The energy consumption in the food production system is an indicator broadly used for sustainability evaluation, which is directly related with the CO2 emission, because most fuels and agricultural inputs are derived from fossil sources. However, most of the energy analyses have been carried out only for the agricultural production stage, leaving the other stages of the food system outside; such as the transformation, the distribution and the consumption stage. In this paper, the maize food system is described in two geographic scales: The rural area of the Pátzcuaro Lake basin and the San Francisco Pichátaro community. The supply flows and the consumption volume are described in the first one, while, in the second one, the energy use and the CO2 emissions to the atmosphere era calculated from the traditional and agro-industrial maize-tortilla chain.
Fifty-eight percent of the consumed tortillas are hand made (51% elaborated with local maize and 7% elaborated with external maize), and 42% are elaborated in “tortillerias” (30% external maize and 12% maize flour) in the rural communities of the Pátzcuaro Lake basin. The external maize comes from Sinaloa (51%), Ciénega de Chapala (19%) and El Bajío (20%). The maize flour is produced in Guadalajara and Silao. Maize production in the Pátzcuaro communities was calculated in 7692 ton, and the human consumption was calculated in 5756 ton, for this reason the Pátzcuaro communities would satisfy their maize needs. However, this doesn't happen because of the technology used in the tortillerías, which is more compatible with the external hybrid maize and because its supply is easier. These issues caused a breakdown of the regional system, thus the rural communities became dependent of the urban maize supply.
The traditional subsystem used an average of 5332 MJ/ha and the yield average was 882 kg/ha and 6 MJ/kg of maize. The energy main input was the machinery (46%). In total (production and consumption), 41.7 MJ/kg of tortilla was used and the main input was firewood, with 82% and only 9% from fossil fuels. It had an efficiency of 0.25. The agro-industrial subsystem used 24,635 MJ/ha, at the production stage and the estimated yield was 7,509 kg/ha, 3.5 MJ/kg of maize. Fertilizer was the main input (59%). The energy cost of transport was 1.2 MJ/kg. In total (production, transport and consumption), 18.6 MJ/kg of tortilla were used, and LP gas was the main input (73%) and was dependent from fossil fuels, in 99%. The subsystem efficiency was 0.51.
There was a gross emission of 0.854 kg CO2 for a kilogram of traditional tortilla’s preparation, if firewood was non-renewable, and of 0.10 kg CO2/Kg tortilla, if firewood was renewable. The agro-industrial subsystem emitted 1.10 kg CO2/kg. The LP gas was the main emitter in this subsystem (74%).
The traditional subsystem critical points were low yields at production stage and high firewood consumption for the tortillas’ elaboration. The first problem could be resolved through fertilization improvements, using organic fertilizer and leguminous rotation. The second critical point could be resolved with the use of more efficient firewood stoves. The critical points of the agro-industrial subsystem, are: high dependence of fossil fuels, mainly fertilizers; thus, legume rotations are recommended to reduce their use. The distance
xv
between the main region producer and the Lake of Pátzcuaro basin was another critical point, thus maize supply should be preferably carried out from the nearest region. The last critical point was the high LP gas consumption for the machinery (tortilladoras), which can be reduced by their replacement with new machinery.
This thesis demonstrates that it is possible to analyze the food production, transformation and consumption stages as whole, using an integrative approach. The food system concept acquires a concrete expression through the energy analysis, when using this approach as a research framework. However, the energy indicators used for the sustainability evaluation should be implemented together with other indicators.
Because of the collapse of the regional food integration that existed until recently, there is a need to carry out studies describing these processes, while looking for alternatives aimed for solving the lack of markets for the local agricultural products. On the other hand, there is a need for the agricultural, agro-industrial and food consumption statistics to be integrated at different scales. The food system should be the framework for political decisions been taken in agricultural, agro-industrial and food supply issues, and not just analyzing each stage separately from the rest.