regional lymph nodes and
distant metastases
10/119 cases (8.4%)
Figure 1. Our experience (during the period from March
2003 to August 2007) on distribution of small (diameter 1 cm)
papillary thyroid lesions according to the 2004 WHO classifica-
tion and the Porto proposal criteria.
Furthermore, in 1 case, multicentric PMiTs were
localized in the right thyroid lobe (1 lesion) and in the
left thyroid lobe (1 lesion), whereas in 5 cases they
were in either of the thyroid lobes. PMiT was often
associated with chronic lymphatic thyroditis (10/50
cases, 20%), follicular adenoma (5/50 cases, 10%), and
both hyperplasic nodular and diffuse goiters (35/50
cases, 70%). Moreover, 2 patients with hyperplasic
nodular goiter also showed parathyroid adenoma (2/35
case, 5.7%), and 1 patient with diffuse goiter also pre-
sented a thymoma classified as B1 (according to the
2004 WHO classification; 1/35 case, 2.8%).
Patients with association of PMiT and chronic
lymphatic thyroditis were all females, with ages
ranging from 39 to 66 years (median age of 52 years)
at the time of presentation.
In our experience, ultrasound imaging was
unable to detect the area corresponding to the
PMiT, because the diameters of our PMiTs were too
small (3.16 mm median size).
All patients are alive and well after a median of
31.6 months of follow-up (range, 5-57 months).
Occult Papillary Thyroid
Microcarcinoma Cases
Despite their small size, 10 of the 119 cases of small
papillary thyroid lesions clinically presented with
regional lymph node metastases. The prevalence of
occult PTMC diagnosis was 0.7% (10/1407 cases) of
all the thyroid specimens analyzed at the
Department of Biomedical Sciences and Human
Oncology, University of Turin, during the period
from March 2003 to August 2007. At histology, the
majority of tumors (9/10, 90%) were located in the
subcapsular region and showed invasion of the thy-
roid capsule (5 cases had pT3N1a stage, and 4 cases
had pT3N1b stage). Six cases showed sclerosing
appearance, whereas 4 cases had classical and follic-
ular features. The sizes of occult PTMCs ranged
from 3 to 10 mm (median size of 7.9 mm). Two
patients (2/10 cases, 20%) showed multifocal
lesions. In such cases, a diagnosis of multicentric
occult PTMC was made. Occult PTMC was associ-
ated with both hyperplasic nodular and diffuse goi-
ter (8/10 cases, 80%) and with autoimmune thyroid
diseases (2/10 cases, 20%).
All patients are alive after a median of 23.5
months of follow-up (range, 12-54 months). In par-
ticular, 1 patient is alive with disease 15 months
after surgery and radioiodine treatment.
Incidental Papillary Thyroid
Microcarcinoma Cases
The WHO (2004 classification)1classified inciden-
tal PTCM as a papillary carcinoma that is found
incidentally and measures 1 cm in its major axis.
We diagnosed 59 cases of incidental PTCM, with
a prevalence of 4.2% (59/1407 cases) of all the
thyroid specimens analyzed at the Department of
Biomedical Sciences and Human Oncology,
University of Turin, during the period from March
2003 to August 2007. Those tumors had features
indicative of a potential for an aggressive behavior
(ie, invasion of the thyroid capsule, blood vessel
permeation, or tall cells features). At histology,
18/59 cases (30.5%) showed invasion of the thyroid
capsule; lymph node metastases were also observed
in 2 cases. Forty-one cases (69.5%) had pT1 stage
variously associated with multicentric lesions (1
cm when take together) in 21 cases, sclerosing or
tall cells features in 6 cases, areas of suspicious for
capsular or blood invasion in 13 cases, age 19 years
at presentation in 2 cases, and lymph nodes metas-
tases (pN1a) in 3 cases. Incidental PTMC was asso-
ciated with both hyperplasic nodular and diffuse
goiters (47/59 cases, 79.7%), to autoimmune thyroid
diseases (10/59 cases, 16.9%), and to parathyroid
adenoma (2/59 cases, 3.4%).
4International Journal of Surgical Pathology / Vol. XX, No. X, Month XXXX
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Benign thyroid diseases
Malignant thyroid diseases
Papillary microtumors
Figure 2. The prevalence of PMiT at the Department of
Biomedical Sciences and Human Oncology, University of Turin,
during the period from March 2003 to August 2007.
Fifty-eight out of 59 patients (98.3%) are alive
after a median of 32.7 months of follow-up (range,
5-61 months). In particular, 1 patient was dead of
other causes soon after surgery, 1 patient is alive
with disease (bone metastases) 41 months after sur-
gery, and 1 patient showed local recurrence, surgically
removed, 12 and 24 months after thyroidectomy
(now the patient is alive and well 52 months after
the first surgery).
Discussion
The term microcarcinoma should be restricted to
papillary carcinomas that are found incidentally and
measure 1 cm in diameter.1These tumors have
been also referred to with various other terms,
including occult latent papillary carcinoma, nonen-
capsulated thyroid tumor, and occult sclerosing car-
cinoma, all of which should be avoided because they
are no longer applicable to describe a small lesion
(1 cm) found incidentally.
The incidence of thyroid cancer, particularly the
papillary forms, has been increasing sharply for
many years in Western countries. The reasons for
such an increase are not clear, but several authors
suggested that overdiagnosis might be involved.
Patients with PTMC represent up to 30% of all
differentiated thyroid carcinoma worldwide,
including in our series when PTMC and PMiT
were taken together. A subgroup of PTMC, desig-
nated as PMiT by Rosai et al,23 is likely to have a
benign biological behavior similar to that of clini-
cal benign thyroid diseases. The extent of diseases
and the variations in histological findings are criti-
cal factors that should dictate the therapeutic
strategy and follow up. The lack of long-term ran-
domized prospective studies makes it very difficult
to establish which therapeutic approach is better,
explaining the present uncertainty and controver-
sies on this subset of PTMC.
The crucial point is how to manage incidental
thyroid micronodules. Recently, at a European con-
sensus for the management of patients with differ-
entiated thyroid carcinoma, participants divided
patients into very low-risk group, low-risk group, and
high-risk group according to the postsurgical
radioiodine administration (following thyroid abla-
tion), with agreement reached on both the high-risk
group and the very-low-risk group. Indeed, in the
first group, postoperative 131I administration reduces
the recurrence and possibly prolongs survival,
whereas in the latter group, postoperative 131I
administration does not have indication and bene-
fits. Instead, for patients in the low-risk group, the
participants did not reach an agreement on thyroid
ablation after surgery.22 However, no definitive treat-
ment guideline was developed to indicate how best
to treat and manage these small tumors.
As a result, at present both surgeons and
patients become alarmed when pathologists report
the presence of carcinoma, which may lead to
reoperation (completion thyroidectomy after previ-
ous lobectomy, radioiodine treatment) or an
aggressive follow-up (substitutive therapy with
TSH suppression), all of which are deemed unnec-
essary. On the other end, the pathologist is bound
to define as a carcinoma a lesion with a most likely
benign clinical course. For these reasons, Rosai et
al23 proposed the term papillary microtumor of the
thyroid during the 12th Annual Cancer Meeting in
Porto and reported strict definition criteria for
such entities.
In our experience, based on 50 consecutive
cases, the PMiT terminology is well accepted by
both clinicians and patients.
This term, which aptly demarks a subset of tumors
roughly corresponding to half of the cases falling
under the definition of PTMC according to the WHO
classification,1decreases the danger of overtreatment,
minimizes the psychological anxiety engendered by a
diagnosis of carcinoma, and maintains unchanged the
patient’s eligibility for health insurance.
We would therefore advise the adoption of the
term PMiT. Our data are relevant inasmuch as it
clearly defines the boundaries and the merits of
the definition of PMiT on a homogeneous case
series.
We assume that our personal experience (in spite
of the few number of cases submitted to lobectomy
[3/50] and the short follow-up) would stimulate col-
lection of new cases with adequate follow-up, and we
favor a consensus of both pathologists and clinicians
on the definition of this subset of PTMC.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank Dr Marco Volante, Department
of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of
Turin, and San Luigi Hospital, Orbassano, Torino,
Italy, for helping review this article.
PMiT (Papillary Microtumor): A Subset of PTMC / Asioli et al 5
References
1. DeLellis RA, Lloyd RV, Heitz PU, Eng C, eds. Pathology
and Genetics: Tumours of Endocrine Organs. Lyon,
France: IARC Press; 2004.
2. Colonna M, Guizard AV, Schvartz C, et al. A time trend
analysis of papillary and follicular cancers as a function
of tumour size: a study of data from six cancer registries
in France (1983-2000). Eur J Cancer. 2007;43:891-900.
3. Hundahl SA, Cady B, Cunningham MP, et al. Initial
results from a prospective cohort study of 5583 cases of
thyroid carcinoma treated in the United States during
1996. U.S. and German Thyroid Cancer Study Group. An
American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer
Patient Care Evaluation study. Cancer. 2000;89:202-217.
4. Verkooijen HM, Fioretta G, Pache JC, et al. Diagnostic
changes as a reason for the increase in papillary thyroid
cancer incidence in Geneva, Switzerland. Cancer
Causes Control. 2003;14:13-17.
5. Trimboli P, Ulisse S, Graziano FM, et al. Trend in thy-
roid carcinoma size, age at diagnosis, and histology in a
retrospective study of 500 cases diagnosed over 20
years. Thyroid. 2006;16:1151-1155.
6. Pazaitou-Panayiotou K, Capezzone M, Pacini F. Clinical
features and therapeutic implication of papillary thyroid
microcarcinoma. Thyroid. 2007;17:1085-1092.
7. Harach HR, Fransilla KO. Occult papillary carcinoma of
the thyroid appearing as lung metastasis. Arch Pathol
Lab Med. 1984;108:529-530.
8. Hefer T, Joachims HZ, Eitan A, Munichor M. Are the
morphology of papillary thyroid carcinoma and the
tumour’s behaviour correlated? J Laryngol Otol.
1996;110:704-705.
9. Hay ID. Papillary thyroid carcinoma. Endocrinol Metab
Clin North Am. 1990;19:545-576.
10. Grant CS, Hay ID, Gough IR, Bergstralh EJ, Goellner JR,
McConahey WM. Local recurrence in papillary thyroid
carcinoma: is extent of surgical resection important?
Surgery. 1988;104:954-962.
11. Chow SM, Law SC, Chan JK, Au SK, Yau S, Lau WH.
Papillary microcarcinoma of the thyroid—prognostic
significance of lymph node metastasis and multifocality.
Cancer. 2003;98:31-40.
12. Carcangiu ML, Zampi G, Pupi A, Castagnoli A, Rosai J.
Papillary carcinoma of the thyroid. A clinicopathologic
study of 241 cases treated at the University of Florence,
Italy. Cancer. 1985;55:805-828.
13. Ito Y, Miyauchi A. Appropriate treatment for asympto-
matic papillary microcarcinoma of the thyroid. Expert
Opin Pharmacother. 2007;8:3205-3215.
14. Schönberger J, Marienhagen J, Agha A, et al. Papillary
microcarcinoma and papillary cancer of the thyroid
<or=1 cm: modified definition of the WHO and the ther-
apeutic dilemma. Nuklearmedizin. 2007;46:115-120.
15. Küçük NO, Tari P, Tokmak E, Aras G. Treatment for
microcarcinoma of the thyroid—clinical experience.
Clin Nucl Med. 2007;32:279-281.
16. Ito Y, Miyauchi A. A therapeutic strategy for incidentally
detected papillary microcarcinoma of the thyroid. Nat
Clin Pract Endocrinol Metab. 2007;3:240-248.
17. Haas SN. Management of papillary microcarcinoma of
the thyroid. S D Med. 2006;59:425-427.
18. Pelizzo MR, Boschin IM, Toniato A, et al. Papillary thy-
roid microcarcinoma (PTMC): prognostic factors, man-
agement and outcome in 403 patients. Eur J Surg
Oncol. 2006;32:1144-1148.
19. Lo CY, Chan WF, Lang BH, Lam KY, Wan KY. Papillary
microcarcinoma: is there any difference between clinically
overt and occult tumors? World J Surg. 2006;30:759-766.
20. Orsenigo E, Beretta E, Fiacco E, et al. Management of
papillary microcarcinoma of the thyroid gland. Eur J
Surg Oncol. 2004;30:1104-1106.
21. Cooper DS, Doherty GM, Haugen BR, et al. The
American Thyroid Association Guideline Taskforce
2006. Management guidelines for patients with thyroid
nodules and differentiated thyroid cancer. Thyroid.
2006;16:109-142.
22. Pacini F, Schlumberger M, Dralle H, Elisei R, Smit JW,
Wiersinga W; European Thyroid Cancer Taskforce.
European consensus for the management of patients
with differentiated thyroid carcinoma of the follicular
epithelium. Eur J Endocrinol. 2006;154:787-803.
23. Rosai J, LiVolsi VA, Sobrinho-Simoes M, Williams ED.
Renaming papillary microcarcinoma of the thyroid
gland: the Porto proposal. Int J Surg Pathol. 2003;11:
249-251.
6International Journal of Surgical Pathology / Vol. XX, No. X, Month XXXX
... Históricamente a todo CPT con diámetro ≤ 1 cm se le ha denominado microcarcinoma. Sin embargo, dado que no todos comparten el mismo comportamiento biológico y que eso impacta en las decisiones de manejo, se les ha dividido en microcarcinoma y microtumor papilar de tiroides 22 . ...
... En consecuencia, el tratamiento está limitado al acto quirúrgico inicial sin necesidad de manejos complementarios. Los criterios histológicos del microtumor papilar de tiroides son: a) tamaño menor ≤ a 1 cm; b) ausencia de metástasis en el momento del diagnóstico; c) presente solo en pacientes adultos (se excluye todo paciente menor de 19 años); d) lesión unifocal o lesiones multifocales, dos o más lesiones ≤ 1 cm (en el caso de ser multifocal que la sumatoria de los diámetros no exceda 1 cm); e) sin invasión capsular, sin compromiso vascular (venoso o arterial) y sin variante histológica de alto riesgo (como células altas o células columnares); f) puede presentarse concomitante con lesión benigna; g) puede detectarse en el preoperatorio por imágenes diagnosticas o que sea un hallazgo incidental en la pieza quirúrgica 22 . Este término ya está aceptado por la OMS y mundialmente está teniendo un incremento en su diagnóstico 23,25,26 (fig. ...
Article
Cancer of the thyroid gland is a neoplasia for which its detection, diagnosis and treatment is interdisciplinary. For this reason, the definitive diagnosis by histopathology should be complete and clear so that it can be interpreted in the same way by the treating medical group. Non-pathology physicians who receive the report of a histopathological study of the thyroid often have difficulties when interpreting the report and therefore in defining the subsequent medical behaviour. The objective of this first article is to review briefly some of the different subjects that generate most doubts in the interpretation of the histopathology report, and the diagnostic techniques used in pathology by the attending physicians that have an impact on clinical decisions arising from the classification, staging, prognosis, and follow-up of the disease.
... La taille tumorale moyenne était plus faible pour les pMT par rapport aux pMC [3,37mm vs 6,41mm]. Ces données sont accords avec les résultats des études antérieures qui confirme la plus faible taille des pMT en comparaison au pMC avec une taille moyenne ≈ 3mm [4,8,10]. Sur le plan histologique, comme c'est le cas des autres études, la variante morphologique prédominante était la forme folliculaire aussi bien dans le groupe des pMT que dans le groupe des pMC (1,4 ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: pMCT is defined as a variant of papillary carcinoma that measures≤1 cm in diameter and which is characterized by an excellent prognosis. Recently, a proposal has been advanced to use the designation of papillary mirotumour (pMT) for pMCTs with no risk factors . Aim: In this study, we aimed to reclassify pMCTs according to the Porto proposal(Pp) criteria. Methods: We have retrospectively collected cases of pMCT diagnosed in our pathology department over a period of 10years(2012-2022). Clinical and pathological parameters have been retrieved from the patient’s medical records and pathological reports. We have evaluated all cases following the criteria of Pp. Cases that fulfilled all the criteria have been reclassified as pMT. We have briefly compared the clinical outcomes in both groups. Results: 29 cases of pMCT was found. Mean age of patients was 46,6 years-old (17-67) with a female predominance (sex ratio=0,45). 23 cases of pMCT were incidentally discovered. The tumor was located in the right thyroid lobe in 15cases. The mean size of the tumor was 5,2mm. Multifocality was observed in 5 cases. A total of 17 cases could be classified as pMT according to the Pp. Only one patient developed pulmonary metastasis and local recurrence; however it was related to the papillary carcinoma firstly diagnosed in his contralateral lobe. Clinical outcome was also good in the group of papillary microcarcinoma (pMC) with no recurrence or distant metastasis. Conclusion: According to the Pp,>50% of pMCT could be reclassified as pMT which could reduce the psychological impact and overtreatment. Further studies with large sample size and molecular analysis are however needed in order to definitively validate and generalize the use of Porto proposal.
... In our study population, the proportion of patients with papillary thyroid cancers, in particular with T1 tumors, was high. This finding is consistent with the reports of a prominent increase in small, papillary thy-roid cancers in several regions [1,3,5,7,18]. This might be associated with a high iodine intake, which is reported to be related to the development of papillary thyroid cancers [1,19,20]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: The aim of our investigation was to evaluate the clinicopathological characteristics and mutation patterns in newly diagnosed cases of thyroid cancer in the federal state of Salzburg, Austria, in the year 2013. Methods: The medical records of all patients newly diagnosed with thyroid cancer in 2013 in the federal state of Salzburg were retrospectively reviewed. The clinicopathological characteristics and mutations of thyroid cancers were analyzed. Results: 63 patients (mean age: 51.0 years, range: 21-81 years; female 75%, male 25%) were identified. 53 patients had papillary (12 follicular variant), 4 patients follicular (1 oxyphilic variant), 3 patients medullary, and 3 patients anaplastic thyroid cancer. T1 tumors were found in 34 patients (pT1a, 20 patients; pT1b, 14 patients), T2 tumors in 10 patients, T3 tumors in 16 patients, and T4 tumors in 3 patients. Lymph node involvement was seen in 15 patients and metastatic disease in 1 patient. Mutations of BRAF (B-type Raf kinase) were detected in 23 and mutation of NRAS (Neuroblastoma RAS Viral Oncogene Homolog) in 2 papillary thyroid cancers. No concomitant mutations of BRAF and NRAS were found. Conclusion: Females accounted for 75% of the patients with newly diagnosed thyroid cancer and the incidence peaked at a younger age than in males. Papillary thyroid cancer was the most frequent tumor type, accounting for 84% of the cases. A high frequency of T1 tumors and cancers with no lymph node involvement was found. Males had a higher proportion of large tumors and more aggressive forms of thyroid cancer than females. Mutations (mostly of BRAF) were found in 47% of the cases. Neither mutations of KRAS (Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homologue) nor concomitant mutations of BRAF and NRAS were found.
... 65,66,[81][82][83] In some places, such as Korea, this has been attributed specifically to screening that has identified small tumours. 84 Others have blamed pathologists for identifying lesions that are benign as FVPTC, 67,85-88 and there has been an attempt to reclassify these lesions in a way that camouflages their metastatic potential, using terms such as 'microtumour', 89 'uncertain malignant potential' (UMP), 32,90 or 'non-invasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features' (NIFT-P). 69,91 These terms are used to describe encapsulated or well delineated follicular-patterned neoplasms that have nuclear features of papillary carcinoma but no evidence of invasive behaviour. ...
Article
Differentiated thyroid tumours of follicular cell derivation have traditionally been classified based on architecture, cytology, or both. The features that distinguish the various entities are controversial and diagnostic criteria are inconsistent and often irreproducible. The complexity of classification schemes has not been substantiated by molecular profiling. In this review, a simplistic approach to the diagnosis of well differentiated thyroid neoplasia is provided to challenge the dogma. The proposed classification matches the molecular profiles of these lesions and simplifies the criteria for diagnosis. This approach can be used to support rational treatment algorithms.
Article
Given the high incidence and excellent prognosis of many papillary thyroid microcarcinomas, the Porto proposal uses the designation papillary microtumor (PMT) for papillary microcarcinomas (PMCs) without risk factors to minimize overtreatment and patients' stress. To validate Porto proposal criteria, we examined a series of 190 PMC series, also studying sex hormone receptors and BRAF mutation. Our updated Porto proposal (uPp) reclassifies as PMT incidental PMCs found at thyroidectomy lacking the following criteria: (a) detected under the age of 19 years; (b) with multiple tumors measuring >1 cm adding up all diameters; and (c) with aggressive morphologic features (extrathyroidal extension, angioinvasion, tall, and/or hobnail cells). PMCs not fulfilling uPp criteria were considered "true" PMCs. A total of 102 PMCs were subclassified as PMT, 88 as PMC, with no age or sex differences between subgroups. Total thyroidectomy and iodine-131 therapy were significantly more common in PMC. After a median follow-up of 9.6 years, lymph node metastases, distant metastases, and mortality were only found in the PMC subgroup. No subgroup differences were found in calcifications or desmoplasia. Expression of estrogen receptor-α and estrogen receptor-β, progesterone receptor, and androgen receptor was higher in PMC than in nontumorous thyroid tissue. BRAF mutations were detected in 44.7% of PMC, with no differences between subgroups. In surgical specimens, the uPp is a safe pathology tool to identify those PMC with extremely low malignant potential. This terminology could reduce psychological stress associated with cancer diagnosis, avoid overtreatment, and be incorporated into daily pathologic practice.
Article
Resumen En la cirugía mínimamente invasiva del cuello poco se ha evolucionado considerando que usualmente se acompaña de disecciones extensas, dolorosas y prolongadas en tiempo operatorio. Este tipo de cirugía que denominamos como: “cirugía en mínimos espacios del cuello”, es una línea de trabajo del grupo y a finales del 2015 se inició el programa de cirugía endoscópica de cuello. En junio del 2016 intervinimos una paciente joven con carcinoma papilar de tiroides, utilizando la Tiroidectomía Axilar Endoscópica Video Asistida (TAEVA) con equipo Endoeye Flex 3 D. Se observaron claras ventajas al usarlo, como alta resolución visual, buena profundidad de campo y versatilidad derivada de la flexibilidad de la cámara que evitó el intercambio de lentes rígidos de 0°, 30° y 70°, lo que acortó el tiempo operatorio. Hasta donde se tiene conocimiento es el primer caso de TAEVA 3 D publicado.
Article
Resumen El cáncer de la glándula tiroides es una neoplasia cuya detección, diagnóstico y tratamiento se realiza de manera interdisciplinaria, por lo tanto el diagnóstico definitivo histopatológico debe ser completo y claro; de modo que pueda ser interpretado de la misma manera por parte del grupo médico tratante. De manera frecuente, los médicos no patólogos que reciben el reporte de un estudio histopatológico de tiroides se enfrentan con dificultades al momento de interpretar el reporte histopatológico y, por lo tanto, en definir la posterior conducta médica. El objetivo de este primer artículo es revisar de manera breve algunos de los diferentes temas que más generan dudas en la interpretación del reporte histopatológico y de las técnicas diagnósticas usadas en patología por parte de los médicos tratantes que tienen un impacto en las decisiones clínicas originadas a partir de la clasificación, estadificación, pronóstico y seguimiento de la enfermedad.
Article
BACKGROUND It is known that patients with papillary microcarcinoma (PMC) of the thyroid gland have a very favorable prognosis. The rising incidence of PMC among papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) necessitates the identification of prognostic factors and the formulation of treatment protocols.METHODS The authors conducted a retrospective analysis of 203 patients with PMC who were diagnosed on or before 1999 and were treated at the Department of Clinical Oncology, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Hong Kong.RESULTSThe cause specific survival, locoregional (LR) failure free survival, and distant metastases failure free survival rates at 10 years were 100%, 92.1%, and 97.1%, respectively. Five patients had lung metastases; 2 patients died of their metastases 12.9 years and 14.8 years after diagnosis, and 3 patients achieved clinical remission after radioiodine (RAI) treatment. Twelve patients had LR recurrences. Patients with LR recurrence were highly salvageable with a combination of surgery, RAI treatment, and external radiotherapy; all but one (who refused treatment) were alive without disease at last follow-up. Multivariate analyses did not reveal any independent prognostic factor for survival. The risk of cervical lymph node (LN) recurrence increased 6.2-fold (P = 0.01) and 5.6-fold (P = 0.02) when LN metastases and multifocal disease were present at diagnosis. RAI ablation reduced the LN recurrence rate to 0.27 (P = 0.04). The presence of LN metastasis increased the rate of distant metastasis 11.2-fold (P = 0.03). Age was not a significant factor in predicting disease recurrence or survival. Subdivision by tumor sizes ≤ 5 mm and > 5 mm did not affect the outcome, but no patient with tumors ≤ 5 mm had mortality related to PMC.CONCLUSIONS Despite the overall excellent prognosis for patients with PMC, PMC was associated with a 1.0% disease-related mortality rate, a 5.0% LN recurrence rate, and a 2.5% distant metastasis rate. Therefore, the treatment of patients with PMC should be no different from the treatment of patients with conventional PTC: i.e., complete surgery with consideration for RAI and/or external radiation therapy if poor prognostic factors are present. Cancer 2003;98:31–40. © 2003 American Cancer Society.DOI 10.1002/cncr.11442
Article
A clinicopathologic study of 241 cases of papillary thyroid carcinoma treated at the University of Florence Medical School, Florence, Italy is presented. The features of greatest prognostic value were patient's age at presentation, small tumor size, total encapsulation, extrathyroid extension, multicentricity, and presence of distant metastases. The prognosis of the disease was not influenced by the pattern of tumor growth, presence of solid areas, initial presence or subsequent development of cervical lymph node metastases, type of initial thyroid operation, performance of neck dissection, or prophylactic administration of radioactive iodine. It is concluded that conservative thyroid surgery in the form of lobectomy, without neck dissection or prophylactic administration of iodine 131 (131I), constitutes adequate therapy for most cases of papillary thyroid carcinoma. More extensive therapy should be considered for older patients and for those in whom the tumor exhibits extrathyroid extension or easily detectable multicentricity.
Article
BACKGROUND The American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer (CoC) has conducted national Patient Care Evaluation (PCE) studies since 1976.METHODS Over 1500 hospitals with CoC-approved cancer programs were invited to participate in this prospective cohort study of U.S. thyroid carcinoma cases treated in 1996. Follow-up will be conducted through the National Cancer Data Base.RESULTSOf the 5584 cases of thyroid carcinoma, 81% were papillary, 10% follicular, 3.6% Hürthle cell, 0.5% familial medullary, 2.7% sporadic medullary, and 1.7% undifferentiated/anaplastic. Demographics and suspected risk factors were analyzed. Fine-needle aspiration of the thyroid gland (53%) or a neck lymph node (7%), thyroid nuclear scan (39%), and ultrasound (38%) constituted the most frequently utilized diagnostic modalities. The vast majority of patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma presented with American Joint Committee on Cancer Stage I and II disease and relatively small tumors. For all histologies, near-total or total thyroidectomy constituted the dominant surgical treatment. No lymph nodes were examined in a substantial proportion of cases. Residual tumor after the surgical event could be documented in 11% of cases, hypocalcemia in 10% of cases, and recurrent laryngeal nerve injury in 1.3% of cases. Complications were most frequently associated with total thyroidectomy combined with lymph node dissection. Thirty-day mortality was 0.3%; when undifferentiated/anaplastic cancer cases were eliminated, it decreased to 0.2%. Adjuvant treatment, probably underreported in this study, consisted of hormonal suppression (50% overall) and radioiodine (50% overall).CONCLUSIONS In addition to offering information concerning risk factors and symptoms, the current PCE study compliments the survival information from previous NCDB reports and offers a surveillance snapshot of current management of thyroid carcinoma in the U.S. Identified opportunities for improvement of care include 1) more frequent use of fine-needle aspiration cytology in making a diagnosis; 2) more frequent use of laryngoscopy in evaluating patients preoperatively, especially those with voice change; and 3) improved lymph node resection and analysis to improve staging and, in some situations, outcomes. [See commentary on pages 1–4, this issue and communication on pages 192–201, this issue.] Cancer 2000;89:202–17. © 2000 American Cancer Society.
Article
Multiple prognostic factors for outcome in papillary thyroid carcinoma are identified. For a cohort of 1500 consecutive patients followed an average of 16 years, survival rates for tumor recurrence and cause-specific mortality are described. Risk groups derived from novel prognostic scoring or staging systems and the role of DNA ploidy testing are discussed specifically. Lastly, controversies are reviewed regarding the extent of primary surgical resection and the efficacy of postoperative radioiodine remnant ablation in papillary thyroid cancer.
Article
From a multivariate analysis of more than 20,600 patient-years' experience with papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), we devised a prognostic scoring system based on patient age, tumor grade, extent, and size (AGES). This scoring system was used as an adjustment variable for analyzing the role of different types of surgical treatment in the development of local recurrence (LR) in 963 PTC patients who underwent unilateral (15%), bilateral subtotal/near-total (69%), or total thyroidectomies (16%) from 1946 through 1975 at the Mayo Clinic. In 866 patients with AGES scores of 3.99 or less, the risk of LR developing at 10, 20, and 30 years was 7%, 14%, and 14% after unilateral resection and 1.5%, 2%, and 4% after bilateral resection (p less than 0.001). In 97 patients with AGES scores of 4 or more, the comparable rates were 26%, 45%, and 59% after unilateral resection and 13%, 20%, and 20% after bilateral resection (p less than 0.001). In neither the low- nor the high-risk group was there a significant difference in the frequency of LR comparing total thyroidectomy with bilateral subtotal/near-total thyroidectomy. At 30 years after diagnosis of LR, mortality from PTC was 48%; the risk of cancer death with an LR located outside the thyroid remnant was much greater than with a remnant recurrence alone. In this series of 52 patients, followed up for as many as 41 years, no patient with tumor recurrence limited to the thyroid remnant died of thyroid cancer.
Article
To the Editor. —In their recent article, Parker et al1 stated that distant metastasis in cases of papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) typically involves "the lung, bone, or liver" and, in reviewing 1346 reported PTC cases, they found only two (0.15%) examples of brain metastasis. In a recently completed study2 of 859 patients with PTC, treated at the Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minn, during a 25-year period and followed for up to 39 years, 11 patients (1.3%) with brain metastases were identified. In 40 patients developing postoperative metastasis, the principal sites of involvement were lungs (70%), mediastinum (24%), bone (23%), and brain (15%). Of 56 patients dying of PTC, 11 patients (20%) died as a consequence of metastasis to the brain or the spinal cord.Both of the patients described by Parker et al1 were males; one patient was found to have brain metastasis 33 years after the initial